Hello everyone, thank you for joining us. I'm Himea Amaya and this is Lavin Lasaris. We are the creative and programming team at the HMCT. Before we get started, we would like to share some context about today's event. It all starts with the exhibition titled Digital Witness, currently on view at LACMA, exploring image manipulation technology and its impact on design, photography and film. At HMCT, we collaborated with LACMA to present a satellite exhibition under the same title, focusing specifically on algorithms for typography and language. So, it was these two exhibitions that offered us the opportunity to organize this panel discussion with LACMA's team, pairing one artist from each exhibition. We are very excited to have Ivan Cruz join us to moderate the discussion. Ivan is a creative technologist, a motion designer and faculty member at ArtCenter College of Design, teaching creative code. So thank you so much, Ivan, for agreeing to participate.
Thank you, Allison and Zach, and thank you everyone for attending. Ivan, we'll pass it on to you and we'll be here in the background in case you need us.
We're all in the same room. I just wanted to show you everybody. Great. So I again like thank thanks I just want to thank LACMA and HMCT for for putting organizing this together. I'm really really excited, especially after just like diving deeper into Allison's and Zach's work. It's a it's a great like pleasure to to to be here. I I want to get started with with this talk before we even kind of like go into into the panel discussion and let me go to
right here. Okay. So, sorry about all that. I I am sharing this on on my mural board here. But so, Algorithm and Rhyme, that's that's the name of our panel discussion. And and more importantly, I was just kind of always like wondering like, you know, why this poster was was picked for for this panel discussion in our links. And the more that I think I was thinking about it, and the more that I kind of was like learning about this this this poster is by April Greiman and and it's it's like one of the first posters, you know, to to be made with with the Apple computer. And so let me zoom zoom in here because I think that's like a we could kind of see see the the the details here and you can kind of see this the the main highlight of this is this wave. So this photograph of a wave that was digitized and and and pixelated, right? Like you could kind of see almost this like pattern in here. And and what one of the things that like April Greiman did was like start like zooming in into these pixels and kind of examining the the the details of of what you know these digital artifacts and and that's like little clue here that we see here. And we kind of zoom in and if you kind of just like remember this pattern. Let me see. Let me move this here a little bit. They kind of remember this pattern here. We see that again, but just blown up. And so I kind of see this as like, you know, zooming in into like the atoms or like the the the pixels, right, of what this what digital means. And and the more that I was thinking about this in terms of our of our panel discussion, it's like I think we're even zooming in even more. It's like we're kind of going into this like almost like the the string this string theory, right? Going deeper and thinking about the algorithms and and the and the the logic that kind of even like puts these pixels in in place. And and here we we have like two two our two guests that are they they spend their their their whole career thinking and and manipulating these algorithms. And so I I thought was just like wow that's such a great great connection. And I'm not sure if that was intentional but like I really just like like how I like that kind of came came together. Well actually I want to start introducing myself and Allison and Zach. So as like Lavin said, I'm I'm a motion designer, creative technologist and I've been
working with algorithms pretty much since I started. I think the it really gave me a sense of of control and and like I didn't have to rely on any other program for me to kind of do what I wanted to do. So algorithms is is a really big part of my work because I could like create my own tools. And I've been teaching at ArtCenter for for over 10 years. So let me introduce to Allison. Allison is a poet, programmer, educator. Her work explores language as data. And what I really like about her work is she looks at language at from every single aspect, from from line breaks to the spacing to like even like new words to the sounds and and I really really really love her work and I'm glad to to have her here. And Zach Lieberman is is an artist, educator, founder of the School for Poetic Computation and his work blends code, visuals and interactivity to express very deep human ideas. And again, thanks again for for being here and I'm going to hand it off to to Allison and what I want to do is just kind of introduce our introduce your work for for a few minutes and then we'll go back to to Zach and then we'll kind of continue our our discussion. All right.
