Welcome to New Jersey Exit Interviews, the podcast all about New Jersey, America's greatest state. Today, I'm super pleased to be with Tyler Cowen, who's an economist, polymath, and philosopher at George Mason University. He's on his way to becoming the world's first information trillionaire, that is if he's not already there. And of course, he's from the great New Jersey. He was born into an originally working-class Irish-American family in Kearny, Hudson County, but mostly grew up in Bergen County's Hillsdale. So Tyler, thank you so much for being here. Good morning.
Happy to be here, and since you call this Exit Interviews, I should note my exit was 168.
There you go. Love that. So in a recent, not so recent, but in an episode of your podcast with Michael Nielsen, you mentioned that you think Amritsar, India is the best place to go to think about religion, that Jerusalem is a great place to go to think and learn about tension. So in that spirit, I wanted to ask you to fill in the blank. New Jersey is the best place to go to think about
politics and economics. So I grew up in Bergen County. What's so interesting about the history of northern New Jersey is that you could say it has a fractal political history. So especially in the 1890s, there was this movement called boroughitis, where things would fragment and polities would break away and become independent towns. So you have many small independent towns next to each other. So you observe so much variation in a small area, and you grow up seeing this. It's quite obvious. Even at the county level, Bergen County was one of the original counties of New Jersey, and Hudson County split away from it. So you just have these secessions going on all the time, and then ethnic clusterings. So it's just a fantastic place to grow up to become a social scientist.
Makes a lot of sense. So as you just said, I see how that leads to lots of great learning opportunities or kind of mini natural experiments almost. But there is some cost, right? In terms of inefficient public services or maybe high property tax. So, do you think are those costs worth the benefits?
Well, I haven't lived in New Jersey in a long time. When I lived there, I left I suppose in 1979 or 1980, it was considered a low tax state especially compared to New York City and New York State. So, the New Jersey I knew did not have that problem and it attracted a lot of business for that reason. Now, what's the biggest drawback of growing up in New Jersey? Well, in some ways it's ugly, but that also means for the rest of your life everywhere else will seem to be beautiful. So, I'm not sure it's a drawback. It's an exporter of human capital and that tells you that it breeds a lot of smarts and ambition in people. And that's great. What's the drawback? I don't see it.
Well, that makes sense. Can you tell us a little bit more about Hillsdale and the towns near it? I think I read that you said Rivervale sometimes had some, I think it was kids was the word. So, can you tell us a little bit about where you grew up in the towns bordering it?
Well, the town of Rivervale shared a high school with my town of Hillsdale which was quite small, very northern. Think of something, you know, 40 minutes or 35 minutes northwest of the George Washington Bridge just to place this for other people. Now, I talked before about this borough-itis tendency. Rivervale in fact split off from Hillsdale and became its own thing. I believe that was very early in the 20th century. So, Rivervale and Hillsdale ended up being quite different. Rivervale was wealthier, it had more space, it had nicer homes. It was more of a golf course sort of place. It was greener. Keep in mind a central important element in the history of Hillsdale was the coming of the train line and the train station. And that was as early as the mid-19th century, I think around 1850. So that connected Hillsdale to New York and Hillsdale to a lot of jobs, to a lot of industry. New York, you know, earlier was this huge manufacturing powerhouse. So Hillsdale had long been the grittier town, I think most of all because of what later became the Erie Lackawanna train line running through Hillsdale. And we felt so sorry for those Rivervale people. They weren't near a downtown they could walk to or bike to. They didn't have a downtown. Now you want to talk about disadvantages of growing up in New Jersey? Well, there aren't any, but there are huge disadvantages to growing up in Rivervale, New Jersey, right? So I think it bred, you know, a softer person, you could say. They're nice folk. I've had many good friends from there. But at the end of the day, even though they're adjacent towns, it's just not the same thing. And you could feel this in the high school. Like people knew this.
Yeah, and I definitely in my high school experience, people would always talk about the towns one town over, like, 'Oh, those kids are weird.' They're from, in my case Hamilton. I was from Ewing. Hamilton is weird, you know, and Lawrenceville is soft or maybe something like that.
