CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Paul Kedrosky gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Paul Kedrosky
Managing Partner, SK Ventures

The Myth of the Great CEO

📅 Oct 29, 2026 The Dick Costolo & Paul Kedrosky Show and RiskReversal Media 45 MIN 3426 VIEWS 170 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Dick Costolo and Paul Kedrosky discuss the “myth of the CEO,” criticizing the worship of godlike tech leaders and the recency bias that elevates celebrity executives despite evidence of poor leadership. They argue management books and public CEO personas create misleading templates that founders try to imitate, often becoming inauthentic and destructive. Costolo recounts a Twitter board story contrasting Jobs-style focus with Bezos’s “do everything” approach to show there are many paths to success. They emphasize good CEOs admit what they don’t know, encourage dissent, manage to outcomes rathe...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:26[laughter] This is like a crime scene. What the hell?
  2. 1:27Are you sure that was the CEO role?
  3. 6:54Bezos looks at Jack and goes, 'Oh, yeah?
  4. 10:32it is... You think people are fooled?
  5. 13:04[laughter] And it's... This is heresy, right?
  6. 15:41... and he looks at the camera and goes, 'I ain't no role model.' And after a Houston Rockets game, this reporter's in the locker room with Hakeem Olajuwon and says, 'You know, do you think it's bad if kids think of you as a role model?
  7. 22:44Or they would have been coming to you and saying, 'You know what?
  8. 23:03Because they're firing all the good people. This kind of thing, right?
  9. 24:19All fives. This is that though, right?
  10. 26:19Critical bug takes down AdSense for 4 hours. Like, okay, what happened?
  11. 31:40What in the world are you doing with those?
  12. 41:47And then there's this bad thing that happened, but here's a great thing—another great thing that happened.' Like just—again, you think your people are fooled?
Paul Kedrosky 0:00 ↗
If you could put together a perfect board, the board of your dreams at a company, I'm like, okay, well, you've already lost me. But nevertheless...
Dick Costolo 0:06 ↗
Yeah, I already have the answer. It's nobody on the board. Zero. [laughter] No board members.
Paul Kedrosky 0:11 ↗
Right. He said, well, the last person we asked this said their ideal board would be like, you know, all of the great CEOs: Dario Amodei, Sam Altman, Elon Musk. And I said, are you setting up a board or like a homicide scene?
Dick Costolo 0:26 ↗
[laughter] This is like a crime scene. What the hell?
Paul Kedrosky 0:28 ↗
I get a board deck from the CEO, and I respond, if you execute this plan, you will have an unfundable company in 18 months. By the way, this assumes you do everything you say you're going to do in this plan. In 18 months from now, God willing and the creek don't rise, you will have an unfundable company. And then they're like, no, the reason that's not true is... I'm like, I'm not asking you, I'm informing you. You know, and but that happens with remarkable frequency.
Dick Costolo 0:59 ↗
All right, welcome back to the Dick and Paul show. I am Dick Costolo, entrepreneur, several-time entrepreneur, former CEO of Twitter, currently venture capitalist at O1 Advisors. And you are...
Paul Kedrosky 1:12 ↗
Paul Kedrosky. And I was just saying to you before, I'm a venture capitalist. But I was just saying to you before, I've also been the CEO, but it was at an institute at a major research university where if you had asked everyone who worked for me, they would have denied they worked for me. Which is the best. It's [laughter] like...
Dick Costolo 1:27 ↗
Are you sure that was the CEO role?
Paul Kedrosky 1:30 ↗
You know, it's possible that I wasn't actually the CEO and no one told me. Yeah. That's actually what... They hid it because at universities they'll call it things like, um, managing director. [laughter] It's like, who knows what that actually means. But this sort of is... This is our topic, though, right? Is this the...
Dick Costolo 1:44 ↗
Our topic is the myth of the CEO.
