Hola, I'm Jorge Ramos, and this is The Moment. What a moment, Paola.
It is a moment. So, we are less than a week out from the November midterm elections. We've been talking about this moment forever. We're finally here, and we're talking to you from Michigan. Michigan is one of the most important battleground states out there. We're in Holland, Michigan, which is about 20%, 25% Latino. Why are we here? Because in just a couple of minutes we're about to interview Abdul El-Sayed, who's the Democratic candidate for Senate here in Michigan, who's running against Republican candidate Mike Rogers.
So that's one of the things that we want to talk about, but also what I find really interesting is to find out, Paola, if we are in the middle of a Latino wave. We know that Donald Trump got about 45% of the Latino vote in the last election.
Even bigger here in Michigan, he won 60% of Latinos here.
Okay. So now the question is, because I've seen the polls, he has gone lower than 30%. So the question is if those Latino voters are going to make a change, a big change here in Michigan and in other parts of the country.
Just to give you guys a quick context around how competitive this race is. Yesterday, President Barack Obama was here campaigning with Abdul El-Sayed. Today, in just a couple of hours, you're going to see Donald Trump campaigning here. Everyone is trying to win this seat. You're hearing Donald Trump calling Abdul all sorts of things, casting him as a jihadist, casting him as someone that has ties with the Muslim Brotherhood. This is them trying to otherize him. And so we're trying to have a conversation with Abdul. We also contacted Mike Rogers,
but they don't want to. Well, we don't know exactly if they want to talk to us, but they haven't answered yet. So the invitation is completely open. But these are the questions that Latinos have for a candidate who I think hasn't campaigned enough with Latino voters.
So our conversation with Abdul El-Sayed when we come back.
Welcome to The Moment. This is going to be broadcast both in English and in Spanish. Gracias.
Gracias.
All right. So, as you can see, hundreds of Latinos and immigrants are here to see you for the first time. And many don't know that you spent some time in Peru as a medical student, and then in Guatemala and also in Kendall, Florida.
That's right. So I was kind of surprised that... español.
Uh, I'm not even going to try. [laughter]
Because I was surprised that you haven't used some words in Spanish for the campaign, as other politicians. I call it the Christopher Columbus syndrome, that they rediscover us.
It can be cringe sometimes. So maybe that's...
So you know, we did record one video in Spanish because, you know, the pronunciation in Spanish is remarkably close to pronunciation in Arabic.
So I remember being a medical student, because that's where I went to medical school, in Washington Heights in New York, and that's also a Dominican/Puerto Rican community. And so I'd be the only brown doctor to walk into a room full of doctors. And I wasn't a doctor at the time, I was a med student, but, you know, wearing a coat with the other doctors. So the patients would start talking to me, and this always became a problem because, of course, I just don't speak Spanish well enough. So I learned to say, 'No...'
[laughter] And they'd look at me for a second and be like, 'Sí, sí,' and then keep going in Spanish. Like, no. No. [laughter]
All right. Okay, that's clear. So we'll continue to do it in English. So one of the things that we keep hearing, as one young man put it, is that Latinos are too often overlooked by the candidate. Abdul, did you wait too long to talk directly to the Latino voters?
So I'll tell you this. We built our campaign on a very different framework. I think one of the problems and the frustrations that a lot of folks have with Democrats is we talk about a big tent, but the way we organize the party is by pushing everybody into one corner of the tent and then everybody makes a round robin to the corner of the tent. And the problem is that in every corner there's this pandering that happens. And the only reason I know is because I've been in the corner of a tent where I'll have perfectly well-meaning politicians. They'll come and they'll talk to you, and, you know, it'll be like Ramadan when we fast, and they'll say, 'We fasted in solidarity with you.'
And my response is like, look, thank you for coming and thank you for your solidarity, but I don't need your solidarity when there's perfectly good food here. Like, we're not not eating because we don't have food. We're not eating because we've made a choice. If you're hungry, go eat. But do not show me solidarity when it's perfectly nice and we have food. Show me solidarity when there's actual lives on the line.
