Hello everyone, my name is Andrew, and welcome back to Frames of Space. In today's episode, I am thrilled to share a conversation with one of the most interesting thinkers in economics and much, much more. His name is Tyler Cowen.
Now, if you're not already familiar with him, Tyler is a professor at George Mason University and the director of the Mercatus Center, which is a think tank and an organization that he's helped to shape over the years. He is deeply involved in hiring bright talent at Mercatus, and he has a knack for spotting people who can do great work on things like market-oriented policy or economic research.
Now, if you've ever listened to Tyler Cowen's own podcast, Conversations with Tyler, you would know that he's a bit of a maverick in his interviewing style. For example, he famously avoids asking follow-up questions most of the time. Now, there is a method to that madness. He believes that follow-up questions often lead guests to restate what they've already said rather than covering fresh ground. This means that his conversations tend to roam across a spectacular range of topics rather than just sticking to one issue for the entire episode. And in many ways, that's Tyler's trademark approach. And trust me, this episode is no exception to the type of podcasting that Tyler is known for. Tyler is a huge generalist. He'll talk about AI, social media's effects on pessimism, the economics of inequality, cultural shifts in cinema, pretty much everything but the sink.
You might also know Tyler as a self-described libertarian, sort of. He's often one of the more libertarian-leaning people in the room, even if the staunchest libertarians might not say that he's pure enough for their label. That nuance of the extent to which he is willing to identify with the label of libertarian, it really shows up in our talk, where he explains how he squares his own free-market views with a reality that still requires some level of things like income redistribution or government intervention. So today's episode is one episode where you might hear many parallels to a Conversations with Tyler episode. There are plenty of quick pivots, a broad range, and a willingness to see where the guest or the host might lead. So without further ado, I present to you my interview with Tyler Cowen. Hope you enjoy.
Tyler Cowen, thank you so much for taking the time to come out to this podcast.
All right, so now I want you to inhabit an audience member that doesn't know who you are or what you do. Explain to the audience, what is the Mercatus Center and what is the work they're designed to achieve?
The Mercatus Center is a research center at George Mason University. It has been there since 1980. The single biggest thing we do is simply support graduate and undergraduate students who want to study economics and go out and have a broader impact in the world. But we also have elements that are a policy shop, and we bring in people who have good ideas on economic policy, typically in market-oriented directions, and we support them and market their work, and we put out podcasts. And I've been faculty director of the Mercatus Center since 1997.
What is it like being the faculty director?
Well, there's a lot of responsibility. Fundraising is a significant part of the job, but also making sure that Mercatus sees and advances important ideas and has talented people to work on them. That's extremely hard. It's much, much easier to fail at that than to succeed. And those are some of my responsibilities.
What is it like? So, like, you're essentially in charge of hiring at a major organization. How does that feel?
Well, there are several of us who have major roles. We also have an executive director right now that is Ben Klutzy, and most of the hiring would be done by Ben and/or co, or some of the hiring is just done by teams. So we have about 150 employees, and only at a high level would I be involved in their hiring, but nonetheless, indirectly, I'm responsible for all the hiring. There's a lot of delegation. A lot of my main roles are external or public rather than making sure, well, if we need a new receptionist, that I'm there to interview the person. That's something I don't do.
Yeah, but one thing I find very interesting is when you talk about how the Mercatus Center is for, I would maybe like, birthing undergraduate and graduate students. Do you think there's any kind of demarcation that you want to draw between the Mercatus Center and what a lot of academia is usually like?
We are much more concerned with applying economic ideas to the policy world than a lot of academia would be, not all of it. We're more interested in podcasts and blogging than much of academia would be. Again, I'm not saying it's an absolute distinction, plenty of academia does that too, but we do it systematically as part of our mission, and that's a difference.
Yeah, then there's one interesting train of this where you mentioned on one of your past podcasts that, like, sometimes you feel like there are people that are trapped in academia. Like, would you phrase it like there are certain people that are in academia but they would thrive better if they were in a setting that afforded them more creative freedom?
