Looking through all this, we don't know, but my strong suspicion is that Nvidia is backstopping, providing some form of guarantee, not for the whole $500 billion, but some portion of it. What that all boils down to is some of this is ultimately a form of debt for Nvidia. I think debt is very pro-cyclical, right? When times are good, like they are now, everybody wants AI, so much demand. This is going to amp that up considerably. The problem is when the cycle turns, and the cycle always turns, this kind of thing will amplify the pain on the downside.
Welcome to Prof G Markets. I'm Ed. It is August 12th. Let's check in on yesterday's market vitals. The major indices declined again after another day without progress in Iran. Brent crude climbed. The yield on 10-year Treasuries inched lower ahead of the next inflation report due this morning. And finally, Apple shares fell more than 1% on news that its head of Apple Pay is retiring. Okay, what else is happening?
Nvidia is joining forces with Wall Street in one of the most ambitious financing efforts ever attempted. On Monday, Nvidia announced memorandums of understanding with six major asset managers to secure half a trillion dollars to fund the AI buildout. The firms will lend that capital to Nvidia's customers, helping them build more data centers and buy more chips. BlackRock CEO Larry Fink called the project the beginning of, quote, 'the next frontier for financial engineering.' And Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said that AI chips have now become an investable asset class.
However, Nvidia shares fell nearly 4% on the news, which was first reported by the Financial Times. Joining us to discuss this half-a-trillion-dollar financing arrangement, we are speaking with Jay Goldberg, analyst at Seaport Global Securities. Jay, thanks for joining us on the show. I've been looking at this $500 billion deal. I can't really tell what the deal actually is. There are a bunch of Wall Street banks and firms involved. It's a big number, but who's lending money to what? What does the financing package actually look like? What do we actually know about this?
We don't know a lot. There's a lot of unknowns in here. They had a press release out yesterday, and the press release was almost entirely sort of, hey, glowing quotes from all the participants about how great they all were. And then Jensen posted on Twitter today, gave a little bit more granularity to a couple of things, but we don't really know. And I think it's worth pointing out that in the press release it actually is very clear that the agreements are not finalized. So they don't know what the details are yet.
I mean, the term that jumped out to me was memorandum of understanding. I've heard that before in a deal with Iran that turned out to not be a deal and turned out to be a little bit of a disaster. Is that the right comparison here?
I'm really wary of getting into geopolitics. I will say that Nvidia had a similar memorandum with OpenAI. They were going to invest a lot of money into OpenAI, and that deal, again, was press released before the contract was finalized, and it ended up not happening, or it radically shifted, that it was a very different deal than the one that actually emerged six months afterwards. So, Nvidia is a company that cares a lot about its image and likes to keep people excited, and so they put out this press release. I'm curious. I don't know why they did it now. That's a little odd. I don't know the timing. It seems, I don't want to say premature, but like there's just a lot of unknowns.
What do you make of the stock reaction? The fact that Nvidia shares fell nearly 4%. I mean, if the idea was to inspire excitement and confidence, that's not what happened. What is the stock price telling us? What is Wall Street feeling?
Yeah, I think there is an undercurrent among some investors, not all, but certainly a sizable chunk of investors who are worried about circular financing. And this certainly looks like it's a big piece of circular financing going on here because Nvidia is providing money to customers to buy Nvidia parts. I think that makes people uncomfortable. Not, you know, run for the hills, sell all our Nvidia stock, but just like we're starting to see investors ask more questions about these kinds of deals and where this is all headed.
Jensen Huang wrote in the blog post sort of announcing the deal. He addressed that question. He said, quote, 'Is this circular financing?' And then he continued on to say, 'This initiative is designed to address that concern. We are bringing independent long-term institutional capital into the AI infrastructure market. The demand is real. It comes from frontier AI labs, AI-native startups, enterprises, cloud providers, and countries building AI services. The investors make independent financing decisions.' I'm not sure he answers the question. He certainly doesn't say the word no or the words 'it isn't circular financing.' To what extent is this circular financing? What is circular about this, if at all?
When companies provide financing for their customers, there's a fine line between enabling demand and creating demand, and Nvidia has been walking that line ever closer for a couple of years now. I think it's perfectly reasonable to provide some form of working capital loan. You lend your, you know, you give them favorable terms. You let the customer pay six months, nine months. That's a form of financing. Or you loan them a little bit of money. That's common practice in a lot of, you know, capex-intensive industries. This one, I think, catches everyone's eye because it's so big, right? Half a trillion dollars, like you said. It's just not entirely clear if you are coming from the point of view that AI is a bubble and nobody can articulate what the ROI on that investment is, or what even the use case is, or the business model. If you come from that viewpoint, this looks very much like Nvidia is creating demand that might not exist otherwise.
Now, Nvidia's take is, no, no, we're not creating demand. We see a, you know, a mispriced asset class, if you will. The lenders don't know how to lend to this. They're missing the point. They're missing the opportunity. They don't understand it. We will step in and help bridge that gap. I get the logic. But it's such a big number and there's so many questions around it. It's hard to see this as something that's not Nvidia giving money to customers so they can buy from Nvidia, left hand paying the right hand.
