Democrats and Democrat Abdul El-Sayed. Shouldn't be this hard to afford a tank of gas. Shouldn't be this hard to pay your rent or your mortgage. Zeroing in on the key issues that matter most to you.
It's so messed up. I don't even know what to say. Too high right now in the grocery store. Gas. Common sense would be nice. AIC more regulations. A critical seat in a battleground state. Over 60% of Michiganders think the state is going in the wrong direction. When they come for our democracy, we vote back down. Tonight, you get to decide which candidate will get your vote.
Good evening from the nation's capital. I'm your host Leland Vitter from NewsNation. It's debate night and the stakes are high, not only for Michigan, but for the country as the balance of power in the Senate takes center stage. Our moderator for tonight's debate is News 8 anchor and veteran political analyst Rick Albin. The debate will air around the state, stream online, and across the country on NewsNation.
Before we get to the questions, let's review the rules. You will each have 60 seconds to answer a question and follow-ups get 30 seconds. A digital clock will turn red to alert candidates they have 10 seconds till time is up. Each candidate will also have 30 seconds for a closing statement. Now live from your local election headquarters and the Wood TV studios in Grand Rapids. This is the final night of debate week in Michigan.
Thank you, Leland, and welcome to NewsNation viewers across the country and voters all across Michigan. Thank you for being here. We're going to start with the subject that will impact every single person watching. Dr. El-Sayed, we'll begin with you. Would you support pausing the federal gas tax? And what else would you advocate doing to lower fuel prices? You have 60 seconds, sir.
First, Rick, thank you so much for having me. Look, I'm a doctor and I'm a dad. And as a dad, I know how much it costs me to fill up my gas tank. It is insane. $80. $80 to fill up your gas tank. And yes, I would support pausing the federal gas tax. But there is one thing that is actually causing this. It's the war in Iran. A war that has been cheerleaded by my opponent since the beginning. Called it a win-win-win. I don't know about you, but when I go to the gas tank, I don't feel like I'm winning. I don't feel like our country is winning. Seven months on, eight months on. How long is this going to last? We can do so much better. But here's the problem. If we don't stop this war, we don't stop it now, we're going to continue to watch as the Iranian regime chokeholds the Strait of Hormuz, making our energy prices higher, and you're going to pay for it, both at the gas tank and at the grocery store. And so, we've got to end that war above and beyond pausing the gas tax. We also have to hold the oil and gas corporations who are using this moment to profiteer, who have bought off my opponent, accountable for what they're doing to raise our prices.
Congressman, the same question to you. Would you support pausing that gas tax? And what else would you do to lower fuel prices?
Yeah, I've been pretty aggressive about saying we need a pause both on the state level and the federal level. Remember when that 50 cents a gallon, which will help commuters, went through the Democrat-controlled state senate? They said no. Republicans tried to give drivers a break. I think that's really important. The other thing we did in talking with farmers is we need some diesel help and some diesel, agricultural diesel help for us. So I've called for a diesel rebate, number one, and a pause on exports of diesel to give a temporary break. We can resume that once the war comes to an end. I do believe it's going to come to an end. We need it to come to an end. But I will say just a couple of things about my opponent here. His policies will raise the cost of every gallon of gasoline. Number one, raise your utility rates, cost you $20,000 for a Medicare for All plan that takes away private insurance from individuals. It is a disaster. We cannot afford Abdul.
Dr. El-Sayed, I want to do a follow-up with you now. The United States is producing oil and gas at near record pace, but the products are traded on the international market and of course that's what sets the price. Should the federal government implement price controls on domestically produced production? You have 30 seconds.
Look, I definitely think that's something we should consider. Look, we are in an emergency. When you're paying $5 gas and $8 diesel, that's an emergency. And I think we have a responsibility right now to make sure we do everything we can to address it. But you just heard something out of my opponent. He said he thinks the war is going to end. He's got a direct line to the president who's making sure the war does not end and he's not using it because he's cheerleaded this war the entire time. And this is not a 'when it ends.' We need to end it. That's what you're electing a US senator to do, to stand up to Donald Trump and end the stupid war.
