CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Lars Moravy
Vice President of Vehicle Engineering, Tesla, Inc.

Tesla and Waymo execs testify before Senate panel on the future of self-driving cars — 2/4/26

📅 Feb 04, 2026 CNBC Television 132 MIN 32326 VIEWS 239 SEGMENTS · 14 SPEAKERS
The Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation holds a hearing Wednesday on autonomous vehicles. Witnesses testifying at the hearing include: Lars Moravy, vice president of Vehicle Engineering at Tesla; Dr. Mauricio Peña, chief safety officer at Waymo; Jeff Farrah, CEO of Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association; and Bryant Walker Smith, associate professor of law at the University of South Carolina. For access to live and exclusive video from CNBC subscribe to CNBC PRO: https://cnb.cx/42d859g » Subscribe to CNBC TV: https://cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision » Subscribe to CNBC: h...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 6:58And all I can tell you is strong oversight is needed. Why?
  2. 39:22So how are you dealing with supply chains?
  3. 1:03:36Share with this committee, how many new jobs has Tesla's automatic driving system already created in Texas and how many more are projected?
  4. 1:10:29Moravy, if a Tesla robotaxi is in an accident and there is a question about liability, it turns out that it was a software error, it's possible hardware error, who would accept the liability?
  5. 1:12:15And how much of your vehicle again for the record is made in America?
  6. 1:19:19So when NHTSA completes its rule and sets standards to passively detect drunk or impaired driving with the HALT Act, do you believe Tesla will be able to implement this technology in the near future?
  7. 1:21:40Will you commit to sending an order out and saying please stop that or not?
  8. 1:26:18From your perspective, what's at stake in this competition with China for autonomous vehicles and what happens if we lose?
  9. 1:36:59Could you tell me what things that you've worked on designing over your career have reduced deaths in automobiles, in passenger automobiles?
  10. 1:38:01And what has, what made it plateau?
  11. 1:45:33Moravy, I understand that Tesla offers no model that is wheelchair accessible right out of the factory. Is that correct?
  12. 1:56:43What are the economic benefits to the United States that we'll see if we can establish the right regulatory framework and what happens if China wins this competition?
Ted Cruz 0:50 ↗
Good morning. The Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation will come to order. America is at a crossroads in transportation policy. Autonomous vehicles, or AVs for short, are no longer theoretical. Like it or not, they are here and they will be central to the future of roadways. AVs are now providing mobility to the disabled, improving auto safety, and advancing technologies that have the potential to save millions of wasted hours in traffic, and even more importantly, to save tens of thousands of American lives. Yet, Congress has failed to establish a clear federal framework to govern AV deployment. That inaction is no longer neutral. It is unsafe. Without federal oversight, we risk a fragmented patchwork of state laws that could undermine safety, innovation, and American competitiveness. As we consider a surface transportation reauthorization bill, it is imperative that Congress act now to create a national standard for AVs. Even as some states seemingly wish to put up metaphorical roadblocks to AVs, other states are smartly getting into the fast lane. My home state of Texas understands that clear rules enable growth, investment, and safety. In Texas, AVs are moving freight on some highways and operating as taxis in cities like Austin. But AVs can't just stop at Texas's border. We should be clear about the resistance to federal action. Some insurance interests and advocacy groups argue against national standards, often under the banner of safety while opposing reforms that would modernize our system. The vast majority of automobile accidents and crashes are from human error. But lower accident rates challenge business models built on high premiums driven by preventable collisions. The reality is this. The overwhelming causes of roadway fatalities today are drunk driving and distracted driving. Autonomous technologies never drive drunk. Autonomous technologies, they don't text while driving. They don't change the radio station. They don't drop their sunglasses and look for them while driving down the freeway. Expanding AV deployment offers real, measurable opportunities to reduce these deadly behaviors and to improve safety on our highways. If we want to save lives and avoid tragedy for almost 40,000 families each year, we don't need lawmakers saddling automakers with expensive junk mandates that make little to no real difference. Instead, we should follow the data, follow the evidence, which increasingly shows advanced AVs reduce crashes and prevent serious injuries. We need a consistent federal framework to ensure uniform safety standards, liability clarity, and consumer confidence. Uncertainty benefits no one, not drivers, not manufacturers, and not state and local officials responsible for public safety. Some, but not all, insurers are responding to the data. Companies like Lemonade have lower premiums for vehicles using full self-driving mode, reflecting growing confidence and growing evidence that these systems reduce risk. The numbers confirm what many already see. Technology designed to reduce human error makes roads safer. Let's also acknowledge that the technological progress from AVs won't endanger jobs, that will ultimately create them. AVs require American engineers, software developers, safety technicians, mechanics, manufacturing workers, and infrastructure specialists. AV deployment can support new high-skilled jobs built in the United States by American workers. Moreover, AVs can make people more productive and traffic more bearable. If Congress fails to act, we're not going to stop innovation, we'll simply push it elsewhere. China is moving aggressively to deploy autonomous transportation at scale. The technologies at stake were developed in the United States. They can be built by American workers and they should be governed by American safety standards. A patchwork approach puts that leadership at risk. Finally, let me be clear about one other thing. The American consumer will decide what they choose to drive. No one is and no one should be mandating AVs. This isn't like Biden's de facto mandate killing the gas powered car. But government inaction should not deny consumers access to be able to choose safer options. A federal framework for autonomous vehicles is not about picking winners. It's about setting clear rules, improving safety, creating American jobs, and ensuring that states like Texas can continue to lead. Surface reauthorization is the moment for Congress to act. I'll now turn to Ranking Member Cantwell for her remarks.
