Well, think about it. If somebody's doing early time-restricted feeding and they finish most of their food intake before 1:00 p.m., they have an extra like 6, 7, 8 hours that they're not hardly eating anything. It doesn't surprise me that the next morning, because they've technically fasted for longer, you have a lower blood glucose. Now, I can't really back this up straight up because nobody's ever measured it, but that I think is a logical explanation while you see some of this stuff. And that's why I tell people, you know, the measurement you take really matters. I think fasting blood glucose is a useful measurement, but I put much more value on something like HOMA-IR, a euglycemic clamp, or HbA1c. So anyways, I think the early versus late time-restricted is kind of doesn't matter too much.
Great. You answered a future question right there.
You're telepathic. Uh-huh. That's what you didn't know about him. So the scenario here is whether or not meals are distributed evenly through the awake day or stacked a little bit more toward the morning or stacked a little bit more toward the evening. If somebody gets that 1 g of quality protein per pound of body weight, then they need to make up the rest of their calories with other stuff.
And we have, broadly speaking, starches, fibrous, you know, fruits and vegetables, starches, and of course, fats.
And weight gain and weight loss, I think we both would agree, or weight maintenance is going to largely be dictated at this point by whether or not you consume more calories than you burn or not. So assuming somebody's getting that 1 g of quality protein per pound of body weight, is there any data that support, or do you believe, just by your own experience, that there's some value in stacking the starchy carbohydrates toward the earlier part of the day versus the later part of the day? And this has been an ongoing debate. Like I, for example, like a nearly pure protein and fat meal for the first meal plus maybe a salad, some fibrous carbohydrates. And then as I get towards evening, I like more starches and I actually taper off the protein. I find personally that matches what I need to do with my brain. I'm more alert when I'm drinking caffeine and hydrating on a backdrop of slightly lowered carbohydrates.
But then as I get towards evening, taper off the caffeine of course for me because I want to sleep well, start ingesting some more starches. It's not starch heavy, but I sleep like a baby. But everyone would tell me and does tell me eating starches late in the day is going to make me fat. Eating starches late in the day is going to do all sorts of terrible things. I find the exact opposite for me.
So is there any real evidence that where one places their starches throughout the day matters? And let's just forget resistance training for the moment because there is this post-training window where if I train the first thing in the morning, I will eat starches at that time. But let's just remove resistance training for the moment.
So again, where rubber meets the road in practicality versus what hard line research says. So I am not real convinced at all that it really matters when you eat your carbohydrate intake.
Thank you. Thank goodness. I knew I brought you here today for a reason. No, I brought you here for many reasons, but...
My bias has been validated, I can leave now. So I really try to get people focused on the stuff that matters the most, right? So this is if we're worried about carbohydrate timing, even if there are differences, we are zoomed way in on the blade of grass, right? We're not zooming out all the way. And I think hey, if somebody likes to eat more carbohydrate in the morning and that fits their lifestyle and that is easy for them to continue to do, then I would say do that.
And could I add in terms of not focusing on a blade of grass, but something that I consider a major lever. If eating fewer carbohydrates in the afternoon and evening doesn't impede your sleep, then you're okay. But I would argue if anything is interfering with your sleep on a consistent basis, you've got a serious problem.
Yeah. So, there are no solutions, only trade-offs, right? And when it comes to carbohydrate intake, you'll hear people say the data is all over the place, okay? In terms of like timing and how people feel. Some people say, well, I feel sleepy after I have carbs. Some people have, I feel great after I have carbs. Like I'm ready to go lift. I have a big carb meal before I go lift, you know. It seems to be all over the map. Now, here's the thing what I'll tell people because people ask me how I eat. People have wanted me to do a, you know, a full day of eating video and I've kind of put it off for a while because I'm like, so much of the stuff I do, I'm not going to be able to give you guys a citation for, you know, and I know you're going to want it and some of the stuff I do because I just like doing it that way, right? Like I grew up in the era of bodybuilding magazines where they said you got to have a big carbohydrate intake and a big meal before you go train and a big meal after you train. So, guess what I did? I got in the habit of eating like that and it still sticks to this day. I don't try to tell people it's better doing it that way. Plenty of people have told me, hey, I don't feel good with a lot in my stomach when I go train or if I have a carb-heavy meal in the morning, I feel tired. The data doesn't really support that in terms of like, you know, on an average response, but if you know that you feel that way, then by all means avoid, right? Like I remember one time I... so I used to go to a massage therapist in Tampa who would do cupping and there's really no data to back up the efficacy of cupping. But she did it. I liked the way it felt and I'm like, okay, whatever. So I posted a picture of me flexing one time, you know, and there's the cup marks all over and everybody's like going crazy like, how can you do this? I'm like, hey, hey, hey, wait a second. I never said this does this and I never made any claims about it. She does it and I like the way it feels. I'm not saying it does anything. Actually, one of the things about being a scientist is like now I'm impossible to placebo, which is really annoying because I would love to be able to placebo myself a little bit more.
