Because I grew up not 20 minutes away from here. I could cross 15 minutes in effect and go the same 10-year life expectancy gap. I knew I wanted to do something about that. That's why I became a doctor. He said, 'That's great, but you got a gift for communicating. Maybe someday run for office.' I wanted to go to medical school to learn how to heal, to take on those disparities that I saw.
But I realized I was about to be practicing in a health care system that's a lot more interested in billing than healing. I want three things. I want money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for all. Everybody asked me, 'Why you start with money out of politics?' I'm like, because everything starts with money in politics. Your tax dollars are literally going to subsidize a big corporation in a local community. So, how about instead of doing that, we take the same money we would have given in tax breaks to a big corporation and invest it in more revolving loan funds to enable new businesses to grow.
Do you think it's possible?
Yes. We're the richest, most powerful country in the world. So, don't be telling me how great we are when it comes to dropping bombs on other people and not telling me how great we are when it comes to providing healthcare for our own people. Makes no sense to me. That is a moral stain on our country. I believe in America. I believe that when we put our minds to something and decide we're going to do this well, we do it well.
We can do it with excellence.
When it comes to healthcare, I think we can do it well.
Welcome to the Black Biz Pod. I am your host, Charity Dean, where we talk about business, policy, and opportunity. I am so excited. Today we have a very special guest. We are going to be talking about healthcare. We're going to be talking about small business, and we're going to be talking about policy, and I have my dear friend here, Dr. Abdul El-Sayed. And I just want to say a couple things. So, the Black Business Alliance, we are a nonpartisan nonprofit. And so we're not here to endorse candidates, but we are here to talk about the issues that matter to you. And so, let's get started. Welcome.
Charity, thanks so much for having me. And it is sort of a wild opportunity to be back. We got to know each other back when we both served in the city back in 2015.
And I'm just thinking about like how stacked that cabinet room was.
Right. You got Garlin Gilchrist. Ellie Savitt was there.
You and I were both there. Basically most of the top of the ticket.
And then you also had Ryan Frederick, who's Joanne Watson's husband.
We were all there in 2015, like down the street.
Yes. So, it's great to be back and just so proud of like the incredible work you're doing, the leadership you're providing in the community, and just the best part of growing up is watching your friends grow up.
And so, it's been amazing watching you come up.
Thank you so much. It's been a minute, and I didn't even realize how many of our friends from the days in the mayor's office are now doing all of these amazing things. Let's talk about you. So, when I met you, you were the health director. Talk to us about your journey from college, med school, to deciding to lead a health department.
Yeah, let's go all the way back. So, you know, if I'm anybody, I'm my grandmother's grandson, okay? The smartest, wisest person I ever met. Never got to go to school. She grew up the ninth of 14 in Alexandria, Egypt, where my parents immigrated from, and I used to spend some of my summers with her. She lost two of her babies of the eight to whom she gave birth. So when I'd go 15 hours to Egypt, I'd cross about 10 years difference in life expectancy. The thing for me though is I grew up not 20 minutes away from here. I could cross 15 minutes in effect and go the same 10-year life expectancy gap.
I knew I wanted to do something about that. That's why I became a doctor. Went to college at the University of Michigan. It was the first time anybody... Go blue.
Even though I didn't go to Michigan, I always say that.
Go blue. We go blue. You know, we'll claim you, Charity. We'll claim you.
Let me talk to some folks, see if we can't get you an honorary degree.
But I went there and I studied biology and political science. You know, those were the two things I was interested in, political science.
That's funny. When I was there I was like, how are you going to bring those two things together? I was like, maybe I think I figured that out, right?
So last day there, I was valedictorian in my class. I got to give the student commencement speech. A real honor. Main speaker is Bill Clinton.
That's awesome.
That's a story, man.
I mean, it was a moment. I'll be honest with you. So I worked really hard on that speech. You can imagine, right? I'm about to speak in front of 60,000 people in the Big House. The only reason my whole family's going is to listen to Bill Clinton. They're like, 'Yeah, you'll give a nice speech.' I give my speech. Clinton gives his speech and says some really nice things about me in his speech.
