CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Eric Schmidt gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Eric Schmidt
Chief Executive Officer, Relativity Space

Keynote : Eric Schmidt - Executive Chairman, Alphabet Inc.

📅 Nov 24, 2024 Internet Society On-Demand 52 MIN 38 VIEWS 43 SEGMENTS · 7 SPEAKERS
Originally published on Livestream.com on May 6, 2017 at 02:44 PM CDT (53 mins) Fireside Chat with Dean Merit E. Janow, Columbia SIPA

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:00Is that cross-border flow crucial to this innovation in these areas?
  2. 10:37How do you think about that problem?
  3. 12:30Are there technology solutions that you are designing or developing that you think help with this problem?
  4. 14:19What are your thoughts on if you're going to build some pillars, should we be trying to do that, or is it going to create more harm than good?
  5. 23:01How do you increase the cyber hygiene?
  6. 25:27How should we think about the ups and downsides of platforms in a world of several enormous and important ones?
  7. 28:02How do you think about that?
  8. 33:40Could you speak a little bit more about both what you see this potential as being, the exciting potential, as well as the challenges?
  9. 40:14My question is, are you describing, is your statement normative, this is how you would like American people to behave, or is it descriptive, this is how American people actually believe? And do we have data?
  10. 43:21What I try to say is that the productivity, the economists keep on saying is going down or stagnating, but which is not true because a lot of it is not really calculated in the old way. What do you think?
  11. 46:04Or if not, will you be doing things on your own? How does the change switch?
  12. 47:56What is your opinion on technology tax?
Interviewer 0:00 ↗
Well, I can't tell you how pleased I am to be joined by Eric Schmidt for this discussion. Could I invite you to take your seats and we'll get underway? As you know, of course, Eric Schmidt is Executive Chairman of Alphabet and is in a really unique position to help us think through some of the challenges and issues we're discussing today. As the head of one of the world's largest technology companies and as Executive Chairman of Alphabet, he's responsible for the external matters of all of the holding company's businesses, advising the CEO and leadership on business and policy issues. He joined Google in 2001 and helped grow that company from nearly a startup phase to a global leader in technology. He served as CEO from 2001 to 2011, overseeing the company's technical and business strategy along with the founders Sergey Brin and Larry Page. Under his leadership, Google dramatically scaled its infrastructure, diversified its product offerings, while maintaining a strong culture of innovation, which is also the subject of a recent book that you have written. I'm very pleased that we had a chance to discuss it a couple years ago, about a year ago you helped me sell the book. Thank you. It needed very little help. So thanks so much for being with us. This morning we've just finished two framing conversations looking at the cross trends of globalization driving economic integration and interconnection, at the same time tensions and frictions that are arising in the system. So I'd like to invite you to start us off with just your own sense of framing on how important is this free flow of data across boundaries in enabling the technological innovation that we think of as important, things like Internet of Things, the app economy, outsourcing of services, cloud computing, the potential of big data, and many other things you would speak to and think about. Is that cross-border flow crucial to this innovation in these areas?
