CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Scott Galloway
Founder; Host of The Prof G Pod; Co-host of Pivot and Prof G Markets, Prof G Media

Why Americans Cheer Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny — With Anand Giridharadas

📅 Oct 08, 2026 The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway and Anand Giridharadas 46 MIN 3179 VIEWS 44 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Anand Giridharadas, journalist and author of Man in the Mirror, joins Scott Galloway to discuss what Jordan Neely’s death reveals about homelessness, public safety, and America’s crisis of belonging. He explains why cities struggle to help their most vulnerable residents, the difficult questions around involuntary mental health treatment, and how community can help people rebuild their lives. Plus, what the reactions to Daniel Penny and Luigi Mangione reveal about Americans’ growing sense of abandonment—and the line between protecting others and taking justice into your own hands. Timestamp...

What Scott Galloway said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Scott Galloway and Anand Giridharadas discuss the Jordan Neely and Daniel Penny case, the subject of Giridharadas's book 'Man in the Mirror.' Galloway shares his observations on homelessness in San Francisco and New York, noting the problem is 'distinctly better' in San Francisco but still severe. He argues that the top of the funnel for homelessness is isolation, citing that only 4% of homeless are veterans and the largest cohort are people with no connections. Galloway expresses sympathy for the view that if you can say whatever you want, you should be able to live wherever you want. He compares the Penny case to the killing of Brian Thompson, suggesting both men were seen as filling a void of order. Galloway notes the jury acquitted Penny of criminally negligent homicide in about 24 hours, indicating moral clarity, and predicts the jury will find similar clarity around Luigi Mangione, though he expects Mangione to spend his life in prison.

Key takeaways

  1. Galloway said the jury acquitted Daniel Penny of criminally negligent homicide in about 24 hours, indicating moral clarity.
  2. Galloway predicted the jury will find the same moral clarity around Luigi Mangione, but expects him to spend his life in prison.
  3. Galloway said only 4% of the homeless are veterans, and the largest cohort are people with no connections.
  4. Galloway compared the Penny-Neely case to the killing of Brian Thompson, saying both men were seen as self-appointed avengers in the absence of dependable authority.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
4% percentage of homeless who are veterans metric 23:08
24 hours time for jury to acquit Daniel Penny metric 37:48

Chapters

  1. 0:00Failed TV shows and COVID filming
  2. 6:16Introduction to Man in the Mirror
  3. 10:15Homelessness in San Francisco and New York
  4. 11:14Right to shelter and street homelessness
  5. 20:11Grants Pass case and right to sleep outdoors
  6. 23:08Isolation as root cause of homelessness
  7. 24:56Fountain House and mental health as public health
  8. 33:14Comparing Penny-Neely and Luigi Mangione cases
  9. 37:48Jury verdict and moral clarity