Paul Kedrosky 1:48 ↗
The all-seeing, um, ubermensch CEO has really never been stronger. Maybe during the Steve Jobs era, but that was Steve and probably Steve and Bezos solely. Now there's this sort of, oh, you know, I mean, the new Vanity Fair new establishment. It's like it's Sam and Elon and, you know, and then Trump has all these, you know, the nine of them into the Oval Office for some sort of book signing or something. And there's this... so there's this myth of the great CEO on the mountain, right? And yet the evidence is pretty, um, compelling that there have never been more horrible CEOs than there are now. So let's go, let's talk about this today.
Dick Costolo 2:39 ↗
On one level, you know, someone has to be in charge. [laughter] Right. So if you start from...
Paul Kedrosky 2:44 ↗
You'd be surprised.
Dick Costolo 2:45 ↗
Yeah, well, that's actually welcome to universities. If you start from the premise that someone has to be in charge, okay, fine. Someone has to be in charge of this. You know, you can babble all you want about teams, but at the end of the day someone's going to have to actually make decisions about budgets and whatever else. Let's start in this place. One of them is, and you just gave the example of this idea of the god-like character of certain tech CEOs. I had someone call me the other day and they were saying, Paul, we'd like you to contribute to this thing. One of the questions we ask everyone is if you could put together a perfect board, the board of your dreams at a company. And I'm like, okay, well, you've already lost me.
Paul Kedrosky 3:19 ↗
Yeah, I already have the answer. Nobody on the board. [laughter] No board members.
Dick Costolo 3:24 ↗
Right. That's the answer. He said, so for example, like, you know, who you would put there and, you know, like would it be Dario Amodei? Would it be this? And I'm like, okay, I'm gone already. [laughter] What are we talking about? He said, well, the last person we asked this said their ideal board would be like, you know, all of the great CEOs: Dario Amodei, Sam Altman, Elon Musk. And I said, are you setting up a board or like a homicide scene?
Paul Kedrosky 3:50 ↗
[laughter] This is like a crime scene. What the hell? Like, and not only is it at face value such a terrible idea having those personalities on the same board, it's a matter of recency bias. I mean, all credit to Dario who's created Anthropic, but I have no idea if he's a good CEO. No one does.
Dick Costolo 4:07 ↗
Of course.
Paul Kedrosky 4:08 ↗
Right? I mean, he's ridden a dragon to get to where he is now. In two years, is it a zero? Is it a trillion-dollar company? Is it a 20 trillion? I have no idea. There's no data there. And so, this idea of this god-like figure who gets celebrated. And I take it back. Like, you can go back to... A friend of mine worked for years for Jack Welch, um, who was probably one of the... General Electric.
Dick Costolo 4:34 ↗
At the time was like, 'This is the CEO to end all CEOs.' He wrote a book.
Paul Kedrosky 4:40 ↗
He wrote a book. He actually created the Jack Welch Management School. Did you know that?
Dick Costolo 4:43 ↗
I did not know that.
Paul Kedrosky 4:44 ↗
Welch Management School to spread the gospel.
Dick Costolo 4:48 ↗
Great if he created like the Teddy Winkler school of management.
Paul Kedrosky 4:51 ↗
It would have been way better, or at least he would have had deniability. And but if you really look closely, and this isn't me, you know, Jack had his faults like all of us, but a lot of what Welch did that was really effective was he exploited a specific way of creating a multi-divisional structure and then wrapping finance around it, right? And then using a whole series of mergers and acquisitions to kind of drive value. Does that make you a good CEO? Makes you a good investment banker. Or even better, makes you a good investment banker client, right?
Dick Costolo 5:19 ↗
Yeah.
Paul Kedrosky 5:20 ↗
But so this is part of the problem is like, so maybe I'll turn it to you. Like, what actually in your mind, having been on both sides, what actually makes a good CEO versus a bad one?
Dick Costolo 5:28 ↗
Well, I'll talk first about, I think, mistakes people make. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, it's 2011. Um, I'm the CEO of Twitter. Jack Dorsey is the chairman of the board of Twitter. Um, and we ask ourselves who would be a great independent director. We have one independent board seat and we really want to get an independent director.
