Good afternoon, everyone. Scott Oler here from the University of Wyoming College of Business. Thank you for joining us live. We're delighted to have Tyler Cowen here visiting with our students, faculty, alumni, and other university officials as well. Tyler, great to see you. Can you hear me? Okay.
Excellent. Folks, we're going to keep the introduction really short. The plan here is for about 45 minutes of Tyler and I having a conversation, plus or minus a few minutes. And then we hope you will submit your questions to the chat function in YouTube, and we'll try to get through as many of them as possible. I've incorporated a few of your questions ahead of time into the script that I have with Tyler, and we'll just give him a really great Wyoming welcome today. Tyler Cowen, as many of you all know, is the Holbert L. Harris Professor of Economics at George Mason University. He's chair and director of the Mercatus Center, co-author of the popular blog Marginal Revolution, which is in 23 years of production now and by far and away the most popular economics blog in the world. He is the founder of Emergent Ventures and also has an amazing set of conversations called Conversations with Tyler that many of you may be aware of and check out. I've known Tyler for 25 years now. I was honored to be a student in one of your classes, Tyler, Law and Literature, which I'm wondering if you're still teaching or not, and we served 10 years together on a nonprofit board. So thank you so much for joining us. We know your time's very precious, and you're really giving back to us by being here today.
Happy to be on this. Sorry I'm not in Wyoming, but there you go.
We will get you here. We'll get you here soon. Let's start just really just with catching up for a minute. How are things at George Mason in Northern Virginia?
Well, this morning I was speaking at OpenAI about AI, of course. George Mason's doing great. Our enrollments are up. The campus has gotten over a lot of the infighting that had plagued it over the last few years, and we're just back in business, I would say.
That's great. Are you teaching this fall?
I am teaching an online class, Principles of Microeconomics. It has about 700 students. It took me seven years to build the class. It's not just taped lectures. It's YouTube videos, which are more like mini movies, and a text and an electronic portal.
Wow, that sounds great. I remember your Law and Literature class, and you know, two things I think some of our readers will appreciate, or our viewers will appreciate, is your suggestion to reread classics. It's something I never really did before that class, and just my mind was blown going back through it, both with an economic lens and then also just the rereading. You reread things at age 48 or 49, and they're just completely different than when you had to read them in high school. So Merchant of Venice, I never read the same way after having your class. The Bible, unfortunately, for better or worse, is something I read through a strict public choice and economics lens, and I thank you for that. It was just an unbelievable course. Anything you're reading a second or third time lately that you just have a different reaction to than when you first read?
Well, I'm always rereading Shakespeare. Love's Labour's Lost was the last one I looked at, and just how good they are. I know that sounds a little stupid, but we haven't produced anything better since then, and that amazes me. There's much higher population. More people do writing, right? There's television, movies, all different genres you can try your hand at, and Shakespeare is still the best.
Yeah, absolutely. And quite funny, too.
And Titus Andronicus I reread also lately, in this age of people asking again, what is democracy really? What kinds of allegiances do we owe our leaders? What kinds of hero worship can be justified?
That's awesome. So as you know, our conversation today is going to have a focus on AI, which is something that you've been commenting on a lot the last few years. A grant made this possible. So we had an internal grant, and one of our faculty in economics, Jay Shogren, who you might know, a distinguished economist here at the University of Wyoming, secured a grant and said, 'Can we bring Tyler to Wyoming?' And this is the best we could do. So we're going to dig in, and we've got a few movements, but the first big one is to just dig in on AI. And Tyler, I want you first to put on your economic historian hat. Go back to November 30th, 2022, and just use that as a marker. ChatGPT's released that day. How significant is that going to be long term in the history of innovations or breakthroughs?
