What part of life gets worse if like an AI agent wins for you? What can we deliberately leave in for the human to do? Friction is what makes pearls. If you don't get a sand in the oyster, you just get an oyster.
What is friction in that example?
I mean, here's friction in the AI is 10 other people are doing the same prompt as you, you got to do something better than them. What do you do? The book, The Facebook Effect, was a promise that connecting on Facebook would allow you to move mountains socially. But then it turned out the money was clicks. And so Facebook never measured on the server how much friendship you were building.
What is your p(doom) score about AI taking over the world by 2030?
Is it no or is it yes? We'll debate the test. Best we get more or less bread plus sandwiches. Put it all right to the test. More or less.
Welcome back to another episode of More or Less. This is your host Brit Morin, joined by Dave Morin. And sadly today we're not — I don't know, we're missing the Lessins. We've got Sam at an AGM in New York. He's actually doing something maybe with a collared shirt on. And Jess is hosting The Information's WTF event this week in California. So instead, we decided to bring on an incredible guest, someone that has been near and dear to our hearts for a couple decades now. He has shaped what you play, what you buy, and how you learn, probably without you even knowing it. I'm talking about Bing Gordon. He was there at the beginning of Electronic Arts. He spent a decade as its chief creative officer. Then he spent — is this true? 30 years at Kleiner Perkins backing companies like Zynga and Slack. How many years?
Kleiner Perkins at '82 was a Series A. I joined Kleiner Perkins in '08. So 18 years kind of in the fold.
18 years. I mean, close to 20. We're still talking decades here. But I fell in love with Kleiner Perkins in the 80s when Brook Byers and Don Valentine were the board members representing the soul of Sequoia and the soul of Kleiner. One of them was loyal and always supportive,
which is the same reason I fell in love with Kleiner.
And I'm still introing by the way, but I'm going to interject here to say what I love about Bing is he's really seen Silicon Valley since the beginning. And I feel like we have this sage here with us today who can impart a lot of wisdom, which we will do. But let me continue on because then you also sat on Amazon's board for 15 years. Is that right?
Yeah. And then I sat in the boardroom for another six.
Okay. And some credit you with the invention of Prime or the idea for Prime.
John Doerr and Jeff Wilke credit me.
Okay. So the inventor of Prime also now on the boards of Take-Two and Duolingo. And this week he and his daughter Chloe came out with a new book called Everybody Wins. It is the playbook for why games win and how any product can actually borrow their magic. So Bing, welcome to More or Less. Thanks for being here with us today.
Thanks, you guys. You talk about decades of knowing you. Dave may or may not remember the first time I came into Facebook's office on University Ave, and my experience is Dave is the truth teller here.
What made you think that, Bing? Because I have to argue against this sometimes.
Dave is the team builder here. Dave is the everybody-wins person here, and you know others were not. I mean, it was when it was a fledgling or just getting started. Dave has always been a kind of a lightning bolt of uplifting motivation and integrity since that first meeting.
Thanks, Bing. I do remember that clear as day. I am very grateful for that day because I quickly realized the same about you and have learned so much from you ever since. But to add to the intro, you know, Bing also was deeply involved in Path. You know, I don't know if I had other than our current business partner James Higa, it was Bing Gordon and James that were at Path the most, helping with everything that we were doing, and also taught me a lot about venture. Well, and I will credit the last thing I'll say is I think Bing is like one of our dad idols. As we are now parenting our children in kind of the elementary school years, we've seen how Bing and his wife have parented their children, who have all grown up to be exceptional humans, and have been very inspired by that. And especially, you know, the idea that you can be a very successful, powerful person in Silicon Valley and still raise an extraordinary family with kids who don't hate you even through their teenage years. So,
it's kind of like the rules of game design, and you have to create motivation that aligns with what people already want to do.
Maybe we should go into that actually. I mean, we are going to cover some news here, but maybe we'll put that in a little bit.
We can put news at the end.
Can we like rewind back? So, you've been in Silicon Valley since the 80s. Is that right?
I actually worked half time at Intel in '77-'78 while I was paying for Stanford Business School as a commercial fisherman.
And what was your draw to technology at the time? What did you see that others didn't?
