You seem fundamentally optimistic that there is a way to make an internet that is better. What are we going to do? Let it be like this?
What? I don't like the way the internet is going. I don't like it as a creator. I don't like posting and having it feel like a slot machine. That shit sucks. It shouldn't be like that for creative people and for their communities. And so I think it's worth trying something else. And there's gonna be a lot of people along the way who say, 'Jack, that's stupid. Jack, what are you doing? You can't win against TikTok. Jack, you're just copying social media. Jack, it's never going to work.' Fine. People can say that all day long. And I don't... Sorry, Lizzy. It sounds like I'm throwing shade at you. I don't mean to be. I'm just saying I'm used to skepticism about these things. And at the end of the day, if you're not going to try, what are we doing? May as well try.
I'm going to start the way I always start, which is introduce yourself. Tell me who you are and what you do.
My name is Jack Conte. I am a creator. I've been a creator on the internet since, oh gosh, 2007. And in 2013 I started a company called Patreon and I'm still CEO of that company. I'm in a couple bands called Pomplamoose and Scary Pockets and Scary Goldings and I make videos and music and all that kind of stuff.
So, you and I met, I think about almost two years ago, at this big tech conference. And at the time, you were all fired up about this idea of making the internet better. And then about a year later, I saw a video you did, an opinion video for the New York Times with the title, 'I'm building an algorithm that doesn't rot your brain.' And in it, there was a section where you said TikTok and Instagram and Facebook are optimizing for attention, which yeah, we know. What are you optimizing for?
Getting creators paid for their labor, number one. Long-term relationships, number two. And human creation, number three. And I could talk a little bit more about each of those things.
Yeah. But maybe at the core of it...
I don't like what the current internet is doing to humans or doing to me. I feel like I'm an experiment in a petri dish. And I feel like my lymph system is getting tested every day with what is sort of maximally fixating me and grabbing my attention. And I think it's bad for us. It certainly feels bad for me. I'm tired of logging on the internet and having it feel like rocket fuel straight into my veins. And I just don't buy. What it comes down to is I don't buy that this is the only way to have media and community on the internet. I don't buy it. I think there's got to be a different way. In fact, I remember when there was a different way. Just a decade ago, the internet did not feel like this. It felt like a much better place.
You think it had fun then?
I do. There were elements of it that felt fun 10 years ago. Certainly 15 years ago. I remember when my bands first started uploading on the internet and we were finding our community and finding people and yeah, there were elements of fun to it. I mean, the comment section was a bit gnarier back then than it is now. But yeah, it was... the very specifically the thing about it that was very different for creative people was you could actually reach your followers when you built a subscription base, when you built a follower base and then you posted your next thing, you could reach the people who signed up to see you. And you can't do that anymore. Every time you upload something on the internet now it feels like putting a coin in a slot machine and maybe you'll reach the people who subscribe to you and maybe you won't. And with that as the sort of system it's impossible to build a community, it's impossible to build a business as a creative person.
So I think the options there are like stand on the street corner and play music and busk for your dinner. The tech CEO version of that is you guys release this discovery network to creators on your platform. And I want you to help me understand it because you've got a home feed which has got posts, newsletters, podcast videos from people who fans already follow. Their memberships are at the top, but then also free posts, videos, things from recommended creators and communities. I need you to explain to me how that is not another social network.
It certainly... I can totally see why it looks like that. And I know there's a lot of people who act... in fact there's a bunch of creators who are saying like, 'Hey, is this another social network?' I don't talk about it like that. I don't tell our team it's a social network. I'm not saying let's go copy social media features. I'm in fact asking our team very specifically to not pull from social media and to not look at social media when we're building. At the core of it, if you optimize for watch time, if you optimize for what will somebody click on, what will somebody... what will a human watch or listen to or read for the longest possible time? You end up with stuff that is highly addictive and stuff that fixates us and stuff that's bad for our brains. Versus if you try to pay creative people for their work or if you invest in people building long-term relationships with the people who actually subscribe to see those people, you end up with a very different system. So, I actually... yeah, even if some people call it social media, that's kind of okay with me. The main reason is because at the end of the day, we're trying to get people to be able to build communities and followings and actually be able to reach those people and have conversation with them and actually be able to build a business with them. That's the difference on Facebook. As a creator, everything is a gamble. Every post. I have no idea how many people I'm going to reach. I can't make any money on the platform. I don't get paid for my labor as a creator. And on Patreon, we're paying creators billions of dollars a year.
