Hello everybody. Happy Tuesday. Me and Chuck Nasty back for another exciting episode of TMZ Live. Um, how's everybody doing?
Hi. Hello everybody. Give us the sauce. Quattro, get out and vote.
Is that what that looks like? I never seen... Is that a... You got to fill that whole thing out. Official sample ballot. What? What's that, man? This is what a smart voter knows. That looks like an SAT.
Yeah. You go through, because if you go in there unprepared and you just walk up and you're like, 'Oh, I'm just going to vote,' there's a ton of things. You have to study before you go. You got to actually do your research.
Or you can be that person who's in the booth on your phone trying to research everything and you take like an hour in the booth. Okay. Piss off everybody who's waiting in line.
Oh, there's a line, too. You can't just do it online. No, you can't just do it online, bro. Where the... Bro, what the... [laughter] civic responsibility?
I can't vote here. I can't vote here. I can't do anything here. So, I mean, since I've been eligible enough to vote, I can't vote here.
You're all, you know, you're new to LA, so I didn't expect you voted here. Did you vote back home?
Well, see, my mom sent it to me and then I lost it, so I don't... [laughter] I like moved to a new house and stuff. So, it's like, and she did the same thing. She's like, 'I did mail-in, but I think I messed it up.' Yeah. So, I mean, like, and I, you know, I would know what to do with it when I get it, you know?
Denver's in good hands, man. They don't need me. Yeah. [laughter] Yep. They make it too hard, man.
See this? See, I got to have an SAT book to freaking vote. Are we kidding? You know what I'm saying? Like, what happened to like maybe a little chart, a little fun chart or something, you know? It's kind of like comparing, compare and contrast. Yeah. Make little... Yeah. Like, see, that'd be good.
I'm so disappointed right now. See, like, I just need them to like sit in front of a camera and just tell me like, 'Hey, this is what I do.' Good. This is what I... This is, you know, and then the other person can do that, too. And then I can decide what... I don't even know where to watch. I don't have cable. I don't know where to watch. What about... I want to hear the chat, but where do I watch that?
I hope they're calling you out.
Um, now they're saying they voted. Did I do my mail-in? I did not do my mail-in. Sorry. Sorry. [laughter] Didn't come. It didn't come. I don't know where it's at. I don't know.
No, no. It came, but then you lost it.
No, no, no, no. So, like, I don't know if it's at my... I didn't see it in my new house, and the people that were at my old house... Actually, I haven't been over there because I didn't... It's kind of far. So, I didn't... Yeah. But then I got to get like a new license. There's a lot of things. There's a lot of factors.
Listen, I understand that you wouldn't be able to vote here yet, but see, wouldn't that make more sense? I could do it online. It's like, all right, let me log into my voter registration account and go vote online, and then I could just vote and you'd feel secure with that.
I mean, is it any more or less secure than a FedEx truck taking my ballot back? Colorado... Packages get stolen all the time. Stuff gets... you don't send FedEx. Where would I sign? UPS. Yes. Just regular mail.
Okay. The US Postal Service is equipped to handle mail.
Like, you know what I'm saying? Like, how is one less or more secure than the other? You know, this is archaic. What are we like, what we're doing? There's like, come on. We've advanced as a people, you know? See, I mean, there's probably some locked-down, secure government websites we can use. You know what I'm saying? You got to put your social security in. Then we good, right? Am I [laughter] am I tripping? Like, I feel like this is... just get out and vote.
Okay. I mean, they're saying they're getting out and vote, but I know you guys agree with me. Good. Thank you guys. Don't be... It's my civic duty. I get that.
You know what? It's always good to have an example of what not to do so people can understand. Here's... I love you, but... together guys to do. Here's what not to do.
I ain't reading all that. I ain't reading all that.
But all this stuff is going to affect you. So, all this stuff that you don't want to read about...
What in there? What in there is going to directly affect me? Like, let me just... you know, not even on anything sarcastic. Like, for me, a 23-year-old living in California, what is in there?
Um, here's one that's most likely going to affect you. Who's going to be superior court judge in office number 64? Because I guarantee you're going to end up in front of a judge.
You're going to end up in front of a judge. You might want to have a say in... Oh, who's going to be the sheriff? The sheriff. You be the sheriff in LA County. Well, you're not voting in LA County. So, let me go past the county.
So, yeah. So far nothing is really...
None of this affects you because you're voting in Colorado.