Let's see. For me, it was I had this fantasy as a high school kid working at Disneyland that when the park was closed, the characters would come to life and I could hang with them. The Abraham Lincoln audio-animatronic on Main Street — I wanted to hang with Abe. And there with Teddy Ruxpin or Chatty Cathy, you pull a string and you hear one of just several messages. And the same with Abraham Lincoln. But I had this fantasy that if I can get you off this pedestal and we go hang, you could teach me a lot. This could be fun. I'll buy you a beer. You tell me about the Gettysburg Address. So I was a book reader growing up and I had that fantasy. You know, books were my virtual world. And so this getting enmeshed in books, I tried acting a little bit, which is the sport of storytelling. And then I had a coworker who was a Heathkit fanatic, and he came in one day with a Heathkit catalog. In the front it said, 'Make your own home computer.' He says, 'I'm going to build one of these. I already built a clock.' And I said, 'I'll build Disneyland inside that computer.' So that was my fantasy attraction to technology. The fantasy was to create something entertaining inside the computer.
That was kind of your vision at the time.
Disneyland inside the computer, it sounds like.
Okay. So, you had this vision for Disneyland inside the computer. Tell us about how that took you to EA and the founding of that company.
It turned out I was good at math, not good at working in an office. So, I'm taking this decision science class, which I also tried to do as an undergrad. And decision science is basically what became machine learning. But how do you make a science out of decisions? And you start out with kind of the underpinnings, tenets, and the assumptions and the probabilities. So I'm in that class and a professor named Peter G. W. Keane said, 'Let's stop this. We got a few minutes left. Let's talk about what really matters. Imagine five years from now you could pick your career without getting paid for it. What would you do?' And a third of the people said, 'I'd like to float the biggest debenture on Wall Street.' Guess what? They became i-bankers. And would they do it for no money? No. There's no i-banker in the world who would do it for no money. And then the second group had some fantasy or other. The third group wanted to do weird stuff. The ones who said, 'I want to start a restaurant,' were out of the MBA workforce in 5 years. Some people said, 'I just want to raise a family.' And they were out of the workforce in 5 years. And I said, 'I'd like to create this virtual Disneyland where all the characters come to life. You can hang with them.' And the room went silent. Peter Keane came up to me afterwards and said, 'That was probably embarrassing, but...' And I said, 'Embarrassing?' He goes, 'Didn't you notice?' I went, 'No.' And he goes, 'In the other class, there's this kid named Trip Hawkins who wants to do the same thing with card-based football games. You should meet.' So I knew him a little bit from a championship touch football team. Had never talked to him. Then I go up to him and introduce myself, and we ended up getting Peter Keane as an advisor for an independent project where we did market research for the first cartridge video game system called the Fairchild Channel F, Fairchild Semiconductor. The day that we went in to show them our findings, the VP of marketing was white as a ghost because Wally Corcoran, the CEO of Fairchild, had just fired half his staff. But at the end of it, Trip said, 'Do something interesting. I'm going to start a computer game company in five years.' Now I said I'm going to start a consumer tech ad agency in five years. He goes, 'Perfect.' And then four and a half years later, he says, 'Okay, it's time.' I said, 'Great. I'll be your ad agency.' 'Nah, you got to be either in or out.' So I went in. These people who kind of have a butterfly effect that they don't know at the time and maybe don't even remember. But Peter Keane, just with that 'we got 10 minutes to do something important' conversation, got me on the path to actually being a co-founder.
The year before that I had three guys committed to starting an ad agency with me, and the year we went public they were picked as the ad agency of the year in the US.
Okay. So you had two good potential outcomes there. You went into the video game world. So now we're talking like mid-80s. Is that right? Mid to late 80s.
I joined EA in '82. So that was February '82. We talked about it and we raised 2 million on 3 million from Sequoia and Kleiner.
No, 5 post. Oh, no. It's not like nothing, but 2 million for 40%. Yeah, a real deal.
And with inflation that would be 2 billion, 5 billion post. That sounds like a good seed deal right now.
You know, hey founders, watch out what you wish for. But that was in November, and four weeks later Atari announced they were going to miss earnings by a lot, and that was the beginning of the great depression of interactive entertainment that lasted for four years until Nintendo came to the US.
Right. And I'm a child of the 80s, as is Dave. So we were definitely the Nintendo generation in the mid to late 80s when we grew up in the 90s, of course, with every other gaming device you could imagine. So I guess like in all of those years, what were some of the fundamental principles you learned about both game design but also building a company, and like how does that either retain today or differ from what you're seeing in the market right now?
