Well, Dr. El-Sayed, I know you don't like to talk about the Hasan relationship, and every time you're asked about it, you say it's not about that, it's about these other things. But apparently, it is about this, too, right? It can be about more than one thing. Two things can be true. People care about everything you spoke of, but they also care about this. In fact, our first text question — we've gotten many of them asking this — can you completely 100% disavow offensive comments made by Hasan?
Absolutely. Look, I take comments on their own terms. And when Hasan made these comments about Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders, I disavowed them entirely. But I do want to ask us a question. What is democracy for? Democracy is about addressing our differences peacefully. That's what it's supposed to be for. And too often the way that our politics happen is that we're told who we cannot talk to. The reason I talk to Hasan isn't because of Hasan. It's because of the 3 million people who pay attention to what he has to say. And I think it's important to be able to offer those folks a pathway back into our politics. I believe in a politics where we actually show up and talk to each other even if we disagree. It's the same reason that I went on Fox News, not a place famously who agrees with a lot of the things I believe in. I went on Jesse Watters of all places, had a 25-minute conversation about our differences. But that's what democracy is supposed to be about. So, I've made a commitment this campaign to go everywhere and talk to everyone. And I resist the idea that we should play this cancel culture gotcha game that tells us who we can't talk to when democracy is about trying to build a coalition because you've went out and talked to as many people as possible. Doesn't mean you agree with everything that the person you're talking to says. But it does mean that you believe in the process of democracy that starts with talking. Again, that's why I'm here, because I think it's important for us to have the conversation and to answer the questions directly.
But Dr. El-Sayed, and to kind of directly ask the next question to you, you say that it's about building coalitions. It is, but there are some coalitions that people don't want to be a part of if you too closely associate with those who make remarks that could be considered dubious. And I'll give you an example. We know that Louis Farrakhan was a big supporter of Jesse Jackson in 1984. Jesse Jackson, the late Jackson said, 'Move out.' Laura Loomer and Donald Trump, Ted Nugent and Mitt Romney, and then Donald Trump. And they had to not just disavow but move away from these divisive characters. And you know, of course, former President Obama and Jeremiah Wright had to — he had to make a very clear message. Would you — do you wish you could be a little more clear? Would you be a little more clear about trying to tell people that you don't agree and rubber stamp like you say Rogers does Trump, Hasan?
Well, I'll tell you this. You raised Mike Rogers and Donald Trump. Donald Trump is the president of the United States. Donald Trump's policies are the reason why you're paying so much more for gas. Donald Trump's policies are the reason why you can't afford your groceries. Donald Trump's policies are the ones that are ignoring the war in Iran he got us into so that he can focus more on the drapes in a ballroom that we shouldn't even be building. Let me just finish the point. To equate a streamer in California with the actual president of the United States seems to me to be a bit of a false equivalency. But let me just answer your question directly. I will take every statement on its own terms. There are many, many things that he has said that I disagree with, that I have disavowed. Whether it was his ridiculous comments about 9/11 or his more recent comments about Jewish Americans, I just think it's important for us to stop playing this game wherein you take a whole individual and pretend like they are the worst thing they've ever said. I remember back in 2020 where we talked about how caustic that cancel culture was. In fact, it was Republicans themselves, the very same people who want to make this race about a streamer in California, who said exactly that. But we have to believe in our democratic process. We have to believe that we can talk about individual things that people have said on their own terms. Now, look, I understand that you're asking me the hard questions, but I also think it's important to realize that the individual who I'm running against did not have the respect to come here and to show you the respect enough of taking your hard questions. He didn't have the respect enough for the people in the city of Detroit and across Michigan who are watching right now to take their hard questions. So, here's the thing you're going to get with me. I'll answer the hard questions. I will take every statement on its own terms and tell you what I think because I have the courage enough to actually show up and have the conversation that is supposed to be the substrate of our democracy. The other guy, he wants to do his campaigning in 30-second ads that make this campaign about anything and everything that is not what it is for you. Can you afford your gas? Can you afford your groceries? Can you see a doctor when you get sick? Does your kid's school look like it did 30 years ago or has it had the funding it needs to be able to thrive and give your kid a good education?
And Dr. El-Sayed, I want to mention because it's the elephant in the room that of course Mike Rogers put out a release earlier today.
The elephant's not in the room.
