I've never had a tech job. This is the only company I've ever worked at in my life. This is my first job.
Yes. My read of the valley is people undervalue brand and narrative and creativity and storytelling things that in my world where I come from those are the things. And in Silicon Valley, the main thing is the product. But you can know that the product is a thing and care about narrative and creativity and storytelling and brand. And I think if you don't care about those things, it's very hard to influence culture and to build a brand that people love and to have trust with your customers and like it's very hard to do those things. A lot of those things are a completely different skill set. There's a lot of operators who like if it doesn't show up in the P&L, they don't believe that it's real. I think it is possible to make art and also to want to get paid for your art. I think selling out is doing something other than making art. Like if you get paid for your art, that's the opposite of selling out. That's making sure that you're setting up your future so that you can make more art. And like I'm on a mission in life and in this company to help creative people understand that they have meaning in the world. We've been looking at these dashboards on social media companies for 20 years now that tell us you just got 3 million views and that's worth $18 in ad revenue. That's your worth to the world. And I think that's a load of horseshit. The internet has enough stuff. We don't need more stuff on the internet. We need things that people are deeply proud of. I sat down at my kitchen table and I sketched out the idea that became Patreon. And it took about 14 pieces of printer paper I did with a pencil. And I felt so dumb. I'm a YouTuber. What am I going to do? What am I going to do with these drawings? And I literally had to say to myself, "This isn't going to work. That's okay. Draw the next page."
Welcome to Dialectic, episode 52 with Jack Conte. Jack is the CEO and co-founder of Patreon. And I talked to him about art and business, about his prolific creation himself over the course of the last 20 years on YouTube and in music in his multiple bands including Pomplamoose and Scary Pockets and running Patreon and his commitment to building a platform that is first and foremost for creators themselves under the view that people should be able to make a living for their art. One thing that is certainly clear is that Jack deeply loves artists and creators and wants us to live in a world where they can flourish for a very long time. I have a lot of respect for what he has built at Patreon and what he is going to continue to do for years to come. Before the conversation with Jack, I'd like to thank Notion, Dialectic's presenting partner. As I joke to Jack during the episode, Notion is essentially my patron. They are the presenting partner of Dialectic and they are a huge part of what makes the show possible. Notion's a creative workspace for your life's work that you and your team can use now with AI and agents to have far more leverage on creating whatever it is you've set out to. Notion has become something of an AI native operating system for you and your team's work. And the critical part of that is because they spent the last 10 years building a platform that houses all of your context and makes it an immediately useful place to have the benefits of AI and agents. They've also natively integrated custom agents which are little guys who work in your workspace and help you have more time for the important work by automating away the busy work. There's been a number of recent developments in Notion's world. One of the most exciting is the developer platform and the combination of all the extensibility and workers which allow you to have cloud hosted agents that are working on your behalf within your Notion workspace and elsewhere across all of the other software that you use. You can learn more at notion.com/dialectic. And now here is my conversation with Patreon's Jack Conte.
Jack Conte, thank you for joining me or thank you for having me, I should say.
Gosh, thanks for being here.
This is a pleasure. We have a mutual friend who really raves about you and it's an honor to have gotten to kind of dumpster dive the archive and get to chat with you.
I want to start with maybe that last point which is I knew a bit like I knew you had the band with your wife and I knew you had made YouTube videos and you kind of made Patreon for yourself and like I guess the idea in my head I had is that like you were a CEO who like kind of liked music and had like done some YouTube in the past which is decidedly not the case. Like I mean I'm sure I'm missing some but I think you've had like four quite successful YouTube channels, maybe three. You are yeah for lack of a better word like just wildly prolific even ignoring Patreon. And so I think that speaks to a level of endurance. It speaks to frankly just like being multi-hyphen or polymathic. But I'm curious across all of these things including the business where how do you sustain your energy?
I don't know the answer to that question. But I do get asked that a lot because you know Pomplamoose was making 50 music videos a year, Scary Pockets was making 50 music videos a year at the same time. So I was outputting a hundred music videos per year and doing Patreon and had you know active Instagram presence and you know and also like it's not like I'm not doing work at Patreon like that is the triple time job. That is my absolute focus and those things were like you know for me in the cracks. I think the answer to the question the best I can do is like I think there's really like a couple things that it came down to for me. One was batching production on the media side. When I was trying to make everything by myself and doing one thing at a time I couldn't get through the like the last 5% that was 20% of the work you know. And so what the system that we ended up setting up is flying down to LA for a Saturday and a Sunday because I'm working all week once a month. So literally one time every four weeks I fly down to LA. On Saturday, do a session with Scary Pockets, which is my funk band, record four songs in a day. On Sunday, do a session with Pomplamoose, record four songs in a day. Both bands are like profitable and so we can hire teams. So we had a post-production crew, audio mixing engineers, mastering, video producers, video editors, like full production team.
Yeah. These aren't hobbies either, which is the craziest part of this.
No, no, it was like a whole operation. Like we're like, you know, 100 music videos a year is like that's a serious, you know, that's serious output. So yeah. So we had, you know, like we had the system to sort of like get eight songs in one weekend and then the teams would sort of like take those songs and mix and engineer and make videos out of them. And then that got me to the point where I was releasing two music videos a week one with Pockets and one with Pomplamoose while I'm up here doing the company. And so I don't want to say it's like a, you know, it is a little bit of a magic trick because it's not like I'm in the recording studio every week or every day, which is maybe what it looks like online. I mean, I'm here every day, but batch production was like a big thing. And the idea of like leaning into like everything I learned at Patreon about around working with teams, applying all of that to like Pomplamoose and Scary Pockets, like the power of a team, the output of a team is you know exponential compared to the output of a person, you know. So really thinking about how to leverage teams and work with teams and build like operations around you know I don't like the word content but like around a content pipeline. And then I know this is so this is a highly contested thing in Silicon Valley. There's like two camps. I do not function without my chief of staff. And I know that role is like there's people who are like ah to have a chief of staff I'm never investing. I literally wouldn't it wouldn't work. I couldn't do it without my chief of staff. She's the best.
