Jeff Bezos got interviewed by Charlie Rose and he said we want to be the world's most customer-centric company, and I like that, but then in the next 20 minutes of the interview he never mentioned a single customer story. I'm on a bike ride with Doerr and Doerr goes, "What would you do about it?" And I go, "I don't know. How about a loyalty program? What would you call it?" It was something new. How about Prime? He goes, "If I give you my plane, will you fly up to Seattle to meet Jeff?"
What happens almost immediately?
A couple days later the board unanimously voted no and Bezos said, [laughter]
It is my absolute pleasure to bring legend and Cameo board member Bing Gordon today to talk about his new book. Bing is a part of the founding team at Electronic Arts, an investor at Kleiner Perkins, working and mentoring some of the top CEOs. Many of the best frameworks that I've ever gotten you taught me early on was forever OKRs.
Goal setting is provably an amplifier. If you hit two out of three you're doing great. If you hit three out of three you probably weren't thinking big enough. Set bigger ambition. People start thinking of OKRs as 100% is what's good, and 100% often means you didn't try hard enough.
I want everybody listening to get a sense for the way that Bing's mind works. So much of the insights that you have gleaned over the years is the result of asking insanely great questions. What's your framework?
Anytime a question can unpack assumptions is really valuable. The first thing about a great question is...
Welcome everyone to another exciting edition of the Zeitgeist podcast. I'm your host Steven Galanis, co-founder and CEO of Cameo. And today I have a very special guest, Bing Gordon. So before we get into it, let me give you a quick bio on Bing. William Bing Gordon is a co-founder and long-time chief creative officer of Electronic Arts, a partner and former chief product officer at the legendary venture firm Kleiner Perkins, and now newly an author with his daughter Chloe Gordon of Everybody Wins, which launches on October 27th. And for an English major, there is nothing better than writing a book. Bing, welcome to the show.
At the foundation of your book is this gamification checklist that you've got. Let's walk through the gamification checklist right now.
Yeah, well, the idea is almost every problem can be addressed by trying one or more of the gamification checklist. So, there's a concept of everybody wins and why that works and how to do it. There's a concept of win first, win fast, why it works and how to do it. There's a concept of social is everything. There's proof of it. There's how we discovered it, how to apply it. There's quantify everything. There's proof of it, where it came from, how to apply it. There's retention hacking, proof of it, how to apply it. And I'd like to show all these kind of what where I learned this in games, where I learned about it in real life, where we apply it kind of in all fields. So, most people think about game design as specific to games and writing as specific to books. And you know, in fact, game design, because it's so closely aligned with human motivation, works in fitness, works in medical, works in education, works in family management, works in relationships, works in commerce, works in relationships. It kind of proven in my... it works everywhere so long as the motivation that you elicit with gamification aligns with people's real needs and wants.
So, the everybody wins checklist to help everybody win across all fields. Can't wait to jump into it. All right, so Bing, we've got the gamification checklist. So, we know what people need to get right to win, but what on the list do people get wrong the most? And which of the steps do you think gets ignored by founders and designers that shouldn't be?
I'd say there, you know, a couple of key things. One is this concept of everybody wins. Most smart people who don't game, and who maybe don't pay attention to their own family, think that competition is all. And in fact, we can prove that competition is a real plus for some, but a turn off for many. As I was even thinking, I went to a WNBA game this week with the Golden State Valkyries, and sports is interesting because on the one hand, all the press talks about is win-lose competition. So, the press says it's a winner-take-all, but in fact, it isn't. It's if you have dramatic games and more people watch, guess what happens? In the WNBA, every player makes more money, every player gets bigger fans, every player gets more famous. So, you actually have, while you're doing this single-elimination competition, all the women in it are uplifting all the other women in it. And by the way, in World Cup women's soccer, when the US women's team won, guess what happens? It makes possible doing a professional women's ice hockey league. So, the thing that people don't see is the drama of the competition gets people to read and pay attention, but in fact, the paying attention can cause everybody to win.
And the rising tide lifts all boats.
The rising tide lifts all boats. And not always equally, but you know, the entry-level salary keeps going up. And the more you get TV viewership based on popularity, and the TV viewership directly correlates with the income per person. So, it's one of the things the NFL has shown that as the NFL popularity goes up, as the Super Bowl gets more entertaining, as the games get closer, as the NFL tries to have every franchise have a chance to make the playoffs, guess what happened? Viewership got up and salaries go up. Same thing with the NBA. I mean, when we started working with the NBA with Dr. J and Larry Bird in the early days of David Stern, no athletes besides maybe David Beckham were influencers. And you know, Magic Johnson, you know, who's Hall of Fame, and you know, cuz he was once on your board, the Magic Johnson ended up not making a whole lot of sponsorship money. You know, that waited for Michael Jordan. So, the athletes who become influencers, and many many of the most popular athletes make more money off the field than on the field, but it's on the field drama that gets the viewership. So, everybody wins certainly works in sports across the board, where what looks like the winner takes all is just an illusion. And we kind of see it now happening in tech, in the world of AI. It kind of looks like there's an everybody wins this cutthroat competition between the various frontier models. But in fact, they all get more valuable the more people use AI more often. And by the way, they could all lose together if the [snorts] consumer snark is such that AI is bad for everyone. So they've got this frenemy relationship where you can compete, but you also have to support.