So that's where you grew up. Yeah, Lawrenceville I think of as quite a WASP town. Like very wealthy prep school kind of place. Very smart people who aspire to go to Princeton, if I might rub that in. Yeah, that's Lawrenceville from my point of view. It's true. Now keep in mind, Hillsdale has this other adjacent town called Westwood. And Westwood was a larger, you could say a bit tougher and grittier. It had a real commercial district, not just a downtown. It had a record store. So I always had to ride my bike to Westwood when I wanted to buy a new record, which was pretty often. So, Westwood stood over Hillsdale and they looked down on us, probably with some justice. I don't even think they ever thought about Rivervale people.
Yeah, there you go. See, I grew up Ewing, New Jersey. So, we bordered Lawrence, Lawrenceville, Hamilton, Trenton, Hopewell, and then the Delaware River and Yardley on the other side.
I'd love for someone to write a book, The History of Rivers in New Jersey and how they shaped the state. So, there's the Passaic, Hackensack, and Hudson Rivers near where I grew up and lived. New Jerseyans just ignore them. You know, everything's car-centered. They treat it as something to drive over. There's that famous scene in The Sopranos, the opening credits. Tony's, you know, in the car on the bridge. It's over some body of water. Like, no one there knows which body of water it is. But, they're very important in the history of northern New Jersey.
For sure, for sure. And I definitely, I grew up sometimes going to the reenactment of Washington Crossing the Delaware. So, I think I think of New Jersey as very related to rivers. Now, were both your parents from New Jersey?
Of course, they were. Kearny, they went to the same high school. They were the smartest, they tell me, people from their high school and they married each other, which is maybe not always the best algorithm, but it was quite common back then. And Kearny, which is in Hudson County, long-standing industrial town with a very strong Scots-Irish background. Kearny is quite distinct. There's a lot we could say about Kearny. But, it was very working class and fairly poor. I guess not relative to the rest of the country. But, it never had the upper-middle-class feel that Hillsdale did. And that's where I was born is Kearny and I think the first 3 years of my life I spent there.
Okay. But, definitely shaped your parents and then, you know, I guess through them, you. I, you know, I take the train. I took a finance job in New York and I gave up my car, which I miss dearly, especially now that I'm no longer in my finance job in New York, but I would take the train from Jersey City, where I am now, to Newark Penn Station and the PATH train. And I'd look out at Kearny, I believe, unless I'm being, unless I'm confusing it with another town, and I'd always like, I've never been there. So, I want to go explore.
It is one of the most interesting histories of any northern New Jersey town. You know, it originally was based on a copper mine. And supposedly it had the first really operative steam engine in the United States. This is early on, you know, in the 18th century. So, it has industrial roots from the beginning, later became Scots-Irish. As early as the 1890s, soccer was a huge thing in Kearny in a way where it was not in the rest of the country or even the rest of New Jersey. And Kearny has had very strong soccer teams since then. I don't know if they still do. But soccer has played this big role in the town. There were multiple fish and chips restaurants. There were all these bars you could see, you know, when I was younger, we'd go back, visit Kearny, visit relatives, and there'd be signs to raise money for the IRA.
And that was done quite openly and without shame. And again, Kearny is just a fascinating place. I think now it's a lot of Peruvians, Latinos, some Lusophone types like Cape Verde, Brazil. It's really a very different town than what I was born into.
Mhm. Yeah, I know definitely I spent some time in the New Jersey National Guard and a lot of the people I served with, I was enlisted, not an officer, a lot of the people I served with were Peruvian, a lot living in Toms River, and I became pretty close with a lot of them and was introduced to some amazing food and then I've gone to Peru a few times. So, New Jersey's Peruvian population is a true treasure, I think.
That's right. Also in Patterson, I think. Very good kind of lower price point Peruvian food throughout different parts of northern New Jersey.
Definitely. So we have Kearny, then Hillsdale, then briefly you were in Massachusetts. Is that
Fall River. My father did Chamber of Commerce work. At first he tried to run a pet store and that went broke in Kearny. I don't have direct memories of this. But when I guess he was 30, I would have been around three, we were totally broke. So although he later earned much better, my history a bit straddles, you know, coming from a poor family and coming from a well-to-do family. But he had this offer to direct the Chamber of Commerce in Fall River, which was not a tiny place and had this textiles and manufacturing background and he decided it would be good if he took it. So we were there for three or four years. Three years, I think.
