We are in for a spectacular hour together, being as my best friend and together with Chloe, daughter of my best friend, other best friend and my other best friend, we've been cycling in the hills around our home. We've been inventing chance in the Marmara. We've traveled around the world together, and we've had the privilege of working with entrepreneurs to build amazing companies. And you're going to hear a lot of those stories this evening.
This book has a really implausible title: Everybody Wins. So I'm going to push them very hard on whether that's possible. But before we get started, I've got two reminders. The first is that this program is being recorded. So I ask that you silence your head, your smartphones for the duration of the program. And then if you have any questions for Chloe or Bing, you can fill them out on the question cards that are on the chairs there. Also, if you're attending via YouTube, just put questions in the online chat. So let's go, John door.
Ladies and gentlemen, Chloe is a director, a writer, a documentarian who explores the intersections of technology, storytelling and culture. Her career spans multiple media forms. For example, she wrote Amazon's first scripted comedy series for Twitch. She also worked on 108 episodes of Saturday Night Live. How's that?
I mean, bad, a lot of late, lot of late nights survived, I survived.
Bing. Bing was also a survivor, co-founder, chief creative officer and longtime executive at Electronic Arts. That's where I met Bing. That's one of the largest gaming companies in the world. He later joined Kleiner Perkins. We worked together on many ventures. He advised and mentored dozens of gaming and health and social tech startups. So Chloe, writing a book with your dad sounds like it's every parent's dream. And maybe an endurance test for you. What made you do it?
This is a great question to ask me in front of my dad. You might get a defense is leaving. And what was the most fun our you spent with him writing this book? You know, I grew up under my dad's tutelage, which meant until I was in high school, no doing homework until I played my video games. And it meant that if I didn't go to school, I refused to go to school. I had to go sit in the office with him and play games all day and give creative notes to adults as a six year old. So I grew up in this world, but I've become really missionary about the social and societal good of video games. I find it, you know, my the way that my dad talks about games and how life enriching they are. I really believe in that. So when we were talking and my dad expresses interest always in writing books but doesn't have much discipline to do it. And I got really excited about possibly applying some of the discipline that I do have to help him elevate this message that I really have been a lifelong believer in. You know, and to scale being he's really he's been such a special mentor to me that it's kind of exciting to get to broaden his audience as much as I possibly can.
So the book was your idea?
You know, I think the book was his idea and that he said, I want to write a book. But, you know, a lot of times it's like when somebody says they have a really good movie idea and they say one sentence and you say, and then what happens? And they kind of go, I don't know.
Yeah. So he had the idea to write a book. And you know what came after? How long did it take? When did you start and what was the most fun? Our...
When did we start? I think we've I think it was sort of two years start to end. Yeah. With at least one early on. Full scrap. Start from the beginning. The most fun our... You know, before we started actually working on the book, we've been sort of figuring out how to tell the story of gaming and gaming, and we've tried a few different mediums. So the first one that we tried was developing a documentary about games that, you know, we'll see if it ever comes out one day. But for the documentary, I went to Tokyo with Bing to go to a Pokemon Go festival, which was 70,000 people in a park on their phones like this in total silence, walking around looking for Pokemon. And just witnessing my dad, who sort of, you know, talks about how incredible it is that games bring people together socially and what a what a net positive it is. And then to be in this park with 70,000 people looking down. And so then my dad just starts talking to people in real life. And I thought that was so funny. And I have a lot of photos of him talking to men who had spent the night in internet cafes so that they could get in early in full blown Pikachu costumes. It turned out a very popular there because you can't get a bison, you know, a buffalo Pokemon in Japan. There you can only get them in habitats in the US. And they looked at me and said, American, you've got the buffalo. And and so I had a line waiting to get all my buffaloes.
So Bing, I would say my my my favorite our...
It's all the minutes when when Chloe lights up talking about the project.
Yes, but it's a minute at a time. Now. Moments not. Wow.
