Today's number is 43. That's the percentage decrease in peanut allergies over the last decade. Ed, true story, I'm pretty sure I had a nut allergy. When I was a kid, my parents thought I was trying to avoid church.
Oh my god, that's pretty bad, right? Is he coming a mile away in all transparency? Brings up an interesting question. Scott, do you have any allergies?
Uh, no. I literally am, as a matter of fact, I can't... I'm so sick of waiters. I think they're legally mandated in the UK. I don't know if they are in the US, to ask you, 'Does anyone have any allergies?'
Yeah. They have to ask you, 'Do you have any allergies?' I'm like, 'Bad service?' [laughter] I've had it with the service in London. You are so spoiled in New York. The service is so good.
That's true. What are some of your horror stories?
Nothing horrible. I mean, you know, it takes somewhere in three minutes to get me my second Maker's and Ginger. Those are my horror stories. My worst days are better than most people's best days, but it's not... I go to this place called... since Children burned down, I got to go to this place called Kensington Roof Gardens, which has way too many dudes and is way too crowded.
Beautiful place, though. I was there over the summer. It's unbelievable.
Yeah, it's great for the 11 days a year you can actually go into the roof garden, but otherwise we're all crammed inside, wishing Children was still open. And [laughter] there's, I'm not exaggerating, there's 700 people lining up at the bar, 695 of them men. And you'd think... and there's like two bartenders sitting there like slicing limes very methodically and elegantly. And Jesus Christ, dude, just start like literally spraying beers at us and we'll open our mouths. That's the thing about... that's freaked me out about the members' club. You're a member of Shoreditch House now that we're paying it.
I'm not a member of that club.
You're not? I keep seeing you there.
Yeah. I get invited by members.
Well, anyways, the thing about it is that freaked me out. I'm like, it's so young here. And then I realized it's not... The reason I think it's so young is, you know what it has? Most of these clubs have guys in their 40s and women in their 20s and 30s. And what Shoreditch House has is it has a bunch of dudes in their 20s, which makes it feel like high school. [laughter]
I got to agree with you. Surely, surely, surely that's a... you're not very happy about that.
I'm fine with that. I like it. They all come up to me. 'I love your content on men. Hey, what's Ed like?' And I literally... you were student body president or the mascot or something? Everybody knows you. And it totally bums me out because I like to get a little up and talk to everyone at the bar, throw an unlit cigarette in my mouth, put on sunglasses, and just be a cliché of me. And then when people come up and say they know you, I feel as if I have to act semi-respectable. [laughter] I'm like, 'Oh, hey. Hi.' Yeah. Oh, yeah. No, I don't know what's... What do you think is going to be the next interest rate cut? [snorts] Good. [laughter] Good. They're also...
This is the trouble. You shouldn't have been a professor. You clearly... you should have been like an actor or like a pop star or something. That's what you really want.
100%. I'm just not that talented. But I agree with you.
No, I think you... Oh, you're just... you're talented in the thing. You've got a good brain.
You've got a good economic brain. And really what you want to be doing is like... you've got the Bezos thing. You want to be... you want to be like Justin Bieber or something.
Uh, you had me till the Justin Bieber part. [laughter] I would have gone for Ryan Reynolds or... Ryan Reynolds, George Clooney. He seems smart and very politically oriented.
But the thing... the thing I hate about your friends... [laughter] That's a good way to start a sentence, is they're so... they're so annoyingly earnest. [laughter] 'Professor Galloway, it's so nice to meet you. I know Ed. He's such a good person, isn't he?' [__] off. [laughter] Anyways, they're so... Anyway, it's... but it's great to meet your friends, Ed.
I've got to learn about who these friends are. I haven't been... your Princeton buddies. What is it like, a reading club or a drinking club? Like, you guys have pimps cups or something and play cricket?
Eating club. That's right.
Yeah. So, instead of fraternities, they have eating clubs.
Uh, they actually have both. Oh.
But yeah, that is what it's called. It's called an eating club. But you were in an eating club and you would get into anyone because of that faux British accent, which by the way, everyone is figuring out is total [__]. They're on to me.
You're from Nashville. [laughter] All right, enough of this. Get to the headlines.
One of our douchiest. Okay, here is our conversation with Daron Acemoglu, Nobel Prize-winning economist, New York Times bestselling author, and professor.
This is not an easy segue. This is not an easy [laughter] segue. Oh god. Nobel Prize-winning economist, New York Times bestselling author, and professor of economics at MIT. Professor Acemoglu, very good to have you on the show.
Thanks, Ed. A great week with you and Scott.
[music] So, we want to start with AI for obvious reasons. That's all we can really talk about at the moment. We've been seeing a lot of bullish sentiment in AI. We've also been seeing a lot of circular investments happening. A lot of people saying that it's a bubble. Um, last year you were asked to answer on a scale of 1 to 10 how much of an impact AI is going to have on the world. And your answer at the time was -6. So [laughter] we want to unpack this, starting with that hot take. Uh, what are your views on AI at this point? And do you still have a negative six rating on AI right now?
