Welcome back to Hardware Unboxed. It is time for the October Q&A. We did miss last month's Q&A, didn't we? Because we were planning on it and then someone got sick.
Not going to point any fingers.
No need to name names or anything like that, but somebody did get the flu and get a bit wrecked for a few weeks and they're like 90% better now. So, I think we should do the October Q&A here. Anyway, enough of that. Let's get into it. Today's sponsor spot is brought to you by Thermal Grizzly and the new Duronaut high-performance thermal paste. Duronaut offers extreme long-term stability combined with outstanding thermal conductivity. And this has been achieved through a specially engineered silicon oil combined with aluminium microparticles and zinc oxide nanoparticles of various shapes. Duronaut isn't electrically conductive and won't harden over time. For best performance, you'll want to apply a very thin layer. And to help with this, included is the TG Spatula Pro. The spatula's revised design allows for increased pressure during application, making it easy to spread a thin, even layer of Duronaut. So, for more information, please check the link in the video description.
Here's a nice simple question to kick things off. There's no 'it depends'. There's no qualifiers of any kind for this one. It's just straight down the line. Real simple answer. What in brackets used GPUs do you find most appealing in the sub $200 and sub $300 price brackets? So, I think it's just whatever GPUs, but because there's no real GPUs, like new GPUs in those price brackets, we have to sort of turn to used.
What is there new? There's like the RX 9050, if you can find it.
The RTX 5050, sorry, is now above $300, I believe. So, that's out of contention. And there's maybe one ARC card,
I think. Yeah, the well they've got the ASRock Challenger B570 that's currently available for $260 US, which as far as new products go, that's really good value because it should be cheaper than the RX 9050 and it's generally quite a bit faster.
Only qualifier there being that you have to have resizable BAR. Without it, performance is terrible. I think it's fair to say everyone would have resizable BAR at this point. You can go back pretty far on. I don't think the resizable BAR thing is really a concern at this point in time.
Most motherboards have got BIOS updates that allow it to be supported on very old platforms. It's about 25% faster than an RX 6600 on average, but if you turn to the used market, it is about 60% more expensive than a typical asking price of a used RX 6600.
So, you know, the 6600's pretty slow. So, getting 25% more performance over that is nothing to sneeze at, but it is quite a bit more. But then you're also comparing new and used, which is kind of chalk and cheese. So, I think if we're talking about new cards, it's pretty hard to beat a B570 right now. The ARC B570. I think that's probably the best way to go.
It's probably the only option as well because the 9050 that we were talking about isn't even available in a lot of regions.
But it's also crap. Like very bad value.
It sucks. But it also isn't going to be an option for a lot of people, especially in North America where it's supposedly, I mean I'm sure you can import it, but it's not available. It's not supposed to be available for that region, making the B570 almost the default new winner.
Yeah, that's right. And again, maybe you'll see like a 5050 slide into that price range, but that isn't a good card either. So yeah, real bad. Real, real bad. And then if you're looking at used stuff, again, doing used content is really difficult because I could say I got a 3070 for like $150, but that's not the typical asking price. So, having a look at the more typical asking price, something like an RTX 3070 is around $250 US. So, you know, not great value in my opinion. As I said, the RX 6600, you're looking at about $160 to $180 for that.
You know, that's okay. Something like an RTX 2070 Super, they're usually around $150 to $180. In terms of performance, they are pretty much pretty similar to a B570. I'm not really, it depends on the games, the settings, and how well the ARC works and all that sort of stuff, but I think if you tested say an 18 game average, they'd be pretty similar. So, that's pretty good value. It's about $100 less than the new B570.
You can get an Intel Arc A750 secondhand for like $120, $150, but I think at that point you'd probably just get the Super. And a 2080 Super apparently they're like $180 to $200. But again, these are rough guide prices and they have been climbing more recently. So, some of these because I've done an average over the last little period, the cards sold over like a month ago were cheaper than the ones that are selling now because prices have just continued to skyrocket. So it's, but you're looking generally at sort of your two to three generations ago sort of products, 30 series, 6000 series.
Yeah. There's nothing in like the 7000 series. Nothing in the 4000 series.