Wow, wow. Minutes with Chloe Bing. Tell us about your family. Where are you? What? What your family means to you? What? Well, you know, it's, What is it in your life? Rank us and order a favorite of all the...
The most important person in my life is Deborah. She's here. It was here. And, And I met her right there. I met her when I was a Stafford. She shot up, and I fell in love right away, and it. I fell in love immediately in that hot tub, and and it took her a while. But, you know, I'd done my homework, and I said. I told her, you know, you're at least ten times better than anybody I've ever dated. And she's looking at me like, you know, maybe. And and in fact, when we met her sister, she rated me number three. But I gave him with her because a couple years later, she married my lookalike brother. So I'm going to have so, so, you know, that Harvard 50 year longitudinal study that was done. It says the secret to people in their silver years being satisfied with life is it's long term relationships, you know, and nothing more long term and relationship than a spouse, but best friends and some kind of feeling of satisfaction for achievement. No, no chronic disease and no substance abuse. So I got I got one of those four things nailed. Debra and I just had anniversary 46. So.
And by the way, so you and Ann have been that long as well.
And then, the only time I walked on air in my life was coming out of the operating room with, you know, one minute old Chloe in my arms carrying her to the nursery. And my life was forever changed for any of you. First time you have kids, nobody can describe what it's like. But I noticed I started crying in movies after holding Chloe in my arms. And literally I felt like I was moving through the hospital eight feet in the air. I was like, you know, I had Elon Musk shoes on, and then. And then daughter, daughter Allegra, who is now, I think, maybe Chloe's best friend, which is wildly interesting. You know, so got the, when when all three of the girls I grew up in household of boys, I was not prepared to grow up in a household of women and female dogs. But when. When they're all under the household, onto the roof, it just feels better.
So, Bing, play or games haven't just been your profession. They've been your family life. Tell us about the games you played before with the family before it became a profession.
Wow. Well, you know, there is kind of the game of life. And Deb and I talked about, you know, games are about, incentives and rewards and constraints. And once you have kids, that is kind of the game of parenting. And, you know, we talked a lot about the constraints and the goals. And the goals was for me. I was deathly afraid of daughters losing their tomboy selves at age 13. And then we wanted, resilience and a sense of achievement. And then Deb and I really concentrated on education as being extraordinarily important. So education with agency. And then I know that Anne did this to you as well, that Deborah at one point started counting my nights home for dinner. And so where did that come? You know, I think in general I tell adult daughters and tell women in general, you know, at the you if you've, you've got to find an okay man and then train them into great and, and so if you don't also tell the daughters that you're more mature than boys now that you're in kindergarten, don't where they're going to catch up when they're 80. So anyway, so family, you know, John, you've been a proponent of Family First for a long time. And, you know, a lot of people espouse values and don't live them. And, you do you play a game now with the family. What's your top game?
Well, my favorite my favorite games are always when when playing with families. So Chloe and I used to play some mobile games together, but now I mostly play New York Times games and Duolingo. And then I play World of Warcraft and Diablo and then games I'm working on. So, Chloe, you know, Chloe's more in the invest in Express story games these days.
The Duolingo streak for a while. Yeah, I'm still my Duolingo is like 2400. You know, I spend too much time out of cell service. It's bad for me.
Oh, yeah? Yeah. You can't. You can't climb out, Whitney. And, you know, and and play a I play a mobile game. You can try it.
When did games become a profession, a business?
Well, you know the talking to Brother Andy about it at the time, I said, you know, I don't think I was a big gamer as a kid. I played a lot of card games and we made up sports games all the time. If the brother was two years younger than me, we made up all kinds of wiffle ball games, home run derby games. We decimated our moms living room furniture, trying to play football and hockey well, playing football and hockey in the house and trying to get away with that. Never get away with it. Hoping those dents wouldn't be noticed. And so we were always making up stuff. And then I also also read a lot. So for me, games, I've told this story, but I worked at Disneyland when I was in high school, and I had this fantasy of finding the Abraham Lincoln audio animatronic on Main Street. And when the park was closed, me and Abe would hang. And then I'd like to hang with some of these other I'd like to hang with Tom Sawyer on Tom Sawyer Island. And and then a movie came out called Westworld with Yule Brenner kind of the first time around. And I thought, that's what I want to do. I want to I want to travel through time and space with interesting characters. And then home computers came along. And so that was my my transition really was from puzzles and card games and sports and books to Disneyland and a little bit of acting. And then technology came along.
