Okay, Tyler, thank you for doing this.
Okay, first question. Do you think like the rate of meta innovation, how we find talents, has been accelerating faster than technological innovation itself?
I think the rate at which we are finding talent has accelerated a great deal in the last 10 years. So the internet truly becoming the thing, even though we've had the internet for a while, I think that's fairly recent.
And younger people truly mastering the internet also is fairly recent. I would say the last 10 to 15 years. So those two developments together, I think, have meant teenage talent we're discovering a lot more quickly than we used to. You're an example of that. You're age 17, right? And here we are doing this podcast. Could this have happened without the internet?
But I even think like the internet of 20 years ago, it could not have happened. So I think it's going to keep on going. You see it in chess. All these great young chess players. Gukesh is world champion at age 18. So I'm very bullish on that development.
And how have you discovered talent on Twitter? Because according to you, all you need to spot a highly talented person is an essay of 1500 words and a Zoom call. So I guess like if you have access to just thousands of tweets of someone, you can kind of have a sense whether or not they would be talented.
When it's on Twitter, I think my formula is to have them discover me rather than me discover them.
So, I'm not very famous, but I'm somewhat well known.
And people I might be interested in, I think they'll come across me, and then it's up to them to come forward, and I will meet them, discover them, you know, chat with them, read something they did. But usually the initiative comes from them. They'll send me a link, something they wrote or whatever, and that works pretty well.
Okay. And do you think overall staying anonymous on Twitter, is it like, do your favorite accounts are anonymous, or do they come with more benefits?
I don't like anonymous accounts. So I like the context of knowing who it is.
Also, the people who stay anonymous, there's some reason for that, right? So a lot of them will self-destruct intellectually because they feel they're not accountable for their views and they become crazier and crazier. Others are people who have a real job, but they're afraid to let on who they are. It just feels like an unstable mental equilibrium to me. So, I don't know.
The accounts I really like, I know who they are, and I mean, the world knows, too.
It might be a pretext of anonymity. So, like Rune, R-O-N on Twitter, he's anonymous, but everyone, not everyone, but people know who he is. I'm not going to say like where.
But people, yeah, he's open about working at OpenAI.
And if you want to find out, there he is.
Have you met like any anonymous accounts that like his tweets were super good, but at real life they were just very dumb or it didn't seem to match?
No. I think if you can be smart on Twitter, you're just flat out smart.
And you will seem smart.
I've never met such a person where they seemed dumb.
Okay. Why do you think the labor market is so bad at spotting talent?
Well, when you say the market's bad at it, you have to ask compared to what. But part of the problem is this. If you spot talent, you have to invest resources, and the talent probably won't work for you. So the profit incentive to spot that talent can be fairly weak, especially younger talent. You spot a brilliant 16-year-old and say you're a company, that person's unlikely to work for you. Maybe in a few areas like AI, there's only a few major companies, you develop a relationship with them or some of the VC companies. But for the most part, you're relying on what you might call volunteers, and it takes time, energy, effort, and attention, and a lot of it doesn't happen. I think that's the market failure, the difficulty of internalizing the gains.
But do you think like even the market cares about spotting talent? Because it seems like at one point it's just you're hiring like a worker and you don't really care if they have that much insight or if they have original work of their own. They just, you just want them to do the work you're assigning them.
I think the market cares a lot. Now, it depends on the type of job. So, if it's, you know, a cashier in a supermarket, you want someone, first of all, who shows up, which you cannot take for granted, someone who won't steal from the till, which you cannot take for granted. And third, you want someone who can actually do the job. But if you go to say Whole Foods, which is a high-quality, pretty successful supermarket chain, their cashiers are pretty uniformly good. So they put a lot of effort into that, and whatever formulas they use seem to work.
And when I go to Whole Foods, I really pretty much know I'll have a good experience at the cashier. A lot of their people are immigrants. They're from poorer countries. They seem really quite smart to me. And I talk to them a little, and I think like, you're undervalued, like why don't you work for me? But they don't quite exactly have the training where they could do something useful for me, and it doesn't happen.
