I'm asking you to be okay not spending money that I don't have. And I'm asking you to take a deep breath, shake off the loss, get back in a room with your guys, and figure out how to find replacements for the guys we lost with the money that we do have.
I'm not leaving here. I'm not, I'm not, I'm, I can't leave here with that.
What else can I help you with?
Welcome to Money Unplugged. I'm Chris Hill. Thanks for being here. If it's your first time listening, welcome to the show. Click the follow button so you don't miss an episode. And if this is your first time listening, you picked a good one.
Because today on the show, I talked with Barry Ritholtz. He's the chairman and chief investment officer of Ritholtz Wealth Management. He's the host of Bloomberg's fabulous podcast Masters in Business. He's also the author of the best-selling book How Not to Invest. And Barry is one of those guys that people in the investing world really pay attention to because he's smart, he's experienced, he's not afraid to go against the grain.
Barry was one of the early voices warning about the housing bubble years before the 2008 financial crisis. This episode is a little longer than usual, and honestly, it could have been even longer because we talked for half an hour before I hit the record button.
And since you can't really talk about the stock market right now without talking about AI, I took the opportunity to ask Barry his thoughts on the topic, including whether he thinks the market is in an AI bubble right now. He does not hold back, which is just one of the reasons I think you're going to enjoy this. So, let's get into it with Barry Ritholtz.
You grew up on Long Island, right?
Born in Brooklyn, fifth grade in like Teaneck, New Jersey, we moved to Plainview, Long Island. And pretty much other than 20 years living in the city for grad school right up through 2000, we actually moved out right before 9/11, all Long Island. In fact, I met my wife at my senior prom in high school. And we stayed friendly, and it was only at the end of grad school we started dating seriously.
What did your parents do?
Mom did several things, ultimately becoming a real estate agent. She started out as an antique dealer, buying and selling antiques. My dad had a really fascinating career. He was a placement manager for engineers, scientists, mathematicians. My office is now like two blocks from where his office was on Madison Avenue. Long Island was filled with Grumman engineers. He placed those guys in different things. NASA, some of the people he placed worked on like the lunar landing and all sorts of crazy stuff like that. And very formative circumstance in my early life.
I don't remember if it's fourth grade, sixth grade, something like that. The person who owned and ran the firm he worked for, very young, unexpectedly suddenly dies of a heart attack in like his 40s. The brother-in-law comes in to run the firm and it all just goes to hell. And so at some point in, I want to say like the early 70s, right as stagflation was hitting and the oil embargo and all that, suddenly he's got to switch careers. He tried to do it on his own. You couldn't, you know, there was no internet. You couldn't work remote. Didn't really work. Ultimately, he started working with my mom doing antiques and that stuff, which led him to opening a sporting goods and sneaker store that became fairly successful. So, towards the end of his life, they were doing pretty well. By the time I was out of grad school, they were starting to make some actual money, but I grew up pretty hardscrabble and have some, you know, memories about really being broke as a kid.
Well, and I would think, you know, the picture you just painted in terms of the work that your mother did, the circumstances with your father's employment, the economic environment of the early to mid '70s, that strikes me as an environment that is conducive to having money conversations around the dinner table. Was that the case or was that not the case?
Not really. I mean, the conversations I recall around the dinner table was my mother would find this rare beer stein that she said was worth thousands of dollars, but she flipped it for 800 bucks. And it's like, why don't you hold on and sell that for three grand? She's like, cuz we needed the money and I can't tie up the capital. I always thought that was kind of fascinating.
She eventually becomes a real estate agent and so real estate becomes a regular dinner table conversation, mortgages and housing and things like that. And I really credit her for me spotting the financial crisis coming because of her, I paid close attention to home prices and ownership versus rental and the value of real estate holdings in the United States versus GDP and all sorts of unusual data points that pretty much all of Wall Street ignored, but if you looked in the right place, you know, nobody saw the financial crisis coming unless you looked in the right place and kind of squinted and it's like this isn't right. This is a backwards real estate driven economy. This isn't normal, but everybody missed it cuz they weren't looking there.