How long have you This is Nicole.
And the first six of them she was my EA. And I don't work without her. Like my life doesn't work. I don't she is she is very much like the executive function side of my brain. And I have so much inbound across Slack and Google Docs and Notion and email and teams and Scary Pockets and Pomplamoose like I cannot operate without an amazing human who's like going through all of that and constantly triaging and making sure that I'm constantly working on just the most important three things. Like she is really good at that. She has full context on my life on everything. And so that's the other like huge unlock for me has been learning to work really effectively with her and finding someone who's as good as her in that role. So yeah, batch production, having an amazing chief of staff, and then there is one other thing which I'm still working on, but it's just like getting used to chaos. It's just like there's a lot of people who think chaos is a sign of failure or like something not working or like, "Oh, we've done something wrong. Exactly. We have to fix this chaos."
And I'm I'm I'm I'm post chaos. Like I accept the chaos of life and company building and like I'm now just at the point where I'm like that is going to be the baseline is like chaos, disorganization, things changing, schedules changing, priorities changing. And I'm like I'm getting used to that kind of just being how things are. It's always going to feel a little stretched, just always going to feel a little unwieldy. It's always going to feel like a little bit too much. But actually, like I don't know, I've gotten a little bit better at kind of relaxing into that.
That is an amazing or at least a helpful strategic context for how this all happens. It doesn't explain how you do this for 15 years.
Yeah. And it's like obviously you love what you do, although that's like even that's a cliche and what does that totally mean? Like are there parts of this where it's like I don't know as an example maybe performing when you're down in LA with the band isn't like really this generative part of your brain or maybe generative is the wrong word but like it's not like songwriting or something where it's like it's just actually like purely energy giving. I don't want to make it about like burnout because I think that's probably even
Yeah. I hate that word. Think of it like that. Yeah.
But like presumably some of these things are energy positive and some of them are energy negative and enough of them are energy positive that you're like staying above water or you're just a sicko. But
No no no there I have so much and as I've operated more I've gotten better at leaning into things that are energy positive for me. Like I would say like one of the main differences between like me as an early operator and me 13 years in is like I used to be just like you know super like growth mindset like lean into the things that I'm my weaknesses and like try and make them better and learn and grow. Of course I still want to do all of that but that takes you so far. I can get from a B minus to maybe a B+ on a lot of those things in a year or two. And like I'd rather have somebody else nail those things and delegate that and have somebody do them better and just make sure that we're aligned from a strategic and sort of vision standpoint on a lot of that stuff. And then I'm trying to lean more into the things that I think like I'm really good at. Like what are my spikes? And then I want to spend more time on those things. And so I've spent a lot more time over the last couple years on a lot of that stuff. And that is super energy giving for me, right? Because that's the stuff where I'm like in flow. I feel like I'm on a lot of things I feel like I'm worse than a lot of people. I'm like there's another person who's going to do this way better than me. And then there's a couple things where I'm like I think I'm one of the few people who can like really crush this. And so I spend a lot of time doing that stuff. I also love those sessions with the bands. I love performing. I love recording days. Like when I'm in a studio my confidence goes through the roof. Like I feel like I know exactly what to do and like it is so much fun and I make such fast decisions. It's like 100% intuitive. It's just like I've learned a lot actually from like as an operator from how I show up in a recording studio. Like there's a lot of that that I'm trying to pull into how I operate here. It's not one-to-one so you have to be careful pulling too much. But it has been that has been a lesson for me. And then there's enough of those things such that I have a good happy life and a fun time. And then when it's not, which is also there's lots of those moments where I think a lot of people would characterize it as burnout. The reason I don't like that word is because for me it's a bit like the word death or like I don't know it occupies a space in your brain that is irrecoverable and I don't think of it like that. So like whenever I'm like I'm done. I've got nothing left. I'm out of gas. This is too there's too many things. This might sound silly or almost pedantic, but like I literally sit down at a piece of paper or not a piece of paper, my note on Apple Notes and I go on device, not cloud. I don't want the on the cloud on device. And it's like what am I feeling right now? I start with that.
And it's like I'm anxious as I'm scared. I'm like demotivated. Like I'm, you know, I'm talking about like the moments where it's like really bad. Like I had a couple of these like maybe twice a year, three times a year. Those like not very often, you know, this isn't like a weekly or monthly thing, but like couple times a year it's like I hate everything, you know? And I literally start with how I'm feeling and I'm like why am I feeling like that? Like what are my narratives around that feeling? What is it that I believe to be true that is making me feel that way? And then I list out my narratives. It's like, okay, here's my narratives. I'm like, okay, objectively, how many of those narratives are real? And like, how many of them are things that I'm assuming, right? And it's like, okay, actually, I don't know that this one is actually true. Okay, let's cut that one for now. But like, what are the actual problem statements then that come out of the narratives? And then it's like I have a set of problem statements. And it's like, okay, now let's prioritize those problem statements. Again, I'm sorry if this sounds, you know, pedantic, but it's like
This is exactly what I was asking about.
Is like, "Okay, here's like here's like my seven problem statements." And what I found is usually when I feel really shitty, what it actually is is a compounding set of four or five problems that are all really gnarly hitting at once. That's when I'm like, "Fuck it. I'm done." And I think a lot of people would call that burnout. And so when I hit that, I list out those problem statements. I make them really crisp. Like I get into like what is the actual problem? And then this is so silly, but it's so effective. I like list out a bunch of potential solutions for each of them. And I do the first three. Do the first three for each one. Do the first three hypotheses that could potentially solve that problem. Sometimes it's as simple as emailing a person, setting up a phone call. Hey, here's the story in my head. Is this true? Like what's your experience of this? And like working through something and like immediately after doing the first three things for four or five problems, I feel so much better and I'm like ready to go again because like I can see a path.
It's real. Like you've put it on the table and you can look at it, right?
