Good morning, everyone. My name is Malcolm Young. I'm the dean of Grace Cathedral. Welcome to the fall forum season. We live in a world of extraordinary access to pleasure and extraordinary opportunities to overindulge.
Our smartphones, social media, food, shopping, gaming, and entertainment offer an almost limitless supply of things that promise to make us feel good. Yet, as psychiatrist and author Dr. Anna Lembke explores in her best-selling book, Dopamine Nation: Finding Balance in the Age of Indulgence, the relentless pursuit of pleasure can have a paradoxical effect. The more we seek it, the less satisfaction we find, and the more we may find ourselves struggling with pain.
Today, we'll talk with Dr. Lembke about the neuroscience of desire, the intricate relationship between pleasure and pain, and why our brains are so vulnerable to the attractions of a world designed to keep us wanting more. We'll also explore what it takes to restore balance, deepen our connection with one another, and find meaning in an age of endless distraction and indulgence.
Anna, we're so glad you're here. Your book is fantastic. You know, as I was reading it, I kept telling everyone I knew about what I was learning. And I did. There's a couple parents in the audience today who wanted to bring their children, wanted to share their children, you know, the insights that you expose us to. There was a moment where I just felt like everything had to do with was dopamine everywhere. You know, politics was dopamine, food was dopamine, you know, our relationships with one another. It was a really important thing for me to learn, and I really appreciate the way that you opened up our eyes. But I wonder if you can think a little bit about what our approach to pleasure is and how that's changed from like the time of our grandparents, because their time was so different than ours. And I think dopamine is one way of talking about that difference.
Yeah. Maybe I'll start with a little anecdote that when I first suggested the title Dopamine Nation, my editor said, "Well, will anybody really know what dopamine is? Will they have heard of dopamine?" So, this was back in 2020 or so. And it is amazing to see how the zeitgeist has sort of changed and how dopamine in many ways has become a kind of a metaphor for the overabundance of pleasure. And essentially, you know, what I talk about in the book is the ways in which almost everything has become drugified in the modern world. And what I mean by drugified is made more potently reinforcing, more accessible, and simple access to our drug of choice is one of the biggest risk factors for addiction. More abundant, more novel, more personalized.
You know, by personalized, we have mastered the ability to use technology to tailor these reinforcers for each individual person, thereby essentially making us all more vulnerable to the problem of compulsive overconsumption or addiction. And just to sort of define addiction for folks, addiction is the continued compulsive use of a substance or a behavior despite harm to self and/or others. We look for the three C's: out-of-control use, compulsive use, and continued use despite consequences. We look for tolerance, needing more of a drug over time to get the same effect or finding that it stops working at a given dose. We look for withdrawal, that we have a physiologic negative response to cutting back or stopping. And we are all now, most of us, I should say, are struggling with some form of compulsive overconsumption, at the very least, to our phones and digital media. And this was very different from our grandparents, you know, parents, grandparents, great-grandparents.
Obviously, addiction has been with us since the beginning of human history, but it's kind of consistently been around 5 to 10% of the population struggled with some form of addiction. Now, we're talking about a youth addiction clinic that we have that is getting more and more referrals, 50% of which are related to addiction to digital media specifically.
Yeah, that's fascinating. You know, there's so much in here that was so helpful just in terms of just a basic course on physiology. And in the book, you write, "Science teaches us that every pleasure extracts a price and that the pain that follows is longer-lasting and more intense than the pleasure that gave rise to it." And at that moment, a kind of light bulb went on above my head. But I wonder if you can talk a little bit more about the pleasure, the physiology of pleasure.