Now, do you think the time there shaped your thinking, your personality or was that more just a detour before you get back on the turnpike?
Well, I think oddly Fall River was one of the parts of New England that felt a lot like New Jersey. So it contributed to the New Jerseyness of me, but it didn't counteract it. It sort of packed it in. But I think at ages, you know, three or four to seven, you're not being formed as much as you will be a little bit later on. So it had this notion of there were homes that were close enough to the downtown where you could walk to the downtown. And that is a classic feature of much of northern New Jersey that is very good for children, in my opinion. It's hard to scale. We've moved somewhat away from it as places have grown. But both Hillsdale, where we lived, and Fall River, where we lived, and certainly Kearny. For all three of those, that was possible. So, I never felt that the suburbs were isolating me. It's one reason I think I've always been sympathetic to suburbs cuz I lived in three very good ones.
And you would, would you walk to the downtown? Would you ride a bike?
It would depend exactly where I would go. I would say I would walk more often than ride a bike, but I rode the bike plenty of times. But say when I had jobs downtown, which I did as a teen, I don't remember why, but I didn't ride the bike. Sometimes I'd, later on I'd drive, but it was just easy to walk. Your bike was a bit of a pain. You had to lock it. It could be stolen. Walking was fine, and you'd see things along the way. So, New Jersey can be a great walking state, at least in its northern parts. This is not well appreciated.
I agree. I think you've written somewhat about your time working at grocery stores in high school and the things you've learned. So, could you talk a little bit about that?
Well, I think one problem with mental health for young people, especially young males in America today, is we don't have enough teenagers working. It gives you a sense of responsibility. You're accountable. People are watching. You have to work with others. Very basic things. But if you haven't had a job before, there are things you probably need to learn. So, I learned what it was like to have a boss, to have to show up on time, when you could go home, that if something wasn't finished, I actually had to stay a bit late, and so on. The idea that you wanted to scramble to be assigned, you know, when you would be paid more for overtime. That might be say on a weekend. You just learned the world. So, and the notion of this competition. You would see the supermarket you worked for, which was Stop & Shop, and before that Valley Fair, they just didn't make that much money cuz they faced a lot of competition. An extremely simple point. But again, when you're a kid, to see that vividly before your eyes, I think that's pretty valuable.
100% and then I think you've said that your time in high school you had a small group of great friends, a lot of them intellectual and your mom thought about sending you to a better school or a private school and you actually pushed back against that thinking that you wanted the space to do your own thing. Is that about right?
That's correct. She wanted to send me to Dwight Morrow school. I wouldn't say she wanted, she was willing to do it. That was supposedly a much better school. I would have had to go on a bus. They would have probably given me all this homework which would have been terrible. And the schools I went to, I could walk to them, both grammar school and high school. Again, the compact nature of these New Jersey towns was a big advantage. So, I'd be home pretty quickly. I could just start reading or playing chess depending on which years you're talking about and I saw no reason to give that up. And in high school, you know, two of my best friends have become economists. One is Randall Kroszner who teaches at University of Chicago. He's very well known. He was on the Fed Board of Governors and the other is Daniel Klein who's a colleague of mine at George Mason, currently working on Adam Smith and well known for a number of things. He was the first person, I think, to really measure and catalog the imbalances of say Democrats versus Republicans in American academia. Those are really seminal pieces.
Yeah, lots of great economists from New Jersey. We have Friedman and Thaler.
Alan Krueger, I think, was from New Jersey. There's so many.
But you lose track. There's so many you lose track of it, right? Cuz this exporting human capital thing.
Yeah. Now what do you think is behind that exporting? Why, why don't more high human capital people stay in New Jersey?
Well, I think it's fairly simple. So, we're sandwiched between these two major cities, New York City most of all by far, but then Philadelphia, which is still one of America's largest cities and in earlier times was relatively speaking more important than it is now. So, that got you exposed to a lot of things and opportunities and ideas and art museums and whatever. So, it would stimulate your interest, but if you really wanted to do things, unless you went right to work at Princeton or earlier it could have been Bell Labs, you had to leave the state. So, it just was set up so perfectly to export human capital. Everything was arranged that way. Like you'd get the inputs, but to actually get the good jobs, you had to go somewhere else.
