The landscape of teenage rebellion has really changed. You know, the teenage rebel used to be the kid that went out and like disappeared in the world and drank, maybe used drugs, experimented with drugs. Now you could almost say that the teenage rebel today doesn't leave their room, doesn't get off their devices, doesn't speak to their parents, you know, has gone virtually mute, is absolutely refusing to participate in any aspect of life. In Japan, they have a name for this, hikikomori, which is kids who just literally disappear inside their rooms and behind their screens.
Doctor, where does this podcast find you?
I am in Stanford, California, in my office.
Makes sense. And I imagine, as is the case 364 days a year, I imagine it's beautiful out there.
It is gorgeous. We're having a great fall. By the way, I really enjoyed our last conversation. I was excited to see that we were having you on again.
Thank you. I enjoyed it, too. And I got a lot of credibility with my sons and their friends. So, that was awesome.
Yeah, there you go. You're with that crazy guy.
So, let's bust right into it. Your newest book, Radical Surrender, which comes out November the 10th, offers readers the tools for letting go in a world engineered for certainty and control. You argue that we live in a time of unprecedented control over all aspects of our daily lives, which has made us unable to tolerate uncertainty. When we do face it, we often experience anxiety, loneliness, boredom, or self-loathing, shame in response. Set the table here. How has the world changed and created, if you will, this level of anxiety? What's changed about the world, if you will.
First of all, we evolved over millions of years of evolution to exert our agency to reduce uncertainty. It's what's allowed us to survive in a chaotic natural environment where famine, flood, fire was, you know, always imminently threatening our survival. We have evolved science and technology to really create an unprecedented amount of control over the natural environment, which you would think would make us all feel much safer. But the paradox here is that the more levers for microcontrol that we have over our lives, the more anxious, fearful, and lonely, I would argue, as well as bored, we've become. And it is a paradox because, again, we are sort of teleologically or biologically evolved to exert agency. It feels good. It's adaptive in a chaotic environment. But now we sort of are experiencing control at the micro level, and also we've created this sort of virtual space where we have engineered a reality that we have an incredible amount of control over. But what I'm seeing is people, more and more people, especially young people, gripped by paralyzing anxiety because they feel like because they have so many choices and so much control that if they make the wrong choice, they're going to miss out on their best lives. Also, a lot of shame that goes along with that when things don't work out perfectly. People feel like they only have themselves to blame. And so there's an incredible amount of self-loathing. Also, sadly, more and more people harming themselves, young people ending their own lives after really quite minor failures, like what a generation ago would have been considered sort of tolerable, like social rejection or an academic reprimand. It becomes intolerable. And of course, the virtual space and the internet makes that worse as our mistakes ricochet around the world, as we see these constant curated images and narratives of these perfect lives. So again, the paradox of control is that we have so many more ways to, quote unquote, optimize that we all feel we should be engineering perfection.
So I want to talk about social media, and that's sort of my go-to for the world's ills, is I immediately look at what social media has done to cause this. But even before that, as a parent, I adopted — I forget — I saw this wonderful movie with Gene Hackman and Ben Stiller where the protagonist, Ben Stiller's wife, passes away and all he thinks about is protecting his kids. And it's a movie from about 20 years ago, and it really struck me because I remember my youngest broke his arm when he was like, I don't know, maybe four or five, and my partner was just so upset and said, 'We need to rearrange the living room.' I'm like, 'We're doing no such thing.' And I remember when I was in elementary school, it was like the outpatient emergency room. There were kids with eye patches. We remember signing casts. That was a thing. Someone always had a cast and we'd sign it. And you don't want them in danger, but you do want them in uncertainty and risk. And I used to leave my mom's house on a Saturday at 9:00 a.m. with a Schwinn bike, an Abba-Zaba bar, and 35 cents. And she wouldn't see me for 12 hours. And in those 12 hours, I faced a lot of uncertainty and even a mild amount of danger, whether it was, you know, roaming stray dogs or, you know, sixth graders who like to beat up second graders. And I think that was good for me. And I find that we inevitably, you know, if my kids are 15 minutes late home from school, we call MI6. And so talk about what, even before they have screens, what parenting — what role parenting, or overparenting, I'll say, plays in all this.