Yeah. So I think the place to start is to kind of do a mini review of the neuroscience of addiction over the past 75 years. And I use an extended metaphor of a balance. Think of about like a beam on a central fulcrum that very simply represents how we process pleasure and pain like a seesaw, right? But when it's level with the ground, when it's at baseline or at rest, it's level with the ground. Now this is an oversimplification obviously, but it's a useful metaphor for conceptualizing some very important concepts in the neuroscience of addiction, which are the concepts of homeostasis and neuroadaptation. So in our brain's reward pathway, imagine that we have this balance that represents how we process pleasure and pain. When we experience pleasure it tips one way, pain it tips the other. There are certain rules governing this balance, and the first and most important rule is that the balance wants to remain level with the ground, and this is what neuroscientists call homeostasis, such that with any deviation from neutrality or this level position, our brains will work very hard to restore a level balance. So for example, in the book I talk about how I developed compulsive overconsumption of romance novels, and it started...
By the way, I have a friend who writes those.
Oh yes, well it's a lucrative business. I mean she's a great writer, but she always, Malcolm, you know, you might be a little bit embarrassed about chapter three or whatever. [laughter]
Yes.
I flush when I read it.
Yes. It's true. It's true. Yeah, and I write about it in the book not to trivialize severe and life-threatening addictions, but to really humanize it and to draw a link between the ways in which so many of us are struggling with compulsive overconsumption and the ways in which some people develop severe life-threatening addictions.
So when we do something that is for us reinforcing, that releases dopamine, our reward neurotransmitter in the brain's reward pathway, and our pleasure-pain balance tilts to the side of pleasure. But no sooner has that happened than our brain adapts to that by wanting to restore a level balance. That process called neuroadaptation I like to imagine as these little gremlins hopping on the pain side of the balance to bring it level again. But the gremlins like it on the balance, so they don't get off as soon as it's level. They stay on until it's tilted an equal and opposite amount to the side of pain. That is the comedown, the hangover, the blue Monday, or just that moment of craving, right? Wanting to have one more glass of wine, eat one more cookie, read one more chapter in my romance novel. Now, if we resist the urge to consume more, then those gremlins hop off and a level balance or homeostasis is restored. But that's difficult to do. It takes some degree of distress tolerance. And a faster way to get back to homeostasis is just to consume more of our drug. But the problem is as we expose our brains to more of our drug over days to weeks to months to years, those gremlins start to multiply. They get bigger and stronger, and eventually we end up with enough gremlins to fill this whole room. And now we've entered addicted brain. We've changed our hedonic set point such that now we need more of our drug in more potent forms, not to get high, but just to level the balance and feel normal. And when we're not using, we're walking around with a balance that's chronically tilted to the side of pain, experiencing the universal symptoms of withdrawal from any addictive substance or behavior, which are anxiety, irritability, insomnia, dysphoria, and craving. Also importantly, once we've changed our hedonic or joy set point, other more modest rewards become less salient. So things that we used to enjoy are no longer enjoyable. And even highly enjoyable things like, you know, a very intense dramatic movie, after watching a gazillion movies, it's hard to find even a very intense movie reinforcing anymore. And so what I talk about in Dopamine Nation is the ways in which not just individually but nationally we have changed our hedonic or joy set point such that I think biologically we're really rewiring our brain such that we need more drugs and more potent forms just to feel normal. And when we're not constantly stimulating ourselves, we're walking around with a balance tilted to the side of pain, experiencing those universal symptoms of withdrawal. And it's important because if that's true, that it has very different implications for how we should approach modern life in order to flourish, in order to get joy. It means that instead of constantly seeking comfort, what we may in fact need to do is avoid these intense pleasures, or at least use them in extreme moderation, and turn toward challenge or difficulty or even physical pain in some ways in moderation, because it turns out those gremlins are agnostic to whatever the initial stimulus is. We know that if we press on the pleasure side, they go to the pain side. But if we intentionally press on the pain side, they will go to the pleasure side, and we can get our dopamine indirectly by paying for it up front. So this is things like exercise, right? Turns out that exercise is immediately toxic to cells, so it's harmful. But in sensing injury, our body starts to upregulate feel-good neurotransmitters like dopamine, norepinephrine, serotonin, endogenous opioids. And that high, it can last for hours after stopping exercise before coming back down to that level baseline of dopamine firing without going into that dopamine deficit or reward deficit state. Now that can also be abused. So this is the phenomenon of cutting.