Let's break that into three pieces. One is, is AI a transformative technology with great capabilities? Yes. That's why it's not minus one or plus one, it's minus six. Second, how quickly will this technology reach fruition? And there I think the answer is it depends on how quickly it's pushed. So I think for a positive development path, I think we need a more deliberative approach. We are rushing into AI in a way that I think makes applications using AI less likely to develop because we are just doing it too quickly and we also don't have a roadmap of what it is that we really want from AI, while everybody recognizes that this is a technology that's going to have a tremendous number of side effects, foreseen and unforeseen consequences. So all of these things, plus very importantly for me, the focus on automation and AGI while there are better things to do with AI, I think tip the scales towards negative. So it's -6, -5, -7, take your pick, but I'm very worried about the direction of AI, where it's much more concentrated, who uses, who controls information, and what we do with it.
Yeah. Could you break down what that negative impact would actually look like? There's the aspect of the concentration of power and I'm sure that could have many implications. We're also worried about it. There is the implication of automation and the idea that this would replace labor. It would replace people's jobs. Say more about how it goes from -1 to -6 in your view. What is that destructive impact that you're so worried about?
In the production domain, if we use AI mostly for automation, I think not only would we be missing some of the really transformative uses of it, but we would create much smaller productivity gains than expected. And we would also create various social outcomes that are negative related to job loss for certain groups, lack of employment opportunities for certain groups, wage stagnation or declines like we've experienced in the 1990s. All of these are on the negative part related to the production process. But I'm also very worried about the fact that AI is first and foremost a communication technology. And as a communication technology, it changes political and social dynamics. And when it centralizes information in the hands of a few companies, it can have a variety of very negative effects on democracy, on dissent, on diversity, variation in opinion, all sorts of things that we are really not prepared for.
What would you say to someone who would say that you are being a Luddite? I mean, we've seen transformative technologies in the past, whether it be oil or the electric grid or the internet, and it seems as though when these transformative technologies come along there is a lot of concern about what it will do to our economy and how it will negatively impact our economy. But many people would say, well, eventually it works out and we shouldn't be so worried about technology. What do you say to those people?
Well, there are really two theories that people could have about long-run effects of technologies in general. The first one is that in the long run, things will work out by themselves. Let it rip, and just the dynamics of things, for example in the labor market or via democratic processes, sometimes semi-democratic processes, is that we'll just find the right way of dealing with things. The second one is that no, it's a deliberative set of choices that we have to make in order to make sure that the long-run effects are better than the short-term ones. And I think if you look at several transformative technologies, indeed they did have fairly negative short-run effects. The beginning of the British Industrial Revolution is associated, depending on how you measure it, 70, 80, 90 years of real wage declines or stagnation and huge increases in inequality. The transition out of agriculture similarly at first created quite a lot of social and economic hardship, but in both cases later adaptation worked out much better. But I would say even though decisions were made without a roadmap, there were specific decisions about how to use technology, how to change the organization of production, and also political decisions that were quite important. And so it's not an automatic process. So I definitely... I'm not an AI pessimist. And so I don't know what your definition of Luddite is, but I'm not an AI pessimist, but I do not believe that we're going to get the best out of AI or even the second best out of AI if we just say, 'Oh, let's not worry about all the disruptions. Somehow things are going to work out.'
So it feels as if a lot of the concern or discussion around AI has moved towards who can secure reliable large amounts of electrons or energy. Uh, one, is this an attempt, it sounds like, do you think this is an attempt to paint a future where the demand's going to be unlimited and a bit of a head fake, or do you see the same sort of power constraints that these guys are seeing? And what do you see as kind of the downstream impact of that?
I do not believe that power, GPU capacity, is the main limiting factor for the kind of AI that I have in mind. Because if we're going to make AI really serve our needs, I think it needs to have much more human-complementary, domain-specific expertise. It has to be able to be an aid to electricians, to accountants, to journalists, to academics. And for that, high-quality, domain-specific information data is going to be the real scarce resource. Whereas right now the energy demand is mostly from foundation models [snorts] that are very impressive in some ways but also very, very expensive to run and have not reliably reached that context-specific, domain-relevant expertise. So I think we have to find a way of getting the best out of foundation models but combine them with domain-specific models.
What I've also seen is that a lot of the different LLMs are hitting sort of a technical parity by most, by most kind of, I don't know, hardcore metrics. Do you think there's a scenario... we had Robert Armstrong from the FT on several times and he said that there's certain technologies where no one or small set of companies is able to ring-fence stakeholder and therefore shareholder value, that the airlines, PCs, vaccines were huge innovations but you didn't have a small number of companies garnering trillions of dollars in market cap. Do you think this might qualify as one of those industries where even if it ends up having a huge impact on society, that we're overestimating the ability of a small number of companies to capture a ton of shareholder value?
I would be very worried about an industry that is so concentrated. On the other hand, it's a cutthroat industry and we don't understand what sort of industrial organization of AI is going to emerge. So it is almost certain that whoever is doing the foundation model advances is not going to be the same company that also does all of the applications. So you're going to form an AI stack. So [snorts] once you form that AI stack, where are the risks going to reside and which part, which layer of the stack is going to get most of the returns? I think that remains to be seen. It's going to depend on where the real bottleneck is in terms of doing useful things and whether the foundation models are close substitutes for each other when it comes to serving as the first layer of that stack. I think those are really interesting questions and it is made more interesting by the fact that industries that look very competitive at some point later on can be very non-competitive because early competition is about being the one that controls things later on. That's why it's so vicious because everybody thinks that they're going to get the prize and the prize is dominate the industry. So I don't know whether the competition that you're seeing right now is going to repeat itself in 10 years' time or whether we're going to go to a winner-takes-all sort of structure at the foundation layer.