This is Mishmash, a weekly conversation where we try to unjumble an important and sometimes under the radar statewide story that affects you. I'm Zach Gorchow.
And I'm Alethia Kasben. Zach, it's time to check in on, you guessed it, Michigan's US Senate race between Democrat Abdul El-Sayed and Republican Mike Rogers. It's been almost a month since El-Sayed won the Democratic nomination, and it took about one-tenth of a second for the general election intensity to go from zero to 100 million.
It has been a blur in the past month of the two political parties uncoiling everything out of their opposition research files on the other candidate. I think it's fair to say, though, that so far Republicans have been the aggressors. They have been pounding El-Sayed on seemingly everything he's ever said or done, and in some cases, things he hasn't actually said or done, but one of his allies said, or something he was assigned to fix. Meanwhile, Democrats are recycling a greatest hits of attacks on Rogers from the 2024 campaign that he lost. Things like ties to big pharma, his longtime residency in Florida, his support for surveillance programs, and more. El-Sayed, our guest on Mishmash this week, for his part, has been reintroducing himself to a broader set of voters. The ads he has run so far are similar versions of what we saw in the primary. He has also been hitting Rogers on his ties to President Donald Trump, who has endorsed Rogers during his last two campaigns. The president is unpopular in Michigan right now, but Rogers really hasn't tried to distance himself from Trump. We've asked the Rogers campaign to come on Mishmash multiple times, but have either been told he's unavailable or not gotten a response to our requests. We continue to try to have Rogers on Mishmash to discuss his campaign, and if that happens, we will bring that interview to you in a future episode. A big difference for the two candidates in the past month is that El-Sayed has been spending time trying to heal wounds from the intense primary he won and build bridges to groups that backed Haley Stevens, the person he beat in the Democratic primary. Rogers, who was unopposed for the Republican nomination, has not had to deal with internal party fissures. For El-Sayed, there's one voting block in particular he has been working to make amends with. Right, Alethia?
Right. We saw El-Sayed speak directly to the Michigan Democratic Party's Jewish Caucus at last week's convention on Saturday and then at a private caucus event on Sunday. During both events, he apologized for comments he made after the attack on Temple Israel earlier this year. El-Sayed condemned the attack but also said hurt people hurt people when noting the attacker has family members who were killed during an Israeli air strike in Lebanon. El-Sayed said he wasn't trying to justify an act of domestic terrorism. Certainly, the apology will not bring over every Jewish Democrat with concerns about El-Sayed, but many have said it was a positive step. Others, like Attorney General Dana Nessel, who is Jewish, have implied Jewish Democrats may have to put the interests of others above even their own self-interest, describing Republicans as a threat to the climate and democracy. Some Jewish voters who historically have largely voted for Democrats are refusing to vote for El-Sayed because he has not definitively stated he supports the existence of Israel as a Jewish national homeland. And Rogers is trying to capitalize on these fractures where he can. His campaign rolled out a Democrats for Rogers group, although it is led by a Detroit lawmaker who left the Democratic party months ago and hasn't voted consistently with her party in years. He also has support from some Jewish voters. You mentioned, Zach, some with a strong history of being Democrats and supporting Democratic candidates and others with a more mixed political background.
So, on the one hand, the past month has been pretty good for Rogers. He's on the offense. El-Sayed seems to have to answer an attack every day, and the attacks on Rogers feel a little stale because they're recycled from two years ago. Additionally, a lot of outside spending already has rolled in from Republican groups backing Rogers, about $14 million, much of it attacking El-Sayed. Meanwhile, outside Democratic money just began this week and is about one-fifth of the Republican spending so far. But on the other hand, the overall political environment only seems to be getting better for Democrats and worse for Republicans. Trump's unpopularity seems to be only growing, and national Republican operatives seem in a panic that the Republican base is going into hibernation. It seems apparent that the Republican hope in Michigan is to use El-Sayed to wake up their base, but they may be tilting at windmills.
In the weeks since the primary, we have also entered the biennial tradition of debates over debates. If you haven't participated before, consider yourself lucky. It involves one candidate proposing many debates, another candidate proposing fewer or different debates, and statements sent back and forth arguing about who is more legitimate because of their willingness to debate. El-Sayed has called for five debates this week. Rogers accepted a debate with Channel 7 in Detroit on October 21st, spurning a debate with Fox 2 Detroit on September 15th. Rogers criticized the moderator on Fox 2 despite his credentials. He moderated a Republican gubernatorial primary earlier this year as well as a US Senate Democratic debate. Both candidates have agreed to debate on Wood TV in Grand Rapids on October 8th. Notably, absentee ballots will go out in September, so many votes will be cast before the first debate and a ton of votes by the second.
This race continues to capture the attention of the nation. Not a day seems to go by without a slew of national commentators offering hot takes or more national news coverage. This race is so important to both control of the US Senate and the future of politics in this country, the stakes could not be higher. We're going to take a short break. When we return, we are going to talk with the Democratic nominee, Abdul El-Sayed, about the campaign. Stick around.
Welcome back to Mishmash. We are joined now by the Democratic nominee for the United States Senate, Abdul El-Sayed. Abdul, thanks so much for taking the time to come on Mishmash today.
Honored to be here. Thanks for having me.
So Abdul, you recently apologized to the Michigan Democratic Party Jewish Caucus for comments you made following the attack on Temple Israel earlier this year. So a large segment of Jewish voters have some key disagreements with you and other Democrats when it comes to Israel. So this was seemingly an important outreach step for you and your campaign. How do you feel your comments were received?
