If you could tell me something in the next 15 minutes that would make me a better investor, what's the first point you would just hammer into my head?
Oh my god. Put the phone down. Stop trading.
So I think the interesting place to start is we've had a few different people from the school of investing wisdom come on, sort of the value investing genealogy. And me and Sam, although we are not investors, we're definitely like entrepreneurs first and then, you know, investing as a sort of hobby sport type of thing, we're so attracted to it. We love the sort of investment wisdom, especially your version, which is the 'aw shucks' common sense version of investing, which is less about how to be super smart and do advanced things and just how to be less stupid than you already are. And don't worry, you'll be fine. And so, I'm excited to talk to you. You have a cool story. You started off really in the content game, in the media game, blogging back in GeoCities early on with podcasting and built a large investment advisory shop named after yourself. I think you guys got to what?
That was a placeholder, by the way. That was not supposed to be permanent. Like, let's just call it Ritholtz for now. Someone else said, and we'll find a better name. And then we never found a better name.
Can we ask you to brag for a minute? I think it's like an 8 billion AUM business.
So, the weird thing about the financial services industry, but before I brag on the firm, the background is: go to law school, do really well, hate being a lawyer. A client is running a trading desk that was a predecessor shop to E*TRADE. And so, I started on a trading desk and found it was just mayhem. It was just random and volatile, and I was more fascinated by why the people around me some days were killing it, some days were getting killed, like what's going on with their process? And that sent me down the rabbit hole of behavioral finance. It just was the only explanation I found as to why the same person could be doing really well one week and applying the same process gets shellacked the next week. It's decision-making, it's emotions, it's cognitive biases.
Can you explain your Christmas tree analogy for constructing a portfolio?
Sure, that's really easy. So we know that historically very few people beat the index on a regular basis. In any given year less than half of active managers beat their index. You take that to five years, it's something like 21%. You take it to 10 years, it's less than 10%. One out of 10 people.
So that includes like huge firms?
Includes everybody, any active mutual fund, ETF, hedge fund, whatever. And then go to 20 years and it's a handful of names, you know, Peter Lynch, Warren Buffett, etc. So, if the core of your portfolio is a broad index, you know, you can't get alpha, meaning outperformance, if you're not at least starting with beta. And when we say people don't beat their index, it means not only are they not getting what the market gives them, they're getting less than that. So, forget beating what the market gets, they're not even getting what the market gets. So, pick a number, 50, 60, 70% of your portfolio is that core. And by core index I mean US broad-based market indexes. Vanguard's VOO last week became the first ETF over a trillion dollars and that's just a super low-cost broad index. You want to own some overseas stocks, some overseas indexes, that's fine. Now, the tree is the garland, the decoration, the lights, the tinsel. That's whatever stink of your own you want to put on your portfolio. So, if you like momentum, great. Add that. You want a little more tech, however you want to decorate it. You know, we've looked at these assortments of different portfolios. They all more or less end up in a similar place. Some are a little better, some are a little worse. They all end up trailing the index. If two-thirds of your money is in a broad index, well, at least you know you're starting with that basis point. And hey, I think Japan is great. I'm going to own EWJ, or I think India is the next big country after Korea, so I'm going to own that ETF. If you want to have a little bit of decoration on the tree, that's fine. Just recognize you're aiming to outperform and the odds are very much that you're going to underperform.
So is this a little bit like when you do a diet and they're like, 'Yeah, we're going to do a cheat meal on Sunday.' And it's not that the cheat meal is good for you. It's just that it's probably the only thing that's going to keep you on the guardrails of the other six days of the week being on track. Is that why you even have the decorations, or would it just be better to be 100% in the passive index and call it a day?
So, my cheat meal is the cowboy account. We have clients. Listen, what's more fun? What's sexier than talking about investing in startups, investing in the hot new publicly traded technology? You look at all the things that we talk about in the media, television, print, web. It's never about 'own a broadly diversified portfolio of low-cost indexes, rebalance every few years, see you in a few decades.' Now, what do you do with the other 23 hours and 59 minutes a day if you have to fill it with content? So, all this sexy news, all this exciting stuff, that's 90% of the fire hose. You see, would that be the best finance channel? They just say that at the top of every hour and then they just play like Home Alone reruns for the next 59 minutes. And actually, those investors would do way better than anybody watching. I tell the metaphor of this little gardening channel and they have a tree cam. They plant a tree and it's very bucolic and relaxing and it's just there and everybody is happy with it. And then the channel gets bought by private equity and now they got to sex it up. So everything becomes a fake conflict. 'That's the wrong tree for this area. Too much water. You planted it too deep.' 'No, it's not deep enough. It's not getting enough.' And meanwhile, the tree could not care less about what they're saying. It just quietly grows. And that is how I think of the media and the broad index. Say what you want. Vanguard and BlackRock have between the two of them $25 trillion in assets because they've dominated low-cost indexing. And I think the financial crisis was very much the last straw for mom and pop investors. Now you have a whole new generation of people on DraftKings and Robinhood speculating, but everybody who's over 40 kind of lived through this and said, 'You know what? I'm going to take my ball and go home.' And by ball, I mean capital. And by home, I mean BlackRock and Vanguard. And you know, before 2008, Vanguard was under a trillion dollars. They're like 11 or 12 trillion dollars. BlackRock is 13 or 14 trillion. Like these are giant, giant firms. And so that's kind of what happened. That's the base core. And you know, the tree just keeps growing.