So the way that we've built our campaign is that we go everywhere, talk to everyone, and we say the same thing. Rather than having people on every corner of the tent, we want to talk in the middle of the tent about the things everybody has in common. It doesn't matter where your family immigrated from. It doesn't matter if your family are immigrants. It doesn't matter if you're black, brown, or white. It doesn't matter how you pray. You need a good job.
But clearly, you need the Latino vote.
We do. I mean, if you're going to win, you need the Latino vote.
But the way we win the Latino vote is by saying the same thing to the Latino community that we say to everybody. I didn't back down from ICE on day one because I think ICE is a foundationally tyrannical organization that should not exist. But I don't just say it to the Latino community and then hide from it everywhere else.
I say it everywhere. You need a good job. You need a living wage. You need healthcare. You need clean air and clean water. And yes, I don't think ICE should exist. And I don't care what you look like, how you pray, where your family comes from. Those things are true for you no matter who you are. They might affect you more, but they're true for you no matter who you are.
I think Republicans have also understood this, right? I think you have, as we speak, Donald Trump is here campaigning...
There you go. And I think one of the things that Trump did in 2024 is that, perhaps pandering, but he understood that he needed Latino voters to win. I think it's worth remembering that in 2024, Trump comes here, he talks to many Latino voters, and he wins almost 60% of the Latino vote, which is pretty huge compared to the national average, which was around 48%.
And so I guess my question to you is, I think you need some of those Latino Trump supporters to win.
Speaking of that coalition, what's [clears throat] your message to them?
So you look at what Donald Trump does and has done. He posed himself as being credibly outside of politics as usual.
And he posed himself as being a protector of traditional family values.
And he posed himself by trying to separate folks on the idea of immigration status. He said, 'Look, you know, those of you who came here, quote unquote, the right way, I'm on your side relative to these people who, quote unquote, came here the wrong way.'
The problem was that he was against anybody who didn't look like him, and his policies have made that clear. And what happens is he's been able to play communities off of each other. He did the same thing in the Arab and Muslim community, by the way. Play communities off of each other to distance people from each other. Because here's the thing about it. If you are an American citizen, or you have your full documentation and you're not yet a citizen, or you're undocumented, ICE doesn't differentiate between you two.
ICE is going to pick you up, detain you, and ask questions later if they even get around to asking questions. And so he's been able to break folks against each other and to pose himself as being different from the rest of politics. So what's my message? My message is it shouldn't matter. You should not have an ICE that is tyrannizing anybody anywhere, detaining and then asking questions, because we have a rule of law in this country and a constitution that protects you. Also, his point about, well, the economy's been so terrible, I'm going to fix it. How has that played out? A tariff war against Canada, a war in Iran that is raising the price of your gas and your groceries. Does the economy feel more attainable for you than it did two years ago? And then there's finally the question of family values. And here's the thing about it.
One of the games that they play is to tell you that politics is about culture. Politics is not about culture. I believe that we need to stand up for a politics that does not discriminate, no matter who you are or how you are. And then people can choose what their best life is. But I think a lot of communities have learned a very difficult lesson from the Trump years, which is that if you allow the government to discriminate against anybody, it's only a matter of time until it starts discriminating against you.
And so we've got to be able to show up in coalition to protect everybody's rights, even if they may be rights you may never use, because the rights that you're protecting might actually end up being your own.
So let me ask you about your community, in our community. You have been seriously criticized by President Trump. He called you a jihadist many times, as well as Vice President JD Vance, who said, and I'm quoting, that you should shut your mouth and show a little gratitude to this country. So they have tried to portray you as the different, as the other, and there are a lot of Pedros, Maras, Josés, Silvias, Lucases in this room right here who felt the same way, the same kind of rejection, the same kind of discrimination. So are there any parallels between what you've experienced in the Arab American community and the Latino community?
You know, here's this game that they play. They set up this trope of the ideal immigrant or the ideal child of immigrants, and then they get to decide who is that person. And here's the game: nobody ever fits.
You're never quite ideal enough. You're never quite good enough unless you're politically siding with them. That's the only way. So if you disagree at all, they're going to come for you because of your identity, not because of your disagreement. And they're going to weaponize your identity against you. And they're going to try and weaponize that identity against you in your own community to say, 'Well, the rest of you have to decide: are you with them or the other?' And they're going to make up all kinds of associations, all kinds of differences to try to make you an other who should be rejected. And I think the thing that we all have to remember is, again, the minute that you assent to them dividing your community, the minute that you say that it's okay that there's a certain litmus test for whether or not you're one of the good ones or one of the bad ones, the minute that you assent to that is the minute that they divide the whole community and nobody quite makes it.