Right. Which is not at all what we're recommending, but it does work through that same mechanism. The body senses injury, releases endogenous endorphins or opioids. People get high from that, but very quickly they develop tolerance. It stops working. They need to cut more. Plus, nobody is recommending injury.
You know, what we're recommending is leaning into right-sized pain or distress or tolerating distress, because in fact that is how we evolved. So this mechanism evolved for a world of scarcity and ever-present danger. It evolved for us to do a lot of upfront work to get a tiny little bit of reward. Whereas the world we live in now is really no upfront work and a huge bolus of reward.
What drew you into this world? I mean, there's so many different things you could have done. You could be like a, you know, setting bones as a medical doctor and, you know, orthopedic surgeon or all these different things. But why addiction? What drew you to this topic?
Well, you know, initially I really wanted to avoid treating patients with addiction. That was partly because I didn't learn very much in medical school or even in my psychiatry residency about how to treat patients with addiction. I also had what we call in psychiatry negative countertransference toward patients with addiction. That is some unconscious negative bias which probably came from the fact that my father, who was a surgeon, struggled lifelong with binge drinking. Never really, you know, got treatment for that problem. It caused a lot of harm in our family life, and I remember distinctly as a child the episodes when he would drink heavily and kind of disappear. So all of that played in the mix such that I really didn't want to treat patients with addiction. But I had a patient who I was seeing for about six months, treating her for depression. She would nod off in the sessions, and I thought maybe it was like a rare slow metabolizer of the Paxil that I was prescribing to her. And then one day she didn't show up, and her brother called and said that she'd been in a rollover car accident. And I said, "That's terrible. You know what happened?" And he said, "Well, she's been using again." And I remember thinking to myself, "I don't understand what he's saying." [laughter] And I said, "Using what?" And he said, "Using heroin. Isn't that what you've been treating her for?" So the family had been paying for me to treat this woman for nominally her heroin addiction, and I did not once ask her about drugs and alcohol. And it was in that moment that I realized that I was a bad psychiatrist essentially, that in my ignorance I was doing harm. And so that, and this was like the mid to late 1990s, and I decided at that moment to make a huge pivot and to learn as much as I could about addiction and to try to avoid making that terrible mistake again. And what I discovered was that when you actually ask patients about drugs and alcohol and addictive behavior, they're delighted to talk about it. They're desperate to talk about it, eager. And the other discovery I made is that when you actually target and treat addiction in patients who have other psychiatric problems, depression, anxiety, psychosis, not only does their addiction get better, but their co-occurring psychiatric disorder gets way better on a level that, you know, should I just hold this maybe?
No, I think [laughter] let me [gasps]
I have small ears and I think this is playing a role here.
I'll just keep fixing it. [laughter] Okay, there we go.
Can you still hear? Okay.
All right. Yeah. What I discovered is treating patients with addiction is pure joy. First of all, there are some of the most creative and tenacious people you'll ever meet, right? Once they get their claws into something, it's really hard to get their claws out. But when they get into recovery, I mean, boy, are these delightful, interesting, insightful, wise people.
Yeah. Tell us about maybe just a few people who've influenced your understanding of addiction, like individuals that you've worked with.
Yeah. There's so many, where to begin. I'll share a couple of stories of patients who have given me permission to talk about their care. So one young woman, just a delightful, bright, creative soul, who had dabbled in a whole bunch of different types of drugs, but ultimately got very addicted to nitrous oxide. And as you all may not know, but nitrous oxide is sort of a gas that comes in like a whipped cream canister. But over time, as per Dopamine Nation, it has become easier and easier to get. You can now actually go get scuba-tank-sized canisters of nitrous oxide, and people do. And what my patient talked about was how the drug gave her this incredible illusion of control because she could use it, be high for 30 seconds, come down, kind of return to reality, and then use it again.