Congressman, follow up for you for 30 seconds. Would you be in favor of doing some type of price controls if these prices stay this high? You have 30 seconds.
No, I think you could do it through the mechanism of which I just described. And the doctor, well, he's not really a doctor. He says he's a physician. As a matter of fact, if somebody came into his office and he tried to treat that patient, he'd go to jail. So, listen to this guy and what he's trying to sell here today. You're going to find out that this guy is not what he says he is. He is actually selling the best con I think I've ever seen. This is the first round of that. And I can't wait to talk more about that.
You were mentioned in that comment. You have 30 seconds to respond.
You know, my opponent here is going to make this about him and about me, but really in the end, this is about you. It's about whether or not you can afford your gas, you can afford your groceries, whether or not you can see a doctor. Look, I have a medical degree from Columbia University. He questions my credentials. He could take it up with them. But it's not really about me. It's about whether or not you can see your doctor. It's about whether or not you trust your next US senator to stand up to Trump. And when you're running because Donald Trump called you and asked you to run, you can tell he's not going to stand up to anybody.
30 seconds to respond, then we'll move on.
Well, first of all, I'm running because in the last quarter century, we've lost 200,000 manufacturing jobs in Michigan. In the last eight years, we have the highest utility rates in the Midwest, highest auto insurance rates in the country. Now you have to be 40 years old, or the average new homeowner is 40 years old. Our education is now 45th in the country. That's why I'm running. My opponent, everything he's talking about, and he won't talk about how to pay for it or what he does to make sure that he's taking money out of your pocket because he can't.
You did that, man. That was your policy. NAFTA, your policy.
We'll come back to this. We'll move on right now. I want to talk about the trade battle between the United States and Canada. What it means for Michigan jobs and Michigan prices. Congressman Rogers, a week ago you said this at a news conference near Saginaw.
Anytime you have that series and list of tariffs, I argue some are going to be really good for Michigan, some are probably not going to be good for Michigan. So what I've said and committed to is going back, working with the president to try to get rid of the ones that we can, there's consensus aren't helping.
But just yesterday you released a new ad that said, quote, 'Here in Michigan, we know Canada is not our enemy. We need to end this tariff war now.' So in the course of a week it seems that you've changed your tone on tariffs. Are you saying that we need to eliminate all tariffs for Canada? You have 60 seconds.
I would like to see the deal made. I have actually called the White House this week, talked to the Secretary of Commerce about getting the deal done. Canada still has some high tariffs for US goods and they did it before this started. Those should be eliminated. There are tariffs that I think are too high and not helpful for us. We ought to get rid of those. So, this is about getting the best deal possible. I'd like to see it end. I think we need to end it. And I, as a matter of fact, have made those phone calls this week to make sure that we can get those things taken care of. Now again, remember my opponent here wants to raise the cost of everything you touch. He's for an energy carbon credit that would make everything you touch, your groceries getting more expensive, your car more expensive, your light and electric bill more expensive. The fact that he's going to take away your private health insurance, turn it over to the government, and it would cost each family about $20,000 a year in new taxes. This is the problem we've got to face.
Dr. El-Sayed, on your website, you say, quote, 'I support targeted smart tariffs that would help protect Michigan manufacturing and incubate the industries of the future with unions at the forefront.' With that said, what is a Canadian tariff that you might keep? You have 60 seconds.
One that's actually logical, unlike anything Donald Trump has ever actually done in office. Look, you're hearing somebody who has cheerleaded again a Canadian tariff policy that we are paying $5,600 a year for. If we were serious about using tariffs, we would do it in the way that the UAW has advocated. The UAW has advocated for smart tariffs where we actually hook it to an industrial policy that makes sense. We're invested in high growth, high manufacturing capacities and then we use tariffs to protect our own market. This is like everything hamfisted, chaotic, self-serving that Donald Trump does. And the issue that is making Mike move, right? You talked about his flip-flop. The reason he's flip-flopping has nothing to do with policy. Has nothing to do with your costs. Has everything to do with his sagging poll numbers. He doesn't like the fact that this is not a pathway to power for him anymore. So all of a sudden he's reversed course. He's doing an ad drinking Labatt's and talking about the Red Wings, pretending like he was not for this the entire time. Be serious, my guy. Like, just be serious. People deserve to know that they have a leader who's going to be serious about policy.
