Thank you. Thanks. Appreciate it.
Hi everybody. Hello. So nice to see you all. I'm really psyched to be here today. Maybe just before we get started, could I get a just kind of want to get to know you all a little bit. Can I just see anybody who works in media? If you work in media, raise your hands. Oh, great. Okay, a lot of people work in media. How about people who work in tech? If you work in tech. Okay, cool. Creators. Any creators in the house? A lot of creators. Awesome. Cool. Hello. Great.
I figured it was probably a good time to talk about change today. So, that's what I'm going to talk about. Talk about change.
I remember when I discovered the camera for the first time. My buddy brought his video camera over to my house. I was like 10 years old and we started making these old movies for fun. It didn't shoot on digital. It shot on like 8 millimeter analog tape. That's me. I begged my parents for a camera because I was just I started making tons of movies with my friend and eventually they got me one and I was like filming movies for Spanish class and family vacations and like action movies with friends. I ended up like shooting hundreds and hundreds of hours. I have boxes and boxes. It's like hundreds of hours of footage over the last, you know, however many years.
And then one day my buddy showed me that you could double click the record button on the back of the camera and then move a little piece of clay and then double click the record button again and then move the clay a little bit more. And I started learning about animation. We started making these characters and sets and I like started going nuts for animation. And then I discovered these movies. Any Wallace and Gromit fans in the house? Okay. Yes. I had these I had the three VHS set of the Wallace and Gromit films. And like as a 10-year-old kid, Saturday mornings, like I was I my VHS remote had a little frame forward button and I would sit on the ground and I would watch the frames. I watch the movies frame by frame. These are 25-minute movies filmed at 24 frames a second. It's like a lot of frames, you know, I'd start in the morning and I'd finish, you know, after lunch sometime. I just studied the heck out of these films because I love them so much.
And look, if good artists borrow and great artists steal, I was the greatest artist in the world. Like I was so like I stole these movies like as my own films. Like I made them like I remade the movies frame by frame in some cases. Then I got a little bit older. I got a little better at animation. But really my films were just still copies of my heroes. So this is a interview that I did with a reindeer for one of my movies. And this is a film from Creature Comforts. A shot from Creature Comforts. A great movie by Nick Park. A short film by Nick Park. This is from a film I made called North Pole Plantation where we interview the snowmen and this is, you know, some polar bears being interviewed for Creature Comforts. Even like my live action movies, I was still really just copying my hero. So, this is when I started learning about lighting and silhouette shots and how to make something feel mysterious and menacing through lighting. And you know, this is Indiana Jones. When I started learning about, you know, like dialogue and how to film two shots and all that kind of stuff. This is a movie I made senior year. This is the opening shot of Pulp Fiction. So like just like lots of copying, you know, this is when I started learning about over-the-shoulder shots and how to establish a relationship between characters. You know, and this is the best chemistry in the history of cinema.
So look, I you know, I didn't realize what I was doing at the time, but essentially like I was learning a hundred years of cinema vocabulary and culture. I wasn't even doing it on purpose. Like in a lot of cases it was just unconscious. But I was learning how to recreate patterns in my own films that were embedded in a hundred years of cinema history and culture.
These patterns had not always been there. So this is the cinematograph. That's the first basically fully contained motion picture and projection camera system. It was invented by these folks, the Lumiere brothers in 1895. That's when this first camera system was invented. The first filmmakers to use this camera had no patterns to learn from. No patterns. So they drew from the storytelling predecessor to film. Theater.
The filmmakers approached film like they were trying to copy theater. Literally like they were trying to recreate what it felt like to be at a play. So they had these big elaborate sets, single shots on a super wide angle lens, just four minutes of the camera sitting there with a wide-angle lens looking like from the front row of where the audience would be in a theater. Big expressive overacting as if everyone was on stage.
