Mayor Mamdani, what brings you to Puerto Rico this time?
I am here visiting for the Somos conference, which is an annual conference in San Juan that New York City, organized labor, politicians, so many different parts of political life come and underline the unbreakable bond between New York City and Puerto Rico.
But I heard that you took this opportunity to meet with some groups. How did that go?
It went really well. And I think part of that is out of a desire to ensure that when you're visiting Puerto Rico, you're also visiting Puerto Rico and you're not just coming to a hotel in Puerto Rico. And it was illuminating. You know, I first visited this morning a community resilience hub that the Hispanic Federation made possible in partnership with El Puente. And I heard from a number of local organizers who spoke about the fact that so often what are in fact political crises in Puerto Rico are described as natural crises. And even this topic of the recent drought is one that they were emphasizing again and again that a drought does not explain a lack of preparation for a drought. A drought does not explain the fact that while most water systems are able to retain north of 80% of the water by the time it delivers it to an individual, the Puerto Rican water system loses more than 60% of its water by the time of delivery. And again and again emphasizing that these are the results of political choices. Later in the day, speaking to organizers about Proyecto in Cabo Rojo and hearing about the contrast in a moment of drought between what people are being asked to do, which is to ration their water, and then a project which would consume 1.5 million gallons of water a day.
So tell me about those meetings with the people who are opposed to Esencia. Is this huge luxury project that is proposed of San Juan they were saying is proposed for Cabo Rojo. And you're the mayor of New York, but in New York there have been Puerto Ricans protesting this project and part of what they're saying is that it's a local project but some of the actors are either based in New York or they act in New York. My question to you is, is there anything that you are planning to do to address the concerns of those Puerto Ricans who are opposed to Esencia?
That's the question that I actually asked the organizers today was beyond learning more about the project which was incredibly helpful is to understand how can we actually be in solidarity. And what they made clear is one, that adding a voice to opposition is incredibly helpful in a time when local government is looking to steer this project to completion through the creation of all sorts of new rules and regulations. And secondly, to look at what is the economic relationship between our city and the project itself. A lot of that work is still to be done but even just coming out of that meeting this afternoon, it's very clear to me that this is exactly the kind of project that leads so many to speak about Puerto Rico and in New York City our connection to Puerto Rico is not just by virtue of the fact that we are home to the largest Puerto Rican diaspora in the world, but also the relationship between that diaspora, this island, and the struggle of working people. And so not only will I add my voice in opposition, but also to look at the shared struggles between New Yorkers in El Barrio who are struggling with rent and Puerto Ricans here on the island who are struggling with Act 60 and the ways in which government inaction and action have escalated the crisis facing working people.
So once again, before we move on from Esencia, you say that you're going to add your voice in opposition to that project. Can you summarize why?
I am opposing this project because it is clear that this is yet the latest example of an attempted displacement of Puerto Ricans from their own land. And when I was sitting with these organizers, they laid out to me how there was a group chat that the prior governor was a part of. The messages were then leaked, and how one member of that group chat said, I had a dream, Puerto Rico without Puerto Ricans. And in many ways, Proyecto Esencia seems to be a fulfillment of that dream. The idea of creating a city five times the size of San Juan that would consume 1.5 million gallons of water a day, that would threaten the ecological facts of life today of this entire island is one that I think should be opposed on economic grounds, on moral grounds, on environmental grounds. And I think the reason that it also matters so much to so many in New York City is that this is what it looks like to lose one's home for so many. And the kinds of roadblocks that are being put up even just to the opposition of it. I mean, today, again, so much of this is new information to me, but the idea that those organizing an opposition would have to put up, you know, I think it was 200, 10% as a bond just in order to sue. It shows in many ways how the cards are stacked against so many. And I as the mayor of New York City, by virtue of leading the largest city in our country, have a platform. And with that platform, a responsibility to ensure that we understand working people's struggles through a solidaristic lens, not just through the sense of this is my constituency and this is not. New York City wouldn't be New York City without Puerto Ricans. So how can we turn a blind eye to yet another example of how Puerto Ricans are treated as second-class citizens in their own home?
You mentioned Act 60. Act 22, which is now part of Act 60, is the law that allows people who move to Puerto Rico at least part of the year. It allows them to pay 0% capital gains tax. At a time where you're trying to tax millionaires in New York City, what does this mean for you? And what are you thinking that you can do about that?
Well, I think tax justice is tax justice wherever we're speaking of it, right? You look at Esencia, it's financed through about $500 million in tax breaks. Tax breaks that even in and of themselves were intended to finance the construction of hotels. And the little that I know of this project is that about 1,100 units are being constructed as luxury housing. And that to me showcases the way that so often these kinds of policies are measures to protect the wealth of the already wealthy. And when we fight for a fairer tax system in our city, we do so because the revenue that it would create would transform the lives of working people and in doing so the life of everyone who calls New York City home. And when we're talking about New York City, we're also talking about the financial capital of the country. And in that there is a relationship between a lot of these kinds of fiscal policies and also a relationship between whether or not we turn a blind eye to what's being done in the name of tax policy at large.
So in Puerto Rico it seems like the policy is opposite to what you are proposing and enacting in New York City because what is often said here is that we need economic development and that the way that you do that is that you invite the wealthy to move here to bring the money. And in order for them to want to come here, you have to give them tax breaks. What do you say to that model of development?
I think it's a bankrupt model of development. It's part of the reason why we created a new position in our administration called the Deputy Mayor for Economic Justice because we wanted to reframe what development should be. Development should be something that a working person can feel in their wallet, not something that they open the newspaper and they can only see in a graph about the strength of the economy. And that is true in New York City, it's true in Puerto Rico. And so much of the rationale that's been given around this, it's you know, you can come and own a home, you have to give $5,000 to a non-profit, and now apparently there are people setting up their own non-profits. It speaks to the fact that there is an entire system, an entire ecosystem that is built around the evasion of accountability. And to think that this would not become a part of that, it showcases that the rationale is not economic development. The rationale is the preservation of wealth.