Yeah. Yeah. So I don't know. That like if you were to go through my computer probably shouldn't say that but you know you'd see a series of brain dumps over the years problem statements and then little solutions to solve each one of them and then sometimes it takes a couple weeks sometimes it takes a couple months occasionally it takes a year to get out of a really gnarly problem but usually within a year I'm out of the problem and then there's a new set of problems and I can do another brain dump.
Yeah, it sort of assumes that burnout or to use the stronger word, death isn't an option, which is like I forget exactly how you framed it, but something along the lines of it assumes that like it could just you could truly run out of gas and you've adopted an orientation that says like whatever the lowest point is like I will bounce like inevitably I will bounce back like it's almost like a belief thing I suppose.
A thousand percent. I so I actually don't think our there's another one of these controversial statements here, but like I don't think up to a certain level your context is really important. Do you have enough food? Are you safe? Do you have shelter? Do you have enough money to get things done in your life? All that kind of stuff. But like I don't think one of the things my wife says I agree with. I forgot who exactly said this. Wherever you go, there you are. So like I don't think changing your environment or my job or my contacts or my partner or my house is going to solve anything. Like wherever I go there I am. So like I better get good at solving the actual problems because the problems that we think like the when you think about oh I'll just change the context. Yes. I think 5% of our happiness, at least my happiness, is context. I think the rest of it is brain chemistry and like specifics. And then it's like, okay, let me either work on the brain chemistry or let me work on the specifics. And that
Can you successfully work on brain chemistry?
Yeah. Yeah. And I do. I go to therapy. I mean I don't know if that changes my actual like physiology but it certainly changes my psychology.
And that has a profound impact on my happiness and my ability to kind of keep going.
It's funny. I think on one hand I agree with you on the wherever you go there you are. I think environments and context matter a lot but we often blame things that are ultimately about us on the environment. And that's like if only I was the grass is greener. And so it's like yeah I think environments can be underrated but not for these internal things which is really risky. Yeah.
I mean I'll give you an example like I like doing things. I get like I get energy out of like publishing work and reaching an audience and building community on the internet and
Those things by the way are different. Like publishing the piece and sitting down in the room by yourself to write it are very
So different. And I like both. I actually really like
So you really like do you get energy from like
Jerry Seinfeld talks about writing. He's like you lock yourself in the room every day and you don't have to write but you're not allowed to do anything else. And I maybe it's a distinctive thing of writers but I feel like so many writers they like love writing the idea and they like excruciatingly hate the process of having to sit down.
Yeah. Do you get energy from the quote unquote boring things or the trudgery things? So I've talked to a lot of people who are like I don't want to write songs but I want to have written songs.
I like if I am in front of Ableton Live and like crafting up a MIDI baseline and running synths through plugins and
Reversing a piano and adding a tape loop to like
I will literally forget to go to the bathroom. I will forget to eat. Like I will wake up like 6 hours into the process and be like, "Oh my god, my bladder is about to explode and then like I have to run to the back." Like I lose myself. I'm gone.
You've got Ableton psychosis. I've heard about Claude Code psychosis, but it's Ableton psychosis.
It is that for me. It is the most like unembodied.
Are there things like that for Patreon? Presumably Patreon is a hugely mission-oriented thing. Yeah. That is largely about the way you're serving the world. Not to say music can't be that too.
So is it a different kind of thing or are there
So different and this is my struggle in life. Which is for me the process call it the input level behaviors associated with making music are the most joyful wonderful behaviors. They are intrinsically motivating. They're what some people call autotelic, which is like a behavior that you do for the sheer enjoyment of the behavior itself, not for some expected outcome. Like that is what music making is for me. And those behaviors just like give me instantaneous joy. Like presence and sometimes I would even call it like lack of presence like I don't even know I'm there anymore. I'm just so in the work. Patreon is not that for me. And maybe I don't know. I've talked to a lot of founders over the years. People say like do what you're passionate about. And I agree with that and I get that. The thing for me with Patreon is the outcome of Patreon is so deeply motivating and inspiring to me. The impact that the company has on people and creators and the world and culture is it gives me immeasurable meaning in my life like
Purpose. It is it feels like the reason I'm on earth it feels like the outcome that is like I can't imagine a more rewarding outcome and then the day-to-day behaviors are nowhere near as joyful as it
It'd be way more fun to be making music.
That'd be so fun. And so like this is my struggle. It's like I love this set of behaviors. I love that outcome. Man, if I could do that set of behaviors to get this outcome, life would be amazing. But you know, you're full of choices.
Why for you, and I guess this obviously maybe an easy question to answer for some people, but why was it so important? Why was it so important, I should say, to make your creative life a business even like pre-Patreon?
I love the craft of music making and creation. I love it. It's just so fun for me. There's another piece of my brain that is the mechanics of system design, business building, whatever you want to call it. That I also love that there are some artists, in fact, we have like three personas of artists that we often talk about at the company. There are some artists that are like, look, I want to play guitar and smoke weed and write songs. Don't bother me with anything else. And like that is a I in fact sometimes I wish I was that type of artist because like
Man first of all those artists make amazing work and they end up working with many of them a team who handles everything and they just get to like play guitar all day and that's amazing. Sometimes they get taken advantage of because they're not paying
Almost like the original benefactors of real patronage like the only way that person was alive or surviving 100 years ago was real patronage. And that is like that's that is a category of ours persona type one. Then there's a second persona that's like I don't like yeah I'll do some other things and sometimes the administrative work like I don't love it but I'll do it and like you know I don't hate talking about money but I don't love talking about money and I prefer not to you know but like I'll manage my Patreon income and I'll sell some merch and like I'll run my thing and like that's a second category of artists. There is a third category of artists. I forgot what we called them. Empire builder, architect. I don't remember what we called them, but there's a category of artists that's like, I love the business part. Like, the business part lights me up. I love and it's creative and I get to design. Like these artists are like, I'm a media company. They're like, I make media and like, oh my god, how do media companies make money? They have an events business. I could have an events business. Oh, they have an exclusive content business. Oh, they're segmenting their premium media and their from their premium media and they're thinking about their premium premium strategy. And how could I do that and what can I oh look how the New York Times grays out you know a third of the way through the article what's the video version of that maybe I can do that with my videos okay I'll put a call to action you know second you know blah blah blah
That's like exactly and there's a lot of artists that think are just like they dig it they like that stuff I have always liked that stuff.
