Good morning everyone. Please take your seats. My name is Ilana Kujenko, co-director of the Griswald Center. Welcome alumni and families. It's a great honor to welcome Eric Schmidt back to Princeton for a moderated discussion with Alan Blinder on the impact of AI. Alan, Eric, take it away.
This event is sponsored by the Griswald Center. I've lectured in this room many times, never to a group this size. Eric Schmidt is a member of the class of 1976, majored in electrical engineering, then got advanced degrees at Berkeley. He had a career at Novell, Sun Microsystems, and Google. His book 'Genesis' with Henry Kissinger and Craig Mundy is full of predictions. I'll organize this talk around science, prosperity, politics, and security.
I'm so grateful to Princeton. This was the pivot point for my life. Let's start with the science of AI. Recently, OpenAI generated a proof of an 80-year-old theorem. The model wasn't trained on math. LLMs synthesize knowledge into a vector space. The history: symbolic reasoning failed, then deep learning, then the 'Attention Is All You Need' paper in 2017 spawned modern AI. The key innovations were cat detection on YouTube, AlphaGo, and transformers.
It's an amazing story. I didn't hear you mention the huge increase in computing power. Was that not a big deal?
Computing power is essential, but it's always been that way. When I was at Princeton, we used an IBM 360/91 with one megabit boxes. Your phone today is 100 million times more powerful. The limit isn't physical; it's financial. Data centers need 90–100 gigawatts by 2030. The best solution is fully renewable data centers. We're going to solve all human diseases in 15 years, find new energy solutions. This is like the enlightenment.
Wisdom is tough. I'm funding research on AI without wisdom. But the positives are huge. We'll need 10,000 times more electricity. Elon Musk wants data centers on the moon. Have we run out of space? No. Data centers should be built in remote areas with their own power, behind the meter. The industry is moving from high-margin, low-capital to high-capital.
But don't they have to have an ultimate energy source? Electricity doesn't just flow in.
You use natural gas combined-cycle turbines or solar with batteries. If you have land – Texas, New Mexico, Arizona – it's practical. My investment strategy is to buy land where you can get permits. Real estate capital is moving to data centers, which is a mistake.
Does this call for sensible regulation? The internet was left to bloom; social media regulation is more questionable. What do you think?
It will all be regulated differently. The best way to maximize revenue is to maximize outrage. I worked with Jonathan Haidt on this. It's hard without restricting speech. Look at China: they solve it with dictatorial regulation. On AI competition, we restricted chip sales to China, giving us a lead, but based on DeepSeek V4, they're within six months. Chinese entrepreneurs are smart and hardworking. On open source vs proprietary, China is open, the US is closed. Historically, open source built the industry. I think we may be on the wrong side.
Let me ask a different question. As I read, China is going closed source and we're going open source. Is that true?
Actually the inverse: China is open source, US is closed. And I think not. The top models here are proprietary. But the industry was built on open source. China lets you take the weights and use them free. Many startups prefer Chinese models. If you're a researcher at Princeton, you'd have to work for those companies. That's a problem.
And are we on the right side of it?
Let me explain. This is a really important distinction. The entire industry started at Princeton based on open source. If you want to go far, go with a crew. Put the stuff out there and thousands strengthen it. China decided to do open source, and it's working. That's a big change.
Google center here on the other side of Prospect, right? So that primarily you could actually walk from here to the Google data centers. Logically, that's not a scalable strategy. So there's a problem with open source leadership in America. Why is this so important geographically? If you don't care about that, it's because the majority of the models in the world will be Chinese. Do you know why? Because they're going to be free. It's not that complicated. We were at dinner last night with my friend who's quite wealthy, and he was joking that he was using one of the American models and he calculated that he was doing it for fun. And he calculated it was going to cost him half a million dollars a year for his entertainment, which consisted of building a newsreader that was biased on his political views. You know, perfectly fine. So he switched to a Chinese model to read American news cheaply. So it's real.
So that's hot tough competition.
Yeah. Chinese are going to be very tough. And I'm very concerned and I want to be clear to everybody here. Most people here are US citizens. We are not meeting the competition and beating them globally. They are investing in science and technology and innovation at a rate to overcome America. What would it be like if China were the winner in all categories? AI, quantum, so forth and so on. Start thinking about conflict. America always seems to be in some kind of war or not. We're getting ready over Taiwan, right? Can you imagine? Here's the thought experiment. So there's something called super intelligence, which is the point at which it's smarter than all of us. Many people in my industry think that this will occur within 10 years. We can debate this. Nobody really knows. Let's imagine they get there first. And as part of that super intelligence, they figure out some attack vector against America that we cannot imagine right now. And by the way, the inverse is true for us. So this is a big deal. If you care about national security, you need to fund this. If you don't care about national security, you care about social welfare, you need to fund this. If you care about economic growth, which I think all of us certainly do, you better fund it. You better figure out a way to keep the engine that got me to where I am going.
What you said before, Kumar, what you just said now makes me think of the electricity grid. I mean, all of this is ultimately on electricity.