So sports have been a very important part of your life and my life. In fact, we bonded when we first met for the first time in a cave at Calistoga Ranch drinking bourbon with Al Gore of all people and Ilya from Kleiner. And we immediately bonded over the fact that we were both hockey goalies, you from Detroit, me from Chicago. One of the frameworks that I've always loved is you once gave me a framework for what the makeup of a winning, like a Stanley Cup winning hockey team is and how that can apply to business. Talk through that. That's one of my all-time favorite Bing frameworks.
I got this from a long-lasting undrafted hockey player named Jeff Courtnall who I got to know through Don Mattrick. And Courtnall said, "Look, here's the secret of making it to the Stanley Cup finals. There's three ages of hockey players. There's the vets, they're kind of over age 31. There's the mid-career, they're kind of 25 to 30. And then there's the youth, the rookies, maybe second year. They're kind of sometimes as young as 19, but basically 22 to 24. They're untested. And so what you need when you get in the finals to succeed is you need the old guys to basically let everybody else know there's limited chances to be here. And you can see in the old guys how much they care. And the mid-career guys, you need them to deliver their mid-career result. But in the playoffs, you can often neutralize a couple of stars. So you need all the mid-career guys to bring it. And then everybody depends on the youngsters who are willing to, you know, run through the boards, run through brick walls to bring this go-for-it energy that inspires everybody. It goes, 'I remember when I was like that. This is so cool.' The young guys have no perspective. They think they're going to be here a lot, but they run through walls and nothing fazes them. So, the old guys aren't nervous, but they care. The mid-career guys have a sense of responsibility. The young guys bring this electricity. And so, when it all works, you kiss the cup."
And I'll never forget the first time you told me that. You also have this analogy of the blue burning flame. So, the old guys have this blue burning flame because maybe when they were the 19-20-year-olds, they lifted the cup one time and they wanted to taste the glory. Or they're all the way at the end of their career and you know, it's like the Ray Bourque and you know, they have a Hall of Fame career, but everybody wants to win one for the Gipper on that. And that's a framework I've always loved.
And when they win, guess what? The captain hands it to the old veteran first. The one for whom they know they've got the most meaning in winning. Could be somebody who just lost a family member, somebody who's never been there before, somebody who's an inspiration. And you know, there is that kind of respect for people who've been there, done that. And that respect actually gives them the ability to create even more leadership in the locker room.
As a field, gaming has moved from something that was considered play, ephemeral, maybe like a waste of time, to something now many people look at as like a core training ground for their mind or for, you know, strategy. Talk about, you know, the evolution of gaming moving from kind of the periphery to the mainstream.
We saw the change happen in the second year of the Nintendo NES, which would have been 1988 in the states. And up until then, when we had focus groups of players, they were loners, they were nerds. Games were mostly solo. And you know, these are people they were kind of like going to the hobby shops and you know, they loved having power of the computers, maybe they learned to program. In 1988, for the first time we had focus groups, we had kids show up who were class presidents of their middle school. And so, being a great video gamer ended up having its own respect, kind of like being a sports team captain. And so, that was the beginning and at the time Nintendo games became head-to-head games. So, at that point, if you were great at games, you usually did it with somebody else in your living room on your couch. And then in the '90s, games became multiplayer, you know, with four at a time and sometimes even more. And at that point, you know, games became online and building whole communities. So, the two-player aspect went all the way up through EA Sports, every fraternity in America had Friday night Madden games. And it [clears throat] became a new kind of bonding. And then, when you got to, you know, four to 16 players, and then eventually to 100 at a time, that was community building. So, most civilians look at kids or gamers at screen time and they think the kids are feeling lonely. And in fact, you know, that's their projection of lonesomeness, but you want to ask the kids doing that because they're playing with other people in a community or head-to-head and building bonds report higher levels of social satisfaction than those who don't. So, what non-players miss is the social cohesion and social capital that can be created online. And the digital generation feels this kind of tangible sense of presence through digital worlds and digital connections, not unlike the way when I was a kid, people felt with being on the phone forever.
I remember, this reminds me so much of a talk I saw the head of Turner Sports give right when they had bought what would become ELeague. And he's a hockey player like us and I remember him telling this anecdote where he's like, you know, there's a family function and all the kids had to be down at dinner at a certain time and everybody's there, all the cousins are there, the aunts and uncles and he goes, my one son just, you know, doesn't come out of the room. We can't find him. Everybody's at the table. Where is he? My wife's giving me the look. So, he goes, I walk upstairs and in my kid's bedroom's locked and the lights are off. So, you know, I started knocking. I don't hear anything. I then pick the lock. I open the door. It's dark and all I see is he's staring at, you know, a screen. And I thought he was doing something else, but then when I turned around, I was even more mad because it turned out he was watching somebody play video games, not even playing himself. And he goes to his dad and he goes, 'And I'm just ballistic. Your mother told you you had to be here at a certain time. I needed you to go and, you know, be with your cousins. Like, how disrespectful.' And he's like, 'And it'd be one thing if you were playing the game yourself, but you're watching people play games.' And he goes, 'Dad, you do the exact same thing.' And he's like, 'What are you talking about?' He goes, 'You love hockey. How many times have the Rangers been on TV and mom's like, "Dinner's ready" and you're like, "Oh, you know, there's 4 minutes left in the second period. Like, I'll be in in a second."' He goes, 'You watch them because you played hockey and they're the best in the world at what you used to do, what you love to do. This is the exact same thing. I love playing this game and these are the best in the world at doing what I need to do.' And I remember him saying like that hit him like [clears throat] a ton of bricks. He called his chief of staff immediately, said, 'We need to spend the weekend learning everything about esports.' And I think a week later they ended up making the purchase that became... Wow... that became that. So, you know, again, it's this idea of like what is play is kind of the new age media.