We're going to move on to healthcare unless you have a response.
Well, listen, here's what he's talking about. A few weeks ago, he said, 'I will go back and fight every one of the tariffs that have been put in place.' Detroit Diesel added a third shift because of those tariffs. The Chevy Silverado came back to Michigan, huge billion-dollar investment because of those tariffs. We saved Traverse City cherries because of those tariffs. He wants to undo it because he can't see past his own political rhetoric. We didn't change. What we said is things move. We're trying to get it wrapped up. We want a deal on those tariff deals.
Dr. El-Sayed, 30 seconds. We have to move on.
Weak, cowardly, won't stand up until his poll numbers drop. This is what you can expect from a guy who's taken $5 million from corporations to run his previous campaigns. Voted to raise your prescription drug prices or to keep them high 19 times. He has the audacity to do an ad looking at the drug prices in Canada. Except for he voted four times to keep you from buying the prescription drugs in Canada. It's incoherent. The only thing he cares about is his power and going back one more time through the revolving door to make what, $14 million you made.
You know, listen, I can't let that stand. I mean, let me just tell you this. I won't let this stand from a guy who is taking corporate PAC money. He snuck in the back. He snuck in the back door to Chuck Schumer. That money is raining down on him. Oh, by the way, corporate executives, Pfizer Pharmaceutical, Google...
Gentlemen, we have to keep this to 15 seconds. We're moving on to healthcare.
Two yachts, made $14 million. Do you guys know what Telefonica is? It's a corporation he advised that was helping Maduro spy on his own people. How much money you make off them? Can you tell us how much money you made?
Okay. Is this like the deal that you cut with the county where you took taxpayers' money to run for the United States? The next woman who replaced him got paid $100,000 less.
We're going to move to healthcare.
I do want to talk about healthcare. I know he doesn't, but let's get on.
We're going to talk about healthcare. And guys, I'm going to tell you right now, we've got to stick to our time limits. We've got a lot to cover. I appreciate your passion, but please let's try to keep this orderly. We're now moving to healthcare. Democratic state representative Karen Whitsett said she is supporting Republican Mike Rogers in this race because of your Medicare for All position. Dr. El-Sayed, her husband has employer-provided health insurance.
You will lose your health insurance if the other candidate gets in office. There's no ifs, ands, or buts about it. That is what Medicare for All means.
Dr. El-Sayed, you have said additional private coverage would become redundant. In your plan, could families keep their private health care? Yes or no, you have 60 seconds.
Yes. Absolutely. Rick, if families want to keep their private health insurance, that's fine by me. But for too many people, if you lose a job, excuse me, if you lose your job, if you turn 26, you get married, get divorced, turn 65, all ways that you can lose your healthcare in America. That is exactly what this guy has signed on to. He voted against the ACA for God's sake. I want to guarantee every single person in this country cradle to grave coverage without premiums, co-pays, deductibles, that doesn't have a network, that does not pay a corporate CEO tens of millions of dollars a year, that allows you to have the security of knowing you're not going to be one of the millions of people in this country who fall into medical debt to the tune of $225 billion. Contrast that with him. He wants you to have to pay $50 to see a doctor. He wants to continue to be big pharma's champion. He called himself big pharma's champion. Took more money from the pharmaceutical industry than any member of Congress, more than any member of Congress in the Michigan delegation. This is a guy who wants to do service for the corporations. Of course, he's going to stand up for them.
Congressman Rogers, staying with healthcare, Flint physician and past president of the American Medical Association, Dr. Bobby Mukkamala criticized the federal healthcare legislation enacted last year that you said would protect Medicaid. The cuts to federal health care programs, including Medicaid and CHIP, will shift costs to the states and specifically to physicians and hospitals to provide uncompensated care at a time when rural hospitals and physician practices are struggling to keep their doors open. The doctor says the changes will instead make health care less accessible. What specifically in that law lead you to say that Medicaid was protected? You have 60 seconds.