Questions asked in this interview

7
  1. 6:42And from the moment news kind of wafted up from that Broadway-Lafayette subway station, it became instantly an American Rorschach test, right?
  2. 11:14And I spent three years with people living them. Right?
  3. 20:11The Grants Pass case came up and it tested, is there a right to be homeless, specifically a right to sleep outdoors?
  4. 20:40But even in a city, right?
  5. 24:56And I think that is often the problem here, that the remedies of the kind you're talking about, how do we actually give people belonging not as happenstance but in a systematized way?
  6. 33:28A lot of them realized immediately that that was their next case, right?
  7. 39:08... guy cared for New York by standing up and stepping into the void, or did this guy do the thing that is most dangerous in this political era we are living in, which is look at someone, fail to see them, and not render them as fully human?
Anand Giridharadas 0:00 ↗
They together reflect what I think has become a very widespread feeling in this country: we are abandoned. The cavalry isn't coming. The system isn't coming to save us. No one hears us. And sometimes people have to step up and do whatever they got to do. That feeling then fractures into a left version, a right version, or this version of that version, and we kind of lose the thread. But it's interesting information that actually so many Americans feel that feeling. And one of the tragedies of this time we've lived in is that that common feeling keeps getting broken into pieces and failing to produce a common politics.
Scott Galloway 0:41 ↗
We are joined with the inimitable Anand Giridharadas, journalist, bestselling author, and publisher of the newsletter The Inc. Anand's latest book, "Man in the Mirror: Hope, Struggle, and Belonging in an American City," comes out September 29th. Anand, thanks for joining us.
Anand Giridharadas 0:58 ↗
Thank you so much for having me. I'm glad you're on Substack.
Scott Galloway 1:01 ↗
Yeah, what a thrill. You're kind of the original or an original gangster here. And just to wax poetic a bit, Anand and I are fellow alumni of the hit...
Anand Giridharadas 1:15 ↗
Alumni is an interesting word for...
Scott Galloway 1:17 ↗
Alumni, yeah, as in it's over. We both had shows on CNN Plus. So, before we get into your book...
Anand Giridharadas 1:23 ↗
Wasn't it Vice?
Scott Galloway 1:25 ↗
Oh, were we both on Vice? I've had so many failed TV shows. You're right. It was Vice.
Anand Giridharadas 1:31 ↗
Oh, it was Vice. I don't know that alumni is the right word for trauma bonding.
Scott Galloway 1:36 ↗
Okay. But your show, to be honest, your show was boring but fine. My show was awful. Awful. I looked like an old man having an epileptic seizure. I don't know about you, but I had to film it from my garage. It was COVID.
Anand Giridharadas 1:53 ↗
Yeah.
Scott Galloway 1:53 ↗
And they put all these MTV-like graphics on it to make it feel younger. I watched it with my partner. This is a true story, and then I want to hear your experience. I watched the first episode with my partner. At the end of the show, she started crying and looked at me and said, "What does this mean for our family?" And I'm like, "Oh my god, I've made my partner..." My show was so bad.
Anand Giridharadas 2:22 ↗
Your show, it was also not great. I had AOC as my first guest, so that gave it a lift. I had you as a guest, which gave it a lift. But here...
Scott Galloway 2:32 ↗
You had Governor Newsom, right?
Anand Giridharadas 2:34 ↗
I did not have Governor Newsom, I don't think.
Scott Galloway 2:35 ↗
Oh, I thought you had Governor Newsom.
Anand Giridharadas 2:37 ↗
Here's what happened with my show. Probably the same with yours. It was kind of developed and set up like winter of 2019, turn of 2020, all set, contracts, ready to go. Let's start filming in March, February, March, whatever. And COVID strikes, and I've never had a TV show before. Spoiler alert: I've never had one since. And COVID hits, and I was like, well, I guess we're not doing a TV show. They're like, no, no, no. We can just make it in this new reality, whatever it may be. And so my daughter had a very severe lung condition. She was like two years old. So I had to go to this remote location because of her. And so then I didn't have proper internet, which was kind of important for making a TV show. So I was filming things on iPads and cameras, you know, and then I had to hire someone to pick up USB drives with the filmed video. Like it was like drug deals of data. And then they would come to my house and pick up the USB drive like from the driveway because we didn't want to have contact with each other, and then drive it up to their house and upload it on some faster Wi-Fi that they had. I mean, it was so surreal. So much energy to make something that wasn't good.
Scott Galloway 3:56 ↗
Oh god. Yeah. I was literally a TV show, me in my garage alone, and they had a producer in my ear saying, "Oh, do this or next episode this." My tech producer drew in the cloud because, you know, we couldn't have, we had social distance. So, it was me trying to make 30 minutes of TV in my garage with like lights and a camera, and it was so bad. And the guy, forget his name, the production executive, nice guy, called me after the six episodes. I'm like, I just got to get through this. Called me after the six episodes and like, I got great news. They want to renew it. And I'm like, no [__] way. I am so out of here. And I remember him, my agent called me, the production called me, he called me back three times. The guy running Vice at the time reached out to me, who I like, Shane Smith. And they were just so flummoxed that anyone would pass up an opportunity to be on TV. And the lesson for me was people must cling to TV like a dictator clings to power. That they were just, they could not believe I was going to pass up the opportunity to be on TV. So, you haven't done any TV since then?
Anand Giridharadas 5:10 ↗
No, not my own thing. I go talk about things I've written on MSNBC now.

20 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Galloway, S. (2026, October 8). Why Americans Cheer Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny — With Anand Giridharadas [Interview transcript]. The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway and Anand Giridharadas. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3012845/

MLA

Scott Galloway. "Why Americans Cheer Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny — With Anand Giridharadas." The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway and Anand Giridharadas, 8 Oct. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3012845/.

BibTeX
@misc{galloway2026_3012845,
  author       = {Scott Galloway},
  title        = {Why Americans Cheer Luigi Mangione and Daniel Penny — With Anand Giridharadas},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway and Anand Giridharadas. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3012845/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}