Today is October 26, 2026, and my guest is economist, author, blogger, podcast host, and omnivore Tyler Cowen of George Mason University. He blogs at Marginal Revolution with Alexander Tabarrok. His podcast is, of course, Conversations with Tyler. This is his 21st appearance on the program. He was last here in March of this year, 2026, talking about AI, education, and employment. Tyler, welcome back to EconTalk.
I am always happy to be back here, and once again, education is at least one of our topics.
Yeah, our formal topic is the essayist, 16th-century essayist Michel de Montaigne. I want listeners to know that, like Montaigne, we may touch on some adult themes. Those listening with small children may want to filter this essay, this episode. I also want to recommend Stefan Zweig's brief biography of Montaigne, which is absolutely lovely. I'm going to give a very brief biography of Montaigne before we start, Tyler, which is: he was born 1533, died 1592, born into a wealthy family near Bordeaux. He served as a judge. At the age of 38, he withdrew into a tower, a library on his estate that had, you can see, I think still see them in photos, philosophical maxims painted on the ceiling, on the beams, and he began writing. His essays appeared in 1580. He expanded and edited and wrote more until his death. He was elected mayor of Bordeaux. Suffered from kidney stones, which he writes about at some length in the book.
But what makes him, and this by the way is not my assessment, this is Claude's, I think it's consistent with what I know about Montaigne, I'm not an expert, but what makes him matter is that he invented a new way of thinking on the page. Essai in French means to try. Rather than building a system or defending a doctrine, he tested his own mind against everything from cannibals to death. He made himself the subject of his essays, and his motto was, What do I know? Shakespeare was influenced by him. Pascal didn't like him. Emerson and Nietzsche revered him. Nearly every personal essayist since is in his debt. And this last sentence I like from Claude: he remains the great patron of the open, curious, and self-questioning mind. So for listeners out there who've never read Montaigne, this will be a little bit of an introduction. I said to Tyler, let's take four essays of Montaigne. We may not get to all of them, but we picked four of the essays. Some of the essays are quite long, 50, 60 pages. Some are two pages. For those who can see, this is my edition of the collected essays. It's a fat book. What do you think, Tyler, of having dipped back into Montaigne?
I think he might be the best model in the history of Western thought of how to encompass intellectual, religious, practical, and political tolerance into a way of thinking that should not be called a system, but nonetheless broadly coheres together. And he did that in a way that was truly humane. And there's nothing in his life really to counter that notion that he was in fact a tolerant man. And he was doing all this in the midst of the French Wars of Religion. And that stands to me as a remarkable achievement.
Would you recommend him to our listeners?
You can't read them all at once. I recommend dipping in. If you read them all at once, you will overdose, and a lot of the very short essays need real concentration, even if they're three or four pages. There's a lot packed in there. The single best one, which was too long for us to do, but that's Apology for Raymond Sebond. If you're only going to read one and have the time for an intense, you know, 200 pages or so, I would go there. But the four we're going to discuss are also wonderful places to start, and they're much shorter.
You know, given that I was knowing that I was going to be interviewing you, that's not the right word, knowing that we would be talking about Montaigne's essays, I couldn't help but be struck by the fact that in some dimension he's not just the first essayist, which is his sort of, I guess, claim to fame for what it's worth. He's kind of the first blogger. You know, he's a little bit self-indulgent. He's his own editor. He doesn't take out anything. He goes on and on as some bloggers are wont to do. Not you, Tyler, but you know, Tyler.
Yeah. He cites examples without explaining them. That's what I like to do.
Yeah, exactly. So do you think that's a fair assessment of him?
Yes, and he had a very strict educational upbringing of his own. And I think part of what's going on in these essays is he is rebelling against that. But reading the essays, you can't help but wonder, well, if he became such an important intellectual figure, was not his own education, which is more one of Renaissance humanism, actually much better than he would let on. And the other point, I think, is, you know, in the Wars of Religion, I think he was not taking sides. And when he was serving as mayor of Bordeaux, he had to get the different factions to work together. And I even doubt if he was actually genuinely a Christian at all.