There's another aspect to it that emerged, say with Twitch for example, is people watching others play, they end up building community. So, it turns out that the popular streamers on Twitch have communities that talk to each other. So, what Twitch found over time is that people who become loyal followers and they become subscribers and become tip givers, it all starts with successful chat. So, it's astonishing to watch the liveliness of the community chat around any streamer. So, the streamers on screen doing stuff, they're kind of like the broadcaster, but in fact, they're the community enabler. So, imagine a rock and roll act that at the end of the live show, people came away with five new friends. And they'd wish to do that, you know, it doesn't work. Basically, you end up maybe dancing with somebody next to you, but you don't end up introducing yourself to somebody and bumping and making new friendships that way in a live experience. Online takes away a lot of that friction. So, it is one of the secrets that people don't talk about is this community membership. People on Twitch even kind of have handles like the old CB radio, but instead of talking to one other person, you know, you're talking to 100 people at once.
How to product [clears throat] manager career. Let's talk about that and let's talk about the journey that you've been on that led to the wisdom that is helping you write this book.
Well, a couple of different ideas. The product manager career, before consumers were server connected, you learned about consumers mostly through focus groups and anecdotes. And so, back in the day at EA, the marketing job was product marketing. We would try to create models to get in the heads of individual users and use it at scale. And then, starting in about '08, we could actually instrument users and see what's going on. So, I credit Mark Pincus for inventing product management for games as a service. And that comes down to weekly tests and a lot of metrics. So, based on that, I found that the product managers at Zynga ended up being the thought leaders and the strategy leaders. And starting in the kind of in the '90s, where I started an intern program in Electronic Arts, I started paying attention to kids' career progress. And I've always been a fan of helping kids like 18 to 30 improve, get ahead faster. So, once we had this model of instrumented product management, I realized that I could turn that to careers. There was a guy named DJ Patil who became really famous in government, but who was the chief data officer at LinkedIn. He tried to predict, looking at someone's LinkedIn, what steps they would have to take to get to the job title they wanted. Spent a year doing it, couldn't do it, because the data in LinkedIn wasn't crisp enough. But there are some clear things that happened. So, a key aspect of product management is benchmarking, figuring out the gap between where you are and where you want to be, and then start testing things to get there. So, the first thing about product managing your career is figuring out not your gap in title, but your gap in capabilities and experiences. So, you can actually look at a LinkedIn equivalent of somebody who has what you want to be doing and see what it looks like they've done to get from here to there. And it's usually experiences. And product management, I tried to break down what is a product manager and found there's three models of product management. At Zynga, product managers get promoted for predicting. At Facebook, product managers got promoted for success. And at Google, product managers got promoted for being on time and on budget and liked by engineers. There are three very different fitness functions: predict, succeed, or get loved by engineers. And so, the first thing about product managing your career is figuring out what's a fitness function. The next thing is nobody does it. Everybody should ask their supervisor and their supervisor's supervisor, what's the best person you've ever seen in this job? Tell me, you know, give me names. What did they do? And you're going to be horrified to find that almost no managers have an answer for you. They can kind of think of who it was and then what did they do? They go, I don't know. At one point at Electronic Arts, I looked at every kid who was in a position of importance before they turned 30 and I talked to every one of their managers beforehand and said, how come you promoted them? And the answer always was they couldn't remember. And then when they dug in, you know, I kind of asked them and they go, oh now I think of it and it turned out it was three things. It's they always got the core job done. They always had an idea that pushed everybody else. And they ask good questions. So, the first thing in product managing your career, if you want to get noticed by superior officers, when every meeting you're in, ask a great question. And it turns out great board members ask great questions. Bad board members tell founders, you should do this. Great board members ask a question that makes you think. So, you know, if you want to get promoted, get your core job done, but ask great questions and always be pushing for something. All right, that's... if you wanted a one-sentence answer, you didn't get one.
It's all about the sound bites here. Then that's great. Another one of the frameworks that I've always loved that you rolled out to me was called forever OKRs. And this goes back to this benchmarking idea. So, you know, even in this audience right now, we have people in all different functions. We have sales leaders, we have heads of marketing, we have CEOs. Walk through the idea of forever OKRs, and maybe let's even start backtrack a little bit. Your very good friend John Doerr literally wrote the book Measure What Matters, which is the Bible on this framework. So, let's talk about what OKRs are, and then let's talk about how you've used, you know, this benchmarking framework to help people understand like, you know, how their performance actually is on an absolute basis.