Maria Cantwell 6:58 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think, you know, I certainly want to get the surface transportation bill done. And I think I've mentioned it as my number one priority since you're taking over the committee. So I hope we will get to that. I don't know whether this kind of legislation is the appropriate place for that. But I do know that nearly 40,000 people die on the roads each year. And thankfully we have seen how innovation in vehicle technology can make human drivers safer on the roads. For instance, automatic emergency braking technology has been shown to reduce injuries from rear collisions by 60%. These technologies are saving lives today. Fully autonomous vehicles offer the potential to reduce crashes on roads, but we have seen the risk of letting companies beta test on our roads with no guardrails. In 2024, a report from NHTSA linked Tesla's autopilot to hundreds of crashes, including at least 13 fatal crashes and many more injuries. Safety advocates have linked 65 fatalities to Tesla's automated technologies. These tragedies have occurred in my state. In April 2024, Jeffrey Nissen from Stanwood, Washington was killed when Tesla's autopilot system failed to recognize his stopped motorcycle. Tesla was allowed to market their technology, which they knew needed human supervision as autopilot because there were no federal guardrails. In fact, it was the state of California, not the federal government, that forced Tesla to change its marketing or lose the ability to sell in that state. So, I do believe that federal agencies have a role. But what's happened so far is the Trump administration has tried to gut NHTSA. The federal agency is responsible for ensuring the safety of vehicles. He basically in the efforts of DOGE lost 25% of their employees. I would say at this point in time it's trying to figure out what are the latest and greatest technologies and the people that understand them and can do appropriate oversight. Not basically gut the agency. At one point last year the office of automation just had four people. Four people. Four people. I don't even know if they knew about automation but only four people. Fewer resources mean less enforcement. NHTSA launched 41% fewer recall investigations last year than in 2024. NHTSA recalls protect consumers. For instance, over 67 million Takata airbag inflators have been recalled in the US after NHTSA confirmed that 28 people were killed when defective airbags exploded. Chrysler recalled 2.7 million vehicles after 51 people died in fires from gas tank ruptures and rear-end collisions. And I have a suspicion right now that a lot of repair dealers are installing faulty airbags from Chinese manufacturers that are failing to protect consumers. And where is NHTSA in protecting and finding out what is happening with these faulty airbags? Are we going to just continue to let people die in the United States? Without strong federal oversight, it is no wonder states are seeking to fill the void. You will hear today from witnesses that believe that the best way for the federal government to keep people safe is through a safety case for autonomous vehicles. Companies may try to reassure us that the safety case is a living breathing document, but I have my own experience having seen this played out in the aviation sector. And all I can tell you is strong oversight is needed. Why? Because the best engineers working on the best safety is going to deliver the best product and the best economies for us in addition to the best safety. So we cannot just rely on a checklist. I do agree, Mr. Chairman, we need a new approach. I'm happy to work with you on that approach. I have, you know, industry proposals seek to force autonomous vehicles into the existing framework of the Motor Vehicle Safety Act. This is the 60th anniversary of that law. The federal motor vehicle safety standard has prevented over 18 million crashes. However, the federal motor safety standards were designed to regulate bumpers and car doors, seat belts, and a variety of things that they're not on top of today. The law was passed 20 years before the first Windows computer was ever sold. So, it's time for us to get a NHTSA that understands technology and knows what to do with it. This revolutionary technology needs a new approach to safety that provides for flexible guardrails for beta testing and a clear path to safe commercial deployment. It needs to have an educated, as I just mentioned, strong safety oversight from officials and the resources to make it the gold standard just like we need in aviation. I did find interesting the House debate on this similar hearing in which I think California Teamsters basically came out and called for a Waymo ban in which a lot of anxiety existed really, Mr. Chairman, underneath was the fact that a law most people were concerned about somehow going to allow very large trucks to exist on our highways in automated vehicles. That seems to be the real crux of the issue. So just like everything else, the devil is in the details. The devil is in the details of how we get here. I noticed that after that hearing that again, Teamsters, safety advocates, even insurers found fault with a preemptive strategy that was unclear. I think we're going to hear from Professor Smith about that. But I think the last point of your statement is that, well, I like two lines in your statement. Quote, and people dying today not because we are careful about automated driving but rather because we are careless about the safety generally. And the notion that, further quoting you, quote, I have read many versions of potential preemptive language in every case the preemptive effect and even the preemptive intent of that language has been unclear to me. Okay, so we're dealing with this in AI and I do think we have to talk about the overlay of AI and AV and how that's going to work. And if we're going to have a preemptive strategy, then it has to be a real law and it has to have real teeth. And we have to understand exactly what we're doing. But please understand, many Americans, including Teamsters, are very anxious about how this plays out for them, how this plays out for very large trucks, and how we move forward on advancing both the safety regime that we need here and to continue to be leaders. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Ted Cruz 13:43 ↗
Thank you. I'd now like to introduce our witnesses for today. Our first witness is Lars Moravy, the vice president of vehicle engineering at Tesla. Mr. Moravy oversees the design, testing, and engineering at Tesla and brings more than a decade of hands-on experience, or more precisely, hands-off experience with automotive technology and vehicle safety. I will also note that I understand it's Mr. Moravy's birthday, so happy birthday. And to celebrate, we decided to hold a hearing. Our second witness is Mauricio Pena, the chief safety officer for Waymo. In this role, he leads Waymo's comprehensive safety efforts and brings decades of experience designing, testing, and deploying complex safety-critical systems across the aerospace and autonomous vehicle sectors. Our third witness is Jeff Farah, the chief executive officer of the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association. He represents companies across the autonomous vehicle sector, including technology, trucking, ride sharing, and automotive. Our final witness is Bryant Walker Smith. He is an associate professor of law in the Joseph F. Rice School of Law at the University of South Carolina, where he researches emerging transportation technologies and teaches product liability, torts, and transportation law. Mr. Moravy, we'll start with you. You're recognized for your opening statement.
Lars Moravy 15:09 ↗
Thank you, Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, and the members of the committee for the opportunity to appear before you today. My name is Lars Moravy, and I am the vice president of vehicle engineering at Tesla. Over the past 15 years, I've had the privilege of engineering the best cars in the world in a uniquely innovative way. In my role, I lead a team of over 6,000 engineers, technicians, and analysts who work tirelessly to make vehicles, batteries, machines, and other products that people love. I oversee our vehicle design, automation, and product manufacturing processes. My team and I develop new systems to ensure the quality, reliability, and performance of these products. I'm incredibly proud of the work we do. At Tesla, we believe autonomous vehicles are the future. AVs present an opportunity to significantly improve safety on the road and enhance accessibility to transportation for all Americans. AVs also provide an opportunity for the US to create jobs and reassert its dominance in advanced manufacturing for the 21st century. US automobile manufacturing was once a tremendous strength of this country and Tesla believes it can be once again. In the face of an unprecedented global challenge, we as a country need to lead the way in AV innovation to make that a reality. Tesla's manufacturing footprint spans 52 million square feet across the country, making the US one of the largest and most advanced electric vehicle production hubs in the world. Our Giga Texas headquarters alone is over 11.5 million square feet and ranks among the largest manufacturing buildings in the world. We know that the future of vehicle manufacturing largely depends on investments made now which is why we are doing everything we can to ensure that the US is an industry leader for AVs and EVs. We believe that AVs can fundamentally reshape how we travel. At Tesla we are relentlessly innovating to iterate and expand mobility independence and access for everyone. For example, our vehicles used in the autonomous driving services or robotaxis are designed to support various accessibility needs such as screen readers and room for service animals. But we also understand that safety is paramount. At Tesla, safety has always come first. Human behavior is one of the leading causes of accidents as drivers may be inattentive, distracted, speeding, or impaired. And by removing this human distraction from the equation, AVs will dramatically cut accident rates. We believe AVs are the next big jump in vehicle safety on our roads. We design our vehicles to exceed all relevant safety standards, and we're taking safety even further by pioneering AV technology designed to reduce collisions and save lives. Building on our industry-leading crash protection, active safety systems, and over-the-air safety improvements, we are developing advanced AV features to continuously improve performance. We work tirelessly to bring the safest cars to the market today and to leverage technology and ingenuity to create the safest cars of tomorrow. That's the reason my wife and I put our children in the back of a Tesla every day when we bring them to school, because I know that the safety of our vehicles is second to none. For America to lead in AV technology, we must modernize regulations that inhibit the industry's ability to innovate. Federal regulations for vehicles have not kept up with the pace of the rapid evolution of technology. Many standards were implemented decades ago and do not adequately address modern advancements such as electric drivetrains, automated driving systems, and over-the-air software updates. We need American leadership for AV rules and regulations. NHTSA has the opportunity to set the standard not just in America, but in the world. To do so, Congress must take steps to modernize so NHTSA is equipped to address the realities of this new frontier. For America to maintain its position in global technological development and grow its advanced manufacturing capabilities, we must enact a federal framework for the development and the deployment of AVs. The committee has the opportunity to position NHTSA as a global gold standard for AV development. And to do so, Congress must advance this federal legislation so that these regulators are equipped to address the realities of a new frontier. And innovators like ourselves have a clear direction forward. Just as the US has historically led transformative technologies that reshaped global markets and enabled America to assert dominance in ways beyond mere transportation, it must now lead in the development of AVs. Tesla is committed to collaborating with Congress to create smarter, effective regulations that drive progress, increase safety, and make mobility accessible to all. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I look forward to questions about Tesla's role in advancing the American AV industry.
Ted Cruz 20:08 ↗
Thank you. Dr. Pena, you're now recognized.