What was the first job you had when you were a teenager?
First job was delivering papers for Newsday, which was a horrible, horrible experience. Not only going door to door to collect the dollar five it was a week for the paper, but they want you to go to the doors of people you don't deliver to, and that sort of salesmanship, having to just muster up some courage and knock on a door. Turns out to be good training, but I hated it. Really did not enjoy that. I started out life as a little bit of an introvert and have since wildly overcompensated.
So you stayed close to home it seems for college. You go to Stony Brook University. What did you study there?
I started out undergraduate in applied mathematics and physics. The expectation was I was going to follow the path of all those engineers, go work at Grumman and NASA somewhere. And you know, by my second year of college I'm like, you know, I'm pretty good at math and science. Those guys are great. I can't keep up with them and started, you know, just looking around for something else. I ended up finding that the philosophy classes I took I really enjoyed and political science seemed to be pretty easy. So poly sci major, a minor in philosophy, and just enough math to be dangerous to myself.
A few weeks ago I had a Robin Wigglesworth from the Financial Times on the show and he is a kindred spirit because he very much wanted a career in science and once he got to the university level realized the same thing you did. I'm good at this. I'm not as good as the people who are going to get degrees in this.
So you have this degree in political science and a minor in philosophy and from there what did you think you were going to do?
No clue. I didn't have a clue what I was going to do. And then about a year after, I use the term graduation in quotes cuz turns out I didn't graduate at the time. I had to finagle that later, but my mom again said, "Listen, you can't..." I had a retail job in college and that became full-time after college. She's like, you can't be a retail salesman selling stereo equipment and cameras and TVs. You need to do more. I'm not sure what to do. Great. In the meantime take the LSAT, go to law school. And I'm like, "All right, I got to take the class before I take the LSAT." So I took the class.
I'm a bit of an idiot savant in standardized testing. So I got into college because of my SAT scores. Yeah, wait, you're going to give me the four answers? I just have to pick the right one? Easy. Some people are wired for that. And then the same thing with the LSATs. In fact, in my third year of law school I taught the LSATs and they would have me fill in for the GMATs and the SATs and I'm like, I didn't go to business school. It's like, it's the same. And it turns out it really was. It's really just logical reasoning. I took a bunch of those classes in college and deductive analysis. And again, you take a bunch of those and active reading, which is a form of reading that you have to teach yourself. You're not just passively letting the words go by. You are looking for specific keywords and patterns and structures. And once you see it, you can't not see it.
Were you interested in the law or was it just sort of the proverbial like, well, I'll do this, I'll have something to fall back on?
When I didn't know what lawyers did, I was very interested. And it took me about a year and a half of law school. I loved law school. I hated being an attorney. When I came out, I immediately passed the bar in New York and New Jersey, licensed to practice for a few years. Ultimately, somebody I got to know who was a client was running the predecessor firm to E*TRADE and I went in-house there and started on a trading desk. And that was my big transition and it was absolutely fascinating.
Ultimately, it led me down in the mid-90s, before all the cool kids had discovered it, it led me down the behavioral finance rabbit hole. Cuz I was more intrigued by why are the other guys on the trading desk, sometimes they make money, sometimes they lose money, sometimes they do both. What's going on? I can't figure out what is driving their outcome. And ultimately, I determined it was their own wetware was to blame.
Let me go back to the transition though, because, you know, you graduate from law school, you've been a lawyer for a few years. I'm assuming you were making some amount of money. And often if someone is restarting their career, that involves a financial sacrifice of some sort. Was that the case for you? How did that go down with the people around you?
Absolutely. Giant setback.
So, before I did the switch, I had a long conversation with my wife who taught AP art and fashion illustration and design. So, she had tenure, so she was a steady income and health care. So, I felt a little freer to kind of go for it. But, I knew pretty quickly when I started, I was like, these guys are all 5 years younger than me and my peers in law school are way ahead of me. So, by the time I'm, let's call it 35 in 1996, my peers are making, you know, quarter million, 300, 400 thousand dollars a year. I'm making a fraction of that. I'm making 50 grand and if I'm lucky a bonus of a couple of bucks.
