The countdown is on, everything you need to get the edge at the end of the market day, this is "The Close." Live from Studio 2A, Bloomberg headquarters in New York, I'm Kailey Leinz. Romaine Bostick is on special assignment in Detroit for the midterm elections. Michigan, a key battleground state in determining the balance of power in Congress. We are kicking you off to the closing bell. Romaine, markets are watching the results of tomorrow's election and some shocking developments in Michigan could influence that. Where do we stand?
Yes, Michigan, for better or worse, has become a proxy for a lot of the national and international issues. Abdul El-Sayed has really become the avatar, both good and bad, for a lot of the issues we are talking about nationally. Here on the ground, when you talk to voters, it is much more about some of the pocketbook issues and the kitchen table issues, and this really came to the forefront yesterday afternoon when a surprise announcement by Representative Haley Stevens, who had run against Abdul El-Sayed in the primary. She said she would endorse Abdul El-Sayed and then decided yesterday she would endorse his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers.
It was a very dramatic setting at a local church in Detroit, and a gathering a lot of people thought might be a way for El-Sayed and Stevens to hash out some of their issues they have had since that very contentious primary. But Stevens making it very clear that some of her concerns about El-Sayed's comments and, more importantly, lack of support in her view on Israel and some of the issues that are important to Jewish voters, that swayed her more into the Mike Rogers campaign. El-Sayed made it very clear he thought this was all just a distraction, and he is much more focused on affordability and some of the economic issues he says are actually going to decide the election tomorrow.
If you look at the latest New York Times/Siena poll, it would indicate that El-Sayed is up 11 points. Is the feeling on the ground in Michigan that those numbers may be real, considering how under-polled he was in the primary?
Like anything, it depends on who you ask. A lot of the Democrats feel very galvanized; they feel like the momentum is on their side. Republican operatives point out some of the flaws in that polling, the idea that the response rate tends to be higher for registered Democrats than registered Republicans, and that can sort of skew what we see heading into the actual official results we will get on Tuesday night. I haven't had a chance to talk with the Rogers campaign, but I did speak with some of their surrogates, and they say Rogers, despite some of the focus on the national and international issues, they say Rogers has communicated a much more coherent plan on the affordability issues. And I spoke with the Detroit Chamber of Commerce and the PAC for that Chamber of Commerce that endorsed Mike Rogers, and they said a big part of the reason is even if Congress does flip in favor of the Democrats, the president, a Republican, will still be there another two years, and they feel they want to have somebody representing Michiganders who can speak and appeal to President Trump.
We will be getting back to you through the hour. The markets just shy of one hour until the closing bell, and I can say it is a better day than Friday was, but that is not saying much since stocks come off their worst day since June. The S&P is flat, having deteriorated through the session due to weakness in technology and chip stocks in particular. Apple down about 1.8% coming after the closing bell. What is happening in the markets today is to some degree being influenced by the downward pressure we are seeing in oil. Optimism around diplomacy prevailing when it comes to the U.S. and Iran sending Brent down to the 104 level. Yields moving lower by about four basis points. We kick things off now with the head of investment strategy. When you look at what has happened in the market over the course of the last few weeks, the rotation we are seeing to have evidence more so up today, is that healthy? When do we cross the line of it being potentially unhealthy? It has come from tech and AI optimism in particular.
The move we saw last week was pretty fast and furious. An outsized move, not always the sign of a healthy market. The signs of a healthy market are: one, we are seeing this rotation. It is not investors wholesale leaving the market; it is investors rotating into parts of the market that could benefit potentially from what we are seeing today, more cyclical parts of the market and value parts of the market. To us, that's a good sign that investors have not given up on the broader equity trade. They may be rotating under the surface. The other part of the story we are watching closely, of course, is: is the tech-AI healthy bull market coming to some sort of close? This is where we would say probably not yet. Last week's earnings did provide a surprise that free cash flow in a lot of the megacap tech names have come down. That is something markets and investors don't want to see. A healthy cloud business and a growth in the revenue streams.