Paul Kedrosky 5:48 ↗
Explain what that is, by the way.
Dick Costolo 5:49 ↗
Sorry. An independent director is someone who's not an investor in the company, but you want them on the board for governance purposes, advice and counsel, and 'I've been here before, and you know, I'm not a VC or a banker who's put a bunch of money in this company, but I've been in the seat you're in before, and I know how to do this.' And so, we decide Bezos would be the best possible independent director. And so, he takes the meeting and starts off by saying, 'Look, I don't let any of my C-suite join boards because they should be focused on Amazon, so I'm already violating my own rule, but this is interesting enough that I want to have the meeting.' And he asks the question, by the way, I'm getting to the point about the bad CEO thing. Jeff asked the question, 'How do you guys think about strategy?' And Jack right away says, 'Well, Steve' — Steve Jobs, who was alive at the time — 'Well, Steve says the most important part about strategy is to say no. And it's the CEO's job to really be the editor-in-chief and to say no to almost everything, and only do a few things really well.'
Paul Kedrosky 6:53 ↗
Okay.
Dick Costolo 6:54 ↗
And Bezos looks at Jack. This is actually a much longer story, but I'll nip it in the bud. Bezos looks at Jack and goes, 'Oh, yeah? Well, I like to do everything.' [laughter] He has this thing like that, big laugh. And then he goes, 'My team has to talk me out of stuff.' And he kind of calms down and says, 'You know, Jack, there's lots of ways to be successful.' The point that I'm making in retelling this is there are all these books written about these great CEOs. There's the book written about Jack Welch. There's a book, of course, written about Elon by our buddy, our friend at the Aspen Institute. Um, there are, of course, the countless movies and books about Steve Jobs. Um, I think he also wrote the... Walter again, Walter again, Walter Isaacson wrote both the Musk and the Jobs book. But, you know, if you try to just go embody the myth and be that person when you're not that person at all, or not that person, you know, think the way that person thinks, it's A, it's not possible. You can only try to be somebody else for so long before people sniff it out. It just doesn't work. And then B, the book is a myth. That's not what the person's really like. I mean, I had a couple, you know, various meetings with Steve and, you know, he's not the guy in the book. He's a different guy. And in fact, Jeff's story went on to tell, like, you know, here's the difference between the myth and the reality. So, I think the mistake people make is they read a management book and they go, 'This is the way to do X.' And that management book was written by a person who did it in an instance when it worked, and it might not have worked nine times out of 10 otherwise.
Paul Kedrosky 8:45 ↗
And it was also this sort of perfect melding of, you know, personality, opportunity, all that kind of stuff, right? That all of those things came together, and if you try to, you know, mix it back, put the ingredients back together and do it a second time, you end up, at the very least, it ends up sort of inauthentic because it doesn't work for you and it doesn't really represent, you know, what the company opportunity was. And I mean, my favorite example of that all the time are the people who say, 'I read that Steve Jobs always wore the same clothes every day to work,' right? As if that was the...
Dick Costolo 9:14 ↗
As if that's one of the key ingredients. Right. [laughter] So, I'm going to wear the same t-shirt and the same jeans.
Paul Kedrosky 9:19 ↗
Black jeans and a black t-shirt and everything else. It's crazy how many people still live by that dogma. As a matter of fact, there's a documentary out right now about Elizabeth Holmes. Holmes early on, this was her whole mantra, was I am the sort of the Steve Jobs-y figure in the sense that, you know, I'm going to really simplify my life down because to be an effective CEO, I need to have a grand vision.
Dick Costolo 9:43 ↗
And in fact, Elizabeth did wear just the black turtleneck and just the black turtleneck. The same. The same.