Yeah, that makes sense. I know, you know, right after college a lot of, I was in the army for a bit, so I'm older. A lot of my friends went right into Manhattan. I took the Manhattan job, but chose to live here in Jersey City. And part of that was, you know, I'm in a relationship, so I live with my girlfriend. So, we wanted a little bit more space and I wanted to look into the city. I felt maybe that, I don't know if it's New Jersey rebelliousness, but I thought New Jersey gets looked down on so much. I want to look down on New York and that's the kind of crazy New Jersey story of why I ended up here.
But I think you're an exception in this regard. So, I'm sure you know the movie On the Waterfront where there's the looming skyline of New York City for the New Jerseyans and they're intimidated by, they're impressed by, they resent it a bit. But it's a draw and a pull. I'd love to see the numbers, but my guess is if you grew up in New Jersey, you're actually more likely to move say to Manhattan or Brooklyn and less likely to do the Jersey City Hoboken thing. That the Jersey City Hoboken thing is for sane people who've been other places and can't take Manhattan and they don't feel it's second class to live on the other side of the river the way a New Jersey person might. Do you think that's true or not?
Oh, I think that's true. I think that in a weird way I wanted to be here because I knew it was second class. I wanted to be a little bit earthy and rebellious. I think is the terms you used describing New Jersey. I don't know if that's rational or if that's emotional or it's I wanted a cool place at a better price.
But Hoboken is not that anymore, right? It's really a satellite of New York City once they put in the train. And there's an earlier Hoboken that was quite genuine and earthy, right? Which is in a way the only Hoboken I've ever known.
Oh, no, that's 100% true. Hoboken is extremely nice. Even, I mean Jersey City is, at least the parts of it by the waterfront have been really, really, you know, these all these new gleaming towers, great transit access.
Yes, very yuppie. Yes, the outgoing mayor.
And Jersey City was once the center of New Jersey machine politics. You know, it was ruled by partly mobs, but not even just mobs, just like party machine. For decades you'd have like the same mayors. It would be corrupt. And Jersey City again epicenter of that and it's so improved itself since those times.
Yeah, no, it's quite amazing. I'm curious if, you know, you talk a lot about suburbs. A recent conversation with Dan Wang where you very strongly defended the American suburb. So, you live, I'm kind of jumping all over the place chronologically, but currently you live in the Washington D.C. area.
Please let's not call it that. I live in Northern Virginia.
Sure, Northern Virginia. [snorts] Thank you. How do you kind of compare and contrast New Jersey suburbs with Northern Virginia suburbs?
Well, I think for kids New Jersey suburbs of my time were much better. Again, this point about walking and or biking. Virginia suburbs, there are not easy ways to do either of those. There are not many places you could live. There like there are some homes that if you live near Route 123 in Vienna, you could walk to many different shops, but for the most part, that option is ruled out. But if you're an adult and you're not doing kid-like things, probably northern Virginia is better. It's better governed. It's less congested, though it has its own congestion. Think it probably has somewhat better food. But they're broadly similar types of experiences. But if you're in northern Virginia, you want to get into Washington, that's typically pretty easy. If you're in New Jersey and you want to get in and out of Manhattan, it's not that easy. And that's a huge difference and it militates in favor of northern Virginia, even though Manhattan is many, many times better than Washington D.C. to visit.
Sure. So then in terms of maybe
Of ease of life, northern Virginia's better.
Makes sense. Do you think is that maybe not a policy failure, but is that a situation that with a reasonable chance of implementation, New Jersey could fix? And the path is running more frequently and the transit they're trying to build this tunnel that we'll see if it gets built or not. So, if you fix the transit or make the transit better, does that just increase New Jersey's value?
Well, real estate prices would go up for sure. I think it would be much better for the world and better for Manhattan and better for idea generation in Manhattan. But I don't feel it would improve New Jersey. It probably would make New Jersey more boring. Maybe boringness is under supplied at current margins. But I don't feel it would be a better state aesthetically.
Would it be more boring because it would just be more of a commuter town, or why would it be more boring?