After the speech, he comes up to me. He's like, 'Why are you going to medical school?'
Which is not a question, by the way, when people ask you when you're going to medical school.
I said, 'You know, I love people and I love science and this is how I want to serve.' He said, 'That's great, but you got a gift for communicating. Maybe someday you'll run for office.' And I laughed in his face. I was like, 'Mr. President, I don't know if you saw my name. There's 11 letters to my name.' So that's the first one.
People like me don't get to run for office.
A year later, I watched Barack Hussein Obama run for the presidency. Filed that away. I got to go to England, got to go to Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar, did a PhD in public health, and then finished med school. The hard part about this though is that I wanted to go to medical school to learn how to heal, to take on those disparities that I saw. But I realized I was about to be practicing in a health care system that's a lot more interested in billing than healing.
And that's what led me into going into public health. And that's where you and I meet, because after a couple years as a professor, I knew that I wanted to be involved in the work of it. And I get this opportunity to come back here to rebuild a health department that had been shut down.
What was surprising to you about working and leading the Detroit Health Department?
Just how little infrastructure there was left.
Yeah.
People don't realize this. Detroit had a 185-year-old health department before they shut it down.
Oldest health department in the whole state. If you think about the history of public health, it wasn't like states building public health departments. It was cities building public health departments.
Yeah.
So Detroit was the first health department in the whole state.
Long history in public health. And I remember, so anybody who grew up in Detroit in a certain era, Herman Kiefer was synonymous with the health department.
Right. And it's this 1885-built, Albert Kahn-designed huge hospital. Still there.
Right. They sold it to a developer. Didn't get developed.
But crazy thing, Charity, I remember when I got that job, I get a call from the state being like, 'Hey, so you're the new health director.' I'm like, 'Yep.' They're like, 'All right, so we need you to go to Herman Kiefer because when they shut down the health department, we think they might have left some sensitive medical records.'
There are tunnels at Herman.
There are tunnels connecting the whole complex.
Yeah. Like literally for my first week of work, and I'm like, 'Uh, yeah, I'll send somebody.' They're like, 'No, we actually need you because you may actually be liable.'
Oh, wow. Because the health department didn't exist and now it exists, and so you're the health official, so we think you're liable, so you need to go check.
Oh my gosh.
So I pulled up to Herman Kiefer, and there's this one security guard guarding it, and I had figured out how to get in touch with security to let them know we were coming, so he expected me. And I'm like, 'Hey, so we need to go into the tunnels to take a look to see if there are old files.' And he's like, 'The tunnels?' I'm like, 'Yep, the tunnels.' So you walk into Herman Kiefer and it's like everybody just went on an extended lunch break.
All the stuff's still there.
Right. Like people just up and left.
They just left. Just like everybody go home.
Everybody's like, 'All right, we're all going to lunch.' And then nobody came back.
And the health department was closed for how long?
Three years. They privatized out all of the state-funded programs to a nonprofit, and it just got severely mismanaged because the nonprofit doesn't have government power, right? And so I walk into the old municipal parking department. And what had happened is the nonprofit brought all of the employees back to the back of the municipal parking department building, all working in one room, like maybe twice the size of this, and we're trying to rebuild this health department. I don't know if you remember this, but the first thing that I get assigned to fix, because it's a gaping issue, is animal control.
Oh yes, I do remember this.
And I had been a professor like weeks before.
I had no idea how to work with media. We're getting protested every day. It's a story on the news every day. And honestly, I have no clue. So we were in this 1927-built building, and the guy who manages this has just no interest in any of it. The budget was under the police, but I was being asked to fix it.
I like that was just the... But hey, here's the thing.
They went from a kill rate of nearly 80% to, by the time I was done, our live release rate was nearly 80%.
That's awesome. So we turned it around, and it's funny because, you know, we have two cats. I got bit by a dog when I was a kid. So I'm like, you know...