Mauricio Pena 20:14 ↗
Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, and members of the committee, it's an honor to be here today. My name is Mauricio Pena, and I serve as the chief safety officer at Waymo, America's leading autonomous driving technology company. Waymo is the first and only company in the United States to provide fully autonomous trips to the public at scale. That means that no human is behind the wheel. When you ride with Waymo, you can enjoy a safe and reliable ride in a space of your own. Thank you for the opportunity to discuss why autonomous vehicles are not just a technological marvel, but a moral and strategic imperative for the United States. Tragically, 40,000 people die due to largely preventable traffic crashes on roads across our country every year with hundreds of thousands more injured, often in life-altering ways. Globally, more than 1 million lives are lost to traffic collisions annually. That's the equivalent of 20 commercial airliners falling from the sky every single day. These aren't just statistics. They are parents, children, friends, and neighbors. At Waymo, we believe it doesn't have to be this way. 17 years ago, we started as a moonshot born out of a simple but radical idea that we could use technology to eliminate serious injury and death on our roads and make autonomous transportation accessible to people who are unable to drive themselves. Our mission is to be the world's most trusted driver. And achieving that mission starts with safety. Today, we have driven nearly 200 million fully autonomous miles on public roads and served over 20 million trips to riders. The data shows that our technology, the Waymo driver, is making roads safer where we operate. Data from our first 127 million fully autonomous miles indicates our driver is 10 times less likely to be involved in a serious injury or worse crash compared to human drivers where we operate, and 12 times less likely to be involved in an injury-causing crash involving a pedestrian. We have developed the most rigorous peer-reviewed analysis to conduct apples-to-apples comparisons of human and automated driving data. We have a relentless safety-first culture that starts at the top and flows through rigorous governance processes. Every software update must be approved by our safety board before it ever reaches the road. For us, safety is not a competing priority. It is the foundation for every decision that we make at Waymo. Today, because of American ingenuity, determination, and investment, AVs are a reality for millions of people. Right now, we operate a fully autonomous commercial ride-hailing service for the public in Phoenix, the San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles, Austin, Atlanta, and Miami, providing more than 400,000 rides every week. Americans trust us to get them to their destination safely. And I'm inspired by the positive impact that we're making on their lives. Our riders are taking Waymo rides after their weddings to gain quality time with their families and even to the hospital to deliver their baby or back home with their newborn. We are there for our riders' most important moments as well as their daily needs. Waymo is an American success story, but US leadership is not guaranteed. We are locked in a race with Chinese companies for the future of autonomous vehicles. If they win this race, Chinese companies, not the US, will set the technical standards for the rest of the world. To win, the US needs a predictable, durable national regulatory framework that sets a high safety standard based on a safety case. Without it, we face a fragmented landscape of state regulations that foster uncertainty, slow investment, and create unequal access to the technology. To truly deliver on the promise of fully autonomous vehicles, we need federal leadership and we need it in this Congress. Chairman Cruz and members of the committee, we share your goal of ensuring a national AV framework is included in the surface transportation reauthorization bill. American leadership in autonomous driving technology must be defended. We look forward to working with you to ensure that American safety and American innovation are the gold standard for autonomous driving around the world. Let's not see the future, let's lead it. Thank you, and I look forward to your questions.
Ted Cruz 24:54 ↗
Thank you. Mr. Farah, you're recognized.
Jeff Farah 24:57 ↗
Chairman Cruz, Ranking Member Cantwell, members of the committee. My name is Jeff Farah and I have the privilege of serving as the CEO of the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association, the unified voice of the autonomous vehicle industry that is committed to American excellence in AVs. I am pleased to testify again this morning. Now is a time of great excitement and promise for the American autonomous vehicle industry. AVs are no longer a futuristic dream of a safer world. Autonomous vehicles are here. They are carrying your constituents to medical appointments, enhancing supply chains for farmers and manufacturers, and creating high-quality new jobs in a mission-driven industry. Autonomous vehicles are not just another application of AI. They are the exemplar of what AI becomes when it moves from the digital to the physical world. What federal policymakers decide to do or not do on AVs will send a clear message about America's commitment to AI leadership. I will use my opening comments this morning to describe two futures for members of this committee. We'll call them choice A and choice B. Choice A means seizing the moment for American leadership on autonomous vehicles. Under choice A, the future looks like this. Safer roads as the US drastically reduces the nearly 40,000 people who die on our streets each year. Enough to fill National Stadium at a sold-out game. More accessible vehicles that finally give new mobility options to the millions of Americans who are left behind by our current transportation system, which holds back the elderly, wheelchair users, the visually impaired, is too expensive and often does not provide the routes to get people where they need to go. New American jobs that simply did not exist until they were created by the autonomous vehicle industry. Jobs like AV fleet deployment specialists, technicians, fleet managers, and manufacturing workers. These jobs will power the future of the American economy. Choice A can be ours if we want it. It does not require a dime of taxpayer funds. Only Congress putting in place federal rules of the road that allow American innovators to thrive. We need action from Congress in these areas. First, raise the bar on safety for all autonomous vehicles by requiring the Department of Transportation to move forward on a series of rulemakings, including requiring that AV manufacturers develop a safety case, that is evidence and documentation demonstrating why their vehicle is safe to be on the roads. The Department of Transportation should also require that AV companies abide by a series of driving competencies so the public understands that the vehicles are safe. Second, put AV data reporting on solid legal footing by enshrining in statute a national AV safety data repository that has NHTSA collecting data and sharing vital information with state regulatory partners. Third, modernize federal standards related to vehicle controls that are intended for human drivers, thereby allowing innovators to develop next-generation vehicles that take meaningful steps forward on accessibility. A federal framework should complement the 26 state AV deployment laws already in place, not replace them. Regulating autonomous vehicles is a shared responsibility between the federal and state governments. But we need the federal government to step up. Under choice A, we set the global standards. We build the technology here. We create high-quality American jobs rooted in US communities. With choice A, America doesn't just adopt autonomous vehicles. America defines them. Then there is choice B under which we reject this opportunity and fail to put in place a federal policy framework. Choice B has the following consequences. China becomes the global leader on autonomous vehicles. At this moment, the People's Republic of China is devoting massive resources to the development of its national champions. It is not waiting to find out what American policymakers want to do. The state-run Beijing Review put it succinctly. Quote, 'Chinese developed autonomous driving technologies have made inroads into a growing number of global markets, citing activity in France, Spain, Switzerland, Luxembourg, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates, with one Chinese industry member calling the development of AVs quote, a hallmark of made in China innovation.' Finally, under choice B, we accept the status quo. Preventable deaths due to human error, transportation options that leave millions in the rearview mirror, faltering supply chains that let small businesses down, and states leading on AV policy with little guidance from their federal counterparts. Members of the committee, I implore you to choose choice A. This committee can on a bipartisan basis advance American leadership, increase safety standards, and create new high-paying and fulfilling jobs. And with the surface transportation reauthorization bill before this committee, you have the perfect vehicle to lead. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify this morning.
Ted Cruz 29:52 ↗
Thank you. Professor Smith, your five minutes.