And the reason that that's so compelling is because a big part of addiction is actually the desire for control. We often think about addiction as people wanting to escape, and that's certainly an element of it. But paradoxically, it's really this desire to feel as if in the microcosm they have some degree of control, whereas in the macrocosm they feel that their life is completely unmanageable. So it's like this search for grip or manageability in this small world within a world which they've created. Anyway, this patient, when she was under the influence, things went very, very badly in her life. Legal trouble, totally not herself. That's the other thing is that people in their addiction can look very personality disordered, whereas when they get into recovery they no longer look that way. And I think that's important too because it's so distressing for families, the ways in which people in their addiction really become completely not themselves, but in recovery return to the person that they were, and it's just so joyful to see that, and in many instances no longer meet criteria for personality disorder. So anyway, Julia, oh sorry, should have said her name. She's doing great. She's in early recovery. She's been able to weather some very difficult things in her life, including a recent miscarriage, but she's a delightful, brilliant young woman and has found her way back.
Another case I can share is a young man who got addicted to the internet and to social media. It started with just a video that kind of went viral, and then when he discovered sort of virality on the internet, started spending more and more time seeking likes and followers and that kind of social affirmation that he got there, and really got addicted to that experience of social validation on the internet. Stopped going to school, stopped studying, stopped interacting with friends, hence the irony of social media, not social at all. And eventually just really started to get deep into depression and anxiety, and ironically again deep self-loathing and shame, which comes often with severe addiction.
Yeah. So it's so interesting because for a while I wrote a Huffington Post article like weekly, and for a while I started like, oh my gosh, only 1,400 people liked this one, and you're right, he's like, I better check, it's like two hours, that maybe 200 more people started liking it. But yeah, I can imagine it leading to something just much more serious. So how do you get away from something like that? How do you, like once you're addicted to, you know, social media, how do you unwind that or step back from it?
Well, the way that we target this in youth in particular, especially when they become so severely addicted that they are not leaving their rooms, you know, they are not participating in life, they're very depressed, in some cases suicidal, we make it a family intervention. So that's really important because addiction is a family systems disease, which is not to say that it is the family that created the addicted individual. It's to say that once an individual in a family becomes addicted, the whole family is affected by that and can become a sick system in an effort to try to help that individual and can get caught up in, you know, enabling behaviors that don't on the surface appear to be enabling but that ultimately have that function. It's very complicated. But what we do is we bring the family in, you know, we talk about the neuroscience of pleasure and pain, we talk about the gremlins, and we talk about how we invite the adolescent to essentially do an experiment, and this is true for all forms of addiction, and to engage in this 30-day dopamine fast or to not use their drug for long enough for those neuroadaptation gremlins to hop off of the pain side of the balance and for homeostasis to be restored. And the idea is by doing that we get people out of the vortex of compulsive overconsumption for long enough to be able to see their addiction more clearly. Because when people are in their addiction, they really lack that awareness of the impact of their drug use or addictive behaviors on their life. Their pleasure-pain balance or their reward pathway has essentially been hijacked by this substance or behavior which their brain now mistakes as necessary for survival. So really the first or early intervention is to try to restore homeostasis for long enough, reset those reward pathways so that individual has a chance to kind of look at that behavior but also feel better, right? Begin to feel better. And usually that takes on average about 30 days of not using screens. Now, we change that for people, you know, let's say adults who can't get off their screens, right? We wouldn't say, well, don't, it's not to say you can't be on any screen for 30 days, but it's to say that how about that platform, whether it's pornography or video games or social media or...
gambling, right, or shopping, you know, we ask them to abstain from that for 30 days as a way to again reset reward pathways, get their frontal lobe back online, have more insight into their behavior, and see how they feel. And at the end of those 30 days, we have them do a pros and cons list. What was good about not using?