So, as has been mentioned, I'm Allison Parrish. I'm an assistant arts professor at New York University in the Interactive Telecommunications Media Arts program. I'm here in my office today. I was thinking about the importance of of computation in my work and I think it really comes down to the sort of modernist compositional concept of the juxtaposition, like how do you take language and put it together in new ways that make language do things that it hasn't done before and that's really the purpose that I use but that's the reason that I use computation because it it has that importance. So I'm going to talk through a couple different projects that that do that. So the first is Compasses and this is the one that is or it's one of the pieces that's on on display in the exhibition.
So this came from the original impulse or one of the original impulses was wanting to be able to make poetry algorithmically that looks like Baroness Elsa von Freytag-Loringhoven's Dada sound poetry, another sound poetry like this, also like the Zaum poets from, you know, early 20th century Russian artists. So being able to create imaginary words that have particular emotional characteristics. And of course there are a whole bunch of ways of doing this. My way of doing this was to develop a machine learning model. It's called Pencilate. This I made back in like 2018, long long before the advent of large language models. It's not trained on like a on a large language model. It's not fine-tuned from something. It's based it's trained on a data set called the CMU pronouncing dictionary. Basically what it does is you put in the spelling of a word and it predicts the phones of the word. If you put the phone names of the word in, it predicts the spelling and vice versa. It kind of looks like this. And I'm not going to go into the technical details. But the main interesting and cool thing about this and, you know, being able to make something like this as an artist and as a developer is that you can kind of poke around into the model and mess it up at different stages or insert random numbers at particular places, change the change the weights of the outputs and so forth. So one of the things that once I had this model developed that I was able to do was something kind of interesting, which is find the average between two words based on both their spelling and their sound. So basically if I put in the word paper it produces a vector that represents the word paper. If I put in the word plastic it outputs a vector that represents the word plastic. If I average the two and then feed that back into the model at that same point, I get pit, which is halfway between paper and plastic. Halfway between kitten and puppy, the the model says puppy. Halfway between birthday and anniversary, the model says Arthur Day. Halfway between artificial and intelligence, it says intellofistle. With this model, and with that capability, I came up with an idea for a form of poetry that I call a compass poem, which consists of I'm going to show like the the compositional process here. It consists of four corner words which belong to a quartet of related words that aren't in a hierarchy. They don't have an order but they're still a closed set. So here like the four cardinal directions. And then the model I have the model find the average word between those two words between each of the corners and then in the middle the average of all of the words. So this one goes north, earth, east, sew it, south, west, west, worth, a north. I'll show a few more of these.
Um, noon through 3. This 6 nick 9 noon fine. Another one. Cyan, ma, magenta, melet, yellow, bal, black, blean, ma, um, Google, agen, Amazon, Acebound, Facebook, Aspool, Apple, Augle, and Aspel. And I made a whole bunch of these and they're up on a wall somewhere there in LA and you can go look at them. The second thing that I want to talk about is When Tints In. This is me trying to take the same kind of work that I was doing with the sound of language and apply it to the visual appearance of language instead. So to do that, to kind of have like a malleable vector representation of language, of the visual appearance of language, I trained a machine learning model called a GAN. Again this was back pre, you know, stable diffusion days, back when we were using these more elegant tools for a more enlightened age like a GAN. And what I did is I trained this model on a bunch of bitmaps of words, of images of words. And after a while when you train this model, it sort of becomes able to output images that look like your input images, but not quite like those. And I stopped it at just the right point to get the results that I was looking for. So it's outputting things that like kind of from a distance if you squint, they look like real English words, but they're not, right? And then I designed an algorithm to kind of typeset these in the traditional way that you typeset a text with Latin characters, you know, moving from left to right, full justifying it. So, again, it kind of looks like it could be an English language text, but it isn't. Alien Press, which is a publisher that publishes computer-generated literature and other experimental literature, it's run by James Ryan and we wanted to do a project together. So I suggested this to suggested using this model and this is the result of that. It's a book called When It Tints In. The title was generated by the model. And James did this like really beautiful letterpress of the poems. We're calling them like prose poems, I guess. All handmade editions. James was happy with the deckled edges on here that makes it look like it's a, you know, actual nice artifact, which it is. So I want to do like a very brief reading of one of the pages here so you can get a sense of of what it sounds like.
