This is Attach Your Resume, interviews with online creators about how their jobs worked and how they got there. If you think you're listening to a different podcast about being online and having jobs, it's actually a recap for Lost. Stop watching Lost. There's nothing else left for you there. The smoke monster doesn't make any sense. I'm Eric Silver. I'm Amanda McLoughlin.
I recently learned that Ben from Lost is married to Elsbeth. You told me that. Yeah, Elsbeth has been married for like 25 years.
This is really important to everyone who is basically Amanda, who one watched Lost when it was coming out and two cares about Elsbeth, a spin-off show from her favorite show. Amanda's favorite show, not Elizabeth's favorite show. Elementary, a Sherlock Holmes adaptation for CBS.
Well, Elsbeth is a spin-off of The Good Wife. I can't keep track of the CBS shows that are out there. I just can't.
What you have correct is that I care deeply about CBS procedurals, Eric, and you are a keeper of incredible fun facts about the world.
Well, you know, it's not procedural. It's the interview that we have for you on this episode. Amanda, who did you talk to?
I talked to Jack Conte. He is the CEO of Patreon and also the co-creator of Pomplamoose, a YouTube channel that if you were online in 2009 or 2010 or so, you definitely watched some of their videos. They also, fun fact, headlined the fifth annual VidCon in 2014, which I was there for. That's so long ago.
I can't even fathom it. I think it's important that you brought up Pomplamoose, because that is the like ur-text of Patreon. Pomplamoose, this band, this was a very like, okay, go time of the internet. And Jack was investing tons of time and effort into the music videos for Pomplamoose, his YouTube channel band. It's like, well, the money I'm getting from Google AdSense is nothing, so I'm going to start this company. Now here we are. You didn't have to say what Patreon was. It's like the Kleenex of online creation.
Yeah, it's hard to imagine that Patreon started in 2013 and before that there was no way really for fans to give creators a recurring amount of revenue each month to support the work that they were doing. Now in 2024 and beyond, that is such a baked-in part of our world and the internet. I'm glad that we got a chance to talk to Jack Conte because we're starting this project within Attach Your Resume that I think is specific to you. This show is mostly about asking creative workers about their experiences and what they would have done if management ever wanted to know what they would have done. And luckily we've been able to ask a few people who started subscription-based websites what they would do, like Defector, an Aftermath, and eventually Rascal, which is going to come on the feed sooner rather than later. But now here we are. You have Amanda, a CEO of a creative online business, going to talk to other CEOs of creative online businesses about what it actually is like and try to ask questions from your experience.
Yeah, I think it's really interesting to have your day job be in a field that affects other creators so deeply. And I really wanted to be able to talk to Jack about the tension of being an artist getting into this, because he's an artist and musician, and now, you know, 12 years later, he is full-time the CEO of a tech company that's raised $412 million in venture capital as of 2021. So other CEOs, Hank Green, we've emailed you a bunch of times. Sam R., I know you've seen our emails. Please come on the show. We want to talk to you. And Amanda's nice. She's really nice. Look at her. I'm really nice. I'll be, I'll be you know firm but fair, I'd say. But it's really important to me that the CEOs of creative businesses think about our obligation to the creator economy, to fellow creators, and to our employees. It's important, and the only way this industry is going to evolve in a sustainable way is if we think about the ethics and example that we are setting for others and the impact that our business decisions have on creators' actual everyday lives. And you're trying to ask these questions to the CEOs to their face. I can't remember the last time someone asked Jack about his intentions and what he was thinking when doing all the choices outside of like a quote from a tech reporter or PR from Patreon.
If you enjoyed this episode and you found it valuable and you like what you heard, we would love if you could post this to your socials. Our goal with this show is to reach other workers, creators, freelancers who need to hear it. Honestly, anyone, anyone who is under the age of like 42 who has a job, we want you to hear these episodes. So telling your people, telling your audience with your social media posts honestly is a huge help. Wherever you're doing it, on Twitter, on Instagram, on Threads, if you have it on TikTok, wherever, or even in your group chats. Yes, but like put it out publicly. We would really, really appreciate it. It would be a huge help for the show. Maybe do your Patreon community, maybe in your patron-only Discord. I don't know. Yeah, maybe in your newsletter, which is probably more effective if you're reaching your audience on social media right now. But just tell your audience about this stuff. We'd really appreciate it. All right folks, I hope you enjoyed this interview with Jack Conte.