I think it will go down as one of the five or 10 most important breakthroughs ever. So that's quite significant. I mean, certainly you'd put it behind fire or language or a few other truly universal innovations, but certainly the biggest innovation in any of our lifetimes, that basically we built machines that in many significant ways are smarter than we are. And I think it will lead to an ongoing boom in information technology. So if you remember the mid to late 1990s, we had excellent wage growth and productivity growth, and we even balanced the budget. Hard to believe these days, but it wasn't that long ago when we did it. And that was due to an earlier wave of advance. Those were very simple things like using software to control inventory or Microsoft BASIC software, and now we have something more potent. So I think it will get us at least as much as it did back then. But I would say to anyone listening who is young, and I think that still includes you, Scott, you'll live to a hundred if you stay off the motorcycle. And that had not been the previous expectation. I think most of the things that kill people we will fix. You'll still die. It's just old age or brain rot, whatever. But that will be a very different era for humanity where the norm is to live to something like 100 years old. And we've already seen, you know, they had a new model out, not at release, but they created a new model about three weeks ago, and it's already cracked probably two of the millennium problems in mathematics that no human mathematician had gotten close to solving. And that's in a small number of days. So over time, that kind of intelligence, machine intelligence, will be applied to many, many areas. And essentially, it will change everything.
That's interesting. One of my biotech friends, a good friend of mine, says, 'Just stay alive 10 years. You have no idea what's going on.'
I'm a little more pessimistic than that because I focus on the regulators, not just the tech, right? But basically, he's correct. Stay alive x number of years, you can debate x, but for any value of x, you should exercise more and eschew the motorcycle.
That's great. What would convince you that we're wrong? Like what evidence would have you say this has all been exaggerated? You know, I'm thinking of like, you know, Solow's paradox in like the 70s and 80s on computers. Like, yes, they're bringing a lot of productivity, but they're just not showing up in any of the data when it comes to progress. Any thoughts on what the alternative might be where we just don't see the growth or living standard improvement that you're predicting?
Well, first, it is being exaggerated by many, many people. So I know plenty of people, some of whom are economists even, who predict ongoing rates of economic growth of 7%, 10%, sometimes crazy numbers like 50%. I don't think there's any real chance of that. There's too many binding constraints from energy, from data, from human inertia. So what I've been predicting is something like half a percentage point a year extra, or maybe a bit more. Now, over time, compounded, that makes the whole world different, say 30 years later. But in any given year, well, it's a nice boost to have, but it doesn't feel like utopia. And then there's some gains like you living to 100. That may even harm GDP if you're not working all that time. We'll see what shape you're in, but it's still obviously an enormous advance in human welfare. So I think yes, very noticeable gains. The whole world will change, but a lot of the people who talk about it do exaggerate it.
So go back in your own history of ideas a bit. Does this mean you're no longer a great stagnationist, and that that has been cracked now?
The great stagnation ended some number of years ago. Absolutely. And I insist on saying this to Peter Thiel. I cannot convince him, but I think grudgingly underneath the surface he knows I'm right. And I'm hoping to see Peter again and continue the debate. But absolutely, it's over. Also, mRNA vaccines, which were done by computational biology, you could think of that as a cousin of AI, saved millions of lives around the world. That was 2020. That was really the first sign that the great stagnation was over.
Let's talk a little bit about your own adoption and usage of AI because a number of the people joining are faculty here in the College of Business. It's really fascinating to just watch their adoption of it, and I'm proud to report that our college is pushing hard on encouraging it. Our MBA program was profiled in a news story about how all faculty in the program have leaned into making sure AI is a component in each and every class in our MBA program. So we're pretty optimistic or positive on what it's going to mean for students. I'm wondering what you've done to your own personal life to incorporate it, and if you were to look back three years, are there any things you've done with it that you say, 'Gosh, I would have viewed this as completely irresponsible a couple of years ago, and now it's just normal, par for the course'?
Well, not irresponsible, but one big shift is things that I haven't done. So I think in some measure of time AI will be a better writer than I am. It's already a better economist. So it changes what I do. I give more talks, I do more podcasts, I travel more. AI can't really do any of those things. But if you give it like a microeconomic test, and you give me the same test, you can even let me write the test. It beats me. It's not close. So I take this seriously. It means we need to teach our students different things. I don't pretend to have that all figured out, but a lot of professors need to become more like mentors or a source of inspiration or career guidance or working more on softer skills. The simple transmission of information, the AIs typically are better at it, and they know more and they make fewer mistakes. But when I'd say when I travel, mostly my trip is shaped by AI because I've written a blog for 23 years, as you mentioned before. It knows my views on many things. I could ask it on any given night, I'll probably do it tonight, 'Where does Tyler Cowen want to eat dinner in San Francisco?' And it knows where, and it sends me there, and it just works. I do this for concerts, for art museums. So anything where I need to make a choice, I just ask it, and it knows me better than I know myself, and it knows the rest of the world better. So it works.