The first was this belief in vision. So we thought in starting a company that we were starting something that could be really big. And you learn that if you're a visionary, most people think you're full of crap and they think you're stupid. So that's — it's always possibly a good sign when people think you're stupid. And it could just mean you're at one end of the bell curve and they can't tell which. At Electronic Arts, I was the first person to care about goals and objectives, OKRs, because at Intel, every bathroom had this quarter's OKRs in an easy-to-see place. And I saw Intel kind of fall in love with OKRs,
the lost art of bathroom OKRs.
Yeah. And it was, you know, at Intel, they were in the business of reducing mistakes, getting yield out of a single platter of silicon. And so the whole culture was don't make mistakes. And the invention of OKRs was no, no, think big. So if you only achieve two out of three things, it's awesome. And so OKRs was not perfection, it was think big. And so I came up with that. The research is that people who set falsifiable, time-based goals achieve about 15% more in education and in work. So I started out being the goal-setting guy at EA when the other co-founders were mostly from Apple. So I'd say that's the first thing: is set time-based goals. In this day and age, the time-based goals almost need to be weekly because now we can prototype and test kind of in a day. So the creative time trial has become much shorter duration, but it's still, you know, set goals. The second thing was I always like to start with a gap. So we learned at Electronic Arts that every other media business that got to scale had at least 7% market share. And with 7% market share, they could afford a global distribution. Now at the time, you know, even in 2008, mass audience was thought to be 30 million households. Now it's a billion.
But back then it was, you know, 30 million. That was the three cable companies. There was just... and
Yeah. And most large magazines were at about that size as well back then.
Hit records could get to maybe 10 million. So millions, you know, and that was why the movie line was $1 million. Two decades later, it's $1 billion, and now Elon Musk gets $1 trillion. So we've — I think that that is one of the stories of Silicon Valley, is technology reduces entropy and increases scale in a way that was unimaginable. Those were the first things. But then the next thing is, because I was a marketing guy, it's how do you get people to want to buy your game? And then we wanted to buy, but we needed word of mouth. Word of mouth was always important. So before we started doing EA Sports, I still remember we did focus groups. We didn't have any server side. So in focus groups, I still remember with pride when I'm sitting around and that would be like 12 people with a moderator, and the moderator goes, 'Would you guys pirate software? What about it?' One person says, 'I never pirate EA's software because they're trying to make this business work in the way I want to make it work.' And I'm quoting, 'Oh man, thank goodness.' So, next thing about founders is all companies go through good times and bad times. The people who stick are the people who are on mission. The coin-operated people all leave. So, you know, watch out hiring coin-operated people. If you say come to my company because the stocks may be worth a lot, those are short-attention-span careerists.
Wouldn't you argue there are a lot of those people in the market right now with the AI wave? How do you see through that?
It's motivating with money is dangerous. It's kind of a double-edged sword. It's kind of like motivating kids in school with candy or allowance. The secret for a parent helping their kid with a college application or a kid writing their own college application: the number one thing, communicate that you're intrinsically motivated. So intrinsic motivation is lasting. Extrinsic motivation is kind of corruptible. So what do you do when people are out there kind of making bank? Dave, you hired technologists. So the technologists mostly don't feel they control the money part. So they kind of think of their options as a lottery ticket, but they all want to solve hard problems.
Yeah. So the mission — you guys both are pretty good at being missionary, you know, on behalf of other people, on behalf of brands, on behalf of beauty, on behalf of friendship. The mission, and mission usually comes with a customer in mind. The people who work late Friday night or work over the weekend are usually feeling they're on a mission. That is kind of the third lesson of Electronic Arts early on. The original ad that we did was 'Can a computer make you cry?' and we talked about software artists, and the finance people on the board said, 'You're wasting my money. You're not showing a product.' Some rookies got phased by bad board advice. For the next 10 years, every Hall of Fame employee that we hired in their job interview quoted that ad. You want people to say, 'I'll be here for more than just the money.' And games — talk about in the book, we found again and again and again the number one motivation for coming back was other people. You're probably old enough to remember the Cheers bar with Sam.
When you went to where everybody knows your name, you go back to the bar where everybody knows your name and they call you out and you have a little bit of history. You go to a bar and people look at you like you're a stranger, you leave. That is the number one thing in games. The productivity, including money, is down the list, which always shocks and bums out business people who want to turn everything into money.
What's the facet of game design where you're known by other people? Is it only in multiplayer games?
