Welcome to the Athenaeum Review podcast, and it is an enormous honor this morning to be joined by Tyler Cowen, who truly needs no introduction, but I will simply say that Marginal Revolution and Conversations with Tyler, I think, are essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the world. So, thank you very much for being here.
Happy to be here, Ben. Thank you for having me on.
And my tribute to Conversations with Tyler is to say that this will be the conversation that I hope our listeners will have wished me to have had with Tyler. So, I will start by saying that, like many humanists, I've learned a great deal about economics and social science from Marginal Revolution, but I've also learned a lot about the arts and humanities from reading over the years. I don't think there are that many people who are truly conversant in both quantitative and qualitative fields. So, my first question would be, from your perspective, do you think that there's something that those who are quantitative thinkers who are not aesthetically trained, is there something that they miss out on, or do you find anything lacking in terms of the aesthetic vision or sensibility of quantitative thinkers?
Well, how people think about government, politics, culture war issues, often depends greatly on their sense of aesthetics. Maybe they think it's ethics or morals, and sometimes it is, but just division of how society ought to look, what would please them, what they would find appropriate, has a great deal to do with aesthetics. And if one more formally studies aesthetics as a thing in the arts, I think one is much better equipped to understand that angle of politics, which I view as really essential to 2026 and maybe most other times as well. So, that's one way in which it matters, but also just if you're trying to understand human behavior, there's the neoclassical rational model, there's behavioral economics. They're both very useful, but I feel knowing aesthetics gives you this extra dimension above and beyond either of those two.
Yeah. Yeah, that makes that reminds me of I often think, you know, the so-called ideological Turing test and the ability to model what is in the mind of another, particularly a political opponent who may appear crazy or stupid or irrational. I often think if people had just read a lot more novels, they might have, you know, great novels would give you a sense of why people sometimes do the things they do. But
And great novels, they're really hard to understand, right? Or a lot of paintings, symphonies, wherever you want to look. And if you just put a lot of time into trying to figure them out, I think it's maybe the single best way to become smarter because they're so hard and you're never really done with them. And you then become much better at appreciating the virtues of other people, so you like them more and because they see that you actually get their virtues, they like you more. It's like a total win-win from my point of view.
Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I remember a few, I don't know when it was, a few months ago I saw a very long thoughtful Twitter post from Patrick Collison about Middlemarch and I thought, "Wow, I don't know how many tech people are reading Middlemarch, but I hope that they are and I'm it I'm
More or less because of Patrick, yeah.
I think that tweet, I mean, a while ago, but it had several million imprints, which is amazing, right?
Like the most popular literary critic of the year.
No matter what one may think of that, but that needs to be taken very seriously.
Yeah. Yeah, and I saw at one point I think that Matt Yglesias had been in a Catherine Project reading group for Middlemarch or something. And so I thought,
And Matt reads a lot of novels and he got on a George Eliot kick and read all the second-tier Eliot novels, which he learned a lot from. You know, there's an argument to be made for not just reading the great books, whatever that's supposed to mean, but just reading more deeply in any particular area.
Yeah. Well, so follow-up question is if you were if you were designing either a formal curriculum for university or informal advice for people educating themselves, picture let's say a person who's highly skilled in say tech or finance but has not had much formal training in aesthetics, what kind of advice would you give?
I'm not sure if formal training is what they need. I think a love of it and pursuit of it is more valuable.
I mean one piece of advice would just be like email me, email you, right?
Ask GPT, tell it a bit about yourself, see what it thinks you should do. But just to start on things you think you might love and pursue them. I think it's better than any more formal piece of advice. Just try stuff.
Don't let it don't put it down.
Yeah. In fact, in fact just last night I was having a conversation with some very well-educated people without any particular background in the arts and it came up as actually it often does this sense, you know, it's almost like the beginning of a Platonic-style dialogue the sort of common sense that taste is purely subjective that I like this, you like that and that's it implying that it's not really possible to rationally argue about aesthetic judgments because, you know, I like vanilla, you like strawberry, that's fine. I wonder if people say that to you and if so how you respond.