But they have very good cashiers. They're very smart people, I think, as a class.
Okay. Would you say like places like San Francisco with a lot of talent and ambition become like less relevant with time because you can just go on the internet on Twitter and connect with super talented people no matter where they are?
This is maybe counterintuitive, but it seems to me the returns to location have only been going up. The returns to being in San Francisco are high and rising.
And maybe AI, it encapsulates and can express general knowledge.
Yeah. But it does not contain secret knowledge or knowledge of very particular matters of time and place that are not in print anywhere or on video.
So just being there is worth way more. You see this in real estate prices, and I expect this trend to continue.
San Francisco in particular, like what's new in AI, if you've never been there, it's very hard to know.
If you go there some number of times a year, you can keep somewhat current.
And that's for me worth a lot. So I think you say in The Complacent Class that San Francisco is the best place in the world if you have a vision and want to work hard to achieve it. So that was like eight years ago. Do you still think that?
Absolutely, all the more so. You know, Bay Area, a bit more than just the city, but that general area, and with the rise of AI, which had not really happened when I wrote The Complacent Class, that's become a lot stronger and a lot more of it is in the city itself than when I wrote those words. It used to be a bit more like Sand Hill Road or, you know, we then called it Facebook, Apple were outside the city, but the city itself is really rising now.
And when we have all these liquidity events, the home prices will go crazy.
They're already crazy, right?
What about Austin? Like it seems there are so many prospects around Austin. Is like Austin the new San Francisco in some way?
I don't think so. I think it's a distant... I wouldn't even say it's second. It's a great place. I love going there. I like the people, but no, it's not close, and it's not gaining on the Bay Area either. Some people moved there during the pandemic. A lot of them moved back. Same with Miami. Those cities are doing fine. They're great places of their own, but they're not becoming second-tier San Francisco. Maybe Austin a little.
Do you think that could ever happen? Like a city surpassing San Francisco?
Well, if California does this billionaire's wealth tax of 5%.
That would give some other places a shot. Even then, I don't think it would happen.
But California would have to blow its lead. I don't think it will simply evolve into something else. Now, eventually, every place does that. Like, what's Florence today? It's a lovely city, but it's not an important place, right? Or Rome for that matter. So, eventually it's lost, but it does not feel close to me, that event.
Interesting. Okay. So, I'm always like struck by soccer teams that are like at the top of the charts during decades and decades. And I wonder if you think it's more like about the team being very rich and being able to hire super talented people, super talented players from other clubs, or if they actually need to be good at growing talent and they have like a good academy, otherwise it would be unsustainable.
I know very little about soccer, but I know more about basketball. And for basketball, I think the quality of the general manager and possibly owner and coach matter a great deal. And they have to really care about winning. A lot of teams, in fact, just have a share of the TV contract. They get money automatically. They want to keep their costs down, and no one really cares to do better than that. And those teams don't do better than that. Like the Washington basketball team, the Wizards, they've been bad for decades pretty much, and it's not about to change.
There is such a thing as a winning organization. Like Houston and Dallas pretty consistently put together good teams. Obviously, those players retire, get injured, but three to five years later, they're back again with another good team. Miami Heat, those are winning organizations, and you can feel it and sense it in them.
So, is it about growing, having a good structure to grow talent?
And it helps to have a larger market. So, if you're the Memphis Grizzlies, Memphis is quite a small city. They haven't done very well much. They have a little bit, they have less revenue. Ticket sales matter less. Their local TV contract is worth less. It's not the end of the story, but they're at a noticeable disadvantage. Players don't want to go there because if you're in New York or LA, like, your shoe contract is worth more, you're exposed to major media more. So small city also hurts, even when you have good management.
Interesting. Okay. How crucial do you think it is for one to develop their talent to be in the US? So I remember when we had the Zoom call for the Emergent Ventures grant, you said, like, I asked you for advice and you said that I should try to keep living in the US. Like, how crucial do you think it is, for example, for me to stay in the US?