He's not the most Christian in the essays that I read, but he invokes God a number of times and nature in a very Smithian way, I would say, very much like Adam Smith does. He's very happy to refer to the natural world and its laws, as he often calls them, as coming from God in some sense. And he seems, I would say, to be a believer in the fact that if it's natural, it's good. That there's some purpose that he may not fully understand, but letting things run their course and to learn from the way the world is structured, not the people in it, but the way pain and immortality and mortality and other things work in the world and in the animal kingdom is something he wants to learn from, and he assumes he can learn from it.
While he disagrees with the Stoics and Plutarch on many points, I view him as coming out of that tradition more. And just to skip ahead, you know, the essay on experience, on the very last page, here's a quotation that really struck me. And this gets to my point of wondering how Christian he is. And I quote: the most beautiful of lives to my liking are those which conform to the common measure, human and ordinate, without miracles though and without rapture. So he seems to be saying, you know, Christ is not the most beautiful of lives. That humans in a way have better lives than Christ did.
Yeah, I mean I agree that he wasn't, there's nothing Christian as far as I understand it in this writing, but it's not, he invokes God a lot. That's all I meant. He's not...
I strongly think he believed in God,
but doubted it was a Christian God.
Or an organized religious God.
Certainly not a Catholic God.
Let's start with the education essay, which of the four we read, I thought was by far the best overall, though there were some significant stretches where I lost interest. But the parts that kept my interest are quite spectacular. And part of me wants to just read, you know, two-thirds of the essay out loud, but let me start with a quote. He wrote this for a woman who was expecting a child and was giving her some advice at her request on how she might educate him. And he starts off early on talking about what kind of tutor is the right one. And this I think is magnificent. Select his guide for him, a tutor with a well-formed rather than a well-filled brain. Let both be looked for, but place character and intelligence before knowledge, and let him carry out his responsibilities in a new way. Teachers are forever bawling into our ears as though pouring knowledge down through a funnel. Our task is merely to repeat what we have been told. I would want our tutor to put that right as soon as the mind in his charge allows it. He should make it show its mettle by appreciating and selecting things and by distinguishing between them. The tutor should sometimes prepare the way for the boy, sometimes let him do it all on his own. I do not want the tutor to be the only one to choose topics or to do all the talking. When the boy's turn comes, let the tutor listen to his pupil talking.
He had his own tutor when he was a boy. His family was wealthy by the standards of its time, and it is believed the tutor would only speak Latin to him, forcing him to learn Latin. But supposedly the tutor also instructed him in German. So I think he's also writing about himself there. Like, don't give your kid a tutor of the sort I had. But are we not glad that he was fluent in Latin?
Yeah. Well, learned from a very young age. I have the Screech translation, and one of the things that's wonderful about it is that he's constantly quoting classical aphorisms and quotations, and many of them are quite lovely, which I guess he was quite familiar with things that were written in Latin. But what do you think about this idea? For his time, it's kind of shocking that you don't want a well-filled brain for your tutor, but a well-formed one. And what do you think that says about using AI as a tutor? Does it resonate at all with you?
Well, I think we're moving back to an age of tutors. Partly, there are just many more wealthy families. There's also more homeschooling, but AI is itself a tutor. So we're going to test his view that tutors are better than group instruction. But mostly, I agree with his view. So I will side with him there. Though what the tutor should do, I think, is teach the kid how to learn, more than fill the kid's head with propositions. So he's rebelling against Erasmus there. Also, you could argue rebelling against Rabelais. A lot of people slightly before him had the sense you cram the kid full of classical learning and Renaissance humanism. And although he's often considered a Renaissance humanist, in this essay, he's not. He's the rebel.
Yeah, I'm going to put a little twist on what you said. You tell me if you like it or not, and we'll probably have an episode coming up soon that goes into more depth on this. But you said it, the tutor's job is to teach the student how to learn. And I would have said that until a few weeks ago. I've started to think about the idea, and of course, that's to some extent a cliché. It's not obvious how you do it. That's a start, but it's not obvious what the technique is. But I think the tutor's job is something narrower, which is to teach the student the pleasures of curiosity and the pleasures of learning, to model that and wet that appetite if possible. What do you think of that?
That's part of it, but you know, on this issue I am torn. So if we think of the Victorians, who are pretty successful on the whole, to say the least, it was very common at that time that students would memorize entire poems, and those poems were long. And if nothing is, you know, filling the kid's head with facts, lines, poetry, it's memorizing poems. And maybe that's just a good idea. Maybe that's why so many people wrote so beautifully is that their heads were crammed from an early age. So I understand it's not possible to do that anymore in an age of television, internet, greater parental freedoms, less authoritarian norms. But still, maybe there's something to be said for cramming the kid's head with facts and poems and memorization and rote.