Well, it's not about how I feel they were received. It's about how folks feel like they were received. And at the end of the day, I don't want anybody to ever misconstrue my comments as thinking that I don't care about their pain or their feelings. And you know, I heard from a number of folks as I sat down to learn more about how to bring folks together that they felt like those comments were putting an unnecessary asterisk, dangerous asterisk on their pain. And I wanted folks to understand that was not my intent. And my commitment to Jewish safety is the same as the commitment that I have to the safety of my own children and every community in this state. But right now, we have about two months to focus on what it takes to take on somebody who has platformed people like Nick Fuentes. What it takes to address the fact that we can't afford our groceries. We can't afford a tank of gas. We're worried about a war we shouldn't be fighting. Whether it's a real war in Iran or a trade war with Canada that's raising our prices for just about everything. You look at this bond market and it's gone belly up. So, we have a responsibility, I think, to come together to take on Mike Rogers, a rubber stamp for Donald Trump, and to remember what it is that we fight for as Democrats.
Abdul, you've been asked many times whether you support a two-state solution regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and you generally say you support equal rights to self-determination for Jewish Israelis and Palestinians. Can you tell us, like, what does that mean? Does that mean...
Zach, with all due respect, this has been hashed and rehashed. This is the Mishmash podcast. I'm focused on what's happening for the 10 million people in this state. It's so frustrating to me that people want to make this race about something that's happening 6,000 miles away when we've got kids who can't afford a next meal here at home. So, you know, I'd love to focus on the issues relevant to Michiganders who listen to this podcast. If we want to talk about Israel, we can. I'm not going to change my position on that. I've been absolutely clear I want our money spent here instead of sending it in the form of bombs and tanks over there. I just find it so interesting that I never get asked about this question on the stump. But it seems to me that every time I sit down with anybody in the press, it seems that that's the most important question. I always wonder why it is that set of questions instead of questions relevant to the folks who are actually making votes on whether or not they can afford their gas and groceries. And so we can pick apart issues relevant to 6,000 miles away in foreign policy or we can focus on issues here at home. But I'd love to have a conversation about Michiganders right now who cannot afford their gas or their groceries. That's what I'm focused on. That's what I've been focused on in a campaign to get money out of politics, put money in your pocket, pass Medicare for all.
Sure. I mean, I'd argue that you have talked about this issue a lot in your campaign. But we do want to talk about...
It tends to be the first question everybody likes to ask me. I wonder why. I mean, does it have something to do with my name? Maybe, you know, how I pray. It just, it's fascinating to me that I'm running to represent 10 million people who live here and you want to ask me about people living somewhere else. And I just think I want to be talking about people living here because people living here are struggling. People living here can't afford their gas. People living here send their kids to schools that look like they did 50 years ago. People living here can't breathe clean air or drink clean water. All as a function of a set of policies driven by the president and his handpicked sock puppet Mike Rogers. So, I'd love to talk about those issues. If you really want to talk about the Middle East, I'm happy to do it once again, but I think the record is really quite clear about where I stand. So, if you want to hash it again, we can go ahead, but I'm not really going to change my perspective on that. But I do want to tell you that it has to do with the fact that we're asking Michiganders to subsidize bombs and tanks for people in other countries rather than to invest in schools and healthcare here in our own, which I think that anybody who is voting on a Michigan Senate candidate really wants to make sure that Michiganders have the right to our tax dollars over anybody else.
So on that front, your mantra has been money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for all. So we want to look at these one at a time. What does your Medicare for all plan look like? So, you've said, you know, people can keep their current insurance if they like that. How would that work in your version of this plan and how would the country pay for it?
So, right now, the way you get health insurance if you're over 65 is you have Medicare or some privatized version of Medicare like Medicare Advantage. If you are below a certain income level, you're on Medicaid. Although the president and his people are trying to make that even harder to have, but for everybody else, you're paying largely private health insurance corporations who nickel and dime you to get the healthcare you thought you already paid for. What I want is a guaranteed health insurance program for every single person from cradle to grave. That does not expire until you expire, hopefully at 120 years old after a long healthy life peacefully in your sleep. It would be there without co-pays, premiums, or deductibles. Meaning, you don't have to pay for it every month or two months with your paycheck. You don't have to worry about having to pay extra money on top of what you already paid for. You don't worry about having to lose money every single time you see a doctor. It covers vision, dental, hearing, all of the health care you need, plus your prescription drugs. And it is guaranteed for you whether you are 26, get a job, lose a job, get married, get divorced, turn 65, it's there for you. That's what Medicare for all would mean. Now, if you want to have an additional private insurance on top of that, that's fine, but you don't need to have it. And I think it's that guarantee of public insurance that makes Medicare for all so incredible. Now, I'll just tell you this. Right now about 25 to 35% of all of our health care insurance costs go to the overhead of paying an inflated C-suite or paying for a marketing budget for health insurance or paying an army of billers that allow your hospital or clinic to cross talk with the insurance company. That goes away under Medicare for all. So, we end up paying a lot less and we pay for it in the same way that we would pay for health insurance. Now, rather than having to pay FICA, which is the federal government, and then pay your health insurer for the insurance that you have to pay for again if you get sick, in this case, you're just paying FICA a little bit more for insurance that's not going to go away for you if you lose your job or if something happens in your marital status. And so, I think there's a far better deal. I think Michiganders by and large agree, which is why Medicare for all is so popular right now even among independents and Republicans.