Oh no, that's like 2000. In the late '90s, I was making or losing a hundred thousand dollars a month. It was totally inconsistent and ultimately it's what led me to realize this feels very random. This does not feel like I am driving this. I'm not afraid to pull the trigger and the results seem to be all over the map. This could be pretty much totally random. Maybe I need to do something that isn't pure gambling or speculation.
And my wife said to me, she's like, you know, you made a ton of money last month, you owed a ton of money this month. You can't go on like this. Figure out how to make less but steady or shift to a different part of the industry. And I went to research and strategy, which turned out to be a really good fit.
It sounds like you and your wife, certainly at that point, had a very straightforward, you know, type of communication about financial issues. Was that the case starting out? I mean, you meet her at the senior prom and years later you start dating. Was money part of the courtship?
She said I was actually studying for the bar when we started dating again. She tried to hook me up with her college roommate and I ditched the college roommate and grabbed her. But, she later said, she goes, "I thought I was marrying an attorney who was going to make a decent middle-class living cuz I had no idea what I was in for." And, you know, my attitude about money has always been I spend at a fixed rate. I either have to make enough money to spend at that rate, but I don't have the mental bandwidth to budget. To just... my emotional defects, I can't go there.
I grew up with ADHD, like real ADHD, not "I need 20 more minutes on the SAT" ADHD. And basically refused the meds and stuff like that, was just so beyond my mental capacity. I'm like, "Well, I better make more money cuz I can't think about..." I literally don't have the emotional bandwidth to deal with tracking every dollar, every penny.
And my wife is the exact opposite. When we lived in the city a bunch of bills would come and she would sit down at night, write the check, stuff the envelope. She had to go downstairs to the post office box and mail it. Honey, it's Sunday night at 7:00. Nobody's going to see this until... It doesn't matter. I feel better when it's off my desk. Like she's the opposite of me. I never kept a bank total on my checking account. It's like, yeah, I have a running total in my head. I more or less know what it is within 100 bucks. She goes, "What happens if you run out of money?" I go, "We'll know when a check comes back, but you know, other than that, I can't be bothered." And when we moved in together, she's like, "What's your system for paying the bills?" It's like, "Well, whatever they turn off, I go pay that bill. So, when the lights go out, I pay Edison." She's like, "I'm going to take over the bills." I'm like, I think that would be for the best.
That seems like a good system. Before we go to the speed round, there are a couple of questions I want to ask and they're sort of, I guess to the extent that these questions have a theme, they do tie into your latest book. Just the idea of making mistakes and I'm curious, what do you think is the most expensive mistake that you've made with your own money?
Oh, that's easy. I've been friendly with Howard Lindzon for about 20 something years. When he launched StockTwits, we put some money into it. And I remember it was 2015. He insists it's 2014. I'll defer to him. I remember sitting in the back of the Embarcadero in San Francisco. Beautiful blue sunny sky. The Oakland Bridge behind us. And he's pitching me on putting money into this new startup that will let millennials trade stocks for free.
Now, before I tell you, can we curse? Because my response was, Howard, that is the single dumbest idea I have ever heard in my entire life. And the punchline is that was Robinhood. Howard made a hundred million dollars on it. I wasn't going to put in as much as Howard, so maybe it cost me 50 million or 25 million, but whatever it is, the technical term is a ton of money.
And in my own defense, I could say, well, StockTwits didn't work out and I had very much embraced the world of fiduciary advisor and indexing, and you know, I come from a trading background. I know how difficult it is. Encouraging 20-somethings to day trade is not on brand, nor is active management generally. Wait, you're going to remove a friction and make trading free? That's terrible. So, I have a slight defense, but that's a lot of money left on the table. I have a few other mistakes that I reference in the book, but those were just single-digit millions of dollars of errors, not double-digit or almost triple-digit hundred-million-dollar errors.
Right. That's just six zeros. That's not eight zeros.
Yeah, seven zeros. Seven zeros.