It will be interesting to see how Apple is the inverse of that story tonight. You mentioned lower oil prices. President Trump just told reporters, according to a pool report, that he says no to striking Iran after the elections. Is there any kind of geopolitical premium still in these markets? It feels like by and large we have moved on. Do you think this market would react if there were a return to kinetic activity in the days to come?
Oil prices prior to the Iran war were hovering around $50 or $60, so we have moved from elevated prices back toward $100 a barrel. If we start to see a meaningful resolution, and we have seen many fits and starts, but if we see meaningful progress and a path to stability, that could potentially bring oil prices heading back toward pre-war. Many economies have ramped up reserves. Many looking for alternative supply chains. The supply of oil prior to the war was actually far outpacing the demand for oil. If we can get back to any semblance of that environment, we think markets have not yet priced that, so we could see meaningful moves, and we could see those in lower oil prices or bond yields.
What about domestic politics? To what extent do the outcomes of the midterms matter, whether it is status quo or divided government or potentially a Democratic wave? How does it make a material difference in terms of investment strategy, portfolio?
When you think about midterm elections in a broader seasonality, history is on your side. Since 1950, it has been higher with a 100% hit rate. We will see if history repeats itself, but given the volatility we are seeing, could we see historically kind of seasonal patterns as we head into the new year, perhaps? The midterm elections is a clearing event. Markets don't like uncertainty. We will move past that uncertainty. In markets, to some extent, we welcome gridlock. It means less chance for new regulation, new legislation, maybe a bit more operating transparency for corporations, which is a good thing. We are hopeful this combination of a reset in valuations on the tech side, plus healthy seasonality and a healthy clearing event after midterms, does set investors up nicely for potentially a better year-end.
Mona Mahajan, thank you so much. Coming up, we will assess the economic puzzle pieces in play with Gene Sperling, advisor to the Biden, Obama, and Clinton presidencies, and the only person to serve as National Economic Council Director under two presidents. This is Bloomberg.
Economic issues are a top priority for voters across the country, including in Michigan, a key battleground state. Let's get back to Romaine Bostick on the ground in Detroit, who just sat down with the city's regional chamber president.
Yes, Sandy, who used to be the Small Business Administrator during the George W. Bush administration, now leading the Detroit Regional Chamber, a chamber that has officially endorsed Mike Rogers in that Senate race against Abdul El-Sayed. He cited several factors, including Michigan being "on fire," and that is not a compliment. On several key economic measures, Michigan continues to slip and now ranks near the bottom of the 50 U.S. states, and he thinks Rogers might be the solution to turning that around.
Well, certainly Michigan has become one of the epicenters across the country to be the barometer for what is going to happen in 24 hours here. Everyone is going to the polls for really the same reasons. It is the state of the economy, related to that is affordability, and it is particularly pronounced in the state of Michigan because the impact on Michigan businesses and Michigan consumers is so much more pronounced with the trade policies we are grappling with right now.
Talk about those trade policies, whether it is tariff issues, whether it is other policies that have come out of Washington that have altered this landscape in some ways for the better.
I would say three things quickly. The most impactful thing is the deteriorating relationship with our friends in Canada. We are basically one region when it comes to manufacturing and automotive. We are not used to these kinds of tensions and the ill will, so that is number one. We are the international trade state, so tariffs. Whichever way they are levied or however they are needed, those tariffs are having an outsized impact on Michiganders. The average impact of tariffs across the country is roughly $2,000 per person, and in Michigan it is $6,000 per person, so a huge negative impact. The last thing I would say, on the positive side, is that some of the regulatory relief we have seen come out of the Trump administration, especially out of automotive and manufacturing, we are very thankful for. There has been a lot of discordant regulations. Department A says X and Department B says Q, and they are just not aligned. They have done a lot of cleanup.