There was this critic named Maxim Gorky at the time. He saw a film by the Lumiere brothers one night in 1896 and he described it like this. It's a world without sound, without color. Everything there, the earth, the trees, the people, the water, the air is dipped in monotonous gray. Noiselessly, the ash and gray foliage of the trees sway in the wind. And the gray silhouettes of people as though condemned to eternal silence and cruelly punished by being deprived of all the colors of life glide noiselessly along the gray ground, their smiles are lifeless.
So, like a lot of people weren't exactly impressed by early films because, you know, it was like a play but not as good. It had a couple problems. It was two-dimensional, it was silent, and it was in black and white. So, as much as you tried to simulate a play, as much as you tried to make it seem like you were at the theater, it just was never as good at being theater as theater was.
And then there was this filmmaker named Georges Méliès and he had been experimenting with new techniques for storytelling through cinema. Specifically, he was experimenting with this something called the cut. A cut where you would cut the film and then tell the next part of the story. And sometimes you could cut the film and move the camera. Sometimes you could cut the film and not change anything. Keep the camera exactly where it is and just change one little thing and then something magical would happen. So actually Georges Méliès was a magician too. So, what one thing he would do is he'd show that a box was empty and then he'd cut the film and then someone would get in the box and then he'd restart the film and they'd pop out of the box and audiences were like, 'Wow, how did that person get in the box?' But like people didn't know about cuts at this point. So, he started developing this like new vocabulary.
And in 1902 he came out with this film called A Trip to the Moon using all these new techniques using cuts and a bunch of other stuff. It still had some big sets. It still had some elements of theater but it changed locations so you could push the story forward. It played with time and space. It involved these guys who got together and they built this rocket and then they got in the rocket and they brought it up to the roof and they got inside the rocket and they loaded the rocket into this big cannon and then it instantly cuts to a shot of the cannon like pointed at the moon and the guy standing up there behind the cannon literally lights the cannon with like a flame. He lights the camera with fire. And the cannon fires and then it cuts to the POV of the rocket moving toward the moon and suddenly you feel like you're moving toward the moon. Imagine being alive in 1902 and feeling like you're approaching the moon. Then you see the rocket landing on the moon and the guys get out. They're wearing freaking top hats. And they look at Earth from space. So, Georges flips the whole perspective around, you know, something that's very hard to do in theater. And then they visit this like forest of mushrooms. You can't help but wonder if Georges is inspired by some of those mushrooms. Then they all get captured. They get bound. They get captured by aliens who live on the moon. They get bound. They get escorted to this alien court. The main guy grabs the head alien, throws him down on the ground, and then Georges does a match cut. So, they stop the camera. They replace it with a bomb. The bomb explodes. So, it looks like the main alien guy explodes. And then they run back to the rocket, they point it off a cliff, they fly back to Earth, they land in the ocean, and they're welcome back at home as like adventurers and heroes.
So, this whole thing, this was 14 minutes long. It had narrative structure, it had cuts, it had changing locations, it had special effects, it had match cuts, it had explosions, it plays with geography and space, it had fantasy, it had heroes, aliens, rockets. Like, if that's not the beginning of cinema, I don't know what is. But more importantly, it wasn't trying to be theater. It wasn't trying to reproduce the experience of watching a play. It was taking advantage of the fact that it was not a play.
One thing I see in my favorite artists is not their ability to recognize and recreate patterns, but their ability to break those patterns and still make you feel something. It's that invention outside of the collective consciousness, outside of the zeitgeist, outside of even a medium that at least makes me interested in my favorite artists.
The exact same thing happened with recorded sound and music. This box here is called a Digi 03. It's a recording studio in a box. It allowed you to connect a microphone up to your computer and you could run the software called ProTools which would allow you to record and mix multitrack songs in your house. And my buddy Ryan Lurman showed me how to use this thing to record my songs. I had always loved music. My dad was a jazz piano player. When I was six, he taught me the blues scale. I started writing songs and you know all through high school I did acapella groups and jazz combos and I wrote songs and I performed at school assemblies. And so by the time I was 16 and Ryan showed me that it was now possible to like record my songs on my computer, I lost my mind. Like I turned my entire garage into a recording studio immediately. I you know hung up this cheap foam that I got at the Container Store. I don't think the foam actually did anything, but it made me feel like I was in a recording booth. I put blankets on the walls that dampened the sound a little bit. I spent the entire summer holed up in this garage recording a bunch of my songs.