Yeah, I agree, and that's a tremendous use for it. Can you describe your own production function a little bit? This is a question from one of our economists in the department, Steve Newbold. How many different platforms you're using at any given time, and you know, just how much intersection there is with your writing and your work on a regular basis?
You mean how many different AI models? Well, there's two main ones that are better than all the rest, and that's GPT Pro, the expensive version, and then you know, the Claude and Fable suite. Yep. I work more with GPT Pro, but I think there's a kind of leapfrogging. Every month or two, one of the companies does something that makes it better than the other, the other catches up. So which is better? Don't obsess over one point in time. I would just say pick one and learn how to work with it and stick with that one, but use both for variety and to see what's going on. The new meta model, Muse, which I haven't downloaded yet, but it gets very good reviews, so I'm going to put some time into it. I think Grok is very useful for anything that's happened in the last three days. I use it for that. It's not a great all-purpose AI. Google hasn't put out a serious new model in a while, but in the past they've been in the running, and I wouldn't count them out. They obviously have a lot of resources. So those are the main models. There's a bunch of Chinese open source models that come and go. At the very least, they're fun. And if you're doing heavy work, they're much cheaper than the US models. They're lower quality, but they're really very good. I'll play around with them. I don't really use them other than to play around with them to stay current. So that's, you know, more or less my suite. And because I give talks on AI, I feel a bit obliged to keep current on everyone to some extent. But really, GPT Pro is my workhorse.
You've had a comparative advantage for a long time at being just an unbelievably fast consumer of information and knowledge. I think it's one of the things that sets you apart is just how informed you are about not only current things, but just could ask you anything under the sun and you have some familiarity with it. I think of AI as closing that gap between you and a lot of other people because they can just look things up really quickly too. So can you talk a little bit about what it means for you and your own productivity and output long term? Like is it a risk or an enhancer for you?
Well, it's both. I would say I have to rely more on my charisma. Make of that what you will. And again, I write a bit less, but giving live in-person talks or talks over the internet, again, AI is not even in that realm. So I do much more of that. And I flew to San Francisco to give some talks at OpenAI, which maybe I wouldn't have, you know, couldn't have done in a pre-AI world. But I travel a lot more, and I spend more time mentoring people and more time in private conversation. And it's a big shift. But I'd say I've reallocated, I don't know, at least half my time because of AI. It's going well for me, and I enjoy it. But I'm also glad I had this earlier period where I did, I still do a lot of writing. I blog every day. I have a column every week. I have a new book coming out. It's hardly that I've quit on writing, but I'd say I used to do 30, 40% more writing than I do now.
What's the new book about?
It's called Mentors and Mentees. And it's exactly what the title suggests. And I think it's a book that is not made obsolete by AI. A lot of books don't make sense anymore. Either the book takes too long to come out and AI has changed the world, or AI knows more about the topic than your book does. So most people should write fewer books, I would say.
That's great. I have a board member who asked a question about the inequality effects of AI, and I'm going to try to summarize that. His name is Jacob Doss. He wanted to understand what your thoughts are on, you know, so the traditional pathway has been get a four-year degree, work your way up the corporate ladder, start somewhere in low-level white-collar work, and then just progress. Those jobs seem particularly vulnerable in the new AI world, and he's wondering what it's going to mean for, you know, young workers going forward who needed that 24-year-old white-collar job to end up in the more wisdom-oriented 45-year-old job. Any thoughts on that?
Well, the new path upwards will be working well with AI. You could call that the new white-collar job. I'm not sure, you know, the white-collar designation makes sense anymore. A lot of it will be quite young people. I don't think credentials will matter nearly as much. Like it's not that easy to go to Harvard and have someone teach you how to work with agents. I'm not saying no one there can do it. Obviously, it's full of very talented people, but it's not what Harvard does, so to speak. Harvard trains people to be elites, but that training is worth less because someone who works with agentic models will kick your butt across the room, right? And some of that will be foreigners, some will be immigrants, some will be teenagers, some will just be people very good at retraining and taking initiative. And they will be our new high earners. On net, I think it will be egalitarian. Income inequality, I think, will go down if you look at it globally. Countries like Africa, where health care or legal advice, consulting, whatever, is very scarce, I think they'll, in relative terms, benefit the most from AI, so that will make it more egalitarian. But I do think it's true there will be more billionaires. So people who otherwise just would have been computer geeks now have a chance of being a billionaire, starting a small company with a small number of people and running AI agents, and you know, they'll hit like a few billion in revenue and sell something, and there'll be way more of that. So I wouldn't count on like real estate prices here in San Francisco to come down, right?