But like... Okay, but like, I live here. So...
You're registered to vote in Colorado.
Eventually, I'll do it over here. But like... um... See, I wouldn't read all that stuff either. Dwan. Exactly. That's what I'm saying. Do you want... That's what I'm saying.
But you're not helping our gin.
No, but I mean like, but I'm saying like, there are so many better ways to do that. Are you kidding? Like, this is archaic. This is old.
What are you talking about?
This might as well be written on some stone tablets.
This is just information for you to look at so that when you go to the ballot, you're actually prepared.
Like, you're telling me there's not a better way to do it than reading the SAT? Like, I already took that.
At some point you do have to read. Yes.
Well, I can read, but I'm saying like, but why wouldn't they make it easier?
You don't have to do it here. You can go online. You can go online. And there's a thing you can go online and say, 'I'm voting in LA County, California.' Yes. And it will give you your ballot. And you can look at it online if you prefer. And it would show you who's running for what. Give you a little blurb about each person. Okay. It can tell you about the state measures like things like, 'Do you want billionaires to pay a 5% tax?' Yeah. Okay. Well, you need to know which measure that is and you need to know what you need to vote on that.
But okay, but my point being because I agree. I need to register. I need to do that.
That stuff will affect you.
Because it can affect health care.
There's a lot of things going on right now, you know. There's a lot of stuff. Yeah. Um, I'm just a boy, you know. So, um... but do you not agree that this is archaic? This is too old. There's way easier ways that this can be done because what you're standing... what it sounds like right now.
Well, you keep saying archaic because it's a piece of paper in my hand.
No, no, I'm saying that feels archaic. No, I'm saying like, there is too much information condensed into one little thing. Like, I need... it's like... Thank you. Then I need somebody, you know, there's like, I understand there's debates and stuff, but I don't even have cable. I can't watch no debate. Like, you know what I'm saying? So how am I supposed to know? Because I'm a vibes guy also, you know. I'm a vibes guy.
I guarantee you can go online and ask the question which candidate has better vibes and you'll get an answer.
I'm saying but if I can't watch them on TV, like, I need to see them. I need to see them talk to me. IG page. That's what I'm saying. Like, I'm a vibes guy at the end of the day. Like, I need to know also if they are going to be giving, you know, like vibes that I reciprocate. That's a very important...
The important thing when you're voting is, yes, obviously there's the big... when it's a presidential election this year, you have Senate and you have Congress members. That's very important to vote on, but also just as important to vote on are the local things that matter, like who's on your city council. No, that's really important. That actually affects you more day-to-day. Than the bigger things. Yeah. Um, all the state measures, there are county measures that affect your taxes. Do you know how much you're paying in tax? Do you know what you're paying in property tax? There may be a measure that's going to eliminate your tax. Yeah. You probably want to know about that because you might want to vote for it.
Lika, that's a great point. She said they should make it a federal day off so every eligible person can go vote. That's a great point.
Unless we have early... now we looking for another day off. Really, y'all.
And what do you think most people would do with that?
Go vote and then have a wonderful day off.
You can... everyone can on your break you can go vote.
Yeah. Well, you know, in fact, [clears throat] you should... Yeah, 30 minutes. It's 30 minutes. I can't really leave the parking lot with that.
I know what time you leave work. Polls are open many, many hours after you leave work. Yeah, it's like, guys, and you guys... I understand. I'm also playing off of it, but I do... He's just... He understands... I understand the importance of you guys. I'm not actually making fun at it, [laughter] but he's just playing dumb. I'm playing in case there are any dumb people out there that you can learn from. It's very informational. It's supposed to be helpful. Excellent. This is like an after-school special. No, it really is. [laughter]
You know, I'm learning a lot, guys. G2, thank you. I am a loser. Thanks, man. I appreciate that. [laughter] Thanks, M.
Guys, I would vote if I could. I just literally [laughter] can't. You guys missed the whole beginning of this. I literally just can't vote here. And I voted beforehand for the mail-in to Colorado, but I don't know where the ballot's at. [laughter]
Guys, quit being dumb because I'm not actually... you would love. It's called Ballotpedia.
Run down all the different... archaic now, right? Is this cool for you?
I mean, this is kind of a mid website. They got to make it like... This is ugly. This is an ugly website, but I do appreciate the effort. The effort to have a website. Yeah, I do.