$50 billion to rural hospitals was a good start for that. But let me just talk about this. So when I was in Congress, I actually pushed the acceleration of generic drugs. Trust me, the pharmaceutical company's not happy about it. There are 2 million Michigan families today who are on Medicare enjoying Part D prescription drugs, which I did champion because there was no prescription drug coverage under Medicare, which I thought was a terrible idea. But what my friend here just wants to do is he's kind of like a glitchy AI chatbot, is say the same thing over and over and over again. But let me tell you this. He has taken money from groups associated with and support the Muslim Brotherhood. He has taken money from individuals on his campaign who openly support Hamas, Hezbollah, al-Qaeda. He's taken money from the George Soros family. What we found out is that this thing goes way back. Apparently, they paid for his education in Columbia. Now they're paying for his campaign. By the way, that's a billionaire, last I checked.
Time. I'm going to give you a 30-second rebuttal.
What degree did I get? As a doctor, I understand exactly what's happening. He says, 'I like to say the same thing.' Not a physician. He says, 'I like to say the same thing.' He's done the same thing over and over and over again. You know what that is? Vote to keep your prescription drug prices high 19 times. A million dollars alone from big pharma. Another million dollars from the health insurance corporations. Of course, he is touting their talking points. This is a guy who has not been serious about providing people health care his entire career. What he has been serious about is making sure that he can monetize his time in public office. $14 million, two yachts, a McMansion in Florida. So, at the end of the day, I'm a doctor. I want people to have healthcare.
All right. We're going to move on after this. 30 seconds.
How does a guy who's had less than four years of work experience, who by the way on the campaign trail said he had 10, own a luxury property in the United Arab Emirates? He's worth a million bucks. Somebody has to tell me how this math works. His facts are wrong. Those are lies. But he is consistently not telling the truth. Well, let me just say it. He's lying. So, he lied about being a physician. He lied now about being an Egyptian citizen or not being an Egyptian citizen. I can't figure out what he is saying. Can I? This impact he's talking about? He's trying to tell you where he wants you to be. That's a con man.
Congressman, we've got to stay on time.
I just want to respond to this.
You can respond directly.
He wanted to make this about him or me. But the question is about you. Can you afford your gas? Can you afford your groceries? Under this guy who's going to rubber stamp everything Donald Trump tells him to rubber stamp, you're going to continue to pay way more out the nose because he works for corporations and Donald Trump.
Okay, look. Here's the situation. We've got dozens of questions we want to get to. You can't litigate all of these with 14 different rebuttals. So, please work with me. I want you to say what you want to say. Do it within the body of an answer and we'll try to move along. Let's talk about another subject. This time it's a viewer question and here's my colleague Amber Crisco with that. ICE has been a source of controversy since President Trump's second term began. This question is from Deb Mel.
My question for both candidates with regard to ICE and ICE agents: what is your plan for holding them accountable or holding them to the same standards as other law enforcement officials? And if the plan is to abolish ICE, what is your plan for keeping our borders and citizens safe? Congressman Rogers, you've been supportive of President Trump's immigration enforcement strategy. Name one instance or one circumstance in which you believe the administration went too far. You have 60 seconds.
You know, I think the public efforts in Minnesota were probably not appropriate. I actually did fugitive raids when I was an FBI agent in Chicago. You always want to go in quiet, get the bad guy, get out of the neighborhood for less problem. So that to me was something that they could have done differently. They made that correction. They made that adjustment. But it has been the largest decrease in murders ever recorded. Almost 20% across the nation. Why? They were targeting murderers and rapists who were here illegally doing bad things. As a matter of fact, just in this town, we had Ruby Garcia who was killed by an illegal immigrant who if he had not been here, we'd still have Ruby alive today. So if you think about what we need to do to make sure that neighborhoods and Americans are safe, that's exactly what we need to do. And I would apply the same law enforcement standards to the FBI as I do the ICE agents. I think they do fine. Doesn't mean every one of them is perfect.
