Welcome to TMZ Live. There was an earthquake, a political earthquake in Michigan over the weekend when Haley Stevens defected in the Senate race there and threw her support to Mike Rogers. What is fascinating and perplexing about this is 8 hours before she did this, she was on the phone with people in the Democrat party telling them that she was going to support Abdul El-Sayed and even show up to his event yesterday, Sunday. So the question: what happened between midnight when she was talking with Debbie Dingell, the congresswoman from Michigan, and others? What happened between midnight and 8 in the morning that radically changed her mind? There is a lot here that doesn't make sense and I think it is underscored by her appearance last night on CNN.
Back in August, you posted on social media, quote, "Mike Rogers will be another rubber stamp for Donald Trump's dangerous agenda. We can't afford to give MAGA another Senate seat in November." Why is it okay now? Why can you afford now to give MAGA another Senate seat in November?
Well, why is it okay to have the Democratic party and a top nominee, you know, injecting this type of anger and lack of kindness? That's all. I'm one Democrat. Okay. So I just am telling people how I'm voting and there's others who feel the same way, you know, the anger and lack of kindness. I'm sorry. I don't want to talk over you. The anger and lack of kindness. No, it sounds like you're upset with me too, Anderson.
No, I'm not. I'm just, you're not really answering any of my questions. So it's somewhat frustrating.
So, look, she was disinvited to Abdul El-Sayed's church service and she seemed to take umbrage over that. And now the question is, Haley Stevens, did she change her vote because she was slighted by people in the El-Sayed camp? Did she change her view because of the ad, the anti-Semitic ad that he would not disavow, although he did disavow it Saturday, or is there something else at play? So I got to say, I am perplexed by it, especially because we had Haley on our TMZ Live as well as her fiance, Jason Turcotte, and she seemed squarely in El-Sayed's camp. What changed? Let's bring in one of my favorite people, Liz Smith, who is a Democratic strategist. Liz, I do not understand this except to say I don't think she's saying what actually is going on.
Yeah, I think you sort of hit the nail on the head there, Harvey, in your analysis that this is personal grievance masquerading as political principle. And I'm all for people taking principled stances and going with their conscience, right? But the time to do that was two months ago when the primary ended, or even before then, to say I can't support him for all these reasons. But instead, for the last two months, she's been a wholehearted endorser of his. And as you mentioned on TMZ Live, she talked about all the reasons why she was supporting him. So it is very hard not to see this as born of personal grievance rather than conscience.
So if it was personal grievance, she could have come out earlier. If it's because she was disinvited, I mean, listen, I got to tell you, to me it reminds me of the 50s and 60s when somebody brought a meatloaf over in Tupperware and the neighbor didn't return the Tupperware and it caused a neighborhood war. It's like she wasn't invited to the church service. It just doesn't hold water to me that that's the reason she would not only say I'm not supporting him, but that I'm voting for Mike Rogers. It just doesn't make sense to me.
Just because someone is in politics, or maybe because they are in politics, it doesn't mean they're a rational actor. And it's hard to see any other precipitating event here other than her being disinvited from the church service. Now, I'm not inside her head. I'm not talking with her. I'm not talking with her fiance, but if you look at her comments on CNN last night, she talked about a lack of kindness. She spoke to the Free Press today and she said that she felt excluded by AOC and others. I think that's part of what's behind this. And let me just say this: campaigns are really hard. They are really exhausting and this primary was a very emotionally taxing primary for everyone involved. We're two days out from the election and this is the time when people, you know, they get a little feral and I think that some of the exhaustion here, some of the adrenaline is probably behind that.
See, I'm sorry, I'm just not buying it. The primary was in June, you have July, August, September, October, you know, it just doesn't make sense to me that on November 1st, you know, in the home stretch. Look, I have two theories, two other theories. One is that Haley Stevens just did not like El-Sayed because of his views on Israel and Jews and that she banked on the fact that he would never disavow that ad and that she was planning on doing this because he didn't. And when he did disavow the ad on Saturday, she needed to come up with a quick plan B. And her plan B was he disrespected me. But that's not the real reason. The real reason is her feeling over a long period of time that he, you know, talking about hurt people, hurt people, you know, talking about all sorts of things where she felt he was either anti-Israel and/or anti-Semitic.
