The bond vigilantes were basically locked up in a dungeon. I've got a better way of describing the economy, I think, and that is the G-shaped economy.
Yes. And stock prices, after all, are slaves to earnings.
We are dealing with the future. And some of those science fiction movies are always frightening.
Hi, I'm Anka Patak, head of global investments at Ionic Asset, and it is my utter pleasure to have Dr. Edward Yardeni here. The man who needs no introduction, but happy to introduce Ed anyways. He's the president of Yardeni Research, one of the most widely read independent research houses on Wall Street. Before founding his own firm, he was chief investment strategist at Deutsche Bank's US equities division and held senior strategist and other chief economist roles at Credit Suisse among other reputed firms. Earlier in his career, he was an economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. He holds a PhD in economics from Yale. He's the man who coined the term bond vigilantes in 1983, and the term is having quite a year as we speak. He's the author of Predicting the Market, Fed Watching for Fun and Profit, among other notable publications, and you know he's been the most consistently bullish and consistently right voices on the American bull market with his Roaring 2020s thesis. Dr. Yardeni, it is a pleasure to have you. Thank you for joining us from New York.
Now let's get straight into it. Bond yields are at a 24-year high. The Fed has started hiking again. And for the first time in a while, you have moved your equity targets down rather than up. Like I said, you coined the term bond vigilantes, and you recently wrote a note called Bond Vigilantes Gone Wild. The US 10-year above 5.2, highest since 2002 rather, and your own view is that US yields are rising on growth, but the 2-year at 4.8 against fed funds at 3.75 is pricing more hikes. Is it growth? Is it the vigilantes, and are they back?
Well, yeah, the bond issue is the main reason why I did lower my expectations for where the S&P 500 would be at year end, but I pushed that out. I was using 8,400 for the end of the year. Now I'm using it for the middle of next year. So I just, I'm still obviously bullish. Still think the market's going higher, but I think there's some reasons for caution in the short term because of what's happening in the bond market. What's happening in the bond market is happening globally, and I think that the global upward trend in bonds, synchronized increase in bond yields, probably has something to do with central banks raising their interest rates, particularly the Bank of Japan, and so it may be the unwinding of the so-called yen carry trade. But here in the United States, I think that to a large extent the increase in bond yields simply reflects the fact that the economy is doing very well and that productivity is in fact showing signs of growing at a faster pace.
At the beginning of the year, the Federal Reserve was saying that the federal funds rate was still modestly restrictive. In other words, they were saying that they needed to lower rates because the so-called neutral rate, the ideal rate for the economy to operate at, was actually lower than the Fed funds rate. Well, they pivoted pretty dramatically, and Fed Chair Jerome... Fed Chair Kevin Warsh, I should say, kind of indicated in the September meeting of the FOMC that the reason they hiked by 25 basis points is simply because they were removing a dose of accommodation, implying that they agree with this view that if the economy is doing better, maybe the neutral rate is higher, and that's what they're getting to. So the bottom line is I think interest rates are back to normal. I think they were abnormally low between the Great Financial Crisis and the Great Virus Crisis. If that's the case, then it shouldn't really slow the economy down. Earnings should remain very strong, and that should be good for the stock market, perhaps offset by some moderation in the valuation multiple.
Perfect, and I think you've touched upon some of the very interesting issues from, you know, the AI productivity boom, yen carry trade, and we will through the course of this conversation deep dive into multiple of those. But sticking to the S&P 500 target at 8,400, which was revised downwards to 7,900, like you said, it has all been, you know, taking the forward PE assumption from 19.8 to 18.6 and keeping the EPS at 425. So it is rather a rates call, not an earnings call. But that you also increased your downturn odds from 20% to 30%. What is driving that increase in probability? And is there a yield level at which 425 of earnings no longer gets us to, let's say, 8,400 by mid-27?
Well, you know, I coined the term bond vigilantes, as you mentioned, back in 1983, and one way to kind of see the relationship between the bond market and the economy is to, on the same chart, put the bond yield, the 10-year bond yield of the US government, versus the year-over-year percent change in nominal GDP and the nominal growth rate of the economy. And what that shows is that during the 1970s, when nominal GDP was growing very rapidly because inflation was increasing so rapidly, bond yields consistently stayed below the growth of the economy. A lot of bond people lost a lot of money in the 70s. In the 80s, they suddenly became very aware of inflation, and bond yields consistently traded above the growth rate of nominal GDP. In other words, they were more vigilant, and whenever nominal GDP picked up in the 1980s, bond yields went up, and that slowed the economy down.