They do say that. I think that reflects a shortcoming of arguing, not a shortcoming of aesthetics. So just a simple example, I pretty firmly believe that Beethoven's Fifth Symphony is better and more important than his Second Symphony.
And I think it would actually be hard to find many people who'd heard all the symphonies who would not agree with that. But I recognize full well in a debate I couldn't demonstrate it. I couldn't derive it from uncontroversial premises, but I think as claims go, it's probably more objective than a lot of things we like to say. And I don't feel bad about believing it strongly.
And I quite like the second symphony, to be clear.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, so moving to kind of ideas or theories about aesthetics, I may have missed. I don't know if you've commented publicly, but Iain McGilchrist, who is sort of a polymath with a medical neuroscientific background, published some very long books with a theory that can be characterized as saying that the kind of intuitive holistic way of understanding the world, which you might find in say poetry or painting, in the modern world, he thinks, is somewhat at a disadvantage compared to the more analytical, task-oriented, utilitarian, utility-oriented way of thinking that wants to sort of take things apart and see how they work. And he thinks that this is a problem because there are ways of understanding reality, again, say poetry, painting, intuitive, holistic, etc., that are underrated or undervalued in kind of our modern society. I wonder if you have any thoughts or comments on his theory.
I'm never happy with claims like that. You didn't mention it, but first, I don't accept the whole left brain, right brain distinction. I don't think that really has held up in modern neuroscience. Again, you know, intuitive, holistic. You read a short Emily Dickinson poem. Is that holistic? I don't know. I'm not sure I'm qualified to classify it, but that's not the first word that comes to mind.
You listen to atonal music. Is that holistic? Or it seems to be imposing a lot of artificial categories on things that can stand for themselves. And then finally, there's this recent dialogue with Peter Thiel. It's on YouTube. And they say, Peter, you know, the AIs are coming. Are they going to come first for the math people or the literature people? And Peter says, "Oh, they're going to come first for the math people. Those skills won't be valuable anymore." Now, Peter may or may not be right, but it's certainly quite possible that he's right. And then finally, most people don't think well in terms of math at all. Like, how many people are really even minimally literate in statistics? I think actually a lot more people appreciate the arts. So, it's like four or five different reasons I have for objecting to that point.
They're all fairly independent. So, I don't I don't buy it. I just think it's all much more complicated than that.
Sure. Sure. Well, no, that's the Yeah, worth thinking about. So, this is a slightly, let's say a slightly related question and it's a quote from Michael Hanby who says, "Questions in the what is form can no longer be intelligibly posed within the dominant form of reason, which can only ask functional questions, how many, how far, by what influence, and to what effect. Ideas cease to disclose reality and are set in opposition to it as instruments for its manipulation." My comment on this quote is that when I if I'm skimming the abstract or a paper in the social sciences, my first reaction is often that the sort of what is questions are somewhat taken for granted. For instance, the set of concepts or the sort of intuition about reality seems to reflect sort of the conventional wisdom that has just been absorbed without really thinking about it. And the analysis may be very sophisticated, but I often wish that they'd tried to delve a little bit more deeply into the question of what is before trying to kind of take it apart and reason about it. So, I don't know I wonder what you think of that quote from Hanby or my comment following.
I agree with your comment, which I like. I'm not sure I understand the quotation. I know I was saying proper nouns are underrated. And I recall there not being a single proper noun in that quotation. So, I'm not sure what he means, but again, I liked your words.
And I would make the general point, there's just so many top-tier social scientists, they do great work, it's very sophisticated, but their basic worldview they'll take from some mix of like NPR and New York Times, and I don't mean the arts page of the Times, either.
And television, oh, they'll watch the smarter shows. It's just to me seems so utterly disappointing somehow.
