It is a little bit concerning to me that there are a lot of really what we would consider high quality names, companies that you just know are going to be around in 10 years, trading at massive discounts to companies who may not be around in 10 years. And it is cognitive dissonance, and I'm not sure what to make of it. It's just a weird time in the market.
Hello everyone. Welcome to another episode of The Circuit. I am Ben Bajarin.
Greetings, Claus. I'm Jay Goldberg.
All right, so we have on the docket another announcement from Intel. This, actually, two announcements from Intel, to be honest with you, in the same week. So, a couple of things. They made an announcement with Tesla. There was a nice picture of Lip-Bu Tan in front of the Intel sign for Fab 52 in Chandler, Arizona, where Ben also took a selfie when he toured Fab 52, standing there shaking the hands of Elon Musk, because sparse on details, but somehow, in some way, Intel is a partner with Terafab. Now, everybody was like, 'Oh, this is how he does it,' because we were all like, 'How in the world are you going to do what you want to do in CapEx and, you know, gigawatts of compute and foundry when you have no ASML machines, you've got no process technology? You were clearly going to use somebody else's stuff. It's just a matter of who.' And so now there's more clarity that Intel is involved. We know Samsung's involved, too. So, both these people are involved to varying degrees. But my initial take, and I'm sort of curious if you land on something, is sparse details and we have no idea what the economics are.
I felt it was a vote of confidence for Intel IP. And again, I'm not going to say it's just manufacturing capabilities, whether this was based on things they can do with wafer production or advanced packaging, although I think it might lean more toward advanced packaging. A big customer, a notable person, celebrity force of the industry, and Elon Musk is going to use some stuff from Intel under one roof at Terafab. So, I thought that was, you know, a vote of confidence.
I'll give it that. It was a vote of confidence, but beyond that, I don't know really what to make of it. I feel like my feelings about this Terafab announcement are the shrug emoji. Like, 'I don't know.' Because they were just very light on detail. What exactly are they planning? You know, Intel right now has its own capacity shortages. They're going to work through those hopefully sooner than TSMC, but like...
Yeah, they don't exactly have a lot of EUV systems to spare. I have a theory on where they're going to get their lithography.
Yeah, it's too crazy. So, I'm going to hold off for now. But yeah, let me do some more. I'm working away at that, but I can't get confirmation. So, I'm going to hold off on that theory.
Okay. But it's something. Like you're right, it is like a big potential customer, like a massive potential customer when you add up x.ai and Tesla and their silicon needs. And Elon runs a lot of companies that are going to need a lot of chips. So, I'll just leave it at that. And Intel is going to be in that mix, and that's good for Intel.
Yeah.
Well, I mean, so there were two other things, too. I think there was a little bit of a confusion like, 'Oh, he's going to use Intel fabs.' And you know, the premise of Terafab is everything under one roof, which I understand, right? When you talk to anybody who manufactures product at TSMC, they essentially say the same thing, which is that I like that it's all under one roof, which is the reason why I'm somewhat optimistic on TSMC CoWoS for optical, is that if you're doing silicon photonics or if you're doing co-packaged optics or need these things, packaging in the same place and doing your manufacturing from your silicon wafers makes sense. And so I get that, right? I get the idea. But what is going under his roof? Like, it's highly unlikely Intel moves, to your point, they're capacity short constrained manufacturing, so wafer equipment material into Terafab. But is it like he's going to build on their process? Is it that he's going to use some of their... like...
It's very vague. It's very vague. It's something, you know? I want to be positive about it. I do think it is important to remember not even a year ago, Elon made a similar announcement with Samsung.
Yes, about using their fab in Texas, right? And that doesn't seem to be playing out, which is in a very weird way actually good for Samsung, because... But it is like, it's Elon. It is a massive wildcard, a massive X factor. Right? x.ai, get it? That's a little pun there. But the reaction, the market's reaction was positive, right? Despite, you know, the news. They were like, 'Hey, look.' And I think they landed similarly like I did. Like this is, you know, more technology validation for Intel, which again, to be honest with you, yes, we would love a wafer scale customer to Intel. Yes, we would love some big name to be using their packaging publicly. The reality of, you know, this being a baby step, that there's validation that something Intel has, process, package, etc., is good. So, I think that was positive. Again, we'd all love to know more, but it was directionally good.
Agreed. And if you look at what X and Elon did with Samsung, as much as volumes are probably not what we thought they would be, that announcement was a major turning point for Samsung. Right? Now, maybe just optically, maybe substantively, they were going to, I'm sure they were going to get there anyway, but like that announcement was the start of a real resurgence in their fortunes. Like they got, not long after that, they got their process working again. They got HBM qualified. Like obviously that's all, you know, mostly on Samsung, but like I think it's safe to say that Elon had done some diligence on their process beforehand. And that served as a pretty important public validation of Samsung. And I think this is equally true for Intel.