I agree with that. I mean, to be clear, plenty of them would just fail, right, and end up with some kind of service job. But you can have tenure, maybe you live somewhere you want to live, or your spouse has a job there, you're used to an academic lifestyle, it's not that easy to leave. But I think, I don't know, one, two percent of those people could really do something pretty phenomenal if they just pressed the eject button and got on with their lives. And I know it would be a less secure existence, and it wouldn't be clear every day what they do in the morning to organize what's going to happen next. But like Shadi Batal, who works at Mercatus, she was tenured teaching in New York City and gave that job up, and she's, you know, 100x more influential now because she did that. That would be one example.
Yeah, but like, I guess if we were to see academia as like a bit more rigid, a bit more structured, I guess then one like thing that is partly an outflow of that would be like a specific argument that I heard that I want your take on. What do you think of the criticism that academia is largely out of touch with the rest of the world, that it is essentially like its own bubble filled with like its own community that doesn't really talk that much to people that don't speak its language?
Well, academia is a very large thing, and big parts of it I don't know much about. So if I look at George Mason, I learned recently that one quarter of our students major in engineering. That's high, that's a lot higher than I thought it would be, and I actually think that's great, that's great news. I don't know what those people are doing, but I would be very reluctant to say they're not interacting with the real world. At some point they will be very clearly in the real world, mostly working on real-world problems, and I think that's a sign of the system correcting itself. Now, if you go to the humanities, I think on average the performance is much worse. Economics is one of the better fields, but I do think you have far too many economists. They simply write for the approbation of their peers, for letters of recommendation for their tenure case, and they're not writing for broader impact as they should be doing.
Yeah, so one of the things you mentioned about the Mercatus Center and something it does differently is it does a lot more podcasts. Do you see podcasts in general, like especially podcasts from academics, as a way to bridge the gap between, say, like human academia and like the real world?
I don't think they need to be from academics. Maybe on average academics are worse at doing podcasts because they are not forced to get to the point by their other training. But I think if you have good content and a clearly defined niche, you can get considerable mindshare from important and influential people by doing podcasts, and there's still room for more. So if you do something Joe Rogan-like, you can make a lot of money. That's not mainly how people can succeed, but if you want an actual audience, I would say try doing a podcast, just make it good and don't worry whether or not you're an academic.
Yeah, make it good and make it consistent, and that's all that matters.
And have it, you know, it should have a clear image. So if your podcast is, well, you know, I focus on the Dobro guitar, like that's an obscure thing, right? But in fact, there are people out there who play the Dobro, they probably don't already have their own podcast, and if you're thinking of doing that, you should do it.
How do you see your podcast in that case?
Mine is a funny mix between being quite general and pretty well known and being quite niche. It's hard to characterize. I cover far more topics than would be wise for almost any podcast, but part of the niche of mine is, in a way, like me showing off that I can cover so many topics, and that's a niche thing. But we have a big audience, and, you know, we don't make any money or have ads or, you know, sell it in any way, but my plan is just to keep on going. I think I have one of the world's best and smartest audiences.
I guess then, if your podcast covers so many topics, how do you decide which areas you want to study very deeply and which areas you just want to remain like a generalist in?
Well, it's really pretty selfish and arbitrary on my part. So if I want to learn an area, I'll like think of a guest, or if a new book takes my fancy, I think, well, I like that book because it was interesting to me, I should read more in the area, and then I'll just do it. So there's a lot of people who are probably very good guests, but I don't do them, you know, I'm not paid, and I just don't want to go through that topic, no, no slight intended to them at all. So if I ever turn you down for my podcast, any listener out there, that's probably the reason why, not that I think like you're not good enough.