When you have a profile in Amazon, when you come back and it says, 'Welcome back, Brit,' it's like, 'Oh, thank you.' Now, unfortunately, Amazon says, 'Welcome back, Brit,' to everybody who has your credit card. So...
Hopefully not that many people do. And now the agents won't go to Amazon right now either, so they don't get that statement.
But you know, friends — you can see with your own kid, they'll do a lot to be popular, to build long-term friendships. You'll have play groups. My kids in their 30s still remember the play groups when they were four.
Can I ask you which social network you believe has done the best job outside of market cap? You know, we could talk about Facebook.
So, the book, The Facebook Effect, was a promise that connecting on Facebook would allow you to move mountains socially, but then it turned out the money was clicks. And so, Facebook never measured on the server how much friendship you were building. And clicks were thought to be a proxy for friendship, but instead they're an on-ramp to advertising. So the social networks, I think, have become viral networks so far, and many of the people I know who were in the early inventive days, even if they got rich, they'd like to do a make-good. LinkedIn with the endorsements thing is the closest to a social capital-building network that I see.
How much do you think endorsements has influenced LinkedIn from a game design?
It's a huge part of their value because before endorsements and before publishing, if somebody was on LinkedIn, they were an exec recruiter or they just started a job hunt. Nobody else came. Reed saw that early on, and he saw it, you know, right around the time we saw him or met him as a Zynga board member, and it was, 'I got to get everybody to come back more often.' And this at a time when Pincus was saying DAUs are the coin of the realm. I got to get people from instantiating to coming back more often. This is a time in 2008-2009, everybody talked about MAUs. MAUs are good for monthly magazines, but we live a DAU life. So even then, the visionaries were people to come back more often. Seeing this now, repetition and habits is the key to self-improvement in fitness, kind of in parenting, by the way, in relationships. It's why anybody who hears about a couple that still has date night once a week feels jealousy and guilt.
So, you know, how do you get — and even I learned this a long time ago from a preventive health care company. They say most people engage with health twice a year. On Google, I think it's 7% of the searches I've heard. So instead of going to see a doctor twice a year, you started talking to Google about it twice a month. And now if you were doing a wearable, you're thinking about it every day. So we've just seen this collapse from annual to monthly to daily and even toward hourly. I don't think there's an HAU measure yet, but certainly daily is the coin of the realm.
This brings up something. I was reading the book and you were writing that people who quit Farmville felt relief even while the retention and revenue numbers had been looking great.
And I think that one of the things going on in Silicon Valley right now is that people are trying to think critically about AI and not making some of the same mistakes that we've made in the past. And so I thought that story was a really interesting one, both because I was there, I remember talking to you about it, but I'm just kind of curious: what do you think could have told you the truth in that moment while the numbers were still going up, and how should people think about this kind of a problem?
We saw it anecdotally. Bezos always says when the anecdotes and data don't agree, trust the anecdotes. You saw it that any kind of NPS survey, the NPS, people expressing NPS about Farmville went down after they quit. We, interesting enough, we found in the Zynga game,
meaning they wouldn't refer it. After they quit, they would not refer it.
After they quit, after they quit, they're, 'Oh my god.' And you never seen that before. You've seen now in the old days of caveat emptor, which is buyer beware. For a while there, premium, it was vendor beware. If people come on board and they don't play for a long time, you're just going to lose money. And so I think Farmville was an example of too much pinch. It used things effectively to get stuff that the NPS score afterwards would say you didn't want to do. You didn't really want to get up at three in the morning. But we all know, you know, if you've ever been on a sports team or if you're on a ski team and somebody makes you go to the gym and, you know, do squats, it's like, not today. But you kind of have to get hacked to do things a little bit that you don't want to do that pays off. But at some point if you got a totalitarian dance troupe leader or coach, it takes all the fun out of it. I think Reed is the first person I talked to said, you know, growth hacking is great for a really short time. Kind of like human growth hormone. If you get addicted to it, you're a cancer risk. Every now and then you might do it, you know, you might do it to win the Tour de France. A little pulse of adrenaline. We can handle long periods of adrenaline. We can't. A great example of gamification getting you to do stuff they don't really want to do. And at some point you start noticing it. So one of the goals of the book is people think, 'Oh, that's how game design works. I can do it for myself. If I feel a little bit alienated from what I'm doing and I feel like I'm being gamed, I can game myself, but if I'm being gamed in a way, I don't want to be gamed.'