Agreed. And you know, we have honestly, I feel like they've been getting momentum as a whole. I mean, I do think, you know, again, the stock's up. I forget, I can look briefly for the week. 19% actually. They closed at 62.38 today. So, that's great. That's amongst the highest it's almost been in some time actually, to be honest with you.
Yep. I mean, like literally since 2020. It's the highest they've been. And okay, so let's jump to Google.
Okay, and I'm just going to make a very brief analogy, and in no way, shape or form am I saying these two things are similar. But like, Anthropic today made another announcement that all of a sudden you can now work with Claude in Word. Like it's insane. They're usurping Microsoft's productivity suite. But they're just launching. Like they're just announcing after announcing after announcing. And to some degree, I feel like Intel is doing this in foundry. Like they actually have a whole series of things that are compounding upon each other. The Google announcement, yes, Google's using Xeon. We should all know, right? That it's not a shock when a hyperscaler works with Intel to do a somewhat bind-up variant of their CPU. Like every, Amazon does that. Like everybody does this with Intel. They do co-design what they call the IPU, which is basically a DPU if you follow this show and you kind of hear all of our love for a DPU. Their IPU is a DPU. And I think there's more to this announcement than led on. I think there might be some packaging involved in this, maybe a little bit more customization that's done for Google on the IPU, because again, IPUs are CPUs. They're not random things. They're CPUs architected to do network security, noisy neighbor, Kubernetes, multi-management, tenant management, all those things. But I like that Intel sort of just keeps dropping announcements, is my point. Like...
Yeah, Anthropic, like we just keep shipping.
Intel keeps making announcements on things that are beneficial for foundry or the health of the business.
Yeah, I mean, I did some work on that exact subject this week, just going through their announcements over the last like three weeks. Because you have Terafab, you have Google, you have their new chairman, which I think we talked about. That's a major positive sign. We talked about last week they got out of that deal in Ireland. Right? I mean, it's just been... And then they have, in addition to that, there are a lot of press reports about other customers kicking the tires. Like I have a whole list of who their announced customers are. And it's a surprisingly long list. And now, admittedly, it's mostly custom CPU, DPU customers. It's not foundry customers.
Yeah, which is what we all want, right?
But then, you know, there are a half dozen or more companies where there have been credible press reports saying these guys are evaluating Intel foundry.
Right. At that point you have to think there's like some substance there. Like there's at least momentum.
Yeah, I agree, and I do think it's not coincidence that you actually have seen, and this was, I don't know, maybe a quarter or so ago, folks at Broadcom, folks at Google, folks at others within the job title say understanding of Intel's EMIB. And you keep hearing that EMIB is becoming such a key part of what's getting them in the door. And this was their thesis a long time ago. Like I think I talked about it, especially when I toured the advanced packaging facility. Like their belief was people are coming to us for packaging because we've got some really unique differentiators there, and that's opening the door to other conversations. Now, again, right? Zisner on the call was like, yeah, packaging could do a billion, like sure, we'd love that. But packaging is not wafers. So, but great, right? You're growing that business. But if that gets you in a customer conversation for an ASIC or custom CPU, and that's where they're at. And so I make that Anthropic point to say I think they have a lot more interesting foundry announcements coming through the rest of the year while they're absolutely, like TSMC, not going to just name drop customers because they're not Hock Tan apparently who can just name drop customers. I think it will become clear who their customers are very quickly for those of us who will be vested to figure that out, but I think the second half of this year will be very interesting for unpacking foundry and momentum for Intel foundry.
Yep, I agree. I agree with that.
All right, good stuff. All right, good stuff on that. Jay has a thesis we're all going to hear for the first time. Ben hasn't heard it, so he's going to launch into his thesis.
All right, so my thesis isn't so much a thesis, it's just a reality that I've been struggling with a lot lately. Which is, if you look at a lot of the stocks in semis right now, there is this weird mix of valuation where you have some very prominent companies who we all know are doing incredibly well trading at, relative to their history, low multiples. Right? Relative to the S&P, low multiples. And then you have a bunch of other companies whose prospects are further out, less proven, and their multiples are through the roof. Right? Really crazy ones. And I'm deliberately avoiding names because I don't want to give any, I'm not giving investment advice.
But it is this weird disconnect in the market that I'm struggling to wrap my head around. And I think a lot of it just comes down to this expectations game, right? Where we all kind of have a good sense of where the sort of the biggest chip companies, especially in the compute side of things, we have a pretty good idea of what they're going to do this year. Whereas like some of the other ones, the networking names, the optical components and optical systems, that's like, they seem to have capacity, right? TSMC is sold out. A lot of other companies aren't sold out yet. And this demand is sort of saturating, has saturated compute, and now demand is spreading out into other areas, creating a lot of expectations. And it is very confusing, I would say, for investors. Certainly confusing for me.