Because placebo effect is powerful.
Powerful, and it's one of the reasons I was telling you earlier before we started filming, I'm like, it's one of the reasons I just don't believe a lot of stuff because I know how powerful the power of belief is. I mean, you had Shawn Baker on here. Your beliefs about pain change your pain, like actually change how much pain you get. It changes your pain experience. So one of the things I've become big on recently is, hey, what happens in the mind affects the body, and what happens in the body affects the mind. So just because I don't have a randomized control trial to support something, if we know that RCTs don't say it's worse, right? Then you do whatever you like, right? And I think a lot of people get bent out of shape when I say, well, you know, when they control the variables that need to be controlled, there's no difference between intermittent fasting or just regular old calorie restriction or there's no difference between low-fat diets and high-fat diets. What people hear is low carb sucks. Intermittent fasting sucks. He said they don't work. No, no, no. This is great. This is great news for everybody. It means you have all the tools at your disposal, and you get to pick the one that fits in your lifestyle best because that is what makes the difference, is what your overall lifestyle looks like. And we have way too many people worrying about the minutiae who just don't even exercise on a consistent basis, or they don't sleep well on a consistent basis, or they don't manage their psychological stress well, or they try to be perfect with their nutrition, then they fall off the deep end. And what I'm saying is like, no, like be imperfect, but be consistent with what you do, right? And so for you, obviously carbs at night have not made you fat. Like I have eyeballs, so we can just dispel that myth right now.
I would say eating the way I eat now, I'm leaner at 49 even than I was 10 years ago or 10 years before that. I was pretty lean then, and I don't put a ton of attention to tracking calories. Although, and I want to be very, very clear, I was not paid to say this. Like I've purchased and used Layne's Carbon app. He happens to be wearing a shirt that says Carbon today, but I've talked about this before on other podcasts and social media. And it's absolutely true that there's no endorsement relationship. But I love the app because that was really the first time probably since college, because I started lifting when I was 16. Running and lifting has always been my thing since I was 16. But since college that I used a tool, in this case Carbon, to basically track what I'm eating. Like exactly what I'm eating. And what I like about it is that I can just click on different boxes of things within the app. And really, you know, it makes it very easy to say, oh, like I ate this thing, you know, white rice from this package, and it generally knows products, it knows brands. And it did a really good job of letting me check in and just see how many calories I was consuming, how much protein, how much fat, and from what sources. But one of the major takeaways that at least I got from Carbon was that you can arrange your diet any number of different ways. In fact it has like a really nice little slider where you can put in, you know, you want to eat more carbohydrates and less protein even, or you want to have a vegetarian diet, which I don't. I'm an omnivore. I'm an omnivore. My dad's Argentine. I like meat. I like meat. In fact I don't even really like fish that much or chicken. I just like eating meat and eggs. Those are like my preferred sources. And whey protein. Okay fine. But you can arrange things within the context of different types of diets. And I think there's real value to tracking precisely what one eats for even short periods of time. And then I confess I stopped using the app for it, but then I went back to it. You know, and not because things want to drift. I think some people really need that consistent checking. Other people need to perhaps just kind of eyeball it for themselves. But for me I've found that knowing exactly what I'm doing for some period of time allows me to explore things in a way that's really effective. And so I just want to, you know, give a nod to Carbon. And I don't do product endorsements on this podcast, you know, I do ad reads and that kind of thing for things I love, but I say that because I think it lands squarely in the context of what we're talking about, which is that I know what works for me. I also know that some people really love like a giant carb meal in the morning. Some people don't like meat. Some people... You know, and I think what's so beautiful about the way that you've been talking about science and nutrition in particular over the last few years and still here now is that you don't really seem to care whether or not people are vegan, vegetarian, omnivore, or even carnivore, dare I say. It's just a matter of how people are couching the advice.
And the reason I keep coming back to this is that I really think that you, this discussion, but you in particular are best poised in this whole field of public-facing health nutrition advice to really change the way that the messaging occurs and the way that people hear that messaging. And I say that with the utmost respect.
I mean, it's a lot to me. Thank you.
Because most people are not going to go read the meta-analyses.
And most people don't know how to parse data. But I think that paying attention to the words that are spoken right before the advice should be... We need to think, come up with some... That's like the Norton method. Pay attention to the words provided right before the advice.
