CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jack Conte gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jack Conte
CEO & Co-Founder, Patreon

Patreon’s CEO: Social media is killing creators

📅 Jan 13, 2025 Taylor Lorenz 35 MIN 29 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Social media as we know it is in chaos. The landscape is becoming more centralized and the very notion of a follower is dying.

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:40What's happened over the last four years to the web?
  2. 6:39Do you think also creators programming increasingly for algorithmic driven feeds is leading to more extreme content, because you have to get more extreme to compete in these feeds?
  3. 7:14Isn't this also kind of good for those smaller creators that are trying to build up an audience?
  4. 10:47How do you leverage these platforms to build a community so that you can even get them on something like Patreon?
  5. 16:01How do you think of that subscription ecosystem and where it's going?
  6. 19:20From a user perspective, what do you think?
  7. 22:41What platforms are emergent? What formats are emerging?
  8. 27:50What are your thoughts on that shift?
  9. 30:23How do you think about content moderation and the creators you choose to allow on Patreon?
  10. 31:51People have a more permissive attitude than even a few years ago. Has your thinking evolved?
  11. 33:45Are you seeing any up-and-coming people natively on Patreon?
  12. 34:58Well, Patreons are the people that subscribe. Patrona?
Taylor Lorenz 0:00 ↗
It's this like mindless dopamine overload. It is starting to make us all feel tired and alone and broken, and we don't want that. Social media as we know it is in chaos right now. The landscape is becoming more decentralized, and creators are facing more challenges than ever. On top of all that, the very notion of a follower is dying, and there's uncertainty about what that means for the future. Jack Conte is the CEO and founder of Patreon. He's been talking about all these issues. 'My followers might not necessarily see my posts. The channel of distribution is broken.' Hi Jack, welcome to Power User.
Jack Conte 0:38 ↗
Thanks for having me. Psy to be here.
Taylor Lorenz 0:40 ↗
So you gave this talk at South by Southwest last year that I thought was one of my favorite pieces of content ever. I don't even know if it's fair to call it a piece of content, but it was so interesting. It was called 'The Death of a Follower,' and you talked about the way the web was changing and moving from this follower model. Can you give people who didn't see that talk a 101 on what you've been talking about? What's happened over the last four years to the web?
Jack Conte 1:03 ↗
I think a lot of people, because of the shift simultaneously to short form vertical first video, just think that's what happened to the internet. But I think short form was the red herring. What's really happened is for the first 20 years of the web, it was organized around this concept of the follower. You had feeds, self-publishing tools like Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube, and you could follow somebody and build a community. That was essentially a guaranteed line of communication to the people that chose to follow you. When they said 'follow,' it was not just 'I like you and your work,' it was 'I want to hear the things that you have to say in the future.' That's what's shifted over the last four or five years, specifically when TikTok came into the scene. They rebuilt the concept of the feed, basing it not around followers but around interests and recommendations. They said, 'Let's forget about the follow. Let's put stuff in your feed that we think you'll like, regardless of if you've followed them or not.' TikTok found that worked quite well at maximizing attention. The unfortunate thing is it worked so well that traffic started being siphoned off of Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube toward TikTok. So all the legacy social companies had to compete. They adopted this concept of 'for you' rather than architecting their services around the follow. Now their algorithms are centered around interests and recommendations. YouTube released Shorts, Instagram released Reels, Twitter launched a 'for you' feed. Essentially, the entire internet has shifted off the follow graph and onto the interest graph. That has been successful at maximizing consumer attention, but it's been really hurtful in allowing creators to run tight-knit communities and businesses. If I'm a creator and I've invested in these platforms for the last two decades and built my following, and now suddenly when I make a post I can't reach them anymore, that's insane. I don't know how any of us are okay with that happening. That was the premise of the talk. I have a lot of thoughts on the solution and what Patreon is doing about it, but that is what has happened to the web over the last four years.
Taylor Lorenz 4:14 ↗
