Hello everybody. I'm delighted to be here in Berlin to speak with you today. Actually, my father was born in Berlin in the 1930s, emigrated to the United States in the 1960s where I was born. Unfortunately, my German is not very good, and that's why I'll be speaking to you in English today.
I am really excited to talk to you about three main topics, but first my disclosures. I do not receive any funding from medical corporations, but I have been retained as a medical expert witness in opioid litigation and also social media litigation on the plaintiff's side against Meta, YouTube, Snapchat, and TikTok.
Okay, so our learning objectives for today. Number one, I want to briefly review about 75 years of the neuroscience of pleasure and pain so that we can understand what is happening in the brain as we become addicted to just about anything. Then I'm going to widen the lens to talk about something that I call the plenty paradox, which is essentially this idea that abundance itself is a modern-day stressor. And finally, I'm going to talk about what we as individuals can do about living in a world in which our ancient wiring is mismatched for the modern ecosystem. But although I'm going to focus on the individual, I want to emphasize that this is a collective problem. We need both bottom-up and top-down solutions.
So let's talk about the brain. First of all, one of the exciting findings in neuroscience is the discovery of a dedicated reward circuit in the brain that consists of the prefrontal cortex, that large gray matter area right behind our foreheads, which you might think of as the brakes on the car. And then the deeper limbic structures, the nucleus accumbens, and the ventral tegmental area, which are rich in dopamine-releasing neurons, which you might think of as the accelerator on the car. And addiction or compulsive overconsumption is a problem of too little brakes, too much accelerator, or some combination.
One of the very exciting findings in the last 75 years in neuroscience is the discovery of dopamine as a human brain neurotransmitter. So neurotransmitters are chemicals that we make in our brain, which allow for fine-tuned control of the electrical circuits that make up who we are. So our brain is essentially a bundle of wires. Those wires are neurons. The neurons do not connect end-to-end. There's a little gap between them. That gap is called the synapse. And neurotransmitters are chemicals that bridge that gap between neurons to allow for fine-tuned control of electrical circuits.
Dopamine is important for the experience of pleasure, reward, and motivation. It's probably even more important for motivation than it is for pleasure itself. The more dopamine that's released in the nucleus accumbens and the faster that it's released, the more likely is that substance or behavior to be reinforcing, rewarding, or something that our brain wants us to do again and again.
So, this slide is from a series of experiments done in rats and mice, sticking a probe into the nucleus accumbens to measure dopamine in response to various rewards. We're always releasing dopamine at a baseline tonic level. When our brain encounters something that it recognizes as important for survival, dopamine is temporarily increased above baseline. In rats, we know that chocolate increases dopamine 55% above baseline, sex 100%, nicotine 150%, cocaine and amphetamine much, much more. And indeed, if you put a rat in a cage with a lever to press for cocaine or amphetamine, it will press that lever till exhaustion or death.
Now, one thing that this experiment does not take into account is the very important concept of drug of choice, especially when it comes to the complex human brain. So, we're all wired a little bit differently, and what's reinforcing for your brain may not be reinforcing for my brain and vice versa. So, drug of choice is an important concept.
Also, unfortunately, we don't have little smartphones that we can give to mice to measure how much dopamine is released in response to digital media. It would be nice if we did, but there was a guy in France who did an experiment to see if rats liked looking at pictures of themselves. So, he set up a rig so rats could press a lever to take a selfie, and sure enough it turns out that rats will repeatedly press a lever to look at pictures of themselves.
We also know that the human brain reward pathway will light up in response to digital media. So, in other words, digital media, social media, online pornography, online shopping, video games, YouTube, TikTok activates the same reward pathway as drugs and alcohol and releases dopamine.
What I'd like to talk about now is what happens in the brain as we go from modest use of any intoxicant, which I will refer to as a drug for purposes here today, when we go from recreational use to addictive or compulsive use. And I'm going to do that by using an extended metaphor of a pleasure-pain balance. So, imagine that in your brain, deep in your nucleus accumbens, there's something like a scale or a teeter-totter representing how we process pleasure and pain. When we experience pleasure, it tips one way, we get a release of dopamine in the reward pathway. When we experience pain, it tips the other way.