More of a commuter town, many more high-rises and condos clustered near the river, more vertical, people would leave them, they'd have high-paying jobs, you know, at Jane Street or something, and that's again, all great for the world. But I don't. And you'd have these big capital gains for people who are currently in New Jersey. Again, good for them, but aesthetically, you're just making the state less interesting and less distinct.
Yeah, I know you've written about the Victorian homes in Ocean Grove. So, is that an example of a very New Jersey aesthetic, or we could talk about the shore more generally, but what do you think about that?
Important concept here. So, like the whole question, what is northern New Jersey, maybe we could get at. But for someone like me from Hillsdale, which is pretty close to the New York State border, hardly any of New Jersey is northern New Jersey. Like I would say the line is at Woodbridge, where the turnpike and the parkway intersect, and below that is all like southern New Jersey. That's a kind of radical view, but it's the one I hold.
You don't believe in Central Jersey?
Not much. Morris something, Morristown, what do they call it? You know, there's things in there. I guess nominally they'd be Central Jersey, but they're not real New Jersey. But the shore towns, most of them really belong to northern New Jersey culturally, even though they're quite far south. You look at Asbury Park on a map, and you're shocked how far south it is, and it has great Puerto Rican food, and you're like, how did this happen? But in fact, it all makes sense when you really think through the geography, the economic geography.
So, anyway, Ocean Grove has wonderful architecture. Everyone should visit it. I think they still close things on Sundays. It's like a dry town, or at least it used to be. Just fantastic homes all over, very walkable, right on the water. I haven't been there in I would guess 15 years, but again, it's an excellent day trip from many places in the Northeast or Mid-Atlantic Seaboard. You've been there, right?
So I'm trying to recall. So when I did this teen travel camp and we'd go to different shore towns throughout the week. It was great. It was a municipal thing. Oh, what struck me? So this is not an Ocean Grove answer, but it's I always remember being struck by the lake in Spring Lake, which seems I guess obvious based on the name.
That's the nicest of the towns, by the way, Spring Lake.
Not touristically the most interesting for architecture, but just if you had to put yourself somewhere that also had real shops, it would be Spring Lake.
Yeah, definitely. Think we went, we went to Island Beach State Park a lot, which is kind of cheating, cuz then you didn't get the town, you just got the beach, not the shore, maybe. I have to give that more thought. I need to have a better answer there.
You know, when my sister and I were young, we hated going to Ocean Grove and we got our parents to stop taking us there. We just thought it was boring.
Which it is, right? We're like, 'Oh, can we go to' First it was Point Pleasant, then it was Seaside Heights, which is now like a nightmare, right? Just awful.
But we were much keener to go to a place with an active boardwalk and other young people. And to us, Ocean Grove was like a funeral home or something. I think we even called it that once.
So on regional thinking in general, is there anybody that's not a regional thinker? If you grew up moving around way too much are you then just an amalgamation of the fractured regions of your childhood or what happens there?
Well, one would need more context to say. But if you move every 2 years, I don't think you're a mix of the bundle usually. You're shaped by moving every 2 years. But it will depend somewhat where you've been. You know, if you're living in the Middle East as opposed to moving around New Jersey and Connecticut, it's going to matter a lot. So, I would say look at context. But you only have room for so much regional thought cuz regions in a way contradict each other, right? So, there's plenty of army brats and where they end up is basically determined by military bases. And you meet plenty of them. I think they have a lot in common with each other. And you don't need to sit down and ask them in detail of which bases was your dad sent to or your mom sent to. It's like you're an army brat and they know that and that's how I think of it.
No, that makes sense. Do you think so within New Jersey, as you've said and I totally agree, the two places with real gravitational pull are New York to the north and Philadelphia to the south. Do you think the people in New Jersey, they're thinking what would be the differences between somebody, let's say like you, who grew up with the New York City skyline looming and somebody that was maybe in Cherry Hill or closer to Philadelphia?
Well, it's funny, you know, I was talking to Jennifer Zambon about this recently. She's from New Jersey. A lot of New Jersey people at Mercatus, I might add. And Jennifer was saying a lot of New Jerseyans, they kind of actually regard Philadelphia as belonging to them. I agree with that. Like, we're not quite a satellite of it. Like, why don't you think about maybe you're a satellite of us?
