enesptjazh-Hanszh-Hantfrdeitkoruarhiidtrnlplvithsvhemsukcselrodafinobn
Google's queries grew at a five-year high while Search revenue stood still
Google Search made $63.35 billion in Q3, flat on Q2, as AI Mode queries earned less. Gil Luria and Bill Ackman explain the drop.
On October 28 Alphabet told investors that people are searching on Google more than at any time in five years. The same release put Search revenue at $63.35 billion, up $79 million from the quarter before. Sundar Pichai opened the call with the query number. Philipp Schindler, the chief business officer, explained the revenue number about half an hour later. The queries growing fastest are in AI Mode, and Google earns less on each one. Shares fell about 10% after hours. Microsoft reported the same evening and went up. Over these two days the market did not reward AI usage. It rewarded AI usage that turns into cash, and Google's didn't.

Pichai led with the queries
The prepared remarks open on the figure Pichai wanted in the headlines.
Search has strong momentum. Our AI investments are driving increased usage and overall query growth, including commercial queries. In fact, our year-over-year query growth rate is the highest it's been in the last five years.
Sundar Pichai, October 28, 2026, Alphabet Q3 2026 earnings call
He added that the Gemini app has one billion users and that Google's model APIs process nearly 32 billion tokens a minute. Cloud revenue rose 103% to $30.7 billion. On those numbers alone, this was Alphabet's best quarter since ChatGPT came out.
Search revenue went flat
Alphabet's third quarter release shows Search and other revenue of $63.35 billion, against $56.57 billion a year earlier. That is 12% growth. In the second quarter the same line grew about 17%, to $63.27 billion. Queries grew at their fastest rate in five years, and Search added almost nothing from one quarter to the next.
The first analyst on the call, JPMorgan's Doug Anmuth, asked the obvious question. Was Google simply showing fewer ads in AI Overviews and AI Mode while those took a bigger share of searches? Schindler listed currency first, then Asian retailers hit by the EU ending its de minimis exemption, then World Cup ad budgets that landed in June. Last, he said that strong growth in AI Mode queries "had an impact because of the lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode." That is a partial yes. CFO Anat Ashkenazi added that Search is lapping about three points of acceleration from late 2025 and will face the same comparison in the fourth quarter.
Schindler put AI Mode at the bottom of his list. The market treated it as the only item that mattered.
Luria calls it the raw nerve
Gil Luria of D.A. Davidson was on Prof G Markets the next day, October 29. He put the lost market value at more than $300 billion, and he blamed one line of the income statement.
We have long been worried that that business would be negatively impacted by AI. And it is Google Search that was the big weakness. If people stop Googling and start GPTing, that means less ad sales.
Gil Luria, October 29, 2026, source
He did not accept the tough-comparison explanation. "They're talking about having tough comps, but that's an abrupt slowdown that nobody expected," he said. He also ruled out a weak ad market. Meta, which reported a week earlier, pushed its ad growth into the high 20s, and Luria said that is now more than twice Google's rate. If he is right, the question is Google's share of ad spending, not the size of it.
Then he said something fair to Google.
It's too early to tell, right? One quarter. I don't think investors need to panic about it. It's just this was the raw nerve that got exposed when ChatGPT came out.
Gil Luria, October 29, 2026, source
I agree with both halves. One flat quarter that also had a currency headwind is thin evidence. But until now, cannibalization was something analysts guessed at. This is the first quarter in which Google's own executives named AI Mode as a drag on revenue.
The cash machine ran negative
Search matters this much because it funds everything else. Alphabet spent $51.4 billion on capital expenditure in the quarter, more than double the $24.0 billion of a year earlier, and free cash flow was negative $9.1 billion. Jim Cramer said it on Mad Money the night of the report.
Free cash flow was also negative $9.1 billion, something you hate to see from a company that used to spew cash and had a pristine balance sheet.
Jim Cramer, October 28, 2026, source
Earlier in the segment he put the Search shortfall at about $1.5 billion below expectations. Reuters put total advertising at $82 billion against $83.4 billion expected. Ashkenazi kept 2026 capex guidance at $195 billion to $205 billion and said 2027 will be significantly higher. She also disclosed $924 billion of future purchase commitments. Luria said the market reads "significantly" as a move from about $200 billion to $300 billion, which means Google has to raise money. Reuters reported that the stock fell about 10% after hours. Microsoft rose more than 5% on free cash flow that beat estimates.

Microsoft got credit for spending less of its own money
Luria's explanation for the split is where the computers sit. He said Microsoft makes 15-year commitments on part of its buildout and rents the overflow from neoclouds on short contracts, so it stays free cash flow positive and stays out of the capital markets.
They're all spending a lot, but Microsoft's doing it a little bit more responsibly, and sometimes that's all you need to get the credit from investors.
Gil Luria, October 29, 2026, source
Google just started doing the same thing. Ashkenazi said Alphabet began using third-party compute at the end of the third quarter, will use more of it in the fourth, and expects that to hurt cloud margins in the near term. In Luria's telling, Microsoft started this three years ago. Google is starting now, while its main profit source is slowing.
Ackman had already sold
Bill Ackman was out before the print. In an interview Equity Mates published on October 28, the hosts noted that Pershing Square had sold Alphabet and kept Microsoft, Amazon and Meta. He gave one reason.
Principally price. I mean, Alphabet got to a price that we felt the go-forward return had dropped below kind of our long-term aspirations.
Bill Ackman, October 28, 2026, source
Later he gave the line I keep coming back to. "Now the search bar is just a way to get access to cheap AI today," he said, and he added that people are still going there. On its face that is bullish, because Google keeps the traffic. The word that matters is cheap. Schindler's answer on the call puts a number on what that word costs. The episode gives no recording date, so read this as a view Ackman held going into the quarter, not a reaction to it.
Pichai's case for patience
Pichai says agents will add revenue, not take it away. "I think agents would, again, be an opportunity to expand the types of problems we solve for our users," he said on the call. Schindler said click-through rates on sponsored and organic product listings in AI Mode are already similar, and that Google is now putting ads into AI Overviews and AI Mode for more users and in more countries. Pichai gave a reason the payoff might come late.
when you're doing it at 70%, it looks like it doesn't work, until you cross a certain threshold, and it really takes off.
Sundar Pichai, October 28, 2026, Alphabet Q3 2026 earnings call
He was talking about agentic tasks, not ad load. The same logic applies to ads. AI Mode has the usage. It does not yet have the pricing.
Is AI Mode eating Google Search?
It is not eating the usage. Queries are up, and Google says most AI Mode queries are new rather than replacements. It is eating the price. Each AI Mode answer earns less than the search it sits beside, and in the third quarter that was enough to keep Search revenue flat while Alphabet spent $51 billion on capex. The test is the fourth quarter. Google is now selling ads inside AI Mode in more countries. If Search revenue is still flat against the third quarter despite that, Luria's one-quarter defense no longer works, and the $300 billion of lost market value starts to look like the market's estimate rather than an overreaction.