I go all the way back with Doerr. My wife was actually his recruiter in the '80s for all of his companies. But when I was at Stanford Business School, I worked half-time at Intel, where John Doerr was the mythical prodigy. And he was this Harvard Business School kid who showed up and everybody talked about him who's never in the office, and he was always beating sales quota. And at the time at Intel, the OKRs of the quarter were printed out kind of in front of at least every urinal. I don't know if they're in the ladies' rooms, but in every urinal, there was one there. So, you know, that was institutionalized sharing with OKRs. But the reason Intel started objectives and key results was twofold. First is it's proven again and again that people who set that falsifiable, time-based goals perform 10 or 15% better. They do it better in fitness, they do it better in school, they do it better in work. So, goal setting is provably an amplifier. At Intel, when [clears throat] when they started out with Grove and the like, they realized that they'd gotten in the mental habit of minimizing mistakes. So, if you ever paid attention to the chip business, the chip prices come down over time because they improve yield. So, [clears throat] chips start out with a circular semiconductor silicon wafer and then with photolithography they lay small wires down and the first chip, like the first Pentium, only like five out of a hundred of the chips that get created actually works. They throw away 95%. So, Intel was all about everybody at Intel was minimize mistakes. And so, when OKRs were invented, the breakthrough was if you hit two out of three you're doing great. If you hit three out of three you probably weren't thinking big enough, so think bigger. So, the OKRs at Intel, it was goals plus forgivable ambition and set bigger ambition. So, I think that idea of set bigger ambition has been a little bit lost along the way where people started to think of OKRs as 100% is what's good and 100% often means you didn't try hard enough. And so, Doerr in the book talks about the Google toolbar where they set a goal of a hundred million and missed it by a lot, but he said because we set such a big hairy audacious goal, we achieved double what we would have otherwise with a normal achievable goal. So, there's always a thought of are you thinking big enough? Jeff Bezos says people who write a lot, they combine this aspirational sense of what can be and this skeptical sense of what could go wrong. So, it's very difficult to do both at the same time. So, anyway, so that was the original OKRs. What I found is, so I'm a believer in OKRs. When we founded Electronic Arts, I was the person who set the goals and kind of got laughed at by the alumni that came out of Apple. They said, 'Oh my gosh, we just want to be culturally relevant and everything will take care of itself.' I was going, 'Oh no, oh no, oh no.' And of course, it turned out that that didn't work. So, I was always the set goals person and write them down. What I found over time is companies that adopted OKRs, employees were unhappy. The NPS net promoter score, kind of customer satisfaction math of OKRs in companies was almost as low as the NPS of banks and insurance companies. And the reason is most employees hate annual reviews. Why? You know, there's not much sense of victory, you don't learn much from it, and sometimes you get rated in a way that you don't quite believe anyway. And the biggest problem with setting OKRs is people set the goals too narrowly and make it task-based. Good employees hate their responsibility to be all tasks as opposed to bigger responsibilities. So, if you're an engineer, for example, you could say, [snorts] 'I've finished this code by such and such a time.' But along the way, you might decide, 'I can do this instead of doing that and I could create even more value.' So, you want to set the OKRs about value creation. And so, the time-based effect of OKRs often gets it wrong. And then the feedback from your boss is often not good enough. So, I came up with a concept of what I call forever OKRs, which is let's start with an OKR that's not time-based. So, what's a good life as an OKR? Most people don't think about that. It turns out a Harvard study of a 50-year study turned out that people who in their dotage, in their silver years, think they have a life, it turns out they don't have chronic disease, they don't have a substance abuse, and they have a couple long-lasting durable social relationships, and they have some kind of satisfying productive output that gives them joy. So then I started thinking about what's a forever OKR at work? Well, a forever OKR for a company is to be a Hall of Fame company, and usually that means grow over a long period of time. So I use sports metaphors, and it turns out there's always argument about who gets in the Hall of Fame, but it usually is great output over persistent time, probably a decade. So a Hall of Fame company has to do something for a decade, an All-Star company can have a single great year. So you start out with what's a company. Now what's a Hall of Fame CEO? A Hall of Fame CEO is somebody who has led a Hall of Fame company, usually from scratch. And so what are the forever OKRs of a Hall of Fame CEO? And I got this by asking people, 'Tell me the best CEO you've ever seen. Now tell me the third best, and what's the measure of best versus third best?' And the number one measure of a CEO is always product market fit. And now the question is how do you judge product market fit? So that gets bandied about a lot in venture and investors, and most people don't have a falsifiable definition of what product market fit is. So for me the falsifiable definition is make plan, but make plan easily. You know, when customers call up and say, 'I want to be on Cameo,' that's an example of product market fit. So make plan easily. The second is get more share of voice in PR and earned media than anybody else in the category. And you know, that's kind of it. And then the next thing for in the growth companies, it's if you have it now, are you going to have it next year? So, I'd say the third part of product market fit is what's called a network effect. How can you build things in your business so the more customers you have, the better the product becomes? And that feels like a tailwind. If you've ever bicycled, you know the difference between a headwind and a tailwind. Maybe a little less so if you're a runner. Certainly there's difference when you're sailing, but a network effect is the ultimate tailwind. So, in venture, the only investor I've ever seen who has kind of a foolproof early judgment about if there's a network effect there is Reid Hoffman. And Reid Hoffman built it into LinkedIn and then in some of investments. So, anyway, so it's make the plan easily, network effect that leads to growth, share of voice. And so, over time what I found is founders, you know, like you, usually they're really good at one piece of the business. And you build a business now, guess what? You got to hire a lawyer. You got to hire an accountant. Maybe you have to hire a salesperson you've never done that before at scale. Maybe you have to hire a chief data officer. And it's almost impossible that you understand all their businesses. So, CEO, what you need to do is have a forever OKR discussion with each of your functional leads and ask them, 'What's the best person you've ever seen in your function before? And what did they do that's better than the third best you've ever seen?' And that factor is one of the forever OKRs. So, forever OKR for head of revenue is beat plan by 20%. You know, what I tell founders, if you miss plan by more than 10%, it's almost always the case that you can replace your head of revenue with someone who'll beat it by 20%. And the exception is if your judgment about what's possible is wildly off. But so, the revenue person beat it by 20%. The engineering is make great code. And now the question is what's