CERNs boon I am gio the wera I guess who Yes. So eron of ha fitus ob6 wo turn away bury thy nitty sorrel wang turf wit your wang to join us god wear in nia wides vc sheave o tier millet on pain their sir mugg tavarin our eway had cargaths abro Boys, peasel and mores. Those winner dot balt thsy nurled revy alms of ba henray fpppes tro belglay west eel theos hior fi afs wayy foil no kar me morrettes Todd Joyce the thing in your thoon feva soy aban the ice bar I spex lips ch as if be a P I've sworn oong t and sack shy's foot or so and yodel inve
I want to talk about one more thing. This just came out last year. It's a piece called Drafts from Text Press. I've been doing a bunch of stuff with machine learning for quite some time and I kind of wanted to get back to some more basic concepts of computation. So this is a short book of poetry that's based on the weaving draft, which is a notation for weaving that shows how you set up a loom in order to create a woven piece of fabric. A weaving draft normally looks something like this where the pattern for the threading of the warp is along the top and the pattern for the treadling or in other words like which shafts are lifted. I realize this means nothing to people who don't know how a loom works but and then the tie up is how the treadling is connected to the threading. And then this big section over here is the draw down. It shows what those instructions what the woven fabric will look like when it's woven according to the instructions and the threading and the treadling and the tie up. So I did a series of poems where instead of representing instead of the threads being yarn of different colors, the threads are each individual letters, but it's still following the rules of the draw down. So here I'm doing a tabby draft of the word abracadabra woven with itself. So you get like araba. I'm not going to read the whole thing because I haven't practiced it.
This is a more complicated example. It just has one of the definitions of weaving from Wikipedia as the warp in the left. The threads running lengthwise, horizontal interlaced threads. And you get this arrangement of repetition that is, you know, both revealing and obscuring the the text that goes into it. And it's a very, you know, I used a computer program to generate this, but you could just do this by hand as well. Here's another piece with an Annie Dillard quote: Nature shows herself to us only in part. Art shows us a wholeness we can comprehend. And this is one of my favorites that I actually forgot to include in the manuscript that I sent to Text Press. So you get to see this exclusive outtake from the book. It's just a color and weave pattern pattern with root in the warp and leaf in the weft. And you get these nice sort of algorithmic combinations of the words root and leaf. That's all I've got.
Wow. Thanks, Allison. I mean, you kind of almost like set me up with a really good like transition to to Zach, how we're like kind of weaving together our our discussion together here. Zach, can can you share a little bit of your work as well?
Okay, great. So, my name is Zach Lieberman. I'm an artist based in New York. I'm actually not far from Allison right now, probably walking distance, but based here. I'm a professor at MIT at the Media Lab and I do sort of art, commercial work and teaching, so one third, one third. Everything I do is created with software. I'm writing code and I write code to make images, I write code to make animations, I write code to make interactive work, oftentimes doing things that take the body as input or simple simple ideas like gesture and try to find kind of creative ways of using them. But again, everything is created with code. And I saw this quote recently. Jensen Huang, the CEO of Nvidia, said that kids shouldn't learn how to code. They should leave it up to AI. Yeah, I'm with you, Allison. I fundamentally disagree. Big two thumbs down. I think that code is the computation is the central medium of our lifetime. And it's not just a technical medium, but it's a cultural medium. And as artists, as designers, we should be exploring it and engaging with it and working with it. So yeah, big thumbs down to this quote. I do the way I work with code is I do daily sketches. So for almost 10 years, I started January 1st, 2016, I post something every day. These are like short poems that I make with code that are oftentimes exploring different graphical ideas, ideas like light and reflection, blobs, 3D things that look like 2D. When you do something over and over again, you have to make shortcuts. Here this kid wrote this sentence, I will make better choices. And you can see they've like optimized like the the L is just a single line. And when you do something again and again, you have to make shortcuts. And I think as an artist, as a designer, just constantly creating