The elephant you're speaking of. The elephant I'm speaking of, of course, the topic of why he didn't come. He cited the moderator, me, because this format is different. And I will say when you and Hill Harper stood here, we got in there and we're going to continue to get in there. We're getting in there now. To allow people to speak for three or four minutes and then go to the next topic is not what a modern-day debate should look like. We know that at Fox 2 and we're challenging that convention and so we do of course regret that he's not here as well. We do have questions, as another Fox 2 way of doing things, to get questions from our audience. And our first audience member, Chip. You have a question here on this Fox 2 Senate debate to Dr. Abdul El-Sayed. Go ahead.
Good evening and thank you for showing up. Again, my name is Chip Clark. Up to this point, what would you assess as the biggest issue facing Black men in Detroit? And what comprehensive policies are you supporting that show us as Black men that we are a respected demographic of voters in this upcoming election? Thank you.
Mr. Clark, I really appreciate that question and thank you for asking it. I think it is the lack of opportunity because of disinvestment in predominantly Black communities for a very long time. That disinvestment is the reason that I came back to the city of Detroit to rebuild Detroit's health department, to put glasses on kids' faces so they could see the blackboard and understand what was happening on the blackboard, to take on medical debt, to take on lead in schools. But right now, you're actually seeing it in multiple different ways. It shows up in the way that we have not invested in affordable housing in communities. It shows up in the way that we do economic development, which too often means subsidies for the kind of big corporations that fund campaigns from people like Mike Rogers rather than investment in revolving loans to empower would-be entrepreneurs to start businesses and be able to build those businesses out, build generational wealth in their own communities. It shows up in the fact that our schools are deeply underfunded. It's amazing that Detroit Public Schools was able to make an investment of $700 million, but they're still $1.7 billion behind when it comes to keeping up with where they ought to be. And right now, we fund school infrastructure based on an outdated model which is built on property taxes. Property tax is a function of property value. Property value is a function of racial residential redlining from the past that we port into the future. And that robs young children, future young Black men, from the opportunity of a great education that they deserve. It shows up in health care. Medicaid too often is the required health care option for folks with low income. And Medicaid reimburses at about half the rate. And that's because of gutting from people like Mike Rogers and Donald Trump. So all of it works together in this morass which serves to take away opportunity from Black men. We need to be investing in these communities, investing in affordable housing, investing in public schools, investing in health care, investing in revolving loan funds in ways that empower folks to be able to unlock the incredible potential that sits in our communities. And so I really, really appreciate the question and I hope that we get to work together to build those things so that six years from now we look back and say we did something to take on the challenges that we face.
Chip, thank you so much for your question. I do want to ask you about some of the Democrats, many of whom are in Detroit right now, who have some doubts about voting for you. As you know, there's a big push, and you can define big any which way you want, but there is certainly a pretty visible push for Democrats for Rogers. And as you see that movement happen, you're seeing it on the front lawns of neighborhoods in Detroit. And yes, there are campaign stops, but there are real conversations happening with Detroiters that we've heard from who say they're going to go for Rogers. How do you win back or try to win voters in the city of Detroit?
Well, we had a really contentious primary and at the end of a contentious primary, sometimes people leave with hurt feelings. They might have voted for my opponent, but I got to give it to Congresswoman Stevens. She endorsed me immediately because she understands that whatever our differences, our shared goals are so much bigger than that. If you believe in public education, if you believe in clean air and clean water, if you believe that corporations should not have their way in DC, if you believe that we should offer more people better health care rather than less, if you believe that prescription drugs should be affordable, if you believe that we should not be fighting wars we have no business fighting, then those are things you and I agree on and I hope I can earn your support. Now look, the thing that doesn't get paid attention to because we have a lot more confidence in our campaign than that is the number of Republicans who tell me they're voting for me. They say, 'You know what? You really are America first. You don't want to send my tax dollars abroad to fund the worst things. We could keep that here at home.' They tell me, 'You really want me to have health care? I really want you to have health care.' They tell me, 'We're sick and tired of watching corporate-bought politicians bought and sold to do the bidding of those corporations when they get to office.' So, we're building a very strong and very robust community of independents and Republicans who are voting for this campaign. But at the end of the day, I want to speak more broadly about what this campaign is about. Folks want to make this campaign about all different kinds of things that are a distraction. The question ultimately is, can you afford your life? Can you afford the things you have to buy every week, every month, every year? And if not, ask yourself why not. It's because folks like Mike Rogers have corrupted themselves at the edge of corporate contributions. $5 million he took throughout his campaigns for Congress. That's not even talking about his campaigns for US Senate. And then he retired to Florida, bought a McMansion and two yachts, made $14 million as an adviser for the very same corporations he had spent his time in Congress regulating. Now, what kind of regulation do you think he actually offered knowing that there was going to be a payday at the back end? If you think that's how our politics ought to run, and if you think you're not the one paying for it, then go ahead and vote for Mike Rogers. But if you want politics of the people, by the people, and for the people, I've never taken a dime from those corporations, and I never will. And I am really serious about trying to take on the affordability crisis that you face.