What's the biggest return one of your clients has had via their cowboy account?
So we've had people that have had some Bitcoin when it skyrocketed. We've had clients that had a lot of Tesla that blew up, you know, in '20 and '21. It exploded. Heading into the pandemic, the people that in their account had like Teledoc and Zoom and Peloton and they just exploded. But what always happens, it's so hard to sell something because most of our sales, like I owned Apple when the iPod, not iPhone, iPod came out, it was $15 a share, 13 cash. There's no downside and it tripled. It went up to 45 and I thought I was a genius selling it. And then it proceeds to gain another 9,000%. But we've seen that. You know, one of my favorite stories in the book is the CEO of Peloton wasn't getting especially great advice. At one point on paper, he was worth, I don't know, two or three billion dollars and just leveraged himself to the hilt, bought a whole bunch of stuff. Then of course as the pandemic starts, as the vaccine starts going around and we start to see the light at the end of the tunnel, Peloton crashes. He must have taken a whole bunch of stock loans against that capital. Had a $60 million place in East Hampton. Had to sell that. Was just liquidating everything. And just, you know, it's always a shame when you see that. I mean, how many disasters do we have to live through before you realize any stock can go to zero? So, anytime you're trading an individual name, the odds, Henrik Bessembinder at Arizona State Business School did a couple of studies and he basically found out that the entire value in the market comes from between 1 and 2% of stocks. So, what are the odds? 50 to 1, 100 to 1, that the company that you love so much, that's run up so much this year, is going to do it for another 10 or 20 years.
You want to hear something funny, Shaan? We did a podcast with Lloyd Blankfein the other day. You know, the...
Yeah, he's got a book out.
Yeah, it's a great book and he's, you know, for the listener, he's the former CEO of Goldman. He's big, shy, great guy. He told me, I was like, 'You're retired. What do you do now?' He's like, 'I love to day trade.' He was like, he goes, 'In fact, I knew I was going to do this podcast for two hours, and it kind of made me anxious because I'm always grabbing my phone to look at like my stocks, and so I had to put all my orders in advance in preparation because I'm not going to be available.' And he's like, 'Right now. I want to look at my phone right now.' And then after the podcast, I was like, 'Well, what are you going to do now?' He's like, 'Well, market's closed, so I don't have anything else to do. I guess I'll walk home.' And I don't know how his portfolio, how he said 70% of his net worth. I think he said that. Don't quote me, but something like that is in his holdings. And so he said he's doing good, but it was just so funny. And what's interesting is that I'm sure he's doing great. If anyone's going to do great, it's probably someone like him. That said, it's like even if you're a titan of industry, you're on top of the world. You know everyone, you're a who's who. There's probably a world where he's going to make every single mistake, the same mistake that an 18-year-old degenerate Robinhood trader is going to make. And I find that's interesting that we all still do these things. Lloyd, listen to me. Put the phone down. Stop trading. 70% of your net worth should be in mun bonds paying you a huge tax-free yield. You want to dick around with a few million dollars, knock yourself out. But if you're actively trading 70% of your net worth, which is a couple of billion dollars, I am disappointed to tell you that you are making the biggest risk-adjusted mistake of your career. And the schmuck that used to run Goldman Sachs should know better. Stop day trading.
Looks like I'm not invited to Shabbat dinner anymore. So, thanks Barry. Oh my god. I hope your memory, your numbers are wrong. So here's the fascinating behavioral side of that.
On this show, we have spent hours talking to some of the best investors alive. Well, lucky for you, the team at HubSpot, they have pulled out the principles that matter most and turned it into a very simple, easy-to-read wealth guide. It's 35 principles from the top investors. We're talking guys who have been on the pod like Howard Marks, Mohnish Pabrai, Morgan Housel, Cathie Wood, and a ton of others. So, these are all their frameworks, their mental models, their rules. Basically, how to play the long game and how to avoid ruin. You can get it in the link below.