What do you like about it?
I just it's a it's I like that it's like it's so different from the music creation. And again, I like both. I couldn't I think I probably like the music creation more, to tell you the truth, but this stuff is really fun for me. What do I like about it? I like that you can make this stuff is so hard to measure and it's so hard to know did I do a good job and it's so subjective.
Clear feedback loops. And this one is like you just put the things in place and you know if it worked or not. And there's something like checklisty about it that just is like it just is nice to see progress over time.
It's also just a different part of your brain probably.
It's a different piece of your brain.
Creativity. Yeah. Yeah. And so I feel when I'm doing all those things, I feel very whole, you know. I feel like I'm being my whole self.
You talk about media market fit. Maybe the first question here would be like what is the difference between content and art which is obviously could be a very big question we don't need to spend all day on it but rough I think what the reason I'm interested in the media market fit thing is on one hand it's really compelling and really interesting on the other hand there are maybe things we gain when creative people are really attuned to the market and there are things we lose when creative people are really attuned to the market maybe even to your stoner guitarist to founder spectrum and so maybe one vantage point or cut on That would be like the maybe the gradient between content and art. Like what aspects are at play there?
Yeah. Big big big wide gradient. Totally non-binary distinction like so, you know, and it's hard to sort of talk about. I'll give you the ends of the spectrum and maybe some things in between and how I think about it. You know, content I often one way to think about it is its purpose is not necessarily the transference of an emotion to another human that the creator of that piece had. The purpose is some intended outcome that to me I think of as like content. So like for Netflix, of course they call it content because their purpose behind the content is adding new subscribers to the system and increasing revenue and like so they think of it as content.
The artist doesn't or the creator of that film or TV show doesn't necessarily.
So the same piece of thing could actually be depending on who's talking about it
100%. And so like this is another reason I don't like that like I don't like the word influencer because I feel like influencer is what that is the commoditized attribute of an artist that is valuable to corporations the influence. And so they call that person an influencer because they're like that's the piece of that person that I care about. I don't care about the rest of them. I care about the fact their reach. That's the commodity. And by the way, it commoditizes artists because I can get influence from there or from there or from there or from there. And as long as there's eyeballs on the other end of that influence, it doesn't matter where I get it from. So it sort of turns artists into corn or steel. It's like doesn't matter. So content for me is a little bit of that same type of thing. It's more commoditized. It's more outcome oriented. It's more trying to achieve something. There's a goal behind it versus like when I think about art I think about I never remember if it's Tolstoy or Chekhov who basically said art is when the person who's creating the art felt something and wanted to communicate that feeling to another person and so you end up literally transferring that feeling you had into another person that is the process of art and like that has always stuck with me because my favorite art is when I finish it and I feel something. And when I feel something that I think maybe that person who made that thing wanted to get me to understand something in a way that was emotional, not logical even and I'm like I don't know if that's exactly what they were feeling, but like they told me something emotionally there. That's my favorite art in the world. And there is something I hate to even you know I've heard Rick Rubin talk about this and he sort of you know he talks about the difference between art and commerce. I think it is possible to make art and also to want to get paid for your art. Like if you're an artist and you want to be paid for your work that's not commerce that's like you feeling like you have value. That's having a sense of self-worth. That's recognizing that you're creating value for the world and you want to be compensated for your contributions to society. That's totally legitimate. I don't think like that's some pejorative version of art.
It's challenging because art is I would certainly agree that art is valuable. I don't know. I think art can sometimes be useful and I think the more perhaps the challenge and perhaps why the idea of patronage is so interesting is that the more entangled the art making gets with the commercial side of it, the fuzzier all of this gets and the incentives and everything else. Maybe it's just what we believe about the artist intentions, but
Not even what they actually are, but what we believe about what they are.
Art is also made as far as we know right now exclusively on planet Earth. And you know most of planet Earth is engulfed in an economic and financial system.
That is the context for art making and like you can try to separate those as much as possible, right? And you can try to say that you're making art in a vacuum and there's a lot of people who do a really good job of that. But like why would you do that? Like for me this is my problem with the term selling out. I think selling out is doing something other than making art. Like if you get paid for your art, that's the opposite of selling out. That's making sure that you're setting up your future so that you can make more art, right?
Goes back to the endurance point.
Yeah. Like that's like creating a sustainable path for yourself to make art. That's like a beautiful thing.
My friend Trevor McFedries, he did he says selling out is punk. Cuz by the way, the only if you're selling out now, it means you're probably not an IPO baby and your only choice is to actually make your thing is to sell out, which is funny.
Yeah. I think there are ways to make money that are really cheesy and or dishonest or like smarmy and like you can be an artist and do that. You can be an economist and do that. You can be a PM and do that. You can be a founder and do that. But like I think there are also ways to create value as an artist and be compensated for the value that you're creating that are wonderful and pure and reasonable and kind and good for the world. And like I Yeah. The reason I'm pushing so hard on this is because so many artists, right, those two-thirds of artists almost think that like if they make money from their art, it's like evil.
And like I'm on a mission in life and in this company to help creative people understand that they have meaning in the world. We've been looking at these dashboards on social media companies for 20 years now that tell us you just got 3 million views and that's worth $18 in ad revenue. That's your worth to the world. And I think that's a load of horseshit and that shouldn't be the case. And it's going to take a lot of convincing artists that like, no, no, no, that's the system saying you're worth only that. You're worth way more than that. You're creating so much more value than you're capturing as an artist. And that's a key piece of Patreon's mission is just to change how people even think about their own self-worth as artists in the world.
Why are fans paying the artists that they enjoy? Why is that such a That's obviously not a crazy idea. Like, it's existed for a while and yet it seems that what you do is not that common. Why are you so bought in on that being a great model for artists?