Yeah, you can pick your town. Let's say you live in Downey. All right. Yeah, let's go check out what's going on in Downey. You can see who your city council members are in District 2. City council members in District 4.
See, this is something they need to teach. See, in school, and you know, I was learning some BS like this. This would actually be helpful to all the towns in LA County. Find your town.
Say you're in Santa Fe Springs. All right. Look at city council at large. You can vote for three of these people.
How are they all nonpartisan?
Because they are... there's just like... Okay, they choose to be. And then you can click on them and you get a little bit of biography on them.
See, why does my guy Johnny not have a photo? How am I supposed to know?
Oh, you want the photo because you want the vibes.
I want the vibes. Yeah, because I would, you know, sometimes they would give an untrustworthy vibe.
I'm sure you could find a photo of him.
I know. See, but whoever's running this got to get their game up, man.
Again, it's Santa Fe Springs. It's not... It's just not a huge town.
Okay. Yeah, I've never heard of Santa Fe Springs.
It's a nice little suburb. Okay, there you go. Shout out to Santa Fe Springs. Your area. Um, Santa Monica. What's going on in Santa Monica?
Yeah. Oh, man. Okay. So, how is everyone nonpartisan? How is everyone nonpartisan? Bigger city. You're telling me none of these people have a party? [snorts]
See, that's something. See, a lack of research probably has gone into this as well because, you know, I'm sure maybe Kurt Ganska is a Republican. How would I know? Maybe Zoe is a Democrat.
How about voting not based on...
Oh, I mean, I would never... I mean, I personally don't. What's Kurt Ganska about?
Um, seems not a lot. No, no, they... see Ballotpedia. You as a candidate have to turn in your information to them. Okay. So, they did not receive biographical information for this candidate.
Okay. So, I mean, guys, at the end of the day, there are ways to do this that are not archaic as you...
No. And I would never read that packet, though. I won't ever do that. But I did... I mean, I talked to my parents. I did my stuff last year. Okay. Or actually when I was in college still, I remember doing mail-ins. Um, it's just lost, guys. Sorry.
Have you ever gone... not dumb? UPS is dumb. Have you ever gone to an actual poll and like voted at a...
I haven't been able to vote since I turned 18 just as I moved here. Um, or no, when I turned 18 there wasn't anything to vote on, I don't think, when... there were no votes, there were no elections. I mean, I just don't think I did before I moved.
Right. So you haven't actually been to a voting booth?
No, no, no, I've never done that.
Did you do it in school? Did they like...
No. See, that's what I'm saying. See, this is my bigger overarching point is that in school I didn't learn how to do taxes. I didn't learn how to look, how to do anything for rent. I didn't learn how to do anything with health. I don't know any of that. Voting? You think I know what half of the stuff on there means? [laughter] I don't. And that's not because I'm dumb. That's because nobody taught me anything like that.
When I was in school, and this was back when the earth was cooling. Yeah. Um, they had like on election day they brought in a voting booth so you could actually go in and see how it works. And you went in and you could click... it was much older back then, and yes, you just click the thing and that was who you voted for. Now you go and you fill out your ballot. Yeah. And you feed it through a machine counting your vote.
Like, I understand the con... like, I just... when I say like all the stuff on there, I've never learned about any of it. Like, I don't know what any of it means. Like, when there's all the commercials going on and it's like Prop 40 doing this, I'm like, I don't know what any of that means.
Anybody else ready for these commercials to be over?
Yeah. Because I don't know what they mean. You know what I'm saying? Like, I don't know. See, I just don't know. But it's like... and it's hard to try. I don't know. There's a lot of stuff, guys. But I would, you know, shout out Denver. We love Denver. Um, shout out. Shout out Denver, though. [laughter]
Denver's in good hands, though.
Not voting for you, Denver. No, I mean, but my mom is though, so she represent for us. Don't give a crap. My mom represents... I do, though.
Your mom doesn't. No, your mom represents herself. No.
My mom represents the GGO family.
Each person has their own vote.
I know. It's lost. Blame my mom. No, I'm just kidding. [laughter] Mom, don't...
We're not doing that. We're not blaming moms.
No, we'll blame UPS because UPS lost it.
No, they didn't. You lost it.
I didn't lose it. It didn't get... I don't know which house it's at. I've been in LA for 5 years and I've never lived in one area for longer than a year. So, I don't know. It could be at any of them. [laughter] Could be at any of those houses.
What are you pulling out right there?