This balance is governed by several very important rules, and the first and most important rule is that the balance wants to remain level with the ground. And our brains are going to work very hard to restore a level balance after any deviation from neutrality. And the way our brains restore a level balance is important for understanding what happens with addiction.
Essentially, as soon as our brain sees an increase in dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens, it works to downregulate dopamine transmission, for example, by involuting postsynaptic dopamine receptors. That process is called neuroadaptation, and I like to think of it as these little neuroadaptation gremlins hopping on the pain side of the balance to bring us level again.
But the gremlins like it on the balance, so they don't get off as soon as we're level. They stay on until our brain is tilted an equal and opposite amount to the side of pain. Now, that is the come down, the hangover, the blue Monday, or just that state of craving, wanting to have one more drink, watch one more TikTok video, eat one more piece of chocolate.
Our brain is designed to restore a level balance or homeostasis as quickly as possible. And the fastest way to do that is to use more of our drug, whatever it is. And living in a world where drugs are easily available, whether in the form of food or digital media or cocaine, we have an intense desire to get more.
Now, if we resist that craving, the gremlins hop off, their job is done, and a level balance is restored. But if we continue to consume our drug of choice over days to weeks to months to years, those gremlins multiply. They get bigger, they get stronger, and ultimately they are camped out on the pain side of the balance. And now we've entered addicted brain.
We've changed our hedonic set point. We need more of our drug in more potent forms, not to get high and feel good, but just to level the balance and feel normal. And importantly, when we're not using, we're walking around with a balance tilted to the side of pain, experiencing the universal symptoms of withdrawal from any addictive substance or behavior, which are anxiety, irritability, insomnia, depression, and craving.
Now, we have narrowed our focus to just this one single reward, and other more modest rewards are no longer reinforcing. Representing this graphically, just thinking about dopamine in a very simplified way, with initial exposure to anything that is rewarding, we see a fast rise in dopamine, followed by dopamine free fall in equal amount, returning to baseline. But on the right-hand side, what we see is that over time, our brain adapts to dopamine, it becomes less sensitive, that upward deflection gets weaker and shorter in duration, that after response gets stronger and longer, and we end up in a chronic dopamine deficit state. And again, this is the addicted brain.
This is an image of a very famous study done in human brains, looking at dopamine transmission in the reward pathway. And you can see here on the left-hand side, in healthy control subjects, red is represented by dopamine, and there's plenty of red, so plenty of dopamine transmission. But in these individuals who have been addicted to cocaine, methamphetamine, alcohol, and heroin, there's very little red. Their dopamine transmission is below normal. Again, really important because you might think that people who use drugs have plenty of dopamine or plenty of our reward neurotransmitter, but in fact the opposite is true. They are in a chronic dopamine deficit state. And by the way, these images were taken in individuals who had not used their drug of choice for 2 weeks, which tells us that it takes time for the brain to correct the chronic dopamine deficit state.
Now, I want to widen the lens and talk about the plenty paradox. So, a very complex and somewhat beguiling phenomenon is that as modern nations become more wealthy, their citizens become less happy. And this is a relatively modern phenomenon. So, for example, I was involved in a large study looking at the United States measuring many different kinds of metrics, and what we found was by every economic metric in every single US state, things were getting better economically. By the same token, by every metric having to do with mental health, happiness, and well-being, things were getting worse. How can we understand this?
Likewise, if you look at similar data across the world, what you see is that as nations get richer in the last 30 to 50 years, their citizens rate themselves as less happy. Likewise, anxiety and depression are increasing and they're increasing more quickly in the wealthiest nations of the world. And for the first time in recorded history, we see that people living in wealthy nations are more likely to end their own lives than people living in poorer nations. This is a paradox. How can we understand this?
Now, obviously there are many factors at play. There's social dislocation. There's multi-generational trauma. There's income inequality. But I would suggest to you that a potential causative explanation that we are missing is that abundance itself is a stressor. That we have drugified or turned into a drug almost every human activity such that I would hypothesize that on a physiological level, we are individually and collectively in a chronic dopamine deficit state.