Are there products that are successful today that you suspect have the same problem?
All the clickables, anything that people say is doom scrolling. TikTok is probably that way. I don't know about WhatsApp. I think Zuck has protected WhatsApp to some degree. Nobody complains about overusing WhatsApp, but there's not really a timeline there.
So, I think, you know, and I have another measure that I like that actually I started thinking about with Facebook. I used to count every now and then, look at a hundred things: am I glad I saw it? A newspaper or a magazine. As soon as I was glad I saw less than 30% of the time, I would unsubscribe. And so the putting in — not organic ads, but putting ads kind of that seem native, I think it's a risk.
And obviously that's a pitch for like subscription products that remove ads, perhaps as one example. But even my Prime subscription doesn't remove sponsored products from Amazon. So I'm getting double hit, I guess, on that front. And every AI agent — well, at least maybe not some of the harnesses, but ChatGPT always ends with a question. 'Here's the answer. Now, would you like to do this? Now, would you like to do this?' And it's sort of an example of that all over again. One of the next questions I was going to ask you, Bing, I think it's in chapter two, you talk a lot about how people value what they earn in games and games best make effort super meaningful, right? And the big debate right now in technology is AI promises to remove your effort, right? And so I was sort of thinking about that question, like what part of life gets worse if like an AI agent wins for you, and then what can we leave in and like deliberately leave in for the human to do? Or is it that you have to sort of run so many tokens to figure this out that we've kind of created the ultimate game with AI? How do you kind of think about this?
It's like three questions in one. So I start out saying, you know, friction is what makes pearls. If you don't get a sand in the oyster, you just get an oyster. Now, sand in the oyster doesn't always make a pearl, but it is necessary to pearl building.
What is friction in that example?
Constraints. I mean, here's friction in the AI: it's 10 other people are doing the same prompt as you. You got to do something better than them. What do you do? So it's so...
You know, it's everybody's got something that's really interesting.
You know, basically what we now think is great, three years from now we're going to think of as slop.
Dave thinks it's all slop no matter what. So...
He's a humanist. Is that what you said?
Couple things about quality. The whole philosophy of quality is wildly interesting. I'm a Robert Pirsig fan and Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. And he says quality is not in the exact measure. Quality has to come from intent. And so actually when we launched Electronic Arts, we did that on purpose. We made the logo small. We made it a little bit hard to discover because we found when people felt they discovered, they're more willing to tell their friends about it. So being harder to find can be a good marketing approach. I think early on with Snap, it was a little hard to get going, and that was also a bit of a marketing approach.
To work for marketing with the ease of use. There's some miracle of efficiency,
but I think what's going to happen is the quality bar is going to keep going up. To get the most out of our agents, we're going to add constraints and boundaries to the prompts. Here's a friction: it's a Hugging Face. It's like, hey, you can't ever do that again. If you ever do that again, your company's out of business and you go to jail for 40 years, or you go fight in Ukraine for the Ukrainians. It's like, oh, that'd be friction. I think I'll think differently about doing this before unleashing that.
You're talking about the hack into Hugging Face.
To the point of friction, there's going to be new frictions based on finding edge conditions. And you know, the Hugging Face is an edge condition. It's like remember the Cruise car that dragged the pedestrian? It was an edge condition that they didn't think of and didn't test for. So we find out in the world of infinite possibility in infinitely short time that we're always going to find edge conditions that we hadn't imagined. The good news is human actors can create edge conditions in tone of voice and in facial expression and body language that we didn't imagine. But the edge condition for these agents are they're going to be forever. The pain of the edge conditions is going to be one of the new frictions.
Nobody's copped to it yet. It's still kind of bubbling below the surface. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to nonplus you.
No, I love it. I have never thought about the edge conditions like that and kind of where we're at in the arc of AI. I mean, you see it to your point with autonomous driving and Waymo killed this person, you know, all of these new technologies.
It was Cruise. It was Cruise.
It was a Cruise. Well, Waymo ran about a cat or something. There's been all kinds of disasters that happen as new technologies emerge.
Sergey and Larry said, 'Can we start doing autonomous when it's 10 times safer than humans?' I don't know. How about 100 times safer? If we wait till 100 times safer, we'll never get anywhere, and then we'll all be speaking Mandarin to our car. 10 times, maybe we can do that. And you know, the human snark on feedback is a bot that's 10 times safer than a human. That seems like about an even tradeoff. So I don't know how people arrived at that, that a machine has to be 10 times better than a person. But so far it seems to be the prevailing wisdom.