When you talk to businesses on the manufacturing side, have they expressed any sort of hope that there might be a light at the end of the tunnel on tariffs?
Well, yes, certainty and stability is what all kinds of businesses need, especially capital-intensive businesses, which is what we specialize in here in Michigan.
If the Democrats take control of one house or both chambers on Tuesday, which is looking more and more likely, will that moderate some of the decisions that the Trump administration wants to take?
I don't know about that because it could actually lead to more chaos. Donald Trump is a fighter. He likes to fight. He likes to have a foil. Having a Democratic Congress will be a perfect foil for him. And a lot of what he has done on trade policy has not gone through the Congress. He has done it through executive order and cabinet agencies. I don't know if Congress will be in a position to take back control of trade policy, which is their rightful right.
When we talk about why people are going to the polls, I drove around this area yesterday talking about it, and it was all about affordability: the price of groceries, the price of insurance, the price of gas. The Detroit Chamber PAC endorsed Mike Rogers against Abdul El-Sayed, who has made it his focus more on affordability than some of the other proposals that have been put out there. Why did you choose to endorse Mike Rogers?
First of all, we are talking about stability and judgment, and that is what Mike Rogers brings. He's the adult in the room. Donald Trump will be our president the next two years. We don't need someone just howling at the moon. I have met Dr. El-Sayed. He is actually an incredibly charming person, but when we looked at the experience, when we looked at the judgment, when we looked at what the policies were, Mike Rogers was an easy, breezy case. And also, El-Sayed never even accepted our offer to sit down with him. He just kind of ignored it.
He has not reported back to us why he snubbed our invitation.
I'm curious if there was an off chance that he were to actually win the Senate race, in theory the business community would have to work with him. Is there a relationship between the broader Detroit business community and the El-Sayed campaign?
Certainly, I would say it is very limited. The business community, obviously not unanimously, but the business community across the state of Michigan is incredibly behind Mike Rogers. When I was serving in Washington, I knew him when he was a congressman and I was working for President Bush. Great guy, solid guy. We will have to build a relationship with Senator El-Sayed, and we wish him nothing but the best if he is our senator.
Thanks to our own Romaine Bostick and Sandy Baruah, president of the Detroit Regional Chamber. We will have more coming up. This is "The Close" on Bloomberg.
Let's get back to Romaine Bostick out in Michigan, who joins us with another interview from a Detroit stakeholder in this election.
Yes, we are broadcasting right now from the North Rosedale Park neighborhood, sort of an upper-middle-class neighborhood. Just across the street, Congresswoman Tlaib keeps her home. I had a chance to catch up with the North Rosedale Park Civic Association, and I asked him about a lot of the development you see in the downtown areas, but a few miles north of where we are right now, has that reached the community here?
Here in Detroit, to get it done, it comes from that governance that they have to make that push to lower those rates. So that is why that governor race is very popular and big for the community.
What are the concerns you have primarily heard from residents overall about what they want to see improved, and more importantly, what they think the politicians running can actually do to facilitate it?
For our community, we have more senior citizens. Price, health care, those who are not working anymore. It is some of the things they are looking for. Gas prices, groceries, even though they are senior citizens, they still have their grandchildren. That is something everyone is talking about, to see how those things are lowered.
There has been a lot of talk about the economic revitalization of downtown. Can you assess how much progress has been made and how widespread have the benefits actually been?
We have a lot of benefits. Downtown is booming. Residents do feel that they are building up downtown, but it is not coming into the local neighborhoods. This is one of the oldest neighborhoods around. We hold a lot of weight when it comes to voting, and we want to see more things done in the community when it helps our schools to bring businesses like that along with jobs.
You mentioned the average age of the population, and there has been a lot of talk about why folks don't stay. What type of jobs do you think would keep some of those younger people tethered here rather than going elsewhere?