is how you find your style. And oftentimes I take a simple idea and I iterate on it. So I'll start with a simple gesture like a curve that a line that only makes circular curves and then I'll say like, oh, what would happen if I made it thicker? I'll try different shading. I'll try color. And then sometimes you'll find it in products that I can't talk about because of NDA. But you know these sketches will make their way into the world in different ways. But again I take the same idea, the same kind of graphical language and I keep trying to iterate on it. And sometimes that's very simple ideas like when you learn to code one of the first things that you learn is a bouncing ball, like making a ball bounce off the walls. And I thought about an idea like what if the walls were bouncing off of the ball. So, if you sort of like change the perspective so that the ball's in the center and then the walls are bouncing off of the ball, like I got kind of excited about it. Just a simple like what if question. And then I thought like let's try like more than one, you know, and and oftentimes I start with a simple sketch and I say, can I turn the volume knob up to 11, maybe two balls and have them be normalized. And then I try like three balls and four balls and you know, it gets super weird. So oftentimes I start with a simple idea and then try to push it to like kind of the extreme. Sometimes I'm trying to convey a very complex idea like after Trump was elected the first time I felt like we were living in a sort of cartoon universe. I was excited about the New Year's and sort of really deeply unhappy and uneasy about the political situation. So trying to show sort of happiness and sadness at the same time. I really like kind of yeah anything that's like graphical ink. I will make a make a lot of sketches that are about kind of drawing and picking drawing as a starting point. Have been doing a lot of experiments with typography. This is an AR typography app where you can work with type and paint type in the air. A lot of work with the body, taking the body as a starting point, seeing what happens if you extrude it, revolve it, adding kind of layers onto it, new forms of costume. I've been making a lot of still images. So, I've been printing. You can see behind me, these are all the prints. When I make a mistake, I put it on the wall. So, all of these prints have a little error in them. But I love printing. Really inspired by the artist Jack Whitten, who is this painter I really admire, and he would he would make these crazy contraptions. His whole idea is he wanted to make a painting in like 10 seconds. So he would make this like carpentry like crazy ideas, crazy constructions to make his paintings really quickly. And I've been doing the same thing in code, kind of making these shader programs that make images, trying to create almost this very complex system to make images and been thinking a lot about kind of making images for these last years. And did a project recently. So this is all the same code but kind of with adjustments. For the film studio A24, for Everything Everywhere All at Once, we made a songbook. So all of the sheet music for the movie, I basically listened to the soundtrack and I took the same piece of code and tried to find at that moment in the movie or what what does that song kind of remind me of? So I was able to make images for each of the for each of these songs in the soundtrack. So it was I got to listen to the soundtrack over and over again which was exciting for me. And then have been thinking a lot about sunsets, the kind of color, the algorithms of sunsets, how to convey that computationally. And had this experience where I was traveling with my family, we lived on a boat and I was looking at the water on the or sorry the light on the water and thinking about kind of how that would be impossible to code. Like in a million years you can never write the algorithm to convey like to capture what you were seeing. So I tried to see if I could capture that feeling, the feeling of light on water, in code. So I've done a lot of experiments with kind of sunset and and sun the colors of a sunset on water. So these are some examples of sketches and the end was a project, a kind of generative project with a hundred of these sunsets and the idea is like maybe you had a very cool summer, you just paying attention all the time to the sunsets and you were watching them on the water, so trying to capture that feeling of sun on the water. Doing a lot of work with light and reflection. My partner Momo does neon work and so she's always coming to the studio with neon and I've been trying to convey like that feeling of neon in code, just inspired by the neon that I'm seeing. So a lot of kind of light experiments, just seeing kind of what you could do with code and light, printing it.