What was bad about not using? And on that pros list, typically there will be so many positive things. The foremost is I was just more present for my life, right? I was just able to enjoy things that I used to enjoy. I spent more time with people that I care about. I had a lot more time because it's like a full-time job maintaining an addiction, right?
So I had a lot more time. And also less anxious, less depressed, sleeping better. Now of course in those first two weeks of abstinence people feel worse before they feel better, right? So when we take that reward off the pleasure side, those gremlins that have been accumulating on the pain side of the balance smash it down, but slowly the gremlins get the message that they should get off, homeostasis is restored. So usually by week three or week four people start to feel better, and they feel not just better than they did in the first two weeks, but often better than they have in a really long time. But this is key because if we don't tell patients that they'll feel initially worse before they feel better, they'll try stopping their drug of choice and they'll be like, this is terrible, right? It's boring, you know, it's not working. So really, we really counsel a lot of patients here.
And then on the sort of con side, what was bad about not using, there are typically two things that stand out. Number one, I couldn't hang out with my friends, right? Because all my friends use and that's the way we socialize. And number two, I was really bored, right? I had all this time and I didn't know what to do with it. And that can be really scary to be bored. So being bored is not just sort of like I don't have anything to do. Being bored can be a profound existential discomfort of, oh wow, I don't have anything to do, so why do I do anything that I do, you know, and what is like the purpose and meaning of my life? And that's pretty scary in a world where we're constantly distracting ourselves from those deeper questions.
Yeah. I love what you say, and I love too the way that you outline it in the book. It's very clear. You know, I think of the way we deal with addiction, you know, we're having the methods that you're discovering as a practicing counselor for people, but we're also building on a framework. And maybe you could talk a little bit about just recovery movements in the 20th century like Alcoholics Anonymous, and what do ordinary people need to know about Alcoholics Anonymous, its philosophy, its history, that kind of thing.
Well, first of all, Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step groups that started in the 1930s are probably one of the most successful social movements over the past 100 years. People who actively participate in Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step groups actually show outcomes that are on par or better than people who get professionally mediated treatment like cognitive behavioral therapy or what have you. So these groups are effective when people actively participate, and they may be even more effective for the most severely addicted. So if you're talking about somebody who has a very severe addiction, they might actually do better by participating in 12-step groups than in seeking the help of a professional. Of course, these things are not mutually exclusive, you know. We encourage folks to do it all. And if you look at the data showing abstinence rates at a year, so you follow, which is a long time to follow people, it looks like folks who are actively participating in Alcoholics Anonymous have better outcomes than people who are getting professionally mediated care. The 12 steps are foundationally a spiritual program, but it's a spiritual program that really widens the lens to define the higher power as really anything that's not you.
Right, grounded on the idea that a big part of the disease of addiction is what they call self-will run riot, but basically a kind of pathological narcissism driving the addictive tendencies. Hence the core intervention or the key piece of the 12 steps is number one acknowledging that the behavior has become unmanageable, identifying a higher power, and then believing that by giving our will over to that higher power we can be restored to sanity, and then a really robust moral program that involves telling the truth, that involves doing character inventory, admitting our faults, and also importantly admitting what we have contributed to the problem. And I can tell you after 30-plus years of doing psychiatry and listening to many people tell their stories, it's been very interesting to note the difference in narrative between people who I can tell are in recovery or are getting into recovery and those who are stuck in their addiction. And almost universally, people who are stuck in their addiction will tell a story, a life story in which it's always somebody else's fault.
Right, they really are not able to see the ways in which they've contributed to the problem or to take ownership for any aspect of the problem. Whereas when people are in recovery, the hallmark of their personal narrative is almost always, you know, these things happened to me, they were not good, but here's what I do that contributes to and perpetuates this problem. And to me, that's fascinating, right? And really an important aspect of how we heal from addiction, and I would argue how we heal from life in general.