Recola. I live on the second floor and that's it. You're right. I actually do live on the second floor. That's true.
I sucks. I actually do. Yeah. Well, now it's... it used to be when I'd introduce myself it'd be like, 'Oh, you live on the second floor.' Now it's like they're like, 'Oh, like Don, that's it.' Oh, yeah. I guess we get that now. Yeah, that's what I get now.
That's right. Help him, Charles. Thank you, Sylvia. Charles is helping me. He's guiding my hand to the polls. If I could do that, he'll work it out.
LJ, I'm going to get there. LJG, I'm going to get there. Don't worry. Shout out Englewood. Yeah, Quattro. Shout out Englewood. Englewood. Shout out Englewood. Shout out, uh, what is that? Santa Fe Springs. Shout out Santa Fe Springs.
My stupid is showing. I'm sorry, Miss Bug. I know. I know. I just can't, uh...
I'm not, by the way, I'm not shaming you because I know that there are a lot of people, particularly your generation, who feel this way.
Yeah. I mean, guys, I see what you guys are saying, calling me like an idiot and dumb and stuff. I get that. I understand that because in a lot of aspects of my life, I am that. But when it comes to this, it's just not my fault. [laughter] [cough] Just not my fault, guys.
No, no, no. It is your fault. But...
It is not my fault. [laughter] How could I...
How is it anybody else's fault?
Because if somebody doesn't deliver the thing to me that is supposed to be delivered so I can then go and deliver it back, how am I supposed to do anything? Someone is having a real hard time adulting.
Yeah, man. That's what I'm saying. Don't tell... Yeah, Antonio. See, that's what I'm saying, man. They're not helping me out. UPS is doing me no favors. You had a postal service. Post this.
Anyway, what are you guys thinking about today?
Me being an idiot is the main topic. Uh, um, Quattro, thank you. Thank you. I'm not dumb. I'm just a little slow sometimes. Appreciate that.
Um, you dropped your ballot at a poll this morning and there's a selfie to take your voting. I like that. Speaking of... Thank you, Justin. It is. Have you guys voted in our, uh...
That's true. I believe they have. If you haven't, you got to go check it out on social.
Only one of us out of the three of us knows what F1 actually is.
That's, uh, that should be something. Let's just say don't allow Luca's level of intelligence or lack thereof about election day influence your vote.
For the team a bit too hard, man. No, I sold a bit too hard. [laughter] Huh? Are you team...? Uh, I have to... I'm impartial. I'm impartial. I can't... I'm sure he is. I'm sure he is. No bias. No bias. No bias. I'm sure there isn't. I don't know. Jimmy, I'm not winning it. Probably not. I'm just kidding. We're taking it back.
All three of you had a much different Vegas experience than I typically have. But...
What's your Vegas experience? You like...
It's all right. We're not talking about that. We didn't have any cameras on me and there's a reason we didn't. So...
God. But... thank you, Brandy. I know I do.
Um, uh, yeah, it was fun to watch you guys do your thing. Mhm. I'm really curious to see how, uh, the public is going to... Well, so far... down on this. So far, we have an idea. Um, we will see.
We don't need to be giving those numbers out.
No, there's none. There's no numbers to be. It's early. It's early. It's early.
Here's the thing. Vote early, vote late, vote often.
I like that. Um, it's like they say in Chicago.
Big mouth BZ saying, 'Sounded real raspy.' Chucky D. I like that. About to go up. Sure. [clears throat] Get some tea. All right. Chucky Don. Got impeach me. Never mind. Okay, never mind.
Okay. Um, uh, let's see. Thank you, Blackbeard. I appreciate that. Um, own it. I'm trying. I'm trying. Antonio, something like that. Today is a good day. Quadro. Shoreline. Crips in Venice. Even left that fight. Dusty. There you go. Oh, Carol. I know. That's crazy. Um, Amanda, who'd you vote for? Say me. Um, I'll be glad when the elections are up. Yeah. Oh, there you go. Can we say hi to guys? He's not here, Tracy. He's not here. He's sick. Let's just all get along. There you go. See, see the one-hit wonder. It's not uncommon. The mail loses stuff. The mail loses stuff. Um, I also just don't know where to look. I also just don't know where to look. It's not in my current home. So, good morning, Tiffany. Um, oh, Slate, thank you. I appreciate that. Uh, Mike Maynard. Um, my first being that I'm the only one who actually knows what Formula 1 is. Uh, that's number one. Two, I had the best experience, guys. And you'll see. Go, we'll watch the videos. You'll hear the pitch. Um, it's going to be great. Thank you, Amanda. Uh, Brandy, definitely not. Definitely won't. She won't do that.