I think you're totally right. I feel like this is a complete paradigm shift that has gone under the radar. You're not seeing articles about it. Aside from you, I have not really seen people talking about it. I think we see the effects of things like this come up, like VidCon a couple years ago when TikTok sponsored VidCon for the first time and they were having trouble getting people to show up for meet and greets with TikTokers because people just don't have that same bond with TikTokers as they do YouTubers.
Jack Conte 4:53 ↗
That is exactly what is happening. Because the platforms have rotated so far toward discovery and time maximization, you end up having hundreds of weaker connections rather than spending more time with one individual and really understanding who they are. You have this passive scrolling, fly-by-night mentality. The unit of value on TikTok is the piece of content that stops me from being bored for 15 seconds. That has commoditized creators. It doesn't matter if I get that content from this creator or that creator. It's just corn, steel, rice. It's a commodity. With the follow, the unit of value is the relationship, getting to know a person over time. The material manifestation of that is exactly what you discussed: creators show up at VidCon from TikTok and there's no lines because it's not about them, it's about that one video they made nine months ago. Their next post got 200 views instead of reaching their followers. So we're seeing fandoms and communities become diluted over time instead of strengthening.
Taylor Lorenz 6:39 ↗
Do you think also creators programming increasingly for algorithmic driven feeds is leading to more extreme content, because you have to get more extreme to compete in these feeds?
Jack Conte 6:49 ↗
100%. The system that you're posting inside of and the feedback mechanisms of that system influence what you say and what you want to say. A lot of what we've seen over the last 10 years is not actually how humanity feels and speaks, but what we're being trained to say in order to get the reach and outcomes that we want as creators. That's a problem.
Taylor Lorenz 7:14 ↗
Yeah, I feel like it's happening across all apps because every app has replicated this system. I was on Twitter, X, I don't know what to call it anymore, and I opened my feed and realized my entire first view was not a single person that I followed. After watching your talk, I talked to a bunch of creators about this. Some smaller creators were saying it's frustrating because we have to program for an algorithm now instead of for our subscribers, but also it was so hard before to get discovered. Discovery has always been a huge problem on these apps, especially for up-and-coming creators when the market like YouTube is so saturated. So how can they do discovery in a responsible way? Isn't this also kind of good for those smaller creators that are trying to build up an audience?
Jack Conte 8:02 ↗
This is the right question. There's a nuanced conversation to be had. It's not one or the other. That's a false binary. Obviously there needs to be a balance. I agree that the balance was off before. Why did TikTok blow up so much? Because they solved the problem that you just said. YouTube was like a brick wall. You could not break in as an up-and-coming creator. Then TikTok came up with this system that allowed anybody to break in and get a foot in the door. That's a beautiful thing. Then the question becomes: how do we solve the problem of discovery and give smaller creators a way to break in, and still offer people a direct line of communication and relationship with their followers that allows them to build tight-knit communities and businesses? It's a false binary to say we can do one or the other. Patreon has algorithms. We're investing in our algorithms. Patreon has discovery, Patreon has Explore. When a creator launches on Patreon now, over half of their memberships come from members on Patreon who already have Patreon accounts. There is discovery and a network happening on Patreon. But if you ask creators on Patreon, 'Do you feel like you can reach your followers?' they all say yes. They say it is much easier to reach the people that you've chosen to follow on Patreon because of the way we've architected our systems. We're introducing more discovery tools, but we're doing it in a way that is architected around the follow, not around the interest. We can afford to do that because our KPIs are not time maximization. We don't have to optimize for session time like these other platforms do. For us, there is no correlation between session time and revenue. We're a consumer payments business. So I think we are more advantaged in being able to solve a more strategic balance for creators. It is possible to do both, and that's how we're approaching it.
Taylor Lorenz 10:47 ↗
What do you think for creators that do have to operate on these platforms and still want to use them to the best of their ability, but the community aspects are atrophied? What advice do you have for creators trying to navigate this social web that's become so broken? How do you leverage these platforms to build a community so that you can even get them on something like Patreon?
Jack Conte 11:11 ↗
