CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Anna Lembke
Professor of Psychiatry; Medical Director, Stanford Addiction Medicine, Stanford University

Stanford Psychiatrist: The More You Try To Control Your Life, The More Miserable You Become

📅 Nov 10, 2026 Freedom Pact | Joseph & Lewis 70 MIN 536 VIEWS 81 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Dr Anna Lembke is a Professor of Psychiatry at Stanford University School of Medicine, Medical Director of Stanford Addiction Medicine, and Chief of the Stanford Addiction Medicine Dual Diagnosis Clinic. Dr Lembke is an internationally recognised expert on addiction, she is the bestselling author of Dopamine Nation - Finding Balance in the Age of Indulgence, which explores the neuroscience of pleasure, pain and compulsive consumption. Her clinical and academic work examines how our pursuit of pleasure, control and certainty can paradoxically contribute to psychological suffering, and what we c...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:06Why is it so difficult for humans to, I guess, accept that we're not ultimately in control?
  2. 2:11What do you think it is?
  3. 6:05Do you think that in terms of control, how we manage our experiences, that this is a unique time in human history for this to be really relevant now as opposed to a thousand years ago or 2,000 years ago or whatever?
  4. 9:08What is there about perhaps mystery that could be such an antidote in these times?
  5. 14:42Do you think that for instance that sort of narcissism can in some ways kind of protect a sort of almost a fragile sense of self?
  6. 18:41And I was thinking as I was reading this in your book, you know, going back to for instance Carl Rogers where he talked about the costs of making self-worth conditional, right?
  7. 36:26Is there something about the kind of concept that you think might be helpful?
  8. 43:07How much of a life do you think we lose by spending it geared towards avoidance as opposed to perhaps allowing life to hurt us in some way?
  9. 46:01I chatted with Steven Hayes, the founder of acceptance and commitment therapy, right?
  10. 50:27Is it possible that surrender paradoxically could become another sort of control mechanism by itself? Is that at all possible?
  11. 53:02Do you think that there's some kind of mechanism or something going on there that drives it?
  12. 59:06Why perhaps is it then that it's so difficult, especially, you know, when you're appearing — what does, I guess, wiggle room but practically look like in a romantic relationship or as parents?
Interviewer 0:00 ↗
Dr. Lembke, what a pleasure. Welcome back to the show.
Anna Lembke 0:03 ↗
Yeah, thanks for having me back. I'm so excited to be here.
Interviewer 0:06 ↗
Why is it so difficult for humans to, I guess, accept that we're not ultimately in control?
Anna Lembke 0:17 ↗
Yeah, it's a great question. I really think it's best answered through evolutionary psychology. So we evolved in a world of incredible uncertainty. Right? At any moment we could die. Fire, famine, flood, you name it. The average human lived to about age 30 until approximately 200 years ago or so when we started to then have increased longevity. So we lived in an uncertain world. And part of our ability to do that, to survive an uncertain and chaotic environment, was that we evolved to reduce uncertainty. Right? Our minds are these prediction machines. We have a model of the world. We are predicting what can happen next. When we get that right, that feels good. And we keep going and preserve our model. When we get that wrong, that feels bad. And we sort of update these mental models. So in other words, we're teleologically mandated to try to exert control. It is just, it feels good. It releases dopamine. And when we're not in control and when things are uncertain and we don't know where things are going, that causes enormous survival distress. So that's really the sort of the biological mechanism behind it.
What's interesting is that we have reshaped the world to fit our minds, right? Because we like things to be ordered and controlled and predictable. You know, as Joni Mitchell said, we've paved paradise and put up a parking lot. We've, you know, humans have reached sort of a peak, an incredible peak of our ability to exert our will over material reality to create, at least on a micro level, a highly controlled environment.
Interviewer 2:11 ↗
I was going through the book, I was thinking if I was to walk down the street, I mean, most of us would never admit to being controlling, you know, but we rehearse conversations, we worry about loved ones, we try to plan our way out of uncertainty. What is it ultimately that we're trying to protect ourselves from? Is it the uncertainty that obviously you mentioned? Is it pain, guilt, perhaps the possibility that our efforts might not be enough? What do you think it is?
Anna Lembke 2:46 ↗
I think it's primarily uncertainty. I mean, your example of the way that we rehearse conversations, many of us unconsciously, we sort of fall into these sort of ruminations or rehearsed conversations. We are really just trying to manage and predict. And again, I think it's a fundamental survival reflex. We have to think about doing otherwise. And yeah, I think it, you know, it's a sort of innate protection against imminent danger, threat, death even, right? Because to be helpless is really to be on the brink of potentially dying, which every fiber in our body resists.