I want to hit you with two questions that we think are really important that people are curious about as well. You talk about health care for all, Medicare for all. You know, that notion is attractive when you talk about all those people who need it, but what about the people who have private health insurance right now who worry about how they're going to have to pay for this now in their taxes? We say put money back in the pockets as one of your slogans, but how do you do that when you're having to raise taxes to pay for Medicare?
Medicare for all is not about what it takes away. It's about what it offers. Even if you're privately insured right now, let me just talk to the middle voter here. The median income in Michigan is $72,000 a year. The median deductible, which is the money you have to pay to get the health insurance you thought you already paid for every single paycheck, it comes right off at the top. That's $4,500. So, if you're doing the math, you're losing a whole paycheck to get the health care you thought you paid for every single paycheck. That's if you're privately insured. I want you to imagine what would happen if you had another card next to your private insurance card as a Medicare card. You got it the day you were born. It does not expire until you expire, God willing, at 120 years of life, peacefully in your sleep. It's zero co-pays, zero deductible, zero premium. It doesn't have a network, so they don't tell you what doctor you can see or can't see. And you don't have to worry about what happens if you lose your job, turn 26, get married, get divorced. That's the security Medicare for all could offer. I think all of us who've ever had to use our insurance understand just how insecure it really is. Just how much you have to be thinking about the finances just because you got sick. It shouldn't be the case in the richest, most powerful country in the world. We can do this. We can't do this though if the corporations keep buying and selling politicians. Mike Rogers took a million dollars from big pharma. He's taken so much money from the insurance industry, taken money from big hospitals. And so, yes, he's bought off his insurance plan. I haven't actually seen it. He wants you to pay 50 bucks every time you have to get a checkup at the doctor. So his plan is, I guess, co-pays for all. Mine is health care secure for everyone.
But Dr. El-Sayed, is this aspirational? Because if you really think about it, and I want to ask you the question again, you haven't been through those halls when it comes to these bills, how this all works. You need support from other senators for that to happen, right? So far in the Democratic party, you don't even have people who believe in Medicare for all. How do you get things done and also put money back in people's pockets when the taxes are being raised in order to pay for Medicare for all?
Well, we pay 19 cents on the dollar for every dollar spent in our whole economy on health care right now. We are both the largest and fastest growing health care system in the world by cost. And we get what for it? The insecurity, the pain, the frustration of having to fight with some unnamed bureaucrat in some insurance corporation because they're trying to nickel and dime you for the health care you already paid for. That's what we get out of this. So, I take really seriously, as we've talked about already, that politics is about persuasion. It's not just about the conversation you have with 99 other senators. It's the conversation we have together for the 350 million people who elected all of the senators. And right now, that conversation is being obfuscated by the amount of money being spent on behalf of the corporations to tell us what we cannot have and should not fight for. So, I want to be having a conversation with the broader public about what we really want. Yes, we really can guarantee health care in this country. Yes, we really can do it while spending a lot less and getting a lot more if our health care doesn't still fund tens of millions of dollars in health care CEO salaries on top of it.
You believe you can convince other Democrats who are more moderate, centrist Democrats and Republicans to get the job done?
I believe we can have a conversation as a society about why those voters should have a conversation with their elected officials. And yes, I'm really looking forward to continuing this conversation with my colleagues. I'll tell you this. I will support any health care legislation that increases health care coverage via public means and does not empower health care corporations. But I also am not going to make the mistake of saying that nibbling around the edges is the best we can do. If you think that at the end of the day health care should be about the profits of big corporations, I'm not your guy. If you believe like me that health care should be about whether or not you can see a doctor, more about healing than billing, then I think I might be. And I'll also tell you this, right now in the United States Senate, there is not a Democratic doctor at all. Never been a public health official in its history. As you think about the challenges we face, maybe it'd be a good idea to hire somebody who actually understands this industry leading on behalf of the broader public who has not taken money from the corporations who benefit off the system.
But when you raise those taxes, do you end up even kind of at that point when it looks like how much you have to pay and how much you — I mean, have you done the math and how much can you guarantee that?