I was like, 'All right, you know what? I feel like I've done my part by saving dogs.'
And it's funny because they're hitting me now. They're like, 'Well, you know, when Abdul took it over, it was a terrible situation.' I was like, 'And then we fixed it,'
which is what you want government to do, which is to fix problems.
Yeah. Let's talk about Medicare for All. So I want you to explain it to me. Like, I don't even know what Medicare is. Like, in the simplest terms, what is Medicare for All? And then we're going to talk about... I got some myths I want you to bust for me.
I love it.
So let's just start with where people get their insurance. Now, chances are you're privately insured.
You got that card that says Blue Cross Blue Shield on it.
Yep. And that card in theory should help you pay for your healthcare.
Here's the problem with it. There's a network and an out-of-network. So you can't just take the card anywhere. You've got to go where your insurer says you can go.
Then there's a copay,
which is money you pay.
I did that this morning. Had a doctor's appointment.
You had money you pay every time you see a doctor.
Then there's a deductible, which is the money you have to pay before the card actually kicks in. Then there's the premium you pay to have the card. So your employer, in your case, you know, you sell the...
right? So your employer pays for some of it, right? And then you pay for some of it out of pocket.
That's called a premium. I don't know why it's called a premium. Like when I think premium, I'm thinking like Haagen-Dazs ice cream. I'm not thinking what I pay to an insurance company, but that's called a premium, right? So you got a premium, copay, and deductible.
And then you've got a network. Okay.
Now imagine you had this other card given to you the day you're born. It doesn't expire if you lose your job, if you turn 26, if you get married, you get divorced,
turn 65. Always you can lose your health insurance. It doesn't expire at all. There's no network.
So I can go see any doctor.
Any doctor, no premium, no copay, no deductible, just health insurance. Now, Medicare right now is a program for seniors that guarantees health insurance. We want to take that Medicare and make it better because there are holes in Medicare right now.
But we want to take that Medicare and make it better so that there's no premium, no copay, no deductible, pays for your healthcare costs, does not expire, and we want to give it to everybody. That's what Medicare for All would be. So what would it mean, right?
Charity, I know you work with small businesses every day.
Yep. Every small business owner that I talk to tells me that healthcare is the worst thing.
It's hard if you can afford it.
So there are many of our members, even, you know, I own a coffee shop, that you want to be able to compete, you know, with the large coffee shop that rhymes with Narn.
I think it's called Buck Star,
but yeah, something like that, right? But they're providing health insurance, tuition, you know, for their... And when you know I got to hunt to eat, right? How do I compete in that space? And so that's why when you and I had that conversation, it was really interesting to me. Let me ask you this. I'm going to ask some myths about Medicare for All. So with Medicare for All, who chooses my doctor? Is it true? Okay, no, I'm going to do it like this. True or false? I'll say true or false. The government chooses the doctor.
You choose a doctor. Okay.
Everyone pays more taxes.
The rich pay a lot more taxes, and all of us pay less than cost. So I just want to think this through for a second.
When you pay your premium, I want you to think about this. Do you pay the premium, or does it just come off the top of your paycheck?
It comes out the top of my paycheck. The irony is not the irony, the unique situation that I'm in as the CEO is that I get to see our company account paying premiums regularly coming out of the bank account, and then I also get the privilege of seeing it coming out of my personal bank account because I have health insurance.
And that's the thing. So you pay that. Now, here's the thing about it. Every year, chances are you're young and healthy. You pay a lot more into the system than you get paid out.
Right. Where does that money go?
Well, think about it. They're a business.
Their CEO makes how much?
We'll just say it's eight figures.
Okay. So, you know,
and when you say their CEO, you're referring to the insurance companies or...
Private insurance company.
Private insurance company.
And then you think about their COO, their CFO, the whole C-suite. And then they have the audacity to put up billboards that say affordability matters.
You can't make it up. I'm like, yes, you should sit here and look at your billboard. But like, who paid for that billboard?
You trying to... I didn't even finish my coffee this morning.