What are you... uh, how are you feeling today?
Um, you have anything you're excited to talk about today?
I think the election is not as significant as everybody's saying. The election is the most important election ever. No, it's not.
Do you subscribe to the notion... heard every election everywhere last night. Everybody was saying it's the most important one of our lifetime.
They were saying it all last night. People were saying it this morning. Everybody said it's the most important election of our lifetime.
So then, because they say that for every election, right? So then doesn't that just mean it's like just another election?
This election is not as important because what the result is going to be is a split in Congress.
So that just means Trump's going to veto everything. Okay, that's true.
It's much more significant when the same party has the House, Senate, and Presidency because then they can do whatever they want.
Yeah, that's fair. Um, all right. Will you settle a debate because the chat is upset at me that I didn't vote because I don't live here and I'm not a resident of California.
Well, then how the hell can you... you want him to vote so Donald Trump will go after him?
No. Well, and Denver would be the place I could...
Oh, you didn't vote in Denver?
Well, because I got the ballot was sent to me and it didn't show up in my house.
Haven't you ever heard of people... Haven't you heard the song 'LA's home but it ain't mine'? New York's... Well, Denver's home, but it ain't mine no more.
Yeah, I have not heard that song, but I mean that makes sense to me. Right. I didn't get... How can I vote?
I'll be honest. With an out-of-state ID. You could vote with an ID. He could have voted. I'll be honest. I voted.
I didn't know you could do that.
I couldn't vote for mayor. Yeah. I could not [laughter] vote for LA mayor.
I just couldn't bring myself to vote for mayor.
He's undocumented. [laughter] Get him out of the country.
I am a citizen of the United States of America. I did not lose it, Marley. See? Okay, guys. I didn't do anything. All right.
Um, what else are you looking forward to talking about?
I just want to get this show on the road. Why am I so tired?
When did you hit the hay last night?
Quarter to 7:45. [snorts] But I got up at 3:30.
Well, I mean that's still a fair bit, but...
Charlie, that's disgusting.
Oh my goodness. That is just disgusting. That just makes my stomach turn.
Only one serving of cereal.
What? That's one serving.
That's a pretty regular bowl.
Keep telling yourself that.
Yeah, I know. [laughter] Do we have anything you're looking forward to eat today?
Oh, yeah. Let's do a turkey and Swiss or an AI tuna sandwich.
Can I get a turkey and Swiss sandwich or an AI tuna sandwich, please?
All right, there you go. Um, not mac and cheese, guys. He ain't no mac and cheese.
Oh, this was actually... I saw somebody talking about this earlier said now it's kind of turned into Thanksgiving season a little bit. You know, it's like people are looking forward to Thanksgiving, the next holiday coming up. What is your favorite Thanksgiving food if you even eat any of the foods at Thanksgiving?
My favorite. It's stuffing.
Stuffing. Yeah, stuffing. That's a good one.
Yeah, stuffing is good. Okay, that's a great answer.
That's my favorite except for you guys stuffing of me. Dressing.
That is if you guys don't use actual cornbread.
Who is you guys by the way?
Well, that's the same thing if like that doesn't make it dressing.
Yeah, it's cornbread dressing.
No, I know my dad. Dude, I know the difference between... but still if you make...
You said it's the same, but you know the difference.
Okay, that is an oxymoron. You can't know the difference, but call it the same.
Well, it is. I mean, if you make...
Kraft macaroni and cheese is not the same as baked macaroni and cheese.
No, they're both mac and cheese. They're the same.
Hey, mac and cheese is mac and mac is mac. Dressing is great.
Dressing is great. Dressing or stuffing? We do dressing, but we call it stuffing, but it's cornbread.
No, I mean it's cornbread stuffing, right?
Um, stuffing is cooked inside the bird.
See, dressing is not. It's a side dish.
Well, I mean dressing or stuffing is the same either.
Are you getting dressing for lunch today?
No, he's... Let's see. Right now, it is looking like you're getting a turkey and Swiss sandwich.
God, you guys hate AI tuna, don't you?
Why don't you guys ever vote for AI? I mean, turkey's fine.
I know. They always see the fish and they're like, 'We're going to vote against the fish.'
