We think we should be able to control everything. We feel that we are the only arbiters of our destiny, such that when we encounter a situation that we can't control — disease, death, unrequited love, a job we didn't get no matter how hard we tried. When I knew he was going to die imminently, I stopped holding him and I told him to increase the morphine so that it would speed up the process of his dying.
When you tried to outrun pain, it consumes you, so you sought control. But that control was never tangible for you.
I'm actually not going to be able to outrun this. I'm going to have to live with this for the rest of my life. We've all become narcissists as a matter of survival. We live in a culture of endemic narcissism — career maxing, relationship maxing, looks maxing. It is contributing massively to our suffering because, of course, that kind of self-focus is exactly the opposite of a spiritual and surrendered life where we really find serenity and connection and all the things that we need to flourish. I need something more. There has to be some kind of sacred ballast, some deeper meaning. What is this all about? It can't possibly just be all about getting more of what I want and more money and more toys. Surely there has to be something else there. We experienced a profound crisis of the will. Connecting on that deep and intimate level is...
Dr. Anna Lembke, thank you so much for being here again for the Chung Hung Institute podcast. Anna, when I read your book, Radical Surrender, I just could not stop crying. I mean, the first paragraph, I'm in tears. I'm in a parking lot of a grocery store and I end up going into the grocery store, literally tears pouring down my face. So I feel just amazed how you just connected many dimensions, your phenomenological lens — something I need to study at some point.
Well, thank you, number one, for taking the time to read the book. Number two, I mean, I'm sad I made you cry, but I'm gratified that you connected affectively and emotionally with the content. That's my hope. That's the space in which I feel like I'm most alive and also learn the most is in that realm of emotional or affective connections.
And it was a good kind of cry, I got to say. I'm not a crier, so afterward I was like, this is actually healing, so everyone should — if you want to heal, you should read this. I felt like I was a fly on the wall this entire time I'm reading. I feel like, did I just walk into your therapy session and you were the client, and then sometimes you were the therapist? And it just felt so intimate. I think this is a world that most scientists and most clinicians don't dare to allow people to enter. So Anna, I'm curious, when you talk about, let's say, your experience of outrunning pain and suicidal ideation, you said that when you try to outrun pain it consumes you and so you sought control. But that control was never tangible for you, and it's not for any of us. Let's get real. If you are not in control, I'm not in control, no one else is in control — who or what is in control?
That is what I set out to try to discover. I talk about 26 years ago the death of our son from leukemia. I really experienced that as a narcissistic injury and responded with the classic narcissistic defense, which is to, on some level, deny what was really happening, deny my grief, try to distance myself from it, and also doubling down on control, right? Trying to run away from the pain and the uncertainty by exerting my will on people and situations that I had no business exerting my will on. Examples of that, you know, in the wake of our son's death was that when I knew he was going to die imminently, I stopped holding him and I told him to increase the morphine so that it would speed up the process of his dying. I told myself that I did that for practical reasons, to protect myself and to ease his suffering. But really it was about running away from the pain, not being able to tolerate the uncertainty.
I tried to control my husband's grieving process by insisting that he wasn't sad enough, that he wasn't crying, that instead of planting a garden to try to get through grief and loss, he should go to grief groups and see a psychotherapist because that's what I was doing and that's the way to do it. So yeah, there was a lot of maladaptive coping which I really only recognized in hindsight. And of course what I was doing was leaning on the coping strategies that had worked for me up until that point, until I reached really a crisis of the will where nothing that I did was going to allow me to escape that pain, and eventually brought me to that place of surrender where I realized, hey, I'm not in control. No other human, no matter how wise, is actually going to be able to take this pain away. I think there was a point when I thought if I just find the right person, if I just talk to the right scientist who can explain to me why our son died of leukemia, if I can just do enough psychotherapy, someone will at some point say the magic words which will, you know, take away this pain, this unbearable pain. But that never did happen. You know, there was no real scientific explanation, at least not one that assuaged my grief. I had a wonderful therapist. He helped me recognize a lot of things, but I was still in pain. So it really was only that moment where I said, I'm actually not going to be able to outrun this. I'm going to have to live with this for the rest of my life. And that thought was both incredibly terrifying to me and also liberating. In that moment suddenly I was like, you know what? It's going to be okay. And I can trust in God, the universe, the cosmos, you know, the mystery of creation to kind of buoy me along here. I'm going to be okay. And that was really a turning point not only in my overcoming grief and loss — I should say getting through it, coming out the other side — but was really transformative for the whole rest of my life.