great code? And I'd advise all companies, their engineers should have a wall of great code and put pictures of the external stuff like Google PageRank or like Unreal from Epic that you think are great code that stand the test of time, that are company makers. And then look at your own tech stack and try to see, you know, what are the great pieces of code we have here? And I even think take the first page of line listings from your code and put it on the wall like you would a patent or a gold record and put underneath it the people who worked on it the day it launched. So, in HR, for example, the forever OKRs are less churn than your industry. In the tech industry, it's about 15%. So, get under 10%. That's pretty good. Even more important is 3% churn of your top employees. So, that means figure out who all your top employees are and on average, they stay for 33 years. And I've seen that happen before, you know, Glen Tullman at Livongo. He did that cuz he was missionary driven and the company was growing. So, keep your great people forever. And of course, to do that you have to, the HR person is responsible for knowing who they are. The HR person usually can't directly keep the great people. But they can predict what are we doing wrong with keeping the great people. And it's usually culture, supervision, and job makeup. So, anyway, that forever OKRs, it turns out that as soon as you get promoted to manage people that are doing things that you don't understand, you have to have the talk with them about forever OKRs starting with the difference between an A+ and a B+ in the job.
Yeah, and one of... Who's the best founder you've ever seen? Who's your role model?
I think Michael Rubin, you know, in my space or Ari Emanuel are the best ones that I've seen.
They're Hall of Fame. Both Hall of Fame, both have created enduring businesses that, you know, also got knocked on their ass multiple times. You know, I'm reading Ari Emanuel's book right now called Roll the Calls. It's amazing. You'd love it, Bing. But how many times like, you know, they were down on the mat and getting their ass kicked and they got back up and that it's so inspiring.
Yeah, the Elon book by Isaacson, same thing. They were facing end of corporate life a couple times.
And, you know, obviously outside of my space, Elon and Bezos, you have to put up there Steve Jobs, same thing, right? Got fired from Apple, came back and changed the world. And it's often interesting, too, how many times, you know, when the professional managers come in, a lot of times it's like the stuff that they were doing seemed off, but that force of personality, you know, getting people through and being as Bezos says, right a lot. You know, one thing that, you know, he found with that is like it's people that change their mind with new information and new data. And that's such an important thing. So not really worrying about being wrong, but just being able to move on quickly when you are and, you know, find the right thing.
I did ask Jeff once, you know, be right a lot and think big and they're kind of at odds. I asked him how often is a lot and he said nobody ever asked me that. And as you say, he said I know the behavior of be right a lot. It's be willing to change your mind on new information, be a skeptical optimist and ask good questions.
So I'm the CEO for forever OKRs. There's a couple other ones that, you know, as you get past product market fit are really important. You talk about hiring, you know, a world-class executive team. Talk everybody through your framework, the one to five framework on that.
So because I'm kind of an education fanboy, I like paying attention to how teachers do their work. And what I found over time and especially in seminars, when I ask professors, how do you give grades, the dirty secret is they know the grade before they know why. And by the way, anytime I first heard my now sister-in-law, the sister of my wife, in an all-girl discussion after wedding about what made a man attractive. And so they all got, okay, here's who's attractive and then why. And when my now sister-in-law said, you know, it's that little V over the man's hip where they've got that definition in there. You know, like Bing's brother Andy and I'm in the next room going, 'Oh, crap.' But now I've been married over 40 years. So, you know, teachers are the same way. They kind of know the grade before they know why. And I think it's the same thing with execs. So, when I go to a CEO and say, 'Rate all your direct reports on a scale of 1 to 5.' They kind of go, 'Well, what do you mean?' I go, 'Well, what if 5 is world-class and 4 is always beats and 3 is industry average?' They go, 'Oh, I know how to do that.' And what I've found is when CEOs are complaining, 'There's something going wrong with my company,' the average score of their direct reports is 3.65. And I say, 'The sweet spot is 4.25. That means for every four direct reports you have, one's a five doing world-class work and three are doing four, they're overachieving. And if you have that, everything takes care of itself.' And so now it's, you know, if you have product market fit, but you don't have that 4.25, that's now the CEO's number one objective this year, maintain product market fit, but improve the management team. And lo and behold, what I've seen is the number one tactic that CEOs take is, 'I'm going to hire a person who's a five.' And unfortunately, half the time when you hire somebody that looks world-class, it's a mistake. You kind of get it wrong. They're not a fit, they're not willing to roll up their sleeves, something. You can get it wrong. And then the next thing is, if somebody's underperforming, 'I'm going to train them to perform.' That almost never works. Very very few people can grow their skills as fast as a company is growing. So, the best way to improve the performance of big leaders is to cut their job in half. So now you got the issue. If you hire your way out of it, it's risky. If you try to develop your way out of it, all you can do is cut people in half. So, you know, what Bezos found when he had a near-death experience for the company in '99, is he turned to people he could trust a lot. He said, 'If I have six of my direct reports who I implicitly trust, if we start out with the same assumptions, I'll back whatever they come up with. I might disagree and commit, but I'll back whatever they come up with.' And for him, he just found that when he started out with that trust, he would listen, he would not interrupt, and they could work together. So, I found just again and again and again, it's once a CEO goes, 'Ooh, my management team isn't good enough.' Daniel Ek of Spotify said the thing that he learned, you know, and see, founder CEOs all have to become learning machines. They're almost impossible to replace, kind of especially in the stage one. Daniel Ek said, 'The hardest thing I had to learn and the most valuable thing is to constantly up-level the management team.' And what he said specifically is, 'Oh my gosh, I laughed at companies that had general counsel who wanted to make $10 million a year, and then I hired one. And what a difference. It's game-changing.' So, somebody who's a great level five engineering lead, a level five architect, a level five principal engineer, a level five revenue officer, those people are always out there. And the hardest thing for a founder to do is to change the role of the people he's loyal to he started with. And so I think what you want to do is have this forever OKR discussion about individual jobs when everybody's doing well. It's really awkward to start talking about I need 4.25 when you have some people in the room you think are doing threes. Because now you can't have that open discussion. Everybody else knows this person's not carrying their weight. This kind of awkward and so there's the elephant in the room is you have some people who aren't performing. So the time to have that A+ discussion is when everybody's at least getting B's.