So, when you're making these adjustments, right, because this is a shift in terms of what you guys do. Are you thinking about it from the standpoint of how a creator experiences that or how an audience member, a fan, a member of the community engages with that?
I think both. I mean, we have to think about it from the perspective of both sides. From the creator's perspective, I mean, this is sort of where Patreon came from, right? My whole perspective as a creator myself, the problems are very clear, which I've sort of just outlined. And then from a fan's perspective, you know, I think there's also a bunch of problems. The internet feels addictive. I don't hear from the people that I want to hear from. Like, I miss things that are important to me because even though I've signed up for them, I can't see them in the future. So yeah, there's a bunch of problems I think both from the fan perspective and from the creator perspective. And we definitely think about it from both. I think it's important that we do. One of the things that our creators have told us, very specifically, is that they rely on Patreon to be able to... I mean, this is the thing that we've been saying for years and years. They rely on Patreon to be able to reach their most important fans. A creator's most important fans. That like 5% of your audience that wants to go to your show, wants to get your merchandise, wants to listen to every episode, wants to download the course, that 5% of your fans is a really important portion of your fans.
Are they more important than just the sort of spray across the internet portion, do you think, in the traditional?
I think so. As a creator myself, I think so. If I had the opportunity to reach millions of people or... I mean, this comes back to the Kevin Kelly thousand true fans theory, right? Like if I had the opportunity to reach millions of people or find my tribe who really cared for me as a creator, I want to find my tribe who really cares.
I remember when we were talking in 2024, one of the things you talked about was like actually you want to bring those people along, bring the audience along to a live show to get your merch. That this is a much more... I mean it's actually very old-fashioned. It feels like a newspaper subscription in the journalist brain, right? That I think that even though it's not all that different from how an influencer, I know you hate that word, might behave on Instagram, the objective is different than say selling ads.
Completely different. Yeah. I mean, if you think about the models on Patreon, there are creators with, you know, a few thousand subscribers on Patreon and they make, you know, tens of thousands of dollars a month and really...
Yeah. Absolutely. I mean, there are creators... yeah, there are creators on Patreon who are making millions of dollars a year, right? They're making hundreds of thousands of dollars a month. But the bulk of the creators on Patreon, over half of our payments volume, goes to creators who are making what we call the sort of middle class creativity. It's creators that are making between $1,000 a month and $30,000 a month. So it's not necessarily the Taylor Swifts of the world. It's not like the biggest creators on the planet. It's this emerging group of people who are building businesses with their thousand true fans, with the people that they found that are sort of powering their business and their community.
Your start into this world is obviously as a musician. But you guys just hit what, $10 billion paid out to creators. That is a lot of money. Talk to me about what you think were the biggest, most important points to get you to that place and then what your vision is for the next 5 years.
I think maybe the first one is just starting the company. The first one is just saying, hey, the internet is going in a direction that I don't like. As a creator, I'm being told that I should upload to these platforms and give them my labor for free and I should do it in exchange for the exposure. I mean, honestly, it's kind of hard to even remember that time period, but that was not that long ago when if you told the platforms, 'Hey, you should pay me for uploading to this platform,' the platforms are like, 'Why would we pay you? Like, if you're not happy with our service, just go somewhere else.' That was the attitude of the platforms. And of course now they all have creator payments organizations and teams and they're building all that stuff in the past. So I guess maybe the first step was just like, hey, this is a problem. This is not fair for creative people. Creative people deserve to actually be paid for their work. They are creating value in the world. They are building communities. They are reaching people who love their work. It's not fair or good for society to not compensate those people for their labor. So kind of I guess realizing that, building that, getting that out, step one. Maybe the next important milestone was building, you know, turning that problem into a professional membership suite. Because one of the things that we realized, probably early on, maybe 2017 somewhere around there, was there's this bifurcation of media on the web now. People are starting to... the web isn't just pure free anymore. Even Slate has a subscription offering and different media companies have divided their offering into free and paid. That's not where the internet was in 2012. Everything was free back then. But now people are starting to realize, wait, why should I give away everything? I should be paid for some of my work. And so we built this membership system that allowed people to section off a portion of their catalog and have a premium offering. And that got really big with podcasters and video creators and a whole bunch of creators who were making episodic media. And kind of building the CRM and the email system and the professional tool suite, the analytics around that idea of this membership platform, I think was step two. That sort of, a lot of creators were able to build really serious businesses at that point on Patreon. And that's why now there are creators that are making millions of dollars a year on the platform. And your second question though around what's next?