I would say tech jobs, things when it comes to film, the film industry, because a lot of my friends moved to L.A. and then moved to Atlanta where all those jobs are popular, where you have so many opportunities. And here in Detroit or the Midwest period, you don't really have those options to really find livable wages doing those careers.
When people see some of the broader national issues or even international issues, are they focused on those things? Foreign policies or tariffs or trade, etc.?
Yes, I would say we have a lot of people in this community that foreign policy and wars take their family members away from home. So they really look deep into it because they are pulling their loved ones away to defend our nation, and some people may or may not agree with why they are defending their nation.
How do you rate the new mayor so far?
She has done an excellent job. She has brought many programs to this building that has helped the community out, along with so many programs that have brought the youth together, that was being able to pull the youth off the streets in the summertime. Just talking community and giving a heads up on what her future looks like.
Thanks to Romaine Bostick and Eric Henry. Let's take another look at the markets as we inch closer to the closing bells. It is a mixed day. You have the Dow up. Underperformance once again for tech stocks with the Nasdaq 100 down. The S&P down. Ending Friday, seeing a little bit of steam come off, down about 2% ahead of its results. Some steam coming out of the oil markets as well. Both President Trump and JD Vance cast some hope toward diplomacy as Trump told reporters he's not considering resuming strikes against Iran, and JD Vance says he feels good about the prospects. That has Brent down at $104 a barrel and yields moving lower today as well. Still ahead, we will have more on the economic needle-movers in the midterms and beyond. Gene Sperling, the former director of the National Economic Council, joins us live on "The Close" on Bloomberg.
Affordability is front and center for voters, and our next guest is the only person to serve under two presidents and a key advisor to Biden, Clinton, and Obama. Gene Sperling, now president of Sperling Economic Strategies, joins us now. It's great to have you on Bloomberg on the eve of these midterm elections. We hear this affordability messaging hammered by Democrats repeatedly. They want to attain one or both majorities in Congress basically on the back of a promise to address it. What actual policy changes will need to happen for them to be able to follow through?
The two most clear things that have negatively affected the cost of living have been somewhat unpredictable and not always coherent tariff policy, together with really a deep mishandling of the Strait of Hormuz related to conflict in the Middle East. That is one of the things that has been difficult. As you say, I've worked for lots of presidents, and you get used to the idea that if gas prices go up, you get blamed whether you had anything to do with it or not. Same with inflation. Here, you have two policies that are signature policies of this president, where he has gone out and boasted about them, talked about them, often recognized in advance that prices were going to go up, so people do see a direct causal connection, and that makes things difficult not just for the president's approval number, but for the people running. And I think what is missing right now is looking like he's waking up every day focused like a laser beam on getting those prices down. And often looks like almost everything else is taking priority, and that is a tough situation for Republicans to be going into a midterm, which are always tough for the party in power.
And when we think about what can drive prices down, the Fed would like to see prices go down as well. They just have a blunt instrument in trying to do that, in the form of potentially raising interest rates even higher. Given the sources of price pressure that you were talking about here, including an energy shock, is that the right mechanism? Would that have the desired effect, or does it have to come from more fiscal-oriented policy?
I think you are asking a great question, and one that troubles me as well, which is the Fed, I think, believes that they have to send a signal to the market. They are not content to have 3.6% headline inflation or 3% core inflation and have it continually going up. And they are saying that the gas price increase, instead of being a temporary issue that the Fed looks through and sees as temporary, now is part of a rise in overall geopolitical risks, and they have to show that they are confronting that. But yes, I think it is a difficult situation for the Fed, because the issues that affect you, even some of the demand for hyperscalers, data construction, it's not as clear how interest-rate sensitive any of those things are. So I think the Fed may have no choice but to raise one or two more times. I think you are right to ask how effective will that be, and it really gets back to how important it is to figure out a way to not just get out of this war, but in a way that brings more stability to the Strait of Hormuz and reduces the significant degree of geopolitical risk in energy markets that come not just from the Strait, but from damaged infrastructure, low reserves, low refinery, things that the Fed is no longer able to say that is just a blip, we should look through it.