Yeah. So this is hugely relevant. You know, I think many of us — maybe not you, but many of us — are guilty of kind of trying to raise our kids in these padded cells so that they are insulated from any kind of pain or uncertainty, so that we can also reduce our anxiety. And it's in many ways, it's a kind of codependent phenomenon where we are protecting our kids so that we're not experiencing the anxiety about how they might get hurt or fail in some way, you know. And as a result, we are raising a generation of young people that has no tolerance for uncertainty and also no kind of psychological touchstone for resilience, for knowing that they can encounter failure, that they can have a negative experience and it's going to be okay, and they can lift themselves up. And the technology really exacerbates this problem. I mean, the ways in which we can now track our children from infancy, you know, with a device in the other room to make sure that their breathing is okay. And of course, these are natural worries that parents have, but we're now mediating this anxiety through these devices, which only make it worse because they play into our sort of obsessive-compulsive loops of wanting constant reassurance. And one thing we know about OCD is that the more we look for and get reassurance, the more OCD or anxious we become. It's kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy. So yeah, it's really — and we see that at the university level. I mean, here at Stanford, we see, you know, these wonderful young people who have enormous gifts and talents and promise for the future, but like any bit of uncertainty or even the hint of imperfection just sends them reeling. It's like there's no ballast to hold all that.
One of the reasons I love speaking to you is I feel like I get free therapy from the most qualified person in the world. So, back to me and my kids. I worry, or what I see — I want to see if you see this path that I see, and that is people think I would have had technology figured out in our home. I wrote a book warning the world about technology in 2017, and the cobbler's kids have no shoes here. No shoes. My kids are, especially my youngest, device-addicted. Will, you know, fib, take TikTok into the bathroom. You know, just we're literally — we've just screwed it all up. Anyway, what I see is constant action, reaction, dopamine, action, reaction, stimulus, AI, a million times a second with content to just keep them glued and the dopamine flowing. And what I worry about — I mean, I used to come home and watch five hours of cartoons for, I guess, a milder shot of dopamine, or occasionally sneak into my dad's garage to get a peek at a Playboy for, you know, another dopamine hit, right? Something, right? And what I see though is now that they have the IV connected to them six hours a day and that constant cycle of dopamine, and then you take the device away. That was the first time I've ever seen addiction up close. The lying, the negotiating, the outbursts, the inability to emotionally regulate. It's like, oh, I'm living with an addict. I mean, this is just what an addict acts like. Is all of this — are social media, are the largest companies in the world basically creating the mother of all on-ramps to addiction to other things later in life?
Short answer, yes. That is exactly what is happening. These platforms are not just powerful tools; they're also very potent drugs. And one of the main reasons that they're so potent, and so much more potent, let's say, than TV, you know, which people try to analogize to and say, 'Oh, people said TV was the idiot box.' This is a totally different level, in large part because of our ability to microcontrol what we're consuming. So, a huge part of addiction — people think that addiction is trying to escape control. Addiction is all about control, trying to assert control over our micro-experience to change the way we feel. And there's no more immediate way to do that than to swipe right, swipe left, scroll up, scroll down, tap, and it goes right to our visual cortex, which goes right to our brain's reward pathway, releasing dopamine in the nucleus accumbens, the same reward pathway that's activated by drugs and alcohol. And you're absolutely right. When kids — people in general, but especially we see this clinically with kids addicted to all forms of digital media — when we take the device away, they go into full-on withdrawal. The universal symptoms of withdrawal from any addictive substance or behavior are anxiety, irritability, insomnia, depression, and craving. But we also see physiologic or physical symptoms of withdrawal: headache, you know, dizziness, stomach aches, and many of these kids have sort of these rageful temper tantrums, flinging themselves against the wall or on the floor. But the thing is, it's all time-limited. For the most part, if you can create a safe container for these kids, within a couple of days they'll begin to emerge. And what so many families and parents report is like, 'Oh my gosh, I got my kid back. This person is sort of the person I recognize. They're socialized. They come and talk to us. They're helping with chores in the house.' And I think this is a really important piece of it. Like, part of addiction is creating personality disorders and sociopathy. I mean, that's sort of inherent. So you talk about the lying — you know, the lying habit is key to any addiction. So, you know, we really change our personalities when we are addicted, and when we get into recovery and emerge from that, we restore our sanity, we return to the people that we are, and we see this all the time in kids. The other thing I would say is there is a growing body of evidence showing that if you take emotionally distressed youth and you reduce their time on social media to one hour a day, and you objectively measure that — so you're tracking what they're doing — and you compare that to a control group of youth where you don't change their social media consumption, what you see in the group that reduces social media use to no more than one hour a day is decreases in depression, decreases in anxiety, improvements in sleep — because sleep is a huge part of this and mediates a lot of the emotional distress — improvements in loneliness and FOMO, fear of missing out. So yeah, this is a huge and real issue. And again, the technology is not going away. We all know that you can't put the genie back in the bottle. But we have got to establish a healthier relationship with the technology, and we can't really leave it to parents alone. It's just too hard. You know, schools have to come on board. The companies that make and profit from these digital devices and digital media have to come on board. Which is why the Meta suit, or the Meta settlement recently, was so landmark, because it didn't just involve billions of dollars, you know, in sort of retributed payment, but also it involved product design for teen Instagram, which I think is really momentous. We'll see if it happens and if it helps, but I think it's an important step forward.
