Hello and welcome once again to the Out of Town podcast. I'm your host Tova and I have been anxiously awaiting the release of this podcast episode. Today I am joined by Dr. David Rosmarin, whom you might recognize with his yarmulke on the TEDx stage, Good Morning America, other major podcast platforms, but today he joins us right here in this dining room having a relatable, down-to-earth conversation about living out of town and thriving with anxiety. Speaking of, that is the name of his masterclass that's now available to all of you, Thriving with Anxiety. The link's below and with the code Tova, t-o-v-a, you get a special discount. If you want to hear how the steps in that masterclass will change your life, just stick around till the end of the episode. Hear for yourself. And with that, let's go there.
Have you ever met someone who has no anxiety?
Do Jewish people struggle disproportionately with anxiety? We want to know.
There are ways to drown that out. A couple too many shots at the kiddush. In town there's this like, "Why isn't my kid keeping up with everyone else? It's embarrassing."
But how do we know when anxiety's impacting our life to an extent that we actually need to seek out care?
You want the truth or you want what I tell you?
And nothing but the truth. Do you feel the weight of you're representing?
Whatever's going to be is going to be. Hashem, this is on you.
This is an episode of the Out of Town podcast that I've been waiting for for a very, very long time. So thank you for joining me.
This is the Dr. Rosmarin, founder of Center for Anxiety and many other things. So thank you for joining me today.
It's great to be able to just drive around the corner and be on such an awesome podcast.
Oh, thank you. You're definitely helping put this podcast on the map, so I appreciate it.
So my first question for the Out of Town podcast is why Boston?
Why Boston? In the medical field, it's the place to be. And being at McLean Hospital, number one in psychiatry, I've just been there for 15 years. It's hard to describe the comparison. I think especially in mental health and behavioral health, there's a big chasm between your tier one programs and then tier two and everything else. And I think we've all heard and know of tragedies really that happen when people aren't getting the right advice, the right care, the innovative strategies that they need, and it's multimodal. And McLean does all that and more. So it's a hard place to give up. And well, they keep putting up with me, so I'm sticking around.
But you also do have a center in New York, right?
Yeah. So, the disadvantage of being in the academic medical system obviously is financial, and intellectually it's incredible from an opportunity for learning. It's just amazing and for connections. But you know, there's a need to diversify one's financial portfolio. So many years ago when I got my license, I started Center for Anxiety in New York, in Manhattan.
And then it grew and here we are.
Are you seeing private clients these days?
Doing something called concierge mental health, which I would never be able to do if I wasn't trained at McLean, because we have sort of pretty high-end private pay programs, and dealing with those types of patients over the years is really a unique training. And it's actually pretty tough. I've learned a lot.
I've learned a lot about high net worth and ultra net worth families and the real challenges that happen, multi-generational wealth, and you know, everyone's like boohoo, like big problems. I know.
But no, there is. There is. It's often children of such families who are really struggling to make it as great as their parents, and sometimes they can't. But they have to find their own way, and parents are often over-involved, at least one parent, and trying to find meaning in ways that are problematic, throwing money at a problem.
What does that impact the concierge? The fact that they're like, "Come in and fix everything."
Well, the first thing I do is sort of orient everybody to like, "This is our plan." It's when people are stuck and they're basically throwing money at it and don't know what to do. So then I have a team.
Wow. I actually want to pause and just share a very funny story. I don't know if it's that funny, but a story that I find entertaining because we moved to Boston. We didn't know that you lived here. But we had just finished our undergrad, me and my husband, in psychology. And a big report that my husband did relied a lot on your research. So the day he came home from school and said, "You're never going to guess who I just met at Brigham," was an entertaining moment for us, and I'm like, "Wow, Boston really is the place to be for all the top-tier professionals."
I don't know if I'm in that category, but you know, really very glad however we met that I got to chat with you and your husband. It's great.
What led to your specific focus on anxiety and other things?