That maybe they're not like from California.
Yeah, guys. There's good fish out here.
Well, there's good fish on the East Coast, too.
Are you a honey ham or a turkey?
I hate ham. I really hate [clears throat] I hate JP.
Oh, honey. Yeah, they're in your email.
Yeah, turkey's like the worst.
You know what? The best turkey is when they put it in the ground and barbecue it. Literally.
I don't know if I've ever had that.
Tony Tony K, this is an Hispanic thing, but um in East LA, Tony Krasco used to work here.
And um his family used to like... I don't know how they did cows. I don't know if they...
Well, no, no, but they have like a hole in the ground and then they barbecue it like in the ground on top.
It is so good. It is so good. It was like, it's amazing.
I actually probably would keep it nice. That does sound good.
Oh. Oh, Jesus. [laughter]
That was awful. Oh my god.
That was awful. God. [laughter] Almost lost it.
It was terrible. No, it was not there.
Oh my gosh, that was crazy.
God, you're... [laughter] No, that was right in your hand.
Wait, Roger. Do [laughter] what we doing here.
Yes. Hey JP, uh, you there?
Harvey, thank you so much for doing this.
Um, okay, we are... Jonah, where is this? Okay. Uh, we are ready [clears throat] to roll. Charles is here.
Am I? Yep. How's my framing here?
Okay, here we go. [clears throat] Welcome to TMZ Live.
Welcome to TMZ Live. This horrific plane crash in West Palm Beach. There are now some clues as to what exactly happened here and um whether it could have been avoided, and weather has a lot to do with it.
Yeah, because they were going through some very intense weather. And there's some information now about what they were going through and what they were dealing with. And there are signs there have been other plane tragedies where we've seen some of this before. So um we're going to get into the details of that, but we also now of course know the identities of the people who are on board. And there's Adam Robinson, a tech entrepreneur, and he and his family, his wife, their kids and some friends were on board. Um and there was something that he said just recently on a podcast about reaching the level of success where he could enjoy private jets. Um and it is a haunting conversation to hear now knowing what happened over the weekend.
Some of my very rich friends were like using it and I just assumed that it was inaccessible to me. And then, you know, because they were almost like using it as like the status symbol. And then I remember when I found out it was only like a couple thousand a month and I could fly for free from New York to Miami or like Chicago. And it was at a time where I was like single and traveling a lot, and it was like this feeling that I got of like, wow, I can actually fly private too, [laughter] you know, was like... and I understand and the status that I got, you know, it became part of my identity.
So, here's where we are right now. The NTSB has come out and said that um when the plane was at 35,000 ft, it was experiencing moderate turbulence and ice started to form on the aircraft. The pilot then asked to ascend to 37,000 ft presumably to get above the weather. Um and air traffic control approved that, and shortly after that happened, the co-pilot declared an emergency. So weather seems to be a focal point here.
Yes. Uh and someone who understands the weather part of this as well as the part of being a pilot is joining us now to discuss what they were going through aboard that plane. Uh JP Dice is a meteorologist and also a licensed pilot, and he is joining us now. JP, welcome to TMZ Live.
Yeah, good to be here. Thanks guys.
So JP, um ice is forming on the plane. The co-pilot made that clear. Um the plane was not having any mechanical problem, at least that the air... the...
crew was conveying to air traffic control. So it seems like, and it doesn't seem like turbulence did this because it was moderate turbulence and most aircraft can withstand that. So it seems like ice is the central focus here.
You know, Harvey, what got my attention is not only was ice talked about, and that's not unusual. The airplanes have ice protection systems, all jet aircraft do, but she mentioned it was minus 47 degrees Celsius and they were starting to pick up precipitation. Well, what that tells me with my meteorology background as well, you're looking at supercooled droplets up there. So you can actually have liquid water with temperatures below freezing. What happens with those supercooled droplets? They actually end up, as soon as they make contact with the metal skin of the airplane, they freeze on contact and you can actually have the non-protected parts of the airplane get covered with ice. And in particular, what you really get concerned about is the tail section, that horizontal stabilizer getting covered with ice. That is usually the first to freeze up.
So JP, what kind of protection would a plane have in that instance? Is there something that they can deploy that helps to deal with that, or is the only remedy just to get to a lower altitude?