Well, I think that's true too. I mean, Dan Willingham was a guest on the program long, long time ago, and I associate him with this viewpoint that this emphasis on learning how to learn or on process without facts is empty. That you have to have a foundation of knowledge of just facts, whether it's lines of poetry, mathematical multiplication tables, and so on. And I think there is a dance in education, and I'm sure you feel it, I'd be curious if you agree, between absorbing information, which you and I do through a lot of old-fashioned reading, absorbing information, absorbing ideas. And for me, it's often seeing connections between ideas that I didn't notice before. And you can't make connections unless you have things to connect. And I think what makes Claude and others so powerful is that for them everything connects. And it's a mixed bag as a result, but the patterns that they notice, the things that LLMs want to apply, old structures to new examples, is really for me a very important part of intelligence. It could be because it's what I think I am pretty good at, and so maybe it's just a bias, but for me that's a lot of what intelligence seems to be.
You know, I'm struck also by Torah study. I mentioned the Victorians. Torah study to me seems like it's been a highly effective method, not just for teaching people about the Torah, which is obvious, but for getting people to excel in other intellectual areas. There seems to be a long, centuries-long history of this working. No? You're in Israel.
Yeah, and I've studied the Torah a little bit. I actually, I'm going to, I have a feeling that Montaigne would not like some things about Torah study. I'll come to that in a second. Let me say something about Torah study. Torah study, study of the Hebrew Bible and then the Talmud, which is a commentary on the Bible and other oral transmissions. It's about trying to figure out what it means, but often trying to see connections between disparate pieces of the canon of Jewish wisdom. And when you see a connection like this, and for those who know Rabbi Forman of Aleph Beta, he's an extraordinary modern example of this, it lights up something inside you. The aha moment is really quite special. But here's what Montaigne said about commentaries, because most of Jewish knowledge and wisdom and study, it starts with the book, but then there's a commentary on the book, and then there's a commentary on the commentary. And in modern yeshivot, in modern yeshivas, places of Jewish study and seminaries, what people are doing are reading the original, but they're also reading a lot of the commentaries and then the commentaries on the commentaries. And Montaigne didn't like that. Here's what he said. Can anyone deny that glosses, let me interrupt for a sec, by gloss he meant a commentary. Can anyone deny that glosses increase doubts and ignorance when there can be found no book which men toil over in either divinity or the humanities whose difficulties have been exhausted by exegesis? The hundredth commentator dispatches it to his successor, prickling with more difficulties than the first commentator of all had ever found in it. Do we ever agree among ourselves that this book already has enough glosses? From now on there's no more to be said on it. That can be best seen from legal quibbling. We give force of law to an infinite number of legal authorities, an infinite number of decisions, and just as many interpretations. Yet do we ever find an end to our need to interpret? Can we see any progress or advance towards serenity? End of quote. You know, so what he's saying there basically is it just expands the area of ignorance, his claim. I don't agree with him entirely, but I do agree that many, many things, Homer just to take one example, should not be read with secondary sources. Should read the primary source, and that's sufficient. What do you think?
He may be criticizing the scholastics there also. It's striking to me that when Montaigne was in Rome he visited a synagogue and he praised it for being so intellectual and thoughtful, which was a shocking remark to make at the time. There's a lot of people in the history of thought who will advocate religious tolerance, and then they'll turn around and there'll be some offhand remark, but of course we must crush the Jews, or sometimes even the Catholics. And it seems he was genuinely consistent.
Let me give you my favorite sentence from the essay on education, or part of a sentence.
That last one I just read happened to be from Experience, his essay on Experience. We'll stick with education for a while because I have a few other things we'll talk about. Go ahead.
This is so much ahead of its time, quote: the greatest and most important difficulty in human knowledge seems to lie in the branch of knowledge which deals with the upbringing and education of children. So when you look at current debates about Alpha School or does spending more money lead to kids being better educated, it's actually hard to figure out the right answers.
And he understood that. This is the hardest thing to figure out is how to bring up your kid. And that I thought was the best fragment of a sentence in the whole essay.