Yeah. Such an important thing for all of us. I guess that's part of the idea of like human sin. I mean it's like there's an ideal and we deviate from that. It's not something that should be a source of shame, but just a recognition that, you know, we're part of the reason why we deviated from what we desire to be, from what our potential might be. You know, I've been thinking, I mean there's, like I said when I first started, like dopamine is everywhere, but I've been thinking especially about just major policy changes in the United States in the last 10, 15 years. I was in Cambridge, Massachusetts last week for a colloquium from one of my old teachers. And you know, the biggest difference between Cambridge of today and Cambridge of back then when I lived there is there are cannabis shops all over the city. And I wonder if you can talk especially about cannabis, just its legalization. I don't often hear the story that there's like a financial, that it's a capital problem of capitalism, but what have we learned about legalizing cannabis? And then, you know, what should we take from that in terms of how we treat it in the future?
Yeah. So I mean California was the first state to make medical marijuana available.
What was quickly apparent was that the majority of individuals who were getting medical marijuana were otherwise healthy young men. The bar for obtaining cannabis was and continues to be very low, even for medical marijuana. You just need to find a doctor who, when they ask you, does cannabis or does medical marijuana help you, and you respond yes to that, you can get a medical marijuana card and that's it. There's really no other criterion. Since the original passage of medical marijuana in California, we've now made recreational marijuana also legal in the state. And the idea there was to really be able to tax recreational marijuana to use those funds to help redress the harms of people who had become addicted to marijuana. In general, sort of the overall trend and the big change with cannabis over the past 50 years or so is increasing potency of cannabis. So it's no longer the soft weekend drug that it was in the 60s and 70s. It's now available in 90% THC forms, dabbing, all different forms. But the other big change is that in the 60s and 70s the way people typically used cannabis was again low-potency pot on the weekends with friends. What we're seeing more and more of now is people smoking every day, all day, by themselves. So cannabis is starting, at least for people who smoke cannabis, it's starting to look a lot more like the way that people smoke and get addicted to cigarettes, right? It's sort of like an all-day thing. And because it's such a potent drug, it's also much more harmful, not just in terms of its addictiveness, so it's more...
addictive, but it's also very harmful in terms of its psychiatric impact. So cannabis is what we call a psychotomimetic, meaning that it can cause people to become psychotic. Psychosis is when people either have delusions or hallucinations. Delusions are thoughts that are inconsistent with reality. Hallucinations are things like seeing things that other people don't see or hearing voices that other people don't hear. And cannabis can make people psychotic, even people who do not have a psychotic disorder. And so we're seeing more and more cannabis-related psychosis and the harms that come with that. So it's become essentially a hard drug. It's a very addictive drug, and in clinic we're seeing it's sort of very common now in our addiction medicine clinic to treat people who are struggling with cannabis addiction.
You know, another thing I think of is just the proliferation of gambling, you know, so it's not just that there's online gambling. So there's the online element, but there's also just the deregulation of gambling. I wonder if you can talk a little bit about that, like why we have chosen this path, and are there ways that we might choose a different way of dealing with gambling?
I mean, as with all drugs, again, one of the biggest risk factors for addiction is simple access to that drug, and online sports betting, the legalization of online sports betting, is a great example of that. In states where online sports betting has become legal, calls to hotlines for pathological gambling have increased between 500 and 800%.
I can't remember the statistics now, but I think something like 50% of young men engage in online sports betting. So it's a huge practice now for people to gamble on sports and to do it on their phones. And with it, we're seeing a huge increase in people who get addicted to gambling. And addictive gambling can, like with all addictions, be life-threatening. You know, people get into serious debt, they become desperate, they become suicidal, sometimes they end their own lives. Again, I had a patient who had a trust fund that he inherited to use for medical school. He lost it all on sports betting. He then took out a loan to pay for medical school, and he lost that as well. So these are real kinds of people who get really caught in it. And of course now there are all of these ways in which gambling also has been made more potently reinforcing and more personalized, right? So the parlay bets where you have a series of bets stacked on each other which are pretty much guaranteed to lose your money and yet very reinforcing. And of course, now we have these, you know, Kalshi and these other prediction markets that are very reinforcing because they're binary. It's either up or down, yes or no. So they're highly addictive. They're available online. And again, they're also highly influenced by insider knowledge. So the average person who's engaging on these prediction markets is going to lose their money. So it's really a huge problem, and we're seeing again, especially with the betting and the gambling, more and more young men who are opting out of employment. And what are they doing? They're at home using pornography, doing gambling online, playing video games.