Paul Kedrosky 9:47 ↗
Oh, all the time, right? But she was, and she said it straight up. And but one of her things was, so that allows me to really focus on the opportunity because I don't have to think about such mundane things as clothes, and I can really, you know, take Theranos to the max. So leaving aside what Theranos turned out like, that style of thinking [snorts] is everywhere, right? This idea that the superficial things I see, you know, Jack Welch was a great financier, so I need to kind of be an I-banker sort of CEO that I need to think in terms of, like, you know, building shareholder value via these transactions, or I need to be the charismatic CEO. I need to be the person who can do this sort of incredible reveal of the iPhone at some conference or whatever. And it's everybody seizes on these little bits and pieces and misses what the...
Dick Costolo 10:32 ↗
The characteristic de jour is the Palmer Luckey Elon Musk. I don't give a [__]. [laughter] You know, [__] you. I'm going to... I'm going to... I'm... Yeah, Alex Karp. I'm going to use words I shouldn't use that people are going to be horrified by. I don't really care. And I'm going to, you know... I'm naughty. Yeah, I'm naughty and I'm going to be naughty on Twitter. I'm a naughty guy. Yeah, yeah, on CNBC and... And on CNBC, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Precisely. And now so you have these young CEOs who look at this characteristic de jour and are like, 'Oh, I'm going to... Oh, I got to go do that.' And that's got to be part of the bundle. And if that's not who you are... it is... You think people are fooled? Nobody... I used to tell my new managers at Twitter this. I was like, 'Your job is not to be omniscient.' Like, you don't have to have all the answers. In fact, I expect you to have very few answers. Like, so get feedback about decisions that have to be made and then make sure they get made. You don't have to make them all, but don't try to be, you know, don't try to pretend to your team that you have all the answers because they're not fooled, and then everyone's just going to be miserable. But it happens all the time.
Paul Kedrosky 11:41 ↗
All the time. All the time. And the mirror image of that is when you do pretend you have all the answers, you can end up with people who are fearful to bring you answers.
Dick Costolo 11:49 ↗
100% correct. Godspeed.
Paul Kedrosky 11:52 ↗
Right. So they're afraid to bring you answers because they're like, well, he already has the answer. All I'm going to do is essentially, I'm saying you're wrong. I'm going to get yelled at. So I'm not going to bring you answers because clearly, even though I know your answers are wrong, there's no upside in me bringing you anything because it's a career-limiting move for me to bring you that stuff. And that's the other message that comes out implicitly if you're the kind of CEO who says, you know, well, I, you know, come and tell me, but I've really spent a lot of time thinking about this. It turns out that I'm actually an expert. Right.
Dick Costolo 12:23 ↗
Yeah. It brings up a great... I used to have these like various CEO groups when you're running a company because you get together with people, you basically get together and commiserate.
Paul Kedrosky 12:34 ↗
Right. Your fellow sufferers.
Dick Costolo 12:35 ↗
Yeah. I mean, you're like, you know, got these 4,000 employees. Someone's always doing something naughty somewhere. [clears throat] I have three VCs on the board and I want to kill them all. Yeah. Like [laughter] Yeah. In my case, six VCs on the board all giving me product feedback. You know what you need to do? Like, well, but really no one suggested that so far of the millions and millions of users we have. What we really need to do. Have dinner with a group of CEOs and Aaron Levie's there, Box CEO, who was great.
Paul Kedrosky 13:03 ↗
Yeah. Aaron's great.
Dick Costolo 13:04 ↗
And I love... And Aaron says, you know, we had this offsite the other day and we're going through the core values and my, you know, CFO is like questioning core value number two. I'm like, okay. He's like, well, I like, you can't question... These are the core values. You can't question these. And I was like, Aaron, how are you going to know if they're still the company core values if no one interrogates whether they're true or not? And if you get punished for going, 'Can we still believe this?' Like... [laughter] And it's... This is heresy, right? We'll burn you at the stake.
Paul Kedrosky 13:40 ↗
In fact, one of the things I used to do at Twitter with the leadership team is, you know, what are things we thought were true that turned out not to be true, and why did we think they were true?
Dick Costolo 13:53 ↗
Yeah. Sure.
Paul Kedrosky 13:54 ↗
And so one of them was at Twitter, like, you have to tweet. When I took over as CEO, the feeling inside Twitter was you have to tweet in order to get... in order to really get Twitter, you have to be a publisher. You have to tweet.