It depends what you want to do, but I would say in over half of all areas of endeavor, it's very important to be in the United States to hit a top level of achievement. Now, there are plenty of things where you can excel in Europe. Even then, I don't think Portugal is a big enough country to be the place to be. But the UK, Germany, Switzerland, France, in many areas you can do very, very well there. You know, in your case, unless you're natively fluent in something like French or German, it's really US or UK if you want to be highly successful.
If I don't go to either of those countries, do you think I might risk like losing my ambition or just, you know, lost, like, became more conformist?
That's what usually happens. Now again, some areas are exceptions. So say you want to be a politician.
That more or less restricts you to Portugal. There are in fact plenty of people in every country, including Portugal, who have the ambition to be prime minister in the legislature. And if you compete in that arena, you won't lose your ambition because your peers will have the same ambition. But there are not that many people in Portugal who stay in Portugal who aspire to be like the greatest economist of all time. You just can't do it there. You'll leave. But if you're in an area like politics, you can stay in Portugal and you absolutely will not lose your ambition. But most sectors you would.
Okay. Okay. Do you think the startup benefits more from being good at identifying talent than a big company? Because like presumably if you go work at a startup, like every employee is very fundamental in the shape the company will take, or if it will take shape, but at the big company at the same time, like you already have the resources to do what you want.
But talent is very important for each, but in very different ways. If you have a big company, you know, say it's Coca-Cola, you need people who fit the culture of that company. So Coca-Cola has been around a long time, there's plenty of competition in their markets, people have actually started drinking much less literal Coca-Cola and they like all these weird sweet and fruity drinks, and Coca-Cola adjusted and they're still a big deal and very profitable because they had talent, people who fit your culture and who will keep you on track. It's not less important, but it's very different than you need miracle workers who are, you know, employee number four and bring your company from nothing to something that exists.
Very different set of tasks. Would you say that most like super talented young people would choose to spend their time in a startup and, you know, not transform into something big, or just go to a straight big company?
Most people prefer to work in the big company. Most people are happier working in the big company.
It's a form of less ambition, but still in a big company you can do quite well and rise up through the ranks. And if after 17 years you end up as some kind of top manager at Coca-Cola, you live in Atlanta, it's a great life. So nothing against it at all.
But it's a different sort of ambition, right? You're a cog in a machine. You're changing the world collectively, but not directly and individually so much.
Interesting. So would you choose, like, if every super talented young people, you choose for them to go to a startup or big company, what do you think brings them more life experience in the long term?
I think it's in the midst of changing. So seven years ago I would have said startup, but I think we're seeing a shift toward big companies. And you look at AI, well, where is good AI work being done? Well, a lot of it's being done at Google, which is a very large company. There's a lot going on at Meta, which is a very large company. OpenAI is becoming a large company. Anthropic, I predict, is becoming a very large company.
And the way to have impact in the most impactful area is probably to work in those places and not do a startup. There's something about the compute you need, the testing and evaluation you need, that is harder to do at small scale. Companies such as Mistral have succeeded at it. But I'd give, you know, at the moment an edge to the larger companies.
That can change too, but for now, yes.
Okay. In what ways does a company benefit from having conformist workers?
You need a common culture. Once your company's around for a while, that's your moat. Because however innovative your product was, eventually people copy it. Is Pepsi better than Coke? Is Coke better than Pepsi? You debate it. Blind taste tests, Pepsi often wins. Coca-Cola is still a bigger deal, and there's something about how well people work together that is very difficult to maintain over time. People want to carve out turf and fight wars against each other. They lose track of the mission. It just takes so much work and diligence and inspiration to keep people on that same common track.
It's an issue, you know, in nonprofits. We're here at Mercatus, 130 employees. It's not a very large number. But to keep people in Mercatus cooperative, which I think we've done pretty well, but it's a never-ending thing you need to work on.