Eric Schmidt 2:27 ↗
Well, thank you. It's great to be back. I really like the fact that you put this together on subjects that I care a great deal about, and I think we all do. When I think about the internet, I start with the story of naivete. The internet, and I was sort of present near the beginning, was really about people who had a different model of how society was going to work, and sort of built it without much supervision from anyone. A small team of people basically interconnected this thing starting roughly in the 70s. It was commercialized in 1991 by various changes in the government. But the goal was to have a true sphere of communication of all people. People were sufficiently naive, of which I was the chief naive person, that there was no notion of security. One of my projects when I was a programmer was I wrote a mail system that allowed you to impersonate anyone else trivially. It made perfect sense. The internet at the time was designed without any core security protocols, any core definition of identity. So if I look back over 45 years of this, the fact that the internet has become so fundamental to everything is one of the greatest and most pleasant surprises of anyone's life, and certainly of mine. But also we're now dealing with some of those core errors. So let me state right up front that almost all of the interesting progress going on in the world is going on because of the internet or in spite of the internet. It is now fundamental. I used to give these speeches where I would say, 'Hey, you know, you can turn this thing off, right? Go back to being a normal person.' And I think the reality is that if you look at your students here, you look at the sort of next generation of users, our customers if you will, collectively it's too fundamental to their lives in every aspect. And you know, is the cross-border nature of that fundamental? Or is it for big economies enough to have a US internet or China internet, Europe internet? Well, there's a... Jared Cohen was here, I think yesterday or the day before, and he and I wrote a book together on this. At the time we were very concerned about the Balkanization of the internet. Someone was in the audience from the Balkans and they found that offensive, so let's just use the word fragmentation instead of Balkanization, which is what I really mean. The question is, if you're a little itty-bitty country, can you have your own internet? And the answer is almost certainly not, because little countries are by nature trading companies, they are codependent on the others. Can a very large country such as China actually cut itself off? Again, 10 years ago I would have said no. Today I think that there's evidence that they can do that, or at least they can have the internet on their terms as opposed to our terms. So for the last, since I'm not CEO anymore, I've wandered around preaching my religion, which is open expression, interconnectivity, things you all care a great deal about. A typical example is you go to an autocrat who runs the country and you'll say the internet is really, really good for your country because the autocrat's primary objective is economic growth and perhaps the spoils of that, and certainly more power. So that message makes sense to typically him. Then you go to the opposition leader who's trying to build a democracy and you explain that the internet is just as important to he or she because of the empowerment of political speech, opposition information, and so forth. But what you conclude over all is that as Americans, most folks here are either American or obviously live here, we are critically dependent upon global integration. We are safer, literally safer, because two billion people were lifted out of poverty. So if you think of it in the context of war, right, and humans are very, very good at killing each other at the nation-state level, look at our history over 2,000 years, right? You can make an argument that the internet is a core constructor of at least peace.
Interviewer 6:59 ↗
And you know, we had a bit of a discussion earlier about whether we should think of this as fragmentation or segmentation, and that in fact there could be safety and soundness that follows from certain kinds of...
Eric Schmidt 7:10 ↗
No, here's the way this works. I'm sorry, I didn't mean to be so rude, I apologize.
Interviewer 7:15 ↗
No, it was very clear.
Eric Schmidt 7:17 ↗
Okay. So here's the problem, and this is what we do at Google every day. There are actually differences between countries on things that have been litigated for a thousand years. For example, copyright laws differ. The definitions of free speech, let's use Nazi speech. Nazi speech is horrific, is illegal in Germany, horrific and legal in America, right? That's not an endorsement of it, guys, it's just true. Right? You have to have an internet that can accommodate the differences in laws. In my exhaustive survey of this with our lawyer, I can tell you there's one thing that all of humanity agrees is evil, and that's child pornography. Thank goodness, right? And indeed the internet is quite good about child pornography in the sense that there are algorithms that have been used so that when this evil stuff shows up, we can essentially provide a hash of it, algorithmically determine that it is in fact the bad content, and suppress it. Right? So if that's the only thing we really agree on as a global society, and I'm talking about legally now, I'm not talking about morally, then we need to work on other agreements of what's appropriate. But for the same reason that we don't agree on that, I don't want other countries' rules affecting the US laws. I want the US to be in charge of those laws, and the inverse is true. So you have to build systems that are flexible with respect to the local laws. Another example, we learned this the hard way in Thailand. I didn't know this at the time, there's a very, very severe law with respect to criticism of the king. And again, we're operating well in Thailand at the moment, but this was now a decade ago. Someone posted a video on YouTube that was critical of the king, which is a clear crime, and it is not okay clearly in other countries. And so YouTube was shut down for a year, right? So that was a pretty heavy penalty for a single individual, right? Who I don't know who it was, but I was told that this particular person fled the country and so forth. This story is repeated over and over again in social media that cross national boundaries. Now if you're a sort of a liberal American internet person, you say, 'Well, isn't it great that all these people are talking to each other?' There are plenty of organizations and countries that don't want this content in their country. So you have to come up with some sort of reasonably flexible model which will allow you to operate globally, and that's what all the internet companies are struggling with. And you know, one thing I worry about, since I sort of moaned, what I worry about is the slippery slope of censorship. So we are very strongly opposed, at a company level, against censorship. So what happens is somebody says, 'This is clearly bad and we should censor it.' Okay. And then they use that to argue for another level of censorship, and then another level of censorship, and soon you have a censored internet. We effectively have that in Turkey by the way today, through a series of builds.