When I read about how you wanted them to increase Lucas's morphine, I was so shocked that you opened that way, and I hope that more people can be so honest in the future. You didn't want to hurt him, obviously. You wanted him to be free from suffering. I mean, you even mentioned that you also wanted yourself to be free from the suffering underneath of that. And when you connect that to narcissism, it makes me think — and you write a lot about narcissism in this book. You know, in the past we would say, what is it, like 1% of the population has narcissism? And that's changing at such a rapid rate.
Yeah. I mean, what you know now, narcissism is often used as a form of sort of political name-calling. This person's a narcissist. That person's a narcissist. What I argue in the book and try to draw people's attention to is the way that we've all become narcissists as a matter of survival. We live in a culture of endemic narcissism that literally forces us to look at ourselves for multiple hours every day. It forces parents to focus on kids' achievements and accomplishments to get into the best school as a validation of having been good parents. It forces young people to try to reach some sort of perfectionist, optimized state of living through career maxing, relationship maxing, looks maxing — you name it. We're all narcissists now, and it is massively to our suffering because, of course, that kind of self-focus is exactly the opposite of a spiritual and surrendered life where we really find, you know, serenity and connection and all the things that we need to flourish.
You said in devastation and suffering a space opens and there serenity can emerge. I might have butchered that a little. You said that very beautifully. So I really loved that, and I'm curious, what's the real blessing of suffering?
Suffering is an opportunity for growth. It is a massive amount of information that is coming to us that forces us to change our rigid constructs of the world, and this is where I actually think that neuroscience and in particular the active inference model is helpful. According to active inference, it is our teleologic or biologic mandate — the thing that primarily drives our existence — is to reduce uncertainty. And we are born not with a tabula rasa or a blank slate, but actually with a pre-existing mind map or model of the world. And as we move forth in the world and mature and grow and have new experiences, we elaborate on that mind map, adding more roads and valleys and houses and towns and cities, until, you know, we end up with a very elaborate mind map of the world. And what this mind map is constantly doing is predicting, trying to predict and problem solve. And when our predictions match up with our experience, that feels good, and we experience that in the form of different positive emotions. But when our mind map does not predict our experience, that opens the gate to a lot of negative emotions, and primarily this state of surprise, uncertainty. And the earliest signal that our mind map is not matching up is usually a negative emotion, something like rage or grief or sadness or anxiety. So that kind of suffering that's brought on by our failed predictions or our flawed mind maps becomes then, if we respect it and revere it as we should, an opportunity — it becomes an opportunity to let in new information and update our mind maps about the world, which we must do in order to move forward effectively in the world. So suffering, I really conceptualize suffering as a moment that we are getting essential information about the faulty model of the world that we're clinging to and our need to let go of that model and widen our perception, be physiologically and psychologically open to new experiences, new information, so that we can update our model of the world and have a more accurate mind map.
Oh, what was it? Steve Jobs at Stanford University during his commencement speech — I think he was right. Didn't he say, I hope you all suffer a lot?
Yeah, I love that. I mean, I'm not remembering that exact line, but I think that's the same speech in which he also said that death informs life. And I think at that point he was already at end-stage pancreatic cancer. So it is a powerful instrument by which we become wiser.
In your book you mention how these unpredictable moments — this is what brings about emotion and this is what we're trying — you said it again more elegantly, so forgive me, but like this is what we're trying to always suppress. And now we have everything as an instant noodle, right? Like we have everything at our fingertips. So we can control what's happening and then we're still suffering. And I mean, you've given this phenomenal example. I think it was a boy or a man in your book who was completely addicted to social media and it just led to suffering and he came out of it. But so nowadays, everyone who's listening, adults and youth alike, how can they overcome this addiction that they may not even realize that they have?