One more question about just the potential for future employment, and particularly young people. My wife Anemone says hi, and she said I have to ask you about our 16-year-old. So our oldest is 16. Can't believe that she's learning all of the things you should learn at 16. You know, she's doing geometry and beating us up with her geometry homework. You know, reading the classics, arguing with us about dishes and who has a comparative advantage in doing dishes. So she's fabulous. What should we be maybe shedding from her training and adding to it, you know, given the AI world we're living in right now?
Well, the first thing I would do is ask the AI and give more information than I have, and that will be a good answer. But I get this question every day multiple times, like what should my kid do? What should my grandkid do? Or what should I do? I think there'll be a sufficient amount of change, there's no simple answer, and not that many jobs will stay the same. So in a funny way, it gives you a degree of short-term license. I tend to tell people, do what you want, but you need plans B, C, and D. Also, like in the old days, you could just say, I'm going to become an economist, as we did. I'm going to become a lawyer. Like, I might want to go to university admin, whatever. And you knew 20, 30 years later what that job would be like more or less, and your expectations were correct. We are out of that world. So maybe there's some jobs that are safe. Like if someone says I want to be a horse trainer, I don't say to them, oh, AI is coming to take that away from you. But for the most part, there's much higher uncertainty. And to teach yourself how to retrain yourself is the real skill, and to have emotional equanimity and flexibility going forward, because a lot of these things will change. And keep current with AI models. I assume she's doing that. She doesn't have to master them, but you don't want her to be like 22 and then out there in the real world and like, 'Oh, here's Claude. What's Claude?' or I don't know, whatever it is. That's a bad place to be.
You feel her. That balance is dangerous because she comes up with arguments that are really difficult for mom and dad too. So we have to go to our bots and argue back.
One last AI question before we transition a bit. I've watched you recently, you know, kind of engaging with some of the doomers and just really on kind of a line of thought on, you know, if the apocalypse is coming, where's the evidence? Or, you know, show me the market price that's indicating that doom is around the corner. And at some level, they seem to be getting under your skin at times because you're coming back to it often. And I'm just wondering your thoughts on probabilities there. So one way of asking this with a bit of Wyoming flavor is like your odds or your probability you would put on like AI extinction versus something really bad like a super volcano in Yellowstone or an asteroid hitting Earth. Like, can you help us calibrate for like your view of the risk, the existential risk?
I don't feel I can give you an accurate number, but I don't think it's any higher now than it has been. And AI might even help protect us against some other risks over time. You and I are both economists. So like, oh, there's a war in the Middle East, the price of oil goes up, right? Right. And you look for things like that. How bad is it with Iran? The Strait of Hormuz? Well, I'm not sure. But if I look at the price of oil, I get a very rough sense. Is it very high? Is it very low? And when I look for indicators of doom, I can look at market prices, volatility indices, S&P 500, prices of insurance companies, prices of cybersecurity companies. I don't see any weird numbers at all. It seems quite normal, and I think that's the correct inference. Now, that's not a proof. As you and I know, you could say market prices, they're wrong every day, every moment. That's why they change. But still, at the end of the day, if the evidence is not there, the evidence is not there. And I would make the broader point that great civilizations do not thrive by obsessing over their doom. They have a pragmatic approach and they solve problems as they come along. And then if there is a truly major existential risk, they're in a better shape to solve it because they've been thinking pragmatically all along and not trading back and forth. Oh, what's your P-doom? What's my P-doom? People saying 10, 20%. That's completely groundless. Like not only is it too high, but if you ask them why you say 10 rather than 20 or 20 rather than 10, they have nothing. So I think it's a very harmful discourse. It's depressing people. It's giving them what's sometimes called AI psychosis. We have huge problems, but I think we're fine and we're continuing, and I'm going to be part of that.