I'm just saying like that billboard costs money.
You paid for it every time you pay a premium. So here's the thing. Imagine I take off that 20% overhead.
Yeah. And then all the overhead that exists because of all of the healthcare providers and the insurance trying to figure out how to talk to each other.
Yeah. So instead of the money coming off the top of your paycheck like a tax, it's less, but instead it goes to a government that you actually have oversight over.
Do you think it's possible?
Yes. I wouldn't be doing this if I didn't think it was possible. Here's the thing about it. We're the richest, most powerful country in the world.
That's right. It's so wild to me. Like imagine we use the same argument that we use to discredit the possibility of Medicare for All about the military.
They'd be like, 'Listen, hey, Latvia has a terrible military. So how come we want a military?'
We're like, 'No, we're the United States of America.'
So when we do it, we do it well.
Yeah.
So everybody does this about healthcare. They're like, 'Well, that other country, they have problems.'
So we can't possibly change.
I'm like, 'We got problems.'
And we're the richest, most powerful country in the world, and we're the United States of America. So don't be telling me how great we are when it comes to dropping bombs on other people and not telling me how great we are when it comes to providing healthcare for our own people.
Makes no sense to me. I believe in America. I believe that when we put our minds to something and decide we're going to do this well, we do it well.
We can do it with excellence.
When it comes to healthcare, I think we can do it well.
Let's talk about disparities in healthcare. You know, we see the impacts of this. Our members, we're the Black Business Alliance, and I know you've seen this, you talked a little bit about it. How do you imagine that even in a role at the Senate that you could impact healthcare disparities?
Well, you know, Charity, this is the cause of my life, right? And the reason I came to the city, I told you infant mortality affected my life. I have an aunt and uncle I never met that died in infancy. My dad was my grandmother's eldest, watched both of his siblings pass before he turned five.
I remember telling my dad I want to be a doctor, and he had this guttural response like, 'Why would you do something like that?'
Because for him, doctors failed his siblings.
Yeah.
In Detroit right now, right, Black moms face four-fold the probability of dying in childbirth.
Their babies face two times the probability of dying in infancy than a child 15 minutes away. That is a moral stain on our country. And while I was in the city and in Wayne County, we built programs like Sister Friends, made sure that folks had transit to be able to get to prenatal care visits, worked with Leslie Welch, who's now doing amazing work at Birth Detroit. She was my deputy director when I was in the city.
In Wayne County, we led the largest expansion of RX Kids to provide cash support for pregnant moms and babies. There's a lot we could do in the federal government if we were serious about solving this problem.
And it would start with Medicare for All.
Why? Because right now a disproportionate number of Black moms are on Medicaid. Medicaid is a critical safety net program, but it's a safety net program. It reimburses at about half the rate as private health insurance. So I want you to think about what that means. That means when I provide healthcare for somebody who's on Medicaid, the care for their body is worth half as much as the care for somebody else's body.
That's what that means. So when you value healthcare for somebody's body at half the rate, what are we talking about here?
What is the experience going to be?
So one of the most important things we could do is say actually it doesn't matter who you are, your body is going to command the same reimbursement for the same care.
And it changes the way that a provider is going to engage because a lot of providers just don't take Medicaid-eligible patients anymore.
Yeah, that's true. And the ones who do think about them as second-class citizens...
Exactly.
So when we talk about disparities, there are so many factors that contribute to this, including economic factors where the Black Business Alliance were supporting small business. Talk to us about some of the conversation you and I had a few months back about your vision for small business and how you see what is the possibility in the future of economic growth for small business.
So let me step back to frame this.
People know I want three things. I want money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for All. Now everybody asked me why you start with money out of politics. I'm like because everything starts with money in politics. Let me just be clear. You and I both understand how economic development, quote unquote, works.
Too often what happens is you've got some big corporation's got a great connection to an elected official because they literally help fund their campaign. Then the elected official gets elected. Then the lobbyist on behalf of that corporation calls up and says, 'Hey, we're looking at so-and-so project. Can you give us a tax break? Can you subsidize the project?'