Support for the show comes from Engine. When 1.6 trillion moves through travel every year, it's a shock to remember that most of it still runs on tech from the 80s. I mean, work travel works fine, but it certainly isn't all that intelligent. That's why businesses and travelers book directly through Engine. Engine closes the gap between wanting to be somewhere and actually being there. Developers, expense tools, and AI agents all plug into Engine's API. And as AI spreads, Engine only becomes more valuable. Every AI agent that wants to book travel needs real supply, real pricing, and real payments. With 40,000 businesses relying on Engine and growing fast, they're powering travel for the masses with partnerships like Navan and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Strong hotel partnerships, proprietary supply, real-time rate shopping, and payment rails. That's the kind of foundation that takes years to build — eight years in Engine's case — and it can't be bought. The future of business travel runs on Engine. Visit engine.com/propg.
Support for the show comes from Framer. Picture this: you launch a website and your whole team's celebrating. Then the support tickets start to roll in and put a damper on the mood. That's when you could use a website platform that lets teams build, ship, and improve their sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. For that, you could use Framer. It's a complete website platform, not just a builder, so teams can launch and keep improving their sites in one place. Framer lets you prompt, inspect, edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. On Framer, AI agents and humans work in tandem. Agents bring speed and scale, while people bring taste, judgment, and control. And that all takes place in the same workspace where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. Framer is an enterprise-level solution that the world's leading brands, including Perplexity and Miro, rely on to build their websites. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist, or get started building for free today at framer.com/provg for 30% off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com/provg. Rules and restrictions may apply.
Support for the show comes from SoFi. Here's the thing: most traditional banks pay almost nothing in interest, so your money ends up just sitting there twiddling its thumbs doing nothing. And if your money is doing nothing, it's not doing its job. You work hard for every dollar, so why not put those dollars to work for you? That's where SoFi comes in, with the Everything app for smarter money. With SoFi Checking and Savings, you can easily track your spending and save towards your goals while earning nine times the national average savings rate. You'll get paid up to two days early with direct deposit, and you can access additional FDIC insurance up to three million dollars on your deposits through a network of participating banks. You'll pay no account or overdraft fees, and you can also earn a cash bonus when you sign up with eligible direct deposit. You also can organize your savings into vaults for the goals that matter most. Small decisions like this can create big momentum over time. You can open your SoFi checking and savings account today. Head to sofi.com/provgank to get started. That's sofi.com/proofgbank. SoFi Checking and Savings is offered through SoFi Bank, N.A., member FDIC.