Never-ending in a way. It just gets harder.
Would you say like that a startup benefits more from having less conformist people, workers, than a big company?
It depends on the sector. When you say startup, most people think tech, new product, software, right? And in those areas, you very often need non-conformists. But most quote-unquote startups are quite ordinary things. It could be a restaurant. It could be, you know, a shoe store. And in those cases, you probably want more or less the conformists. Maybe you need one new idea, but after that, you just want execution. And then again, you're looking to the conformists.
Why do you want less conformist people in the tech sector?
It used to be the case, still largely the case, that you need to work insanely hard, and a conformist person won't do that.
And you need people who can imagine the future being quite different than it is in their sector, and you need non-conformists for that. But again, if the startup is a shoe store, you don't need people to imagine the future being totally different. You just need people who can imagine that they can sell shoes pretty well.
And that's more or less going to be the conformists.
Okay. Then like Mercatus, I'd say we need a balance of conformists and non-conformists. And I think we're pretty good at that. But the idea people are largely non-conformist. But a lot of the execution people, like your event staff, you don't necessarily want crazy people on your event staff.
So it depends on like the job you are trying to assign them.
And a lot of companies have this mix of both, like the ideas people will be more non-conformist and the executors. Again, this can vary, but they're more likely to where you want conformity.
Okay, I see. Where do you and Malcolm Gladwell differ when it comes to talent?
I'm not sure I know all his views, you know, in his book on talent. He stresses practice a great deal.
I don't disagree with what he wrote, but I think he undersells genetics a bit, at least implicitly. So, it's not quite a disagreement, but it's a difference of emphasis.
But Malcolm is himself an amazing talent, a very underrated talent, one of the smartest people I've met, and he's done a great job throughout his life picking great talents to work with, just like publishers, agents, production companies. So, he's a great judge of talent, too.
When you look at academia, why does it seem that professors in America are way more likely to produce original work and have ideas on their own and write books or blogs than when compared to professors in Europe?
Well, we pay people much more, and your ability to move if you do well is much higher. So, if you're in Europe, even now it's hard to cross national borders. The countries are smaller. In Germany, you're technically a civil servant and you're on a bureaucratic pay scale, and that's poison for ambition. And there's just a lot of paperwork associated with many of those jobs. US is getting worse in this regard.
And in terms of immigration in the academic market, a talented academic can just get a visa to come here. It's not hard at all. It's like we have open borders for academic scientists.
So we attract the best, we pay the most, we have the single biggest market. Yeah, China is now a rival, but they're not a rival for attracting people. Like, if you're a great researcher from Switzerland, you probably still don't want to go to China. It's just a worse life than coming to the US.
I wonder if you think it's more important to give money to poor people or to talented people like you do through Emergent Ventures, because like if you give money to talented people, that might just completely outweigh giving money to the poor people, because you know the person you invested in might even become a billionaire and give tons to the poor. But at the same time, it doesn't seem like the average person can really invest in people like that.
I believe in what I call a barbell strategy. You want to do both. It's people in the middle you shouldn't give much to. They're not poor enough to really need it, and they're maybe not talented enough to do something astonishing and wonderful.
So you're never going to be sure the money you give to talented people, what will be done with it. The person might be awesome, but then you ask, well, they might have succeeded anyway, right? You'll never really know if you made a difference. Poor people, even then it's hard to know you made a difference. I'd say when you give money to poor people, mostly you're buying them what I call consumption insurance. So if something very bad happens, they have something to fall back upon. But you're not elevating them out of poverty.
And you need to approach it somewhat realistically. There's a lot of evidence on this. But my own efforts personally, I help out some very poor people in Mexico and Ethiopia. And then I put a lot of time into trying to help out very talented people. And say like the lower middle class, I'm not much interested in helping them at all.
Okay. Do you take the EA 10% pledge?
No. My wife and I, we send a lot of our money to poor countries, and my work for Emergent Ventures is volunteer labor.