Dick Costolo 14:05 ↗
So as a leader... Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Paul Kedrosky 14:07 ↗
No, the company thought that. And it was because, you know, whoever, I don't know whether it was Biz or Ev or, you know, whoever had said, 'No, you really have, you know, this is all about tweeting. If you don't tweet, you can't really get Twitter.' Well, as we now know, and, you know, at the time there are lots of people on Twitter who never publish.
Dick Costolo 14:27 ↗
Never. Ever.
Paul Kedrosky 14:28 ↗
Yeah, the vast majority. And so, you know, if you don't interrogate, if you don't let people bring you, 'Hey, why do we think that?' You know? Like, have we actually gone out and found out whether that's true or not? People are walking around saying like, well, you know, as dear leader says, you have to tweet in order to get Twitter. If you don't let people interrogate these things once in a while, then these things that you hold dear are just dogma and are, you know, 50% chance they're true and 50% chance they're not.
Dick Costolo 14:58 ↗
Yeah, but I mean, it's true, but the problem always is, I see, especially for new CEOs, is they see it as a loss of power, a loss of authority.
Paul Kedrosky 15:04 ↗
Yeah.
Dick Costolo 15:04 ↗
It's as soon as I start... care less whether I made the... People would ask me questions and I would be like, I don't know. We should go find out, though.
Paul Kedrosky 15:12 ↗
But why did you feel like you could do that?
Dick Costolo 15:14 ↗
I don't know. I think a lot of it's just... I think if there's one thing I would pat myself on the back for, or just say about, like, okay, well, at least I did that, I was always myself. I was never like trying to be someone I wasn't. Ever.
Paul Kedrosky 15:29 ↗
Yeah.
Dick Costolo 15:29 ↗
And so when you're not trying to, you know, there's this great old... actually Ben Horowitz talked about this way back in his good CEO, bad CEO blog posts. Um, Ben Horowitz from Andreessen Horowitz.
Paul Kedrosky 15:40 ↗
Yeah.
Dick Costolo 15:41 ↗
He's got this great anecdote about Charles Barkley, the basketball, NBA basketball player, and Hakeem Olajuwon. And so at the time Charles Barkley was doing a Nike ad, and in the Nike ad he dunks the basketball and he looks at the camera and goes, 'I ain't no role model.' And after a Houston Rockets game, this reporter's in the locker room with Hakeem Olajuwon and says, 'You know, do you think it's bad if kids think of you as a role model? You know, do you think that's something they shouldn't do?' And Hakeem Olajuwon goes, 'No, I think it's great if kids think of me as a role model. I hope I am a role model to some kids.' And the reporter says, 'Well, Charles Barkley, as you know, says people shouldn't, you know, look at basketball players as role models.' And Hakeem says, 'That's because Charles is a different person in public than he is in private. So he's got this constant tension about whether I'm in this moment my public Charles or am I private Charles?' I'm always the same person, so... That tension doesn't exist. And a lot of the challenges that a lot of CEOs have is they have this, here's who I'm supposed to be, but here's who I really am, and they're two different people.
Paul Kedrosky 16:56 ↗
And I think a lot of that, though, is... it's so [clears throat] visible now and so... Constant, right? So they feel as if, you know, it's easier to imitate other CEOs, but it's also easier to be seen doing what you're doing, and there's this constant almost performative aspect to it where I need to make sure that I'm meeting all the criteria and looking how I'm supposed to look and sounding as knowledgeable and charismatic and everything else. And I think it's just incredibly destructive because they end up doing things that just make absolutely no sense. I had a CEO once who took, um, training because he thought he needed to be a bit better public speaker, which is fine. By all means, be a better public speaker. But what he meant by a better public speaker is he basically wanted to do all their product launches, right? He wanted to go out and go the full Jobs, right? And say like, you know, 'and one more thing' and all that stuff, right? And it was so inauthentic for him that it actually became a huge problem that he essentially was like stomping on people all over the organization who, in theory and probably in practice, were much better at all of that than he was, but he felt like that's the job of the CEO. The job of the CEO, you know, unlike what Jack was saying at Twitter, is not to say no, it's to be this kind of evangelist, right? This guy who's out there and, you know, follow me over the cliff. This is where we're going next, you know?