I do want to get to your work, but I think of you as one of the foremost authorities on the very broad topic of addiction. And I've said that people say we're an attention economy. I don't think that's true. I think we're an addiction economy. I think we have figured out a way to tap into — my sense, and I want you to correct me here or edit me — that addiction stems from a healthy place of our instincts. There's a scarcity of salty, sugary, fatty foods. So when we have it in front of us because of industrial production, we gorge. An absence of free, safe play. So when we have free, safe play on our phone, we get addicted to gambling. An absence of mating opportunities. So if something resembling or a reasonable facsimile of a mating opportunity, and there's industrial production of it, we get addicted to porn. Help us understand when an addiction is forming. And also, my other thesis is everyone has addictions. It's just what it is. Is it online shopping? Is it codependency? Is it addiction to food? Is it addiction to affirmation of others? Is it an addiction to money? What is it, right? Everybody has a certain amount of it. If you see a kid or a teen, and you could really sit them down and say, 'This is how you recognize what flavor of addiction you are going to develop,' and quite frankly, how to modulate it. I have addictions and I know it. I'm able to recognize them and I think modulate them. Recognizing I engage in this too much, this is not good for my life, I continue to engage in it too much — to me is a pretty decent definition of addiction, but I recognize it and I'm able to modulate it. Take us back to: if you're a parent, where do you notice kids are beginning to develop, or even in yourself as a young adult, some type of addiction? And I think part of the problem is we treat it like a monster and we put it in a closet and we all try and ignore it, not recognizing we're all guilty of some sort of addiction, at least I believe. So take me to: you're a parent. When can you recognize certain addictive tendencies, and how do you start to, if you will, educate a kid around modulation?
Great. Yeah. I mean, I agree with everything that you just said. I think addiction is the modern plague. It's going to be the major problem that humans face in the foreseeable future because we have created this world of overwhelming abundance and also drugified almost everything that we do and consume by making it more potently reinforcing, more accessible, more novel, more bountiful. Parents need to understand, number one, that digital media are inherently reinforcing and therefore potentially addictive. Moving videos are drugs. Moving videos are drugs, okay? It doesn't mean that we should never watch them ever, but they are so potently reinforcing, especially in their short form. But our brains evolved to fixate onto moving images, especially moving images of other humans and other living organisms, and that has become a drug. Quantity and frequency matter. So although we don't base our diagnosis of addiction on quantity and frequency for any substance, it's not that quantity and frequency is irrelevant. It's highly relevant. The more people use, the more they change their brains, the more likely they are to get addicted. Addiction is a brain disease characterized by the continued compulsive use of a substance or behavior despite harm to self and/or others. What do we look for? Out-of-control use, compulsive use, continued use despite consequences. We also look for tolerance, needing more of that drug over time to get the same effect, and also withdrawal, a physiologic negative response when we stop using. What does that look like in kids? Number one, that looks like a kid who is constantly, compulsively seeking more time online. That looks like a kid who, once they're engaged, is totally transported and entranced. That looks like a kid who, when they get off, plunges into an acute withdrawal phenomenon where they're highly emotionally dysregulated. Why? They're in withdrawal. That looks like a kid who has lost joy in other things that used to give them pleasure: in reading, in playing outside, playing with friends in real life, spending time with family, playing with a pet. That looks like a kid who's narrowed their focus where this one thing is the only thing they want to do. Other things become less salient. And that looks like a kid who lies. So, you know, kids to some extent are going to experiment with lying as they play around with language and try to figure out, you know, what are the boundaries of what language can communicate and not communicate. And, you know, but really, one of the unspoken and sort of not in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, but a key feature of addiction is lying about use, but also developing the lying habit more broadly — just lying about other stuff because lying becomes the sort of modus operandi. I think you're right. This whole monster in the closet, not talking about it, terrified to name it, only makes it worse. One of the very first recommendations I make for families is not to immediately take the devices away, but to immediately sit down and talk openly about the problem. And I really encourage parents to be transparent about their own addictive patterns, you know, to say to their kids, 'Hey, you're not the only one. I'm also struggling with, you know, consuming X, Y, or Z,' and to really be open about, like, it's a — we're all struggling, right? And it's difficult for all of us, but let's acknowledge the ways in which our individual lives and our family life has become impoverished because of the ways that we're all in our separate rooms on our separate devices consuming our separate digital media.
In addition to addiction to actual social media itself, how has this constant dopamine economy — what addictions has that increased or, quite frankly, decreased? I see that alcohol consumption is down. I think it's because people are at home because they think a cheaper and easier and lower-risk means of getting dopamine doesn't involve going out and drinking alcohol. So I would imagine alcohol addiction has gone down among teens because of social media. How has social media impacted other addictions distinct of social media itself?