So Chloe and Bing, I want to challenge the title of this book. How many of us are game players? Show of hands, please. And how many of us think about games in terms of winners and losers? Losers? You see, everybody wins. Yep. I don't believe it. Tell tell me, tell me the Pogo story.
Well, I will tell you the story. So, you know, I've been doing a sports stuff for a while. This game started out as primarily nerd solo, playing a little like, you know, doing a New York Times crossword puzzle. With screen time on TV. And in the mid 80s, a company called Nintendo came out and games started going from nerd single player to head to head. And we saw in focus groups in 1987 that suddenly half the focus groups were the most popular kids in middle school instead of the outcasts, because to be a to be a Nintendo star started verging toward being the homecoming queen or the football quarterback almost overnight. It was wildly interesting. And then in the the era of LAN and then web game became community games. Friend here named Alex Gardner, who kind of figured that out and rode that wave as well. But the community games, you know, suddenly you'd play with first four at a time and then 16 at a time and then 64 at a time. And now now thousands at a time. So in that in the beginning of the community era, EA had a, a web game called Pogo, which was a bunch of little casual games about like what the New York Times games are right now. And we would do 8 to 10 minute games, like a bingo game or like a slot machine game where everybody in the room would compete to see who won the room. And, and I invented a game for that. That was the first ever court mechanic where whoever won that game, whoever one each round, could give a gift to whoever was in last place. And we put together something where people had to collaborate in real time to beat, to beat the system. But I'm playing one of these games. And it was, you know, one of the things where 12 people at the end of about eight minutes, there's one at the top and we're playing along on there's chatting, everybody's got screen names, and suddenly somebody shows up as like, you know, Big bad Earl or some name like that and comes in and comes first and, and then in the chat. It's a beat, y'all. I'm awesome. I crushed you, you know, take it kind of anybody's ever been online with 14 year olds and you know it's four letters. You know f bomb versus f bomb versus, you know, scatological insults. And there was no comment in the room. They don't you don't get it. I beat you, I beat you. And then one comment showed up. It was your time to win it. We're so happy for you. And I was like, no, you don't understand. I kick your And I was like, you remind me a lot of my 14 year old son. You know, congratulations. It's everybody should win from time to time. That was the last we heard of them. And and I thought, you know, this is very different now, Pogo at the, you know, in the early 2000. The club Pogo was 72% female, average age 46. So it was kind of a laboratory for me. And it was actually a precursor to Facebook games and mobile games, where we went from 85% boys of all ages to kind of 5050. But it was it was, you know, there's a different way, to spend time together around games and this notion that everybody can win together, that we actually actually build something where the first thing is if everybody's chatting and sharing their winning on social while somebody is winning the game and John, John and Annabel fans go, you know, the way the WNBA works, there's only going to be one champion. All the press about who beat who. But in fact, every woman in that league is winning. Every woman. That league is taking home more money than female athletes used to do. Thanks to thanks to the women's soccer team, thanks to women's tennis. So they're competing and they're winning at the same time. And anybody's ever competed in something good. You know you love a great competitor. It's a more myself. You pushed me. Thank you so much. And it's you know you could even see in the 40 Niners game, Luke McCaffrey and Christian McCaffrey brothers who just competed on the field are changing jerseys and hugging. So you know there's a lot there's a lot of comradery that can be that's a winning around competition. And I once was talking about this with a guy who is trying to do a virtual Las Vegas game. And he had been he had been a a loyalty program developer for a casino. And I'm going, you know, we're doing this, we do this. And and he said, oh, you have a second currency. I go, well, I got here. Second currency. Everybody knows second currency in Vegas. We got two currencies. We got money and we got VIP points. You may not win the money. You can forgive yourself. You're going to win the VIP points. And that's what I realize is. And the psychologists will prove that that losing has a lot more emotion than winning. I've been in with those Club Pogo people or one said, you know, I feel like a loser in real life. I don't want to feel like a loser in my entertainment. So you build this. Come. Everybody's getting something out of it. You can build a second currency and a lot of a lot of stories about that, about how you might lose. You might come 99th out of 100 and Fortnite, but you still get some career points. So does everybody wins. I'm kind of a missionary about living a life, so everybody around you can do a little better. You know, Adrian out there knows as well that, you know, if you if you build a community, everybody can uplift, uplift one another. What's your take on that?