That's great. Shifting gears, my boss is a pro, my pro host Ann Alexander here. She's an economist, huge fan. She can't join live, but she had a couple of questions for you and wants to hear from you a bit about your views of higher education and the university business model. What are your thoughts about the future of higher ed? When we're looking at a world where AI is able to do so many amazing things, what is it going to look like for the typical faculty member? And you know, is our industry overbuilt or just right or too small? What are your thoughts on industry size as well?
I think it will be rough. First, putting AI aside, as you know, we are due for declining enrollments in the aggregate, and the immigration picture will not rescue us. It takes like 17, 18 years to get a baby to university age. So there's no quick reversal coming, and many schools already have closed, but many more will just shrink. And as you know, colleges and universities find it hard to control their costs. I think they're a somewhat less attractive proposition for many, not all donors, but they're not obviously the place where everyone's dying to give all their money because they've become politically controversial or just sometimes they seem inefficient. And then you have these spectacular advances, say in mathematics, most recently. The role of university research and professors has been essential. I can't stress that more. But still, at the end of the day, the press release is that, oh well, you know, an OpenAI model solved this math problem, and that makes universities seem less important. I think actually they're more important because you need humans to work with the AIs. But the sense of the university as the hero upholding the banner of intelligent thought, it doesn't quite feel that way anymore, and maybe it's not completely. So it's like shared credit, and we need to work more effectively with the private sector, with AI companies. I'm glad to hear you're all making that shift, but universities turn and change very slowly, and it's not really in the interests of faculty for this to be real. A lot of faculty would just prefer it went away, and they will slow down change in many, many institutions.
Let's say we could appoint you president of a new university. And what would be some of the things you would do to just put it on a different course than, you know, some of these, you know, grinding institutional issues that can really slow things down?
Well, I have an hour-long lecture on that. It's on YouTube. I was invited to U Austin in Austin, not UT Austin, but University of Austin, which is genuinely a new institution, as you know. Yep. And you know, they have not a huge number of students in any given semester. They offer a total of 30 classes. I was told it's great that they can do it, but 30 is tiny. Think of all they don't cover, right? So I said, just try this experiment. Let each student once create their own AI-driven class however they want, whatever. You know, AI gives them a reading list, AI gives them quizzes, they chat with the AI, all sorts of models. Just let people experiment for one class. And they have to pick something that's not in the normal list of classes, so they're not avoiding what's there. And then just see how it goes. Have a professor grade the final stuff, but all the rest is AI. And if people don't like it, you can abolish the option, or just people may stop doing it if it's not any good. But if people like it a year or two later, consider letting them do it twice in their four years. Just let it be done once. Have competition, the AI class versus the other classes. I think none of us know how it's going to go or which models will students like the best. I don't think, you know, being a Hayekian, we cannot top-down design, oh, here's how to do AI in education the right way. I'm quite sure I don't know that the students will figure it out more than the faculty. Let them try things. They can even write up reports for us, what they liked, didn't like, what worked. We can see what leads to good grades, good understanding. You can give them oral exams at the end, whatever you want. Just see how it goes, and set in motion this Hayekian learning dynamic. They haven't done that. I don't know of any school that has. I've said this to a number of university presidents, board members, people probably you would have heard of or maybe know. It could be someone's doing it and I don't know about it. But no, I don't hear peep about it. Yeah, that's my idea. And it's so tiny, like just one class in four years. And the fact that it is not being tried tells me a lot, indeed too much. Right. So I'll tell it to all of you. Just try it. One place.
Well, maybe folks listening will, they'll give it a whirl. They'd have my support, for sure. Tyler, talking a little bit about George Mason and its distinctiveness. Here in the College of Business, we have a pretty distinctive economics program. It has a strong reputation in natural resource economics, experimental economics. John List is a graduate of it, and we're very proud of everything he's accomplished. Mason is another place that has had a 50-year reputation of distinguished and, you know, just really unique contributions being made to the field. You know, going back to Buchanan and Tullock, and then you have a period where Walter Williams is synonymous with George Mason, Vernon Smith and the experimentalists, and now the contemporary Mason period, which is Masonomics. It's you and it's Bryan Caplan, Alex Tabarrok, Pete Boettke, others. Can you tell us a little bit about how Mason has sustained distinctiveness for so long and how it's feeling now, especially with you essentially being Mr. GMU in terms of, you know, you think of the place and it's like, oh, that's where Tyler Cowen is. Can you talk about that a little bit?