Bryant Walker Smith 29:55 ↗
Thank you for your invitation. I'll offer seven points. First, American driving is dangerous. Automated driving could help if we're careful about it. But people are dying today not because we're careful about automated driving, but rather because we're careless about road safety generally. Other countries do care. Driving in the US is twice as deadly as in Canada and Australia. As a South Carolinian, I'm 10 times more likely to die in a crash than my friends in the UK. 10 times. These countries aren't hiding some vast secret fleet of AVs. I can't yet hail a robotaxi in London, but I can cross the street. Second, arrogance is careless. AVs have tremendous potential, but believing they will be a panacea virtually guarantees they won't because that confidence blinds us to risks. Many engineers working on AVs show humility. They talk with me about what's hard, what went wrong, and what's uncertain. They want to learn from local officials. I wish AV companies would show more of this humility in their PR. Third, the best proxy for the safety of AVs is the trustworthiness of AV companies. There are no self-driving or driverless cars. The companies that develop and deploy AVs are the drivers. This means that an AV is only as safe as the companies responsible for it. We can and should proactively assess their trustworthiness. AVs won't be perfect, but a company can still do right after its technology fails. It can explain what went wrong, how it's addressing the actual harm, how it's reducing future risks, and critically what it's learned more broadly. We need to see more of this. Doing right does not mean forcing victims into arbitrations, and it does not mean buying their silence and thereby misleading the public. These are betrayals of trust. Fourth, safety is a marriage, not a wedding. Safety is a lifelong commitment that continues as long as an AV is on the road. It's not just a one-time test or certification or checklist. A credible safety case must be a living document that is clearly supported, robustly interrogated, and routinely updated. Vehicles placed on our roads stay there for decades, and therefore need oversight for decades. NHTSA provides some of this oversight and AVs will dramatically expand the scope of it. Yet both NHTSA and FMCSA are tiny, under-resourced agencies with huge mandates. Fifth, AVs are an especially visible part of a much broader discussion of AI. As a society, we're likely to place many of our hopes and fears about AI generally on AVs specifically. The Transforming Transportation Advisory Committee which I vice-chaired addressed many of these issues including employment, accessibility, sustainability in the face of climate change, privacy vis-a-vis both companies and governments, and fundamental questions of power. For each we need clear policy goals and an iterative approach to achieving them. Sixth, local government has essential expertise. Few appreciate how much local governments are subsidizing automated driving. First responders, for example, solve all kinds of problems today, from waking up people in robotaxis to literally moving AVs that are stuck. These local officials deserve our respect. They want the people who remotely assist AVs to be in the US. They need to know AVs will help rather than hurt their response to disasters. They want to be able to ticket AV companies for moving violations just as they would any other driver. They emphasize that every city is unique and AVs must operate accordingly. Finally, we must empower, not disempower, our communities. Preempting state and local authority would be profoundly shortsighted. And I say this as someone who believes strongly in the potential of AVs. Many states want the federal government to lead on AV policy. But great leaders lead. Telling US DOT what to do and providing the resources to do it would help much more than telling states what not to do. Preemption could create litigation rather than certainty. It could bar states from getting unsafe vehicles and unsafe drivers, human or otherwise, off the road. Our AV industry started through federal research decades ago and then grew through our system of federalism. Brand America does have a serious credibility problem abroad, but preemption does not solve it. In a scary time of technological change, we need to make sure that communities and the people in them have control and feel in control. We can deploy both technology and policy in a way that protects and empowers them. Thank you.
Ted Cruz 35:08 ↗
Thank you to our witnesses. We'll now begin our questioning and I'll yield to my colleague Senator Blackburn to begin the questioning.
Marsha Blackburn 35:15 ↗
Thank you so much and to each of you. Thank you for taking the time to be here today. Mr. Farah, I want to come to you first. 2017 I was over in the House and chaired Comms and Tech over at the Energy and Commerce Committee and that is when we took the first legislative text to the committee to deal with autonomous vehicles and to allow this technology to flourish. We had worked on it for about three years to get to that point. And of course, we had some folks that did not realize the safety components that come from working on this technology. So, they chose to repeatedly shut down the guidelines that would be there for AVs. And I want you to just touch on how this technology, the autonomous technology, helps make our roads safer, helps make our vehicles safer and more responsive and how it is helping to reduce fatalities.
Jeff Farah 36:30 ↗
Senator Blackburn, thank you very much for the question. And before I answer, I'll just say thank you very much for all your leadership going back to when you were in the House and now here in the Senate. And I'll say that it has been quite a few years since a lot of this discussion has started. But a couple of things have really changed. The first thing that's changed is this is no longer science fiction. This is on roads. As I said in my opening statement, 26 states proactively authorize this technology. They are carrying passengers right at this very moment. So this is a reality for many Americans. The second thing that's changed is that we are no longer alone in the quest to have self-driving vehicles. We now have strategic competitors, most notably the People's Republic of China, that are bound and determined to be the global leaders when it comes to autonomous vehicles. But without a federal policy framework, we are asking our innovators to fight with one hand behind their back. And so that is why it's so important to pass a federal policy framework. And you touched on safety. This is the driving force behind our industry. We want to make our roads safer. We reject this idea that we just have to accept all the fatalities, accept all the injuries, accept millions of Americans being held back because vehicles are not accessible enough. And fundamentally, what we're trying to do with safety is we're trying to overcome human error. We're trying to overcome the things that Chairman Cruz talked about in his opening statement, the big drivers of fatalities in this country.
Marsha Blackburn 37:50 ↗
And Mr. Moravy, pardon me, and Dr. Pena, let me come to you. I know that you all are working on safety and we talked about this yesterday when we met and thank you again for your time. And one of the things that people are concerned about is the amount of consumer data. They like the safety. They want you to innovate. They want to lower fatalities. But they're saying, 'What kind of data are you getting?' So, how are you all collecting and storing and working through the data, Mr. Moravy?
Lars Moravy 38:41 ↗
Thank you, Senator Blackburn. And appreciate the time we had yesterday to discuss a little bit ahead of it. With regards to the data that we collect to improve our products, you know, we always use an opt-in policy and that occurs when you select the advanced driving systems. We always aggregate and anonymize the data to ensure customer privacy and then we use the swath of data that was collected to create generalizations about individual scenarios that we can improve.
Marsha Blackburn 39:12 ↗
Okay. So you do not store the data from the car, you anonymize that data.
Lars Moravy 39:20 ↗
That's correct. The data comes to our central.
Marsha Blackburn 39:22 ↗
Let me ask you this. I know you all are focused on US production. So how are you dealing with supply chains? And Dr. Pena, I'm coming to you on that one also after his answer.
Lars Moravy 39:34 ↗
Thank you, Senator Blackburn. Yeah, as you may know, Tesla produces four of the five top US-made cars and we've always been committed to building locally. We produce all of the vehicles sold in the US by Tesla in the US. We have facilities in both Texas and Fremont, California that do that and we work hard with our supply chain to ensure that they are also local to the US and North America. Over 95% of our parts come from North America.
Marsha Blackburn 40:02 ↗
Okay. Dr. Pena.
Mauricio Pena 40:06 ↗
We are not a vehicle manufacturer. We design and build an autonomous driving system. So that's the hardware and software that we then install onto a variety of vehicle platforms at our factory in Arizona.
Marsha Blackburn 40:22 ↗
But are you affected by supply chains? Is that a constriction?
Mauricio Pena 40:27 ↗
We like to have a stable supply of vehicles and so it does affect us.
Marsha Blackburn 40:32 ↗
Okay. All right. That's what I wanted to know. Thank you.
Ted Cruz 40:36 ↗
Thank you, Senator. I call on Senator Peters now for his questions.