From the moment we wake up in the morning and reach for our smartphones and our favorite caffeinated beverage till the moment that we go home at night smoking our joints, drinking our alcohol, watching our favorite shows, we are chronically over-stimulating our brains. And in order to compensate for this firehose of dopamine, our brains are having to adapt and reset our hedonic set point into this chronic dopamine deficit state.
And it's very clear that technology has something to do with this. Technology has many wonderful aspects, but we definitely need to recognize and acknowledge the dark side. And one of the darker aspects of this modern medium is that it is highly reinforcing for our brains. In many ways, I think of computers as the human brain turned inside out. We have invented the perfect machine for our own self-titillation.
And when we think about the qualities that make anything addictive, they can be distilled down into three main factors. Access to drug makes it more addictive at a population level. Potency of drug, including drug of choice and how it's tailored for us, makes it more addictive. And any drug that is inherently novel and uncertain makes it more addictive. Why? Because our brains release more dopamine in response to uncertain or unpredictable rewards than they release in response to predictable rewards.
So, if you just take for example the US opioid epidemic that began in 1999 and continues to this day, caused by the increased availability of prescription opioids in the United States, a fourfold increase in opioid prescribing between 1999 and 2012, what we saw there was massively increased access to opioids through opioid prescriptions, massively increased potency going from opium all the way to fentanyl, which can now be made cheaply in a laboratory and is 100 times more potent than opium or morphine. And then of course, novelty. How do we overcome the gremlins and tolerance? We put a new molecular moiety onto the chemical. We combine fentanyl and Xanax, and all of a sudden we can temporarily overcome tolerance and make a novel drug.
This is exactly how digital media is so addictive. It is the dynamic design features, even more than the content, that makes digital media addictive. When we think of access, we have 24/7 access to our mobile devices, in our bedroom, in our bathroom, at the dinner table. Potency is engineered through the algorithm that modifies the feed based on our use, creating the perfect drug of choice for each of our individual brains.
And then novelty is achieved not just through notifications, but through the insertion of video feeds that we didn't look for, right? So, I may suddenly get an injection of YouTube videos about raccoons prowling at night. I'm not interested in raccoons, but all of a sudden I find myself 4 hours later engaged in watching raccoon videos. And then, of course, uncertainty, the slot machine effect, the mystery of the algorithm, pulls us in and keeps us there.
And there is an overabundance of data and experiments and research showing that digital media is addictive and can cause other mental health harms. So, for example, a study just came out in the last couple of months showing that kids who own their own smartphones are more likely to struggle with mental health disorders than kids who do not own their own smartphones. Please, parents out there, do not give your kid their own digital device until later. Wait for it. Wait for their brains to develop and mature.
Personalized TikTok videos activate more dopamine than generalized videos. This is getting to that idea of potency and the fact that that generalized feed learns us and then drives content to titillate our unique brains. The likes is a way to turn social validation into a drug. When we quantify likes, the brain actually responds with more dopamine and more activation than when the likes are not there. And now of course we have AI. And what has AI done? It's embedded the like button into the text. So now we don't see it as a like button, but it's still there.
Beauty filters negatively affect body image. This study showed that when teens look at images that have been filtered or changed using beauty filters, number one, they see those images as realistic. They do not recognize that beauty filters have been used. Number two, they feel worse about their own bodies after having viewed these images.
Short-form video like TikTok or Instagram Reels are associated with more engagement and more mental health harms. And then finally, a very interesting series of studies actually quantifying how much getting a notification on our devices slows down cognition. This study found that one notification slows down cognitive processing by 7 seconds, which just strikes me as a lot of time when you think about the number of notifications that people have to focus on all day long.
What can we do individually and collectively to combat these harms? I'm going to focus on the clinical paradigm that we use. I will say that in our teen addiction medicine clinic right now at Stanford in Silicon Valley, about 50% of our teen referrals today are for addiction to digital media. Not drugs, not alcohol, addiction to digital media. We use a similar framework to intervene for digital media addiction as we do for drug and alcohol addiction.