Well, George Mason as a school, but in particular economics, has been willing to do things differently. Dare to be different was Buchanan's motto. And somehow we've kept that longer than I thought we would have been able to. I think some of that is leadership, but some of that is simply that it's worked. But that said, we face this new threshold with AI where we need to rethink everything we're doing. And I don't think we're ahead of other people at GMU. I'm not sure if we're behind, but we're not in the lead. And this worries me. So we'll see how it goes. But I think we need to feel the heat really and not rest on past laurels, all these great things in the past. But there's a new wave of stuff coming, a bit like how math came to economics. Whatever you think of it, like the math pretty much won out. This in a way will de-mathematize a lot of economics. There'll be math done, but it won't be done by the humans, and the humans will have more room to be intellectually creative and deal with ideas. So that to me is fascinating, but I want us to be in the lead of doing that. We'll see how that goes.
Can you talk a little bit about benchmarking and the challenge of, you know, I mean, just keeping up and being reputable with the other schools, but yet daring to be different and, you know, just driving this product that has you all blogging and, you know, really active in public intellectual discourse, and how Mason has somehow embedded that as a value that people can be doing and that you place a premium on? Like, how did that happen? That, you know, just the traditional measurement, you know, I can count numbers as a dean, I'm really good at that, and I can look at journal lists and say these are the things that matter. A lot of the contributions at Mason are outside of that normal parameter.
You know, we've continually placed our students well, that helps keep it going. People want to come into the world. You know, we continue having this reputation in terms of influence. You know, probably we rank in the top five of economics departments. We wouldn't be in the top five if you're counting AER publications, but we have realms where we truly excel, and it's been good for the students, and we really value teaching. That's an important part of it. We really value mentorship. Maybe we've gotten a bit lucky as well. We've been in a great part of the world to live in, right outside of Washington, D.C., a growing community, not really all that politically partisan, a well-run state. So a lot of things have gone our way, but you always have to keep at it. And again, I'm always worried that we're not going to make the next cut.
Tell me a little bit about how you feel about doctoral education in the field of economics. A lot of our students tuning in are grad students in our doc program here today. Let's say a 21-year-old comes to you, very talented, and says, 'I want to study economics at the doctoral level.' What's your answer now compared to when you were starting your career 30 years ago or so?
Well, when I started, which is to be clear way more than 30 years ago, it's 50 years ago, and at age 14, I decided to become an economist. But when I made that decision, I had this clear vision of what my life, career, and job would be like. And reality delivered exactly what I was expecting because the world just didn't change that much. Now I would say to a person, you're looking into like a mirror of the past, and the next 10 years will be about economists working with AI agents and doing things together. And if you don't want to do that, maybe you should change your mind. If you do that, you can do better work than ever before, more creative work, and just more work in terms of quantity. We'll be in a world soon, if not already, where you can write an excellent paper a month. So that's pretty incredible. I don't actually know how journals, tenure committees will deal with that. So there'll be all this clumpiness. There'll be a subset of people who can write a really good paper a month. Then other people who are like impressed they have two good papers a year. And how do we change the standards over time? Or, you know, for whom do we credit for what? Or how much of the work was yours? How much was the AI's? What if you just had a really good prompt? Does that count for you? And so on and so on. I'm pretty sure we're just going to evaluate final outputs, but the transition will be very messy. But if you're looking at what these jobs were like in the past, I think that's a mistake. Like you will certainly be able to find places that refuse to change, and you might ensconce yourself in them, but over time they will lose revenue, morale, enrollments, slots, and I don't think it will be that great a life if you're like 21 and want to do this. Like say you live to 100, what, you're going to do that for 80 years and be in a place that is a dinosaur? It won't even have the revenue. So there's this big new thing you need to take into account. None of us really know exactly how it's going to go. That uncertainty may intimidate you, but I'd say most professions will have a comparable uncertainty. So it should not, in relative terms, scare you off, but it's a lot of rethinking to do.
Can you tell us a little bit about how you approach evaluating talent, both in terms of recruiting faculty, but also in this graduate student space that we're discussing as well? Like, I look at what it's taking to get into grad schools now, and it's like there's no way I would make the cut anymore. It's just, you know, more and more things that they're doing ahead of time, pre-docs, and you know, they all have 800s on their GRE or whatever the new standard is. And you know, are we getting really good at the front-end application, but are the economists that much better that we're producing on the back end? Any thoughts on how you untangle and evaluate talent both at the graduate market but then in the market for, you know...
economists that you're trying to hire.