Well, that's fair, right? And also, Harvey, you're asking me to get inside her head and I have no idea what's inside her head. And for this conversation, it might be better to have a psychologist on, honestly. But to the broader point here, I agree that it's very possible that she disagreed with his positions and his statements on Israel. But the time to speak out about that would have been a couple months ago, two months before the election, not two days before the election. Nothing in Abdul El-Sayed's positions or rhetoric materially changed between then and now. So I really do think again that this is born out of personal grievance. And another thing I would just say that I found sort of distasteful about the whole thing is, and I've seen Black leaders in Michigan call this out, is that she didn't just go out and endorse Mike Rogers. She went and she did it at a Black church. And why was she doing that? Was she having a conversation with them or was she using Black voters more as a prop? And it certainly looked like the latter.
Okay. Can I give you my second theory?
I'm here all day. You know what? This is the thing, Harvey. You had a front row seat to this. You interviewed her fiance, all of that. So I want to hear from you. I think you know a lot more about this than I do. So fire away.
Okay. It's because of that exactly what you just said. So she talks to Debbie Dingell, the congresswoman from Michigan, at around midnight, sometime around midnight, and she says, and it was a weird conversation because the way Debbie Dingell described it was not so much I'm going to keep supporting El-Sayed, it was I won't support Rogers. So it's almost like there was something going on where Debbie Dingell was worried enough not to talk about failing to support El-Sayed. It's don't support Rogers. That in itself is weird. But she was giving her word apparently at midnight that she was still going to hang with El-Sayed. At about 8 or 9 in the morning, it radically changes. So what changes between midnight and say 8 in the morning? Well, the only thing I can think of is she has a fiance who she's with who is strongly against Abdul El-Sayed who supports Mike Rogers. And they talked on TMZ Live about a divided household, but it's something that is not unique in America and they are dealing with it. And so I can tell you that my intel is that Jason Turcotte is saying that there's no way that he could influence a change like this in her, that she makes it on her own. But I'm thinking he's really strong on the Mike Rogers side and the only thing that was changing in terms of her interactions were sleep and him.
Yep. Yeah, I agree with that. And you know, Harvey, you and I both know this. People do crazy things for love, but I mean, my lord, she just threw out her political career overnight and made this endorsement that I don't even think is going to make a difference in this race. 30%, I think 31% of registered Michigan voters have already cast a vote. They expect that's going to be around half of the total turnout. And I don't know that anyone was necessarily waiting on Haley Stevens' last-minute conversion here to make up their mind. And if anything, I could actually see this backfiring because it does look so opportunistic, a grievance-y, a little bit odd, frankly. And it turns Abdul El-Sayed, who has made his whole campaign about running against the system, running against the establishment, running against the swamp, it turns him into a sympathetic figure and sort of underscores his message the whole time that there are all these people over here, Democrats, Republicans, who are, you know, working against us and I'm here to fight against them, to be a fighter for you. And so I could actually see this working out to his benefit.
Well, we will see in 24 hours. Okay. Well, thanks for going down the rabbit hole with me. Appreciate it.
No, no one else I would love to go down the rabbit hole with more. Thank you, Harvey.
Coming up, when a 74-year-old breaks up with a 25-year-old, it's just, it's really sad. Bill Belichick and Jordan Hudson, they are not only no longer together, they broke up a year ago. Be right back.
You know, when a 74-year-old breaks up with a 25-year-old, it's just, it's really sad. And that happened to Bill Belichick and Jordan Hudson. They are not only no longer together, but they broke up a year ago, which is crazy because nobody knew they broke up. We broke the story on late Friday that they have been separated. They broke up a year ago and they still interact. You see her at the games and this is shocking to me.