Jack Conte, welcome to Attach Your Resume.
Oh my gosh, thanks for having me.
Our pleasure. Would you let people know who you are and what you do?
Yeah, my name is Jack Conte. I am co-founder and CEO of Patreon, and I've been a creator also for about 20 years. I have a band called Pomplamoose. We've been uploading to YouTube since 2008. I got another band called Scary Pockets. We're a little bit more recent. We started in 2017. And then I have two talk shows slash podcasts: one called Dead Wax where we go deep into music and music analysis, and then another one called Digital Spaghetti where I interview cool visual creators and storytellers and we break down their process and artistry.
Something that really interests me about you and your career is that in introducing yourself just now, the thing that most people probably know you as is co-founder and CEO of Patreon, and then like 85% of the words you said are about the stuff you make and being a creator. And so I am really curious on your thought on something I think about a lot and that I think all of the folks looking for jobs in digital media listening to Attach Your Resume have on mind, which is: do you think art and commerce are contradictory?
We're really jumping in. Oh, I love this. Straight into it. Big picture thoughts. Okay, I have so many thoughts. How long do we have? I don't think they're contradictory. I think there's tension, and I think it's really hard to do art and commerce well. And kind of that's like the job of the artist. Art does not exist in a pure vacuum. It just doesn't. And I think that's part of what makes it hard to be an artist: to stay true to what you want in your heart and what you want to say and how you want to express yourself, and to somehow be able to do that despite market pressure and algorithmic pressure and fan pressure and Mom and Dad pressure. You name it, there's always pressure around us. And when I think about my favorite artists in the world, they are somehow able to truly be who they are despite all of that pressure. I think that's one of the things that I respect a lot about those artists. When you do that really, really well, I don't want to say the economics always follow, because they definitely do not, but the truth is people really like to see someone be unafraid of being themselves. People really love to see someone who just wears their heart on their sleeves and is okay saying exactly what's on their mind. That's attractive. So one of my favorite artists, for example, is Louis Cole. And the dude is the most, he's not a commercial artist. He's so weird. He wears like a waffle necklace with his shirt off and then plays drums and has a hot dog iPhone case. He's so weird, but his music is amazing and he deeply connects with a group of people, and that makes his business work. So I think the challenge is existing long enough to make the stuff and feel mature enough in what you're making that you connect with an audience without having to spend 80 hours a week paying your rent.
Totally. I think people underestimate how long this stuff takes. Building an audience while you're learning how to be a creative person and say what you want to say and developing the self-confidence to say more and more of that, that's a long process that's never ending. And it's not the kind of thing that you can really nail in 18 months. It takes years of work and trial and error and falling on your face and getting back up and trying again. I often find that when people are talking about the sort of art versus commerce debate, they sort of presume a luxury to choose between the two, or a luxury to eschew commerce in favor of art, which for me and all of my peers and a lot of people that I imagine you're in community with, the dream is just to be able to do the art full-time without a full-time job. So I'm curious then about the rise of the term 'creator,' which I think Patreon had a large part in popularizing. It's a term that we kind of know what it is. People want to be a creator when they grow up. I definitely have my thoughts about what that term means in opposition to artist or in conversation with artist, but how do you feel about it?
Man, you're getting into such good stuff right off the bat. When Patreon was getting started 11 years ago, the term 'content creator' didn't even exist. I remember having discussions with my co-founder. We were like, what should we call these people that we're helping? And we were thinking, should we call them content creators? We didn't like that because even back then I didn't like the word 'content.' And then we thought about 'creators.' And I remember having a discussion with my roommate. We're like, should we just call them creators? And my roommate was like, that sounds like God. That doesn't work. You can't just call them Creator. Everybody thinks of God when you say the term Creator. So we're like, okay, we can't use the term Creator. But we had those discussions 11 years ago. And now, you know, 2024, Creator is just a part of culture. It's a part of society. It's something that everybody takes for granted almost. How do you feel about it though? Do you think that's the right word?