Gary Peters 40:41 ↗
Yeah. Thank you, Senator Cruz. And thank you Ranking Member Cantwell for deferring. I appreciate that. As a senator from Michigan, I have long focused on issues related to autonomous vehicles, and I believe that today more than ever, Congress cannot continue to stand on the sidelines when it comes to AVs. First, we know that this technology is a huge part of the future of the global automotive industry. But right now, as has been said, China is investing heavily in dominating the autonomous vehicle market. So, I believe it's absolutely imperative that we take action to ensure that American innovation and American standards lead the way on the world stage and not China. Second, it's a matter of protecting good paying American jobs. Congress cannot be silent on a technology that will literally shape the future of mobility. Automotive jobs have been at the heart of my state of Michigan and our manufacturing economy for over a century and we need to ensure that those jobs stay here in America. And finally, and most importantly, as has been said, this technology will save lives. Today, more than 100 Americans die on our roadway each and every day. As we sit here today, 100 people will die today. And we must do everything we can to harness solutions with the power to bring that number as close to zero as possible. But that also requires building trust. Americans deserve to know with certainty that these vehicles will deliver safer streets and that federal regulators have laid out clear rules of the road. The bottom line, it's up to Congress to do something. And that's why today I'm calling on our chairman and my colleagues on the committee to work with me to make that a reality. And I'm calling for a bipartisan AV title in our next surface transportation bill. We can't wait any longer. With that, I got a couple questions. First, Professor Smith, you and I share the position that it is both avoidable and unacceptable to have 40,000 deaths on our roads every year. And I believe we need to harness every solution to that problem, as evidenced by the hearing that I held on this issue last year. And I believe that AVs are certainly part of that answer. However, even autonomous vehicles will not be perfect. We know that accidents will occur and I believe we should assess those incidents against the larger backdrop of our extremely dangerous roads today. So my question for you is in your opinion, how should legislators approach the idea of relative safety when it comes to AVs? And why should we not be satisfied with the default level of danger that we see on our roads today?
Bryant Walker Smith 43:22 ↗
Oh, thank you, Senator Peters, because the current level of carnage is horrific and is preventable and we know how to prevent it. And so with automated driving, we have these two different frameworks that are kind of in tension. One is the car framework. Can we save one more person? The other is the aviation framework. Any crash is a failure and unacceptable. And so automated driving is essentially this challenge of shifting from that first paradigm to the second. And so in assessing the safety of any crash, right, we could ask, well, did the system perform at least as well as a human driver in the equivalent scenario? Did it perform at least as well as a competing technology? And importantly, did it perform better than the last one that failed? In other words, we can't have static standards. The bar has to keep going up.
Gary Peters 44:13 ↗
Great. Well, I thank you for that answer, but I'd also, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to enter into the record an op-ed from a neurologist published in the New York Times about his experience with car accident victims and how recent peer-reviewed AV data is too promising not to pursue. I think it's important and would like to enter that in the record.
Ted Cruz 44:32 ↗
Without objection.
Gary Peters 44:33 ↗
One of the key reasons I believe Congress must act on autonomous vehicle legislation is because AVs represent a huge part of the future of the US automotive industry. We need to not only make sure AV technology is developed here, we also need to make sure these vehicles and their sensor suites are manufactured in America as well. Michigan autoworkers have led the nation and made the US automotive industry internationally competitive and I believe they can do the same for autonomous vehicles. Mr. Pena, Waymo currently does import vehicles from China to pair with its software stack. And I'm glad that you're moving away from this partnership, but from your perspective, how can Congress better ensure that AV companies prioritize US manufacturing and union labor when it comes to building the vehicles hardware of the future? And is this something that aligns with your company's vision of the future?
Mauricio Pena 45:27 ↗
Senator, we design and build our autonomous driving system right here in America. And as I mentioned before, we use a variety of platforms and we install an autonomous driving system
Gary Peters 45:46 ↗
Great time is low. Mr. Chairman, can I just ask a question for the record? Mr. Farah, some of your automotive manufacturing members, including Michigan's own General Motors and Ford, are driving consumer acceptance by introducing consumers to high levels of autonomy in their personal vehicles, including hands-free highway driving and more. That includes the goal of introducing level three hands-off, eyes-off driving technology for consumers to deploy when they choose. This way, autonomous technologies are delivering safety benefits in personally owned consumer vehicles today. Neither NHTSA nor Congress though has established a dedicated regulatory framework for level three systems. What do you think are the greatest regulatory gaps today for Congress to fill for level three deployment? I can enter that for the record to respond unless you have a quick response.
Jeff Farah 46:44 ↗
With the indulgence of the chairman, I would be very glad to elaborate on the response for the record. And certainly, level three is an important piece of automotive technology, and I didn't want to miss the opportunity to thank you for all of your past efforts on behalf of the AV industry.
Gary Peters 46:57 ↗
Great. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Ted Cruz 46:59 ↗
Thank you. We welcome any other responses afterwards as well. Well, I now yield to myself and appreciate our witnesses being here. Appreciate this topic. I think it's fair to say that there's broad agreement that Congress must lead on this. Professor Smith, I'll give you a little asterisk that states can play a role as well. And I think that's a worthy conversation. And I think that the real question isn't whether or not we should lead, but how we should lead without sacrificing data privacy, without sacrificing transparency, without sacrificing innovation. If not careful, the federal government can clamp down on innovation. And with that in mind, I'd kind of like to turn to the data privacy part of this. Dr. Pena, I was in Los Angeles this weekend and I noticed with some awe the number of your vehicles that I saw. Do you know roughly off the top of your head how many you would have in a market like Los Angeles? Semi vehicles.
Mauricio Pena 47:56 ↗
I don't know. Don't have an exact number for you, but there's a few hundred vehicles down there.
Ted Cruz 48:00 ↗
Yeah. Enough that you see them on almost every corner. Do you know per vehicle how many cameras are part of that?
Mauricio Pena 48:09 ↗
We have, I think, 29 cameras approximately.
Ted Cruz 48:11 ↗
29. Are any of those internal?
Mauricio Pena 48:15 ↗
Oh, yeah. We do have cameras internally to help our riders when they need it.
Ted Cruz 48:20 ↗
Sure. So, if you take 29 cameras and you times it by a couple hundred vehicles, the potential for data collection, that was my first impression when I saw that vehicle go by with those cameras, is the amount of data that potentially could be collected is staggering. And so, I think my first question for you and then Mr. Moravy is what internal policies do you currently have for data privacy?
Mauricio Pena 48:47 ↗
Yeah, we have strong privacy protections for our riders. We don't share any personally identifiable information, and when we are driving, we collect information to make our Waymo driver better. That is the only purpose of collecting data as we drive through our cities.
Ted Cruz 49:07 ↗
So, as a former mayor, I would often be approached if somebody had an accident and they wanted to go get the traffic information from our recordings on the lights. Is that a scenario that's possible where law enforcement's going to come to you and say, 'Hey, you were going by this intersection. Share with us your recordings of what happened at that intersection.'?
Mauricio Pena 49:28 ↗
Senator, we would only comply with a valid legal order, and even at that point, we would review it to ensure that it is not too broad, and if we believe it's too broad, we can object as well.
Ted Cruz 49:46 ↗
Okay, Mr. Moravy.
Lars Moravy 49:49 ↗
Yeah, similar to what Mr. Pena said, we do collect a bit of data. We have only eight or nine cameras in our vehicles today. All that data is for consumers, as I mentioned before, is an opt-in policy, but it is aggregated and anonymized when it comes through to our servers for review. And to your point about whether or not we comply with federal or state authorities for requests for data, actually Tesla has been doing that for almost 15 years now with our vehicles and the recordings that they take both in our event data recorders and our cameras whenever there is a pertinent legal order to do so.
Ted Cruz 50:30 ↗
Yeah. And I think that's, I don't want to overstate that point with complying with law enforcement. I think more of my point is the vast amount of data, particularly with 29 cameras collecting through a community, and have we really thought through that data and what to do with it. And Mr. Farah, I kind of turn to you as an industry, is the industry ready for this data privacy question and are you prepared or is industry prepared with future legislation to discuss how we deal with data privacy?