And I think the reason he understood it is also not a small thing. A theme that runs through the essays we read is the complexity of the human being and how different people are, not just from each other but from themselves at different times or different issues they have to deal with, their inconsistency. So of course raising a kid, it's impossible. There's no manual.
You can even ask Claude, right? But it's still a hard thing to do.
I don't think he gets it right. I loved what he said about assessment testing. This is what he wrote. This is also way ahead of its time. Or a better way to say it is it's just as appropriate today as it was in the 16th century. Let the tutor not merely require a verbal account of what the boy has been taught, but the meaning and substance of it. Let him judge how the child has profited from it, not from the evidence of his memory, but from that of his life. Let him take what the boy has just learned and make him show him dozens of different aspects of it, and then apply it to just as many different subjects in order to find out whether he has really grasped it and made it part of himself. Judging the boy's progress by what Plato taught about education. And now he has a quote that's really kind of perfect: spewing up food exactly as you have swallowed it is evidence of a failure to digest and assimilate. The stomach has not done its job if during concoction it fails to change the substance and the form of what it is given.
I think that's part of his ongoing intellectual war against Plutarch. Like when he says, let him not be taught so much the histories of lives as how to judge them.
Say something about Plutarch. He has a book called Lives, right? So...
He did a book Lives and also Moralia. And Plutarch, it actually was not the real Plutarch, but people at the time thought that Plutarch was author of an essay on education. And Montaigne was very influenced by that essay, which he thought was Plutarch. It turns out it's probably not. And there's this whole back current of what everyone else wrote, you know, Quintilian and Plato and Erasmus and Plutarch. And he has all that in his head. And whether or not you've read those pieces, it's useful to read this essay on education with all that as background. A lot of the offhand remarks are comments on these other people. And he's basically jabbing them in a very polite way and without mentioning them by name usually.
Yeah, I have a soft spot for Plutarch. This is an aside because of a quote. And I'm going to quote the quote, but of course it's not a quote because Plutarch didn't write in English. So whoever translated this translated it in a particularly powerful way. He said, very Montaigne-like, he said, the mind is not a vessel to be filled but a fire to be kindled. It's kind of a perfect quote about a particular style of education. Obviously he never said that because he wrote Latin. So when you look for the actual quote, which I've done in the past, I forgot how it actually was termed, but somebody really crafted a lovely translation of that line to make it memorable.
One thing that really struck me on this reread of the essay, which I hadn't read in probably more than 40 years, is how much of it is like John Dewey. And that I was not expecting.
The ultimate test is in praxis. You think of things in terms of systems and lived experience, and does something work? And education is supremely practical. This line he has, to quote: the surest sign of wisdom is constant cheerfulness. I don't actually agree with that. But nonetheless, it's an interesting claim. And the supremacy of lived life is again an idea well ahead of its time.
It's kind of a strange thing when you think about it. He's in this library of his for what, a couple decades? So he's not really living much. He lived a lot as a youth. He describes his sexual experiences, his military experiences, or at least knowing about such stuff. And you're right. The proof is in the power of how it changes how you behave, how you experience life. And yet in a way, he's the ultimate ivory tower kind of guy.
He's pro-travel on the printed page. I'm not sure how much he traveled in his lifetime. I know he went to Rome. I don't think he could have traveled all that much. But the idea that the whole world is your study, right?
And to be places is itself a form of learning.
Kind of your motto, I would say.
Absolutely, very much so.
Yeah, I was going to ask you about travel. You're a famous traveler. He says, again, I don't know if this is from his own experience, he says, for this purpose, mixing with people is wonderfully appropriate. So are visits to foreign lands, but not the way the French nobles do it, merely bringing back knowledge of how many yards long the Pantheon is, or of the rich embroidery on Signora Livia's knickers, nor the way others do so, knowing how much longer and fatter Nero's space is on some old ruin over there compared with the space on some comparable medallion, but mainly learning of the humors of those peoples and of their manners, and knocking off our corners by rubbing our brains against other peoples. I would like peoples to be taken abroad from their tenderest years mainly so as to kill two birds with one stone, to any neighboring peoples whose language is being least like our own, or ones which our tongue cannot get round unless you start bending it young. End quote. That is really a magnificent defense of a whole bunch of things. What do you think of it?