It is shocking. I mean, and when you talk to people, like I was talking to people this weekend, they were like, how are they broken up? Like there's all these photos, like she posted photos holding his hand in May. We got these photos of them on Nantucket. They were broken up, but they look like they're together. It's very odd, but they are broken up. And the people that we've spoken to that are around them say they are still around each other because they have businesses together. They've remained good friends.
That we are still trying to figure out. That we do not have the answer for.
Are either of them with somebody new?
Well, we have confirmed that she has started dating other people. We know for a fact that since the breakup last year, she has gone on dates with other people, has seen people romantically. For him, we don't know the answer to that, but I have a feeling that he might have called this off. Why would Jordan call this off? I don't know.
Well, why would Jordan call this off? I mean, she's got a nice life with him.
She had, well, she still, but the thing is, she still has a job. Yeah, she, you know, she is still part of North Carolina now.
And so why, I mean, I get it, but it could be either of them that called it off. She could be saying maybe a 74-year-old isn't my thing.
Or, you know, but if she called it off, there's no way that she would be wanting to keep it under wraps for a year. She's dating someone new. She wouldn't want to keep it under wraps as if she's still dating. Unless she's worried that if it gets out, it's going to put her job in jeopardy because it's going to put her job in jeopardy. A lot of people, and you know this, a lot of people were pissed off that he was dating her, that they felt he was distracted, that the team wasn't doing well because of it. You know this.
Well, and also too, you point out the team. She's been going to all the football games this season even though they've been broken up. This weekend, they played the number one team in the nation and she did not go to the game and they almost won. So if they would have won and she, like, three points, they would have said it's a Kim Kardashian effect and I'm starting to think it is because they still look a lot better and we now know that Bill's been single for this whole time.
Which then is exactly the reason why she could break up but didn't want it to become public because people would start saying exactly what you're saying.
No, she definitely got dumped and asked Bill, okay, we could not be, but can you please not tell people that we've broken up yet? Can we please keep this under wraps for as long as possible?
You don't hang out with ex-boyfriends and help them carry their bikes knowing that you're going to be photographed. You want to be photographed. She's... If she wanted to do that, she wouldn't be dating other guys. She likes the clout that she gets being associated with Bill Belichick. Simple as that.
But she's still getting it. She's still part of the team.
We'll see now. We will see now. Now that we know, we will see if she still gets the same clout. It is interesting that she wasn't at the game this weekend, but she was with him at a game four days before we broke. She was just literally just there. She's doing damage control now. She knows.
I'm Chloe in Belfast. My immediate thoughts on this is this has been kept private totally as a strategic move. Kind of similar to their relationship itself. To me, whenever you see an age gap dynamic like this, it's never really because they're in love that there's something quite transactional about it. In my opinion, both of them have something mutually beneficial to it and to keep it quiet.
Well, it's possible. It's possible they were in love. Come on. I mean, it's possible. But I don't know typically that a young, beautiful woman goes for a 74-year-old man if he doesn't have wealth, connections, something beneficial. Okay, I won't take it personal.
Savannah Guthrie cried out for some information about the whereabouts of her mother's body. And it is clear from what she did this weekend that this pain is not only not going away, but it's standing in the way of Savannah Guthrie and her family continuing their lives. So she posted something from her daughter, and this is really telling. It says, "I know it might not seem like it, but I really need my mommy." And that is just heartbreaking that what she's saying is essentially my mom is not present because she's grieving. And Savannah put this on her social media. She wrote, it says so much about how I feel. The world goes on. Things appear normal as we try to keep going and be strong, especially for our young kids, but it's not and it never will be. So this is so clear. There was no event, no anniversary, but it's every single day, right? And you try to have a normal day and then the thoughts come up and they haunt you and there's nothing to be done about it. It reminds me so much of Natalee Holloway when she disappeared as a young kid. Her parents for years, I mean, I'm still sure they still do, but it just every single day they would just try to get by and they couldn't because the thoughts of this came back and without any closure at all, right? They have no idea what happened to their mother. The difference is that people see Savannah Guthrie every single day on the Today Show and that she can laugh and she can interact and it looks like her life is going on. But what she's saying is this is kind of a two-dimensional thing, television, and my real life is stalled.