Jeff Farah 51:00 ↗
Senator Curtis, thank you very much. And I think that Mr. Pena articulated very well what's the industry standard, which is that you would need to get a valid order from a law enforcement agency or court in order to comply with that, and if it was appropriately overbroad, that would be something that the company would certainly evaluate. And I would say that we are very eager to participate as Congress, as this committee takes on future data privacy discussions, we absolutely want to be a part of that process.
Ted Cruz 51:23 ↗
Yeah, and I would point out we've got good actors at the table today, but as industry grows, you'll have people who may not take good care of that data, you may have data breaches. And I just think it's something that's very important for us to consider. We talked just briefly before the hearing about Utah. Utah would love to be a leader on this. We have the Olympics coming. We talked a lot about safety. Could you briefly just discuss traffic congestion and how a state like Utah might use autonomous vehicles to deal with less traffic on the roads and the impact that that could have on a state like Utah?
Jeff Farah 51:59 ↗
Absolutely, Senator. And as you know, I'm a huge fan of your state. As I told you, I've been there many times, and I will say that Utah is one of the 26 states that has an AV deployment statute. So, you're very well positioned to take advantage of this, including for the upcoming Olympics. In terms of traffic congestion, what we're really trying to do is to give more transportation options. So, in many cases, for example, in Salt Lake, this may be an elegant solution for moving people through city centers in a more effective way in some sort of shared-use vehicle. That's something that, on a city-by-city basis, we're trying to give new optionality.
Ted Cruz 52:28 ↗
Great. I've used up my time and I'll yield to our ranking member for her questions.
Maria Cantwell 52:32 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Professor Smith, you talked about trust and faith and building that over a period of time. My point is that the information age is delivering a lot of technology change. I'm not sure Boeing understood software as well as they should have understood software. I think here we may not have a NHTSA that understands these challenges either, but we certainly can't dismantle them. And we need to have people when it comes to AI or privacy, we need people in the federal government who are going to understand the issues. Otherwise, we're not going to do a good job. So, I think that's part of building that trust and faith you're talking about because you're going to continue to repeat issues. Not everything is going to be known. You're still going to, again, there's a difference between a beta program and a large-scale program and then something else you find out happens. So I'm trying to get to this point because we have these, you know, we have an autopilot issue. I mentioned a constituent of mine, Mr. Nissen, who was run over, he was on a motorcycle and he was run over by a Tesla car on autopilot that the family is saying did not detect the motorcycle. This isn't like blaming it on the people who were supposed to be in the car, although that is a pretty big debate that did the term autopilot mean something to the users of Tesla and then they're responsible. But I think the family in some of these cases, there was a case in Florida where they basically are saying no, it's still negligence because of the way autopilot was marketed. I'm assuming Dr. Pena, you like this binding arbitration that your users are under now, that they sign an agreement and then if something goes wrong... could you describe the user for Waymo, you basically sign an agreement that basically if there's a dispute about what happened you now are in a binding arbitration with the manufacturer, with Waymo, over the results of those cases. I'm trying to get to liability here. I'm trying to get to liability. So you approve that now, correct?
Mauricio Pena 54:41 ↗
Ranking Member Cantwell, that's not my area of expertise. My area is primarily AV safety. But I'd be happy to get back to you.
Maria Cantwell 54:49 ↗
Okay. My understanding, Professor Smith, these are just like binding arbitration contracts.
Bryant Walker Smith 54:55 ↗
It's very common in industry. Yes. Unfortunately,
Maria Cantwell 54:58 ↗
We are not going to take this common standard in software where I'm downloading a game or some app and now we'll apply it to cars. We're just not going to do that. I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to allow that to happen. I'm not going to sign a binding arbitration agreement with Waymo and then basically say I can't sue them. I'm just stuck in binding arbitration. I guarantee you this Congress isn't going to be for that either. The Senate has already taken action trying to be more aggressive. But where do we go with this issue, you know, of building that trust that you're talking about and showing Mr. Farah just said he doesn't believe in preempting states. That's a good thing. But how do we get this to the point where there is true liability so that people will build products and be accountable for them.
Bryant Walker Smith 55:49 ↗
Thank you. And the reality is that we all do sign these agreements every day agreeing to arbitration and we don't realize it. We don't realize it matters until we're hurt, until we're the victims, and then we realize that we can't use the courts and no one else realizes it because arbitration is often secret and therefore that information is not coming out. So you talked very much about trustworthiness. The companies in this field are necessarily saying to regulators and to the public, trust us. And that needs to come with substance, right? With great power comes great responsibility. So, they need to say, 'Here's what we're doing. Here's why we believe it's safe, and here's why you can trust us.' And then that needs to be interrogated by, as you've described, competent, capable, well-resourced officials. The idea that our automated driving office could fit in a McDonald's or our defects agency could fit in a warehouse is astounding to me for a country of this size and sophistication.
Maria Cantwell 56:53 ↗
Well, I think not. I think the chairman of this committee berated the then CEO of Boeing, Dave Calhoun, for, you know, basically breaking that trust and faith. I think Kelly Ortberg is trying to reestablish it and to say that no, it has to be based on good engineering and a constant accountability. But I do think figuring out the federal responsibility so that we can have predictability and certainty, but it has to come with some liability. It just does. And when you look at these instances of NHTSA playing this role in the past, it also had to come with changing a culture. We're trying to change the culture of the FAA right now. But you're going to have to change the culture. You know, when companies just want to go along and just keep promoting airbags that don't work, then that's a problem. You got to get rid of and change the culture. So anyway, I look forward to hearing more about what you think that federal framework looks like. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Ted Cruz 57:57 ↗
Thank you. Today autonomous vehicles are being deployed on public roads. Yet, there's no unique safety standard for AVs from the federal regulator, NHTSA. There's no federal framework governing their deployment. There's no accountability or consistency across states. The patchwork of state laws means that driverless AVs can be deployed commercially in states like Texas, Arizona, and California, but they aren't allowed in New York, Massachusetts, and Vermont, where a driver must be present. Or in the case of California, AV operational data must be turned over to regulators, but not in Florida or Michigan. Mr. Moravy, from Tesla's perspective, what risks does this regulatory gap create and why is a clear national framework necessary sooner rather than later?
Lars Moravy 58:47 ↗
Thank you, Chairman Cruz. Appreciate the opportunity to answer this question. As an original equipment manufacturer up here of autonomous vehicles, a patchwork of state regulations really presents a lot of uncertainty for us in producing those vehicles. When we talk about FMVSS regulations, it's important that we homogenize them for purpose-built AVs so that we have certainty and we have a path forward that is consistent across all 50 states.
Ted Cruz 59:22 ↗
Dr. Pena, when incidents occur with AVs, they're highly scrutinized in part because the technology is so novel and different. Recently, there have been incidents with Waymo involving school buses in Austin, and a child in Santa Monica, California. What safeguards has Waymo implemented since the school bus incidents in Austin, and how do you verify that these changes will protect school bus riders moving forward?
Mauricio Pena 59:51 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We take those incidents very seriously. Safety is our top priority, especially safety of children and pedestrians. We're evaluating every one of those events and developing fixes to address them. And we have already incorporated many changes to our software to dramatically improve our performance. And we are working with the Austin Independent School District to collect data on different lighting patterns and different conditions. And we're also incorporating those learnings into our system. But we do safely navigate thousands of school bus encounters every single week and we're continuously learning and improving because our work on safety is never done.
Ted Cruz 1:00:40 ↗
And the report of Waymo striking the child in Santa Monica indicates the AV quickly slowed down from 17 miles per hour to 6 miles per hour. What lessons can be drawn from what occurred and how might that have been different if a human driver had been driving?