Interviewer 10:37 ↗
Well, I was thinking as you were speaking of perhaps French privacy thinking that it should have a global reach. How do you think about that problem?
Eric Schmidt 10:48 ↗
Well, let's talk about the specific issue. There is a bill in France which has been described to me as saying that the right to be forgotten, which is a law in Europe, technically it's a found law from the European Court of Justice which we opposed. That particular law allows people, if they're not a public figure and it's not material to the public standard, which is not defined, that information can be withdrawn from the internet, although still published on the sites that it's at. We argued against this, I testified against it, and so forth. Nevertheless, that is the law in Europe. The question is, should that law now apply to the US? What would the Americans say? It's pretty obvious. In the same sense, I don't think the French would particularly want some aspects of our law in their system. So that's where the negotiation is. I understand on a personal basis why countries feel this way, they want to do this, but it's not how the internet works. So our answer in the case of France is that there's a French country domain which we are absolutely 100% compliant with. But the technical term here is global removal. If we establish a principle of global removal, that the French would have... The French are certainly a strong democracy, they have an important election on Sunday, they're certainly great people, they certainly have a long tradition on these things. But should they make the decision for the global content? I'm not sure that the US and the Russians and the Chinese and the Indians would all agree to the same terms.
Interviewer 12:30 ↗
Of course, this is not the first area where this has revealed itself. Jurisdiction is a fundamental problem in the globalized world. Are there technology solutions that you are designing or developing that you think help with this problem?
Eric Schmidt 12:48 ↗
So there are some issues that are not resolved in an obvious way. So if you want a global standard of content, is the rule for your global standard the least common denominator, that is the most censored, or the most liberal for the global standard? Right? I'm asking that rhetorically. I would prefer, and I think our company would prefer, and I suspect you all would prefer, the lowest possible level of censorship, right? But there are other people and other countries and other religions that would strongly disagree with us, right? So how do we adjudicate that? And they feel, and I'm trying to channel their anger, that this is American hegemony. In other words, we built it and now we're enforcing our values on them. This is what they say to me. And so then it becomes an important negotiation where we say, 'Well, look, we really believe in the empowerment of individuals and the empowerment of this information, and we think you're better off if you embrace this to some degree.' Try telling that to an autocrat whose power derives precisely from the omission of fact, right? So again, these are trends which have nothing to do with the internet, they have to do with societies organized. But I would hope that all of us would agree that open political speech and at least partial, if not full, democracies are a better way to run a country.
Interviewer 14:19 ↗
You know, we've seen in the postwar period some institutions designed to deal with the economic flows. The WTO is one, I served for some years on that panel body. And digital trade was really never part of the regime, although it has crept in through certain non-discrimination and services protocols. So one might think about the problem that you're raising, differences in national preferences, as requiring some kind of effort at an international level to create rules, or bilaterally or regionally. There's a debate about multi-stakeholder, how to incorporate that, etc. What are your thoughts on if you're going to build some pillars, should we be trying to do that, or is it going to create more harm than good?