The truth or do you want what I tell everybody?
And nothing but the truth.
Yeah, what I tell everybody is that, you know, it's treatable, which is true, and that there's great psychosocial treatments, psychotherapy treatments, which are effective, which is true. That it's very ubiquitous and everybody has it, which is true. But the real truth, I have anxiety myself, and like, research is research for a reason. It took me a while to sort of acknowledge that and admit it and come to it. I don't know if I would have been able to if I didn't live out of town.
And that's why the theme is let's go there. Because we're just kind of looking right in the mirror and saying, "It's time. It's time to face ourselves and use what we consider deficits as superpowers," which is definitely...
I'm there. I mean, I'm there. I think when it comes to anxiety, there's two types. There is clinical anxiety, which gets in the way of your life. Thank God I've not had much of that. Maybe a couple periods, but I think we all do.
Do we deny it ever? Do we have it and then looking back we can say, "Oh, maybe I did."
A couple times in my life I have, for sure. No question. Had it when it got in the way a little. Not, thank God, not really out of control. I had tools. I was learning them in school. I kind of knew what to do.
There's also normal anxiety that every human being has. And we as a culture are obsessed with getting rid of it. And it's terrible. It's actually making the anxiety epidemic worse. So that's where the opportunity to thrive and to welcome normal healthy anxiety into your life to enhance your existence.
I was once told by a therapist years ago that the line between excitement and anxiety is very fine. Would you agree?
Think about it. You have the butterflies in your stomach.
Okay, your heart palpitations.
But if it's a symptom, we call it tachycardia, right? Sounds...
Sounds a lot more clinical, right?
But it's not, it's like excitement, and you know, same thing. You're short of breath because your adrenaline's going through your system. Your pupils are dilating to increase your field of vision because you're excited and taking in new information.
Yeah, the only difference between excitement and non-clinical anxiety is whether you're embracing it or whether you're like holding on for dear life.
How do we choose that though? Like what we push for and what we kind of decide, "No, this is a message to step back."
When you've been told your whole life that anxiety is a problem, it's hard to make that choice.
But it is a choice that we make, and we can choose to embrace it and to invite it into our lives in a positive way. Reframe it.
It is my honor to once again be working with okclarity.com.
Oh my god, they're great.
We, Center for Anxiety, have joined okclarity.com, and a number of our clinicians who are servicing people in the frum community, and they've just been fantastic to work with. I think they're really getting the word out about mental health care in a unique way. I mean, often it's been referral sources and different agencies doing that, and to be able to have it online and more direct to consumer, it's just breaking a lot of stigma in the community. So we love working with them.
That's awesome. How do you know them?
It's a funny story. She was like, "I love your stuff. Can I please sponsor you?"
So thank you, Faye, for reaching out directly. Made me feel great, and also I am so grateful to be working with you. I think your resource is incredible. I also think I want to give a special shout out because she also lists coaches, which I think is like revolutionizing the therapeutic space in general. So many therapists have a lot of issues with...
I do not have an issue with that, and I'll tell you why.
So recently McLean Hospital, like I said, they were really innovating a lot of things in mental health. One of them is this support that's non-clinical.
And there's an Institute of Coaching at McLean Hospital.
McLean Hospital, and it's focused on research. It's focused on actually increasing the academic credibility of coaching within clinical science.
Are they looking for specific certifications or qualifications?
Certification. It's really a research arm in some ways of the International Coaching Federation, of the ICF.
Hold on, get this. When I started doing this work on thriving with anxiety, they actually tapped me to become their director of research.
Working very closely with the Institute of Coaching at McLean Hospital and Harvard Medical School these days.
Okay, I need to continue this conversation after. Okay.
...that OkClarity has this focus.
And not just like, you know, wellness coaches, it's also like emotion code or life coaching.
Mhm.
Do Jewish people struggle disproportionately with anxiety? We want to know.