In the 1990s, the new administration under President Clinton was very aware of the bond vigilantes, and they were very careful with their fiscal policies and ran a surplus by the end of the decade. So the bond vigilantes didn't have to be vigilant. As we know, between the Great Financial Crisis and the Great Virus Crisis, the bond vigilantes were basically locked up in a dungeon. They couldn't do anything because the central banks around the world were basically rigging, they were manipulating the yield curve. They brought the Fed funds rate and other policy rates down to zero, or actually negative in the case of Japan. And of course they did quantitative easing which brought bond yields down. But in the past couple of years, the bond market's been freer to voice an opinion. And the opinion right now, on a global basis, is there's concern about inflation, perhaps clearly related to the war in the Middle East and what that's done to oil prices, and the possibility that that will spread to other prices. There's clearly a concern about fiscal excesses, particularly in the case of France, which seems to be going through a debt crisis.
But I think of all the bond yields that are affected by inflation and concerns about debt, I think the US has, to a large extent, been driven up simply by the fact that the US economy has been stronger than expected. So that's obviously a more benign spin or analysis of what's going on in the United States. Now, if the bond yield, which is currently up to 5.3% as we're speaking, if that were to rise, continue to rise and move up above nominal GDP, which is currently about six and a half percent, then I think that would be an indication that we are seeing the bond vigilantes responding to concerns about fiscal excesses in the United States.
Five, 5.3%, five and a half percent, even five and three-quarters percent, I don't think is going to really affect the economic growth. The economy is less interest rate sensitive. Consumers, a lot of them are retiring, and they actually enjoy seeing rates going up, and they don't really care much about what's going on in the labor markets because they've retired. We've got a generation of baby boomers that are retiring, and they're collectively retiring with a hundred trillion dollars of net worth. That's what they're going to be living on. So the stock market's very important to them. If the stock market were suddenly to take a big, big drop, that might affect the consumers, but consumers are not interest rate sensitive on the whole. Capital spending is driven by AI, and AI spending doesn't seem to be very sensitive to interest rates.
You know, so I think the key takeaway for me is that given how the US is set up today, like you said, stock market drop really drives the economy way more than a hike in yields, given how the demographics of the US have evolved over time. But interestingly, Dr. Yardeni, I think at 19 times forward earnings and a 10-year above 5.2, true, the earning yield on the S&P and the Treasury yield would probably give us the same number, right? So is the market now getting at zero equity risk premium?
Well, I think what we're seeing is a very interesting stock market this year. We've had much better than expected earnings. I guess I like coining phrases and acronyms, so I came up with FIMO, fabulous earnings momentum. Earnings have actually been remarkably well, they've been fabulous, and they're still fabulous. And I think the third quarter reporting season, earnings reporting season that's starting now, that's going to show an increase of something like 25% year-over-year for earnings.
Second quarter was up 50%, but we know that half of that was related to big capital gains for Alphabet and Amazon and SpaceX. So without that, that was up 25% too. So earnings have been really, really good. On the other hand, we haven't had FOMO. We haven't had fear of missing out. We haven't had investors jumping to buy stocks. So valuation multiples have actually gone down. The stock market's actually gotten cheaper since the beginning of the year as earnings have continued to grow at a faster pace and move to record highs. So when I look at the simple arithmetic of the stock market, it's PE times E. The E side is very, very strong, likely to remain strong because the economy is resilient. If the economy is doing well, earnings will do well. It's the valuation side that's a little trickier right here.
I'm thinking that if there's no recession up ahead here, and I don't think there will be one over the rest of the decade, a decade I've called the Roaring 2020s as a result, then I think we're looking at maybe a range of 17 to 20 for the multiple for earnings. And that certainly would be still consistent with a bull market. But as I said, the reason I pushed my 8,400 out to the middle of next year is because I think some of the volatility in the bond market, both domestic and global, may weigh on the valuation multiple. Having said that, we're pretty close to 7,900. I mean, we could be there in a day or two the way the markets moved.