I think it's important to recognize that the internet and platforms like social media are essentially our brains turned inside out, writ large on the world. And when we are spending inordinate amounts of time on social media and other innately reinforcing platforms, what we're doing is essentially spending time in our own heads reinforcing our mind maps. We're not actually navigating the world. So I think that that's an important beginning point. And yes, my patient Logan realized very quickly that he could figure out what could go viral on TikTok or Instagram Reels or what have you. And because he was good at that and he was an attractive young man, he got huge virality with his videos and he got flooded with, you know, a simulacrum of love or connection through that medium, and it was so incredibly powerful and so incredibly reinforcing that over time he essentially got addicted to that. He stopped going to school, he stopped socializing, to some extent he stopped eating because he wanted to lose weight because he recognized that being physically attractive improved virality on the internet. And he got more and more internet famous. I mean, literally he became internet famous and more and more miserable in the process.
And there's a way in which he articulates it, which I think is just so powerful. He says, the more internet love I got, the smaller my world got and the more anxiety and shame I felt. So I think this is really key to understanding that when we exert our willful control and get in these very small prediction-action-reinforcement loops, we have essentially allowed this medium to hijack our evolutionary and adaptive strategies of decreasing uncertainty, predicting the future, seeking out pleasure, avoiding pain — which are in and of themselves highly adaptive when we're doing that in the real world. But if we allow this medium to hijack those highly adaptive mechanisms, now we're pursuing control for its own sake, not as a way to problem solve in the world. And then we can get caught in this tiny little cage, which is not the world, right? It's a world we've made, a simulacrum of the world within the world, where in the short term we can predict, right? We can have these prediction-action loops that are very, very reinforcing, but we're not actually living, right? We're missing out on our lives. And I think to recognize that, to begin by recognizing that that is what happens, is this really important starting point. And he did recognize that, and he got off social media, and he got a dumb phone, and he put all kinds of blocks on the internet, and he went back to school, and he used the textbook instead of trying to use the internet to study. And lo and behold, he was getting the best grades in the class because it turns out the teachers were actually, you know, teaching from the textbook and issuing exams from the textbook. And he thought he would be totally cut off from his social world, and it turns out he felt more socially connected. He thought he would be really boring because he wasn't on the internet, you know, tracking all the latest memes and what people were talking about. And he said instead he felt more mysterious and more interesting and more grounded and more real. So it's just all of these really fascinating paradoxes that come when we leave this virtual space and go out into the real world and really connect with other people and nature and other things, and when we feel real again.
Real question. How does that align with people like you who are phenomenal writers, who are out there in public, who are doing this meaningful work, and it comes out onto social media? Like, it is an important platform for people to know who you are. And I know you don't use social media yourself. However, I'm curious, like, how does that work for you?
Yeah, it's a great question and a fair challenge, right? Because here I am criticizing the medium and yet I'm doing all these podcasts talking about my book. So, you know, it's not that I'm saying let's put the genie back in the bottle. Number one, that would be impossible. Number two, I wouldn't even really want that. There are a lot of good things about the technology and about our ability to connect with other people, you know, have conversations like the one that you and I are having now that I'm very grateful for. We wouldn't have even been able to make this kind of connection were it not for this amazing technology. It's about being wise about the kinds of relationships we're having with this technology and recognizing when the medium has hijacked what is an innately healthy impulse to connect and turned it into something that is essentially the illusion of connection or the illusion of control for its own sake, removed from the real deal.
Yeah, when I read this whole part in your book about the algorithm, I thought, maybe I should email Anna and say, can I fly into your office and we just do this? I'll bring mics.
Yeah, yeah. I know what you mean. I mean, you can't beat the convenience, right? Of me being in my office, you being in your office. It makes it, you know, so much more possible. But yes, I mean, I think it's important to acknowledge that something is lost when you're not in person. And by the way, you know, in the work that I do as a psychiatrist in clinical care, you know, overnight with COVID, we went all online. COVID was six years ago. We still have about 70% of patients who prefer to be seen online than come in person, even though we're here, we're back in the office, we're in person. And that just speaks to kind of like the tradeoff. Like, you know, it's just so convenient to see us from their homes or from their offices or from their cars. You know, the traffic's bad. And so even though I think people get a lot more out of it when they're here in person, it's not necessarily always worth the tradeoff.