So yeah, you've really got to look at like the Radeon 6000 series and the RTX 3000 series before you start to get options. I guess the good news with something like buying a 3070 or even some of those 20 series products is that Nvidia has done a reasonable job of supporting those cards with driver updates, feature support, you can use the latest versions of DLSS. And while those cards are slower for things like DLSS 4.5, like there's more of a performance hit using that versus a 40 series card, you can still use it. So that does help out a bit on the lifespan of those cards. They're not completely dead. A lot of those cards though will be limited by things like the usual VRAM issues. You know, the 2080 Super, 2070 Super, the 8 gig GPUs. Same with the 3070. So, you're not going to be able to run the highest quality settings, but even then, like the performance of the GPU core is not going to necessarily allow you these days in modern games to run those highest settings. So, they're all like, you know, fine enough options, but yeah, as you said, they're sort of increasing in price isn't great. Ideally you'd want to see used cards get cheaper over time, but what does a 5070 cost these days? Like nearly $800 or over $800 US now.
Pulls everything else up.
Yeah, that's right. So, good news if you have an old GPU because that means if there's just one sitting on a shelf or whatever, you can sell it for more. But, yeah, those are the sorts of options that are available. And like I said, you know, with the way a lot of games are today, they will be usable. Like it's not like a game like Gears of War: E-Day won't run on a 3070. It works. The Witcher 3 remaster, obviously an old game that people are playing now still works on those cards, so they're usable, but obviously they're not going to have the lifespan that you would hope to see that we used to get in that sort of price range. But well, maybe we might have 8 GB GPUs next generation, so the 3070 will get another breather.
Yeah, who knows? Do you think consumers would be easily confused when given the choice between an RX 9050 and the RTX 5090? They might be confused by the difference in price.
Yeah, those 5090s, why are they like five times as much as an entire system with a 9050 in it?
Yeah, I don't think they'd be easily confused on that one. I don't think there's, yeah, it's quite a funny difference in the way that the numbers are configured there, but no, I don't think that's a problem. I don't think there's anything to be concerned about. I think the bigger problem is that there's two variants of the 9050 and one is, well, one's not great and the other one's horrific, but they share the same name. So, which we've detailed and covered on the channel already. So, I think that's the bigger problem with the 9050. And the 5090, the bigger problem is just that it's no longer a gaming GPU because it's a workstation GPU. It's up like workstation prices.
Yeah. Yeah. Not great on the 5090 front these days, unfortunately. I think people making those jokes, right, that it would cost you $50,900 US.
And that's a bargain. Yeah, you're getting a really good price if you can get one for that. Yeah, these days they're what like $8,000 or something. So that's absurd.
Yeah, not good for those people unfortunately that want those cards. But yeah, when you've got that much VRAM, they're just popular for AI now. So it is what it is.
I bought a DDR5 8000 kit because it was older stock that hadn't been given the full AI boom inflation treatment. Okay, not too bad there. Do you think there's any realistic chance that the next-gen AMD CPUs will have better support for faster DDR5 XMP speeds despite the memory shortage?
They were supposed to this generation support DDR5 8000, right? But then it turned out to not really do all that much.
Well, it always in that sense did support it. You could always run depending on, you know, motherboards and whatever and memory support there, but you could run DDR5 8000 on your Zen 4 CPUs. It's just that yeah, either the motherboard support wasn't there or people realistically just didn't bother doing it because you had to change the ratio with the memory controller, which while it increased bandwidth, it also increased latency, which often hurt gaming performance. So, it just wasn't worth doing or it just didn't really improve it. So, it just again wasn't worth doing.
