Navi Pillay, how sure can you be of your conclusions when you didn't have access to the crime scene and Israel didn't cooperate with your investigation?
Yes. No, I'm confident over our findings because it was so painstakingly and carefully done and over two years. People asked us this morning at press conferences, you know, so and so has come out with it first and so and so, and why only now? Well, we took — we knew what we were doing. We're very careful. Um, you know, I have my previous involvement in the Rwanda tribunal. So, I know what the standards are and what where where and what we should look for to establish the genocidal intent.
So I'm confident. Obviously we would have benefited from talking to victims on all sides in Israel, but we were not allowed in. Amazingly, we — the evidence came out to us from many people. So I'm happy to say we had the cooperation of victims and academics and doctors who shared information with us.
Can you explain when your findings say Israeli forces have been killing Palestinians and destroying the population in part, why that constitutes one of the tests of genocide rather than, as Israel claims, people who were just killed in the process of trying to target Hamas?
Right. So, you know, once again, you know, Krishna, I have to say there's an 80-page report, it's difficult for me to summarize that for you. We looked at the test that the ICJ uses and that is only reasonable inference that can be drawn that it's not an act looking for vengeance against Hamas or excessive excesses by the soldiers or military objectives.
So we examine all that, and then we say that, for instance, the direct killing of children — the number of children, the largest number anyway in previous conflicts — the number of women who were sexually abused, for instance, the number of journalists who were killed, the numbers in this particular case do count, and they could not have been victims of indiscriminate killings or accidental killings. So we're very careful to see whether the only reasonable inference is intentional killing. Many issues and areas we've highlighted.
But if you take the standalone and the only fertility clinic in Gaza, which had like 1,500 embryos in there, and there's no military objective in finding that standalone building, attacking it, attacking in particular, targeting the nitrogen tanks that kept the embryos alive. They smash the tanks, kill those embryos. So what military objective does that serve? And so we draw an inference from such an act.
Yes. Now Benjamin Netanyahu has said if we were doing genocide, they'd all be dead. The key point on genocide is it doesn't have to be the whole population, does it?
That's right. That's right. The words are very clear in the statute: in whole or in part, as such. So it's a group, an identifiable group on racial, ethnic, religious grounds, for instance, and whatever other motives there. You know, I've often heard this defense — I was a judge on the tribunal — as to, well, if that was the case, we would have killed them all.
So actually, all that will be tested in the ICJ when they file the documents in the South Africa case. But I could tell them now that doesn't take you anywhere. We look at the facts and who were killed, not what crimes could have been committed. Such an explanation that we didn't kill all of them, for instance, doesn't detract from the fact that you had an intention to wipe out a part of them.
Now you have very clearly found intent, genocidal intent. What is that based on?
We first begin with the facts in our case in coming to this report. It's a two-year investigation. We investigated, we verified, and we did our own investigation. We did not rely on anyone else's reports. We heard from live witnesses. We got a lot of live testimony. We held oral hearings here in Geneva and also some time ago in Jordan and other places.
We particularly benefited from the evidence given by doctors, especially doctors who came from foreign countries and volunteered to serve in these hospitals, who have no motive to exaggerate or lie. And their evidence is moving on the direct targeting of attacks on children, for instance, where the shots were on the front, on the forehead and the chest, not on the limbs.
All this is very important, and for other crimes listed under the Genocide Convention such as the withdrawal of medication, water, food, all the life's essentials. These doctors experienced and saw that, and it was very moving to hear them. We also have a great deal of video testimony, digital evidence. We cooperated with all the experts inside the United Nations. So we, for instance, had their satellite footage. We have a military expert guiding us in our own team.
So all I can say is we were as thorough as we could be. But I agree with you, the ideal would have been for us to investigate, talk to everyone in Israel. You see, this is why we were unable to pinpoint whether rape occurred on the victims of the Hamas kidnappers, and similarly the extent of sexual violence suffered by detainees. We did see footage, and it was terrible to watch, the reproductive violence on women. So all this will be made available when there's a court case.
Now what do you make of the Israeli reaction? They have often attacked you in the past, and they have again said that you are a proxy for Hamas, that the commission has a record of anti-Semitic and deeply biased comments. What is your answer to that?
My answer to that is I expect them to read the report and challenge the facts. Which facts are wrong, false, falsified? Do tell us what is it that you are disputing? So instead of addressing that issue, they indulge in name-calling. They've always done this, but one can never get used to that kind of thing.
I want, in my defense, to say I was never called anti-Semitic until I became chair of this commission. I was never called anti-Semitic in my six-year term as High Commissioner for Human Rights, in which period I was invited by the Israeli government to lead a mission into Israel, and it was very successful because, being who I am, I went to Sderot and talked with Israelis who were the victims of all that bombs and missiles being fired from Gaza into those camps. And I saw how frightened the children were by that experience.
So we went all over. I was able to see from the president down to politicians. It was a privilege to meet with the chief justice, to whom I asked, you know, I just read in the paper that one of your judgments on the wall — that the wall is encroaching on Palestinian land — is still there. The wall is still there. How do you feel when your judgment is not implemented? And that chief justice, a woman, then said they don't know when their judgments are not being carried out until it comes on appeal. I'm just saying that was the level of that visit.
Because again and again they said they invited me because I had shown a sense of balance, which I could as High Commissioner. Balance must not be misunderstood when constantly they raise, what about Hamas, what about the Hamas attack? We were the first to condemn the Hamas attacks. On October 10th, we issued a full statement where we said Hamas had committed war crimes, crimes against humanity, and must be investigated, prosecuted, and punished for what they've done.
Now, so we can't, when we're dealing with reproductive violence, for instance, keep bringing in Hamas because it's totally artificial for us to view the two sides as equal parties. They are not equal parties. You have the occupier on one side and the occupied.
One of their criticisms is that they claim that you have taken uncorroborated evidence, that you've just taken the word of one person and not checked it and put it into your report. Is that true?
It's true. We followed the test that the ICJ has, which is drawing a reasonable inference. The only reasonable inference — I am, of course, a judge from South Africa. I was a judge on the Rwanda tribunal and the International Criminal Court. These are all criminal jurisdictions. Clearly there the standard of proof is much higher. The ICC, the prosecutor will have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. So I agree this is a lower standard, and that's why we were extra careful about ensuring that we personally investigate and verify everything. You know, that's the best we could do because we were not allowed into the country.