And maybe we're just saying the same thing there.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm not sure I can formulate this clearly, but that makes me think, I mean, you know, I certainly spend a lot of time online myself, but I'm also old enough to remember that when I was sort of college age and doing traveling or even just kind of exploring nearby, my pre-existing knowledge about whatever I was about to experience would really be a couple of paragraphs in a travel guide say, "You should go here. It's nice and interesting." And thus, when I stepped off the train or whatever, whatever I experienced would be not totally new, but almost totally new. And it makes me, you know, I'm a little sad to think that any sort of such experience now, unless you kind of work really hard at it, almost everything that you see if you travel somewhere will sort of you'll sort of have a vast array of pre-existing knowledge that maybe makes it a little less novel. I don't know what you think of that perspective, cuz I know you might disagree with that, but I'm curious what you think.
I think it depends on the part of the world. So, I think traveling, say, to Western Europe, maybe the quality of that peaked in the 1980s.
But much of the rest of the world, especially Latin America, to me still feels quite fresh and fairly under-discovered. And guidebooks can clue you in a bit, but I think that the time to travel there, or say India, that's peaking now, or maybe it hasn't peaked yet. So, I think it's a European problem. It's extreme in Venice, Florence, you know, the usual places, but you can get around it. I don't think it takes really that much work. Just reorient where you're going to go. You know, you go to Java, Indonesia, a very fresh experience, I think, full of surprises.
And I'll put a link in there. There is a wonderful recent in the Free Press advice about Mexico that Tyler recently published there, which I hope will enlighten and inspire a number of readers to be curious about Mexico.
And more places are getting ruined. I'm sure you're worried about this. Like Tokyo peaked sometime in the past for a traveler.
But there's just so much of the world that is still fresh. So, I don't feel too bad about it.
Yeah. I was actually there I was talking to a couple of Japanese guys from a Japanese art gallery who were here for an art fair a couple of months ago, and I expressed admiration for their work, and I said, you know, someday I'd love to go. I've never been to Japan, and he kind of sighed and said, "Oh, there's a lot of tourists right now." And I felt like I should apologize. I'm sorry about that. But still, despite that, I'm going to get there someday.
I don't think it's that far from peak, and the tourists tend to cluster as in Mexico City. So, it's still a wonderful time to visit Japan and Tokyo and outside of Tokyo, but it's not unspoiled in the way it almost was not too long ago. It's one of the best travel experiences you can have, I think, Japan. Still.
But past peak, also, but not by that much.
Like to him, he's so used to the peak. To him, it feels terrible, but it's not terrible.
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I wanted to also to ask the question the say question of nature and culture. There is a sort of conventional wisdom thinking about culture of let's say pure complete cultural relativism or pure social constructionism that, you know, kind of blank slateism, if you will. And you could say that people take, you know, particularly academics, I think, often take the starting point of something like that. On the other hand, I put in my email there these attempts to ground culture and implicitly aesthetic judgments in some form of human nature. And examples being music, the octave is a phenomenon in physics, there's physiology that there's some sort of connection with nature in music. Our colleague Fred Turner published something with a neuroscientist a while ago called the neural liar, which argued that most poetic lines in different cultures are a certain length of about 3 seconds, which they claim corresponds to the sense of the present or the now. And the third example in the field of architecture and design, the late Christopher Alexander published another, like McGilchrist, another very long series of books claiming that there were 15 fundamental properties of order, which, based on his somewhat informal empirical studies with Berkeley students and other people, were present in what he called good design. So, perhaps there's a spectrum between pure social constructionism and, let's say, the strongest possible theories of nature and natural, etc. I wonder what your views are on that.
Well, that helps in part to explain why consensus is possible
Yeah.
One of my more strongly held views is that in the arts, most things that are claimed to be great are in fact great. It's a very simple hypothesis, but if you just picked up like Penguin Guide to Classical Music, something very normie.
You know, even from 20 years ago, and like, who are the great composers? Or ask GPT. Like the list you get, they're all great composers. Or who are the great painters, sculptors? It's a pretty kind of efficient market in that way.
More recent creators, there can be people elevated who won't last or these trends, certain things are politicized as they were back then in earlier times.
Well, like Rodin, Michelangelo, they're just astonishingly good and I don't feel that's arbitrary and I don't think history feels it's arbitrary.