I have pain inside every single day and I'm stalled and once in a while it bubbles over and she makes a public sort of comes out publicly about how much pain she's in. She's also begging somebody to come forward and she says the reward still stands for any information leading to the whereabouts of her mother and her mother presumably her mother's remains. But we have, you know, spoken with the FBI from time to time and the last contact we had was this case is cold.
In your long legal career, you ever seen anything like this before? Anything quite so mysterious where somebody just disappears without a trace?
I mean, the thing that is so weird about this is just in this new world with cameras everywhere, how it could just be nothing. And that's the craziest part of this story.
From Toronto here. I think the worst part about this is that people may not feel as empathetic as they should because of how wealthy this family is, but the reality is families across the world are missing loved ones and they're honestly no different.
They're no different. And money is not the cure to this. Money has nothing to do with it.
Coming up. So Selma Blair attacked two flight attendants and when the plane landed, she then allegedly attacked a cop. Selma has spoken out, although kind of obtusely. Be right back.
So Selma Blair is now speaking out about what happened on that chaotic flight, that Delta flight where she attacked two flight attendants and when the plane landed she then allegedly attacked a cop and somebody, a nurse at a hospital where she was taken. She has been charged in state court and there is a summons for her in federal court making it look like she is going to face criminal charges in both state and federal court that could end up where she goes to prison. Now her lawyers have said that this has to do with medicines that she either was taking or not taking in connection to her MS diagnosis. Selma has spoken out although kind of obtusely.
There is a legal matter going on and my lawyers have asked me to not say anything about that day. What I can tell you though is very simple and the truest thing I know about myself and that not one day ever have I intended to hurt or frighten anyone a day in my life. And so to the people that I disappointed, that I hurt, that I frightened, alarmed, I am so sorry.
You know, there's something in the law called mens rea. Which means intent. Yeah. To me, the key word here she said is, "I didn't intend to scare the people. I'm sorry I disappointed them." She's acknowledging that people were scared, disappointed, injured by her during this ordeal. But she's saying, "I didn't intend it." Which is entirely consistent with what her lawyer said about not taking the appropriate medication and having this adverse reaction. Now, why say anything if she's just saying exactly what was consistent with the legal team? I'm not really sure where this gets you, but there was a groundswell of people wanting to hear from Selma herself and not just hear from lawyers in a courtroom.
And I think she knew about the groundswell. And you know, it's sort of like when a bell rings, people around hear it and goes away. Her head's in the bell.
I think that's exactly right. I don't think she's harmed herself in any way. She hasn't said much, though. She hasn't said anything other than, "I didn't intend to do these things," which is what her lawyers said in open court. So whether this factors into the state court proceedings or the federal court, you know, sort of investigation will remain to be seen. The lawyer would not say you can talk about the medicines, what you weren't taking, what your condition was. The lawyer would not allow that. That's really clear. The only thing the lawyer would allow is to say there was a lack of intent, which means a lack of criminal intent. And that's actually really significant in the law. Whether people pick up on that. Look, I mean, it's significant.
My name is Colleen. I'm from Maryland. How you doing? I understand the whole concept with intent when it comes to the law. I think there's a lot that we don't know yet. But at the same time, when do we stop holding people accountable for their bad behavior? That is my position. You can explain it without justifying it. And I think that's where we've come to is we're justifying people's bad behavior with an explanation.
Well, except if she really did not have the capacity to form a decision to attack anybody and this was her actually acting out of her head, legally, you know, you got to prove she had an intent and if she was out of her head because of meds, that works in court if you can prove it.
Right. And I do agree with that and that's why I say we don't have enough information right at this point. I mean we know what they're saying. It was a medical condition. She didn't have her medication. I think that we can't form a conclusion without knowing all of the facts and we don't know all of the facts.
That's true. Her lawyers aren't letting her tell us all of the facts.
No, you're absolutely right.