Eric Schmidt 15:10 ↗
Well, I think that the globe is much better off because of the multilateral institutions that were created largely after the Second World War. If you look at all the systems of global trade, global commerce, global banking, they all have in their root a set of our predecessors, if you will, who saw that the sum of us was better than the individuals, right? It's quite obvious. And partly that happened because America was 85% of the global GDP at the time, right after the war, and that we could essentially dictate American terms. Now that's not what they said, and so forth, but we sort of got a free pass here because 60 or 70 years ago we had a greater influence than our population would have indicated. So it seems to me that now that we have, America invented the internet but the entire world depends on it, what percentage control should we have? Most people agree that the IANA structure has been a good one, right? That it has allowed a multi-stakeholder process. And again, there are complicated issues of where it's managed and who controls it, but the fact of the matter is that there's value there. My concern is that I don't see these issues coming so fast, and the consensus building in peacetime is so long, which I'd rather have peacetime than wartime obviously, that I don't know that it's going to happen fast enough. My current favorite example has to do with the militarization of cyberspace. There are many computer science and technical people, we have computer science in the room, who feel that this newest phenomenon where governments are using the internet to attack other individuals, companies, or nation states is really a bad thing for all sorts of reasons, which we can go into. And there are many people who think that, well, wouldn't this be a perfect example of a treaty? Okay, well I don't need to tell you all how long it takes to do treaty negotiations and so forth. And we can have a separate debate as to the likelihood of that treaty. But if this stuff is this important, then maybe we should start thinking about what are the treaties that would allow for multi-stakeholder collaboration, individual countries' freedom, but full integration of the global sphere which we are critically dependent on as a society. Right? So again, just to make sure I say it clearly, the core thing about technological progress is time, and the core aspect of time is communication. We now have almost all of the interesting developments in science, which I care a lot about, occurring across national borders in nanoseconds because of fiber optics, right? So if you go to the history of drug development, you'd have so-and-so would develop it and then they'd wait six months for both the shipments and the letters to arrive from New York to Paris or what have you, and then they would make more progress and then they would ship it back and so forth. That compression of time, which is core to economic growth, core to efficiency, core to human health, core to prosperity, core to IQ, intelligence, education, you name it, right? That's one of the greatest accomplishments of the internet. And I do not want to see anything that slows that down, right? Because the challenges of growth, the issues that we're going to face over the next hundred years, will be strongly enabled by that. Imagine if you didn't have that. Imagine if communications with Europe required a boat. Just think about it.
Interviewer 18:49 ↗
So you know, one of the things I think we're going to puzzle over is what are the steps that can be taken to increase trust, both technologically and otherwise. Just this week we had some attacks going on Google Docs and Google could bring it down almost immediately. I would think, well we did, I think we did it in a few minutes. And so they had a huge press cycle that inspires some trust. If you have that problem and you can correct it very quickly, few companies can do that.
Eric Schmidt 19:21 ↗
Yeah, by the way, the headlines didn't say 'Google fixed this in 30 seconds.' The headlines say 'Big bug affecting everyone in the internet.' By the way, just to be clear, the actual story is someone figured out a way to create a false secondary page, which we then figured out that they had done this and we blocked it. Okay? But because of virality, it spread very quickly. So the correct story, not to tell the press what to write, was this was discovered, it was fixed just like that. Hey, that's how it's supposed to work.
Interviewer 19:55 ↗
So I was trying to give you an open to talk about trust, and that's one example. What others would you speak to about how we inspire more trust?
Eric Schmidt 20:05 ↗
Well, the first question I always ask about trust is, are the people trying to improve trust or increase distrust? Right? So we have lots of evidence, for example in the election, that Russia was involved in confusion, shall we say, in the US elections. And there's some evidence that that's now going on in Europe. So not all the players have the same collegial goals that members of this audience do. And so what do you do in the presence of people who are trying to destabilize as well as stabilize? I think to me that's the core question. One way to understand that is that it's possible on the internet to create large amounts of misinformation for your own purposes that are not necessarily for the betterment of society. And it's relatively easy now to create information sources. A typical example is you'll get somebody who will utter a falsehood, which is a known falsehood, and you get another group that will try to magnify that by various forms of identity theft and making it look like this is some huge phenomenon. So the analogy in television is you've got two protesters, right? I'll give you a simple example. In 1989 there was a big earthquake in California, and there was a fire in the Marina. The fire was very severe and it consisted of three buildings. So the cameras were all placed on that fire, and that became the narrative that California was on fire. I remember this because I was in California, and California was not on fire, but these three buildings were. So we've got to be careful as a society around this pinpointing of information and then its expansion. I'm not criticizing the coverage of the earthquake in 1989, I'm just using it as an example. It was a fine outcome, it got fixed, and San Francisco went on to great success. I worry that these techniques in information markets can be used to create falsehoods that deceive either consumers or what have you. To me, this is the core issue of trust. There's a secondary issue which is, is the system itself being hacked? And the good news there is that there is technology in the form of very powerful encryption which is unbreakable at current technologies and likely to be unbreakable for the rest of our lives. The bad news is that these technologies are not uniformly applied. So for example, many of the government computers that we're using are very back rev because the government doesn't upgrade its software very quickly. That's a huge opportunity for hackers and people to steal data from the government. It needs to be fixed, and my view is that's a national crisis. Other people agree on this and people are working on this.