Interviewer 3:31 ↗
I'm curious, how did your thinking then evolve from Dopamine Nation to Radical Surrender? And was there kind of like a psychological mechanism that sort of connects the two?
Anna Lembke 3:44 ↗
Yeah, they're very much related. So, in Dopamine Nation, I was originally going to have a chapter on surrender and its role in recovery from addiction because it's key for so many people with severe addiction. But I ultimately felt I couldn't do it justice. So I ended up cutting it and then later it became, you know, this new book, Radical Surrender. You know, one of the things that many people don't understand or appreciate about addiction is that at the end of the day, whatever our drug of choice is, addiction is really about control.
It's about exerting our will in the moment to predictably change the way that we feel. And even people who get to the point where their brains have adapted to their drug of choice such that they don't even get pleasure from it anymore will still continue to engage with that drug because of the control piece. As a patient of mine who got addicted to slot machines said, 'At least I'm controlling my own misery.' And that's what addiction is. We create a tiny little world within the chaotic, uncertain reality that we humans exist in. And within this tiny world, we are gods, right? We can do our little ritual and it will lead in that moment to a change in our felt experience, and ironically kind of also a sense of merging with a power greater than ourselves, which is also, by the way, a strong need and an urge. It's not just that we want to exert control. We also need a vast, uncertain, unknowable force that we're trying to exert control over. Those two things have to coexist.
And you know, you're absolutely right. Dopamine Nation explores all of the ways in which we have now to sort of escape reality, distract ourselves, get addicted, you know, ping our reward pathway. But what makes so many of these modern drugs so incredibly reinforcing is again our ability to use them to control our micro experience even as our macro experience, that is to say, our real lives are going to hell in a handbasket.
Interviewer 6:05 ↗
Do you think that in terms of control, how we manage our experiences, that this is a unique time in human history for this to be really relevant now as opposed to a thousand years ago or 2,000 years ago or whatever?
Anna Lembke 6:23 ↗
Absolutely. And I think a lot of the ways that we suffer now are uniquely modern and unprecedented, and as I explore, you know, in this new book, have to do with all of the levers that we have to press in order to exert our control on the environment such that we have become the ultimate optimizers. We're relationship maxing, career maxing, looks maxing. We're counting our steps and our sleep and our calories and our accomplishments, each other. And you would think with all of this, you know, ability to exert control over ourselves, other people, our experience, we would feel safer and happier. But in fact, the opposite has happened. People are more anxious than ever before. They're more ashamed and self-loathing. They're lonelier, and they're also more bored because in this engineered environment, we are lacking the organic uncertainty that makes us feel alive. So what are we doing? We're now engineering uncertainty in the form of online gambling, gambling, slot machines, social media. But it's all this kind of recursive loop.
And what I'm seeing in clinical care, sadly, is, you know, more and more young people coming in with paralyzing anxiety because they believe that they should be able to control their destiny, that they have infinite flexibility, that they can become whatever they want to become, and as a result, they live in dread of making the wrong choice and missing out on their best lives. So this sort of notion of, very modern notion of infinite flexibility then morphs into the dread of unmet potential. Likewise when life doesn't go according to plan, you know, we have no tolerance for uncertainty and there's also self-loathing shame that we didn't, you know, that we're not perfect. And that manifests with more and more young people actually ending their own lives in response to what a generation ago would have been a tolerable disappointment, a social rejection, you know, an academic reprimand. People are now, you know, young people, they just can't tolerate that they made a mistake, that they're imperfect, that they're not controlling their experience. And of course with social media, our mistakes ricochet all around the world. We're exposed to all these curated images that make us think everybody else's life is so much better than ours. So it's really a kind of a uniquely modern problem, this intolerance for uncertainty, this belief in ultimate control over our destiny which we obviously don't have.
Interviewer 9:08 ↗
You wrote in the book that the path forward is not more mastery but rather a return to mystery. What prompted you to write that? What is there about perhaps mystery that could be such an antidote in these times?