Mauricio Pena 1:00:59 ↗
Mr. Chairman, first I'd like to express that we are grateful that the young girl was able to walk away from the scene. And as you state, our analysis indicates that our technology was able to detect the young girl as she emerged from behind a parked SUV, brake hard, reduce speed, and reduce harm. And we performed an analysis as well of how we compared with an always-attentive human driver. And we found that the Waymo driver would have responded faster than our models of an attentive human driver. So in this case, I believe that we mitigated harm.
Ted Cruz 1:01:45 ↗
Question for both Mr. Moravy and Dr. Pena. In your assessment, what are the safety benefits of widespread adoption of AVs? What human lives do we think could be saved?
Lars Moravy 1:02:02 ↗
Yeah, thank you, Chairman Cruz. I mean, I think NHTSA has a legacy of safety over the years and the auto industry has made improvements since the 70s when that was first in place, you know, on the road, getting us down to, as many folks have said, about 40,000 deaths per year. But in the last 20 years, that number has stayed pretty flat. I've been involved in some form of automotive safety over my career for the last 25 years, whether it's crash structures, airbags, seat belts, autonomous driving systems. I can tell you without a shadow of a doubt that the next big jump we have in reducing that number from 40,000 to hopefully a day where it's zero is autonomous driving. Simply put, an autonomous driver, the system and the computer that operates it doesn't sleep, doesn't blink, and doesn't get tired. And those are the real opportunities we have to face against the serious crisis we have on our roads today.
Ted Cruz 1:03:01 ↗
By the way, one just marketing suggestion. I'm not sure I would use the litany from the Terminator to describe your AVs. Dr. Pena, same question.
Mauricio Pena 1:03:13 ↗
I think we have demonstrated our performance today in over 100 million miles. Our data shows that we are 10 times less likely to be involved in a serious injury collision as compared to human drivers in the cities where we operate. And data also shows that we're 12 times less likely to be involved in a pedestrian injury collision in the cities where we operate. So I think we're making a difference already.
Ted Cruz 1:03:36 ↗
All right, final question. There's quite a bit of concern that the advent of AVs with automobiles may jeopardize jobs. At the same time, I think Tesla is demonstrating that AVs can produce an awful lot of high-paying jobs, that there is a strong, positive job story. Share with this committee, how many new jobs has Tesla's automatic driving system already created in Texas and how many more are projected?
Lars Moravy 1:04:08 ↗
Yeah, thanks, Senator Cruz. As you mentioned, we build all our AVs here in North America and in Texas. We've invested over $2 billion on a purpose-built AV line in Texas that will operate first at 1,200 jobs a shift and then when fully ramped up to 5,000 jobs, and that doesn't include our supply base which is also largely here and the exponential factor that that would have, perhaps 10 times that many.
Ted Cruz 1:04:31 ↗
Thank you. I've also received outreach from 33 stakeholders who support an autonomous vehicle federal framework. And I ask unanimous consent that these be entered into the record without objection. So ordered. Who's next? Senator Kim.
Unknown 1:04:53 ↗
Thank you, Chairman. Thank you to all of you for coming out for this really important conversation. Before I even came into Congress, I spent years and years working on cybersecurity, national security related issues. So, as we're talking through safety and control, I guess I just wanted to get a sense from you just where we're at when it comes to the capacity to protect ourselves from cybersecurity attacks as we are worried about the growing number of devices that we have that are connected to the internet. I have to say at the top of the list, you know, I do have concerns just about autonomous vehicles and I wanted to just get a sense from you what's true and what's not. So maybe Dr. Pena, maybe we can just start with you. Just what levels of concern have you had and what steps are you all taking to try to prevent the ability for someone else to be able to access data as well as take control of controls and features of the vehicles?
Mauricio Pena 1:05:48 ↗
Yeah, cybersecurity is a very important part of our safety framework. It is something that we take very seriously and we take a number of measures to identify vulnerabilities, perform risk assessments and then mitigate those vulnerabilities. One example is by design our safety-critical systems in the vehicle are protected from external connections. So you cannot actually hack into it, connect to it and drive it remotely. And so we do design, we do testing. So we do a pretty extensive evaluation of cybersecurity and mitigations.
Unknown 1:06:23 ↗
So with your company, with your fleet, have you had any instances where someone was able to access data or features or control of any of the vehicles?
Mauricio Pena 1:06:35 ↗
Not that I'm aware of. Senator,
Unknown 1:06:37 ↗
Dr. Moravy, I guess I wanted to ask you just similar questions. Just, you know, how are you able to protect your consumers, your drivers from cyber attacks and have you had any instances of cyber attacks upon vehicles that were able to access data, features or gain control?
Lars Moravy 1:06:58 ↗
Yeah, thanks Senator Kim for the question. I guess I'll quote our CEO here from over 10 years ago when we started on this endeavor. He said one of his biggest fears was the possibility that someone could do, as you described, take over an autonomous vehicle and do something nefarious. Since that day, we've been committed to making sure that never happens. We have many layers of security within our system. And similar to what Dr. Pena said, our driving controls, go, stop, steer, are in a core embedded central layer that cannot be accessed from outside the vehicle. In addition, our security protocols ensure that no firmware can be downloaded to the vehicle without what is a modern-day equivalent of a two-man rule. In order to sign such a firmware, two people have to sign it off with individual keys to make sure that that encrypted firmware can be uploaded to that vehicle safely. And to answer your question very bluntly about has anyone ever been able to take over control of our vehicles, the answer is quite simply no. And to make sure that that happens, we actively participate in hacking events trying, paying people to try to get into our vehicles. And we are the only automotive manufacturer that does that.
Unknown 1:08:12 ↗
Yeah, Mr. Farah, just from an industry side, I mean, I think we all are in agreement here. We want to make sure that answer continues to be no in terms of ability to be able to access. Just what are you seeing in terms of across the industry as well as what we should be thinking about here in terms of setting standards to be able to ensure that we can look the American people in the eye and say, you know, this is not a scenario that can happen. You don't have to worry about this.
Jeff Farah 1:08:38 ↗
Senator Kim, I appreciate the question and I think what Mr. Pena described is very much industry standard. There's a thought of this as being a closed universe that the company controls and that is a natural way of keeping out certain cybersecurity intrusions. I'll also just note here that from our perspective, we want Americans to understand that these vehicles are safe. We want Americans to trust these vehicles and understand that this is a huge priority of each of the companies that are there. If we don't have that trust, the technology doesn't get developed and it doesn't get deployed. And that's obviously not something that we want to see. And so there's a massive incentive on the part of the companies to do everything they can to address cybersecurity intrusions and that's I think why we have the track record that we do.
Unknown 1:09:16 ↗
Yeah. Dr. Pena, one last quick question for you on a different topic. You know I'm from New Jersey, very densely populated area. Just as I'm talking to people in my state, how do you explain a deployment to a densely populated area? What types of markers, what types of metrics you need before you can say, you know, this is safe now to deploy in these different areas.
Mauricio Pena 1:09:38 ↗
Yeah. Before we enter any market, we do an extensive evaluation and test of the different driving features, different road types. We do analysis, simulations, and we also perform testing with our vehicles with what we call autonomous driving specialists behind the wheel prior to us removing the human driver. So we take our time. We do it very methodically and we have a very strong safety framework and all of that evidence needs to be presented to a safety board in which I'm a part of and we approve that deployment with the sufficient evidence that the system has been demonstrated to perform safely in that city.
Unknown 1:10:21 ↗
Okay. Thank you so much and I'll yield back, Chairman.
Ted Cruz 1:10:26 ↗
Thank you, Senator Marino.
Unknown 1:10:29 ↗
Mr. Moravy, if a Tesla robotaxi is in an accident and there is a question about liability, it turns out that it was a software error, it's possible hardware error, who would accept the liability?