They actually have a system that's already turned on in those kind of conditions, whether it's a 737 or a Learjet. They have heated wings. It actually takes some of the air from the engines, that hot air, and heats the leading edge of the wings, and there's an electrical heated element back on the horizontal stabilizer. So in ideal conditions, that works pretty well. But when you start getting in these supercooled type regimes like we could have had with this situation, it can totally overwhelm the ice protection systems on any airplane.
So the co-pilot said what the temperature was, and air traffic control was aware of it. Yet the request was to climb 2,000 feet. So that is curious to me because what you're saying is that if it is that cold out and water freezes on contact, you know, even if they have those protective devices, at a point it becomes dicey. So is this an issue of going higher rather than lower?
You know, a lot of times higher is better because what you can do, you can get out of what we call the instrument conditions, the visible moisture. So you can get above that and you may get into some clearing or even sometimes an inversion layer where the temperature could be just a little bit warmer. So it's not uncommon to look for a higher altitude when you're in icing conditions. I think what they were trying to do though was not really avoid the icing conditions. She had mentioned the ice was manageable. It looked like they were in moderate turbulence and they were up and down 600, 700 feet, that they were actually looking for a little bit better ride. Get up a couple of thousand feet and the air should smooth out. We hear that a lot of times even on the airliners. So I think that's what they were looking for in this particular case and not so much trying to necessarily avoid the icing situation.
This, you know, as soon as I heard the co-pilot talking about the ice, it reminded me, and Harvey, you talked about this this morning, this plane crash you were talking about was in DC, right?
It was like 40 years ago. I think it was 1982. And they had a problem with the deicing on the wings and they never got enough lift.
That was a commercial airliner.
That was a commercial airliner. But is it possible, JP, that they have turned on the system that is heating the tail section, but at some point it just stops working? It's too cold. And that's what happened. And that's when the plane would have gone into the dive that it did.
Yeah, it's possible. What you have there, the ice protection systems generally are turned on in that kind of environment. It would be very uncommon for those systems not to be turned on. And if they're not working correctly, you'll get some kind of message in the cockpit or a light that will come on that will indicate, hey, the tail is not being heated or the wings cold or so forth. But you can have these ice protection systems. They do have limits and I've seen historically airplanes crash when there's so much ice that it overwhelms those systems. So they're great, but they don't work perfectly all the time in certain regimes. So that's one thing we have to be aware of. Also to point out, it's not only ice. It looks like based on radar data, they were going across the top or going through the top of a very rapidly growing thunderstorm. So it could be a combination of ice and it could be what we call an aircraft upset from a strong updraft within that thunderstorm that can put the airplane in a really unusual attitude where it's a loss of control type situation where you're really close to your maximum operating speed and also your stall speed. They get really close together at those higher altitudes.
So that is something I've been thinking about all morning. That I have a friend who was in Palm Beach and his plane was delayed because of weather. Now, this plane took off from Austin where the weather was not as severe, but there was clearly a storm in that area. So what I've been wondering about is, number one, I would assume the pilot knew that there was weather in that area and is the better part of valor to avoid it. And two, does air traffic control warn, because we didn't hear any kind of a warning, warn the pilot of an aircraft that's at 35,000 feet that hey, you are in a pretty dangerous area right now. Avert it. Go 20 degrees to the left or something like that.
Yeah, it would be very uncommon for a pilot not to be aware of even before they take off that they're going to be crossing some pretty active weather across Florida to the extent of really understanding what's going on with the atmosphere. Most pilots are not trained at that level, but they are trained enough to look at what's being put out by the National Weather Service, what aviation maps are out there to really show where you're going to have severe weather. So they really are briefed on that, and also the weather where they take off and they land. In terms of the air traffic control, that was one of the things that I was kind of listening for. Anytime we're flying, I typically, and I fly corporate jets all the time, we're looking at the weather and it's kind of a, we work together. Air traffic control will often suggest, hey, try heading 180. It looks like a lot of people are getting through that way. That's a suggested heading to avoid some of this weather. I did not hear that on any of these conversations. Not to say it didn't happen at some point before, but I have not heard any suggested headings to avoid some of these thunderstorms. And air traffic control does have access to radar data, ground-based radar, that they can look at to help augment what the pilots have.
You know, it's funny. I used to listen to channel 9 on United all the time where you listen to air traffic control and I heard that routinely when you went into weather they would automatically say, you know, turn 20 degrees or whatever it is. It seems like that's something air traffic control in Miami would be keenly aware of, especially if flights were being delayed.
