We have two longtime Nvidia watchers with lots of insight joining us now. Ivana Delevska of SPEAR and Jay Goldberg of Seaport Research Partners. Jay, of course, famous as the only analyst for quite a while with a sell rating on Nvidia. Ivana, great to see you. Give us your off-the-top reaction to the departure of Jensen Huang, please.
Well, Andy, thanks for having me. We believe this is a big loss for the company, as Jensen has been a great leader, but I think at the end of the day it is the right decision in light of what's been going on. I think the biggest risk for investors to assess here is how much is there related to these Chinese sales. It's not so much the personal aspect and the morals and the ethics. I think it's really all about the legal aspect of this, of whether there were sales to China that were illegal and that he wasn't aware of. So, I think we've been long-term investors in the stock. We exited this summer for various reasons, but if we were to establish a new position today, that's what we would be looking to get comfortable with.
Jay, can we flip to you? You were quoted by Bloomberg as saying yesterday, if Huang goes, the bull case goes with him. You saw it as very damaging if he had to go. He is out of there. What's your take now, Jay?
I think we live in a smaller world now. Despite all the problems, I enjoyed covering Jensen. He made the industry a lot more interesting. I think the company now is in a very difficult position. He founded this company, right? He grew it from nothing to what it is today. He was the center of so much of it, and it's going to be very hard to replace him. And so I think in the near term I'm still cautious on the stock because it's a big mystery who's going to replace him. Whoever that person is is going to have a very difficult time rebuilding the organization and rejuvenating them. And then on top of that, we still have lots of other questions, like as she was just saying, like what is the actual situation with their shipments to China, to Southeast Asia? Are there any violations going on? The company faces a lot of challenges now.
Ivana, flipping back to you, you say that there's these open models and closed models of AI. Tell us why that's important, because Nvidia, they don't make custom chips. Is that right?
Well, yes, Andy. So, just to provide a little bit of background, in the past, Nvidia has literally served the entire market with over 90% share that dropped to close to like in the mid-80s. So, they've really been, when you talk about AI and GPUs, they've really been the hardware of choice. As we get into the future, there is a bifurcation between open and closed models. And over time the closed model companies like Anthropic, like OpenAI, they've built a portfolio a lot more mixed than in the past. So they have chips with, they're building hardware with AMD. They're building their own custom chips, which we believe is going to ultimately be what they go with on a long-term basis. So we believe Nvidia is not greatly positioned to capture this closed model market. They're well positioned on the open-source model side. However, that's really been dominated by China. So, as you can see now with these concerns incrementally getting harder for them to sell chips to China. So, basically looking forward, they're really kind of getting cornered here just to the open-source general purpose market outside of China.
Jay, I know we're straying into espionage and politics here, but apparently Singapore is saying America, Washington wasn't that responsive when it was looking into this lady who Jensen Huang had the affair with. So what is Washington's game plan here, do you think?
It's a little bit out of my expertise, but I will say that there are a lot of strange things taking place in Washington, which is perhaps the understatement of the year. In regards to this matter, I have a lot of questions. It certainly sounds from the reporting that's been done so far is that the president knew that Jensen was very close to an alleged Chinese spy and they didn't warn him. That's a little odd to me. I think the sort of more serious question though is the United States has restrictions on sales of chips to China and Chinese entities. That is an effort that is now very obviously full of loopholes. It always has been. The mega speed was quite possibly just exploiting a loophole, not necessarily even doing anything illegal, but just running through the gray zone.
On top of that, the sort of the government apparatus that's supposed to be inspecting all these things, the BIS, is woefully understaffed and it has been for years. That's not just Trump. That's just been going on for years. I think there are two BIS inspectors in all of China, right? It's clear to me that the regulations and the restrictions were not particularly well written. It left a lot of loopholes and then it wasn't really well enforced. And so I think that is absolutely the case where the government bears some responsibility for what's taking place.
Ivana, maybe we can put up a stock price again. Is there a price at which you would get definitely interested in Nvidia shares?