Wonderfully translated, I would add. It is recorded that when he was a young boy, his father sent him to a poor village to live with the poor family so he would see how the other side lived. I suspect his father was an extraordinary man in some ways, though I think we don't know much about him. And I think that was highly unusual back then for a family essentially from the nobility to just send the kid to a poor family to be lodged. Maybe that helped him appreciate what he had.
Yeah, which he's good at. It reminds me a little bit of John Stuart Mill's father teaching him Greek at three, I think. So poor Michel learning Latin for the first six years of his life, if indeed that's true. Kind of an intense...
thought hard physical labor was very good for children. That's part of what I take to be the Charles Koch theory, at least according to Chase Koch. And I suspect there's something to that. It shouldn't be too hard. I don't know how hard he meant by hard, but that physically the kid should be challenged and have to do things that are strenuous.
He was very big on his body. Besides those understanding it, observing it, kidney stones, bowel movements, and so on, he was a fan of treating your body well, taking care of it, exercise, sports. Again, very un-16th century in some sense, it seems.
I feel he was a major influence on Foucault, much later in the 20th century. The notion that a lot of the real liberties or lack of liberties are those of the body. It would not surprise me at all if Foucault either consciously or, you know, subconsciously got them from Montaigne. Because they're in plenty of the essays.
The emphasis is on health, what health means, imprisonment, what is true liberty, what are the structures of power that limit what you can do with your body. Again, we think of that as Foucault, which it is, but it's also in these essays.
Yeah, for sure. What do you take, how do you think about his socializing tastes? So he's living, he's spending a lot of time on his own here at the end of his life, but obviously he was a very social man in some dimension. I don't know why or how hard it was or whether he really was Waldenesque in his tower. But at one point he says, the world is nothing but chatter. I've never met a man who does not say more than he should rather than less. Yet half of our life is spent on that. They keep us four or five years learning the meanings of words and stringing them into sentences, four or five more in learning how to arrange them into a long composition, divided into four parts or five, and then as many again in plating and weaving them into verbal subtleties. Let us leave all that to those who make it their express profession. What do you think about that? He's talking about two things, hanging out with people, particularly teachers, but he's also of course talking about teaching reading and writing.
Yeah, it's the anti-small-talk side of him. So I like this essay very much. I think it's still one of the best essays on education.
Yeah, I want to close with two points from it, and you can respond to that, and we'll move on. But at one point he says, you know, there are people who don't write very well and they're hard to figure out what they mean, but he says that's because they don't think clearly. And I don't think that's changed since the 16th century. I think he's right. And this is the end of the essay, which I love. And he's going to mention the pan, the side basket of O say bicycle, or I don't know what else he was writing in those days, but he says, there's nothing like tempting the boy to want to study and to love it. Otherwise you simply produce donkeys laden with books. They are flogged into retaining a pennier full of learning. But if it is to do any good, learning must not only lodge with us. We must marry her. End of quote.
This is again, I think, the influence of Rabelais and the jab at Renaissance humanism.
And the jab is the emphasis on learning for learning's sake? Is that the...
He at least believed, I think, that Renaissance humanism was stuffing people full of facts and books and names and Greek and Latin, and much of this was a waste. Again, there's this tension in the work, that that was his education and he turned out to be so splendid as a thinker. But putting that aside, he has this resentment of his own upbringing, as many people do. And he's rebelling against his own time.
So let's turn to On Experience, which he wrote, I think, toward the end of his life, and in some sense it's thought of as some kind of summing up. I did not feel that way reading it. I felt it was more of a summing up of his own physical experience, his body and its pluses and minuses.
But maybe that is the summing up. So this is the very last essay in his entire series of essays, right? So the Straussians might tell us, well, this is very important. But I'm inclined to agree with this as a final statement of what he believes, that matters of the body are primary. It is hard to generalize from experience. And again, there's something about lived life that is more fundamental than all the philosophizing in the world. So I'm on board with how this might be placed in his oeuvre.