Yeah, okay, so one, one, a guy with some YouTube channel, he, he travels the world, it seemed very interesting, but I felt I'd have to spend like 20 hours listening to him on YouTube, and he is very good, but it just didn't feel to me like that, that's where I'm at right now. But theoretically, if you found some like Russian historian that talked about like some like event or some conflict that you thought was really interesting, you would, you be willing to spend like 20 hours studying for that?
Oh, more than 20 hours, you know, I might read 40 or 50 books on it. So, yeah, it's quite arbitrary and selfish, basically.
Yeah, um, do you ever enjoy like hosting a podcast where you're talking about one topic and then you suddenly like abruptly pivot to like a completely different topic, and then like, do you enjoy asking like very abrupt questions that feel unrelated to like whatever topic you had just been discussing?
Well, people say I do that all the time, but to me they feel very related, so I don't feel that that's what I'm doing. I would admit like how other people describe me is more accurate than how I would describe myself, but it's all about like how does the person think. It's what I'm trying to get at, and I think I'm along the same lines of questioning.
Do you, do you enjoy asking follow-up questions, or do you think follow-up questions in an interview are overrated?
They're overrated. Most people are not good at answering follow-ups. They repeat what they said already in an inferior way. There are exceptions to that, but it's hard to get into an actual back-and-forth dialogue. Now, I just recorded one with Scott Sumner, and I did have some follow-up questions, and I felt he was very good at not just repeating what he said the first time, so I'm glad I did that, but I would say at least three-quarters of guests, I think follow-up questions are mostly a mistake.
Well, I guess just to add my own editorializing into the ring, I guess my take is that in my favorite episodes of yours are the ones where you do have follow-up questions. Like I really loved your conversation with Jonathan Haidt because you did ask quite a bit of follow-up questions, and I think the guest answered those questions pretty well.
Well, I think that's consistent with my view, though. If only some people are good at follow-up questions, those people on average are in some way better guests, right? So if the better guests are your favorite episodes, it may or may not be causal that you like them because I have follow-up questions, they're also just better guests. It doesn't mean you necessarily think I should do that with everyone.
Yeah, but like it does mean that like there is a selection effect where the guests where you tend to ask follow-up questions, those tend to be better episodes because the selection effect dictates that like in general those guests are better on average in the first place.
And on average, I have more respect for them, whether or not they're better, I would say that's correlated, but someone could dispute that. And if I have more respect for them, that's another way it might make the episode better.
Yeah, I guess then one question I have as a result is like when you're podcast hosting different guests, how do you determine whether a guest's arguments are worth pushing back on, and like how do you determine when it's not worth like asking those sorts of follow-up questions and just moving on?
Well, any guest I've heard already on YouTube or their other podcasts, almost everyone has those, so I make a judgment. But even apart from that, somehow I feel intuitively in the first minute or two a sense of whether they can do it, even if I had to approach the whole thing blind. So you can just tell by how engaged people are in having a sequence of claims that are new rather than repetitive. Even on the first round of an answer, you get a sense of how a second round might go.
So like sometimes that's a judgment call that you make like during the episode itself and not beforehand?
Absolutely. I mean, I have put in work beforehand, but even if I hadn't, I feel I would have a reasonable sense of how it would go.
Yes, so on a, I, I, I would consider this an unrelated note, but maybe you could find some kind of tether to highly related.
I know this already. All right.
On a, on a highly related note, um, could you explain why you are a libertarian?
Well, most libertarians would say I'm not one, just to start off the bat. But I look at it this way: let's say I go to a public event with a lot of well-known people, say there's a hundred of us there, odds are I'm one of the three most libertarian people in that room. So if someone says I'm a libertarian, I don't run away from it. They have pretty good reasons for thinking it, but the people who are like true capital L libertarians would mostly say I'm not, I'm not close enough to it for them. So I don't outright just say I'm a libertarian, but on economics, I'm much more free-market oriented than most of my peers in the economics profession. In general, I think it's wrong to send people to jail for things they do to themselves, that makes me pretty libertarian on social issues. On foreign policy, I'm more of a hawk than many libertarians. I'm not sure how much that rules me out. I guess I think of it as the more libertarian point of view, but I certainly think that's contentious, right?