And I post the work a lot and you get really funny comments. I love the comments. Somebody said this is gorgeous and nauseating. When I was young, I had a reoccurring nightmare that looked a lot like this. You get some really weird, funny comments. Sometimes people say really beautiful things. I took a look at these full-size. You wouldn't know it at a glance, but this is time-based work. But probably my favorite comment is, this: I had a bad day. I saw your work. My day is good now. Thank you. So, if I think about why I like to do sketching, why I love this medium, why I am like so thumbs down on the Jensen Huang quote, it's this. I want to make work, put it out there, and try to make people's days good. Thank you.
Okay. Well, thanks, Zach. And this is like a kind of what I what I do miss just being in person and just like hearing like, you know, people's reactions and and like the energy of the the room. This is something that we're kind of lacking. But I I could imagine like just hearing people like gasp and and wonder and and be like with with Allison's when you're reading out like I could feel it, right? It's something that's like kind of hard to capture in this Zoom environment. But thanks thanks again for for sharing the the work and I I think one of them like kind of like a you said one one word about like normalization and this is the the this idea of just kind of getting things to zero and one and that's one thing that I kind of want to help to kind of structure this this panel discussion and I'm going to go ahead and share my screen screen again what you guys are going to be looking at now and this is live which we kind of I'll talk about in a second. So, we have this idea of zero to to one is like a a very important kind of concept that I I grabbed on to and I was able to kind of apply to to a lot of things in in in programming. And so that's like if you get if you get anything into a zero into one, you know, you could do anything. The zero is like the start, five is the middle and one is the the end, right? Or we have white on one side, we have black on the other side and and vice versa. Like you could drive a whole complex animation and you just kind of as long as you have zero and you drive that to one or if you have two colors or multiple colors, you know, as long as you have zero to one and you're kind of going through them like we we there's a lot of kind of control that that that that you you you have within these kind of systems that that we created. So, what I'm doing here is I'm going to like I just kind of wrote down some some questions here and and we're gonna kind of go through our panel discussion this way. So, we we'll start off and I have this little gradient here. So, I just focus. And, what I really like about like just like this technology is just kind of having fun with like what you could already do with that program. One of the things I kind of saw at the exhibit is just like how like artists back back in the day, they just had like a few very simple tools and they were able to do a lot with it. And so I like having fun with with with our mural board here as well.
So I I kind of want to start off with our first kind of question and and and part of the the exhibit is just you know seeing how technology and how things have been like digitized over time but I kind of want to get go back and zoom back to to the past and kind of get a sense of where you know what's like the first question, what what's your earliest memory manipulating manipulating languages or or images? Right. And this could be a toy, too. It doesn't have to necessarily be within within a computer, but like what is there something in the in the past where that like you kind of look now and and maybe that was kind of like a start for you to to start kind of like going in that in that direction. And I think Allison, I'll start with with with you. So what what is what's that something in the in the past that that like was kind of like your introduction or like your your your first kind of go at at your career or your your path at my at my career. It could be a career, you know. It could it could just be anything. It just kind of like your your interest, right? I think it's more of your interest. Yeah.
Well, you know, I was usually when I tell this story or when I answer a question like this, it goes through J.R.R. Tolkien, who I read, like, you know, I read The Hobbit. My dad gave it to me to read when I was like in third grade or something like that. And I loved it. And that that got me to be interested in language and and linguistics because I was really into his constructed languages. And you know I also learned to program when I was a kid on a little you know first on a little 8-bit home computer, the TRS-80 Color Computer 2. For any of fans in the house, shout out to the Color Computer 2. And then in in high school, I was taking a creative writing class. I was mostly interested in like writing fantasy novels at that time. But she my creative writing teacher showed us a poem by Gertrude Stein, As a Wife Has a Cow, a Love Story. And that just really captured me because it seemed like Gertrude Stein's work was like combining these threads of like making language do interesting things that were simultaneously not, you know, not algorithmic. Like Gertrude Stein wasn't using computer programs, but they're still, you know, structured in a way that is alien to the way that language is usually structured. And that kind of like cemented things together. But recently I was like I found the the programming manual for the Tandy Color Computer 2 on archive.org or something like that. And this is what I what I read when I was like really really small to learn how to program that computer. And I saw that there was like in the chapter where they first talk about strings, one of their examples was printing out a string that says a rose is a rose is a rose is a rose is a rose is a rose is a rose over and over and over again. So now I'm thinking like it was just that. It was just that like string tutorial in the basic the manual for the BASIC programming language for the Tandy Color Computer 2. That is that is where my career comes from. Exactly. Is that that line? So whoever wrote that, thank you. I'm having a pretty good life.