What's so what I love about this question is like so for thousands of years really pretty much every piece of great art that we ever have known any piece of art in history books was funded basically through patronage was funded because somebody was like hm I really like what you make you're cool here's a bag of coins go make more cool stuff
Or god wants it or whatever.
Right or god wants it or the government wants it. Then like in the early 1900s like humanity figured out how to record light onto celluloid paper and record sound onto a wax cylinder. And we were like, "Oh my god, you can put art on a physical object and you can ship that physical object to consumers and they will purchase that physical object not because of the object, the materials, but because of the art that's encoded on the object."
Although I will say I think the distribution friction and cost made it easy to justify charging for it.
Only the distribution and cost and lack of scarcity, right? And cost of materials, right? And so, you know, that created like a hundred years of an infrastructure buildout. Jewel cases for CDs and cardboard record sleeves and, you know, magnetic tape in, you know, VHS.
Also worth noting, really good for musicians and filmmakers, not that good for a whole bunch of other art mediums, right?
No. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. But anybody telling stories with sound or moving pictures, right? Great for those folks. And that sort of then over the 1900s there are all these it was all this industry popped up that was sort of around the distribution and economics of unit sales as a replacement for patronage as the main economic model for artists, right? And so it became CD sales or tape sales or laser discs or Blu-rays or whatever it is. And then the internet came around and suddenly the thing that you said made those objects valuable which was scarcity disappeared. Pieces of art were infinitely replicable and no longer scarce. And the early experiments with okay what are we gonna do here is like Napster and then it was like well there should be some type of economics around this was like iTunes and then about 10 or 15 no sorry like maybe five years into that and I was like no no ad revenue because sometimes I think of ad revenue as basically like the go to market strategy for the web.
I would argue it's probably the only truly defined and great business model of the internet as it currently stands. You're trying to change that, but it's the only one we really found.
It is the mature one for sure. And the one that started the earliest. I think also humanity is like reckoning with all the
Problems associated with that.
But it's the one that's least fighting gravity. Like from a user experience, there are a whole bunch of things structurally about music that actually make sense for I shouldn't have to pay a dollar to listen to a song once, right? Like I'm going to enjoy it the more I listen to it anyway.
Free experiences for the end consumer will always beat paid experiences for the end consumer straight up.
And so that's why the internet kind of got to scale so quickly right like this technology was invented and like 20 years later like billions of us are using it that's because it was free right if it cost everybody 10 bucks to get on like it probably I'm not sure we would have seen it explode like it did so it was a great kind of way to get things up and running and to get humanity connected. But I think the early companies that kind of won there thought of art as like a subcategory of information, right? They were like information should be free.
Information such as art and news and artists were like what? And so I looked up one day and just felt like this system is not like in a day and age of infinite replicability and a lack of scarcity and no more physical objects with your art on it. How are artists going to get paid? And strangely, it sort of initially was like before those objects existed in the first place. Back to 1900, pre-magnetic tape, pre-wax cylinders, pre-Edison cylinders, like back to bag of coins. You're doing something cool.
Is there much history? No, no worries if you don't know, but is there any serious history of a more democratized or fragmented patronage? Because the obvious huge difference is that back then it was a rich guy, the Medici family and some governments.
It's funny. I sometimes joke my podcast is free for all listeners. I have one sponsor. It's Notion. They're a software company. They're great. They're my patron. Like quite literally closer to the Medici than before. Obviously the big difference in your worldview is like it's not going to be one guy or even two guys or three. Which does have a lot of things that are structurally different including but not limited to something I referenced earlier which is when your core audience and your customer are the same group. There are good parts of that and there are bad parts of that.
So interestingly, patronage for us was where the company came from and was the first thesis behind this model that we started building and also the kind of emotional truth of what Patreon is. Right. And narrative truth of what it is. But what we have found, you know, years in, not even that far in, we started working on a different way to think about it because what we found is the truth is like a lot of artists are like, I don't want to put out a hat and ask for money. Like what do you think? Like I'm reaching millions of people. Like I'm a badass. I'm going on tour and selling $5,000 worth of tickets. Like I'm not going to busk on the internet. I'm not doing patronage. And that feedback was like loud and clear and what we saw was actually like the way of thinking about Patreon that's like
It's not a donation. It's very important that it can't be a donation and actually it's not just a positioning thing. It's not just a marketing thing. It's in the product. So, we built this CRM that's more about running your business, getting the email address of the fans, building the direct relationship with your audience. We built one-time payments, which allows artists to transact and sell a piece of digital media or a collection of back catalog of videos.
I love that the fact that you can buy a single video for $8 or whatever, which is maybe a lot for a video, but I wish I could do that on Netflix or whatever. It's great.
We built a more robust membership system. So we, you know, before Patreon in 2017, you could be a member, but you were a member of a gym. I don't even know if people realize that. We literally invented the category of digital creator membership. No one was using that term. You couldn't become a member of a creator. You could become a member of an organization. But there was no membership for creators before Patreon started calling it that and building the product that was membership for creators. And then during the pandemic that really took off with podcasters. It started taking off. Membership as a category started taking off even before the pandemic but it got augmented during COVID with the sort of podcast explosion.
Why do you think that was? Because podcasting is episodic and the sort of dollars per watch minute to produce podcasts is like that's an amazing ratio for podcasters versus animation for example is like very costly per watch. Was it primarily fully gated shows or shows that were two-thirds like Josh Citell or whatever where there's a bonus episode?
This is precisely what changed over the course of the pandemic because that's when New York Times's subscription revenue surpassed their ad revenue. It's when The Guardian introduced premium and freemium. Now, you know, there are no publications who don't have some type of premium. Even like Disney, Netflix, they have the free tier, they have the paid tier. It's kind of in the public consciousness now that if I am a producer of media on the web, some portion of that media should be gated and some portion should be free. And there's a user journey there. There's a fan journey there associated with that free to paid conversion that is like important for artists. And that was not a part of the internet 10 years ago. That's like new in the last five, six years that that's become part of the public consciousness.