Yeah. So yeah, I had a friend my freshman year who, I mean, this is in the '80s, so he had a $12,000 gambling debt, and it was just kind of the end of that life. He couldn't be a normal college student after that. And I just can't imagine what it would be like if instead of just a few handful of people having exposure to it, if all of us did, you know, what that would mean. But I wonder if you can talk a little bit about pornography in particular, just how it changes, like what happens to us in the real world and how we are with people and how people relate with each other.
Yeah. So it's very hard to get numbers on pornography, on the use of pornography. But I can tell you in clinic, it was probably one of the earliest signals in terms of digital media addictions was middle-aged men coming in endorsing a severe pornography addiction which they attributed to the advent of the smartphone. So they had used pornography through much of their lives, but it was manageable until they had 24/7 access on the phone. And since then, we've just seen a huge, huge increase in addiction to pornography, compulsive masturbation, and sex more broadly. And these are very difficult addictions to overcome again because of the ubiquity and incredible access to these images, ever more graphic images, but also because of the predatory nature of the companies and the individuals who promote these images, actually seeking these people out, intruding on their inboxes, sending notifications so that even when people are trying to avoid this behavior, it's very hard to do. Also, as one of my patients said, the bar is in his brain when it comes to sex and pornography addiction, and that even fantasy becomes sort of a trigger for engaging in this problem. People often get uncomfortable, I mean understandably, talking about sex and pornography addiction, but I really think it's important that we normalize these discussions because the problem is enormous. And if you have a son or a grandson or a nephew who's eight years old or older, they have probably seen pornographic images already, even if you think they haven't. And if that child is uniquely vulnerable to pornography, which again, this whole drug of choice concept, we all have sort of unique wiring, and what's reinforcing for one may not be for another. But for a person who gets addicted to pornography, they can tell you the first time they were exposed, typically as a young child, and how incredibly reinforcing it was from the very first image, where their friends sort of looked at it and said, 'Oh, that's weird and creepy, and you know what's going on there,' and then ran off to play soccer. That child was mesmerized.
And that's why in the book I do try to draw this analogy between my own sort of compulsive problem with romance novels, which I talk about as socially sanctioned pornography for women, and the kinds of pornographic images that many men get addicted to, as a way again to humanize it and normalize it and, you know, even let's say put a positive spin on it. And what I say to my patients with sex addiction is, it's clear that you're interested in human beings, you know, and human attachment.
Yeah. And connection with other people.
And connection with other people. And somehow this very specific behavior has come to replace what you get from connections with other people, which is why it's so important in recovery that we foster, seek out, and make more robust those intimate human connections that mean so much to us, and that is ultimately our lifeblood. I also want to say, you know, I hope that this isn't like a downer, because people with addiction get into recovery, and there are millions of people all over the planet in decades-long sustained recovery from very severe addictions. There's enormous hope to be had.
Yeah. And I think of all those people in my life, they've been helpers, you know. I mean, so you know, people who I've known who have been in recovery have helped multiple people themselves, just one person, and have helped maybe a dozen, maybe two dozen other people. And it does give you hope that, you know, once we have experienced that shame, once we've experienced that sense of dependence, that it may help us to be better helpers to other people.
Well, absolutely, and of course that's all part of the 12 steps too, right? Trying to help another person struggling with addiction and how important that is.