Okay. So in opportunity cost terms it would be more than 10%.
Right.
That no, I don't give 10% of my money away in that manner.
Okay. It seems Emergent Ventures attracts a lot of effective altruists. Do you think effective altruists as a whole are very talented?
In the past, effective altruism has been a great place to find super talented young people. It was a set of ideas. It brought them together. It was attractive. It was a broadly optimistic view of the world that you can actually improve things. I think that's important.
So I've been a fan of it for those reasons, even though I don't agree with every single one of the doctrines. I agree with a lot of it. Their attitude toward talent, it was different than mine. I think they're maybe they're changing a bit. A lot of effective altruism has been focused on projects rather than people. So they'll say, 'Oh, we know like mosquito bed nets save a lot of lives, so we're going to spend a lot of money on mosquito bed nets.' I think that's made good sense from a group such as, they used to be called Open Philanthropy, now they're renamed as Coefficient Giving, because they had a lot of money and could do that at some decent scale. I don't have resources anything close to what they have.
So my hope for leverage is to get really talented people, find them at hinge moments in their lives, often when they're young, and have them turn into people who will have major impact.
Okay. So you don't think EA is still a fault for smart people?
I think less. EA is less of a coherent movement. Unfortunately, when everything happened with Sam Bankman-Fried, EA took a reputational knock, which I consider to be unfair. And EA events are not the attraction they once were. But when you meet all these people who are, they now use the phrase 'I'm EA adjacent', they're still great people, but they're just a lot more diffused. They self-identify less clearly. That was probably inevitable, but it's been a noticeable change.
Do you think the movement will ever like die?
Well, look, effective altruism we had in the early 19th century with Jeremy Bentham and arguably in the 18th century with Picaria. Yeah, sort of went away. It'll always come back, maybe with different names. So, no, I don't think it will ever really go away.
It makes some basic sense. Again, you don't have to agree with all of it. But the idea that you should not give money away mindlessly, but you should try to calculate maximum impact, that idea will always have appeal.
Do you think humanity benefits more from having smart people or good-hearted people in the long term?
I think it's a multiplicative model. You need first and foremost people who are determined and who stay the course, and then they need to be smart, and some of them need to be good-hearted. A lot of them can be bastards in reality, but some have to be good-hearted, and you need all those things to come together to get anywhere.
So it's not really an either/or. You need both.
If rich people give money to the poor, does that make society overall more rich or more poor?
Oh, it's a good thing for the poor, and I don't think it much harms the rich. But I would just say it's very difficult to give money away effectively. In many ways, it's easier to earn money than to give it away effectively.
If you simply give money to anyone, whether the poor or not, whether it's academics, a lot of them just don't use it very well, or they don't invest in it properly, or they give it away to their friends, or they squander it. The money, you know, say my wife and I send to Mexico and Ethiopia, they're actually families we know a bit and who behave responsibly, but not everyone is in a position where they know some poor families in rural Mexico and Ethiopia.
So, you don't trust like the effective charities?
Well, I'm sure there are good ones, but it's hard to know from a distance, and I would trust my own judgment over, you know, other people's judgment.
Okay. What's the best explanation of why Europe's rich don't give as much away when compared to America's rich?
In the United States, it's a tradition. We have a very particular radical worldview that is in part derived from Protestantism, that you have a life mission and you ought to incur real sacrifice, including working harder, to fulfill that mission. Here there's also a bigger tax break, and the way peer groups are formed, if you give a lot of money to something, you get on the board, you're invited to events, you use that as a way of building out your peer group and your network, in a way where in Europe it's maybe more what high school you went to or people you've known all your life, and the value, the selfish value of being philanthropic is much higher in this large diverse country.
So often you say that if you really care about the long-term future, the best thing you can do is to promote economic growth. I wonder if you think like the promotion of economic growth, so like the creation of innovations, is more altruistic long term when compared to like some EA related approaches like donating to charity in order to reduce global poverty or trying to reduce existential risk.