Yeah. Slightly related you know, talking to a lot of different people over the years, there are you know, I've noticed there are people who may be passionate about one form of art and not so much another. I'm thinking of one person I talked to who is truly profoundly devoted to music but doesn't really care much about poetry or fiction at all. Someone else who is absolutely you know, completely devoted to fiction and novels but isn't particularly moved by music. You know, if I'm curious whether you, you know, surveying the whole field of arts and culture do you think that it's worth trying to develop one's taste in a field that doesn't seem to come naturally or is it more worthwhile to just stick to the kind of medium or tradition that particularly moves you without you having to work too much at it?
You know, I would say try and try to put in some work.
But if you need to give it up, that's fine and there's even neurological reasons. Like I think about 1% of the human race has a condition called amusia. They just don't enjoy music.
And trying harder is not going to get them there. I've read Milton Friedman had this. Should Milton Friedman be trying to appreciate Haydn's Paris Symphonies? Probably not. So I think it's fine and it means when people look at the things they love, they'll have these very skewed perspectives that might be out of balance but the rest of us can still learn from that. So I'm fine with that kind of specialization of consumption and we all have it at some margins. Like I don't really go see ballet or modern dance. I'll admit that's my fault.
I might go see plenty of other things. I saw Wilco in concert last night. That was very good. But I don't go to ballet and modern dance and you know, you like to think oh, I know all these fields, but relative to the whole no one knows really that much.
Yeah. Yeah. Well, that makes sense. That makes sense. So I wanted to I wanted to ask or speak broadly about the question of about modernism, about newness, etc. Thinking back, you know, in very simple terms, it seems like there's been an imperative, you know, as Pound said, make it new, make it new. You know, certainly in the era of so-called modernism, a widely felt need to kind of be present, be contemporaneous, be contemporary. I think there's a whole book that I read about what is contemporary art. Why do we call it contemporary? And you know, a kind of a simple idea might be, well, there is something to do with the state of technology and rapid economic development that, you know, let's say several centuries ago when technology and the economy were not changing as rapidly, people were more comfortable with tradition. But now with so many things changing so fast there's more a sense of urgency to be up to date. I wonder if you just had any general thoughts on that question of is it important for art in general or judgments about art to reflect the present in some way?
Well, I'm not sure the general claim is correct. So if you look at so-called popular music
People today listen to music a few decades old much more than they used to.
So when I was a teenager in the 1970s, it was unthinkable that someone would advocate for the music of the 1940s.
Even most of the 50s, you might like Chuck Berry or someone like that, James Brown, but most of it was just obviously passé. And now for people who are young to love the Beatles or Led Zeppelin, it's common. It might even be the norm. So, we're less contemporary oriented in a lot of fields. The whole revival of interest in Shakespeare, Jane Austen, you know, very new novelists, can they really get attention?
Depends who they are, the genre, but again, I think they're in a worse position than they would have been in the 1960s.
So, I guess I see the generalization if anything is running in the other direction.
I don't object to it either way. I think you just have to sort through and iterate and maybe at some particular moment it's not ideal, but it's never ideal and I think we're in this bridge period where a lot of the new creativity hasn't quite come yet, so it feels like a drought, but I'm not very pessimistic about it either.
Yeah. I remember, I mean, as a Gen X person listening to the Beatles and thinking, "Oh, this is great. It is sort of my parents' generation of music, but they are pretty good." And I loved the Beatles for my whole life, but I never ever ever would have predicted that in the 2020s seemingly every generation of young people seems to love the Beatles equally as much and almost as much and they're still at the top of the charts from time to time. But well, a little bit more specifically about art. So, there's this quotation which if one studies modern art it becomes very familiar. It was written by Baudelaire about a now forgotten painter named Constantin Guys, but then at some point people realized that if it was applied to Manet and other modern painters, it would somehow try to explain what they were doing. And Baudelaire said in The Painter of Modern Life was his title saying that the painter should, quote, "Extract from fashion whatever element it may contain of poetry within history to distill the eternal from the transitory." And then a bit later he said, "By modernity, I mean the ephemeral, the fugitive, the contingent, the half of art whose other half is the eternal and immutable." So, this sort of formulation of half and half, transitory and immutable, seemed to capture the imagination of at least some critics. Do you think Does this make sense at all to you as a kind of formula for modern art?