I remember this one time actually I was playing the guitar and I was recording it. I listened back to it and some it didn't sound right. It sounded like the time was off and I thought maybe there's a problem with the box and so I zoomed in to the waveform and I was trying to like see like what's going on. Is it just maybe it has a delay or something? And like some of the hits were ahead of the beat and some of the hits were behind the beat. And then I realized what was going on was I sucked at guitar. And so I spent the next like 45 minutes on my back with the guitar after realizing this just playing the same three chords over and over and over again to a metronome before I did the next take. And then when I did that take, it was a little bit better. And I had this like insanely motivating feeling like, 'Oh my god, I can just put in a bit more work and make my records better and better.' It was really such a good feeling.
I just met this girl named Natalie at the time. She played bass and she started coming over my house on weekends. We would record together. She wrote these incredible like melodies on bass. She had this amazing voice. We were 20-year-old kids, so we couldn't like afford to go to a recording studio or hire anyone to help us, you know, make these recordings. So, we just learned to do like everything ourselves. I would play guitar and drums and piano. Natalie would, you know, play and sing just about anything cuz she had an amazing ear. And I'd record and mix and master the tracks myself. I was just obsessed. I thought recording was like the coolest thing in the world.
But when recording technology first emerged commercially in the 1930s, a lot of people were worried that it would actually ruin the music industry. I didn't know this. This is James Petrillo. He was the president of the American Federation of Musicians. That was the major musicians union back then. He estimated that recorded music was stealing 60% of live music jobs.
That might sound crazy, but the way that people were approaching recording back then in the 1930s, I can understand why James was so worried about it because similar to the invention in the camera in 1895 where filmmakers were just trying to simulate theater. That's how early record producers thought about recording. They thought of it as a way to reproduce close, you know, what a live band sounded like. So to make a recording, they invite a band into the studio. You set up two microphones. You record the band once all the way through and then they're done. And that's the recording. You try to get it as close as possible to what it sounds like when that band plays live. That was what the first wave of records actually were. And so James Petrillo felt very threatened by this. And the president of this union organized a national ban on recording music. This is actually true. It was a union level strike against any recording sessions lasted years. No one was allowed to record music. He said any musician doing any recording gigs was playing for their own funerals. And the union actually ran ads through the 30s against this idea of recorded music. They called it canned music. This is one of those ads. And like if you can see this, there's a robot up there loading acoustic instruments into a meat grinder and it's outputting biff bang bop boom into a thing labeled canned music. And so they ran a bunch of ads like this. There were a whole bunch of them. Trampling art for profit, profit without honor, you know, the robot's lullaby. There were a whole series of these.
And then of course over the next decade or two a whole lot of amazing recording artists emerged and started using recording not as a way to simulate live music but as this new medium. Until you know 30 years after the union ran these ads. The Beatles made this record called Revolver. It's one of my favorite albums of all time. And the Beatles were stringing together tape machines. They were looping two bar drum sequences. They were playing sounds backwards. They were running their vocals through Leslie organ speakers. They were doing a whole bunch of things and making sounds that you could not make live.
This is George Martin. He's their producer. He described the recording studio for the Beatles as a new canvas on which they had to paint. He was basically saying recording is a new medium. So, in just a few decades, we went from banning recording music to thinking about recording as this new cherished art form.