But I still have some concerns over the rest of the year for the midterm elections. The president, Donald Trump, has said that he's going to resume bombing Iran after the midterm elections. It's possible that the Iranians will do something before the midterm elections in an effort to influence the elections, so they might start the bomb before the president starts to bomb. And so I think there's still those rather important issues that need to be clarified. So I'd still be somewhat cautious about this market. And as you know, while the market is at a record high, it's been very concentrated. There's been a lot of stocks that have not done very well. And so bond yields have gone up, and that has had consequences, that has weighed on some areas of the market.
No, I mean, we were looking at the data, and apparently some 59% of the stocks are below 20% of their all-time highs. So while the index is continuing to make all-time highs, it has been kind of a shallow rally. And what we've also noticed is, you know, the flight to safety. So Mag 7, for instance, has done well. Then if you plot the US 30-year yield with Mag 7, it's almost moving in lockstep. So people are considering, or investors are considering, companies with pricing power to be a safer bet at this point. So a narrow market rather. Yes.
Yeah, I think you're right about that. I think when people feel that they need to be more risk averse, when it's risk off, the Magnificent 7 tend to benefit. You know, some of these Magnificent 7s have done extremely well through thick and thin, through the pandemic, through tariffs and so on. And of course, they have a lot of influence with the government. So yeah, right now we have a concentrated market once again in the Magnificent 7.
Before the war broke out, we did start to see a broadening of the market. Small caps were doing well. I call them the impressive S&P 493. Take out the Magnificent 7, and you still have 493 S&P companies that have done really very well. As a matter of fact, in the third quarter earnings season that's coming up over the next few weeks, we're expecting that every single sector, all 11 sectors of the S&P 500, will show positive year-over-year earnings comparisons. So, again, we're still very much in a FIMO mode, fabulous earnings momentum.
Yes. And stock prices, after all, are slaves to earnings. So if earnings continue, I think there is, you know, some rally left in the market. But also an interesting point that you made, that you know you do not foresee a recession until the end of the decade. And I think again you've been consistently right because we've had this whole patch of 2022 where a recession was expected, but it has now turned out that the odds are shifting towards overheating of the economy rather than a recession. Any thoughts on growth being too strong or too early yet?
Back in 21, 22, 23, there was actually a bear market in 2022, and at the time I said the market is discounting the most widely anticipated recession of all times that isn't going to happen. I think I was, if I wasn't alone, there were very few of us who predicted that there would not be a recession, that the economy would be resilient. And part of that was a bet on the strength of the consumer. The retiring baby boomers would continue to spend money, and that they would help their young adult children, maybe with mortgage payments and some after-school activity fees for the grandchildren. And I see a lot of that happening. And of course we have data that shows something like 30% of young adults are still living at home. So a lot of people have been talking about the K-shaped economy.
Which I find to be, I have a problem with it. The K-shaped economy basically says the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer. It's very Marxist or at least socialist in nature. And it's a very pessimistic view that therefore the consumer can't keep this, can't go on. It's not possible that we can run an economy with fewer and fewer people doing well while everybody else is doing poorly. I've got a better way of describing the economy. I think that certainly explains why the consumer continues to spend, and that is the G-shaped economy, generational shape. It's not that the economy is doing a G. What it's doing, it's just meant to indicate that the age composition of the economy matters a great deal.
And you know, one-third of US households, we have 130 million households in America, families, people living together, people living by themselves. So there's 130 million households, and of those, one-third are headed by somebody who's 65 years or older. We have the biggest senior citizen cohort ever in American history, maybe in world history, and it's the richest ever. The baby boomers account for most of these people, and the baby boomers have a hundred trillion dollars of net worth. There's even people who are older than the baby boomers, called the silent generation, and they have $20 trillion. So again, a third of our households are basically retiring. They're seniors, and they have an enormous amount of net worth that they've accumulated over their lives. And that makes them sensitive to the stock market, not sensitive to rising interest rates. They're not sensitive to the labor market because they're retiring, and they're definitely still spending.
A lot of them have the attitude: as long as we're retired, as long as we have our health, let's enjoy life. Let's travel. Let's go out to restaurants. Let's have recreation and sports events. So there's a lot of money being spent in those areas. The cruise lines are doing extremely well. And then we've got the resilience of capital spending that we mentioned. AI is the real deal. I think it's clearly here to stay. I don't think it's going to kill us. I think that AI is really just a continuation of the digital revolution that started in the early 60s with the IBM mainframe. And the main idea of the digital revolution is it's all about processing as much data as fast as we can, as cheaply as we can. And AI certainly has been an evolution of the digital revolution. We're processing an enormous amount of data now, so much so that you can basically have a conversation with these AI models.