Dr. El-Sayed, you've made your position clear. You want to abolish ICE. Let me give you a scenario. If an undocumented immigrant in Michigan commits a violent crime, serves a sentence, and has a deportation order, under your system, would he be deported? You have 60 seconds.
Yes. But you don't have to do that by violating the whole Constitution in the way that ICE has been enabled to do by this rogue administration. ICE right now is not about immigration enforcement. ICE is about terrorizing our streets. He talked about what happened in Minneapolis. I went there. He said it was probably not right. I mean, definitely not right. They killed two people. You can keep a safe and secure southern border. I believe we have to keep a safe and secure southern border, which is crazy to me because my opponent, he voted against border funding when he was in Congress and now he likes to talk about being a tough guy on a border. Those are not the same thing as what ICE is doing. I think we can go back to an era like INS when we enforced immigration policy at the edge of the Constitution and we respected the Constitution in doing it. But I also think we need a pathway to citizenship for folks who are stuck in limbo right now. You've got this tough guy attitude to immigration that's not keeping us safe. In fact, it's terrorizing folks in our streets. It's not funding the southern border which needs to be kept safe. But what it is doing, it's weaponizing an agency of the government at the tune of Donald Trump and his goals.
All right, Congressman, in the interest of a short rebuttal of 15 seconds, he talked about one of your votes when you were in Congress.
You know, this is really fascinating to me. He has called for open borders, decriminalizing crossing the border, giving illegals identification, and allowing them on Medicare. You can't get a worse plan than what you hear from Abdul. Go to stopabdul.com. Every one of his deleted tweets and videos are there. Very educational.
That's awesome. Good for you. Look, at the end of the day, I think we have to have a safe and secure southern border. That's why I wouldn't vote against border funding like him. But we also have to obey our Constitution. We are a country of laws and a country of immigrants and I think we need a pathway to legal immigration for folks.
Thank you both. I want to turn now to the war in Iran. You have both indicated you want it to come to an end and we talked about this a few minutes ago, but what does that look like? Dr. El-Sayed, can the war in Iran come to an end if the Strait of Hormuz isn't fully open and if Iran has the ability to produce a nuclear weapon? You have 60 seconds.
I might be old-fashioned, but I believe in diplomacy. In fact, diplomacy is what the Obama administration had used to negotiate a scenario in Iran where we did not have proliferation of nuclear material. We were at a steady state except for Donald Trump just doesn't like anything that President Obama has done. So, he decided to rip it up in his first term and then his second term decided to make war that was completely unnecessary. So, I do think that we can end the war and we can actually by peaceful means diplomatically address this challenge. But look, this is what happens when you start wars you never should be fighting. We literally taught the Iranian regime that they had a choke on the Strait of Hormuz. And now we're living in that reality. But that's what happens when you've got a ridiculous leader like Donald Trump who does not know what he's doing and jumped into this war for God knows what reason. And the whole time my opponent backed it. 'Win, win, win.' Are you winning? Are we winning? Is anyone actually winning? That's the kind of policy you're going to get from a guy who wants to be a sock puppet for the Trump administration. No thinking, no thought. Whatever Donald Trump says, jump. He says, 'How high?'
I'm going to give you 10 seconds. And once again, the question, can there be an end to the war if the straits is not open and if Iran has the ability to produce a nuclear weapon? 10 seconds with a yes or no, please.
Yes. And we do that at the edge of diplomacy rather than war. That's raising our gas prices and our grocery rates.
Congressman Rogers, same question to you. Both of you have said you'd like to see this war come to an end. But if the straits aren't open and if Iran has the ability to possess a nuclear weapon, can you have an end to the war? 60 seconds.