Lars Moravy 1:10:44 ↗
Yeah, thanks for the question, Senator Marino. Of course, if in the unlikely event that a software error occurred in our autonomous driving system, we would take liability for that event much in the same way that a driver takes liability in our current legal system if they make an error.
Unknown 1:11:02 ↗
Right. So, it'd be no different. Dr. Pena, how about at Waymo?
Mauricio Pena 1:11:07 ↗
Likewise. So, you would take that liability and you wouldn't look to skirt the types of protections that we have now, which is obviously some sort of terms and conditions that nobody reads that's 17 pages long that you just said accept. It would, in other words, a driver does not have binding arbitration against somebody that they hit. So you would not be in favor of that. Correct.
Senator, that's again not my area of expertise. So, I would have to discuss with my team and I can get back to you.
Unknown 1:11:40 ↗
Okay. I mean, that's not a great answer. Are you familiar with that 7 years ago, President Trump issued a national emergency around foreign adversaries accessing our critical infrastructure and put in place something that we call the connected vehicle rule. Are you familiar with that?
Mauricio Pena 1:11:58 ↗
Yes, I am.
Unknown 1:11:58 ↗
Okay. And Mr. Moravy, are you familiar with that as well?
Lars Moravy 1:12:01 ↗
Yes, sir.
Unknown 1:12:02 ↗
Okay. And Mr. Moravy, are you in favor of the connected vehicle rule? Do you think that was good policy?
Lars Moravy 1:12:08 ↗
I think any policy that regulates and promotes US security and manufacturing is a good policy.
Unknown 1:12:15 ↗
And how much of your vehicle again for the record is made in America?
Lars Moravy 1:12:18 ↗
Over 95% of our vehicles are made with North American parts. All of our cars are made in the US that are sold in the US and we're working toward making that 100%.
Unknown 1:12:25 ↗
So you get to the point soon with these robotaxis that 100% US content. So the connected vehicle rule would have no impact on you whatsoever because obviously all the telecommunications infrastructure connections would be US-based. Correct.
Lars Moravy 1:12:38 ↗
Yes, sir.
Unknown 1:12:39 ↗
And Dr. Pena, how about you?
Mauricio Pena 1:12:42 ↗
Our autonomous driving system is designed and built in the US and we install it onto several different platforms. We are in support of the connected vehicle rule.
Unknown 1:12:52 ↗
But how is that possible given that you said in your testimony that we're locked in a race with China, but it seems like you're getting in bed with China. The cars that you're looking to bring into the United States are Chinese automobiles owned by Chinese auto companies. Are they not?
Mauricio Pena 1:13:09 ↗
We use a variety of platforms. They are...
Unknown 1:13:12 ↗
Right. Right now you use a Jaguar that's made in Graz, Austria. And the car that you're looking at doing is a car by a subsidiary of Geely, which is a Chinese company. Is that not accurate?
Mauricio Pena 1:13:22 ↗
Yes. And we...
Unknown 1:13:23 ↗
So then how would advancing the US interest over China be met by having a company allow Chinese-made automobiles to enter the US market which are currently not allowed to enter the market? It seems like a very backdoor way of bypassing the connected vehicle rule?
Mauricio Pena 1:13:40 ↗
Those Chinese vehicles, the Geely vehicles have no smarts, no connectivity. What we do is we install our autonomous driving system right here in America and we don't share any information whatsoever. And so I feel that having a stable auto supply actually enables us to scale more quickly and more efficiently which is in fact helping us retain our lead over China even extended.
Unknown 1:14:10 ↗
So giving a natural market to a Chinese company to ship us cars is making us better and creating more jobs for Americans. That's completely ridiculous. Let me ask you another question. When you operate in the cities that you do, what's the price difference between Waymo and Uber? Like if I were to go on and pick an Uber and then I go and pick a Waymo, what's the price difference?
Mauricio Pena 1:14:34 ↗
Senator, it really varies more or less by market. It varies so much that I probably can't give you an accurate answer.
Unknown 1:14:43 ↗
Well, I'll give you the answer. It's almost exactly identical. So, what you're really doing is really taking the labor cost out of your business model. So, just let's just be clear, which is by the way, I'm a capitalist, but don't we need to frame this as, hey, look, we figured out a way to save a ton of money, which is to get rid of the human driver in the vehicle so we could make more profit. But let me ask you another question. You're owned by Google, correct?
Mauricio Pena 1:15:05 ↗
Alphabet is our parent company amongst others.
Unknown 1:15:08 ↗
Are you going to be using disaggregated data to target advertising towards your users?
Mauricio Pena 1:15:14 ↗
No, that's not our plan.
Unknown 1:15:16 ↗
That's not your plan. So that would not be any kind of situation where you'd serve up different ads. People could use the service and then get that data to allow them to target ads towards your users.
Mauricio Pena 1:15:28 ↗
That's not the plan.
Unknown 1:15:31 ↗
Is that plan subject to change?
Mauricio Pena 1:15:34 ↗
I'm not privy to that.
Unknown 1:15:35 ↗
Okay. All right. Thank you. I'm out of time.
Ted Cruz 1:15:41 ↗
Senator Lujan.
Unknown 1:15:42 ↗
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Many of you may be aware of some legislation that I was proud to work on years ago with some of my Republican colleagues and we got together and we came up with some legislation that would require technology and vehicles that would prevent drunk driving deaths. I remind my colleagues that when I was in my early 20s, I was hit by a drunk driver. Thank God I'm here today. As many as 10,000 people, 11, 12,000 people lose their lives every year because of this. Now, one of the questions that I have in this particular space is around the many types of anti-drunk driving technology that already exists. There's even a recent announcement from a company that will provide a Japanese OEM with a driver monitoring system that includes alcohol impairment detection. The current NHTSA administrator, Jonathan Morrison, recently warned, quote, 'There's a very major difference between an advanced driver assistance system and an automated driving system. The system you can buy in your vehicle today, with very rare exception, is a driver assist system. If you have an extra cocktail or two and you get behind the wheel and put it in quote hands-free mode, you're a drunk driver. I want you to be pulled over and I want you to be removed from the road.' That's what Jonathan Morrison, the current NHTSA director, recently said. Mr. Smith, can you explain why self-driving features in cars requires a person to be alert and able to safely take over the vehicle's operations?
Bryant Walker Smith 1:17:23 ↗
Thank you, Senator, for the question, but particularly for your work on the HALT Drunk Driving Act. That is incredible to be able to do something that will eventually save tens of thousands of lives every single year. And what you're describing is the fact that we have technologies that can do that. We have technologies that can drive a vehicle. Some of the same ones and other ones are able to detect if a human is actually capable of safely driving the vehicle. And as you point out, certain applications of driving automation envision that a human might still be able to or even need to drive for a portion of the trip. Not the kind of robotaxis that we might talk about, but features on production vehicles often. And as part of the safe design of the system, the manufacturer needs to know that when the system says, 'Hey, human, drive,' that the human is in a position to do so. That they're not sleeping, that they're not drunk, that they're able to re-engage. And so, a lot of that is the ability to understand directly or indirectly if a human is able to drive.

119 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Moravy, L. (2026, February 4). Tesla and Waymo execs testify before Senate panel on the future of self-driving cars — 2/4/26 [Interview transcript]. CNBC Television. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/684972/

MLA

Lars Moravy. "Tesla and Waymo execs testify before Senate panel on the future of self-driving cars — 2/4/26." CNBC Television, 4 Feb. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/684972/.

BibTeX
@misc{moravy2026_684972,
  author       = {Lars Moravy},
  title        = {Tesla and Waymo execs testify before Senate panel on the future of self-driving cars — 2/4/26},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, CNBC Television. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {feb},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/684972/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}