In many ways I think the journey of Patreon echoes the journey of media. Because essentially Patreon is like we're serving small business media companies, right? Like that's what a creator is. It's a small business media company. They make things for the internet. And the challenge with that is the same challenge for media companies, same challenge for creators, same challenge for Patreon. Being downstream of Facebook and YouTube and TikTok is a perilous business for creators. It is a dangerous, difficult position to be in to rely on those platforms for traffic, for community, for payments. I won't go so far as to say it's a losing strategy because you still kind of need those companies. That's where the world has congregated. But I wish that weren't the case. It sucks being downstream of those platforms. It sucks for media companies. It sucks for creators. And it's bad for Patreon, too. We don't want to be downstream of those companies. And so, what's the future of Patreon? That's the future for creators on the platform. I want to be able to have Patreon send our creators traffic without needing it from Facebook and Instagram and YouTube. I think if we force creators to rely on those platforms, it's bad for them and it's bad for us. And so the next phase of the company is what you mentioned at the beginning of this show: building a place where creators can not just get payments for their work but they can actually get new audience as well.
I mean you have lured some big names, I believe Helen Peterson, Virginia Sole-Smith too, some people who have quite large followings have left other platforms and come to you. Why?
I think the real reason is because of our values. But I think, you know, we have a lot of the features that a lot of creators who are starting to realize, hey, I want to build a business around my work, we have a lot of the features that those creators need to be successful. We've spent 13 years building everything from RSS syncing to analytics to free to paid conversion tools to a really good CMS to a CRM system to collecting emails of all the people who follow you to all that to integrations across other platforms. Like we have that full suite of tools that creators need. But then I think from a value standpoint, we also do right by creators. And two, I think just the way we handle things on the platform is different than how a lot of companies handle stuff on the platform. We have very specific opinions around what we don't want on Patreon. And we act on that. So like we've taken certain posts down off of Patreon. And at times we've had to take creators down because they're outside of our content policy. I hate taking income away from people, I do not want to do that. And so we take those decisions very, very seriously, but if someone is spreading hatred and is spreading Nazism and using Patreon to do that, I don't want that. Our team doesn't want that. And we act on those decisions. I think a lot of other platforms...
People maybe said, 'Oh, there are Nazis on Substack. I don't want that. I'm taking my stuff to Patreon.'
I mean, I know that's happened. Yeah, absolutely. And I realize that's a very controversial thing to say right now because it's sort of in vogue in tech to not have trust and safety anymore. I disagree. I think it's important. I want Patreon to be a nicer place to hang out. I want it to feel safe. I want it to be a home for artists and creators and that means that we draw a hard line on those things. And I'm proud of those decisions.
Help me understand something about the new system though because if your new system is built on people kind of engaging more with their home feed, right? Doesn't that create an implicit pressure on creators to make more stuff, put more stuff up there? Which is the opposite of being considered.
I don't think it has to do that. I think the current systems that exist have put that pressure on creators because they're trying to maximize for time spent. So, I'll tell you exactly how it works. Those systems say we need to maximize the amount of posts, maximize the length of those posts and maximize the amount that creators can make those posts on the platform such that people log in every 20 minutes for new, more stuff and spend an extra 10 hours on the platform because every extra hour that people spend on those platforms is extra ad dollars for their business. That is not how Patreon's business model works. We don't get paid if you spend an extra two hours on the platform. In fact, Lizzy, if you ask me what is time spent on Patreon, what is the average time that a fan spends on Patreon? I don't know. We don't track it. It doesn't matter to me and it doesn't matter to our teams. That's what I mean by this is fundamentally a different system and it has different incentives and I think we should expect to see different things happening because of that.
I mean I think what you're talking about here when we talk about kind of web 2.0, right, is an internet built on advertising. Google and Meta are advertising companies. That is kind of the backbone of what they do. And what you are talking about is an internet that kind of got rid of ads, that wouldn't have ads. But I think a problem is that consumers also like that. They like being served the exact sweater that they're going to wear because Instagram tracked enough third party data about them that they're going to serve him the sweater. Like that seems like a really difficult tension in terms of growing audiences on a platform like Patreon.
If consumers like that, then they can go to Instagram.