Maybe there was like flickers of this on Twitch or OnlyFans. I don't know when that showed up, but even that I don't know if it's quite the same psychology. It's a little different.
Yeah. There were always there I don't want to say always but like even in the early days of the web there were things that artists were posting that you could pay for. Right, like I remember in 2011 Pomplamoose, my band, was doing paid live webcasts. We had a show and a red curtain and we'd sold tickets.
Why do you think that hasn't worked more? Is that working at all on Patreon?
I actually think there is a reason. I think it's very hard to make something live that is super engaging. Versus like if I'm going to spend half hour watching something, if I frontload six weeks of work into making a really engaging half hour, it's just so much easier than doing a bunch of production to make an engaging half hour.
Totally. And this is why live streaming the average streamer streams for six hours is actually like a lower bar, longer duration. And you're watching it while you work, whatever.
Right. And what you're streaming is actually something that someone else has produced and spent a long time producing and making excellent games, right? Like the graphics, the intrigue, the strategy, like you're watching a game and then what makes it compelling and why you're not just watching a game is because there's an awesome human who's talking about it. Yeah. Or even the I mean even speed and clvicular and the crazy like they have to go to such an end of spectacle.
Right. We don't have to get into that but I may have cut you off but I think this is a helpful transition maybe along a similar point which is one thing I've observed is that a lot of the big consumer internet companies the last 15 years we think of them as technology companies and they obviously are but the breakthrough like obviously they're tech hosting live video or whatever these things not easy. But if you look at you guys or even Uber or Airbnb or Twitch or whatever, it's actually like culturally normalizing a behavior and saying like you're allowed to do this. Obviously, I assume some of this is emergent, which is you're having your creators or your fans telling you to do this, but I'm curious what you've learned about how that actually happens.
Slowly. I remember pitching Patreon to investors in 2014 and like one of the main pieces of push back was like, Wait, so you guys are going to ask people to pay for something that's free on another platform? And I was like, Yeah, at least Twitch, it's on our buffer and it's on YouTube. And they were like, Thank you. Good luck with that.
Didn't you raise money pretty quickly?
We raised $700,000. We got a term sheet for 700,000. We ended up raising the ceiling for the round to 2.1 million about 3 months after launching.
Okay. Okay. But it wasn't working yet or was it?
No, it was so it kind of worked right away. It worked immediately. And but so I have to caveat when I say that because a lot of people are like, Oh my god, that's amazing. But what isn't said there is I tried 5,000 other things that went absolutely nowhere. This was one of the 5,000 things that kind of that worked. And so like there was that product market fit hunting phase. I never set out to start a company is the thing. Like I've never was like I want to make a company and that's going to be my life. I never thought that. But this was just one of the hundreds of projects that I was working on that took off right away. And so we just leaned in, you know, over the years and that's why I think it's not remarkable that it worked.
What about presumably you guys have done this multiple times including but not limited to the shift from donation to actually like you're selling digital goods basically. Even that is a version of this culturally normalizing something and at least from my view you guys have kind of done this and I would even add like new categories on the platform like being able to actually take hold in the board game world or in the podcast world or whatever like is most of that just being really attentive to what's happening on the platform or are there ways that you can kind of bend things in the direction you want them?
Yeah, my take I come from the world of YouTube right like I come from the world of artists and creators I've never had a tech job. I've never worked at another tech company. This is the only company I've ever worked at in my life. This is my first job that I've ever had. Yes. Like this is my first time I've ever worked straight out of college music and then YouTube. I worked as a contractor I was an SAT tutor. I was a contractor doing in-house background music for corporate videos for Google, but I was just composing.
You did voice some characters on The Sims 2.
I was an actor. I was the voice of a teenage boy. So like I did all but I never like went to work at a company every day. So this is my first job. My read after 13 years of working with all kinds of different execs and people in Silicon Valley is that I think Silicon Valley largely this is maybe one of the reasons I think Silicon Valley often just looks so out of touch with the rest of the world and why there's so much push back and honestly like a lot of backlash and hatred of tech in the last 10 years. I think a lot of it is because my read of the valley is people undervalue brand and narrative and creativity and storytelling and a lot of these things that in my world where I come from those are the things.
And like in Silicon Valley like the main thing is the product which is really true like the main thing is the product.
Also the projects are magic half the chatbot comes out you need a lot of narrative.
You don't need narrative because the product is so it just it is incredible. Yeah. And so I don't mean to say the product isn't the thing. At the end of the day like 99% of people their interaction with the company is going to be the product, right? And so the product is the thing, but you can know that the product is a thing and care about narrative and creativity and storytelling and brand or you can not care about those things. And I think if you don't care about those things, it's very hard to influence culture and to build a brand that people love and to have trust with your customers and like it's very hard to do those things. A lot of those things are a completely different skill set. It's a completely different mindset. It's a different way of thinking about the world. Yeah, there's a lot of operators who like if it doesn't show up in the P&L, they don't believe that it's real. And then there's some operators who like actually operate from a place of conviction and belief in hey this is going to build trust with customers. It's going to be hard to see the incremental impact in the P&L, but I know it's going to build trust with customers and that's going to create loyalty and that's going to improve retention. It's going to improve conversion at every stage of the funnel. And so from a place of belief and conviction, we're going to do that. There's a type of operator that believes that and there's a type that doesn't. And I think Silicon Valley a lot of people here are the type that just don't really believe that for whatever reason. I do I can't prove it.
Can't prove it. I can't there's no model. We've tried building the attribution frameworks. It's a waste of time. Like you can't it's just why do that?
But I believe it. And so yeah, I'm trying to answer your question around like changing people's mindsets and mentality and normalizing behaviors, you know, around paying creators for their work. And I think a lot of it is understanding brand and narrative and storytelling and then if you don't have the product to back it up, it won't work, right?
But it's maybe not mechanical first. It's like most emotional or a human problem first.