Well, you're absolutely right. Alcohol consumption is going down broadly across the United States. I like to think that's at least in some part due to increased awareness about the harms of alcohol, but I think you're absolutely right. Some of this is just trading addictions or compulsive, sort of, you know, addictive tendencies to our devices, to digital media, to the internet. Some of the fastest-rising addictions — and the numbers are very hard to get on this because the people who have them don't disclose them and they're otherwise also just hard to get — are addiction to pornography and compulsive masturbation, addiction to online gambling, especially sports betting, addiction — we've talked about social media — gaming in all its various forms, massive uptick in addictions to online shopping and sort of consumptive behaviors more broadly. So those are really leading the charge. There are gender differences here as well, where we have more women getting addicted to social media and online shopping, more men to pornography and sports betting. But, you know, we have plenty of men and women in those opposite categories. So yeah, the landscape of sort of teenage rebellion has really changed. You know, the teenage rebel used to be the kid that went out and like disappeared in the world and, yeah, drank, maybe used drugs, experimented with drugs. Now, you could almost say that the teenage rebel today doesn't leave their room, doesn't get off their devices, doesn't speak to their parents, you know, has gone virtually mute, is absolutely refusing to participate in any aspect of life. In Japan, they have a name for this, hikikomori, which is kids who just literally disappear inside their rooms and behind their screens.
I literally think there's millions of young men that we don't see that are living with their parents in their basement, leaving, you know, quiet lives. You know, that saying about millions of men live quiet lives of desperation. I think there's millions of young men living quiet lives of isolation, and we just don't see them. And it's not even that they're criminals or that they're joining the Taliban or that they're — they're not necessarily inherently bad people. They've just disappeared. They're just invisible to the world, invisible to themselves, and they wake up in their late 20s and they don't have — maybe they're overweight, they're anxious, they're fearful, and they've never learned the skills to have friends, mentors, mates, get into an office, figure out how to get along with others. You know, they just kind of become almost unsavable. Do you think there's a role — this comment is pregnant with a question. So, or this question is pregnant with a comment. So, I'll just make the comment. I would like to see — and maybe they have this in junior and senior years in high school, I think it's got to start pretty early — something resembling what I'll call an adulting curriculum, just very open and honest conversations around — I remember taking Psych 10 at UCLA and it changed my life because I'm like, 'Oh, wait. Insecurity is a thing. I'm not the only person that feels impostor syndrome and doesn't —' and I mean, all of these neuroses I learned about, I'm like, 'Wait, that's an actual thing other people had? I thought it was just me.' And it was so helpful, and I wish that at an earlier stage — I mean, things like, what is the interest rate on a credit card? I lived alone with my mom. Like, I wish someone had kind of dialed me in as a young man into this thing called menopause and what your mom might be going through. Do you think if you — and I imagine you are asked to consult to different lawmakers, the governor, Governor Newsom calls you and says, 'How do we better prevent bad behaviors in high school? Is it education? Is it coursework?' Like, what if you could have influence over the curriculum of all the public schools in California, what would that influence look like?
Yeah. Wow. Great question. So, first, just going back to some of your earlier commentary about how men have disappeared — the statistics bear this out. Men are not entering — men and young men of all ages are not entering the job market. So, we have a ballooning number of young men who are not working. And the data suggests that it's because they're at home, you know, playing video games and on social media. So they're literally not engaging, you know, with their milestones at their various ages. In terms of how to change the curriculum, I would recommend three things. Number one, I would teach young people about the neuroscience of pleasure and pain, and about how as we continue to bombard our reward pathway with highly reinforcing substances and behaviors, we don't get more pleasure, we get the opposite. We change our hedonic or joy set point, and we actually tilt our mood and our baseline capacity for pleasure to the side of pain, such that we need more and more over time — more and more of our drug of choice to get any pleasure at all. And when we're not using, you know, we're in misery, we need to use just to feel normal. I think this is really key for young people to understand that what feels good or pleasurable or reduces anxiety or depression or insomnia in the moment actually probably makes that worse in the long run because our brains will immediately adapt to that surge of dopamine. So I think that's really important. Number two, embodied anything. So way more curriculum that involves using our bodies, using our hands, doing real things in the real world. So this is for — and, you know, a lot of people have talked about this, but I really think this is important. Lots of options for sports, for engagement in sports. They actually did this experiment in Iceland. It was called — you know, they had a growing youth drug and alcohol problem.