You know what's interesting is my feeling has changed a lot about it over time. And I think the thing that's changed the most is that the web has increasingly put negative pressure on artistry and boldly being yourself. It's hard to do that now. It's so much pressure. And I think that has sort of been antithetical to what it means to be a true artist. And so I've just found myself using the term 'artist' more and 'art' more over the last year or two because I want to remind myself of why I got into this in the first place as a creative person, what it is that I care about. And even that's also why I don't like the word 'content.' Content is faceless, nameless. It's a commodity. It fills a hole, it fills a void, it fills a feed. It's manufactured stuff to plug into a feed. That's not what I want to make as an artist. That's not why I get up in the morning and devote myself to my craft and my creativity. So yeah, all of the words around the sort of ecosystem that we're in, I find my own feelings about that stuff changing over time.
I almost feel like Creator is akin to like 'working actor,' something like that, where you know maybe you're not taking gigs because you think they're incredible and maybe you can't be super choosy about it, but your day job is actor, which is pretty dope if you want to be an actor. So I almost feel like my day job is creator. And as I get more mature and find myself clawing back a little bit of inspiration or not thinking about stuff I want to make in relation to how it can either support me or take time that I have to otherwise fail to pay rent in other ways, artist is the thing I get to do. Instead of when I was working in finance, it felt like I had to spend most of my time off recovering from my day job and then much less thinking about what I wanted to make. Those are two very compatible roles. And that's not probably how everybody sees it, but I'm extremely fortunate to have Creator as my day job, and maybe that'll let me get toward being an artist in some moments.
I mean, what I hear there is you expressing essentially the constraints around being a creator and what that means. And yeah, what I have seen, you know, amongst creators, and by the way I still use that word and think it is right, but I also think it's true that culture is changing at a pace that's kind of extraordinary right now. What I have found is that creators, there's a whole brand and type of creator on the internet that's like, you know how to edit your videos to maximize attention at second 30, and it's like this very analytical, almost growth-hacky approach to making media and art. I call it the Tim Ferriss effect of like, how can you do four hours of work per week to take advantage of laborers and underpriced places and then spend the rest of your time doing shrug? It's optimization focused. By the way, that's a subcategory of creators. I know a ton of creators who are so self-expressive and so artistry focused, and so I hate to make a sweeping generalization or classify.
No, I think that's what we're here to do. Our reason for starting the show is, you know, for Eric and me, there was no manual of how to be a full-time creator, that that was even a job title. And so we want to get into the intricacies. In any profession, in any industry, there are camps and people who do things one way or another, and loyalties and competing schools of thought and research papers that get contentious in the footnotes. And I think as the industry and profession of being a creator evolves, I want to have those kinds of conversations. You can't uncritically just say everybody's doing a great job, let's move on folks. You need to learn from what your peers are doing. And I think that's really difficult when our learning is performing support on Twitter necessarily. I think having these conversations in trusted ways is essential to growing.
That's the other thing that I think is driving me bananas now. The older I've gotten and the more I've used the platforms, actually this part of it isn't even the platform's fault, but being who you are publicly, broadcasting who you are to the world, is a very new skill set for humanity. That was reserved to a very small number of people just 20 years ago. And it's only in the last decade or two that everyone has been able to broadcast themselves to all of humanity. And we're learning a lot about how to do that and the pressures of that. And yeah, what I found is it's just so easy to broadcast who you want to be instead of who you are. It's easy. That's what I do. I broadcast who I want to be. The internet sees a sliver of my whole self because I'm not going to broadcast everything about myself onto the internet. But what the net effect on me and on my psychology as a human being is that there's this gap between this image that is being cultivated online and then the whole human who lives in this flesh and bones body, a flesh mech. A brain riding a mech suit covered in a meat skeleton. We're all piloted by neurons when you think about it. We're piloting these very awkward sacks of fluid. But yeah, that gap between the avatar that I have accidentally stumbled into and then the whole me creates anxiety in my life, to tell you the truth. That's a very difficult thing to process as a human, and I think a lot of people are feeling that right now. I think the net impact on a lot of us is loneliness. It feels lonely to be in that state.