In general, I'm a bigger fan of innovation, but I would stress a lot of EA types recognize this and they've tried to fund innovations, sometimes successfully. Sometimes they fund the innovations they didn't intend to. So the people in the EA movement who are the AI doomers, they've actually done more to encourage AI advances than anyone else. I find that interesting.
You talk about how powerful something is, and the rest of the world gets excited. They don't always buy your story about doom, but they'll buy into part of your story about its power, and they'll want to invest a lot more money in it.
And that's exactly what happened. And then over time, the institutions that start off focused on safety, they get shaped by the imperatives of being an institution and having to raise money and maximize profit. And over time, they just become very effective companies at building and marketing AI systems, which I think is a good thing, but they're very different from how they were when they started off. And again, the doomers have spurred this on rather than slowing it down.
But I think effective altruism has plenty of room for innovation. You know, innovation is an ongoing game. It tends to spread to most of the world. Giving stuff away is one time, and a lot of it gets wasted. So, if you can pull off an innovation, that's definitely my priority.
But it's harder to pull off. Like, you can always give more money to anti-malaria bed nets, and you know, you'll do some good. Like the bed nets work. It's not that hard a thing. And most innovations fail. So, it's a tricky balance. You know, you want to do some of each, I would say.
Okay. You wrote the true disagreements over long-termism, as with most political concerns, remain foundationally rooted in our emotions and our personal temperaments. Do you mean that like no amount of data or analysis can fully resolve them because like we differ on which feels morally urgent?
Yeah. I think people's views are largely guided by their temperaments. Like I have pretty optimistic world views. I do think they're correct. They're fully sincere. But I also recognize I was born with a pretty positive temperament, which my mother tells me I exhibited early on. I was like a well-behaved child and had a lot of fun just doing different things. And so, okay, it's easy for me to be an optimist. And I think that really matters for where you end up. And it's hard to talk your way out of it even when you ought to. So, if the world were somehow ending, I probably would be trying too hard to see a bright side in that.
Fortunately it's not ending, but if it were.
Oh, you don't think it's... In a conversation with Warsh, I think you gave like that we have like 700 years left. Do you think that...
Well, my view is this: there's always a risk of either nuclear war or something like nuclear war, with maybe different kind of weapons, but equally or more destructive. And in any given year, I think the chance of that is quite small. In that sense, I'm an optimist. I think the chance of that in a given year is smaller than most people think. But I do recognize there's such a thing as a probability density function. And if you let enough years run, at some point it's going to happen. Now, when I said 800 years, that was a bit tongue-in-cheek. It's just a number I made up. It's probably not going to happen soon. Yeah.
But I don't think you need a million years for it to happen. I also don't think it would end all of civilization. Some people will survive, but it would set things back very severely and maybe permanently.
Don't you think like we should be more focused on trying to expand humanity to other planets because a lot of existential risks matter because we only are on one planet. So if we destroy this planet, all humanity dies.
As a youthful science fiction fan, I would like very much if we could do that, but it seems to me very, very difficult. And even Mars, which is relatively close, I think would basically kill or disable all the people who go to live there.
And to survive on another planet, you need exactly the right planet. Maybe you have to live underground. There's issues of radiation. I just don't see it working. So, there's the upper atmosphere and under the ocean or on the ocean. Those seem more promising to me.
I don't even know that we need them. Like, you ever go to Nevada? Like, where are you living right now?
Omaha. Okay. Drive 10 minutes and it's empty, right?
So, you're like, we need Mars? I don't know. Nebraska, there's a lot of land there.
So, do you think Elon will ever like launch a rocket to Mars?
Absolutely. But I don't think it will matter that much. He'll launch a rocket. There might be people on it on a suicide mission. They'll land on Mars. It'll be a big deal, but just like we went to the moon in 1969 and that was the end of that, I think it will be a bit similar.