I just going to say first, John was saying backstage that he'd be really good at keeping things answers short and not that that was going up the trajectory of games. I think in the 80s and the 90s, a lot of games were more win loss and the audience was more selective. You know, head to head competition games really appeal to hyper competitive people. And we all know a couple hyper competitive people, and that's not most of us. So, as you know, ye was very much a part of this. But as games figured out how to make everybody walk away feeling like they got something more out of it, whether or not they were on the top of the scoreboard, or just gaining career points, or up leveling their own skill level or making friends. As game design evolved to make more players feel like they were walking away, accomplished games became more popular. So yeah, I think my we cite Fortnite now, which has 100 people drop in. There's one person at the end, 99 in quotes, losers. But every single player has uploaded their career score and becomes a better player in the next game because of it. So even with 99 in quotes losers, everybody's walking away feeling like they won something out of the game. And it's a magic trick that you can do in games that you can kind of like adjust the economies easily in games so that everybody on average is a winner.
Do you do you believe in today's world, today's America as lived by you? Everybody wins.
I absolutely believe in the aspirational vision of it. I think that like, for me, one of the amazing things about games is that they are. Successful economically, and they're also a world where all of the participants feel better off for having participated in it. And so for me, I'm like the fact that those that model does succeed financially to me, is proof that there's a better way to run our our economies and our capitalism than what we're doing right now. So there's there is a way for more people to feel like they're succeeding in the world while still having great financial boon. And and it's proven in video games. Do I think that do I think that we're succeeding on doing that in every area of life? I don't, but I think that it's it's a model that Video Games is proving out that we should aspire to.
So would you say that video games can improve governance and democracy?
I, I absolutely yes, I'm constantly, constantly pointing my most cynical peers towards the world of video games to see models of society where most people are better off instead of, you know, so many people feeling disenfranchized you get better community, you get better internal fulfillment and games than you tend to in the real world.
You know, some of those is a mental model. So I'd start out with, hey, everybody here. A thousand years from now, none of us are going to be here right now. We're all winning. You know, we could have been, you know, amino acids in a swamp. And, you know, you know, that would be we could have been we could have been gerbils. So we're all lucky to be here. You know, it's all random that we're here. There was a moment in time where, you know, there was one thing swimming toward another thing, and it might not have become you. And so, you know, there's this mentality of winning it, you know, let's let's appreciate how lucky we are to be here and let's pass it along.
Being we we were on a bike ride in Woodside a few years ago that I considered to be a very lucky ride. What's your memory of that?
