Some platforms have been engineered to optimize clicking and scrolling independent of content. Dr. Anna Lembke is a psychiatrist and professor at Stanford and one of the leading voices helping us understand addiction in the modern world. Many people with very severe addictions can get into recovery at every stage of life and sustain that recovery for years to decades. As medical director of addiction medicine and author of the best-selling Dopamine Nation, she explores how our brains seek pleasure, why it's so easy to overdo it, and what it takes to find balance.
The way that we tell our stories is really essential. We can tell healing stories, or we can tell stories that keep us stuck in our suffering.
In our conversation, she shares fresh insights on managing desire, discomfort, and the search for real joy.
Welcome to Stanford Department of Medicine's inside look at the future of medicine. Anna, welcome to the future of medicine.
Thank you for inviting me. I'm delighted to be here.
It's been amazing to see the ripples that have happened after you gave the medical grand rounds just in the, you know, a week or two ago, and to hear people talk about the topics that you discussed, and so it's really great to spend a few minutes just talking about it.
Oh well, thank you. Yes, I've had a number of people reach out to me who were at the grand rounds. I've been able to meet with them, graduate students, medical students who are excited about the ideas and want to contribute to helping people recover from addiction and the full range of compulsive overconsumption. So that's been nice.
Dopamine Nation was such an amazing book and really landmark, but also very enjoyable and informative. It just, you know, I love reading popular science books, even better when they come from my colleagues here at Stanford. And that one has had such an impact. It is a very personal book as well. It is more so than many of the books that our colleagues write.
And I wondered what led you to be kind of so open about your own life. Yeah. Even from really from the beginning of the book.
Well, thank you for that question. I think that's a really wonderful question. You know, the book is an interweaving of science with patient stories, and I had to get permission from my patients to include their stories. And they were so generous in their willingness to talk about these very personal subjects. But I got to a point in kind of crafting the book where I realized that it on some level would be disingenuous if I didn't also include my own experiences with addiction and compulsive overconsumption. So I sort of took a leap of faith that people would be okay, you know, with me admitting to having these areas in which I lack self-control. It's been wonderful to see how people have resonated with that, and I really appreciated sharing on that level.
I also think when you look at books written by doctors, there are so many wonderful books, including many of our colleagues. But I have to say many of them, like the physicians, just seem so sort of saintly.
You know, so I thought, but maybe it's time for us to kind of admit like we've got problems, too.
Yeah. We're real people, too. Yes. That's right.
And I think as a reader, it really draws us in immediately and allows us to identify with you not just as the doctor and the world expert in this area that we're interested in learning about, but as a human being.
Yeah. And we all have these flaws and challenges.
And so it was really, I think, a moving part. And you mentioned this really wonderful interweaving of science and patient stories. That's hard to do. And in particular the stories that you tell, as you say, are very personal, and the sorts of challenges, I mean, there's lots of medical books that talk about challenges, maybe for things we talk about more often in the public domain, cancer and heart disease, but your patients are telling you stories that they probably have not told anyone else, and yet they've given you permission to share broadly so others can learn. That's just an amazing thing.
It is amazing. And it's interesting because, you know, they wanted to share their stories in many instances as a way to help other people. And I found that incredibly moving. And of course, what's very gratifying is that the book has been read by a lot of people and has actually helped a lot of people. I know that because I get scores of emails every day from readers all over the world. Readers who otherwise wouldn't have had access to some of the basic science about addiction, but also just having this de-shaming experience of realizing, wow, I'm not the only one struggling with this particular type of problem. So yeah, my patients' generosity has really transformed some people's lives, which is great.
Yeah. You talk a bit in the book about radical honesty, and I wondered if that was also somewhat connected to the personal nature of the book and that you were feeling that such an important part of the recovery process that it might also be an important part of your book writing process.
Yes, very true. And thanks for jumping to radical honesty. It comes in the latter half of the book, and I don't often get asked about it, but it's the idea that by committing to telling the truth about things large and small, we can improve our lives and the lives of other people. It's actually hard to do that because the average adult tells about one to two lies per day.
I was trying to decide if that was me when you were writing that in the book.
Yeah. And, you know, it's usually little things that we kind of discount like false flattery, or just small ways that we cover up some selfishness that we think is insignificant, like why we were late for a meeting or why we can't go to a particular event. But one pattern I kept seeing again and again in my patients who were able to get into sustained recovery from very severe addictions was this kind of commitment to radical honesty, or what Alcoholics Anonymous calls rigorous honesty. And I just found that absolutely fascinating. And so I do explore that in the book. But yes, you're right. This kind of telling my story and patients being willing to tell their stories is in a way in homage to this idea that by opening up and being transparent, we're really better off, and other people come closer, right? We foster intimacy. The danger is this sort of disclosure porn, you know, that we just sort of try to use intimate stories to manipulate other people or on social media to get followers or posts. So, I mean, there's a potential dark side here. But I think when we genuinely allow ourselves to be vulnerable with other people, the rewards are great, and yet we're so terrified to do it.
To do it. Yeah. Yeah. You mentioned Alcoholics Anonymous there. It does recur in the book a little bit, and I was really interested in coming to the book sort of, you know, in a way where you would come down or what the nuance was of your view coming from a scientist's perspective and a doctor's perspective of their program. Yeah. But I in a way maybe I was a little surprised how positive you were about many elements of it.