It does. I think that in 2013 when Patreon launched to now, there's been a fundamental cultural shift. People, it's almost the Kleenex effect where people know what having a Patreon is, you know, being a patron, all those kinds of things. I think it really changed our attitude as the internet towards selling out. I try to explain to people sometimes, you and I both came up on YouTube in the late 2000s, and the idea that someone would give viewers an option to support them for a thing that is otherwise free was pretty mind-blowing. And it's almost like I think audiences have outpaced creators in their comfort about thinking and talking about money. Audiences are smart. They understand that it costs money to make stuff, that you need to use the dollars that you have to make the stuff that you want to see in the world keep existing. And at the same time, to get into this nuance, I think I've seen a real variety of attitudes from creators where some folks are really happy to talk about money and be transparent about it, talk about how that direct support from listeners goes to making their lives and content better. Others find it kind of icky. Yet others, I think we've seen examples as in any industry of bad actors that sort of use it in a icky and gross way. But I wonder what you think we need to do as an industry of full-time creators to increase our financial literacy or earning capacity or just our comfort in talking about money, because it's a thing that I really think is hampering our growth.
Such a great question. I think about that a lot. I mean, I'll take us back even further historically to the 80s and 90s, before the consumer internet and before humanity basically digitized all of art and put it online. In that period of time, paying for art was what you did. You didn't get to listen to the record unless you shelled over 15 bucks. Now, most of that went to the record label and that sucked, and artists weren't taking home that money, but the behavior of paying for a piece of media, whether it was a song or a movie or an album or anything, that was very common. It wasn't actually until the early 2000s when the first winners of the internet, the Facebooks and the Googles of the world, basically came out with this new fresh opinion that information should be free. And by the way, art is a subcategory of information and it should also be free because it counts as information. That's what the early winners of the internet said, and they created this business model where everything was free and it was monetized via ads. And that was the first decade and a half of the internet. And very quickly we all looked up and said, you know, wow, this sucks for a variety of reasons. First of all, we turned the web into a billboard. Second of all, there's all kinds of downstream impacts of that business model on humans and our brains and psychology. And that then precipitated companies like Patreon to start to change culture back to where we had been for a long time, which is: hey, artists need to be able to sell their stuff. Art doesn't work without some type of commerce mechanism to fund it at scale and support the people who are producing the art. So that's the shift that I want to say Patreon had a big hand in starting in the early 2010s. And then by 2024, I think you're right, it's very commonplace now for people to realize, oh yeah, there's a person behind this who's making something valuable to me, and it makes sense that I would not just should pay for it but want to pay for it. When we do research with members and fans, fans want to pay for stuff that is really valuable to them. They find it important to pay for that thing. And I totally understand that. I have the same feeling as a fan. I get messages all the time of people saying, I'm so sorry my financial situation changed, I have to end my membership. And my answer is always, whatever you can pay, I'm so grateful, and you don't owe anyone any apology because I'm so grateful you're here. And half the time then they're referring our shows to friends and supporting us in different ways totally, which I think is amazing.
Kind of connecting earlier to the vulnerability and self-representation that you brought up, do you think there is a way to be honest about your finances either as a business or an individual without coming across as needy, cringy, oversharing? It's something that I think about a lot and I don't know if I have an answer to.
Yeah, I don't know. A lot of people have tried, including me. Sometimes it's worked, sometimes it's really not. I wrote one article, oh man, I got absolutely raked over the coals for it. It was so poorly received. There was a huge backlash. A bunch of articles got written. It was bad.
Can we get into it? What was the subject you were writing about?