And I think what that means is that we've reached a point where data has a tremendous amount of value. It's basically a factor of production, and the ability to process it, to analyze it at an extraordinarily fast speed at lower and lower prices means we will find more and more data to process. So the end demand for compute is kind of like Buzz Lightyear, you know, to infinity and beyond. We're just going to have more and more data to process. And as a result of that, the demand for AI is very strong, and the hyperscalers are rushing to build more compute because they know that if they had it today, they'd be making money. So I'm watching cloud computing revenues, and cloud computing revenues, as long as they're growing at double-digit rates, I think that's confirmation that this spending on AI is paying off and will pay off in the future.
So the economy, the Roaring 2020s thesis, I first started talking about it in August of 2020. Again, it looked kind of delusional at the time. But this is the seventh year of the Roaring 2020s. Real GDP is at an all-time record high. Stock market's at an all-time record high. So I just am working on the next three years. Now, I'm not saying a recession is going to happen at the end of the decade. It could be the Roaring 2030s. I don't really want to make the analogy with the 1930s because the 1930s were absolutely horrible. The geopolitical nightmares that led to World War II occurred in the 1930s. But it doesn't have to end badly. It may very well be that the prosperity, the good times continue into the coming decade.
Some very great points there, and I'm taking the G-shaped economy with me. But sticking to demographics, we spoke about how there are more 65-plus people, they have an immense amount of wealth, and the consumption for them is rather sticky. But do you, and I wanted to pick your view on it, do you buy the argument that sometime in the future, nothing is seen in numbers today, AI can be detrimental to job growth? I think at the start AI is adding to job growth, so we don't see a problem as we speak, and I think it's a problem maybe a decade later, but do you see one?
Well, you know, Elon Musk clearly has been at the forefront of bringing the future into today's reality. You know, 10, 20, 30 years ago, we were all watching movies like The Terminator, and it was all science fiction. We were watching movies about humanoid robots, and it was all science fiction. But it's not science fiction anymore, and now we're dealing with the future. And some of those science fiction movies, I guess science fiction movies are always frightening. So not surprising that now that the future is here, which was the subject of these movies, there's a lot of fright about where this is all taking us. And one of the concerns, well, of course, the new concern is it'll kill us. Can't think of anything worse than that. But the other concern is that we're all going to lose our jobs.
If we accept that as a possible scenario, then I suppose we'll be going to universal basic income. In other words, factories will be operating 24 by 7. There won't be any lights, there's no bathrooms, there's no lunch breaks. Everything, all goods will be manufactured in abundance. Elon Musk keeps saying the future will be of abundant prosperity, everything will be available. And I guess the same thing will happen for services. Services will be automated and be delivered more efficiently. So if none of us have jobs, we'll have to tax the owners of these companies and pay a universal basic income so that the rest of us can have a reasonable standard of living. I mean, they need us to be able to spend money, because if they make all these goods and services with robotics and humanoids, then who's going to buy all these things? So that's sort of an extreme outlook that some technology people have been talking about.
I guess a historical analogy, it's not a great analogy, but the Romans, when they conquered people around the Mediterranean, they took a lot of them as slaves, and slaves did most of the work, maybe all the work in Rome. And so I guess they had a lot of time for parties and for entertaining and for writing poetry and so on. So it's not a terrible life. But I don't think we're going to see AI eliminate jobs. I think we're going to find that it actually creates more jobs. We're all going to have to learn how to be prompters, how to use these languages to do some of the things we do routinely.
But I think we're still going to find that, I don't believe that we're going to have super intelligence. I think we're still going to be more intelligent than AI. And we'll be intelligent enough so that we can always pull the plug on the electricity. So if AI becomes too dangerous.
No, fantastic. But do you think in a way this has questioned the hypothesis of demographic dividend per se, because now it might, I mean, having more young people who would find it hard to find employment, especially in the emerging markets where UBI would be hard to implement, it's not a dividend anymore. And that also questions the whole thesis of end of US exceptionalism in a way. I think both of them come under question because US exceptionalism can then continue for way longer than people had thought.