Do you think it's also because people kind of have a wall in front of them? They don't need to be so vulnerable at that point?
Oh yeah, I think that's really exactly what Radical Surrender is trying to discourage — the ways in which we don't want to be vulnerable, right? It's so much easier to just stay at home and connect via the screen and then disconnect, you know, in a way that I directly control. So much harder to sort of put ourselves out there now and just even go outside and, you know, unexpectedly encounter another human that we weren't — you know, it wasn't a scheduled Zoom call or what have you, right? Or, you know, and actually talk to that person and wow, really? What would we talk about? So I, you know, I often encourage a kind of graded exposure therapy where I say, get off your device. Again, go out, have a conversation with somebody you don't know or you weren't anticipating. See where it goes. You know, try not to control the moment.
And so you say nowadays it's like the weather has become a data set. Food is just another manufactured thing. I'm going to skip ahead, like psychedelics, right? It's a shortcut to awakening. You again might have said all this more elegantly. But all of this — psychedelics can turn into addiction quickly, right? Again, we're in the golden age of narcissism. And all of this seems to come back to this need of control. When we get our cravings met, perhaps like junk food, right? People used to smoke cigarettes. Then they were drinking alcohol or both. Now then they did hallucinogenics. Now it's all about psychedelics and ayahuasca and plant medicine and all of that. So it just seems like this is just another symptom of society's self-hatred. Is it? Maybe it's connected even to the narcissistic culture of like, I'm going to awaken faster than you. I'm going to reach radical surrender faster than you.
Let me go back a little bit to psychedelics because I really think that the resurgence of interest in psychedelics points to something very positive, which is that people recognize the need for the sacred. Like, they realize, I need something more. There has to be some kind of sacred ballast, some deeper meaning. What is this all about? It can't possibly just be all about, you know, looks maxing and career maxing and relationship and, you know, getting more of what I want and more money and more toys. Like, surely there has to be something else there. And so I think that that really does explain this intense interest in psychedelics as a means of tapping into sort of that greater mystery. I will also say that I have, you know, in researching the book, I talked to many people for whom psychedelics were a very valuable and positive change agent in their lives. It really, what it essentially does is it melts those mind maps, right? And forces people to recognize that their mind maps are just maps and not the terrain itself, right? It massively and suddenly sort of widens that lens. And so I think in that sense, for a modern human, if used appropriately and let's say just once, or in a very limited fashion, it can be helpful.
The problem is when it becomes its own vehicle for control, addiction, for kind of trying to manipulate a certain kind of experience. Now they're on the hedonic treadmill of seeking out greater and greater levels of spirituality, using monthly, microdosing daily — you know, all of a sudden it's become this adulterated thing which is not really, you know, its intended purpose either in ancient times or as part of, you know, religious and spiritual practices, you know, or anything that will ultimately help that person. So I think it's really important to kind of, you know, flesh out that there are nuances here and that this can be for some, you know, really a really valuable tool. Of course, what I see a lot of is people for whom it's become just another object of their desire and a way to try to exert their will on the world. In terms of whether like society we're at a point of self-hatred, I mean, it's an interesting turn of phrase. I will say that, and I talk about this in the book, that I, you know, our endemically narcissistic culture, which really forces us to focus on ourselves to get along and get ahead in modern society, I don't think this is how humans were meant to live. And I think, maybe this is what you were getting at, really we were meant to be in tribes and to be deeply connected and perhaps not to think about the self at all. But because we're forced to try to distinguish ourselves above and outside of the tribe, I argue that nature's homeostatic reckoning or mechanism to bring people back in is to make them feel shame in the wake of accomplishments. Again, a paradox. You would think the closer you get to your idealized version or your goal or whatever it is, the happier you would be, but almost universally that's not true. As people asymptotically approach their idea of the perfect life, they tend to get less and less happy. And I think that that is in some regard biology or mother nature's attempt to bring people back into the fold, for that kind of narcissism to be naturally accompanied by a self-loathing shame that then tries to correct for excessive narcissism.