Anna Lembke 9:28 ↗
I see so much nihilistic boredom. People who feel like they're not real. The world's not real. We're living in a simulation. Life has no meaning and no purpose. Everything is sort of leeched of its vitality. And what gives things vitality is mystery and uncertainty, right? I mean, as much as we try to escape surprise and uncertainty, we crave it and we need it. You know, when you look at the avidness with which people follow their sports teams, it makes total sense to me because sports may be the last place where we can't actually predict and control what's going to happen, right? We give ourselves over to the mystery of fate, destiny, you know, whatever you want to call it. And it is so revitalizing and it makes us feel connected. Now, of course we've adulterated that too with online sports betting and all of that, you know, the cults of social media, but nonetheless, it's emblematic of a very deep need of ours, which is to connect to a power greater than ourselves, however we define that, to connect with the sort of enchanted vitality, uncertainty, and mystery of life.
Interviewer 10:51 ↗
And if you were to perhaps give a, you know, this sounds very Dopamine Nation-esque, but if you were to I guess give a perhaps an elevator pitch, someone's listening and says that that really resonates with me, you know, but I'm wondering perhaps what the benefits were if I was to radically surrender or to really embrace more uncertainty in my life. How would you sort of describe the potential upside of that?
Anna Lembke 11:26 ↗
First of all, when we really radically surrender to the things that we cannot control, most of us experience relief and a felt serenity. There's a sort of immediate sense of, oh, thank goodness, I don't have to try to manage this unmanageable thing. Now, there's enormous resistance to accepting that we can't control these things or even acknowledging that we're trying to, but when we actually stop trying to juggle 5,000 balls in the air and just let them drop, there is paradoxically an immediate sense of release. And there's neuroscience to suggest that this may actually work through an opponent process mechanism whereby when we quiet our control centers in the brain, we actually activate these spirituality or surrender networks that are rich in oxytocin, rich in mu-opioid receptors, rich in serotonin. And these are, you know, sort of this kind of feel-good neurotransmitters that give pain relief, a sense of connection, and also a sense of openness and neuroplasticity that allow us to have a new perceptual experience, which is so important because as we're constantly trying to like fortify our existing mental models of the world, we're not open to perceiving what is actually happening. So that felt experience alone is worth it.
But the other benefit is there's just so many benefits to like going out and just seeing what's out there and connecting with new people and, you know, making sort of real relationships in the real world. It absolutely enhances professional life. You know, you have so many young people who are like trying to strategize for their careers and they're not seeing the next good right thing in front of them that's calling them and they could just do that, but they're so busy future-tripping that they're missing out on sort of what's calling them right here and right now. And when we engage with what's actually calling us, like our careers blossom. I know that certainly happened with me, you know, when I stopped trying to like figure out how I was going to become professor and what grant I could get to do that and I just like, you know what, I have a bunch of addicted people that need my help. Like my whole relationship with work changed. My whole career took off in ways I never would have predicted or was even aiming for in a way. I just kind of gave up. I was like, 'Okay, forget it. I'm just going to do this work and who cares what happens with the career,' and then my career blossomed.
Again, with relationships, you know, trying to control other people, it feels like we're doing good, but often we're enabling, we're intruding, they can sense our need for them to be a certain way. When we just surrender and let them have their own unfolding experience, it's fascinating. But it creates somehow this space in which we can be more truly connected when we're not trying to force it.
Interviewer 14:42 ↗
Seems to be, you know, an idea in the book that you talk about where striving can almost become a prison of itself. You talk in this book about this sort of narcissism which is not necessarily in a clinical sense but sort of has arisen as a result of, you know, different cultural mechanisms and the way in which we sort of inhabit this world at the moment. This sort of way that we demand that life sort of conforms to our own expectations. Do you think that for instance that sort of narcissism can in some ways kind of protect a sort of almost a fragile sense of self? Because one of the things that I was thinking about at least in my own life is that, you know, any success that I've had it sort of feels briefly exhilarating and then generally empty following it. You know, I'm just curious your thoughts there.
Anna Lembke 15:44 ↗
Oh yeah, absolutely. I mean, we're really living in a time of endemic narcissism, which is to say that we're all forced to be narcissists now as a matter of survival. We have a culture that from very early childhood reinforces accomplishments, reputation enhancement, success, achievement. You know, parents measure their own worth as parents by whether or not their kids got into the right school, married the right person, got the right job. You know, your experience of sort of finding that you'll have these accomplishments and then for maybe a nanosecond it'll feel great and then it'll be empty and you'll be right back, you know, left where you were. And certainly, as you know, I write about that myself, how really my drug of choice was control and outward accomplishments.