I'm glad you raised the hyperscalers as well, because this market is having a reckoning right now with whether or not there will be a turn on the massive capital expenditures we are seeing into this space. How much does the U.S. economy need that return to materialize and the boom to keep booming? How much is it being held up by the data center boom we are seeing?
If you look at the GDP numbers, there's just no question that the best thing for GDP is the fact that there's been this extraordinary investment in AI and data centers. It's a tough one because, as we've seen, there's been both Republican and Democrat backlash, and they help some particular job categories like electricians, but it's probably something that a lot of people [are concerned about] with interest rates. They are seeing their mortgage rates go up. So there's no doubt it's been critical to GDP growth, and I think it's been the most consistent driver. If you look at the GDP numbers, consumer spending was up, but it wasn't pretty. Like 30% of the increase was in energy and gas prices, and there's a lot of proof that that came from people withdrawing from their savings. So consumer spending that is coming from paying more for gas prices and running out of savings is not the most pretty example of robust consumer spending.
Gene Sperling, thanks so much for joining. And we will have more on affordability pressures from the ground in Michigan. We will hear live from Anika Goss, CEO of Detroit Future City. This is "The Close" on Bloomberg.
Affordability is as much a state and local issue as a national one. Let's get back to Romaine Bostick, who is on the ground in Detroit, Michigan. Romaine?
I'm here with the CEO of Detroit Future City, as well as a member of the Federal Reserve Board of Chicago and the Bank of Indianapolis. We were also on Governor Whitmer's Growing Michigan Together program, and I think that's where I want to start here. We talk about growth. Is Detroit growing?
Detroit is technically growing by the numbers, so we [have seen growth over the last few] years. I think the challenge is that it's not growing at the rate it should be, and we are only really seeing the growth in new immigrants, which is what is tracking over time. Instead of what we would like to see is new immigrants and middle-class households, families, young people moving to Detroit and in the region, we are seeing less of that.
Explain how you actually get that back. Anyone who walks around downtown Detroit, you see prosperity. You see a downtown area that has been built back up to something glorious. Does that reach out to the communities, particularly the middle-class communities?
Not at the rate that we would like to, but all of this is also very new. It took us 50 years to get to the point where we were, and so this new investment that we're seeing is really just within the last five to 10 years. So it will take some time for Detroit to really adjust. Now, Detroit is a city of 136 square miles, it is huge. There are roughly 700,000 people that live in Detroit right now. We very likely will not get back up to the 2 million number that we once were. We might be able to get back up to something toward 1 million, but I feel like that is part of that challenge right now.
Any city, but in order to get that population back up, you need jobs. There is a kid who is 16, 17, 18 who will graduate high school, maybe go to college. What assurances can you give him or her that there will be meaningful, gainful employment in the state of Michigan?
Unemployment is actually down in Detroit and in the region. The issue isn't if there is a job available, I think it is what kind of job, and are Detroiters even prepared for the jobs of the future? A lot of the jobs of the future are in new sectors like tech and advanced manufacturing, health and [life sciences]. It's not the same jobs that you might see across the country, and even in other areas, the entire industry of entertainment and the industry of finance, those are areas that we still really need to invest in in order to produce those kinds of jobs.
Seeing the potential for creating about 20,000 tech jobs and billions of dollars in economic activity, what do you have to put into that to get the final product?
Some of it is really positioning the labor talent pool and the entrepreneurship talent pool as an investable unit to actually build an industry. And economic development is not local, it's actually regional. So once we begin really thinking about our entire region as a place of opportunity for tech, and Detroit being at that hub, that is really where we can begin to make those kinds of investments across a broad spectrum of tech. So then you can really see some of the yielding results of a new industry.
