For more on how we should be making out all of this, Jay Goldberg is senior semiconductor analyst at Seaport Research Partners. He joins us live on the show right now. Jay, good to have you on the show. Nvidia, let's start with that, reporting results November 17th, and Congress on Huang behind closed doors the next day. I want to know what you will be listening out for on that earnings call. First of all, I know you're going to be totally objective, but would this scandal in any way, you know, affect your call on the company, if at all?
So, it's very difficult to make a stock call on the company right now because of the scandals around Jensen. Next week, yes, they're going to report earnings. I don't know that anyone's going to care about their numbers. You know, my best guess is right now they're going to have a pretty good quarter and have a good outlook, but that's definitely going to take back seat to what's going to happen with Jensen. There's a lot of speculation swirling around him. What's his role going to be at the company? What is the US government going to do? Those, I think, are much more top of mind for investors right now.
Yeah, Jay, I mean, you've argued that forcing Jensen Huang out would be a mistake. Just how much of Nvidia's success depends on him, and what would be most difficult to replace if he steps aside?
Yeah, he's the heart and soul of the company. He's the animating spirit. He's the founder. He's run it the entire history of the company. He has famously 60 or 70 direct reports, which is very unusual, right? Everybody in the company basically reports to him, and that has made them much faster. They're able to make decisions much faster, less bureaucracy. But there's no obvious number two. A thing I keep challenging people with is, can you name another executive at the company? And the CFO, people know the CFO, but nobody's really that familiar with some of the other executives. And that's a deliberate policy on Nvidia's part. They have made it a policy for years to make Jensen the face of the company, and that's mirrored internally. He really makes, you know, he's involved in all the major decisions. If he's not there to do it, the system stops working, and it's very unclear who could replace him. And in fact, I would argue there's no one who could replace him. He is such a larger-than-life figure, certainly one of the best semiconductor CEOs ever. How do you replace that? There's no ready alternative.
Yeah, Jay, but let's examine some of the potential scenarios where he actually could be forced out. I mean, if it's simply an affair, yes or no, right? And if they find that information, trade secrets, even national security that's been compromised, then is that enough to get him out?
That's a hard question for me to answer. I worry, though, that it certainly feels like there's another shoe to drop here, that there's more news coming. There definitely seems to be an organized campaign to sort of lobby against him there. He doesn't have a lot of friends in Washington right now, and the knives are out. And so my worry is that there would be some other news, maybe not as significant as this, but say they release the transcripts, or he's, you know, done something else. He's, you know, any possible thing, and it sort of makes his position untenable. I think that's the risk, is that there's more news to come. There's more things that get disclosed, and that sort of leaves the board with no choice. I don't think we're there yet, but that's the thing that I think a lot of us are worried about, is what's still to come. What don't we know? What exactly was going on with Mega Speed? Was Mega Speed actually shipping units into China? They've been investigated before and cleared, but there's, you know, a lot of scrutiny going on right there. And so, what else is going to come to light around Jensen and Alice Wang's relationship? There's all kinds of things that we could speculate on, and I don't want to do that too much, but I do worry that there's more news to come, and that makes it much harder for him to hold on.
Well, I'm guessing you're saying this because maybe you, I mean, an insider, you know, might be privy to something or some other kind of information that's swirling around the industry when you say that, waiting for the other shoe to drop. Do we have an idea what this could be, or is this just more details on the alleged, you know, spying and affair, or is it something more?
I certainly don't have any inside information on this. All I know is I've been talking to the press a lot lately. I've been on a lot of panels discussing this, and it feels there is a certain amount of frenzy around this in the US right now. Everybody's looking at it. Certainly, I've talked to any number of journalists in the last 48 hours who are all starting to dig into things. And I worry that it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, right? You know, everybody has something that they would rather keep hidden, and if enough people are, if you get anyone under enough scrutiny, those things come out. And it could be trivial, it could be nothing, but in this context, he is very much guilty until proven innocent. And that's a very hard position for him to climb out of.