Small business don't have that.
They do not. Now your tax dollars are literally going to subsidize a big corporation in a local community. So how about instead of doing that, we take the same money we would have given in tax breaks to a big corporation and invest it in more revolving loan funds to enable new businesses to grow.
People like to hit me and say, 'Oh, Abdul, he's not a capitalist.' I'm a capitalist. I just know that we don't live in capitalism.
Yeah. Yeah.
When a big corporation, we just talked about them, right? Buck Stars, right? Like when a big corporation can use their power to influence government policy,
they block out competition. That's anti-capitalist behavior.
Because capitalism is about the market. Let the market decide.
Let the market cook.
But if you got enough power in the market that you can out-compete anybody and you can shift government policy, that's anti-capitalist.
So what I want to do is I want to enable small businesses to build real capitalism.
I would rather live in an economy where we have a thousand millionaires than one billionaire.
I saw that. I was like, 'Okay, that's it.'
But that's the thing. It's like, how many millionaires can you make for one billionaire?
A thousand. And people don't think about it that way. They're like, 'Well, the billionaire worked hard.' I'm like, 'Did they catch a couple breaks?' And then all of a sudden because of the nature of our system, it's like you catch a couple breaks and you catch all the breaks.
You said something I saw, which by the way, we got to talk about how you're a whole celebrity now.
I don't know about that. Just ask my wife about that. She knows I'm not a celebrity.
But you were talking about, you were sparring with someone on Fox and they were talking about billionaires working hard getting paid off from their labor, and you talked about their money makes money. Is that like...
Yeah. I mean once you got enough money, right? You know how billionaires live? They don't go to work and then come home and get a paycheck. They're not worrying about their W-2 or the premium.
They're not checking out the premium.
No, you know how they live. They literally borrow money off the top of their billion. And because they got collateral, everybody's going to let them borrow money.
So they report negative income.
And because they report negative income, what do you think they're paying in taxes?
Nothing. It's interesting because one of the biggest issues that we see for our Black businesses and small business trying to access capital is lack of collateral.
Is lack of collateral. We just did a report that we're going to release soon that's talking about some of these issues. So I think you're right to talk about equity in this way, that we need an economy that centers small business as opposed to big corporations. And what you're doing here is you're building a hub that enables people to bring together their human capital to leverage that for capital, right? So like...
Here's the thing about it. I get it. Like if you're a lending institution, you want to make sure that if you offer a loan that there's going to be something you can do, but there's so many folks in community who've done this before. So you can imagine a situation where you can have a bank and a CDFI come together to say, 'Look, we're going to back a project.'
We're going to have a more seasoned business owner who is part of the project with a sunset plan.
Who then comes in and backs the project and then enables a new entrepreneur to form with a plan of saying, 'Look, over the next three years, here's how equity is going to move.'
That enables that to satisfy the needs of the bank. The CDFI comes in as a booster.
Right now you've created a new entrepreneur, and the seasoned entrepreneur, they were able to leverage their experience to help build that business. Right? And now the whole ecosystem works because here's the thing. When you've got a coffee shop next to a restaurant, next to a bookstore, everybody benefits.
This is what we talked about last week with Rep. McKenna, was this idea of capitalism but really talking about how we need each other, that you actually can't do this, we can't do this work alone, that we actually need community is actually the way that we actually will thrive and grow, and the individualism that we see is actually working against us. So...
Yeah, I mean it's also like community is your customers.
Community is your employees.
Right, community is the additive benefit of that other business that complements yours.
And I think the thing to me is also this, like every time you give that money to a big corporation based in Delaware, where's that money go?
I'd rather a small business owner make their millions and spend their millions here.
On other businesses. So you really have to think about it like an ecosystem. I think about it like a garden, right? If you let a few trees grow really tall, they shade all the rest of the garden and they destroy the garden.
Yep. So what you got to make sure to do is you prune the big ones and make sure that there's resources for the small ones to grow and build, and then the garden can build on itself.