I was writing about the economics of one of our tours and the fact that we had lost $112,000 on the tour. Remember, the goal for us, I did not articulate this well, but our goal was not to make money on that tour. Our goal, Pomplamoose's income comes from our song sales, not touring. Touring is a way to connect with our fans for us. But there were other problems. Patreon had started to exist and I was a CEO and I had raised money for Patreon, but then I was writing this article about Pomplamoose and being in an indie band. And that was such a miss. In retrospect, I should have started the article with, hey, I'm a CEO and I've raised money and I'm going to write this article about my band, but you should all know that I'm a CEO. And I didn't do that. I think I didn't do that because Patreon was like a year old. I wasn't taking a salary as CEO. I was making my living as a musician and I hadn't shifted any, I hadn't assumed the identity of a CEO psychologically yet. I was still just living in a two-bedroom apartment trying to build a product with my roommate. But I think in retrospect I should have just very clearly called that out at the beginning. Anyway, the point is, for a variety of reasons, it was not a good article. And maybe if I had approached that better, I would have different views about being transparent around your finances. But I think it's very hard. It's hard because on the one end, if you're doing well as a creator, that's the dream job. And if you're doing well, then you're kind of living the dream for a lot of people. They would love to be in that position, meaning complaining or getting into the details will just be received badly. Exactly. You know, there are lots of creators on Patreon that are making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year. They have all kinds of problems that they have to be very private about because they're building companies, they're leasing office space, they're hiring employees, they're running into production output problems. But if the average person read about those people having problems, it would come across poorly. So yeah, I think it's very hard to talk about money as a creative person. I haven't found the right balance yet to do it. It's honestly very tough.
I'm curious about this on an even larger than the individual level as well. Because I think you do an excellent job of starting and sort of summarizing the origin story of Patreon. I'm going to say it fact to you having heard it a few times, which is like you spend $10,000 on a music video for your band, made something like $15 in AdSense revenue for that month. $166 bucks. Bad. And was like, holy shit, I am never going to be able to make the kind of thing I want to make and fund it this way, which was the only way, which was YouTube ads on the video. I'm curious why, if the problem you were solving is starting Patreon as a way to properly value art and for fans to support creators directly, what made a venture-backed startup the right solution to that problem?
So at the time, when I actually started the company, there was no business strategy. There was no strategy. There was no business plan. There was literally the first version of Patreon that I sketched out on printer paper was a website that I wanted for myself. And in my life, I had no idea or even desire to become a CEO. And actually, still, my goal in life is not to be a CEO or to have a tech company. I care about this problem that I'm solving, and I think doing it this way is the best way to do it, but that was not in my plan for myself, just to be very honest. And I would love to take credit for some genius strategy or something, but there was no strategy. So what happened was I posted this YouTube video. I explained to my fans, hey, come follow me here. It's a thing called Patreon. I made it with my buddy Sam. We were roommates in college. Come become a member here, and I think this could help a lot of people. And very quickly, a lot of my fans turned out to be creators themselves. And then those creators launched on Patreon, and that snowball just kept repeating. And we got to the point where we were very quickly totally overwhelmed and totally underwater, getting hundreds of thousands of support tickets a month that someone had to reply to. We had one engineer, my co-founder, and we were getting feature requests, you name it. We could not keep up. So what we wanted to do was hire some people to help us, but the company wasn't profitable because we were taking 5%. So we needed to figure out how to afford to hire a head of operations, more engineers. And so we raised money. We went out looking for $700,000. Pitched probably 20 or 30 investors and finally found one who was like, I want the full $700,000. And then very soon after that, a couple others asked to be included in the round as well. We ended up raising $2 million. That was in August 2013, like an angel seed round. Again, I want to say there was no thinking, there was no strategy. It was, oh my God, we need to build a lot and we need to respond to all these support emails. We need to raise money in order to do this. I wasn't thinking, oh, we're going to raise more rounds. That was not in the calculus. It was literally just one foot ahead of the next, solving every little problem kind of as we approached it.
Yeah, I wonder, did you have in mind then that artists are kind of always waiting to get screwed over by a tech company? That there are a lot of ways in which, I've heard you speak before about how banks for example don't love looking at YouTube AdSense payout receipts to help people buy houses and things. That any change makes people really jumpy. And I think we're more literate now, but even back then the idea of why would a tech company want to be here? Why would venture capital want to be in the lives and finances of a creator or an artist? Was it something on your mind?
A thousand percent. That has been on my mind since the first day. Because I feel that as an artist, I feel that the platforms have largely abandoned me as a creator or just not really taken care of me or helped me. That was the reason for starting the company, right? It was like I was looking at my ad revenue feeling like there is no way that my value is being represented in this check that is being sent to me. This is stupid. And just to put a number on it, in 2024, when ad revenue is much higher actually than it was back then, a YouTuber earns an...