Because they've been trying to portray you as un-American.
I was born and raised in Michigan.
I was going to ask on a personal note, like, what does it mean to grow up as Abdul in Michigan?
Born and raised in Michigan. I was the captain of my high school football team, wrestling team, lacrosse team. I graduated valedictorian of my class from the University of Michigan. If I'm not American enough, I don't know who's American enough.
But has Abdul been discriminated?
But here's the thing about it, right?
So I know what it's like to be an Abdul in Michigan. And here's what I'll tell you. Like, this is what I've always seen. When your name is Abdul in Michigan, there's always a small number of people who want to use your name or your faith to try to divide you from other people.
It's a small number of people. They're just very loud.
But the vast majority of people use whatever difference as an invitation for a conversation. People are curious. They want to learn. And I've gotten to travel my state now for the last 18 months. Been invited into living rooms and town halls and VFW halls and basements and churches and synagogues. I've been invited everywhere. And the vast majority of people could care less how you pray. They really want to know what you pray for. They're not as interested in the differences in your name. They want to know if you care to know their name. And the vast majority are good people who believe in a big America that's big enough for all of us. It's those small-minded people who want to make America small like them. So sure, have they been weaponizing my name and my faith against me? Of course. But the thing that always bothers me is two things. Number one, I'm not trying to defend myself. Like, I've had a good life. I know my cousins whose lives look very different than mine. I've had a really good life. My job is to defend people who are sitting on the wrong side of their policies, who are paying too much for gas and groceries, who can't see a doctor. But the other part of it is when they say, 'Oh, well, we think we can attack your name and faith to get people to vote against you,' it's not really a comment on me. It's a comment on Michigan. And Michiganders are open-minded and they're big-hearted and they're earnest and they're gritty. And it's insulting to watch them be assumed to be anything that's not those things. And so I get mad on behalf of our state. I'm like, 'Wow, you really think that low of the people in this state who have been so open-minded and so big-hearted?' And I know that in nine days, Michigan is going to reject that small-minded aspect, those small few, and is going to embrace just how big our state really is. And that's the kindness, that's the care I've seen. So, yeah. Are there a few small people who want to make America small like them? Sure. But I'm taking a bet on the big America who believe in that big-minded, open-hearted version of our country.
And you've said that many times, right? That you believe that people are innately good.
I think the problem also is that if you are an ICE agent, right, you're an immigration officer, your eye has been trained to see us, to see Arab Americans, Latino Americans as innately threatening people. You know, the immigrant is always correlated with a terrorist. This has been happening since DHS was created. And so let's talk about immigration. You've already said within five minutes that you want to abolish ICE. In fact, you've been saying that since 2018, so it's not new. You've been incredibly clear about this agenda, but I think a lot of people in the room, I think, want to understand exactly what that means. I think some people resonate with that: let's abolish ICE. And I think others are kind of allergic to that term. So break it down for us. What does that mean?
Yeah. So let's differentiate. Let's just ask ourselves, like, what should an immigration system do?
Right. I believe that we have to have a safe and secure border. That's not ICE. That's Customs and Border Protection.