And at Cameo especially in the 2018 to 2022 era when we were really hyper-scaling growth, we actually used to make the A+ 12-month performance review part of the hiring process. So not only were we negotiating on salary and equity, but people that joined in that time, you know, would talk to their hiring manager and they would actually have to submit in a Google Doc what an A+ performance review would look like a year later and then, you know, basically they would negotiate that with the manager, have an agreed-upon framework so then you could check in 60 days, 90 days later and see if they were on track or not. Right? If you're on track for a great, you know, get back out there. If you're off by 10%, it's like, 'Hey, you're doing really well, but here's the small tweaks we need to do. If you're off by 20%, it might be like, 'Hey, this...
You're putting our company at risk.
Right, we're putting the company at risk and then if you're 30% off, it's very clear that like, 'Hey, we made a mistake or you made a mistake and you know, this isn't going to work and you...
got to try to cut bait as quickly as possible there."
And so you said you did it then, you you're doing it?
We just haven't been hiring as much. So, this was more like when we were hiring, you know, senior execs especially.
It's I vastly prefer that to normal job specs which talk about experience in years. I advise kids when they're writing resumes is if all your resume says is what your experience is, what you're really signaling to me is you're an employee who needs to be told what to do and you don't have agency.
If your resume has relationships where you call out people's name, that tells me you're a people person and you're going to build teams and you're going to build networks. If your resume has achievement KPI after achievement KPI, it tells me that you're an achiever. And if you show up, you're going to be unhappy if you aren't achieving. So, now with that person, I want to define what achievement is. And so, I'm just not a fan of job specs. The ones that say six years doing this, must know this, this, and this. I don't know. Did you ship any great code?
[snorts]
All right. So, let's now get back to all those frameworks that are really helpful and I want everybody listening to get a sense for the way that Bing's mind works. To call me a non-linear thinker would be an understatement. So, you know, I didn't know we'd be talking about, you know, hipbones, but it all works, you know, and Bing always brings it back around. So, I think it's a big part of, you know, how my brain works as well and that's why we've got along fantastically, but let's talk about the books. So, you know, you've spent years and years and years building this career and I'd always tell people because when I get interviewed, I'm on podcasts, I find myself bringing a lot of Bing's frameworks out. And I always said that at some point I was going to write the book of Bing, but you actually wrote the book of Bing with your daughter Chloe. So, talk about this process of writing a book. Talk about the process of writing it with your daughter. And, you know, for those of you listening, this will come out October 27th, so go buy it at your local
And there's the book, the audio book is coming, and I actually narrated it because I was jealous. I was a board member of Audible, and I saw them doing it early on, and I was always jealous of how hard it looked and how cool it looked.
And for everyone listening, you're hearing a lot of these stories in Bing's voice. And my one sentence review of the book for Bing was it's Bing's stories in Chloe's voice. But now, when you listen to the Audible, it's going to be Bing's stories in Chloe's voice in Bing's voice.
[laughter] That's a good one. So, here's the story kind of in a nutshell. As a kid, and then as an English major, it was my bucket list to write a book. And then I discovered really early on writing for myself is hard. You know, I always wrote for teachers, I wrote for something, and I never had the ego to write for myself. So, and everybody who's a writer knows that sitting by yourself pulling words out of nowhere to a blank sheet is painful, painful, painful for most humans. But, now I go back and realize I actually track my business catastrophes. And a catastrophe is something that misses by 90% the short-term forecast. And I had it with companies, I had it with people, I had it with games, a lot with games. And so, keep a track. For a long time, I also kept track of my 10 favorite games of all time with a goal of getting to work on a project with at least half the people. So, I put that on my office wall and my catastrophes, I kind of keep track of which are the catastrophes and I realized that in the first half of my career my catastrophes all came from taking shortcuts.