I've not seen any studies that suggest that Jewish individuals have more anxiety than our non-Jewish comrades. Maybe a little more depression among men.
There's data on that. Gender differences are more pronounced in depression and mood disorders among non-Jews. Women have two to one usually historically.
Twice as many women relative to men in the general public will develop depression over the lifespan.
Among Jews, it's about equal.
And I think that there's a spiritual sensitivity that men in particular, especially in the Orthodox world, are sort of brought into from davening and from learning and from just relationships and...
You know, obviously there are ways to drown that out, like a couple too many shots at the kiddush.
The kiddush club culture I don't feel has infiltrated us here in Boston.
That's one of the reasons I'm here. I mean, I think relationships are a lot more real when you don't have to keep up with everyone.
Yeah. And when you can't get lost in the crowd by making choices that are unhelpful.
There's more accountability in our community, I would say.
Yeah, to some degree. But healthy accountability, not showmanship.
One of the special perks of living out of town is that we get such incredible guests and opportunities, and I'm just so thankful that I get to share it with all of you. Thank you to our sponsors: L'zecher Neshamas, Elisheva Passi, Bassi Huda, Aaron Neshamah, have an aliyah. Does our faith help us then through that?
Good question. Spirituality and religion can have positive and negative effects.
When it comes to anxiety, orthopraxy or being a practicing religious faith has no impact on your anxiety. It's not positive and it's also not negative. It's not associated with more obsession or compulsion.
There's the sort of lore of people who are more religious having more OCD. It's not true. If you have OCD and you're religious, your OCD will have religious themes.
But it doesn't cause more OCD. Internationally, there's data on that. When it comes to anxiety, there's really no effect. But the internal world of spirituality, faith, prayer, davening...
...bitachon, no question. I did my dissertation on bitachon and anxiety, right, way back, 20 years ago. Oh my god, getting old. There's definitely what to be said about the internal world of spiritual and religious life that can protect, to your point. But some people struggle with their faith and they struggle like, "Why is this happening to me?" And that can create a lot of existential and interpersonal angst, tension within families, you know, why are they acting that way? Why aren't they...
Does understanding help also? Some people like to name it to tame it. Does knowing more actually affect how we feel, or is it just a tool that we can use in some other way?
I think there's a lot of family dynamics in the Orthodox community, in the frum community.
Maybe less so out of town, by the way.
I think so. But certainly in town there's this like, "Why isn't my kid keeping up with everyone else? It's embarrassing. You know, what if other people find out about what's going on?" And there's a sort of like a bit more. So sometimes that knowledge that you have of your kid's struggle or whatever it is can actually make it worse.
Depending on what's going on. But it shouldn't. It should be a context for understanding and for connection and for bringing them in and for figuring out what they need. That's what it's for. Like being healthy.
I noticed that you were posting that you were... Where were you recently? In Venezuela and Chile? Where were you?
You were in Brazil? I was so off. You were in Brazil. And you met with people, you were talking about something to do with also spirituality and psychology. I found that fascinating, but you had only posted like a tiny little caption, so I wanted to ask you if you could share a little bit about...
Sure. Sure. So actually, the center of my McLean Hospital research portfolio is on spirituality and mental health.
Yeah. Again, one of the reasons I stick around. You're able to do literally just out-there research in a very niche area and really push to...
So, how does it show up? Like in what kind of studies?
Oh my god. Yeah. I mean, I've been doing this work for 15 years here. This is my academic work. Published about 100 studies on it. So, hard to say where to start.
But, you know, I'll give you a couple pieces of data that I shared with the folks in Brazil. One of them is that 60% of our patients here in Massachusetts, which is not exactly a religious fundamentalism hotbed...
Right. Like super liberal.
Not at all. Like zero. 60% of our patients want to have conversations about spirituality and religion with their therapists.
Okay, that's interesting.
Mhm. Yeah, fascinating. I never would have guessed that had I not studied it. And when we offer spiritual care, about 60% of our patients actually show up voluntarily.