So Allison, just so is it so you would type that command onto the computer and it would just like line by word or word by word like how how did it look like?
Oh, I don't remember from the from the thing. I assume it was like a I in my I could bring it up, but it was probably just like a for loop that kept printing that string or maybe appending to it after it, but it was just it was interesting that that was their that was their example because that is also a Gertrude Stein poem. So yeah.
That's a really great connection. Like I I think that's like one of the the one of the best things to to do when you're programming or like just like learning to program is is make these
connections, right? Because like a lot of the things that like um usually well when I'm teaching my students is trying to like they think programming I teach a lot of graphic designers and so programming is something just completely distant and it's really far away. And so I always try to make connections to kind of bring it closer to them for for them to understand. Yeah. Zach, what about you? What was um
Yeah. So I I actually was thinking of something that is not something like I was manipulating but something that I saw that really inspired me. Um which was this I was watching a television show. I think it was on PBS and it was like people that make art with cars, like they decorate their cars and there were like all these like crazy cars like people put like cover the car with buttons or you know like painted the car in a really kind of cool way. But there was one car and I found the video um I'm going to paste it in the chat which is a car that is like m a VW Beetle that's covered in light bulbs. And I remember seeing this as like a really young kid and being like so amazed that you could have a like a display that you could create a a surface, you know, that you could drive around and you could have an image that's moving that's animated. And I for years I like was like did I hallucinate that? Like I saw this as a kid, but I never knew what the project was. I could never find it. And then I went to this like I don't know dinky um automobile museum in the middle of nowhere in the middle of uh Pennsylvania and then like turned the corner and saw the exact same show that I saw as like you know a six-year-old or seven-year-old or something. And it was so amazing to like be reacquainted with this thing that had a profound impact on my life. So I think as a kid I think about that when I exhibit work. this idea that like maybe there's some young kid that like gets a chance to see something that I've made or some other artist or an exhibition like at Lakma seeing some really cool weird thing and then they'll be like they're really young but maybe like years later they will remember like oh I saw that you know crazy thing that showed me something is possible and and for me it was seeing um this car with covered in light bulbs.
Yeah, I I think that that's always like a a great thing to like any visuals, right, that that just like grabs your attention and then just kind of makes you wonder how is is always like a a great starting point. Um and as as you're ask um telling us this um I also kind of want to invite the audience to you could share your your your own um you know experiences as well. It'll be great to kind of have a little bit of back and forth as as we're doing this because like for for me the the the just the word algorithm. I learned it from a Rubik's cube when my brother gave me a Rubik's cube and he told me like, "Hey, if you could solve this, you know, like I'll uh I'll buy you a PlayStation 2." And like I was younger and I was just like, "I'm going to do anything I can to get this PlayStation." And um and that's when I like learned um uh some algorithms on on on online and then I was like I figured it out and I was like wow this is amazing and that that was like my my introduction to to to algorithms. Okay. So what what programs did you begin with? And uh we'll start with uh so Allison we go back go back to you.
Um I started with uh basic for the color computer too. Like I mentioned there was a game creation system for uh for MS DOS called ZCT which was actually created by Tim Tim Sweeney of um Epic Games fame. Um it was like his first attempt at making uh a system for like you know userenerated content. Um, so you just make little games uh that ran in text mode on DOSs. Uh, and there was like a really really simple scripting language for those uh for the game creation system. Um, and that's kind of like where where I learned like programming for the first time and interactivity and stuff like that.
And how how were how young were you when when uh you started kind of writing your own programs?
Oh, very young. Like six or seven. Six or seven. Yeah.