So, an example is we did a great game called Dr. J and Larry Bird Go One-on-One. It was one of the first sports hits from Electronic Arts. And then we thought, "Well, let's do Jordan Bird One-on-One because Jordan is kind of the new Dr. J." And I was totally confident in it and the first package looked like the two guys on a playground in Boston, kind of very funky, and with Jordan we made it look more exciting. We put a red background on it going to the hoop. And it turned out that game didn't sell at all. It missed by 90%.
But I went to a... I always used to test packages and at this point we had this package and it was sitting at a consumer show where people could come and the stores would put out the games and you could buy them. And so, I went over and here's a card table back then, a card table and people walking around the card table and I saw people go touch a package, touch a package, there's our game. They skipped it and they touched the package next to it. And it turned out there was a game called Tetris that came out exactly the same time that had a red package and people picked up the Tetris package, they skipped our red package and then they went to the next thing. And I saw that and I went, "Oh, crap. I didn't do my homework." Because I always used to take packages and put them in a fake shelf and let people come and see if they'd pick it up. Kind of the equivalent now of click testing in an app where you can actually put something to see if people click. And I was like, "Well, oh crap, I didn't do my homework."
I did the same thing with a sequel to a game called Seven Cities of Gold, which was kind of the inspiration of Civilization. And we did a sequel to it called Heart of Africa. And I was so confident I didn't check. It turned out Americans are totally uninterested in Africa. It sold great in Germany, where the Germans love conquering Africa, but the US it literally sold zero copies in the first week. And I just needed to do my homework. So that was the first half of my career.
The second half of my career the catastrophes came when I was right, but I couldn't convince the founder to do it. And to some degree it's because, you know, I throw out so many ideas that it's sometimes easy to ignore. And even when I say no, pay attention to this one, this is really it, I still couldn't get across. An example is a Harry Potter game from Niantic. They'd just done Pokémon Go. I was in there helping John Hanke and team figure out how to keep Pokémon Go alive because it was falling off and they thought it was done and so they had to quickly do a new game. So they do a Harry Potter game. And [snorts] the Harry Potter game in soft launch couldn't get repeat players. And it's like, okay, you know, you got to keep working on this. It's got a great initial opening with an owl and then it falls apart, you know, it doesn't give you the Harry Potter experience. Hagrid's boring. You know, you don't see Hogwarts. You got to do more stuff and it's yeah, it's too hard, you know, we've been working on this a long time. How bad can it be? Well, the answer is sequels don't have a right to do 50%. Everybody thinks so I have a success the next thing is going to at least do 50%. No, the next thing can do zero. And we have to take seriously the zero. And that was basically a zero.
So what I realized is when I'm trying to convince people that my idea is right, I do it with stories. And if I can back up and give people the whole meta like, you know, gamification is a thing. For gamification to work, you've got to align the game design and get people to do things they already want to do. So, games are great for motivation, but if you're being motivated to do something you don't want to do, you get bummed out and get snarky and it works against you. So, I found with when I'm trying to convince people, please think about take this seriously instead of what you're doing, that if I could back up and give the meta and give stories. And I've done speeches about this and blogs about this.
And you know, with Chloe I say, "Well, you know, this would probably work better in a book." That would be, you know, if every team I work with read a book first, they'd probably listen a little more closely. I work with a guy named Luke Bartley who said, "A year later I realized you were right. Now I want to listen to everything you say." And I go, "How do I save that whole year?" And Chloe goes, "Well," she says, "You know, Dad, I'm a writer." And I go, "Oh, yeah." She said, "Well, let's do this together." So, it was can we put the meta and the stories that I know that can convince people in real time, can we put it in book form so that people can get a whole context before we get any visual ideas. So, it really started out as being can I give a book to every product team I ever work with and then convince them to read it or listen to it. And then once we got into it is, oh wouldn't it be nice to even reach more people because I do get a kick out of doing stuff that's useful for other people.
Well, and the book starts out with the being because of the intro of it, you talk about the story of how you actually inspired Amazon Prime. So, let's talk about that.
Well, the whole story in that one. So, again back to John Doerr. So, at Kleiner Perkins, Kleiner Perkins was a Series A investor in Electronic Arts in 1982. And as was Sequoia, the other two reigning venture firms at the time. And Kleiner was long-term supportive and helpful and positive. And the Sequoia founder guy was long-term bazooka to the chest and really negative. And so anyway, so I had affinity to the goals of Kleiner Perkins and still have. Mamoon Hamid who is kind of the lead along with Ilya Fushman at Kleiner right now, those guys start out with this long-term culture building and they both came to America after they're born and so they've got kind of this outsider's appreciation for the importance of culture. Well, Kleiner Perkins had that forever. So, after some years Doerr invited me to come give a talk about branding at a Kleiner Perkins CEO conference. So, I did and that was well received and you know, the importance of brand. Most people don't know what a brand is. So, a brand is an intellectual property that either increases volume or increases price. And the value of the brand is a discounted cash flow of the incremental cash flows from price or volume. And it turns out that you can do marketing that sells stuff in the short term that adds to a brand. And that's anyway, so talked about that and engineer founders at Kleiner kind of got that.