And the problem with that is really that we did not evolve to distinguish ourselves as separate from the tribe. We are our best selves and also our happiest selves when we are in community. And yet we have evolved a culture that tells us to constantly strive and distinguish ourselves. And I believe that the natural homeostatic ballast or counter mechanism to that individual striving is actually shame because shame is the emotion that forces us to come back to the tribe. So what I think move in tandem are both striving and sort of this endemic narcissism, move in tandem with self-loathing shame, and that you really don't get one without the other.
So not only often for people after a big accomplishment is there an emptiness, there's often, if sometimes outside of conscious awareness, there's often a kind of a self-loathing shame. Now, sometimes it'll manifest as like, oh, will I be able to top that next time or even do that next time? But mostly it's just kind of an amorphous shame that I really think is the reflexive response to these individual achievements, which our evolutionary model has recognized is ultimately not good for us, even though that's absolutely what our culture emphasizes. So, and that's important to understand because what it means is that all this striving for individual achievement is actually wrongheaded. It doesn't get us to where we want to go. In fact, it gets us further and further away from where we want to be. And instead, what we need to do, and you know, this is sort of clichéd, but it's absolutely true, you know, be of service to the community.
Interviewer 18:41 ↗
I interviewed the psychiatrist George Bonanno recently and he talked about the tragedy of why we're wired to pursue things like professional goals that often don't make us happy. And I was thinking as I was reading this in your book, you know, going back to for instance Carl Rogers where he talked about the costs of making self-worth conditional, right? And I'm curious why do we do that, you know, what is it about perhaps, you know, the way we've evolved or the way in which much society is set up that we perhaps, I guess maybe to Bonanno's point, why we pursue things that are perhaps antithetical to our own psychological well-being.
Anna Lembke 19:29 ↗
I would argue we've almost been too successful at a basic survival necessity. I mean, we need to strive in order to survive. And that's just fundamental, but we have reached a tipping point where now through the application of science and technology we are now striving for the wrong things. Right? We have sort of the object of our striving is tickling that basic reflexive mechanism and it feels good, you know, to achieve and to assert our control and to dominate, you know, our environment, but it's now detached from what is actually happening in the world and in our lives. So a little bit like, you know, the ideas in Dopamine Nation, we are sort of self-titillating, you know, an ancient brain mechanism, but that mechanism has become misdirected and not focused on a worthy object.
We're sort of like in this loop of prediction, action, self-titillation disconnected from what's actually happening in the world. For example, what's actually happening with our environment, right? And the way that our dominance over material reality is destroying our environment, what's actually happening with our communal sense of communal living, which is rapidly eroding, people living by themselves, people not connected, people relying on AI, chatbots to kind of make themselves feel connection and love, which is a simulation of the real thing. So, I think we need to recognize that this tipping point has come to pass and to begin to, you know, really acknowledge the damage that we're doing.
Interviewer 21:30 ↗
And I could imagine perhaps at this point someone listening at home that might say, you know, I completely get your argument. I understand for instance, you know, that perhaps I've become addicted to control, that I feel this constant pressure to be perfect and to not make any mistakes, and this seems like a relief that as you described that can come from letting go. I'm curious how we balance that with, you know, for instance the history of psychology where people like, you know, for instance Bandura, Albert Bandura talked about, you know, the benefit of having an influence over life or Martin Seligman talking about the costs of learned helplessness, you know, and what can I guess happen if we're perhaps too powerless in a situation. I'm curious how they sort of fit into your view and I guess kind of the ideas that you talked about in Radical Surrender.
Anna Lembke 22:38 ↗
Great question. You know what I argue is that the surrendered life is not actually a passive life. In many ways, it is a call to moral action. When we let go of the things that we cannot control, we must then acknowledge the things that we can control. And there are many, many things that we can control. And then we need to engage with those things. Which is why one of the most important things I tell my patients who are in the throes of feelings of helpless despair, and also what I tell myself in the throes of feelings of helpless despair, is to do the next right thing. And what's really key in that phrase is not just the doing part, like we are asking folks to take action, but also this really drilling it down to the next right thing.
Really look around and see what are the things that I know I can do right now and let the rest of it just fall away. So, you know, in the throes of helpless despair or even just everyday mundanity, like, okay, I can get up and make my bed and I can try to exercise and eat breakfast and brush my teeth and then I can, you know, what else do I need to do around the house to help other people or to help the family or help the household? So, what are the little day-to-day immediate actions? Because I believe that positive change in the world occurs through the concatenation or stringing together of a lot of people's small good actions.