There's been argument that on the tech side you can build off effectively what the auto industry had for years, even though a lot of the manufacturing is gone. There is a technological know-how that went into that which can be extrapolated into other industries. Is that true?
I think so. There are certainly significant aspects for advanced manufacturing and from traditional manufacturing that would lend itself to tech. I feel like Detroit has always been at the cutting edge of tech because we've been a national leader in manufacturing and particularly in auto manufacturing. Being able to then translate those skills into other forms of tech, that is the challenge and also the opportunity. How do we provide that early education to the young people you are talking about to get them to think about those spaces?
Are you hopeful we will get there soon?
I think so. We are beginning to see new investment and new industry. Yes, it gravitates downtown because that is where the momentum is, but I think we are quickly going to begin to see the larger talent pool in and around the entire city.
Anika, thank you. Detroit's progress has been fascinating to watch from afar, and it is great to be here with you, CEO of Detroit Future City.
Thanks to Romaine Bostick and Anika Goss live in Michigan. Coming up, the closing bells with Andrew Slimmon, Morgan Stanley Investment Management senior portfolio manager.
The move we saw last week was fast and furious. An outsized move, not always the sign of a healthy market, though more broadly, signs of a healthy market we are seeing, as you noted, rotation. Not investors wholesale leaving the market, but rotating out of the tech and AI sectors into parts of the market that could benefit from what we are seeing today.
That was from Edward Jones kicking off the show today, talking about the rotation last week, rotation we are still seeing evidence of as we approach the closing bell. The cyclicals outperforming. The Dow up 300 points or so. Tech stocks under pressure. The Nasdaq 100 down one percentage point. Semiconductors on the worst three-day stretch going back to May last year, and S&P 500 deteriorating, down 0.4%. The question as to what extent Apple will be deciding the direction of travel tomorrow after it reports after the bell, it is down 2%. As Trump posted on Truth Social that a settlement could happen with Iran, optimism of diplomacy a factor, oil back down from $104 a barrel on Brent, driving yields lower with the 10-year down to 4.89%. For more market analysis, we welcome Andrew Slimmon from Morgan Stanley Investment Management. Great to have you. As you watch what is playing out, the rush into safer areas away from growth, is that a train you want to chase, or are you seeing buying opportunities created in the tech space?
I would not chase a trade. If I had sat down with you in late September, here is what the playbook says to do in October: it is rotate out of tech, rotate out of higher-beta stocks, and buy safety. That always works in October leading up to a midterm. That is exactly what happened. The playbook has played out consistently. What happens after the midterm is the trade fades and the market takes a deep sigh of relief about politics and gets back to what drives stocks, which is earnings. That is when tech tends to come back. The playbook worked out perfectly in October. I see no reason why we will not have a re-rotation back in November because I see some very stretched trades in terms of staples, healthcare on the upside, and tech on the downside.
I hear you on historical precedent and patterns, but I dare to ask if this time might be different, in that it is the first midterm cycle where we had such strong rhetorical pushback around AI, data centers, the very things powering this economy and a good deal of what is happening in the markets. Do you not see the risk from a legislative, regulatory perspective? Could there be structural barriers to allow this trade to recover to the extent you think it will?
We have to see. However, here is a counterargument. When these politicians who have voiced against data centers either get elected or re-elected, now the running campaign is over, now they are sitting in the mayor's office and looking at their finances, on how they will finance all this spending, whether it is local, state, federal. Mr. Moneybags shows up and says, 'I want to build a data center in your community, or I will take my money elsewhere.' I think this issue is going to die and be very silently going away. It may not be tomorrow or next week, but I think it will be too tempting. Where is the money? It will be too tempting to take the money.