Yeah, I was surprised not to hear that kind of dialogue in the conversation. The one thing that I did hear was the fact that air traffic control gave the airplane the free will to deviate to the left, but they said no more to the right because of other air traffic. So to the left, you actually had a lot more active weather. To the right would have been a better setup, but it's one of those situations where the pilot really has to follow ATC or air traffic control unless you can declare an emergency and say because of weather I'm going to be turning 180 and you just do it and they'll move other people out of the way. So sometimes you have to take what we call that PIC or pilot in command authority. But I did hear they hit a limit on them turning to the right. They would let them turn more to the left to avoid the weather. And that's one part of the communication that I did hear.
Um, yeah, I think we're going to find out more obviously as the investigation goes forward, but this seems like a really tragic situation just as the weather they ran into and how they could get around it, if they could get around it.
JP, thank you so much for being with us. We appreciate your insight on this.
That was good. Thank you.
All right. Thanks for having me. I appreciate it.
Christa in our chat is asking the question of who is responsible for inspecting a private jet before takeoff? Does the ground maintenance crew or the pilot do it?
The pilot definitely does, but there is a ground crew that looks. But this wasn't an issue. This wasn't the issue.
No, I mean, I think they just ran into really shitty weather. And it is interesting when I saw the radar, the first thing you think, like just common sense, you look at it and go like, there's a huge storm south.
Why don't you just go south? But then you heard him saying like, well, you go south and now there's a lot more air traffic, so maybe you can't go that way. But you knew there was going to be weather, so I guess that's when you plot out your flight plan and...
Yeah, but at the same time, air traffic control, they can see the weather also. And they've been dealing in that specific area for a much longer period of time with other planes.
So I get there was more traffic going to the right, but at the same time, was anybody going to the left? And did it look really ominous? Because clearly it was.
Yeah. The left didn't look any better if you go to the left on that radar.
Well, he said it was apparently worse.
Yeah, but that's where they went.
Black Beauty in the chat is saying, 'We've been having terrible weather down here and they ran into it.' But why would they even take off in the first place if they...
Well, because they took off from Austin, right?
But wouldn't they know that there's inclement weather?
I know, but then you go around. They don't know how intense it is until they get closer.
I guess a lot of people, like at least we're saying that, like it doesn't make a lot of sense because like you should, the weather's happening, you know, like you should know that it's pretty bad. I feel like if you're going to fly into that direction, like they should...
You can make a flight plan that avoids it altogether, right? It may take longer, but it may be safer.
But that doesn't seem to be what happened.
Um, didn't the ATC guy say he couldn't see them on the radar?
Uh, that's just what Carlton is saying, or not Carlton, um, Eaten Hog saying.
No, they said that at the end. I didn't hear the very end. The very end. Yeah. So that must be what he's referring to.
I mean, we got it's like I didn't hear this until today, but the captain is doing the Lord's Prayer.
You know, look, I don't want to get super dark here, but I was just thinking what those last 75 seconds must have been like for that family.
It just got, they were unconscious. I guess if the pilot and the co-pilot were still talking, but...
I don't think they would have been lost altitude that quickly sometimes.
Maybe, but they knew the terror of what was happening and it's just...
Who say look outside, talking to the captain like look outside like...
Because it happened, it went from okay we're going to 37,000 to we just lost 10,000 feet.
Which is like there was a radical change. Also, I saw someone was like, 'Private jets should have parachutes for situations like this.' But someone said that the way that this would, you would have died.
They were descending so fast they wouldn't have been able to stand up or open the exit door to even jump if they had a parachute.
Impossible to stop that kind of force of that speed.
They wouldn't have been able to even get up to like put the parachute on or open the door. It was so fast.
You're going to come here.
What are we doing here? You're going to go there. You're going to go there.
Just kidding. We're doing Paris Jackson now because things are moved around.
But you can still say you go.
Well, I'm not going to sit here.
No, Ryan Alman's on Paris Jackson. So I'm saying the camera's already set up.
I know we're going here. Do you want this?
No, no, no. We switched the order of the story because we just got a guest.
God, I just got so tired. What's going on, Jonah? Did we drink coffee?
I've never seen you drink coffee.
I drink coffee. First thing I do in the morning is drink coffee and then I have an iced coffee here.
Vanilla. Another killer.
Um, again, I worked out and I swam and I was fine. And not...
Oh, now you don't feel well.