Well, the, I knew of John. And when John and Brooke invested in Electronic Arts in 1982, and then Deborah became a recruiter for John, over time, you know, we got closer and closer. And John turns out to be a great aerobic athlete. I could I could tackle him, but I can't really run as fast as he can run, but I can keep up with the biking. So we're out on a bike ride. And John said, well, Bing, you went to the Kleiner Perkins CEO summit. How was it? And I said, John, it was so such a relief. I wasn't on stage this year. I just got to sit in the audience, enjoy it. But it reminds me one thing kind of bugs me. Jeff Bezos, interviewed by Charlie Rosen, said something that's just been haunting me a little bit. He said, we're the world's most customer obsessed, customer centric company, and that's Amazon. Jeff Bezos of Amazon. And I said, you know, I, I've worked with toys R us, and I worked with Walmart and I've worked with what's now GameStop. Every retailer has his ego. They can walk in the store, look at a customer and go, here's what this person's going to buy. And that person there in a hurry to get out of here, watch. When they come up to the cash register, they're not going to pay attention. That person is going to be really polite and ask the cash register, the register what their name is. That person is pissed off and going to walk over there. And Bezos didn't tell a single customer story. And John goes, John asked, good question. John says, well, what should they do? And I went, John. I hadn't really thought about it at the time. I'm, you know, puffing to try to keep up with him. He's talking about shoulders. What should they do with John? I haven't thought about it. I don't know, how about a customer loyalty program? If they did a customer loyalty program, the person in charge would be held responsible for understanding customers. And you could then, you know, instrument metric. And he goes, well, what would you call it? And I go, John, John, I own the Amazon Black. How about that? And I always admired American Express. No, that's that's kind of copycat. When an Amazon box shows up at our front door, it feels like a holiday. And Amazon is proof that I'm better than my parents. So Amazon deserves better than that. How about Amazon Prime? John? Nobody's ever used Prime before. And you know, I'm thinking, okay, now maybe he'll shut up when I get peddle. And he goes, well what would you offer in it? And I go, John. I say, well, I guess you know, it's missionary. I think a monthly letter from from the CEO about the mission. I do the super saver shipping. I do it kind of in one day and said it two. And I'd add a concierge at holiday time because my wife as a concierge Deborah at four Schwartz. And it's the only way we can get the popular toys and and then I think now I'm done. And he goes, if I, if I give you a ticket to Seattle, will you go visit Jeff? I said, no, I said, I got to go to Seattle every quarter. We got to see you up there. I'm not taking any charity, but I'm up there if you want me. So next thing that happened, I met EA Seattle and I know I'm going to meet Jeff Bezos, been on the man of the year and all that stuff. This is after Amazon toast that I'm going to see him for lunch and I'm going, oh, I am going to be such a dork. I'm going to go and say, hi, Jeff. I've seen a cover of magazine. John thought we ought to meet whatever. And I well, I know, and so I sat down and I said, I got to give him some ideas. I did one Amazon Prime and then some other ideas and, print it out on a piece of paper just in time. Headed over to. He showed up a little late with his booming laugh and our half hour lunch turning a couple hours, and at the end he said, you know, a lot of people have called on me kind of notice. Ever done it before on a piece of paper? And we all learned later that he cares a lot about writing. And I had kind of accidentally done it. And the next week I had called up and said, Jeff really was impressed with you. Would you like to talk to me about joining the board? And in the first board meeting, I said to everybody else, thanks for having me here. Amazon needs a loyalty program. And the people on the board, you know, John included. Well, that's a dumb idea. We're already losing 500 million a year on Super Saber shipping. Why would we do something else? And loyalty programs never work. We all have loyalty programs that don't work except for the airlines. And I went, I said, I'm pretty sure I'm writing. You're wrong. So I went, I went home, and I sent a an email to 20 friends in the game business who were tech forward and said, next year you're going to buy more or less e-commerce. More or less Amazon and 18 out of 20 said more e-commerce and two said more on Amazon and about ten said less on Amazon. I went to the next board meeting and said, this may or may not be true. Jeff has said when the data and the anecdotes don't agree, trust the anecdotes. Here's an anecdote. Somebody should take this seriously and everyone in the board has gone okay, you're not when we talk about games will call on you. But that's a that's a dumb idea. Now, luckily for me, there was a G genius guy named Jeff Wilkie who was the guy, but he was also a low weight football player from Pittsburgh. He was a blue collar guy. He was a weightlifter, and he took this as kind of a challenge. And we walked out and he kind of looked at me and, you know, and it was two years later he came in and said, I