Were were um did you play like a lot of like kind like the the text based games? Uh or were were there games that you were kind of playing with that kind of made you want to like like what drove you to keep programming? Because like one of one of the things like you know a lot of students uh will have when they're learning program is just it's really frustrating you know to learn at the beginning you were not taking that class and you're just kind of like it's an environment. What what was that like what was driving you back then?
I mean, I think uh I was getting uh constant rewards from adults for appearing to be clever because I was doing stuff on the computer and that was probably honestly a big part of it. Um but you know, I like I like making fun things. I liked the idea of making video games when I was a kid. Um, I still do like that idea, but it's a different a different impulse now in a lot of ways. Um, and it's it's fun, I think, once you get through the frustration. Um, then the rewards of just like when stuff clicks into place and you feel like you're, you know, in the zone, um, it just feels really good. It's a very pleasurable activity when you're when you actually all parts of it are pleasurable. Some of it is like type two fun, but then some of it is is actual fun.
Yes. And Zach, what about what about you?
Yeah. So, when I was like young young young, I um I took a like my parents sent me through a um like a workshop or course in learning logo. So I learned like logo and basic and some of those languages but I really didn't like do any programming until much later in life. And then for me the sort of first programming language was action script with from a tool called flash which I think is like and we were discussing this offline but like that for a lot of creative coders is a kind of gateway drug. um because it was a tool you could do like timeline things but you could also program key frames and so you could make like you could do things very um without any code or 100% with code so it's a great way to get started and around that time I was a student um at Parson's and I discovered a few other languages that meant so action script meant a lot to me but then a few other languages meant a lot to me one was called uh design by numbers which is really a precursor to processing um that was uh created by John Maida at the aesthetics and computation group. And that um that that programming language really spoke to me because it was very constrained. It had no color. It had like a fixed size canvas. Um the for loops were like artificially slowed down so that you could watch them. Um but it was so beautiful like within those constraints you could make things. And I I was really hungry as a young student. I was going to the bookstore and hanging out in the computer section of the bookstore and every book was terrible. learn C++ in seven days, learn JavaScript in 21 days, you know, data types in Scola or whatever. But then there was this book designed by numbers that was like all these books were like how to do something and the design by numbers was why and for me that was the first book he maid my was writing putting into words what I was feeling as a student and so that language means a lot to me and then I um really wanted to like study his work. So I learned Postcript which is a fun programming language that actually you can like write a text document and then open it in illustrator or open it in preview like you b it's basically a programming language for graphics. Um but I knew that like Maida was using that to make his posters and I was trying to recreate them to learn how he was doing what he was doing. So I learned postcript. So for me it was probably like action script and then design by numbers in postcript as the first languages that really meant a lot to me personally.
Yes. Yeah. Like I kind of we're talking about like offline is but just like Flash for me was like also my like when I really kind of got into into programming and uh but like I came from it from like animation cuz I was looking like you know it was like the the early internet days and flash animations were the only things that you could actually share that was like you know like um like you know there was no YouTube back then. So like uh if you want to watch an animation, you had to see things through Flash. And I was I need to I need to do that. I need to learn that. And I remember buying this giant Flash Bible, right? Like this huge and like half of it was action script and stuff like that, but the other h half was was animation. And that's something that I kind of really like um just like because I I learned the the first half, you know, I just selftaught. There's no I'm not gonna there's no classes and stuff kind of like to to do that that kind of stuff back in the day. And um and the action script was always in the back and I just like I kind of had to dip a little bit into it, right? Just to kind of oh like how do you actually play your animation or how does it like all load and I have to kind of use a little bit of of code and that that was kind of like the the definitely the the gateway drug to to start kind of like moving your timeline around going from one place to to another.
Uh this is this is really great because I I kind of like as you're talking to me I'm really like missing bookstores like as how like we used to just hang out there, right? And I just kind of order something online and just kind of just shows up like that that experience of being at a bookstore and just kind of exploring uh these topics.
Um they they do still exist, you know.