I think that we need to make sure that we are solidifying our border. We know who comes in and who goes, and that that is done in a principled, human rights-oriented way. But that is clear that we have and maintain control of that border. That's one part of it. Then there's internal immigration enforcement. That's what ICE has been doing for the last 25 years. But ICE is new on the scene. Before ICE, we had INS, Immigration and Naturalization Services, and they were able to enforce immigration law without also violating the whole Constitution to do it. And that's been the problem with ICE. ICE is in effect an agency that has flipped the Constitution and immigration law. They take immigration law as the law of the land and they will enforce immigration law even to the detriment of the Constitution itself. In this country, the law of the land is the Constitution, and every other law gets enforced within the bounds of the Constitution. Now, here's the problem with ICE. The moment you create a culture and hire people and tell them that they are allowed to run roughshod over the Constitution and that that's going to be allowable, that's going to be defended, at that point you can't unring that bell. And so I think we need to go back to an era much more like INS, where yes, we enforce immigration law, but we don't do that in a way that violates the Constitution itself, where you detain first and ask questions later. I want you to think about this. What is the difference between an arrest and kidnapping? When you're under arrest, you are told you're under arrest. You know exactly who's arresting you. You are told why you're under arrest, and you are told how to challenge the circumstances of your arrest. Kidnapping is just somebody coming and picking you up off the street. Ask yourself whether or not ICE detention is more like arrest or kidnapping. And the difference between those two things is the rule of law. That's why we have arrest and not government kidnapping. And my family comes from a place where there was government kidnapping. I don't want to live in a place where there's government kidnapping, where you have no actual rights to challenge the circumstances of your arrest. ICE has done that. And I'll just tell you this: I don't think that ICE is actually about immigration, not under this administration. ICE is about normalizing paramilitary force on our streets. To understand ICE, you have to also understand January 6th. So if you can normalize ICE with the presupposition of immigration enforcement, you can normalize somebody, anybody acting outside of the bounds of the Constitution. When you do that, it opens up the opportunity to do a lot of other things if, in fact, you don't want to operate within the bounds of the rule of law, which of course this administration's already shown itself not to want to do. There's a third part, though, which is the process of immigration. So I would like to abolish ICE, replace it with something like the INS, and then I think we need to be invested in the court infrastructure, in the legal infrastructure, to create a clear pathway to citizenship for folks who have been left in legal limbo. Because one of the worst things that's happened is this: you give people status, and then you rip away their status, and then you pretend that they never have status at all. That's what's happened. And that is a failure to recognize that when this country makes a commitment to somebody and gives them status, people uproot their whole lives to come here. And that's a good thing. We want people to want to be here. But when you shake that and you don't create a clear pathway for people to citizenship, it undercuts the very foundation of immigration. And I'll finish here.
Which is exactly their goal. They want to do two things with this. Number one, they don't like the idea of immigration at all. They've been clear about it. Immigration has been a net good for this country. Immigrants have been a net good for this country. You go to any farm today and you ask them, 'How is it going finding labor?' They'll tell you, 'I can't find any.'
Immigration has been a net good. And I think it's important for us to recognize that we have to tackle the infrastructure on which they're trying to weaponize government against immigration itself, and they are weaponizing government against the rule of law itself. And I think we have to abolish ICE for that first.
So let me ask you, Latinos are — I mean, I understand what you're saying, but Latinos are really tired of empty promises by Democrats. You know that, I know that President Barack Obama campaigned for [clears throat] you yesterday, but he deported three million people and he has been called by many as 'Deporter-in-Chief.'
So if you win — I understand what you're saying, but if you win, what can you realistically do for the Dreamers? Or what can you do for the 11 million, not 25 million as President Trump says, but for the 11 million, maybe 14 million undocumented immigrants? What can you do for the 200,000 children that have been separated from their parents by ICE? What can you realistically do?
So, number one, let's just start with children separated from their parents. That is wrong.
200,000. That is wrong, and we need to make every effort to right that wrong. When it comes to deportations, we need a very clear pathway, a coherent approach to immigration. We have not had that. I'm going to be one United States senator.
But folks in Michigan have been watching this campaign for some time.
The thing that you get with me is I say the same thing to everyone everywhere. I don't shy away from my positions, and I believe in the work of persuasion. You know, you go up north and you'll be talking in a room that does not look like this one, and you talk to people who live in farming communities, and you tell them that the current immigration system is not working and is not even working for them, they nod their heads.
The problem, though, is that too often people in my party, what we pay attention to are consultants who run these polls who say, 'Oh, this is popular, this is unpopular. If it's unpopular, you shouldn't talk about it.' I don't think the job of a politician is just to say what's popular. I think the job is to make popular what is right. And I think the courage to show up in places where something is unpopular and make the argument about why it should be popular is the thing that I can offer. And as one United States senator, what I'll tell you is this: my job is not just to go and have a conversation with 99 other senators. It's to have a conversation with the public such that the public is talking to those 99 other senators and saying, you know, 'That guy's making some sense.'