It's possible the answer to this question is embedded in part of what you just said, but my sense is and it could just be my kind of corner of Twitter and the world is that in a certain part of Silicon Valley and startup land, Patreon is very underrated. Perhaps you feel that and if so, why?
I would say even dismissed.
Why do you think that is? I would agree. It is I'll do an on the nose example. And I like them. I like the platform. Substack is very in vogue in that world. Patreon is not. Part of that is obviously the content on the platform and who uses it. But it's really interesting to me and Patreon's quite big and quite successful. So I'm curious.
Yeah. Why is that? Well, let me give you what I think is the real answer, which is a little painful for me to say, but I think it's a big piece of the truth. I think it's I think I have to take accountability for that. Like my vibe is not very Silicon Valley. I don't like I don't even think of Silicon Valley people as my people, you know? Like the way I talk like what I care about like talking about brand and narrative and marketing like it's really
I mean I feel like it's more in vogue to like talk about how you're cutting your marketing team to invest in engineering. Like I feel like that's more tech vibe.
And I don't believe in that. Like I understand where that's coming from, but like my values, the things that I care about show up in how the company talks and how the company messages and what I say and what we all say and how we write our blog posts and like we very much speak to creators. We don't like I know a lot of companies Substack included like when they speak the primary lens is like reaching tech people. How do we make tech excited about our product? I just when I'm writing communications to people I'm not thinking about that at all. I'm not thinking about how do I reach the next hundred engineers as much as I am thinking about how to build trust with creative people and artists. And so I think just like 13 years of doing that, I think people in Silicon Valley just don't care about us as much. Which is I think very I think that's legit. Why would they care about us? We're not talking to them.
I think there's something to that. I think there is obviously a part of it is that like a lot of people in a certain part of Silicon Valley read the types of people who would be more likely to be on Substack than on Patreon. Like part of it is just like where is the audience?
I think that's a big piece of it too is like the stuff that people the media that people author on Substack is about tech about politics. Josh and Racho and these people are not huge on Twitter. And like the people on Patreon are like they're talking about Reckless Ben and the Lego scandal from last year. And like those are my people that's what I want to talk about. And ironically it's actually but so here's what's weird Patreon is more YouTube obviously that's like a in there isn't this with YouTube maybe just because YouTube's so colossal and so big although maybe it's also true that the average technology-oriented person or startup person.
I think this is actually one of do you know the TVN guys Josh and Jordy?
Yeah I mean I don't know them but I know of them.
Or John and Jordy I should say. I think one of the reasons they were successful is they took a whole bunch of ideas that were like really well trained on the other parts of the internet and brought them to Twitter. But yeah anyway it's so this is actually recent with tech on YouTube. Tech was not big on YouTube.
Right? Yeah. Now All-In is playing mafia on YouTube. But I mean, honestly, like I think the pivotal moment was All-In, right, which was more of a podcast, but like the podcast was the entry point into YouTube and then podcast exploded in tech and now everybody has a podcast and that is the that was how tech got onto YouTube. Yeah. But like before that, tech communities didn't really exist on YouTube.
Yeah. It's also just funny like Silicon Valley is a place that loves people who are out there and like very like don't fit into a box. At least that's the stated preference and you were very that. But anyway, I don't know if we're going to fully litigate it, but I always thought that was funny. I'm sure there are other examples, but there aren't a ton of easy ones of platforms and big products that really really ruthlessly prioritize creators over the rest of the audience. What has that and that's not to say you don't clearly you guys value Patreon viewers, consumers, fans, whatever, patrons. What has that kind of orientation or principle how has that shaped the company over particularly over the long run?
It is the shape of the company. We of course we value fans. We have to value fans. If we don't value fans, we can't truly be a creator first company because creators first priority is their fans. So we must value fans and we have to build the systems and processes and tools and products to help creators reward their fans, think of their fans, prioritize their fans, etc. For us as a company, the way I think about it is like there are so many great products out there that are an awesome deal for consumers. There's a lot of big muscly companies that push their weight around and get the consumer what they need.
That's great for consumers. We have a lot of options. There's a lot of competition, but there needs to be a big powerful company that has sharp elbows that muscles its way around that makes the world better for creators. If such a company, if such a system does not exist, things are going to keep getting better for consumers, which is asymmetric.
That drives that makes things worse for if you're always optimizing for good then it's always all you can eat 10 bucks a month you get as much art as you want. That's not a good economic model for creative people.
I think that the reason this has been challenging for people to see even creators is that most of these other aggregator style platforms promise creators audience which is like the ultimate scarcity and so it feels like that's obvious if you want creators you need to give them audience which actually means catering to the consumer and you've kind of inverted that in a way that wasn't obvious. We've totally inverted it. It makes it very hard for some people when they get here to think about it from the creator lens because they're used to thinking about it from the consumer lens.
Any UGC company, they think of it as like that is a means to the end, which is driving DAU, which creates ad revenue.
Yes. And so they're like, how are we going to get that DAU? Oh, let's spin up a program where we help creators author posts. Like for us, the creation of the art is the purpose and everything is downstream of that. And so it's a different way to think about the world and it comes down to the company's KPIs, right? Like our primary KPI is dollars sent to creators, right? And so like that's what we're thinking about. That's what we're talking about. Like that's not a byproduct of the company. That's the purpose of the company.
It almost you can almost imagine somebody coming in and saying maybe there have been examples of this we're going to charge half of Patreon's take rate but in the end their core incentive is to grow audience so it gets maybe to put it a different way why do you think perhaps I mean philosophically I'm sure it is that commitment why do you think Patreon has remained so sticky both for creators but also for fan and patron cohorts?
This is a big number to put it in a different way. Yeah, this is one of those things that I'm going to have the sort of spiritual answer and then there's maybe the technical answer.
Right? I'm interested in both.
I think the real answer is the spiritual answer which is we've done right by creators for 13 years and that compounds just like anything else. And that compounding trust and understanding from the community has built a lot of goodwill. I'm not saying we don't have detractors. Of course we have detractors. It usually has to do with content policy stuff. When we make a really difficult content policy decision, a lot of people get angry at you.