I think often when we look at history or even when we look forward and think about politics, we think it's one person who is going to, you know, make the world change. And you know, maybe there's some degree of that, but often that person doesn't even come into power unless we make these smaller actions in our lives to give that person power. So it's really these day-to-day small actions over many, many people that makes, you know, transforms the world. And so our small actions really, really matter. They're everything. And so this call to action is really a key part of the surrendered life.
Interviewer 25:03 ↗
I guess what you're describing, it sounds very different to something like resignation, which sounds so much more passive. You know, you think of perhaps war metaphors of raising a kind of a white flag. So you're saying that surrender has a much more kind of like an active component to it.
Anna Lembke 25:26 ↗
Absolutely. In fact, when we get in our heads and are continually trying to control other people and the world, we are denying what is actually happening, right? We're trying to impose our will on the world and sort of strengthen our mental models. And as a result, our model of the world gets more and more distant from reality and what is really happening. The surrendered life is not at all a life of passive resignation. It is opening our mind to what is really happening and then taking action to affect positive change at a realistic scale where we can actually do that, and that gives life a lot of meaningful purpose.
Interviewer 26:13 ↗
The therapeutic action, if I sort of understand it, it would be something like stop controlling, or act where the action helps, and release the demand for guaranteed results.
Anna Lembke 26:31 ↗
Yeah. I mean, so very, very process-based. You're right. It's like, first of all, it's stop, first of all become aware that we are trying to control things that we have no business trying to control, like other people, some future, you know, outcome that no human could control, like drop, let it go, you know, become aware that we're trying to control, let it go, accept the limits of our control, and then really have a trust and a faith that by controlling the things that we can control and choosing, you know, choosing the right thing, choosing to be of service, choosing to try to choose the moral good, we can exert our agency but not get a reward in the short term. Right? So, it's then really trusting again that through these small actions at some future date, the reward will come. So in many ways, you know, it is a selfish, it's a selfish program because the idea is we still all want to feel better, you know, and to feel happier and more serenity in our lives, and we can get there through this kind of trust and faith that these small actions will lead us to that place.
Interviewer 27:50 ↗
And it's such an interesting concept, isn't it? Because I guess, you know, to the point you were making earlier, we can now communicate across continents. We've got AI models that can write 20,000 lines of code in a day. I mean, I look at some of the amazing work coming from places like Stanford, yourself, Karl Deisseroth, etc., doing all these amazing things and you go, 'Wow, you know, this is, things can happen. Incredible things are happening.' And that belief, it sounds like, can lead us to do great things and it can also lead us to really despair at the same time. It sounds like it can do both things depending on the context.
Anna Lembke 28:31 ↗
Just because we can do something doesn't mean we should do something. So just because we can make an army of dancing robots doesn't mean that we should be doing that. Do you know what I mean? Like there are a lot of other endeavors that we could be investing our great scientific minds to try to accomplish. I think that that's really the key there. It's like, yes, we could, you know, apply technology and make that happen, but really should we? Like, does that make sense? And I, so I just think really being much more thoughtful and also kind of again not getting caught up in our own version of reality and then trying to impose that on other people in the world.
Interviewer 29:17 ↗
Before I ask this next question, I just want to say in advance, if you don't want to answer this, absolutely fine. We can pretend it never happened.
Anna Lembke 29:25 ↗
No, that's okay.
Interviewer 29:26 ↗
Cut it out. But in, of course, in the book you talk about your own grief. Again, I preface this, if you, that's absolutely fine. We can cut it out and move on.
Anna Lembke 29:37 ↗
No, no, it's okay. I mean, I wrote about it. Yeah. Yeah.

30 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lembke, A. (2026, November 10). Stanford Psychiatrist: The More You Try To Control Your Life, The More Miserable You Become [Interview transcript]. Freedom Pact | Joseph & Lewis. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3253597/

MLA

Anna Lembke. "Stanford Psychiatrist: The More You Try To Control Your Life, The More Miserable You Become." Freedom Pact | Joseph & Lewis, 10 Nov. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3253597/.

BibTeX
@misc{lembke2026_3253597,
  author       = {Anna Lembke},
  title        = {Stanford Psychiatrist: The More You Try To Control Your Life, The More Miserable You Become},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Freedom Pact | Joseph \& Lewis. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {nov},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3253597/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}