As you refer to the hyperscalers as moneybags, that is a concern the markets have had, that eventually the investments they are making, all this capex, will either have to be met with demand and perhaps quickly, or risk backfiring. Which is why we will pay so much attention to Apple just about half an hour from now, because it is a different story. They have been more conservative on [capex]. They have the cash flow and have been seen as an area of safety. Where do you come down on the narrative, whether there are bubbleistic tendencies, and overdoing it as we see more tech companies coming to the markets with plans for issuance, even equity issuance? Is there risk?
Sure, the risk is the over-levered ones, and we have seen this. Some of the worst performing of the AI trades are the companies with the most leverage that borrowed the most money. At a time when rates are up, I know they are down today, Fed potentially raising rates, it is a dangerous concoction. As it pertains to a portion of the portfolio in AI stocks, you want to make sure you don't have it overly levered. If you listen to the reports so far, the cloud business, there is no sign demand for cloud services is going down. What has hurt these big hyperscalers, there are other businesses. Some of their other businesses, AI is nipping at their heels. That is the first thing. Two, the lesson we learned from all this is, spending a lot of your cash flow to capex, the market doesn't like. If you show signs of spending slowing, the market has rewarded that. The market continues to reward companies buying back stock. These large hyperscalers that have halted buybacks, issuing stocks, they are the ones being penalized. But I don't think you can point and say the demand is slowing.
Do you expect the demand deterioration could materialize if we see ourselves faced with an even higher interest rate environment? You were alluding that rates could move higher if the Fed hikes again. Are we going to potentially see more interest rate sensitivity?
I look back, I was in business in the 90s, and I remember when the internet came along and Wall Street threw cash at anyone with any remote game plan on how to produce an internet company. Now there are a lot of questions about leverage and how much credit and so forth. That could slow the buildout of the data centers. But, as I'm sure you can attest, we are all using these services more and more for more complicated requests, and that requires more token usage. I would argue that the supply being constrained but demand going up could extend that scarcity of power even further versus in the 90s when there was just too much supply, too successful.
I alluded to this, the president posted on Truth Social about a potential settlement between Iran. He said Iran wants settlement as soon as possible. I would caveat we have heard of a settlement before. But how are you thinking of geopolitical risk? It is one thing for the markets to get through the midterms, know about the balance of power in Washington and domestic policy, but do you see the need to price in a geopolitical risk premium with potentially more elevated oil prices?
Excellent question, because what you're really asking me is, how will that impact the Fed's decision? This is the story of this year I don't think people get right. Earnings have been very strong. At the beginning of the year the earnings estimate was for earnings growth 11% with the S&P. We are now up over 30%. In theory the market should be doing great, up 20%, 30% for the year. But we are not because it is not about earnings. It is about the valuation, what you pay for those earnings. Rates have gone up, the Fed has pivoted from on hold to raising rates, and that brought the multiple down from 21 times to 18. If you tell me oil is heading lower because we will have a resolution, the market will say [that is] very strong. But if inflation remains persistent, then you can look back to 2016 and 2022 and see that multiples drop even further.
Andrew, stick with us. The closing bells are ringing. The first day of the trading week with the Dow rising some 260 points, but [the market] lower. The S&P just around 7500, down 0.5% on the day. Some of the serious underperformance coming once again from semiconductors, which closed out their worst three days going back to May of last year. A little bit of pressure downward for small caps at the Russell 2000, which closed lower by about two-tenths of 1%. When you look beneath the surface, that underperformance obviously coming more so from technology. There were actually more sectors that were higher, in the form of consumer discretionary, materials, even a little the financials. The biggest underperformer was energy, that falling around 4% due to the drop in oil prices, and that of course contributed to the moves lower in yields. Some of it energy-driven, at least on the curve. Let's get back for a final note to Andrew Slimmon of Morgan Stanley. We obviously saw the rotation in play once again today. He said he wouldn't be a chaser of that. You see buying opportunities coming in tech. What would make you more nervous than what we are seeing is not a healthy rotation, but that in fact something potentially within the tech and AI trade is wrong? What would be the signal that would make you think otherwise?