That's phenomenal because now you're bringing us in the realm of Maslow, right? Maslow — like, we should in theory, and like you wrote, we should be going toward self-actualization. I mean, we have the conditions, but yet we have all of these obstacles, all these distractions. We're too busy ruminating about the past, worrying about the future, which is — this is like the first biggest kind of section of obstacles in meditation traditionally, in Buddhist meditation specifically, that one must overcome to go further. So your hypothesis is, or my understanding, that when we're in this world of endless reinforcement, we're seeking pleasure, craving, clinging, we will never be happy.
Well, I think we can be happy as long as we recognize that the ecosystem that we have engineered is contrary in many ways to our happiness. Now, living in Maslow's hierarchy of needs is this idea that, you know, first you just simply have to survive, right? And then as immediate survival becomes less of a pressing need because we have enough food and we have, you know, clothing and shelter and all of the things, then we kind of enter into a phase of self-actualization, you know, altruism, living on this higher plane. Instead, what's actually happened is we're all masturbating, you know, playing Candy Crush and, you know, eating cupcakes. So there was some, you know, Maslow's prediction was in fact wrong. And it was a very idealistic view of humans and where we would go once our basic survival needs were met. But ultimately, I'm optimistic about humans, and I think if we now recognize that the world that we have engineered and live in is actually contrary in many ways to human flourishing, we can begin to try to think about, well, what can and should the world look like so that we're living in greater harmony with ourselves, with other people, with nature.
And when you talk about this in your book, you mention a lot about God.
And that is such a broad term. You know, it was funny when I read that part, and for anyone listening, like this isn't a book where you have to become a Christian or follow God, okay? Like when I was listening to that, it was interesting. I just remembered like my first few experiences in church. And also I had so much overlap with you, like I had to ask my parents to take me to church and explore different spiritual paths. And they sent me off with some person who I didn't really know, and they're like, go with this person to church.
I love it. I love it. I love that you had to say no, and then you're like, you're ending up in your church, like, what is going on here and who are these people, right?
[laughter] Yeah, and I was so young. I'm six years old.
Wow, I was the same age. I was around the same age. Yeah.
And I go there a few times, and then one time I decide to wear pants, and I get scolded for wearing pants and not a skirt. For females should wear skirts, and then they said God will send you to hell if you don't wear skirts, and I was like, what kind of God is this? What is God? And then that kind of jump-started my whole exploration of a whole lot of different paths, and eventually becoming a Buddhist nun. But yeah, so when you talk about God for people who maybe had experiences like I did, and who are like, well, what is God? And I've explored it in depth since then, obviously. I mean, it's been decades, but...
Yes, your whole life. Okay, so I love this. First of all, let me just say, I love how you were raised in a secular home too, where God was not present.
I mean, it was like half Christian, half Jewish, and then all of that was present, and like random, like my dad had a little Buddha, and that was like the secret I was not supposed to touch, which ended up profoundly affecting me.
Yes, right. That's the path you took. Yeah, you know, so there's been a lot of research and work on looking at the natural spirituality of children and how, as we grow in a secular society, it often gets squelched. But when you have a child who just has that innate and deep spiritual longing like you did, right, and like I did, that search begins very early and it's very pressing. You got there a lot more directly and faster than I did, and you made a much bigger commitment. But I don't think necessarily there's that much difference between becoming a psychiatrist and becoming a Buddhist nun. I think there might be a lot more overlap than we're giving credit for, right? So I just love that we have that kind of shared experience.