What's really valuable is space, the satellite belt, property rights up in space. We're going to put data centers in space. We may get solar-powered energy from up there in space. That's super valuable. A lot of that might happen, but that's where the action will be, not Mars. What's on Mars? It's not in Nebraska. Mars doesn't even have cows. You have great beef in Nebraska, and I should go to Mars.
Interesting. Okay. If long-term impact is about what endures for centuries, do you think like EA people underrate the role of religion in shaping institutions?
Underrate the role of what?
I've noticed sociologically a lot of the EA people do not think enough about culture and religion at all. Very distant from that. But I have seen in the last two, three years some noticeable shifts where they're starting to do it more. I hope that continues. So I think they're willing to learn on those topics, but they're also just harder to wrap your arms around. Like we all know what it means to invest in mosquito bed nets. If you say, 'Well, I want to invest in giving America a better culture.' Okay, but what do you do the next day? Much tougher issue. And a lot of the EA groups, they want to be transparent and they want to have a kind of defensibility and legibility to what they do. Yeah. And that pushes them more in the direction of bed nets and less in the direction of these less tangible things. But the less tangible things are super important, and they're right now underinvested in.
So do you think like if EA people start to look more at religion, they like would change some of their practices or...
I don't know. Again, if you look at the talent in the EA movement, I would say a lot of it is highly analytical, and as talents they're not that strong in the humanities. That's just an observational fact. So maybe they're better off just sticking with the analytic stuff, and someone else will have to do the cultural and religious issues. But still, you'd like if there could be more crossover, right, in both directions, right? But maybe they're just not good at it.
Like some of the EA people, you talk to them, they just seem like they're in quite a fog. They grew up in the rationality community. They're very good at a certain like very narrow set of ways of thinking. They can be very effective applying those ways of thinking. Maybe that's just their comparative advantage.
Okay. Interesting. So you've said before that the most important thinkers of the future would be religious. You could even say the present.
You know, I said that a while ago, but yeah, religious thinkers. Absolutely.
Oh, but like wouldn't you expect that religion generates some pressure towards conformity, and like just the single fact that most religious people came from religious families says a lot about it? And the way like we get interesting stuff being done and creations being made is by having more risk-taking people, therefore less conformist, therefore less religious.
I think historically what you're saying has been true, and it's probably still true in Europe today, but I think in America today there's been a bit of a flip. The religious people are often the non-conformists. The formal religious structures themselves no longer exert much conformity power. Like the Catholic Church, the Pope tells you what to do, everyone ignores it for the most part. The Episcopalian church barely exists.
People who are LDS, you know, Mormons, that's become a much more diffuse thing. Who's a Mormon, who isn't is much looser than it used to be. So, I think religious conformity as a pressure is far weaker. Secular conformity with the rise of the woke became much stronger. And the ability of Americans to use religion to find new and different ideas and justify them, I think, has been pretty phenomenally positive in the last...
Like look at Peter Thiel, whether you agree or not. Well, his theory of the antichrist. There were like some bishops who condemned Peter for talking about the antichrist, who no one cares. They listen to Peter. They don't listen to the bishops. Interesting ideas will come of it. That's just a simple example.
But why do you think Europe is behind the US?
You have state churches. Those state churches still have a strong, small, conservative role in your societies. They're supported by tax money. You have fewer sects in the way that America has them. You also, this is changing, but you have fewer religions. It's less and less true as non-Westerners are migrating more to Europe. But I think the forms of Islam you have are much more conformist than what's here in the US. They're more harmful. They're working less well in terms of assimilation. US has more forms of Judaism that are more active here. That's another plus. Again, some parts of Europe have that, but overall much less than would be the case here. Hinduism much more successful in the United States.
So, is it good that there are more religions in the US than in Europe?
I wouldn't say it's unconditionally good. I would say the way it's evolved is good. US has a better functioning labor market. We have better mechanisms for selecting the higher talented immigrants and religious immigrants. We have strict guarantees of freedom of religion, freedom of speech, and you put all that together, our recipe has worked much better.