Okay, that is interesting.
I'm surprised to hear that.
I thought it would be 10 or 20.
I don't know how we figure that out and how you document that, but that is really the way that I'm filing it away right now. Just like I was just in one of the only mixed-faith environments that I've worked in, which was when I was in Chicago, and the amount of people who wanted to stop me not to network but just to talk Judaism...
Yeah, I wear my yarmulke. I wear my yarmulke at McLean, I get stopped all the time, with patients, staff sometimes.
Do you feel the weight of like you're representing?
Yeah, I mean, I think of myself as a bit of an ambassador to that world, to the academic psychiatry world. So I like it. Like I kind of thrive in that. In Brazil I was at the Congress of Psychiatry, the Brazilian Congress of Psychiatry. Yeah. So I like it. I mean, I love, you know, I was in front of 400 people there, had, you know, professional translators in the back, and of course I'm like, that's really cool.
But also the fact that I'm sure that people are surprised that Orthodox Jews care about this, or work on this, or aren't like... I mean, I know that Freud, let's say, was Jewish, but the fact that we're into like modern-day mental health.
Are you serious? It was called the Jewish science?
Yes, yes. And Jews are disproportionately present within psychiatry. In fact, to the point that since October 2023 I've actually not really experienced a lot of anti-Semitism at all because I'm in a psych department. And a lot of my colleagues, a lot of the people are Jewish. Not particularly religious, but have a strong Jewish identity, and they've come over, and if anything I've had more connection.
That's pretty cool. Is there a difference between being anxious and having anxiety?
Okay, what's the difference? Let's hear it.
When you say having anxiety, I assume you mean clinical anxiety, because when they say "I have anxiety," I assume you mean an anxiety disorder. Let's just back up a second. When it comes to depression, we talked about depression before. People talk about sadness, which all human beings have, and then we talk about depression, which not all human beings have had. That's a discrete period of sadness which gets in the way of your life.
Mhm. Even though that's like a numbness for so many, it's still considered...
Either one. Either sad or numb or anhedonic, not enjoying things. But that's the constellation where at a certain point it gets in the way of your existence. We don't bifurcate. We don't distinguish between anxiety being clinical and normal. We use the same word, anxiety.
Right. So when somebody says I have anxiety, though, I assume what they mean is that I have anxiety that's causing me a problem.
Being anxious is actually... Let me ask you, have you ever met someone who has no anxiety?
Okay, what about successful people? Have you ever seen a super successful person who has no anxiety at all?
I think they do. I think they live differently. Some people can hide it well or they can bypass it. That's how I see it.
I don't know if we're bypassing it. I think it's a matter of using it in a constructive way. You know, if you use it to do more, to prepare more, to be more on your game, to be more self-aware. I think there are other tools you can use where you harness anxiety forward to build more resilience, to build more connection.
To build more connection.
I like that. Is it because we care about what other people think?
In the best of worlds, the experience of anxiety, feeling anxious, should draw us towards and closer to other people who are in our world.
I do love that. Step two in my process.
Step two. I want to go through all the steps. But I have this question that I think other people might have even sent to me. But can we be both anxious and happy?
100%. 100%. I mean, we said before, nobody has zero anxiety.
Right? So if there's anybody who's happy, then right away...
Like a dialectic approach, or just in general people can be anxious and...
It's not true that anxiety can be eliminated from your life. Like there's something called adrenaline. You have it. There's actually a test which is done for babies at birth to make sure that they have a fear response. And if they don't, then they're usually not going to make it.
The Babinski or whatever that is?
Well, it's like a... either a sound is emitted and then you see whether the baby has a startle response, or the baby's like lifted up like three inches off and then they're dropped back. And if they don't startle, like you call in a neurologist.
Those are dangerous cases. Like you have to have some degree of response to threat.
So you're really offering that connection between why that's important at childbirth and how it presents in adulthood.