It's really hard right now to be a creator on the web. All the pressure, the dashboards, the feeling when you make a post and it doesn't perform, all points us to optimize around outcomes and metrics. How do I increase my CTR? How do I make my videos longer so I'm more favored by the algorithm? These things are becoming part of the culture of being a creator. The tendency is to be so outcome-driven and goal-oriented that you forget to be an artist, to speak from your heart, to make mistakes and say things that are true to you even if they're unpopular. Our favorite artists in history are the ones who were bold and fearlessly themselves. We're being trained to not do that. My advice: one, be very aware of that tension and don't over-optimize for the outcome. Don't forget why you got into this in the first place. Feed your soul with your craft. Two, use short form to break in. If you're a new creator without an audience, upload Reels, upload TikToks. I don't think you can break in on medium format right now. Break in on short form. Three, once you've found an audience, launch something long form. You're renting your audience on short form. Use your short form to bridge to a podcast, a YouTube channel, a newsletter, or something where you can retain your audience. Find a place where you can nurture and build that community in a long form piece of content. Four, build a community around that long form medium. Invest in real togetherness. Have real community, real discussion. Meet up in person. Have real human interaction. I remember when Pomp was getting started, we did things like Cookie Run. We'd tweet out that we were going to play a live set, baked chocolate chip cookies, and give them away for free in the park. 20 people would show up and we'd have a beautiful little thing. The more stuff you can do like that, the better. Five, there are a lot of ways for creators to get paid. The easiest is brand and advertising income. That's a good way to make money. But don't forget about direct-to-consumer payments. I'm biased, I run a company that helps creators accept payments from fans, but our research shows that consumer payments are the bigger part of the creator economy. Memberships, subscriptions, one-time payments, digital commerce, physical commerce, merchandise, courses. Investing in the consumer payments portion of your business, in addition to ads and brands, helps you build a well-rounded, diversified business that can catapult you into the long run.
Taylor Lorenz 16:01 ↗
I think it's phenomenal advice. There's been so much conversation lately around subscription fatigue around creators. It feels like we all have to manually pay for all of our favorite creators, which I love to do, but it is a lot. It's hard for new creators, especially young people, to get people to subscribe because they're already paying for their top 15 people on Patreon or any other platform. You're also seeing the rise of Substack and other subscription-based platforms. Then the platforms themselves are trying to facilitate subscriptions. How do you think of that subscription ecosystem and where it's going?
Jack Conte 16:43 ↗
Subscriptions are a great way for creators who make episodic media to make money. If you make a thing a week, like a podcast or a YouTube show, subscriptions are really awesome. The primary model is three of four things are free, one is behind a paywall. Another is the first 30 minutes are free on YouTube, the next 30 or 60 minutes are behind the paywall. That allows creators to put every piece of media out online and still monetize behind a paywall. But you're correct. On the consumer side, not everybody wants to pay with subscriptions. Our data shows that over half of even super fans don't want to pay with a subscription. They have subscription fatigue or they want to try before they buy. So it's important for creators to have other ways to make money. Patreon launched a one-time payments product, and it has grown 4X in its first year. There's so much demand for it. The big categories are merchandise, digital commerce like one-time payments for wallpaper or an illustration book, collections of videos like courses, back catalogs, ticketed live streams. Those are all a piece of Patreon's present and future. There are a bunch of ways that fans want to pay and that creators want to be paid that are not subscriptions.

15 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Conte, J. (2025, January 13). Patreon’s CEO: Social media is killing creators [Interview transcript]. Taylor Lorenz. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/614650/

MLA

Jack Conte. "Patreon’s CEO: Social media is killing creators." Taylor Lorenz, 13 Jan. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/614650/.

BibTeX
@misc{conte2025_614650,
  author       = {Jack Conte},
  title        = {Patreon’s CEO: Social media is killing creators},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Taylor Lorenz. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {jan},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/614650/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}