So, that's one big difference, but no one would say that about New York City or Manhattan. And Philadelphia, it's been ailing for a long time. You don't really necessarily go there to hang out. There's things there you might do or see. It's actually a wonderful city, great to visit, but it doesn't like impress you when you just show up. Partly you might be a bit horrified. So, I think that changes the whole slant. And you're still like sitting around wondering, well, how long is that train trip to Manhattan anyway? And it's not actually that long as you very well know from where you come from.
And that's still in some ways the greater attractor. But Philly's there, too. So, Cherry Hill's a great part of New Jersey. Or is it Haddonfield is around there? A lot of excellent towns.
Yeah. You know, they're maybe also not what they used to be, but I have a high school friends that moved to like Bordentown, Burlington, and kind of the appeal there, a lot of them work for the state, so you can get to Trenton pretty easily. And you have, you know, kind of a walkable, nice downtown. And it's just really cheap, and it can be very charming, very charming towns.
Yeah, and you're near so many wonderful things. I don't just mean those two cities, but you want to get to Washington, to Boston, other parts of Pennsylvania, it's all right there.
That it is in some ways like the best parts of Western Europe, I don't feel it's sufficiently appreciated. Like northern New Jersey, it evolved a bit like Italian city-states in a funny way. And then the broader environment, it's like you're living in Basel, Switzerland, or something. So much is around you, and you can just spend your whole life exploring it.
Huh. That's very interesting. So, not maybe in terms of the geographic access, although maybe we can't separate the two, but would you say there is a country in Europe or anywhere else that most reminds you of New Jersey, say culturally, attitudinally?
Well, there is, and I mean this is a real stretch, but if you're making me pick one, there are parts of the Netherlands. By the way, Bergen County comes from Bergen in the Netherlands, where it's densely populated, you can walk to the downtown, the homes can be of a certain sort, and some of this is actually eastern Netherlands. In a funny way, when I first saw it, I thought a bit, this is like New Jersey. Now, there's no mafia, there's like so many other differences, not many Italian Americans there. But yeah, I definitely had that thought when I first went to the Netherlands.
Yeah, very interesting. Do you think... I think I've heard you...
Bodies of water, of course, also. Just like the key rivers in northern New Jersey. So, yeah.
Yeah. Huh. You know, I've heard you mention that your philosophy or life outlook is somewhat Humean. So, a lot of like passion plays a role. Do you think New Jersey is Humean? Or do you think that's not quite right?
Well, it's Humean plus, like it might also be Machiavellian, right? Is the mafia Humean? Well, that's a complicated question. So, I think it's more brutal maybe than Humean. But yeah, Humean plus.
Okay, interesting. On some literature questions, you wrote that Stephen Crane is from the state, but somehow it doesn't count in my eyes as a New Jerseyan. Why is that?
Well, as you know, he died very young, so he could have done much more. But the key work he wrote, which I think of as more important than the short fiction, though they're both quite good, is about the Civil War. And New Jersey's a Revolutionary War state, not a Civil War state. So, you don't connect him with New Jersey that readily.
Not intended as a criticism, but just as an observation. It's like you have to remind yourself he's from New Jersey. You don't really have to remind yourself that Vince Lombardi is from New Jersey.
True. True. Why do you prefer Norman Mailer over Philip Roth?
Philip Roth might be the better and more serious writer, but to me Mailer is more creative. I get tired of Philip Roth. I feel a bit, I grew up with all that. Do I need to read about it now? I think like the first half of Executioner's Song by Mailer is quite fantastic. It's also not about New Jersey. His whole history with Jack Henry Abbott is very interesting. His book on the astronauts and the moon, the Chicago riots of the late '60s. He was very versatile. And I think he's become quite underrated, partly because he was such a bad guy. Like he stabbed his wife with a penknife. And on purpose, it seems, not some kind of accident that his hand slipped when, whatever. But yeah, very, very fertile and creative mind, even though he's super flawed. And can be like stupid or in poor taste or your eyes roll. But I don't go back and reread Philip Roth. It doesn't interest me. But he's quite a good writer. If someone says, 'Oh, I love Philip Roth,' I just think a bit, 'Oh, maybe you're not from New Jersey, right?' Which is fine.