I wrote, as you know, I wrote a whole book on this and folks are welcome to check it out, but let me just talk to you a little bit about the exchange right now. If you look at your W-2 paycheck, okay, you get paid every two weeks or four weeks. First payment that goes off the top is FICA, Federal Insurance Contributions Act. That's Uncle Sam. And then after FICA is your health insurance, your private health insurance. They eat before your family eats. And we pay so much more than they do in other countries for health care that isn't there for you when you need it. Think about a deductible. Think about a co-pay. All the money that comes out of your pocket. It's why we have $225 billion of medical debt. We are being nickeled and dimed by corporations who exist specifically to hold our health care dollars and pay out as little as possible. We can do so much better than that. And so the amount of money that you end up paying for health care under Medicare for all is substantially lower. And I also believe that we should be taxing billionaires their wealth. Why? Because I care more that we provide things like child care and health care and good schools and good roads than allowing a billionaire make their second billion. I don't think that's a crazy idea. And I think it's incumbent on us to be asking as a society, how is it that we invest in the things we actually need? And right now people need health care.
We got to take a break. Dr. El-Sayed, we're back on the other side of the break talking about courting Jewish voters and also talking about Israel. You're watching our special edition of The Pulse, the US Senate debate next here on Fox 2.
Back now on this special edition of The Pulse, the United States Senate debate. A reminder, we're taking your questions via text. We're already above a thousand questions that have come in. Our team is sifting through them right now. Just scan the QR code on your screen or text us at 248-200-5004 to ask your question. We're going to continue our conversation with Dr. Abdul El-Sayed. We have a podium here. We told Mike Rogers and his team they were welcome to come here up until when the debate started. Frankly, they're welcome now as well, but obviously he has declined that invitation. Want to continue our conversation with the doctor talking specifically now about Israel. You know, this has been obviously a topic that's very important to the whole country, to the whole world, and as US senator, certainly you'd have a big voice in those hallowed chambers to talk about it. What are your thoughts on a two-state solution for Israel?
I believe in equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. For a very long time, we've been told that our country was for a two-state solution. Even as our taxpayer dollars to the tune of billions of dollars a year were being sent unconditionally to aid, arm, and abet a government trying to foreclose on the possibility of the second state, and we've seen this unstable equilibrium, the violence that it's created. We saw the attack on October 7th. We saw the genocide that followed thereafter. I believe deeply that every child in the Holy Land, Palestinian or Jewish, deserves to grow up without worrying about whether or not their life is going to be upended by war or apartheid or genocide or terrorism. So I think as a country we need to be serious about our responsibilities. And let's step back for a second. Those billions of dollars that they send abroad to drop bombs on other people's kids, those billions of dollars ought to be spent to make Detroit public schools whole, to build our roads and bridges, to provide us health care. The same people who talk about America first are perfectly fine sending our taxpayer dollars to foreign governments. And it's not just Israel that I believe we should not be funding unconditionally. It's Egypt where my family immigrated from. It's Pakistan. It's Saudi Arabia. They should not be getting unconditional military aid. And I just think I pay my taxes, you pay your taxes to provide health care, to make sure our schools are good, to invest in roads and bridges. We don't do it so a foreign government gets a bomb or a tank. I don't think that's a particularly crazy idea, particularly when you think about what's been done with our money. And that's not about being opposed to anybody when it comes to the well-being, the safety of the Jewish community here in Michigan. I believe in that safety the same way I believe in the safety of my own daughters. But it's about believing in everybody's safety and the recognition that putting more money into militaries out in the world increases the probability that people lose their safety rather than having that safety protected. Whether it's a child in Detroit going to an underfunded public school or it's a child in Gaza worried about bombs.
Let's talk about Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state. Your thoughts on that? It's an important topic and one that a lot of people ask about. Of course, we know that the Arab League, they have a formal diplomatic non-recognition of Israel as its own Jewish state. Do you believe that America should continue its recognition of Israel as a Jewish state?