It's a fundamental part of being human. It doesn't just end at childbirth. The importance of that emotion, it's something that you can carry through. You can just have more sophisticated ways of dealing with it than you can when you're a baby at birth.
Okay, so some people obviously are learning about the difference between an anxiety that needs some more support and some that doesn't. And the word is the same, which makes it confusing. But how do we know when anxiety's impacting our life to an extent that we actually need to seek out care?
Great question. First, if you're not sure, there's no loss to going and getting a consultation. Okay? I mean, I think if you have any questions, just go and meet someone and see if it's causing an issue. I prefer a false positive than a false negative in some regards. However, there's an understanding among not all mental health professionals that some degree of anxiety is normal. The main factor that turns something into clinical versus non-clinical anxiety is if it gets in the way of living the life that you need to live.
If it's keeping you up at night that you can't sleep, that's a clinical problem. If it's getting in the way of you performing in your job or completing classes or dating...
...you know, or certainly going to the supermarket, running errands, like doing whatever it is that you have to do day-to-day, driving.
Yeah, there's so many different ways that it can manifest. There's like freezing, avoiding, agoraphobia, things like that that I would say seem to me like stress response or anxiety response.
And you deal with the whole gamut.
Yeah. I want to make also an important point here. Sometimes people have severe anxiety in a certain area, but it doesn't really interfere with their life.
So they're just anxious about a certain experience, like let's say flying a plane, and if they don't go on a plane, they're fine.
They don't need to. Like it really just never gets in the way. It's hard to say that that's like a clinical issue.
There are medications though that people do for them.
It doesn't get in the way of their life. They have ways of sort of navigating around it, and it's not...
So that's considered doable. Like that's manageable.
Are there other ways to manage it? Sure. But I don't know if I'd be so quick to intervene in that kind of case. But then you have other people who have actually lower levels of anxiety, but they interpret it as I am a failure.
And they're like, I can't date anyone. I'm not going to get married. I'm not going to have kids. Like I'm done.
It is. It is. But it can start with the point of like something must be so broken.
I met someone recently in the concierge mental health case. And shame, by the way, is so common in...
Huge. Among, I think it's...
Is it like cultural? Because it's like in America for sure you hear so often.
Especially in wealthy families.
The shame is much worse. There's a chasm between me or my perception of myself and my parents.
Is it also about giving airs, like, you know, putting on a like presenting, performative?
Have to look a certain way because you're a whatever. And they put the last... fill in the famous last name because you're one of them.
And then I think about certain cultures where they're... I don't know, I'm thinking like Israel, right? Israelis. And they come at things with this confidence and this clarity, and they're not apologizing, and you don't see that shame peeking through. And I always wonder like why? Is it because they're living through survival, like they are more resilient? Is that what it is because they've been through more? Is that what makes the shame, like fights away the shame?
Thank God my wife and I spent a bunch of time in Israel. She has three siblings over there.
One of the things I always marvel at is when we go to friends' houses and meet with their Israeli kids. And thank God I got to have several of those. They're talking about their struggles. They don't have to be perfect.
American kids need to be perfect. Like, I don't have any struggles. Everything's fine. I got, you know.
Yeah. So you think that's a big part of like...
100%, that's the core of it.
That's the core of it. That we need to talk about it. We have to normalize talking about it. It is something that I see with certain friends of mine. They'll talk, they'll be immersed in an issue, and then they're good.
That's very... Yeah, I would say it seems very healthy to me.
But I think there are other people who get lost in it. Like what's the defining factor for each one to know who's going to get lost in it and needs to work what I would consider like past it?
Do you know what the defining factor is?
What's the defining factor?
No. If you accept that you're not fully in control and that some things are going to suck...
That makes a lot of sense.
But if you think that everything has to be under your thumb... I don't know if I would have come to that conclusion if I lived in Jackson.
Okay.
I hear.
We're not hating on in-towners, but a little bit.