We see this all the time. I mentioned the clients, hey, do I buy a Ferrari or not? The folks who are, and I mean this in all seriousness to Lloyd, people who, a guy like him works really hard his whole career, constantly striving and saving and investing and putting money away and accumulating stock options and going through all this. It is really difficult even for people who are, you know, masters of the universe, billionaires, to recognize and just stop and say, 'I won. Hey, I won. I don't have to put this much capital at risk.' Because over the decades I have just seen that story play out and end badly. Hey, I'm sure Lloyd will be fine. He doesn't have to take financial advice from little old me. But anybody who walks into the office with a giant portfolio, the challenge is how do we convince you that you've won and how do we make you create a portfolio that is highest probability of reaching whatever your goals are. And PS, if your goal is just more, well then you're going to be disappointed both in your portfolio and your life.
You mentioned something about selling and I thought there was two interesting things in your book about selling. One was about panic selling and the data around what happens for panic selling. The other was that there was some study about hedge fund managers where their buys were actually good but their sells were terrible. And I wanted, can you explain those two ideas around selling?
So again, a lot of behavioral finance research behind this. It turns out that people panic sell into a market crash, something like a third of them never return to equities. So, let's just use either the 2020 34% pandemic sell-off or more likely the 2008 57% market crash. Imagine selling down 57%, not getting back into equities and watching 15% a year compound over that entire period. It's shocking. So you take a million-dollar portfolio, you're out at like 450,000 net worth. If you never would have sold it, it would be worth 10x today. It would be 4.5 million. And to be fair, you are getting a percent or two up until 2022. Now you start to get 4% in a money market, 3.7% today. But that doesn't compare to a 10x and it doesn't keep up with inflation. So, that's the first data point that's shocking. Panic sell into a portfolio. One in three people never get back into equities.
The hedge fund, the buys are good, but the sells are worse than just if they sold at random.
So I love this study. It's by Alex Edmans, who is a University of Chicago professor. But they did this study where they looked at all these buys. And my explanation is the buys are rational, spreadsheet, database. The sells are always emotional. But the clever thing that Professor Edmans did was, hey, how can we tell how good these sells were? I know, instead of selling the company that the manager wanted to sell, let's randomly pick anything else that's in this manager's portfolio and sell that instead. And it turned out that the random sells outperformed the manager-selected sells by something like 150 to 200 basis points. Maybe it was even more. It was some crazy amount. And it's like it makes sense that the buys are thoughtful and logical. But the sells very often are emotional, impatient. You know, sometimes the stock doesn't work out right away. People sell it even though the underlying thesis was correct. Sometimes something else bright and shiny comes along and you got to sell something so you have money to buy that. It's an amazing data point and it just goes to show you most of our decision-making is bad. And so one solution: make fewer decisions.
Hey, can I, I'm going to pick a friendly fight with you.
So you say buy low-cost index funds. I'm on board with you. Anyone who's listening to this pod knows you're speaking my language, but why would I pay you a fee then to do that?
You don't have to. Our whole business model from day one has been, so we've been writing in public, myself and my partners, hey, you could do this yourself. You don't need anybody. You just need to put together a broad portfolio of low-cost indexes, manage your own behavior, stay out of your own way, and you know, check in on it once, twice a year. That's it. And there are a bunch of people who said, 'Well, I like the advice, but I have a little more complexity in my portfolio. I have tax issues. I have estate issues. I have whatever. I need some help with this.' We don't have minimums. We set up different levels of, we have two digital platforms, one for under a quarter million dollars and one for a quarter million to a million. But our whole line of thinking has always been, 'Do it yourself. You don't need our help.' And it turned out something like 0.01% of our readers said, 'I don't have the time. I don't have the discipline. I'm not interested in this crap. I pay someone to do my taxes. I pay someone to mow my yard. I'm going to pay you guys to manage our money.' I did a post a couple of weeks ago about organizational alpha. And if you beat the market by 50 basis points or below the market by 50 basis points, clients could not really care less about that. However, if you manage to quarterback their finances in a way that our tax team has done a great job minimizing capital gains taxes, we use a couple of complex products, and I always think simple is better than complex unless it really solves a sticky problem. So direct indexing really helps with that.
Sam, do you direct index or do you know what that is?
Yeah, I know what it is. I don't do it. Sam's people make fun of me, Barry, on the show because I am a very strict, like at this point it's a little bit like 90/10 equities and bonds.
I don't even think you need the 10. You got 30 years before you need the money. Why drag the portfolio down with bonds?
Which by the way is somewhat controversial. It just helps, it's a mostly emotional decision. But direct indexing, it's summarized as instead of buying an index fund, you have a program that basically buys the stocks of the...
Components, right? The components of the index in the same proportion.
It seems like over the course of like, for example, the way that my personal finances are set up, I live off my income. I don't ever intend to sell my index portfolio, in case, I guess I would sell in an emergency, but why would I do direct indexing if I don't intend to sell it?