Is that the biggest risk for the company right now? Like, is that the main problem? And if so, is that why Jensen Huang is specifically calling it out in his blog post?
I don't know why he's addressing it in that way. I think he's very cognizant of what the street says about him and what the zeitgeist on the street is. So I think he wanted to address that. But I do think there is a bigger concern here, which is, as complicated as this is, and you want to call it, you know, financial engineering or, you know, a whole new asset class, ultimately it's debt, right? And lenders don't care about fancy technology, they don't care about AI, they care about when they're going to get paid back and ultimately who's responsible in the event of non-payment. And so looking through all this, we don't know, but my strong suspicion is that Nvidia is backstopping, providing some form of guarantee, not for the whole $500 billion, but some portion of it.
There's talk in his blog post about a 25% coverage of certain things, sort of paying for the depreciation risk, paying down whatever the exact mechanism, we don't know, but Nvidia is providing some form of guarantee. Ultimately, that is giving the lenders comfort enough that they can lend at a reasonable interest rate, right? Because imagine the counterfactual: if Nvidia weren't involved in this, what would happen? These deals wouldn't get done, right? Because the interest rates would be priced too high. What that all boils down to is this is going to end up, some of this is ultimately a form of debt for Nvidia. I think debt is very pro-cyclical, right? When times are good, like they are now, everybody wants AI, there's so much demand, this is going to amp that up considerably. The problem is when the cycle turns, and the cycle always turns, this kind of thing will amplify the pain on the downside, right?
Because imagine what happens at some point in the future when the hyperscalers have run out of balance sheet and don't want to buy any more AI or can't afford to buy any more Nvidia GPUs, AI demand gets saturated. Just at that moment is when these backstops, when these obligations are going to come due, and all the neoclouds who have borrowed money from this platform are going to suddenly see unused capacity and they're going to put that back to Nvidia. But at the same time, Nvidia's own core business sales will be declining, or margins will be declining, earnings will trend downwards, and that makes it much more painful on the back side of this. That's the big sort of fear.
It is debt, right? That $500 billion. I assume it's debt. You say it seems like it's mostly debt. That's what it is, right? It's just $500 billion in debt.
Yeah. We don't know that. So I'm hedging a little bit, but yeah, it's debt. Like, ultimately, it's a form of debt.
The one thing that I just want to get your reaction to as well, he mentioned this idea that chips are an investable asset class. That seems to be kind of the main thrust of this announcement. And he said that on CNBC. He had this roundtable with all of the Wall Street CEOs. I want to play you this clip and see what you make of it.
This is really the first time that technology chips have become an investable asset class. This is a very big concept. It's a big concept because the computers, these systems are not like our PCs or like our phones. These are revenue-generating assets now. They're productive. They're long-lived. They're fungible. They're flexible. You can use it for all kinds of different things.
Why is it so important to him to communicate that the chips are an investable asset class? And why is that such an essential component of this big announcement?
So, let me wind back the clock a couple of years. There's a history here for Nvidia providing financing for customers. In the early days, in 2022 and 2023, Nvidia provided essentially what I was talking about before, easy working capital terms to the first round of neoclouds like CoreWeave. And it was so hot back then that CoreWeave could take delivery of systems, earn enough from running those systems for a few months that they could pay back Nvidia very quickly. Over time, as the neoclouds and Nvidia's ambitions grew, that wasn't enough. The numbers got too big. And so Nvidia started getting more actively involved. And the key thing they did at that point was they provided backstops: if you can't sell all the compute we're selling you, if you can't use it all, we'll buy some percentage of it.
Right now, today, Nvidia already has, as of last quarter, $30 billion of what they call compute service agreements in place. It's not on their books. It's not on the balance sheet, but it's in the footnotes. What's been happening on the debt side, as these neoclouds, these new cloud service providers are coming up, there are hundreds of them now, and they've all gone to lenders and said, hey, loan us some money so we can buy some GPUs. And the lenders look at that and they want collateral, and they have always said that the GPUs are not sufficient collateral. And so if you look at most of the really big neocloud financings that have taken place, the debt is ultimately backed not by the GPUs, not the hardware, but by the customers, right? Microsoft signs a long-term agreement. They're going to buy this compute. That's the credit guarantee that the lenders want.
Even that wasn't enough. And so Nvidia's had to step in more and more to provide sort of a topper on that commitment. I think a lot of the borrowers in this market would really, really, really like to have GPUs themselves as collateral, right? Because we're at the point now where the hyperscalers who have been providing most of the commitment so far are getting much more aggressive in building their own capacity. They don't need to use third parties as much. They're less willing to sign these deals with third-party neoclouds. They want to use their balance sheet for their own purposes, for buildings and data centers that they control. And so that source of guarantee is not going away. It's not gone, but it's probably shrinking.
What's going to provide the guarantee here? What's going to be the collateral? It sure would be nice if the lenders would accept GPUs as collateral. And I think that's the message he's trying to get across. I personally don't think that's going to land with investors. I think they're still going to want to see some other forms of guarantees. And that's ultimately why Nvidia is going to take on some form of obligation here.
So he's basically saying, 'This is the anchor of the $500 billion in debt that I'm about to go raise, and you guys should all do the same thing because this is something that we can all do, right?'