Very simply, this framework is as follows. We ask folks for data. What are you using, how much, and how often? Objectives. What are your reasons for using? People usually use to have fun or to solve a problem. Number two, what are the problems caused by your use of your drug of choice? And what's the gap between your objective for using, to calm myself down, for example, or the true outcome. Is it really working to lessen anxiety or is it making anxiety worse?
Then we do an intervention and we ask people to abstain from their drug of choice for 4 weeks. Why 4 weeks? Well, we know that 2 weeks isn't enough, right? We saw that in the brain imaging studies. But also, we see clinically that the first 10 to 14 days are characterized by acute withdrawal. People feel worse before they feel better.
When we take the pleasure stimulus off of the pleasure side of the balance, those gremlins accumulating on the pain side crash us down to the side of pain, and we are in a state of painful craving. But, if we wait long enough, and the brain is still flexible enough, the gremlins hop off, and homeostasis is restored. So, people must abstain for about 4 weeks on average to begin to feel better.
And by the way, this is old news, right? Every major religion and philosophical tradition over the centuries recommends how long a period of Lent? How much Ramadan? 4 weeks. So, this wisdom is so old, and yet now we begin to understand the neuroscience behind it.
This dopamine fast or abstinence trial is a great opportunity to practice mindfulness. Mindfulness is our ability to observe our thoughts and feelings without trying to run away from uncomfortable feelings, and also without judging ourselves negatively. So, a great opportunity to practice mindfulness. It's also a great opportunity for insight.
Because when we're chasing dopamine, we do not see cause and effect. We are not good self-observers of what our drug of choice is actually doing to us. We need to get some distance from it in order to get our frontal lobe connected to our limbic brain, so that we can say, "Oh, wow. I thought smoking pot at night was helping me sleep, but now I see it's actually contributing to my insomnia, right?" Or, "Oh, wow. I thought watching TikTok videos was just a harmless recreation, no big deal. But now that I've stopped for 4 weeks, I can see that it was actually making me more depressed and more anxious."
And then when people have completed that dopamine fast, we ask them, "How are you feeling? What was good about it? What was bad about it?" The number one bad thing about the dopamine fast is, "I was bored." Right? I was bored. I had all this time. I didn't know what to do with myself. And number two, I was lonely. I was lonely because I couldn't hang out with my friends who all use. But when it comes to digital media, I was lonely because I went outside to play and nobody was there. They were all inside on their devices. Again, not just an individual problem, a collective problem.
Nonetheless, we ask people, "Do you want to continue to abstain as your next step, or do you want to go back to using, but use in moderation?" Guess what? Most people want to go back to using. But they almost always want to use differently. They want to use less. And so, we talk about in detail how to do that. They go out and they do the experiment.
To get into a little bit of the specifics of how to make this work, this intervention, we really need to focus on data as the first intervention. What are you using, how much, and how often? We often use what's called the timeline follow back method, where we ask people to focus on the past week. So, I'd like each of you to think about a substance or a behavior that you use too much of and or too often that you would like to change. And then, in your mind, I'd like you to think about, starting from yesterday and the day before yesterday, and the day before that, quantify how much you used. If it was digital media, it was time spent. If it was number of drinks, it was number of drinks.
But something really interesting happens when we focus on that behavior, which by the way is not comfortable, right? Because we don't really want to look at it. For example, in my case, early in my 40s, which was some time ago now, I developed what you might call a mild addiction to romance novels.
Now, my gateway drug was the Twilight saga. Keeping in mind this was a teenage vampire romance series that I discovered in my early 40s. I can't tell you why, but it just titillated my reward pathway. And I've always been a reader, and we think reading is healthy, no big deal. So, you know, seemed like no big deal. So, I read all four books, and then I was like, "Wow, that was great." So, what did I do? I read them again. And then I read them again, and then I read them again, and then I said, "Gee, I wonder if there are any more vampire romance novels out there?"
Turns out there's a whole universe of vampire romance novels. So, I started going to my little local library, and we live right next to a library, so that was easy. And I found a whole ton of vampire romance novels, and I started reading them, reading them more and more often. And then my friend Susan, trying to be helpful, said, "Anna, you should get a Kindle." I thought, "Okay, great. I'll do that." So, I get the Kindle, and now I can get romance novels at the touch of a finger, right? And I'm like discovering this whole world of like really really graphic sex scenes in these romance novels. So, that's awesome, because now I don't have to hide them behind the economist when my husband walks in the room. I'm like, "Oh, hun, War and Peace right here, Tolstoy. That's some good stuff, you know." Not really.