Yeah, maybe the economist in me is coming out too strongly here, but it just sounds like a bunch of words.
[laughter]
You know, we just bought a print by William Kentridge, who's still a very active artist.
It's an amazing print. I don't even know if I should call it modern art. Is it eternal? Is it transitory?
I go back to the proper nouns are underrated.
And I think discourse about very specific things often gets us further. I think that's Now is a great time for a lot of creativity.
And we can enjoy it, and I don't mind people agonizing over the abstract categories, but I you know, I do better talking to GPT Pro about the arts than I do talking to such people.
The best art critic today is GPT Pro.
Okay. Okay. Yeah. I mean, I can see that. Well, I might So, I might predict that this may be a similar thing, but in the education of Henry Adams, he became very thoughtful and melancholy, let's say, while encountering new electrical technology. And he wrote a long piece about the Virgin as the inspiration for these truly amazing works of Gothic, etc., in the European past. And the Dynamo, which he clearly saw as the wave of the future, so to speak, and which was awe-inspiring in its power, but he was worried about an alleged lack of soul or something like that in the Dynamo. So, I don't know if you if what you would respond to someone like Henry Adams who sees culture as defined by these two opposing poles.
He never listened to Jimi Hendrix, right? That's electricity driven by electricity. But that's it. Jimi does two YouTube videos where he plays acoustic guitar and that's amazing as well.
I do think we're in this bridge period where AI is not quite good enough yet to create amazing art and it will be soon and there's a sense of we're all waiting for that. But it will come. It will be an aid to the human but it will be a quite incredible flowering of a new technology.
Speaking of this is a bit of an aside thing but there is a comment recently that somehow it seems to be the use of language in particular that gives rise to all kinds of worries about consciousness and so forth. In other words, when looking at AI in image generation or in protein folding or something like that, people don't seem to worry so much about whether AI is conscious but it seems to be something about language which triggers this sense of concern in humans. Do you have any views on that?
Well, it's our biological programming fooling us.
So, because of evolution we're trained to think that things that talk to us are alive and sentient and they used to be but now we have things that talk to
us and they're not, and we're just making a mistake. It is in fact a glorified cash register, a lot of complaint, but there's no alive sentient being in there, and even some very smart people have just fallen for this hook, line, and sinker. I'm amazed.
Yeah. I mean, my, you know, speaking of speaking of AI and art, so like at the at this point in time, summer 2026, when I see an AI generated image, to me the highest value at this point is often some sort of clever concept, like if someone wants to make a kind of joke or cartoon and say, "Give me, you know, give me 10 monkeys in academic year pointing at the blackboard," and they just get it right away, and I say, "Okay, that's funny." But assuming that it will get very, very, very, very good soon at generating great pictures, let's say. You know, I had the thought that there's trying to sort of disentangle one's reaction to these things. Circling back a bit, you know, there's the long-standing question of forgery. Like a truly great forger, a truly great kind of counterfeit maker of paintings can make a very good painting, and then you enjoy it, and then you discover that it's not a real Rembrandt or whatever, and you feel cheated ethically. You feel wronged by being misled. But retrospectively, does that sort of taint your original enjoyment of the picture, or at least it does for most people. And then that reminded me, I mean, I think you know my friend Robin Goldstein, who does research into kind of blind tastings of wine and things like that. It's like, "Yeah, he's great. Yeah, he thinks this is a $10,000 bottle of wine, you might like it better." So, I suppose my rambling question here is, if it's a great picture that you think is done by a human, and then you learn that it's done by AI, and you like it less, and that's perhaps a little bit like learning that a painting was forged and not really a great baroque painter, say. Is that, I don't know, should one sort of train oneself to separate the aesthetic and ethical judgments and be able to just enjoy it if it's a great picture, or is it somehow inseparable from the kind of, you know, overall scenario of having been done by a particular person, and it's just not possible to recover that enjoyment once you learn you've been so-called cheated, let's say.