And is that or might that become a vulnerability in a case like that? You don't really need to send airplanes with bombs. So first place, China last year built 130 gigawatts of renewable energy. Okay, remember the number I said is that we needed about 100 gigawatts between now and 2030 in America. They already have it, right? There are estimates that they have 20 gigawatts just sitting around, right? I don't know what the real numbers are. I'll try to find out. So assuming that these data centers continue to be these large things, they become military targets. I wrote a paper which we called, um, the argument went something like this. This is influence of Kissinger. You start thinking about what happens when we're getting stronger and China's getting stronger or whoever. There's a point at which one side could decide to do a preemptive attack of the other, which is your question. Doesn't it make sense to slow down your competitor by just bombing their data centers? So, we being pleasant Princetonian type graduates said there's a better alternative, which is to just give the enemy a switch. So they don't have to bomb the data center, they just have to turn it off. And everybody goes, that's the stupidest idea I've ever seen. I, if you believe that these data centers are essential for the national security of a nation, you've got to come up with some kind of a deterrent strategy. In that sense, it is similar to nuclear.
which is cross your fingers and hope that this there's symmetric forbearance.
Well, well nuclear worked because of a theory of mutual assured destruction. And it's important to know I wrote a book about this that mutual assured destruction has never been tested.
Yeah. But let's start with an assertion. It's never been tested. We don't know what will happen. We don't know what will happen if there is a third nuclear bombing of any kind. Having the US having done the first two, we just don't know. And we're playing with incredibly powerful stuff here. So, one thing I've learned is that this is not a kids game. There are these huge organizations that worry about safety and security and biosecurity and so forth. One way to understand the threats of models. There's the threat to democracy which everybody here understands. There's we've known for a long time that the first things it would be able to do would be cyber attacks. And the reason is that if you can do good software programming, you can also write good cyber attacks. When Mythos came out, which is a couple months ago, this is the Anthropic cyber attack model. They had the good judgment of only releasing it to about 40 companies as well as the US government. By the way, this is during the time when they're having a big fight with the Pentagon and the White House and they get banned while they're essential for the use of the NSA. So it's crazy. And I'm sure that will get resolved because they ultimately have to work together. But if you think about it, if you're the head of the NSA or in that group, you want these tools for offensive cyber attack and you also want to be able to use these tools to prevent defensive cyber attack. The term in the industry is called offense dominant versus defense dominant. Are you more likely to win with offense or defense? My assessment is these tools are offense dominant. So we need to be very careful that we have a strong offense as well as a strong defense. That's my personal view.
Let me turn you something a little less cataclysmic but that a lot of people worry about which is job loss as opposed to job change or both or is one bigger than the other. Do you spend any time worrying about massive unemployment as a result of AI?
Uh, I do, but not now. And I'll give you the numbers. We know that the current stuff in the US is displacing low-level customer service jobs, and we know it's displacing softer jobs, typically the lower level, entry-level jobs. Which is a big deal for those people who are displaced. We have not yet seen mass effect of the white collar workforce. It's going to happen in the next five years. And here's how it happens. There's a very good article yesterday by a friend of mine who runs Cloudflare who wrote a very nice explanation that he runs a company which is growing at 30% a year, has huge valuation and so forth, and he's a 20% layoff and he justifies his layoff by looking at the categories of workers and he doesn't need this set of categories and those specific categories are not sales, they're not engineering, they're a bunch of the infrastructure. So your decision, you should decide whether you think those people can be retrained or get new skills that are more consistent with what AI cannot do. Well, one way to say this is that this is the first technology that's really threatened white collar work and because white collar people write really well, they write about it all day. Right. They write about their experience. Two-thirds of the jobs in America are essentially labor, human labor centric. They require hands or pressure or presence or so forth.
And these are important jobs.
So as long as robots don't really work, the impact will be manageable. The fear I have is that in 10 years, the robotic revolution, which is much slower than software, will in fact begin to displace those jobs. If that begins to occur, now this is a long time from now, we're going to have a whole lot of problems, right? For obvious reasons. And why do I say it's going to take that long? The US robotics industry is relatively slow and relatively expensive. In China, they have, I'll give you an example. They have a company called Unitry, which builds a robot called R1, which I've ordered for $5,000. Look at the videos of what it can do. So that's what's coming now. It's dumb as you could imagine. The thing needs a proper brain, right? Whatever that means. I mean, it's like the stupidest robot you could imagine. But that can be fixed over time. That's I think the real concern.
Take you back before the robots. The good side of the answer to this question that's been around since the Levites is that yes, the new technology will destroy some jobs, but it will also create a lot of new jobs. So it's mostly about job change and disruption and moving resources from here to there.
Uh, a lot of new jobs. So it's mostly about job change and disruption and moving resources from here to there.
The United You could tell me if you agree with this or not. I would say the United States among the rich countries is almost uniquely bad at managing that transition, retraining workers, supporting them while they're unemployed, etc., etc. Making the transition easier rather than harder. So, do you see it that way? That that's the answer to the on the worrier side of it's only job change. It's not job destruction.
Um, the benefit, the counterargument is the benefit of the brutal nature of American employment is that it's a reconfiguration into a new role quicker, which is part of why American productivity is better than Europe's, for example. And there are debate, technical debates about that. Paul Krugman, for example, has been arguing against that point. What do I really think?
Yeah, what do you really think? You're a very good thinker.