So then next year Doerr said that was great but is that great? They invited me to the next offsite and at the end of it I'm on a bike ride with Doerr. Weeks later she said, "How did you like it this year?" I said, "It was great. I didn't have to talk. I didn't have to go to a green room. I wasn't nervous about talking to her. I just got to sit and take it all in." But that reminds me of one thing. Jeff Bezos got interviewed by Charlie Rose and he said, "We want to be the world's most customer-centric, customer-obsessed, customer-centric company." And I like that. I've done that a lot. But then in the next 20 minutes the interviewer he never mentioned a single customer story. My experience with retailers is they all have customer stories. And in fact Toys "R" Us or Walmart or Babbage's that then became GameStop with those founders they'd proudly walk on the floor and say, "See that person? They're going to buy this. See that person? They're a looky-loo. They're not going to buy anything. See that person? When they get up to the cash register they're going to buy something else." So they believe they can look at people in the store and predict what's going to happen. And by the way, I think the same thing with a salesperson calling on a prospect, they got a spidey sense it's going to work or not. I think in Bezos, he's trying to be the world's leading retailer, he doesn't tell me those stories. And Doerr goes, "Okay, what would you do about it?" Doerr is kind of a first principle person and I go, "John, I haven't thought about it. We're just biking." And I go, "I don't know. How about a loyalty program?" And I go, yeah, loyalty programs never work, but I think it will for Amazon because when I get that box on my Amazon front door, I feel like it's my birthday. I feel like it's a holiday. It's like special. And I don't think Amazon knows how special that feels. So, I'd do something to amplify that. And he goes, what would you call it? I go, John, come on, I haven't even thought about this. He said, come on, give me an answer. And I go, Amazon Black. You know, I always was jealous of American Express black card holders. I've seen one once. I don't have one. And then I go, nah, Amazon's too good for that. Not derivative, something new. How about Prime? Nobody's ever used Prime as anything other than in beef. And so, nobody's ever used Prime as branding. So, Amazon Prime. He goes, Bing, what would you put in it? And I go, oh god, John, you're pushing me beyond beyond beyond. I'd say, how about a better shipping benefit? I'd like to get a monthly missionary note from the CEO about what we're trying to accomplish here. And then I'd like a concierge who tells me what I should buy for what purpose. And he goes, okay. Well, if I give you my plane, will you fly up to Seattle to meet Jeff? And I go, I won't take your plane. No, I don't want to do that. I got to go to Seattle anyway. And because I got a studio there.
So, you could tell when Steven asks for a one-line answer, it never turns out to be a one-line answer. So, I'm sitting in the EA Seattle office. And I'm thinking, oh, I got to meet Jeff Bezos at lunch. I don't know much about what's going on in this company. I admire it. I remember he was on the cover of Time magazine for something or other. He was man of the year or something. Oh, this is going to be embarrassing. I'm just a schmuck. And so, they're all, I got to go with something. So, I sit down and take a piece of paper and I wrote down five ideas. And the first called Amazon Prime, a loyalty program. If you had this, you'd have to pay attention to customers and here's what would be in it. And then add a couple other things.
And so I go to lunch with Bezos, he of the enormous laugh and the great charisma. He comes in a few minutes late and it's going to be kind of a 35-minute lunch and it lasted a couple hours and we went through the whole thing and at the end he said, "You know, nobody's ever come and pitched me something before with something written down." He says, "I love things written down." Turned out later that Amazon became a very writing culture. He said, "You actually had something written down. I admire that. So, thanks a lot. You know, it's great to meet you." And a couple days later I got a call from a guy named Norbert Gottenberg who is a board recruiter and he says, "Amazon needs a board member. Would you want to meet?" And so actually based on that, there's a guy named Scott Cook, the founder of Intuit, who'd been on the board of both eBay and Amazon and he quit Amazon because he thought eBay was a better company. And so they needed somebody who was consumery. And that turned out to be me.
And you know, Bezos, I've never seen anybody as good as him. There's more story about how it happened because of course when I came into the first board meeting and I said, "Should do a loyalty program called Prime." The board members said, well, that never works. And you know, shut it down. There's a guy named Jeff Wilke who is another operating genius, entrepreneur genius, a blue-collar guy from Pittsburgh and it just pissed him off that it sounded to him like I thought I was maybe right, and he wanted to work on it. So, a couple years later he came back to the board and said, "Here's the proposal." And the board unanimously voted no because giving away more free shipping was a stupid idea. And Bezos he said, "Well, this is a two-way door. Let's try it." And then it started working, and Bezos said, "Well, this is a good surprise." So, I've almost never seen anybody that any of them is good surprises immediately double down. And in the world of games when somebody does something that works you go, "Don't mess with it." That was really emotionally hard. Don't mess with it. And in fact, it's always a good idea to take the risk and double down, double down. It surprisingly feels risky to try to double down on something that works because you might screw it up. And I don't know if you've ever had that in dating. You have one good date, and somebody will go, "Well, that was good. I don't know. This might not work." And so, Bezos is one of his geniuses of always double down on good surprises. And the other genius is two-way door versus one-way door. A two-way door, you know, again in relationships, marriage is a two-way door. You can always get out of it. In fact, the average marriage lasts about as long as a Prime membership. Kids are one-way door. So, you have kids, you got them for 18 years. And you know, they're going to be as needy at year 80 as they were at 80 days. So, you know, be careful what you wish for. But Bezos is a genius in so many ways. It was one of the delights of my life to be able to sit in a room with him again and again and again and again and again and again.
And let's talk about the impact. So, you ship Amazon Prime after a board that is skeptical of it and saying they can't do it. What happens almost immediately to customer LTV and repeat rate?