And you know, initially, it just seemed sort of like, eh, who cares? It was sort of funny. I was like, oh yeah, I'm kind of addicted to romance novels. But what I didn't see was the slow accumulation of actual harm. It got to a point where I just wanted to read romance novels. I didn't really want to do anything else. We were on vacation with the family. Everybody went down to the beach. I was like, nah, I'm good. Stayed in my room and read romance novels.
We went to a neighborhood party, one of these paella parties, where they have a big paella in the yard. I actually found a room in their house and went there and read romance novels while the party was going on. I went to work. And in the 10 minutes between patients, I didn't think about my patients or read their charts. No. Pulled out my Kindle. I'm like reading romance novels.
I gradually became more anxious, more depressed. My focus narrowed. I didn't really want to be in the real world. And it really didn't hit me that there was a problem. Well, there were two moments where I thought there might be a problem here. One of them was when I was up at 3:00 in the morning on a weeknight reading 50 Shades of Grey. And I got to the part about butt plugs. And like, I didn't even I don't know what a butt plug is. I really don't know. But I thought to myself, wait, something's gone very wrong here. How did I get here?
And the other was when I was teaching my students, we did a little role play and I was the patient and they were the doctor. And he said to me, what's the behavior you'd like to change and what's one thing you can do to change it? And I said, well, I probably should change my late night reading habit and I should probably get rid of my Kindle. And the next day, after I had verbalized that, I couldn't unsee it. So, there's something very powerful about putting into words, first of all, putting our attention on what we're doing, and then putting into words how we want to change it.
What we also sometimes do with patients is a lifetime dopamine chart, looking at when their compulsive consumptive behaviors began, and how it relates to other events in their life. And it's very interesting, because for some people, when life gets worse, they use their drug more. For other people, it's the opposite. It's when life is going well that they are at higher risk to over consume.
We tell people the reason for abstaining is to reset those reward pathways, so that you can get out of the vortex of craving, and recapture your ability to take joy in other more modest rewards. So, this is what we hold out to teenagers, for example. They say, "Why should I get off TikTok? You know, it's fun. Why should I stop smoking pot?" Like, "Well, you're saying you're anxious and you're depressed. Maybe these behaviors are driving that."
How about addictive substances and behaviors that we can't just stop, right? We can't just stop eating, and yet we have a drugified food supply with the addition of salt, fat, sugars, and flavorings. We really don't want to stop having sex, cuz sex is healthy. On the other hand, how do we stop unhealthy sexual behaviors? The technology is everywhere. We have to be using it. How do we then deal with a compulsive use of technology?
This is a bull's-eye that's adapted originally from Gamblers Anonymous, where you put in the center circle the specific addictive behavior. For me, it was romance novels, not reading more broadly. I could read other things and not get caught up. Romance novels became a problem. So, that went into my center circle. The middle circle is triggers for addictive use. It turns out that our brain reward pathway releases dopamine not just in response to our drug of choice, but also reminders of our drug of choice, people, places, things. So, we need to have that circle for triggers that we avoid. That outer circle is what do we want to approach? Okay, I'm not going to do this, but what is a healthy source of dopamine? Almost always, it's connecting with other people, doing creative work, and being in nature.
This is just to show you from a series of experiments again done in rats, measuring dopamine in response to a reminder of the drug. So, these rats were trained to know that if they saw a light, they could go press a lever for cocaine and get cocaine. And what you'll see here is that not only does dopamine increase in response to the cocaine, but there's a little increase in dopamine just in response to the light.
And my patients will describe that as they're getting ready to go out at night and drink or use, they're already getting a little bit high. If they're reminded of their drug of choice when they're trying to abstain, it's very hard because they're already triggered. And then if they try not to use, they get into an intense state of craving. Why? Because when our brain is expecting a reward that does not come, dopamine levels go below baseline. You see here, this rat was trained to see the light and expect cocaine, got a little bump of dopamine. But when it received no cocaine, dopamine levels went well below baseline. That is that prediction error that creates that state of craving.