Yeah, then I guess something that I would wonder is like, to what extent do you think your, like, so obviously you would consider yourself to be a libertarian, so maybe that's sufficient. Do you think that your libertarianism is a product of like moral conviction or utilitarianism? Like one way I would phrase it would be like, do you think libertarianism is like inherently correct from like a fundamental philosophical point of view, or are you a libertarian because this specific political context suggests that libertarianism would be the most like utility-maximizing ideology?
I once wrote in my book, Stubborn Attachments, that I'm a two-thirds utilitarian, and that was tongue-in-cheek. I would say on economic issues, I'm almost completely consequentialist or even utilitarian. On a lot of social issues, I would grant some kind of strictly enforced moral code that morality by law might be better. I just think it's wrong to coerce people, so on that I would say it's mostly not utilitarian. Then on foreign policy, maybe I'm a hawk in that I think we need to ensure that civilization continues in the world, that will involve some rights violations.
What, what rights violations?
Well, U.S. foreign policy causes a lot of rights violations. Some of them are wrong and unjustified, but some, some of them are necessary, and I just think we need to do it, that otherwise the world will collapse into some state of affairs, you know, say pre-1945.
What rights violations from the U.S.'s foreign policy establishment do you think are justified?
I don't think there's a good abstract answer to that question. I would just say when you fight any war, typically you kill a fair number of innocent people. Not saying all those wars are justified. Vietnam War was not, for instance. But the Iraq War was not justified. So, sorry, the Iraq War was also not justified. That's more complicated, and there's several Iraq Wars, right? A Korean War, I would say, was justified. So it's going to depend. But it's also taxation at home, and that's coercive as well. And in earlier times, you know, it may or may not have required a draft, and that's clearly coercive. So there's some heavy-duty coercion going on there. It's one reason libertarians would say I'm not a libertarian.
Yeah, but like you would, so like, but you would say that you are a libertarian, so I guess I want to flesh out.
I wouldn't insist on it. I again, I wouldn't deny it, but I don't insist on claiming that word. I'll just say I'm more libertarian than most of my peers, and other people can call me what they want.
Yeah, so like you're not opposed to it, but it's not like a hill that you would die on, like calling yourself a libertarian.
Correct. And I think on foreign policy, my prescriptions lead to a more libertarian world than what the libertarians claim they want, which is strict non-interventionism. People are going to disagree about that.
Yeah, so then I guess one thing that I'm very interested in fleshing out is your, your, how your ideology relates to economics. So like, would you consider economic efficiency to be one of the most important goals for people, like for society to achieve right now, and if so, why?
There's a lot of big concepts behind that question. I want to know what's the policy area, what's the country you have in mind. But think of economic efficiency as roughly equivalent to growing wealth. We have a number of places in the world today that are not growing their wealth, like the United Kingdom, and they're pretty miserable and they're failing. So I'm a big believer in having GDP growth.
No, but most of the time it's going to come together with other good things.
Yeah, but not at more liberty, not at all costs. Like, like you would acknowledge that there are some times where there is a trade-off between efficiency and fairness.
Let's say if the UK were to execute all of its alcoholics, that people would stop drinking and they would grow more rapidly, I would not favor that. That would be an example.
Yeah, would you favor like Amazon's exploitation of its laborers in terms of like constantly keeping their mind on the clock and trying to maximize output as much as possible, even if it leads to like cruel working conditions?
There's a lot of premises behind that question. I've never been inside an Amazon plant. My impression from a distance is that those are better jobs than what the people would get otherwise, so I tend to be for them. I'm open to more evidence, but that would be my immediate response.
Okay, um, do you think that economic efficiency is like sufficiently prized among economists? Like, do you think that economists prize economic efficiency to the extent that it is worthwhile to do so in society?