This is something that happens with new technological mediums that impact artists and storytelling. There's this period right after this new medium gets developed where collectively we all just use our previous reference points as what that medium is for. So if you're, you know, it's 1895 and you're using film, you think of theater, or if it's 1920 and it's recorded music, you think of a live band, or if it's now, you know, you use an image generator to make something that looks like it's hand-drawn. Or you use a video generator to make something that looks like it was shot by a camera or use a music generator to make something that sounds like a human playing bass and a person playing drums. That's where we are now. We're at that very early stage where we haven't figured out what this new medium is yet. And I think that's why it feels and seems and is like slop. That's what slop is. It's that lazy phase after the introduction of a new medium where we're all just trying to reproduce existing things that are honestly just better if the people do them. If we do them that way. And I know the tech is going to catch up and it's going to get better, but right now we're just all using these pre-existing frameworks.
I'm actually I'm gonna talk about this more later, but I'm so upset about how this tech has rolled out. I'm upset because in order to do that, in order to create all this stuff as a creator, you know, my work has been used for a lot of creators in the audience, our work has been used without our consent, without paying us, and without giving us credit. Our work has been used to create these models. And it feels like that keeps happening.
If that's all I felt, if I just felt angry, I wouldn't be up here giving a talk because it's more than that. I have this incredible sense of conflict because I don't just feel angry about it. There is a piece of me like as an artist, there's a big piece of my personality that is attracted to things like this to new technological innovations because I feel like maybe there's a way it can help me express myself. And there's a piece of me that feels really grateful to be like I get to be alive in 1895 for the invention of the cinematograph. That's what it feels like right now. I feel like I get to be alive in the 1920s for the invention of recorded music. And I feel both of those things fully. I feel so angry and I feel so like strangely grateful and excited. I have this incredible sense of conflict around those things.
I know on social media these days it does such a good job of just creating the pros and the cons, creating the fors and the againsts and we're so polarized on social media. The algorithms just sort humanity. They just sort humanity into this group and that group. Including for topics like this for AI. I think it's such a shame because this is such an important time for artists right now. It's so important right now. And if you're a creator who feels a sense of conflict about this stuff like I do. One, that's okay. You don't have to feel singularly this is good or this is bad. You don't have to feel singularly about it. There's a lot of people, more than you would know, more who say so publicly. There's people in private. I talk with thousands of creators. You know, I think there's a difference between what people are willing to say online and how people feel internally. I know a lot of creators who feel conflicted about this. And so that's okay. That's okay if you feel conflicted. I just ask, especially in creator communities, this is really important for us to talk about right now. We're at an important moment in history. I think it's really important for us to each approach this with our own sense of how we feel about it.
By 2007, Natalie and I had started making a lot of recordings together. That was right around when this new website emerged called YouTube.com. There was no iPhone yet. There was no apps. So, it was a website. It was YouTube.com. I thought it was the coolest thing in the world that this new tool allowed me to put out my music without having to sign a record deal or get lucky somehow and get discovered. So PMPU set up a YouTube page and we started making videos of our recording process.
Now they weren't music videos because in a music video, right, the band makes the album first and then they like mime the music video. That's not what we were doing. We were showing the actual recording process. It wasn't a live video, which also existed because in a live video, the band plays and then it's done and then the live thing comes out. Instead, we were filming the actual recording process layer by layer. Vocals and electric guitars, acoustic guitars, piano, string plucking, whirler, synth, background vocals, and then we usually goof off at the end for a little bit. And then Natalie would film like would edit the whole thing into these little three-minute clips that we would upload to YouTube of our songs. And you could see all of the layers that went into the recording. It might sound really obvious right now with me talking about it this way in 2026, but no one was really doing that back then. It was either like music videos or live performance videos. You couldn't really see the at home recording process. So, we started making dozens of these videos. They started getting millions of views on YouTube. And it was so much traffic that we decided to start selling these songs as MP3s on iTunes.
And we started selling tens of thousands, tens of thousands of MP3s. So we went from like being bedroom musicians to being full-time professional recording artists like in a period of months. I couldn't believe how well it worked. It was like, you know, film ourselves making music, edit it into videos for YouTube, and then sell the MP3s on iTunes. It was such a simple model.