Yeah. So I'm not surprised that you're surprised because we are living in an era of AA and 12-step bashing, and I'm not exactly sure why that is. But, you know, 12 steps, Alcoholics Anonymous, and all the offshoot groups have been around for almost a hundred years now. And it's evidence-based. So there's a wonderful article by my dear, dear friend and colleague Keith Humphreys, along with John Kelly from Harvard, where they basically compared active participation in 12-step groups like Alcoholics Anonymous to professionally mediated treatment and found that they're really comparable. And in fact that the longer you follow patients out, the better AA looks.
Really? Yeah. Interesting.
And there's even evidence that for the most severely addicted, AA may work the best.
So, you know, of course it's not for everybody. And of course you have to actively participate and engage in the program for it to work, but we do know for those who actively participate, it can be incredibly effective, even when they're mandated to participate, which is also interesting. So yes, it's evidence-based. You can recommend it with confidence based on the evidence, but just like all of our medical treatments, they're going to work for some people and not others. There are many paths to the top of the mountain. So it's good that people have access to many different types of treatment.
Yeah, I thought it was interesting that it lives sort of in the same world as this mild skepticism lives in the same world as a knowledge that there are people who are years out who are counting the days and can tell you how many days it's been. That's also in the public domain, and those two things almost don't quite add up, right?
Well, I think that whether it's characters on television or people in the real world, that there's this sense that people who've been through a 12-step program sort of know to the day how many days they've been sober and they can recount. So there's a sense that that's a commonly recurrent feature. There are people out there who've been very successful. But at the same time that coexists with the sense that maybe there's a mild skepticism of the scientific basis of it, which I think you explode in the book, and I think you show that that's not true and that there is real scientific underpinnings.
Yeah. I mean, I think that the biggest point of resistance around 12 steps is actually not whether or not there's an evidence base for it. It's the whole higher power and God thing, right? And we're just living in a time when people are so polarized on issues related to secular versus spiritual. It's become so politicized, unfortunately. And even that politicization has infiltrated 12-step groups, which is fascinating and also somewhat discouraging. So now whereas 12-step groups used to be sort of the bastion of secular spirituality and a place where people who were both highly religious and people who were atheists could come together and self-define their higher power, what we're seeing now based on actually a study that's ongoing is that now you have some 12-step groups where you can't really go unless you have a certain type of faith, right? Or others where you're not welcome if you do have faith.
It's really interesting. Yeah. One of the central themes of the book, one that I think resonates with everybody but maybe is somewhat surprising to them, is this idea of pleasure and pain being sort of two sides of the same coin. And I was particularly interested in maybe have you explore a little what we know about the neurobiological basis of that because I think people understand there's a yin and yang in the world, but I'm not sure they necessarily think it's so closely connected in their brains.
Yeah. I mean what was so fascinating to me as I was researching the book, and let me emphasize I'm not a neuroscientist. I'm not the one in the lab doing these detailed experiments. That's the work of my amazing colleagues. But what fascinated me is the discovery that pleasure and pain are co-located in the brain. So the same parts of the brain that process pleasure also process pain, and that at some fundamental level they work through this opponent process mechanism, kind of like a teeter-totter or seesaw. And that became sort of a metaphor for me to think about the ways in which pleasure and pain are relative, and also the ways in which with the relentless pursuit of pleasure, ever more potent intoxicants, you know, not just traditional drugs but things that are new to the world altogether like digital media, that we ultimately, our brain adapts to whatever pleasure we get and kind of downregulates that whole hedonic system such that now when we're not engaging in this pleasurable pursuit, we're very unhappy. And the more pleasure we get, the less happy we get. To me, that was absolutely fascinating and also beautifully mirrors what we see clinically. And I think that's what I was really trying to do: take some of these fundamental, very basic neuroscience concepts and say, what does that look like for real people in the real world? You know, how does that manifest as people are in their addiction when they first try to stop using? How they slam down to the side of pain. That's withdrawal. This kind of counter mechanism. And how with continued abstinence and treatment, they can gradually come out of that. But it's tough because there's that euphoric recall and those triggers, and it takes a long time, and it's limited by neuroplasticity and all of those things.
Yeah. I think I love the way you sort of brought us in. You actually described at the very beginning of the book into your consult room. I think the description of that was beautiful. And then it meant for the rest of the book we could see ourselves sitting there with you. And then describing how you would work through this idea with some of the patients, that it would take them the first two weeks or so and they were going to feel worse.
Helping them get to the other side so that they could eventually feel better.
Tincture of time, you know, just having faith and waiting when we first stop our drug of choice. The cravings not only are intense, but they actually initially get worse with each successive day. And it feels like, oh my goodness, I can't live like this. But, you know, the longer we can go without using, the faster we'll get to that point where the cravings start to abate. We begin to be able to take pleasure in other more modest rewards, and that whole cycle, and the world kind of opens up.
Yeah. The other part I loved, and in medicine here we are thinking maybe more often on the physical side and you're obviously thinking more often on the mental side, but you brought up this concept of hormesis.
And I talk about this a lot actually because of work we do with exercise. Actually, you touched briefly on exercise. So I was actually, as I mentioned a moment ago, running as I was listening to your book. But the concept that something that causes a little bit of pain, a modicum of stress if you like, could ultimately create significant benefit is something that I was really interested in because we often think of exercise in that dimension. And we're actually involved in a variety of different studies to try and work out what the molecular basis of that might be.