Most economists will say they do, but then they'll go away and take their actual views from NPR and the New York Times. So in that sense, I'll say no, but if you just polled them, I think you'd get pretty reasonable answers. So it depends on how you're going to look at this.
So do you think that economists are engaging in preference falsification in, in terms of what they say they would prize compared to what economic policies they would prize?
No, I think they're mostly sincere. Some of them might be saying it cynically to go along with the crowd, but I think it's more likely a conformism that people grow into believing.
Could you elaborate on the whole thing about conformism that they grow into believing?
Well, they're surrounded by other graduate students, faculty, that's the audiences they need to please. Academia in economics, it's not left-wing, but it's quite Democratic Party-oriented. So those are the views, either explicitly or implicitly, that you're encouraged to have. You keep on running into evidence for those views, and over time you grow to hold them, and maybe you, you held them to begin with. It's just a very common story. I think there's some amount of cynicism, but I sometimes like to say sincerity is the most underrated motive, and I think that's true here as well. Even with politicians, I think a great number of them are pretty sincere.
Yeah, it reminds... so this is, this is going to sound hackneyed, but maybe it's actually completely relevant. Um, it reminds me of this one quote from the video game Metal Gear Solid 2, where like they're talking about the prevalence of like echo chambers online, where like there are like cardinal truths that neither clash nor mesh. So when you're trying to like, like build up your own worldview, you can just like only look at the truths that like sort of seem to validate you, and like as a result, when you retreat into like those echo chambers, like nobody is invalidated, but nobody's right.
But mainstream Democratic Party-leaning academia in economics, it's hit by it pretty strongly.
Yeah, um, so I was, I was gonna say on an unrelated note, but I'm sure that this is actually completely related, even if I don't realize it. Um, would you be opposed to, like, within the U.S.'s current, um, economic system, would you be opposed to income redistribution on purely utilitarian grounds?
I think there's a utilitarian case for income redistribution, but I think the strongest case for income redistribution is that you need some of it to keep your democracy up and running. So the force of that second case and the kind of redistribution you need will typically outweigh the force of the first case. I would agree that both are valid cases, but the second one is typically what's going to really matter.
All right, elaborate on like your characterization of the second argument then.
Well, most voters, including Republicans, favor income redistribution, social safety net, and I think we're very far from a world where that is not true, and it's true in all the wealthy countries, all the democratic wealthy countries. So you have to take that somewhat as a constraint. I don't think it's going to change. So the kind of oppression you would need to blunt those desires, you could say to people, well, we should redistribute much less, it would be better to invest all that in science or taking care of immigrants. It could even be true from a utilitarian point of view that that would be better, but you're not going to persuade your citizens of it. So you need to go along with a version of a social safety net that will allow enough people to agree so your semi-free society keeps on progressing and holding free elections. And really, a lot of countries have succeeded in doing that. I think it's quite impressive.
Are you saying that you would be more like sympathetic to the argument for income redistribution on political grounds rather than moral grounds?
They both point in the same direction, and the political one is stronger, is how I would put it. The moral grounds argument, it depends what, what else you're doing with the money. So if you would take that money and send it to very poor people in Africa or use it to support their immigration, like the moral argument then goes away. But if it's, well, have a safety net or, you know, give subsidies to agribusiness, well, it's clear the moral argument then points in favor of the safety net.
Do you think there are any important negative externalities that come from large levels of income inequality within a society?
Any? That's a dangerous word to use. I'll say this: there's a book coming out in 2025 by Lane Kenworthy where he goes through all the evidence and he shows it's very difficult to show that income inequality causally has bad effects. And Lane is on the left. It's a very good book. So when you say any, I don't know, like it's probably going to be something, but I think those effects are significantly overrated. And if anything, income inequality might be a symptom of some bad features of your society, like too much crony capitalism. Take Russia as a super obvious example. But it's not like the causal reason why your median voter has high blood pressure, say.