Well, I think it's terrible how it's evolved. It's really helped kids from wealthy elite families. Nothing against them, but when they have such a relative leg up, it's not a good thing. And you have more conformism. People play the game by the rules, you know, they think of themselves as RAs who slowly become the person in charge. Everything is done by teams. It's much harder to get a controversial idea through a team than solo or with two people. So, I'd like there to be more graduate schools. I wouldn't say that they literally take everybody. The person for economics would have to know calculus, some stats, some other things. You know, their English would have to be good enough. But the idea of simply taking everyone within some range appeals to me greatly.
We're not great at predicting talent, and people will have chances to blossom, and things are changing a lot anyway. We should make exit very easy and be very honest with people, like, no, we think you should leave, or kick them out, even flunk them out, whatever. But that's what I'd like to see. That's what the University of Chicago did a long time ago. They didn't quite take everyone, but they would say, we're the place that will give you a chance if you can't get in anywhere else, and I think that went very well for them.
One of our faculty asked, and this is more generally than just finding talent in econ: any unconventional hacks for just finding talent more generally, like things that you rely on to just, you know, get beyond the basic questions every candidate is being asked?
Well, I try not to overvalue articulateness, which gets overvalued.
The level of detail that a person answers questions with for me is paramount. You keep on asking them questions, ask for more detail. If they can keep on giving you more detail and maintain enthusiasm and determination, when you see all that together, to me, I just want to work with the person, support the person, whatever. Talent's more global than ever before. That's a cliche, but not that many people actually live by that. It's harder to evaluate talent from other places. So maybe you just need to take more chances. That's why I like semi-open admissions at some schools.
And I like to get people off script. If they're talking out of prep, to me, it's worthless. Maybe you learn if they can do prep, but you don't really learn about them. So just talk to them about other things and see how they think about the world and see what their values are, and approach it in a relaxed manner. You should be enjoying yourself talking to them most of the time. If you're not, it shouldn't be you doing the call or the interview or whatever it is. So they should feel that you want to learn something from them. That's how you bring out the best in them. And if you don't feel that in yourself, like we all have bad days, but if it's a recurring thing, like step back and give up the job. And in institutions, whoever is best at talent, it's not that correlated with smarts or achievement.
So like at George Mason we had Buchanan, obviously was the Nobel laureate. I don't think all of his talent judgments were so great, frankly.
And you look at sports, like Michael Jordan, maybe the best player of all time, he was GM of the Charlotte Hornets, Patrick Johnson was a coach. They did terribly. So to have faith in whoever is best at talent and really give them more authority than their position or title or academic status might justify, and be willing to double, triple down on that, it's very important. And not that many groups do it because it's kind of a slight to the more senior, more famous people, but you really just got to do that.
Like there, I taught at UC Irvine a long time ago, and they were very smart in a number of ways, but they had someone back then, she was called a secretary. She'd have a different title today. No post-graduate education at all, but she was super perceptive, and they would all ask her what she thought of the different candidates. She had the best judgments of all, I thought.
And again, whatever it takes.
Yeah, that's amazing, and so often the case. We've got a few minutes, and I think there's going to be a really robust Q&A from our audience here. I want to put you in the hot seat and give you a Wyoming overrated/underrated treatment here for a few minutes, Tyler.
Sure. I will do poorly, but let's try. Is this like Jia? Is she really buried in Wyoming or...
So I love this aspect of what this part of your conversations with Tyler. Just looking for one sentence or fairly brief explanations on a number of things. So this is going to be Mountain West themed. And just wondering first: Yellowstone National Park, overrated, underrated?
It's still underrated. That sounds crazy because it's maybe the most famous of the national parks along with Grand Canyon, but there's something about the magic you feel in there and the diversity of experience that social media or influencers... So I think it's pretty phenomenal. I've been, I don't know, four times, and it still seems underrated to me.
We have Bryan Caplan headed there in the middle of October, and then coming here for a debate on immigration. So I think it's his first time, if I'm not mistaken.
Excited for his report too. And I told him to get bear spray.