Well, this is why I've called for an end of the war. Militarily, they have set back the nuclear program at least 20 years. They've decimated their army, navy, their air force. They still have some limited capability to inflict harm on their neighbors. So this would be the time to wrap it up. That was the stated intent. But this is, I think, the issue that is maybe the most important. My opponent here would not condemn the IRGC which today is hanging two 19-year-old kids for saying that they want freedom in their homeland. This is the same IRGC that has killed American troops in Iraq. It has blood on their hands, tried a terrorist attack here in the United States. If you can't condemn the IRGC, you have no business in the United States Senate. And if you think about why, his supporters funnel money from a group that supports the Muslim Brotherhood, this is a huge problem and that is an ideological problem that we cannot allow to walk into the United States.
Quickly in 10 seconds, can the war be ended if straits are not open and if Iran can produce a nuclear weapon?
Well, no, it can't if they have a nuclear weapon, but all of the information is they do not have that capability any longer. So, I mean, you're asking a question of a hypothetical. The information that is available says that they have been set back 20 years.
So, I just want to say he's been cheerleading this war for the better part of 20 years. And I will condemn any use of force against a domestic population abroad. That's not hard to do. But I also condemn a war we shouldn't be fighting because here we are fighting this stupid war because people like him have been pushing for it for 20 years. When you've got an international problem, he's got a war for that. That's his approach. Every single situation, Iraq, Iran, and what other wars is he going to cheerlead? That is dangerous. We cannot have that. And I tell you what, this is important.
He can't condemn a terrorist act that happened on our soil in the state of Michigan. He can't bring himself to condemn.
I didn't condemn it? No, you did not. You absolutely did not. Make stuff up.
Talking about making stuff up. He can't condemn Hamas. He can't condemn the Muslim Brotherhood. He says his home is Egypt. This is all starting.
We are going to continue. We can continue this conversation in the second half.
He doesn't want a home in Florida. I just, he took it off the market. I don't know why, but he did take it off as a home in the United Arab Emirates.
We're done. Staying in the Middle East. Congressman Rogers, in the United States...
I'd like to be part of the debate, too. So, let's do this. We'll stay in the Middle East. Congressman Rogers, you have pledged unconditional support for Israel's right to defend herself. Is there any action by the Israeli government that would cause you not to support sending US military assistance? You have 60 seconds.
Pretty hypothetical question. I support just staunchly their right to exist, the right to exist for the Jewish state and the right to defend itself in a very difficult neighborhood. And if you think about why my opponent is so wrong on all of this, his biggest funders are from a group that supports the Muslim Brotherhood. He gets money from people who openly support Hamas, Hezbollah, al-Qaeda. His family was even included in those discussions. Listen, this is the most important thing that we do when we go back to Washington is keep America safe. I wore the uniform of the United States of America. I was a special agent with the FBI to keep America safe. These are the most important issues. The prattling and repetition of his argument does not solve the dismantling of terrorist networks that America demands.
You've got 10 seconds. Is there anything Israel could do that would lose your support?
Listen, if they're talking about using nuclear weapons, they would definitely lose my support. I've never heard them say that, though.
Dr. El-Sayed, you have opposed direct U.S. military funding to Israel. But if Israel were attacked tomorrow by Iran or another state actor, would you vote to provide defensive weapons necessary to protect the Israeli people? Yes or no? And you have 60 seconds to explain.
I've been absolutely clear. I want our tax dollars spent here to provide schools here. And by here, I mean Michigan, Florida. I want to make sure we've got good schools here and health care here. I want to make sure that we are taking care of people here. That is my priority. You know, you asked the hypothetical question about being attacked by Iran, but let's be honest about what happened here. Israel has pushed us to go to war in Iran. And of course, my colleague who thinks there's a war for everything went right along with it. And here we are. Israel had clear war aims. They wanted us to go to war with them, and their war aims were what? The annexation of southern Lebanon. Ask yourself, are we safer because of that war? He wants unconditional support for a foreign government. I want unconditional support for kids in our schools, unconditional support for our health care, child care, things that he would vote to defund. So, it's just inconsistent to me to be running for Senate from Michigan when you're more focused on what's happening to a foreign government than you are focused on what's happening to folks right here in Michigan. It's just not serious.
If there was an attack, would you provide defensive weapons for Israel?
I don't want our tax dollars buying weapons for other countries. I don't know what's so hard about that.