That's because Zen 4 and Zen 5, their IMC, the integrated memory controller which is in the IO die, is pretty much exactly the same. It uses the same 6 nanometer IO die. So memory support, and that's why that was such a funny thing because when we were saying Zen 5 is a flop, it doesn't really bring much to the table, it's not great, a lot of people were quick to point out, oh but it's got much better memory support. You know, they're now guaranteeing DDR5 8000. Like, doesn't really have anything to do with the CPUs. It's more that they've now updated the motherboards, the AGESA code, the BIOS to better support 8000, but it doesn't, by better support I mean it just works. It doesn't actually offer better performance. So whether you had a 600 series chipset or an 800 series chipset, it was much the same. So you can run DDR5 8000 if you want on your Zen 4 or Zen 5 CPU, it's just not really worth doing in a lot of instances. Now with Zen 6, which is what you're hinting at, that's going to have a new IO die. So a newly configured IO die which hopefully has better memory support and yeah, will better utilize DDR5 8000, but all of that's yet to be seen. So that's, we know for a fact it's getting a new IO die. What that's going to bring obviously we haven't seen.
Yeah. I mean you'd be hoping with a new IO die that it will improve performance. I think that'd probably be the goal because that was the thing that we sort of assumed. You can't really know for sure without testing it, but it's assumed that that was one of the main factors holding back Zen 5 from higher gaming performance gains because there was a lot of IPC improvements in that core design that benefited some workstation tasks, server applications, which made it really popular for certain types of tasks, but it did appear to be being held back in terms of things like memory latency for gaming. And so that's why it didn't have this, you know, Zen 5% was kind of the talk at the time. Never really offered a huge improvement in those areas, but hopefully with the new IO die, we will see better memory support and that will hopefully improve the overall gaming experience for people along with all the other stuff that you'd be hoping to see like just generally improve performance and things like that. Supposed to be a fairly substantial improvement. At least that's what the rumors are suggesting in terms of not just the IO die, but the core designs as well, potentially more cores per CCD, things like that, improved IPC, and quite a substantial change in the nodes as well, moving up several tiers of process node. At least that's again, that's all what the rumors and leaks are sort of suggesting, but I think we'll learn more early next year. So, not too long to go.
All right. Which company do you think has treated us the best during the AI apocalypse? I'm glad they say company and not companies because it would be a short list, right?
Well, let's rule out some companies, right? Let's rule out Nvidia immediately for making the 5090 $8,000.
And everything else. Can we rule out AMD for anything? Obviously, I think they kept their CPUs at a fairly reasonable level, right? So, that's not too bad. On the GPU front, I don't know. They've tried to do some dodgy stuff with their drivers, trying to not support older GPUs, which hasn't been great. And obviously the FSR 4.
I think you put AMD in the same camp as Nvidia because they would like to screw us over. They've sort of proven that, and if they could leverage the situation more they would have. So they've sort of leveraged it to the best of their ability which is kind of AMD in a nutshell. It's like their slogan.
So actually maybe not for some things.
They're not eating into their margins to keep GPUs at a low price. They're certainly not doing that. If you look at the cost of like a 9060 XT 16 GB, it's gone up pretty substantially and it's a high margin card. Of course, I'm not saying that as a business you should just sell products at cost. But they haven't, they've kind of just followed Nvidia for the most part like Nvidia cards go up so AMD cards go up by sort of a similar amount.
Yeah, it's sort of a similar situation. Intel is right as well. They've refocused for the workstation efforts rather than gaming because that's where the money is. So, it's like not saying, you know, you can blame them for that. They are for-profit companies, but we're answering the question.
Yeah. Have they done anything for gamers? No. Like I'm not, there's nothing that comes to mind where I'm like Intel did this or AMD did this that helped gamers.
Yeah. Even with things like some of the bundles, it's like they weren't, like they tried a little bit and then they're just kind of like, eh, you know, memory is what it is. So, yeah.
Yeah, I mean you can't really point to other, like there's no point saying a case manufacturer was good or whatever because they can't really take advantage of the current situation. Is it the same for like ASUS, MSI, Gigabyte and so on as well? Obviously, they've refocused some products towards the AI thing, but there's not much they could do really.
There's not much they could do, but also they haven't done any, like I know what you're saying, like that there's no option because they're basically beholden to what Nvidia is charging for GPUs and same with like your motherboard sales are kind of dictated by whether it's worth buying a CPU and DRAM. But yeah, there's nothing I can really point to and sort of say wow they tried to make this really good value option for people or like some sort of product that would help to offset the cost of building a PC, right?