Interesting. So Bing, I want to go back to — I mean, we're going to pull some, extract some more wisdom out of your book, but just to start, you wrote this with your daughter. How did that come about and why did you decide to do that?
I know you probably already feel this way, but you kind of want your kids to be great. If you remember when you were teenagers, you weren't so sure your parents really wanted you to be great, but you want your kids to be great. You know, talking to Chloe, I've been doing meeting notes for decades. And in the first half of my career, my catastrophes were for taking shortcuts. In the second half, it was for not being convincing enough when I was right. And I found when I wanted to convince people I was right, either I tell them something, they don't agree, they die in the bind, and they come back and say, 'Tell me next time,' or I say it wrong, I sound too much like a brainstorm, something or other. And I found when I back up and start all the way back to prime moving, which is gamification is based on human psychology. So let's go all the way back to human psychology and think about your product design. If I can back up and then tell stories — I like to think about my teaching as anecdotes wrapped around lessons. The anecdotes make the lessons easier. You know, it's like the sugar that makes the medicine go down in Mary Poppins. So I'm doing that and I'm talking to Chloe and go, 'But writing is so painful.' And she goes, 'Well, Dad, I'm a writer.' And she says, 'And I'm a gamer, and you know, I've been watching this forever.' So we thought, haha, this would be fun. Let's collaborate. So on the collaboration, she got my talk, said, 'What's this gamification checklist that you like to end with?' You know, I like to end talks with something. Sometimes it was favorite books and, you know, other lessons or business task force. She said, 'Well, let's do something like that.' And so that was the beginning. The gamification checklist has a structure. What I learned through her is screenwriters start with structure. And it's like where if you have a story, do you start at the beginning? You start at the end? You start in the middle with a flashback? How do you do it? And so the structure is a really important creative decision. There's the best book about movie screenwriting by William Goldman called Adventures in the Screen Trade. I kind of tried to model a little after that at my wow scale, going kind of second by second through something, but that's what he said: it's structure, structure, structure, and then at the end it's dialogue, dialogue, dialogue. But it's structure. You got to have these mini completions. And so Chloe was the structure. She likes to say, 'My dad thinks like a video gamer, kind of all doors are openable, it's kind of nonlinear. Most people like linearity.' I can linear. And I said, 'Okay, Chloe,'
You're badass. You're linear.
This is why Dave and I work so well together.
I like that. That's a new metaphor for me. All doors are open. That's also how my brain works.
But most people like linear, Dave, let's not forget.
I don't know. I think some people like all doors open.
Well, you and Bing, the visionary and the operator, right? And there's obviously a blend between the two, but yes. So you paired up with your operator as the visionary.
I paired up my operator and it's so much fun. You know, John Doerr in a session asked, "What's your favorite hour?" She's thinking of a favorite hour as a contiguous 60 minutes. And I said, "My favorite hour is 61 minutes." 60 one-minute sessions. And it's one-minute session when she glows telling a story and kind of, you know, almost like she's just had three beers. And I look at her and think, "Oh my god, I love that face. I love that look." So 60 of those is my favorite hour. And for her, she goes, "Well, I think it was when we were doing this, but maybe it was this." But she thinks of life in acts, ACTs. And you know, I think of lives in moments combined with faces.
With open doors everywhere. And so you did structure the book. So you put these eight different steps to gamification. Can you tell us about a few of those?
The first one is wow. It's the wow factor, getting to wow. And what I discovered — I was trying to, I wish I did this back with Path — but I realized that when I'm talking to developers, I can channel the everyman. I can be the dumb user. I can get there really quickly. And so I would be a novice, the uneducated mind, and I would be the novice, and I'd go in with a stopwatch and I would wait until I had a feeling. I'd stop the clock, I'd write down what happened on screen and what the feeling was. And I realized the feelings were, "Wow, I got to tell somebody about this." Good. Yeah, nice. I'm leaning in, you know, I'm feeling warm inside. Not good. I'm sighing. My brows are knitting. I'm crossing my arms. Or...
But I called it the wow [__] scale. And he would come into Path and say that all the time.
Yeah. I mean, a big reason...
Show him a new product and he'd say that if it was good.
Yeah. He'd invoke that all the time.