You know, I'd love to hear what Mike has to say about this. I'd love to ask why he went to four AIPAC fundraisers in a single day after asking AIPAC not to support his campaign. I'd love to understand what his perspective is, but let me share mine. I believe in equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. I think it's really important for us to ask right now whether or not we think our responsibility is to impose a plan on other people or to enable a free Palestinian people and a free Jewish Israeli people to come together to decide how they are going to engage on this question. People ask this question about the right of the state that actually exists to exist. But I never get asked about the right of the state that does not exist to exist. I don't get asked about whether or not the state that exists has a right to use our tax dollars to do heinous things. I don't get asked about whether or not the kids in Detroit have a right to their tax dollars. So, I just think the premise of the question is built around trying to ask people to agree to the current status quo that we have seen become a deeply unstable, deeply violent equilibrium. And I'm a lot more interested in thinking about the future state where you have equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinian and Jewish Israeli people alike. And I just want to say this. It's really important to me that we understand that this is more about process than it is about outcome. If free Palestinian people and free Jewish Israeli people come together and decide that they want two states for two people, I'm for it. If they decide they want one state for two people, I'm for that. If they decide that they want 23 states, as has been talked about, or land for all, I'm for that. But I'm not for, as a senator from Michigan, sending my tax dollars abroad to drop bombs on other people when they could be used here to do the right things here. And I'm not for telling other people how to solve their problems and I'm not for making those problems a lot worse as our unconditional foreign military aid has done right now.
Want to get to one of our text questions right now. This is actually from a Libertarian US Senate candidate who texted us and she's asking, 'What are'
Your plans to tackle prison overcrowding and homelessness, two issues that plague our community right here at home."
Well, I appreciate the Libertarian candidate has now participated more than the Republican candidate has in this debate. Now, look, I think it's really important for us to be thoughtful about how we solve these big society-wide problems. And on the one hand, I think it's important to recognize that when it comes to housing, housing is a housing problem. We have to build more housing. I actually think that the housing bill that just recently passed into law is a really great first step. I think there's a lot more we need to do around protecting the rights of renters through a renter bill of rights. And I think there's more we need to do about making sure that big tech that has enabled people with excess money to buy housing in our communities have to pay their fair share to building the housing we need. We do that and we actually have the opportunity to start solving our housing crisis.
When it comes to prison overcrowding, I think it's really important for us to realize that the answer that we've had right now around private prisons has been extremely dangerous for everybody. I don't believe that you should be able to make money in this country as a contractor selling prison outcomes. I believe that we need to use that resource and it has to be fully public, and when we use that resource we have to recognize that it has to be a public resource. I believe that it's really important to answer public safety problems with the things that we need. That sometimes is going to be a person with a gun. And if that is, it's going to be somebody ideally from the local community because we've invested in the kind of recruitment, retention, and retirement we need. But we also need to be investing in things like community violence intervention, things like behavioral health response when somebody is having a mental health crisis, things that the Trump administration has defunded. And so I am for public safety. Everybody deserves to get home safely at night. But the challenge right now is that the Trump administration is leaving us less safe by taking away the kinds of things that actually can help to keep folks safe in the first place.
Before we get to our audience question, I want to ask you a question about President Trump. When it comes to working with him, how do you plan on working with somebody who is of a personality, a political party that you just don't line with? Would you be able to sit in the room with President Trump and have an honest conversation without trading barbs and try to work towards a common goal?
Look, I'll work with anybody to get a job done. I don't have to like him. I don't have to agree with them on most things. But if there's a place where we can agree and we can get things done, I will be right there to try and get things done. My job is to get things done for folks in the state. But here's what I'm not going to do. I'm not going to sell short my own values. I'm not going to be a sock puppet for Donald Trump. That's exactly what Mike Rogers would do. I'd love to hear why he's underwriting this tariff war that's forcing us to pay $5,619 a year in this state. I'd love to hear what his commentary is about this war in Iran that we can't get out of that we're paying for both through our taxes and at the pump. But he's not here because he doesn't want to answer those questions because he doesn't even want to be asked them because he understands that he's between a rock and a hard place. We all know that Donald Trump's tariff war is a vanity war. We all know that this Iran war was a ridiculous idea we never should have fought and he doesn't want to have to answer for that. So he's letting his 30-second ads paid for by the corporations who've owned him forever do the talking.
Do you think that it was a good idea for Governor Whitmer, not once, not twice, but three times to go to the White House, work with someone she's politically and diametrically opposed to to get the work done?
Well, look, you know, she had her reasons for going and I understand in public service that you don't really second guess the choices that somebody makes. She had clear goals and when it came to her goals, she was able to achieve them. Like I said, he is the president of the United States and if there's an opportunity to serve our state, I will talk to him and engage with him. And so, you know, it's not my place to judge Governor Whitmer and the choices she's made because I know that she was serving in good faith to try and secure key resources for Michiganders, but it is my job to remind folks that we have clear policy goals. If he wants to work with me on my policy goals, I'm all ears. If he thinks he's going to try to bend me to his policy goals, that's a different story. That's what Mike Rogers will be interested in doing.