Yeah. I think how you say it makes all the difference, right? And even, you know, take somebody I've had, you know, conflict on social media with, which is Paul Saladino, which, you know, when he would say something like, well, I cut vegetables out of my diet and I felt like my eczema got better. Okay. That's your experience. You can't go on average that's definitely not reflected in the research, you know? But hey, if you know that you did this thing and you felt better, that's fine. But how we're overgeneralizing to the population is the problem, right? And so I think, I mean, again, I'll say, hey, I calorie cycle a little bit, which again, you can do using the app, right? You can change your days and whatnot, give you more calories some days, more calories other days. And I was, I had a screenshot of it one time and somebody goes, so why do you do it like that? Like is that because it's better this way for like muscle growth and fat loss? And I go, uh no because I had a get-together with friends on Saturday and I knew I was going to have a couple beers and I knew that there was going to be some fatty foods. So I put 4,000 calories on that day and less the rest of the week. And they're like, that's it? That's your reasoning? Like yeah. Like compliance is the biggest one. I will tell people, I'm like, the reason that I, and we talked about this earlier, like I have never used performance-enhancing drugs. I've never even, even when prohormones were legal I didn't use them. I've never used them.
Not on TRT. We need to distinguish this because people nowadays like kind of put TRT, well as long as it's keeping someone's testosterone in the normal reference range which is somewhere between 300 and 1,200 nanograms per deciliter then they're like they're not... You've never injected a synthetic version of a hormone.
No. And like my testosterone even from like age 18 when the first time I had it measured up until like even a year ago, the lowest it's been I think has been like 750 and the highest it's been was like 1,050. And so I obviously don't need it, right?
You're well, you're on the upper, you're on your high normal.
So the reason that I've been able to have so much success, and I get the skepticism, I really do. So many people say, I mean look at how many people are out beating their chest saying they're drug-free and then it comes out that they weren't, right? But I have been brutally consistent for 25 years. In 25 years the longest I ever took off of resistance training was 7 days and it was after I won world championships in 2022 for M1 93 kilo. You know, so I've been able to be really consistent with my training. And I always give this comparison of I think it just really highlights how powerful consistency is. And it relates back to my favorite quote I've ever heard. The magic you're looking for is in the work you keep attempting to avoid. The work is the hack. If people, and I liked what our friend Peter Attia said this when he was talking about biohacks and why he didn't like the term biohacks. He said I don't like that it occupies so much mind space, right? You get people really focused on the minutiae, which is fine if they're already doing the big stuff. If they want to kind of level up a little bit, cool. For me, minutiae is where I live because the difference between me winning a powerlifting meet and me losing world championships is 1%, right? But for most people, we just got to get them consistent. If I said, Andrew, I want you to become the best three-point shooter you possibly can be, but you can't get any coaching and you can't even watch any tutorials, right? But all you did for 10 years was go out and shoot three-pointers for 2 hours a day. You probably won't go to the NBA, but I'd bet you'd be pretty good at three-pointers, right? And I feel like if people could just get that message and internalize it more. No, it's not that you didn't have your carb-to-fat ratio perfect. No, it's not that you ate your carbs at the wrong time. No, it's not that you didn't get exactly this much protein. It's you just stopped being consistent.
You stopped doing it. Yeah, you were really consistent Monday through Friday, and then Saturday and Sunday came and you blew out, right? Like if I'm consistent with my budget Monday through Friday, but then I blow it on the weekend, hey, guess what? That weekend money still counts and calories are the same way.
And you enjoy resistance training.
Do you do cardiovascular, defined as, because people get, I'm starting to catch flak these days when I say cardio, believe it or not, repetitive motion movement designed to elevate your heart rate for 12 minutes or more.
So I'll usually do like a 5-minute warm-up on the bike before I train, and then I will also make sure I get at least 10,000 steps on average per day. I usually average more closer to like 11,000. But I don't do a lot of purposeful cardio. Now, what I will tell you is my average heart rate in lifting sessions is about 140 to 150. So if the definition of cardio is that, then I'm getting cardio. And actually when I've had, you know, most of my markers of metabolic health assessed, I'm very metabolically healthy. I've got good... Actually it was funny. I just competed at Nationals in late May and...
Won. So I won. And actually again very cool kind of side story. We talked about the injuries I've dealt with and so I'm 42 now. It's been an eight-year journey and I mean going from I've had back pain so bad I couldn't even get off the floor. Needed a cortisone injection in my spine at one point just to be able to stand up. And multiple hip injuries and a lot of chronic pain I dealt with and I'm very proud of myself that I never gave up because in my heart of hearts I felt like I haven't hit my last PR yet. And at Nationals this past year I actually set a national deadlift record for my age and weight.