There's a number of different questions in there. I would respond to a few of them. I think one should adopt a portfolio approach. You should always want to love some art done by AIs. We don't have good enough art yet for that, but I think we will soon. And you should always want to love some art just done by humans, and then want to love some art that is collaborative. Just like you should always be interested in like some Brazilian music, some Cuban music, some gamelan music. It's a pretty common intuition, and I think we can transplant it to this new realm. Now, that said, I think a lot of these famous forged works, they're not actually that good. And I think a lot of people, they don't have an eye as good as they think they do. And the mistake they're making is they fall in love with too many Rembrandts.
The notion that a lot of these great artists, much of it wasn't that good to begin with.
It's hard for people to buy into because they feel they're supposed to like it. But if they're willing to make that mental adjustment, they'll be fooled less by forgeries. I do think things like a Malevich forgery can be indistinguishable from a good Malevich, you know, original work.
But a lot of the forgeries, or you know, like the Haydn forgeries, they were never great Haydn works to begin with. Like most of the Haydn symphonies, they're not that wonderful. And yeah, you can forge one, but you can't forge one of the, you know, top-tier London symphonies. So, I think we need to be more discriminating. And that's what the forgeries are showing, not that the forgers can do it so well.
Yeah. Yeah, that makes sense. I mean, I think a related sort of scenario that I think about are these cases where a painting is lost and then eventually through expert connoisseurship, it's reattributed to a master. So these, you know, the really famous ones in the last year, the Salvator Mundi, eventually determined to be a Leonardo. Right here, not far away at the Kimbell Museum, a small painting of St. Anthony that was eventually redetermined to be a Michelangelo. And I think to myself, you know, if you see it in a thrift store listed for 100 pounds or whatever it was, and you would walk past, but now you won't walk past it because you know it cost tens of millions of dollars. Or the famous experiment, I think Joshua Bell, great violinist, played on a subway platform and people ignored him. Is it, you know, I don't know how to put this. I sort of think to myself, well, if your view is so dependent on knowledge of how much someone paid for it, maybe you should kind of relax a little bit and just wander around and see if you might enjoy something in a thrift shop. Or our final case would be that as far as I understand it, it's almost impossible to see the Mona Lisa because everyone wants to see the Mona Lisa, so you have a couple of seconds, but, you know, 100 ft away there's a gallery of amazing paintings that's almost empty because they don't know.
Right. So, I don't know if... Let's use the facade. So, yeah, but the two works you mentioned, to me they're not amazing. Salvator Mundi, I don't really like it. I'm not even sure how much is by Leonardo. I read some of the debate.
So, yeah, we need to be more skeptical and cynical. You know, if this happens with Shakespeare, and just to say not every Shakespeare play is wonderful, even though I think at least two-thirds of them are. Is King John so great or Henry VIII? Even of the Shrew, I don't love, and or maybe some parts are by other people or derived, but like just trust your own judgment more. You might be wrong, but you'll be fooled less on these other occasions. If you're just willing to say, "A lot of these Rembrandts are just a bit so-so to begin with."
Yeah. Yeah, I remember I think watching the Two Noble Kinsmen on streaming and thinking if this were all we had, would we think so much? Often when I'm talking to people about, you know, I actually think it's worse with people who are educated.
They talk about going to museums, and I don't know if you'd call it the superego. There's a little voice in their head saying, "I need to be able to show that I understand this and appreciate it, or I'll be exposed as an uncultured rube." And it seems to sort of spoil their experience. I want to say, "You just have to switch that off. Just wander through and stop when something interests you, and don't worry too much about whether you have the correct interpretation or whether you're, you know, showing yourself to be uneducated. Just kind of notice your response and do that because I think it interferes."
Popular music fans do much better on this. It's very easy to get Beatles lovers to debate what's the worst Beatles song and no panic whatever their pick is. Like, what do you think is the worst Beatles song?
Oh, I don't know. Wild Honey Pie. I don't know. I mean...
That's one of my favorites. I would say like Good Night where Ringo's singing.
I don't know, but you're just not that ashamed to have a pick.