When we think about these kinds of triggers, it lets us know that we need to abstain or create barriers between not just our drug, but also reminders of our drug, which by the way is very, very hard to do in a dopamine overloaded world where we're constantly being invited to consume. Everywhere we go, there are triggers.
Here are some examples of self-binding or creating space between ourselves and our drug of choice, specifically for digital media. First of all, we can try to decrease access. How do we do that? We need robust age verification and parental controls for kids. This is bare minimum. We can delete app from our phone and use it only in our desktop, where scrolling is less possible. It is the mobile nature of these digital drugs that contributes to increased access, that contributes to their addictive potential.
We can set manual screen time limits on our phone or use third-party apps and devices like the brick to restrict opening certain apps. Or we can just turn off the phone and leave it behind, which is harder and harder for us to do. Why? Because we get spike of anxiety and a sense of craving and withdrawal, fear of missing out. But we can do it.
We can engage in self-binding strategies that decrease the potency of digital media. For example, avoiding short-form videos, turning off the quantifications like likes, comments, followers. Eliminating beauty filters, going grayscale so that that vivid color isn't constantly stimulating our visual pathway and releasing dopamine in the brain.
And we can engage in self-binding strategies that decrease novelty and uncertainty. For example, turning off notifications, which remember delay cognition by 7 seconds, and also turning off the algorithmic infinite feed and search history so that instead we have to put in a search prompt. This is a small thing, but it can make a big difference. Turn off your algorithmic feed. Don't let your device suggest to you. Turn it off so that you have to input what you're looking for.
There's a concept in diabetes called chronic sedentary feeding. And it is this idea that one of the biggest risk factors for developing diabetes mellitus in the modern age is people who do not move their bodies and eat a little bit all day long. This concept of chronic sedentary feeding translates perfectly to the way that we consume digital media. When we're constantly checking many times throughout the day, we're much more likely to rewire our brain toward this addictive nature. Whereas if we consolidate our use to discrete times of the day, we become less vulnerable to this problem of compulsive overconsumption.
Okay, so we've talked about the neuroscience of pleasure and pain, the pleasure-pain balance, the rules that govern it. We've talked about the plenty paradox. We've focused on digital media, self-binding strategies. Now I want to talk about a very countercultural concept, which is the concept of hormesis.
Hormesis is an area of science that has to do with looking at the way that an organism responds to toxic or painful stimuli. And it turns out that an organism that is exposed to painful stimuli, not too much and not too little, is a healthier and more resilient organism. From fruit flies and worms, all the way up to humans, we are wired for pain. We are wired for friction. We are healthier and happier when we have pain at the right amount and friction in our lives. This is the concept of hormesis.
That by intentionally seeking out pain, those neuroadaptation gremlins hop over to the pleasure side of the balance, and we can get our dopamine indirectly by paying for it up front. And this is in fact how we as humans evolved. We evolved for a world in which we would do a lot of work for a tiny little bit of reward.
Now, exercise and ice cold water baths are evidence-based forms of hormesis. We know from experimental studies that when people do exercise, when they go into ice cold water, they don't get the dopamine spike, they get a gradual increase in dopamine firing over the course of the exercise, but then it remains elevated for hours afterward. I put here fasting, meditation, and prayer. Now, we don't typically think of those as painful activities, but they do release dopamine in the reward pathway, and it's just a way of showing that anything that requires effortful engagement over longer time periods has the potential to be healthy for our brains.
This is just a simple graphic showing that when we initiate the painful stimulus, we get a gradual increase in feel-good neurotransmitters, not just dopamine, but also serotonin, norepinephrine, endogenous cannabinoids, endogenous opioids, and that lasts for hours after we stop exercising before going back down to baseline levels of dopamine firing. We don't go into that dopamine deficit state, right? We don't go there. So, it doesn't set us up for that state of craving.
And what we think is happening here is that the body, in sensing injury, because it turns out exercise is actually causing injury at the cellular level, the brain responds and says, "Oh, I've got to make more of those feel-good neurotransmitters to respond to this injury."