Dick Costolo 18:12 ↗
The other thing, we were talking about this before the podcast. Um, you and I agree, I think, that a shitty CEO can wreck even the business with the best tailwinds behind it.
Paul Kedrosky 18:28 ↗
Oh, absolutely.
Dick Costolo 18:28 ↗
You know, there's this old... In Silicon Valley, there used to be this... is it the market... The Sequoia thing. It was markets or something. I think it was markets. The market... What do you invest in? The market or the founder? You know, the jockey or the market. Like, and I think you and I both believe a bad CEO can take down the best product in the best market with the most tailwinds. And conversely, a great CEO can make even the, you know, most challenging environments work.
Paul Kedrosky 19:01 ↗
And that's the thing. It's really... and in particular in technology, where there's this faith that if the opportunity is big enough and the tailwind is strong enough, this is just going to work. We just have to put some money into this, if you're an investor, or I should join it as an employee, or whatever the case may be, and then it'll all sort itself out. And I'm sure there probably are examples of that, but in general it's not the way to bet because I have watched... I don't even... I have lost track. I was talking to my partner Eric about this the other day, that like how many companies where the opportunity was incredible and we had someone in there we were like, yeah, I don't know if this is the right CEO to make this work. They run it into the ground every time. Every single time they run it into the ground. And it's just become so obvious to me that it's so much not about the tailwinds and about the market. It's all about someone who knows, you know, how to hire good people, how to run a... sort of manage a balance sheet, how to keep track of burn rates, how to... like all these really mundane things. None of them that have to do with, you know, waving a flag and putting on a zippy presentation to get some million YouTube views, right? Because that's not what gets you there. It's like this ability to, you know, to have... I mean, this is one of my claims. So what a good CEO is really good at is really good at both hiring and firing.
Dick Costolo 20:20 ↗
Yeah. That's right.
Paul Kedrosky 20:21 ↗
That good people want to come and stay, and they're really good at slow-walking bad people into the organization to the point that they often don't even get in, and when they do get in...
Dick Costolo 20:31 ↗
They're gone quickly.
Paul Kedrosky 20:32 ↗
They're gone... The reality is they almost always get into the organization. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It has to be the case that they're gone quickly.
Dick Costolo 20:39 ↗
Right.
Paul Kedrosky 20:40 ↗
But there's always... Jeff Weiner, the CEO of LinkedIn for quite some time and took the company public, used to have this great analogy of it's like the baseball manager going out to the mound when he knows... okay, Pedro just gave up a home run.
Dick Costolo 20:56 ↗
Yeah, right. [laughter]
Paul Kedrosky 20:57 ↗
His arm's looking kind of noodly. And he goes out to the mound and Pedro's like, no, I'm good, coach. I got it. I know exactly how to strike this next guy out.
Dick Costolo 21:07 ↗
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Goes back to the mound, goes back to the dugout, next guy comes up, hits another home run. And just like...
Paul Kedrosky 21:14 ↗
People want to believe, so they leave the pitcher in too long. And it happens all the time.

78 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Kedrosky, P. (2026, October 29). The Myth of the Great CEO [Interview transcript]. The Dick Costolo & Paul Kedrosky Show and RiskReversal Media. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3266093/

MLA

Paul Kedrosky. "The Myth of the Great CEO." The Dick Costolo & Paul Kedrosky Show and RiskReversal Media, 29 Oct. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3266093/.

BibTeX
@misc{kedrosky2026_3266093,
  author       = {Paul Kedrosky},
  title        = {The Myth of the Great CEO},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, The Dick Costolo \& Paul Kedrosky Show and RiskReversal Media. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3266093/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}