Yeah, so my journey kind of similar. You know, since childhood, kind of a deep longing, emptiness, saying to my parents, well, okay, everybody else on the block is going to church, why don't we go to church? Maybe that's the solution. Going, feeling like a fish out of water. You know, and then dabbling here and there with other things as I grew up, but ultimately not really looking in earnest again until our son died, and then feeling like, okay, I need something more than what I have as an answer to this deep search for meaning and how to cope with suffering, really. And then went around to a lot of different, you know, religious sort of services and met a lot of different people, but never really felt entirely at home. And where I landed is interesting, it's a little bit different, I mean it's a lot different than you landed, you committed your whole life, right? And I admire that so much. What I did was I finally ended up in this place where, like, you know what, maybe I actually don't need to further define God. God is mystery, God is the cosmos, God is nature, maybe God is a theistic God, but maybe not, and it's okay for me to say I don't know. That took me a long time, but it was very liberating for me to finally just say, you know what, I don't know what this God is, and I'm not sure I believe, but I'm going to believe in believing and proceed as if, because my life is better for it.
And you say pray, like even if you don't know what you're doing, how you're doing, what is that like, especially your first time? Can you go a little deeper, like the emotional side? Like I cannot imagine, I can't imagine, because I remember I was like praying and I'm like, I don't know what I'm doing, but anyway, [laughter] I'm here, here, here, like something happening.
Oh, I love that. That's so great. Yeah, I mean, for me, the actual, I mean, the first intentional prayer was next to our son's empty crib, realizing I'd come to the end of the road, saying to myself, okay, well, if I'm not in control and no human can take this pain away and no human is in control, I'm going to just conclude based on logic that something is in control, some higher power. I don't know what it is, but I'm going to turn my psyche and my attention toward this higher power outside of myself, whatever you want to call it. And I'm going to try to be in relation with that entity, and I have no idea what that means or what that looks like, but I'm going to do that. And I was suddenly filled with a feeling of hope and serenity that I had not been able to get through any amount of scientific research, through any amount of psychotherapy, although again I had a wonderful and compassionate therapist. It was the first moment where I felt like, oh, this might actually be the way. And I can't really describe it other than that, just like a moment of like, it's going to be okay. You're going to be okay. I went to my bed. I slept for the first time, honestly, in what felt like months. And I woke the next morning, and it was like I had a different perceptual experience of the world. The sky was bluer, the leaves were greener. I went out, and this garden that my husband had been planting as part of his, you know, grief and healing and let's say prayer process probably, I saw it for the first time. I was like, oh my gosh, what a beautiful garden.
And then the other really powerful thing, which for me just has stuck with me, is I sort of looked to this higher power because I was surrendering control. I didn't trust my own storytelling. I didn't feel I could rely on my own decision-making because it seemed like everything I did just made things worse. So that was the state that I was in at that point. And I said, you know what? I don't know what to do next. I'm going to surrender to my higher power for what to do next. And then it was very interesting. I very clearly had a deep sense of moral realism in that moment. And moral realism is sort of the opposite of cultural relativism. So cultural relativism is this idea that like good and bad are just made up. They're culturally contingent. You know, what people should do morally changes with the times depending upon what's happening in the world and their culture. And that's what I had believed to that point, and that's the way I had been raised, and that's the way that my education had shaped me. But in that moment of trying to be in dialogue with my higher power, I had a distinct sense that no, good and evil or right and wrong, moral facts exist in the universe and they can be known. And if I can just tap into making a morally right choice, I can align myself with this higher power and then I will know what to do. And it was as simple as just doing the next right thing. It was like, okay, Anna, you need to eat some breakfast. Okay, I'm going to eat some breakfast. You need to brush your teeth. I will brush my teeth. Okay, what is this higher power? You should get on your bike and go to work because you have patients you need to see. Okay, I'm going to get on my bike. And again, I had been doing those things anyway, but it was with now a sense of doing them in alignment with some kind of cosmic force that was going to guide me and help me make the right choice. And that was the pivot. That was the prayer. That was the radical surrender that I was not going to be driving this bus. I was going to look to this power outside of myself. And that for me was just critical.
It seems to me like what happened was on top of, like you experienced interdependence.
Yeah, yes, an interdependence with the people around me, but a healthier dependence too. Like I think a lot of my suffering had also been because I was codependent. I essentially managed my own emotions by controlling other people or trying to control them. You know, nobody...