Yeah, I'm going to push back. A lot of it, well, he has a very interesting set of thoughts about habit. And he talks about how as you get older, you start doing things the same way and you get used to certain things. You know, it was, I think I can't remember now if he liked using a napkin. I think he did like a napkin, but he liked to use his hands when he ate rather than cutlery. His, you know, morning bowel movements, his drinking habits, how much water he drinks. It's a, to really stretch things, it's a Tim Ferriss level using yourself as a source of experimental empirical evidence with a data set of n of one. And that is what makes him, of course, marvelous. He is the data. But I found some of it kind of dull, to be honest. I didn't find it so interesting. And there's some moments in here, but that obsession with chronicling his preferences I didn't find so interesting.
Well, I think this essay reveals one of the biggest weaknesses in his...
thought, maybe the biggest. He had no understanding of what we now call the Scientific Revolution. I don't mean that as a criticism. There wasn't a scientific revolution then, right? That's 17th century in England. But this sense of, well, to understand your well-being, all you have are these momentary pains and snatches of feelings, and yes, you pass the kidney stone, and maybe you learn something from that. And it's hard to get more systematic. Well, he may have been right about his own time, but not seeing the potential for this other means of elevating human lives, I think leads him to place too much importance on the inner life because the notion that control over the external world could actually get you somewhere, he just didn't appreciate. So also the biggest weakness in his thought comes out in this essay. But I think all the different passages, they all mean something to him. And the idea that it's a bit monotonous, which it is, and self-indulgent, I think that's part of the point. There's something a bit Larry David about all this, if that reference makes any sense to you. So there's what, like now nine seasons of Curb Your Enthusiasm. After the first few episodes, they're in some ways all a bit the same, but I think that's part of the point of Curb Your Enthusiasm. And same with this essay.
I'm a little bit speechless. We talked earlier about connecting things that don't normally get connected. There we go. That's a beauty. Larry David's connection to Montaigne is a very high level. I'm going to make a different claim. You're right. He doesn't understand the scientific method. Can't remember when Bacon wrote, but it was a little after maybe or right? I can't. Francis Bacon is when? Do you remember?
Okay, that's good enough. That's good enough. But having said that, I think he had a kind of fundamental wisdom about him, not about the physical sciences, which are right. He couldn't imagine the generalizations that would come and their power and usefulness, but about the social sciences. He's very skeptical as a social scientist about the ability to generalize reliably. There's some fascinating passages about law that it's kind of foolish to try to create a compendium of cases that will handle everything and maybe you're just better off with a few simple rules and some smart people. So in that way he's foreseeing some of the power of various heuristics, rules of thumb, the impossibility of crafting a set of regulations that will always be transparent and clear for people meeting expectations. And he understood the diversity of the human experience. I'd say if anything it's like an obsession almost. And he had, there's some wisdom there, real wisdom about the challenges of the social sciences generally.
One of the most striking sentences in here, it's quoted pretty often and it surprised me when I ran across it, but he simply writes, quote, when I dance, I dance.
And it's not what you're expecting from him at that moment, but it is part of the capstone of this essay. At the end of the day, that's what you have. And he says, you know, our most great and glorious achievement is to live our life fittingly. He also says, when I sleep, I sleep.
Do you have the rest of that dance quote? Because it's a little bit Buddhist, by the way, while we're on this, the diversity of his thought.
I hear it. When I dance, I dance. When I sleep, I sleep. And when I am strolling alone through a beautiful orchard, although part of the time my thoughts are occupied by other things, for part of the time too, I bring them back to the walk, to the orchard, to the delight in being alone there, and to me.
I thought that was beautiful. Almost a little solipsistic about this. But this is another place where I think he's somewhat wrong. So about a page later he's saying, you know, everything else, reigning, ruling, building, laying up treasure, he says those are at most tiny props and small accessories. And at his time the amount of wealth you could achieve, of course, was quite small, but I think in the light of later history those are big deals. You know, you can live longer, you can go to the dentist, you can have anesthesia, you can get penicillin. They're not small things. Again, for his time his view was entirely reasonable, but it wasn't really correct either. This interface with the external world is something he's underrating. And although he's rebelling against the Stoics, he's too much a captive of a lot of what they wrote. But I'm an economist, right? I would say that. You're a little closer to him than I am.
Yeah, you're more than an economist. You're my favorite defender of growth for growth's sake because of what it, not literally for growth's sake, but what it can, by focusing on it as a national policy, you can achieve great things that matter. And I think that of course is right. I can't deny it, don't want to deny it, and I love what you've written on it. And yet, and yet, what's the phrase, what's his dismissal of, what does he call them?