Yeah, so I know the names Jay is talking about are relative to optical names, so do your own assumptions there. I think what's come down to, to be honest with you, is like, so I agree with you on expectations. I think what is interesting is when you unpack, I think some of the market narratives, there's this like thesis similar to, to use the name, as to who owns the scarcity. And then who has to some degree some monopoly on that scarcity. Now rightly or wrongly, there are some names in optical that have believed to be like the only ones who can do X, Y, and Z, and that's not true. But the reality is that's where some folks have landed. And there's some of that emotional sentiment, you know, that you've talked about right before. There's some of that, yes, there's a lot of retail people pumping these up. I've even seen the bigger, we won't name them, influential substacks, if you will, of the last few weeks do some things where they're shorting or longing like some of these stocks. So okay. But I think there's such a desire to kind of make a pick on a name who essentially's got, call it, like the edge on something that's scarce. And with an optical, this is an interesting debate, right? Because this is very difficult. And we are not sure which direction it's going to go yet. And someone might win and be a very big winner, but we don't know who that's going to be. So I think there's those dynamics. But then there's also, to your point about like the Nvidias and the Broadcoms and some of the others of the world, which is like, I mean, do you not think, like, are you discounting really the trajectory that they are when they're actually the gatekeepers for the success of those optical names, for example? They're the ones that will define that path and to some degree pick those winners. And I would argue they also have a fair element of control of scarcity given their ability to secure the supply chain. So I don't know. I mean, I'm with you. It's weird. I mean, I watch these stocks regularly and I see a couple of these names and it's like 400% in six months and you're like, okay, okay, you certainly aren't making that much money in the next two years, man.
Yeah, it's very, I mean, especially we're also getting to the point where we're plumbing the very dark corners of the industry. Where, you know, a lot of the substacks I'm on and Twitter and Discord servers I lurk in, we're having debates about like really, really violent debates about some very obscure names that no one would have talked about two, three years ago. Right? Mostly in optical and test and optical test, but other areas, too. And it's just, it is, I'm somewhat cautious on parts of the sector. And it is a little bit concerning to me that there are a lot of really what we would consider high quality names, companies that you just know are going to be around in 10 years, trading at massive discounts to companies who may not be around in 10 years. And it is cognitive dissonance, and I'm not sure what to make of it. It's just a weird time in the market.
I think that's true, and just being, you know, sort of aware of that I think is important as you, you know, factor through this and as folks do some research. But, you know, like I said, at the same time it's like the echo chamber that is Twitter, which, and I just can't emphasize this enough, has become a fairly vocal place in which some momentum does go to things, for that is just the reality of it. It just moves really quick, you know, in some of these things. Like emotion and sentiment can move quickly. And it's just interesting. So, you know, be aware of that obviously I think is important. And stay on top of the ever-changing dynamics of... But what's interesting, I will say, like, I don't know if you've seen it, but I have had a lot of conversations with investors, and I think I talked, I think I had said this a while back. Like it's actually interesting to me that so many, you know, people on the equity side are actually bringing in technical people to be a part of their investment team. And what that has led them to do is to, and so I use this like, you know, obviously there's big picture, and then, you know, for a long time I was saying like, hey, let's get in the weeds in semis. And then when we start talking about like testing and substrates and all these things that we're talking about, tungsten like we talked about, you're talking about the soil now. And you're having people go like, the weeds aren't enough anymore. We need to get into the minerals and the soil of the semiconductor industry and the supply chain. And that just opens up a whole another can of worms. And so I just find it fascinating that that's where now these conversations have led is like, no, no, no, I don't want to talk about manufacturing anymore. I don't want to talk about wafer equipment. I want to talk about minerals. I want to talk about, you know, testing. I want to talk about how we do, like I'm going to find every bottleneck I can.
In the soil. Yeah, I love that metaphor. Although I do want to say I owe an apology to the tungsten community. Tungsten is very important. I mentioned last week there was a supply that I didn't really know what it was used for. Now I know because you've all educated me, and I'm sorry.
Jay, I mean, I didn't know either when we talked about this. It's fascinatingly important, especially to memory.
But we're at the point now where we're not talking about chips, we're talking about exactly elements. Not even like how many wafers or who makes the wafers. It's like, no, no, no, no, I want to talk about all of the nitty-gritty of, into the soils and the mineral composite of the soils that makes the semi nectar and any, anyway. Everybody's going deeper. That's my high-level point, and I think it's great.