Interviewer 23:01 ↗
How do you increase the cyber hygiene? I mean, a lot of, we have the OPM hack is one example that you're referring to, but there are tremendous vulnerabilities that could be addressed if there was an upgrade of cyber hygiene generally. Do you think that...
Eric Schmidt 23:19 ↗
Well, let me start with this group and say that I'll give you the numbers roughly. 90% of the attacks are phishing. Phishing is where a page is presented to you that looks like a legitimate login page and it's not. So be very careful. This is what happened to John Podesta. There's a long, long list of victims in this space. About 10% are malware, and malware is where a piece of software gets inserted to your computer and it sort of takes over the computer in some complicated way. Both of these are best addressed by keeping the software of your computer platform up to date, and I mean the latest version, by using a browser that happens to be the most popular and the most free, which is Chrome, which does various checking, and then also two-factor authentication, that is a second factor, so not just your password. Most people, by the way, think that they have all three, and almost none of you have all three. So if I could do one thing with this audience, it is that sometime today add two-factor, make sure you're running Chrome which is free, and then if you want to have extra protection, use Gmail for all of your secrets. The reason is that Gmail is encrypted at rest as well as in transit. Right now people say, 'Really?' And I said, 'Yeah.' And in fact, many of the systems, and probably here in the university, they're not fully updated, they're not fully encrypted. That will take care of most of the issues, right? So that's a thing that you can do. With respect to the overall systems, like the OPM hack which I looked at pretty carefully, the core issue is that in the case of OPM and others, the government's systems were designed in the 80s and 90s and they're highly porous, right? And so it's reasonable to expect that this will continue until the government learns how to build proper integrated modern software. I know the current administration is aware of this, I know they have teams working on this. The Obama administration was working on it, I was part of that. It needs to get addressed.
Interviewer 25:27 ↗
Thank you. Let me shift topics and ask you to share some thinking about the role of platforms. I think you know we think about them now as matters of competition policy. We also see them as offering benefits for security purposes, you can run your systems, etc. How should we think about the ups and downsides of platforms in a world of several enormous and important ones?
Eric Schmidt 25:53 ↗
Well, we're in a situation where for most of my career we had one or two platforms that defined everything. So when I started it was the IBM mainframe, and then for a long time it was the IBM PC and in particular Microsoft. When the internet arrived, the internet sort of broke a lot of that up and gave people hyper-competitive choices. So today you have a number of platforms which are hyper-competitive against each other, and that hyper-competition is why your prices are so low for supercomputers. My best example here is the iPhone versus Android. The claimed market shares of the two: Android the market says is around 85%, iPhone is something north of 10%. That competition, right at price and scale and so forth, these are billions of phones across the two platforms, is the most brutal competition that I've ever seen, right? Just in terms of economics and movement and pressure and so forth. You benefit from that competition. So that's a good example where the platform structure ended up with real material consumer benefits globally. So notice that the two operating systems in that are done out of California, and the hardware is done all around the world. So there are people who want more competition, which I certainly agree with. I would rather have, using Europe as a specific example, I would rather have many stronger Silicon Valleys in Europe and many stronger platform companies, many stronger digital companies. I've spent a lot of time trying to develop this in Europe, I can talk about it at any length, rather than having the Europeans prohibit the entry of the global platforms into Europe, right? The problem is that there's always a possibility that this will ignite essentially a trade war, and a trade war is not beneficial to the Europeans, it hurts them. And so I have worked personally a lot on that.
Interviewer 28:02 ↗
Do you see the DSM as an effort to create more national champions, or is it creating distortions that are making it more difficult for interoperability? How do you think about that?

21 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Schmidt, E. (2024, November 24). Keynote : Eric Schmidt - Executive Chairman, Alphabet Inc. [Interview transcript]. Internet Society On-Demand. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/628767/

MLA

Eric Schmidt. "Keynote : Eric Schmidt - Executive Chairman, Alphabet Inc.." Internet Society On-Demand, 24 Nov. 2024. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/628767/.

BibTeX
@misc{schmidt2024_628767,
  author       = {Eric Schmidt},
  title        = {Keynote : Eric Schmidt - Executive Chairman, Alphabet Inc.},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Internet Society On-Demand. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2024},
  month        = {nov},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/628767/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}