Well, because you know, if it's really expensive to buy a GPU and, you know, DRAM, then I guess component manufacturers could be like, well, let's try and make some really cheap stuff so that your overall build cost is sort of similar, but you know, you're spending a bit more on the memory and a bit less on other components. But we haven't really seen that. I don't think they can to be fair.
Well, we haven't seen an example from say MSI or ASUS where they've put their hand up and said, you know, stressful times, difficult times for gamers. If your MSI Gaming Trio or whatever melts or has a failure, you know, we will replace it. We won't just refund you the original purchase price.
That's right. So, we haven't seen any of the companies put their hand up and say they'll do anything extra above and beyond for their customers like that or make it easier to buy certain products that are often out of stock for existing customers like, oh, you bought, let's say you're like an MSI Supreme buyer or something and they sort of have you on record as being that sort of buyer and then maybe they'll offer you the latest batch of GPUs that keep going up in price at, you know, like an early bird sort of deal. We haven't seen any of that. It's just like, let's put them on the market and if they're sold for $8,000, 5090 is now, too bad.
You know, Nvidia's done that pop-up store thing, which is kind of funny. I think that's probably a way to get around false advertising on the pricing.
So, we've got plenty of examples of companies being anti-consumer and basically atrocious customer support. So, more recently, we had PNY where a customer had the cable melt, which is now more of a waiting for that to happen than if it'll happen, it seems to be. And they didn't honor that because they weren't using the adapter that came with the graphics card. They were using the official cable with the power supply, which was once upon a time thought to be the way you should do it rather than using the adapter. And initially they also publicly said that it wouldn't validate your warranty if you used the official power supply cable, but because it's convenient to backpedal on that, they're doing that now. So anyway, that was a bad situation. We've seen plenty of memory brands not replace memory and just offer, you know, the purchase price and
or SSDs. Same thing happening in that market as well. Louis Rossmann is suing Samsung for I think it was a 990 Pro or something. They wouldn't replace or repair that drive. They just wanted to refund the original purchase price which obviously leaves someone like him or anyone high and dry in the current market. And that's inexcusable for a brand like Samsung who actually makes the product in full, not like Corsair who buys all the components and then just sells the finished product.
So, I think one company that comes to mind where we've only seen good news would be G.Skill. There was a story recently where someone bought an open box memory kit for, I think it was 64 gigs or something absurd like that for $150, you know, a year ago or something.
It would have to be a year ago.
Well, yeah. I'm just not sure how far back it was. Clearly before October last year.
Pre-apocalypse. Yeah. So, still, you know, green trees and stuff, but yeah, bought open box memory off eBay, had it fail recently, and G.Skill honored the warranty, replaced the memory. Can't remember, was it $2,000 or something worth of memory. So, that's a cool story. And while people are saying, well G.Skill can just get the memory back, repair it or whatever, and you know, they're not losing that kind of money, which may be the case, their competitors haven't been doing that. They've just been like, 'Give us the memory back because that's valuable and we'll basically buy it back at the original purchase price.' And a lot of that's been going on, but G.Skill hasn't been doing that. And there's been a lot of people in our comment section saying they recently RMA'd memory with G.Skill and G.Skill took care of it. So, and they probably are losing money because it's not, you know, they have to buy the components like the memory modules or whatever. And my understanding is it's not always the case where they can warranty that type of thing directly back to the manufacturer. It's more like an internal, they would used to buy, they need like 110% of the supply they need or whatever so that whenever something fails they just have the additional chips available. It's all worked into the price and that sort of thing. But if the memory modules are costing so much more now then obviously it's creating significant pressure. I think they'd be hoping that, you know, fingers crossed it was like a controller that failed or some other component on the board so that they don't necessarily have to replace that memory. Maybe that's how they're getting away with it not costing them necessarily as much. But I think in a lot of cases it would be costing them. So the fact that they're willing to do that, you know, is hopefully people will remember that once these sort of
Well, regardless of whether it is or isn't costing them, a lot of their competitors or pretty much all of their competitors aren't doing that.
Yeah. So that's at least one good news story there and that's maybe the company because I can't, are there any other examples that you've heard of a company doing something like that.