figured it out. I figured out how we can make this work. We moved all the, the, the, the Amazon Prime one day stuff close to the loading dock, and I got USPS and I got ups to cut down their their delivery charges for those. So I think we can try it. And the ball goes, this is a stupid idea. What is the research say? The research said that the only people who would be $89 a year to get better shipping already bought twice a month. There aren't very many of those. The average Amazon customer at the time bought about 1.7 times a year. And so Amazon was going to the research, said everybody who didn't already by 25 times was not going to do it. And so we were going to lose another 500 million on on those people. And Bezos, another genius, goes, this is a two way door. If we try it and it doesn't work, we can revert. It won't take long. We don't lose very much. By the way, if you ever heard of a one way door and a two way door, a marriage is a two way door. But not for me. Kids or kids are a one way door. You know, the average marriage in the US reverts in seven years. You know you have kids, you got them for 110 years. You can't get out of that kid thing. So. And and so the rest is Amazon history. It was Bezos. Oh. And then the next board meeting comes in and says, I have a good surprise. Everybody is subscribed to Amazon Prime is now buying twice a month. Whether they told us in research they wouldn't anybody who does marketing. So Ron Young here just knows when you ask customers what they're going to do, they always lie about price and they always get it wrong. And so you can't trust what they say. You got to trust what they do. And so Bezos two way door Bezos always double down on good surprises. And Jeff Wilkie saying I don't know if it's right or not, but I think I'm man enough to give it a shot.
And you spent you know, you spent decades with both of them there. They and you are amazing. Now, what was the effect of going to two purchases a month?
Well, it took the average Amazon customer over time went from spending about $150 a year to $5,000 a year. But better yet, they saved, you know, kind of an hour per shopping trip. And, you know, at 5000 a year, that's about 50 shopping trips here. So it's $100 or 100 hours worth of time and all the gas and carbon because of it. And, and Amazon over time took this and turned it into savings. So I figured the, the 200 plus million Amazon customers on their 5000 could save as much as $1,000 in travel and purchase price. So for consumers in a 200 million times $1,000 a year for 20 years is I'm going to do some rice math here.
That's, there's plenty of rice math. You know, the one about. I'll take double as many rice kernels on a chessboard. And that's all I want from the king.
No, I did by about by about two thirds the way through the chessboard, they realized he was going to get more rice than the kingdom. And a few later, because of the power of doubling, he was going to have more rice than it ever been grown on Earth.
The question was about Amazon.
You said rice. I was going to do some rice.
Math price 2 billion of benefit over 20 years is 4 trillion. I think that sounds right.
Is that right? Coin $4 trillion bike ride. Chloe, one idea in this book is that game design works best when it helps people do something they already want to do. What's an example outside gaming of using game design for the good?
Yeah, I think like the superpower of games, right, is that they're super engaging and super motivating, and we want to come back to them all the time. So think about like, what other parts of life do I want to come back to all the time? I think a lot about the first, you know, seven years of my career as an adult were spent at Saturday Night Live, which operates, you know, with where everybody that goes through there is so loyal and so motivated to be there every day. And they get paid pennies. So clearly they're not there for the financial incentive. And it works sort of the same way that a video game does, which is that, you know, in a game, the most motivating reason for a gamer to come back tomorrow is social connection. And then the second most is the personal mastery and the self betterment and the flow state you get into. And then the third most important is the productivity. So I think a lot about my time at SNL that the first thing they do is they take 150 young people and stick them in a small building together for 100 hours a week. So you build incredible relationships, and then every single young person there is sort of set free to produce their own ideas and get them on television. And how cool is that, that you're becoming, in real time, a person who's getting better at your craft and learning a lot. And it was so motivating. I mean, we were all excited to go to work every single day, even as we were exhausted. And I've seen that work in that place so well that now when I'm, you know, in my own life, I'm always trying to replicate what works at SNL and what works in games in, you know, I am most of my work is freelance writing, which has no external structure. So I have to try to channel what happens in a game and build internal structure. So I think a lot about, you know, how can I. How can I do the career points for at night model on my career as a writer and stop measuring my output in terms of earnings and start measuring in terms of hours of experience I put in. Right. And then that makes me really excited to put in a lot of work for.