So, these are examples of hormesis that I have gotten from my patients over the years. We've talked about exercise and ice-cold water plunges, but look at all the other hormetic activities that we can engage in in order to reset our reward pathways. And you'll notice that many of these activities are ordinary everyday tasks, but unplugged. Not listening to music, not listening to a podcast.
This is painful for us modern humans because we're so used to the constant stimulation. But with the quiet, we also let our brains rest, right? We let that default mode network synchronize all of the stimuli, we allow ourselves to be a little bit bored, and to follow a new idea to its end without the kind of anxiety and frustration of having to reach for our drug to shut it down.
Now, unfortunately, this is really hard to do. And why? Why is it so hard to do? Why is it so hard for me to get up in the morning and exercise? Cuz it is very hard for me to do that. And the reason is because our brains have an excellent memory for the initial stimulus. If you think about your most vivid childhood memories, you'll note that they're almost always associated with either intense pain or intense pleasure. That is what our brain remembers because that is what we needed to survive in a world of scarcity and ever-present danger, which is not the world that we live in now.
However, our brains have very poor memory for the gremlins that come afterwards. So, we have to remind ourselves of the gremlins. I have to tell myself when I wake up in the morning and do not want to get out of bed, I say, "Anna, remember, you feel a lot better if you exercise." My husband, who doesn't seem to have this problem, comes around and says, "Get up. We need to go exercise." Right? So, we also coregulate with other people. And their behaviors are highly contagious around what we do.
So, we need these reminders in place, and this is one of the ways that Alcoholics Anonymous functions and other 12-step groups, right? People have shared stories and shared narratives that serve as a reminder for how they want to consume and live their lives. Of course, we have to be careful. Anything that releases dopamine has the potential for addiction. People can get addicted to pain. We do see exercise addiction, usually combined with calorie restriction, but it's much less common.
And then I also want to emphasize that although I have focused on the clinical paradigm, individual to individual, this is a collective problem, not just an individual problem. It's a problem of the mismatch between our ancient wiring and our drugified dopamine overloaded world. So, we all need to come to the table, families, schools, corporations that make and profit from these addictive platforms and products, and governments to pass legislation, none of which will be perfect, but I applaud every country that is now making an effort to try something, implement something, see how it goes, see what works.
In conclusion, I would like all of you, if you think you are struggling with some degree of addiction or compulsive overconsumption to your smartphone, to try a 24-hour phone-free challenge. Don't touch your phone, or for that matter, any screen for 24 hours. The aim is to interrupt your physiology. It's not going to reset your reward pathway, it's not long enough, but it may be enough of a reminder for how overly attached we've become. What I find happens is that in the first 12 hours, I'm thinking about all the reasons why I really should go on my phone, and in the last 12 hours, I'm thinking I never want to go on my phone again. I feel so much better.
Optimize your chances of success with this mini dopamine fast by setting a date, telling other people that you'll be away. Sometimes this is a digital Sabbath. Do it together with your family, but plan for it, right? So that you can't rationalize returning to use. Remember, you will be bored, time slows down, perception changes when we are in withdrawal.
Anticipate these symptoms of withdrawal by engaging with hormesis, doing things that are hard. When you have an intense craving to check your phone, go do, I don't know, 10 push-ups, or clean out your closet, or wash the dishes. Very counterintuitive, right? Cuz typically when we're uncomfortable, we think of making ourselves more comfortable. I'm asking you to try making yourself a little bit less comfortable in order to speed up the process of resetting these reward pathways.
And then finally, when the fast is over, think about how you might want to change your digital use in the future, especially thinking about these self-binding strategies.
So, what I hope you've learned today is that what goes up must come down, that the relentless pursuit of pleasure by itself ultimately leads to pain or anhedonia, the inability to experience any pleasure at all, and that to be healthy in a dopamine-overloaded world, we must abstain to some degree, we must self-bind so that we can maintain our abstinence and moderation, and we need to do hard things. Not too much, not too little, but just enough to keep our brains healthy. Thank you so much for your attention. I'd be delighted to take your questions.