I love that question. So, you guys have both sold startups and ended up with substantial capital gains. And so, in any given year, even when the markets are up, there's some 20, 30, 40% of stocks that are down. And of that group that's down, there are some that are down substantially. So if you have VOO, I think it's 700 or 800 positions, the S&P 500 is 500. You look at the bottom decile, the bottom 10% of stocks and all right, this small-cap biotech is down 40%. I'm going to sell it and replace it with something that looks very similar, another small-cap biotech that's down in the same space. I harvest that loss. The portfolio value doesn't change. The way the portfolio trades doesn't change. But if you do that every year, you could pick up 75, 85 basis points. In Q1 of 2020 when the market was down 34%, O'Shaughnessy did a research study on direct indexing. Their study said that it was 400-plus basis points of losses harvested and replaced with very similar companies. And when the recovery happened, it matched the performance of the index because effectively it's the same thing. So founder stock, IPO stock, sale of a business, inheritance, high concentration positions. Every now and then someone comes in and says, 'Hey, I have a $10 million portfolio and I've owned fill-in-the-blank Apple for 15 years and now it's 90% of my portfolio.' How do you get them out of that position without paying a giant cap gains tax? And so this has been like a very effective way to do that. It's not for everybody. It adds complexity. It adds a little bit of cost, not much, but some. But it's definitely useful for that. For most people, I don't think it's necessary.
Can I ask you a bunch of stories? I want to do a story time thing because the cool thing about you is you've been doing the content game for so long. And so I know you've met some incredibly interesting people. I want to do a little rapid-fire bit, but of all the people you've had on the podcast or interviewed at conferences or through work, who's the person who you think our listener should research and someone you admire?
So, you mentioned Ray Dalio and Howard Marks. Those are obvious. I'll give you a couple of really interesting names. Richard Barton is this former Microsoft employee who founded Expedia and Zillow and just one crazy company after another. He's got this crazy framework. I think Shaan and I have talked about it. His whole, I think I'm summarizing this correctly, Shaan, I think he said his whole career is taking messy data and organizing it, or I think he even said, 'I free the data.'
Yes. He calls it 'give the power to the people.' Let's basically take data that exists that is just not transparently, easily structured and available and make it transparent, easily structured and available. And so if you look at what he did with housing, you know, the housing data, that's the MLS data. He made it more easy to access through Zillow. They did it with Expedia. He did it with Glassdoor. And it's the same thesis he's just played out in like four, you know, plus different companies at this point.
I'll give you a couple other names that are a little below the radar even though they're all kind of known to the industry. I think David Rubenstein of the Carlyle Group could be the best human being I've ever met in my life.
That guy's awesome. Have you seen the show, Shaan?
Yeah, of course. I've just seen this. I didn't know he was such a legend. I just thought he's an interviewer because I just only ever seen him doing interviews. I didn't realize he was the founder of Carlyle, which is...
Well, he's like a, I knew him as like a historian. He has these amazing books. I'm reading one of his books on Washington and Lincoln and the rest of the presidents. I don't even think of him as a money guy.
So, he started out in the DC area when Carlyle started and he would put together these off-the-record conversations with experts in spaces that were being debated by Congress and then he would invite a whole bunch of congressmen and senators and staffers from both sides. And the idea was this isn't partisan. This isn't political. This is just a way for you guys to hear from an expert who you may not come across. And...
And why did he do that? Was he in politics?
No, he just wanted the Congress of the country he lived in to be better informed and make better, more knowledgeable decisions.
But was he a big shot when he did that?
No, he was, Carlyle was a tiny little company that was specializing in telecom and that's why they were based in DC and eventually expanded to everything else. So later on in his career he becomes super wealthy and the Washington Monument starts falling apart. The cement starts cracking. It's a couple hundred years old and Congress being paralyzed and incompetent. 'An idiot and a congressman, but I repeat myself,' is the Mark Twain quote. They couldn't get their act together. So, he steps in and says to Congress, 'Hey, I'm going to fix this. See if you idiots can get around to passing legislation. I'm just going to patch it up. See if you can do a permanent fix, and I'd appreciate if you pay me back one of these days.' And he basically guilted them into fixing all the national monuments. This was in like the '80s and '90s. And then he's a kid who grows up in Baltimore, and Baltimore is a city that's having a hard time. He buys the Baltimore Orioles, promises the city that it will not move over the next 20 years. And I think he said, 'And I'm going to keep the beer and hot dog cost the same for the next 10 years,' not what you think of when you think of as private equity.
What personality attributes do you think made him great as a business person? Because he sounds like a warm and lovely guy, but he's in PE, which is not particularly a warm and lovely industry.
He is really, really good at finding a space that is being ignored by the rest of the market and not just ignored, but undervalued. So, telecom wasn't sexy in the '80s. There was some post-Reagan deregulation and it kind of got ignored for a while. So, and not just like the big names, but the block and tackling or all of the fundamental pieces, just the ability to, it's not even see around corners, it's identify a spot that the markets have...