But we've done right by creative people like people think of Patreon as the a lot of people think of Patreon as the good guys. Certainly a lot of artists and creative people think of Patreon as the good guys. If you're gonna run your business on a platform, if you're going to trust that platform with your revenue, with your monthly income stream, with the main thing that you use to build a life for yourself to pay your mortgage, you're going to go with the platform that you think is the good guys. You're going to go with the platform that you trust.
Or that the creators you admire trust.
Right. And so what does that mean tactically? It means that we make long-term decisions founded on trust, I think, just more often than other companies do. We don't trade that for a lot. And I'm not saying we don't ever have to make decisions where we trade trust. There's sometimes we have to deprecate a product and that's really hard for the market and so we have to build mitigation plans and like okay we do all those things. But like we will often make trades where we trade short-term revenue for long-term trust with our creators and fans. We make those trades all the time. I believe those trades are in the best long-term interest of Patreon's mission and even the shareholders, certainly the creators, certainly the fans. But like I want Patreon to be a hundred-year company, you know? I want us to be around. I want us to be fighting for creative people 100 years from now after I'm dead. And I think you can't get there unless you really care about long-term trust. And I think about some of my favorite companies. I know everybody tech is all hot and bothered about Costco. So, I'll be one of the people who's hot and bothered about Costco. I think Costco's awesome. Like Costco kept the price of the hot dog at a buck 50 for like decades. And when Costco got down to the point where they couldn't keep it at $1.50 anymore, because their suppliers weren't supplying them at the right prices anymore.
They bought a hot dog factory and they made the acquisition. They retooled their whole operation. They figured out a way to keep the price of the hot dog at $1.50. Like a bunch of people look at that and say like that's a terrible business decision. But Costco's like we believe that people trusting us is the most important thing. We believe our customers are fiduciaries.
Right. And it's aligned with their critically for Patreon. It's like that's all nice and it's aligned because you have chosen a business model that makes money when their creators make money.
Which I think is an important kind of part. It's not just the values, it's also the incentives.
100% the and that I wish I could say that was strategic and thoughtful. I think it was just accidental but maybe there was some intuitive element of that but yes having a take rate model means that all we have to do is help creators make more money and if we do that then we make more money. So that business and people incentive means that we don't have to kind of choose between us and creators.
What will actually make Patreon outlive you? What will it take?
This is a deep question. I think there's a couple things. Really great governance. Really great culture and values. And then a focus on building long-term trust. Trust, values, culture, governance. If you nail those things, I think a company can last a long, long time.
To maybe invert the question, why are you still the right person to run Patreon? Now, hire a professional CEO. And by the way, you sure like that. I don't mean a big gray suit. I mean, find somebody who's really value aligned, who has more manage experience. You can go make more music, whatever.
You could be the chairman who goes around does podcasts more.
I have thought about that and I'm I didn't like in my life I wasn't like ah I want to be a CEO. Like that's not my goal in life. Like I want to solve this problem. Yeah. You know. And so right now I think I'm the right person to solve this problem. And I think it's also possible that there will come a moment where I'm like, okay, all of the long-term things are in place. The culture is just this snowball rolling down a mountain at a million miles an hour. Has so much momentum. The governance is all in place. Like all the pieces are there and like honestly the company doesn't need me anymore. Benefit from somebody else. I'm not against that. I don't think we're there yet, but like how will I know we're there? I mean, culture, governance, like it's just literally those things. I mean, I think it's very like I'm pushing to make that happen.
Not because I don't want the gig anymore, but because I want Patreon to be under your company.
Yeah. In any context, obviously you have more experience in running Patreon and maybe leading bands sense. What makes a good leader?
Oh, boy, hard lessons over the years here. A lot of pain. I don't know that I'm ready to raise my hand and like offer leadership advice to the world on a public podcast. Like I think there's a lot of things that I've learned and that I'm a lot better at now. I think there's a lot of things I'm still growing and want to get better at. But I have worked with a lot of leaders who I think are really amazing and I have worked with leaders who I don't trust as much and maybe I can offer some lessons from that lens. One is like who is the ambition for? Is it for the self or is it for the mission of the company? I like working with really ambitious people, but I want that ambition to be aimed at the mission of the company. And when the ambition is aimed at the self, that's on the denominator of the leadership quality equation.
It's gotten faster and faster for me to pick up on to the point where I can start to pick it up in the interview process. Now, where is the ambition coming from? But sometimes if somebody's really strategic you cannot pick it up or I cannot pick it up for a little while.
So that's one like ambition for the self versus ambition for the company for the mission. There's some basics like do you do what you say you're going to do? Like do you execute what you promise? You deliver what you say you're going to do. That's like reliability, dependability, those sorts of things. Like not everybody's got that.
That's huge. And somehow also like the busiest and most effective people in the world are also the most reliable.
Not a coincidence, right?
There's some really important things to me that I think are important. One is like do you have the passion muscle? And what I mean by that is like did you love something before you got to Patreon? Can you fall in love with your customer? Can you go to the ends of the earth to serve someone else to create value?
Does that passion need to be outside of yourself?
Yeah. Same thing as like the ambition. It's like is there something external that you just you can fall in love with? It's like call it obsess, call it passion, call it whatever. It's like is this a person who gets obsessed with things? That's what I really value about people like Hank Green who's like one of my favorite people in the world. It's just like dude can get obsessed about so many things. I think it makes him really special. Another thing is, can you egolessly self-reflect and do so with humility? That's maybe not important for a lot of other companies, founders, operators. Maybe it is in some capacity. For me, it's really important. I really want to see a leader who can not only self-reflect egolessly and be like, I didn't do this well. I'm sorry about that. I want to make sure that doesn't happen again. And not like with a bunch of guilt and shame, but like with a, huh, like I'm puppeting this meatsack that did this thing and this meat sack has now learned that thing and it's going to do better next time. Like there's some objective ability to do that that some folks have that I think is