And we lived happily ever after. Thank you everybody. Safe travels back home. Thank you. Okay. So, no, seriously, like what was nice about this for me as an artist was, you know, no delusions of grandeur here. Like I don't feel like I was Georges Méliès like inventing cinema or the Beatles inventing recording here, but I didn't feel like I was copying Wallace and Gromit anymore. I felt like I was doing something new as an artist. Even if it was just a small little thing, I felt like I was saying the next sentence in the conversation as an artist. I was helping to kind of make something interesting and that felt really good. That was like a really nice moment.
The introduction of the Vitaphone has been received both by the public and the artistic world with a great deal of interest. A development which is destined to create an entirely new art for the medium of expression is the synchronized reproduction of sound and scene.
In 1927, Warner Brothers released a film called The Jazz Singer. It was the first mainstream film with sound. Theaters played this film using a machine called a Vitaphone that was able to synchronously play back film and audio together. The Vitaphone cost between 9 and 15,000 bucks to purchase. So it was a significant investment for the theater owners, but for the first time you could show movies with sound. These films were called talkies because you could actually hear the characters talking and they had sound effects and they had music and audiences loved it. Movie theater attendance exploded from 50 million movie goers per week in 1926 to about 90 million movie goers per week in 1930 just four years later.
But not everyone of course was excited about this new technology. A group of Soviet filmmakers published this statement on sound in 1928. They wrote, 'This new technical discovery may not only hinder the development and perfection of the cinema as an art, but also threaten to destroy all its present formal achievements.' And the push back on the new technology wasn't just philosophical. At the time, movie theaters in the United States employed tens of thousands of musicians every day to create live scores behind the otherwise silent movies. Many theater owners paid for the new Vitaphone technology by firing their orchestras because a 15-piece band could run around $50,000 per year. So in a few months, the investment in the Vitaphone paid for itself. And the theater owners were thrilled about it because they could now play movies all day long and not have to worry about overtime and employing union workers and dealing with union rules. Musicians organized strikes and the union bought ads to fight canned music, but it didn't matter. By 1930, the union estimated that 22,000 musicians lost their jobs to the Vitaphone as talkies became the new standard.
A lot of actors didn't make it either. John Gilbert was often cast in leading roles during the silent era, but his vocal delivery was evidently a bit stilted and it made audiences laugh when they weren't supposed to. Clara Bow was nicknamed the it-girl of silent films, but she hated talkies. She had this thick Brooklyn accent. She got so nervous delivering lines out loud that she eventually had a mental break and she checked into a specialized hospital for her emotional health. Her career was over by 1933.
Charlie Chaplin also hated talkies. He said, 'I loathed them' and he felt like they were spoiling the art of pantomime. Charlie refused to make the transition. In 1931, four years after the first talkie, four years, he released City Lights, a film with no synchronized dialogue. His next film was Modern Times. Almost a decade after the introduction of the Vitaphone and long after culture had moved beyond silent movies. Modern Times had sound effects but almost no speaking.
Why did Charlie refuse? Why did he refuse this new technology? I don't know. But I wonder if Charlie felt conflicted about it. Conflicted about the potential but scared about what it meant for this great art form he had worked so hard to perfect. I wonder if he felt like he was choosing between being left behind and becoming irrelevant or changing his work in a way that he was angry about and didn't believe in.
Finally, in 1940, 13 years after the introduction of the Vitaphone, Charlie released his first actual talkie with synchronized dialogue and picture. He did it. It was called The Great Dictator. And it was a satire of Hitler and fascism. At the time, Germany had just invaded and occupied much of Western Europe, including Belgium and Poland, Denmark, France. Nazi planes were dropping bombs in the UK and the United States hadn't yet entered the war. Political neutrality was the going strategy. At the end of the film, Charlie gets up in front of an army of soldiers in a nation that his character just conquered. And he breaks character. He gives a speech right to the camera with the whole world listening.