Yeah, all right. Um, can you explain the concept of the hedonic treadmill to our audiences?
Well, the way I think of it is that some people, as they acquire more wealth or a better situation, they come to expect more, and they don't end up all that much happier. I'm not saying I agree with this claim, but that's how I understand the hedonic treadmill argument. I think it's pretty clear that people, with some qualifications, but they have more wealth, typically they're better off, is my view. I think there's less of a treadmill than is commonly believed.
But maybe there is a very sharp law of diminishing returns when it comes to the net benefit, like from, from the iPhone 7 to the iPhone 11, where tons and tons of money was invested in trying to improve like the iPhone just a little bit from generation to generation, but the actual net utility that it grants people or the net increased amount of joy that it gives people is not actually worth the enormous amount of money that Apple puts into making new iPhones every few years.
Well, when it comes to well-being, I think there's a cardinal element and an ordinal element, and I'm pretty sure the cardinal element maxes out.
Could you explain what a cardinal element and what like an ordinal element is roughly?
The cardinal element is your happiness. Do I get more joy if I'm a billionaire and I can buy a better ice cream cone? I think, in fact, the billionaire cannot buy a better ice cream cone than what I can buy. But that said, there's other aspects of your well-being that simply come from the desire to be able to do certain things. So if a multi-billionaire gives away wealth to help solve some problem in Africa, I don't know that that makes the person happier, but it's a preference the person had, and it's part of their well-being. Maybe it's a kind of satisfaction. People who have children, they may or may not be happier in the sense of being relaxed, feeling at ease, but they might have more joy, they might also have more frustration, they're probably more stressed, they have less ability to do what they want. I think quite a few of them are somewhat less happy, but they're more satisfied that they have one kind of life rather than another. So happiness is complicated. The fact that one part of happiness, you know, maxes out at some income level doesn't mean that all of human well-being does. So that's why I don't fully buy into this hedonic treadmill thing. It's not all hedonic, is one way to put it.
Would you accept the premise that like within first-world countries like the U.S. and in the world at large, like general people's general quality of life and like material living conditions have improved dramatically over the past few decades?
Probably. Again, I want to know the country. When you say a few decades, you...
I know I want to know the years, but in general, yes, living standards have improved, but at a slower rate than what they used to do, say, you know, 1948 through 1973, for instance.
All right, how about material living conditions for the US since the turn of the century?
That's quite complicated. Overall, they've improved, but it's been disappointing, I would say.
Okay, so then I guess the question is, like, do you think that all of the technological innovation that Apple did to go from like the iPhone 7 to the iPhone 11, do you think that that actually led to any kind of substantial improvements in happiness compared to if that money was funneled to help deal with like poverty?
I don't think I know the differences between those two iPhones, or late iPhone is much better than early iPhone. You have to ask, like, what's the institutional system you have in mind that turns Apple resources into poverty alleviation? What I see is that the success of the iPhone led to a lot of copying and a lot of cheaper smartphones, and those actually have done a lot to fight poverty. So I would look at it that way.
You think that they did more to fight poverty than if like the government were to increase taxation on those corporations to fund like a greater child tax credit?
Probably yes. You look at the impact of smartphones in Africa, Philippines, I think it's been pretty phenomenal.
All right, so then would you reject the premise that there is a sharp law of diminishing returns when it comes to the US economy's current allocation of resources and its like slavish, what I would characterize as like a slavish devotion to like marginal technological improvements on leisurely things?
I think those marginal improvements are part of a broader competitive environment that spreads around the whole world and makes many billions of people much better off. So they don't upset me at all. I say, bring it on.
Yeah, so you're broad, would you say that you're broadly supportive of them?
On a completely related note, what are some ideological positions that like you've changed your mind on in recent years?
Well, what's recent years? What's ideological? You know, at first I thought Bitcoin was a bubble and a fraud. I don't think that anymore.