This week on the podcast, yet another fascinating conversation. I sit down with Vanguard's CEO Salim Ramji. Previously, he was at BlackRock helping to oversee iShares and indexing. He's got a fascinating background and really one of the people in the wealth management industry who is so uniquely situated to see all of these different things that are going on. What a great perch to observe the future of wealth management. I thought this conversation was fascinating, and I think you will also. With no further ado, my conversation with Vanguard's Salim Ramji.
Salim, welcome to Bloomberg.
Well thanks, Barry. It's great to be back. I think we did this about half a dozen years ago right in the middle of Covid.
Yeah, it was a frightening time. I wanted twice to be in the studio. Yes. I want to talk about your career and what led you to Vanguard. Yeah, but I have to start by asking about your academic background. Bachelor's in economics and politics from the University of Toronto. And then a master's in law at Cambridge. And I'm assuming a master's in Cambridge is like a JD here. Is that right?
Was the original career plan becoming an attorney?
Neither. My parents finished high school. My dad used to run a grocery store that I worked in as a kid. And from my parents' point of view, they just wanted me to go to college. And so I don't think there was any great kind of original plan other than I thought like going to college would be a good thing. And I was drawn to the law. And ultimately my first job was at a law firm in London, in part because there were so many exciting and interesting things happening in the world of law and business in the early 90s in Europe at the time. And so that for me was kind of a compelling piece. But I wasn't one of these kids who was like, you know, from the age of ten they wanted to be a lawyer. From that it was more, it felt like a really interesting time at that point with like markets liberalizing and lots of new markets opening up all over the world.
I'm curious how your upbringing affected how you look at money. You mentioned you worked in your dad's grocery store. Both your parents were immigrants, working and living in British Columbia. How did that affect how you have a relationship with money and work?
It probably, you know, some of these things you don't really truly understand until years later. But we didn't always have a lot of financial security growing up. And I'm at a company that cares very deeply about people's financial security. And you can sometimes abstract kind of that away in terms of what it means. But at least for me, I know what having it is, and I know what the absence of it is. Obviously having some financial security is far better. And I think it really drove home for me the real importance at a kind of very personal level as to what financial security means in somebody's life or somebody's family, and the importance of it to so many other things in terms of like the general kind of happiness of the house, the levels of stress in the house, the freedom to be able to do things kind of once you have attained it. And so financial security isn't, it's something that I know kind of deeply because I know its absence too. And so I think it makes it meaningful for me. Even if you ask the 20-year-old version of me, I wouldn't have thought of it in that way.
I think a lot of people don't realize the first checkbox is lack of financial stress is a huge weight off people's mind.
Yeah, if you could solve for that, everything after that feels like gravy.
Yeah, no, I absolutely agree. So you're working in London at Clifford Chance, you also spend some time in Hong Kong.
Was that doing legal work?
And then how do you transition from that to McKinsey? What led to that?
It was, you know, I enjoyed the business part of being a lawyer. Like I'd work in financial markets and work in M&A. And I was always interested in what happened after the deal closed, in the business aspects. And McKinsey for me kind of offered the chance to still be in a professional services firm, which I liked, still serve clients, which I liked, but also to get a little bit deeper on kind of the business of things. And I had kind of a wonderful career there for a dozen or so years, really learning about financial institutions and working and advising a whole range of financial institutions in New York and beyond that.
So I'm fascinated, of course, attorneys and consultants advise people running businesses. And then you made the transition to actually running a business for BlackRock. And when you were at McKinsey, you were running their asset and wealth management practice. So it wasn't a radical jump to go to BlackRock. But how different is it offering advice versus actually, you know, where the rubber meets the road after?
It's really different. And I'd worked kind of with them as a client for a number of years before joining them. And it's a very different aspect when you're owning the outcomes, when you're having to lead broader groups of people, and when you're having to kind of sweat every single detail, every single moment of every single day. And it was a great learning experience for me because I joined them, you know, in my early 40s, and it's a chance to really learn a whole new set of skills. Even though, you know, the industry and you think you know a thing or two about kind of the firm, you really don't until you're kind of deep into it. And for me, it was a great source of, you know, renewal, revitalization, a whole series of things that even to this day I'm very grateful for.
And I think if my research is correct, you started in 2014 at BlackRock as head of corporate strategy.
Which is probably the most advice-oriented position within BlackRock, advising the board. You're advising management. Hey, this is our strategic outlook. Here's how we should proceed from there. You end up running US wealth advisory and eventually taking over iShares and index investing in 2019, which I want to say that was about $3 trillion, more or less. I don't know if it started there or finished there.
Yeah, that's some real money.
Now you're actually really running a business as opposed to offering advice at BlackRock. Tell us what it was like taking over such a massive part of the firm. You're talking about iShares and index investing.
You know, it was all of it was a bit of a journey. I probably spent about a year in corporate strategy. And that was really, you know, I got to learn the culture of the firm. I got to learn the people at the firm. I can't say I had tremendous impact in that year. But it really led to the business of serving kind of a whole range of financial advisors all across the United States. And that for me was fascinating because I got to spend time with financial advisors in every major city, several not so major cities all across the U.S., and just understand kind of how they were looking to grow their practices, grow their businesses. Many of them were effectively mid-sized business owners. And the chance to really understand what their needs were, how they served their clients was really meaningful. And you know, for iShares it was just really expanding that on a much more global scale, given the global breadth of that firm.
So iShares has become legendary. It's probably the single most successful M&A action taken by any asset manager, and has just grown into one of the most important parts of the world of advisory. When you assume a leadership role at a division like that, that's so important and has been running on all cylinders for so long, is there any reluctance to interfere with what's working? On the one hand, you can't just rely on its momentum because eventually that peters out. How do you figure out, hey, we want to step on the accelerator without, you know, killing the goose, to mix metaphors, that laid the golden egg?
Well, you know, the thing about any markets business is that the momentum sometimes interrupts you. And so you don't have a great choice in terms of how things evolve and the like. And you know, when we last spoke six years ago, kind of right in the throes of Covid and the pandemic, a few months before there were also big dislocations that were happening in the bond market. And so one of the things that I learned was just about how to maintain the resiliency of investments that millions of people rely on, particularly in moments of stress. And some of that kind of translates, you know, through to Vanguard today, because even at moments that look kind of like they're not going to have kind of big disruptions, that doesn't mean that they might not kind of a few months from now or a few years from now. And the thing about investments, and particularly things like index investments or ETFs, people naturally expect them to work kind of not just some of the time, but all of the time. And that's an inherent part kind of in the operation of it. But there's just a whole range of underlying pieces, whether it's in how our portfolio managers manage the assets, whether it's in how kind of the system of broker dealers and exchange providers and index providers kind of help maintain an orderly system. But one of the things that really struck home to me, you know, back in 2019 and especially in 2020, was you can't take any of that for granted. And that requires work every single moment of every single day to make sure all the investments work as they are too.
It's kind of funny because we had been warned, hey, just wait for the next dislocation, indexing is going to fail, ETFs are going to fail. And it turned out, especially down 34% in about six weeks in the first quarter of 2020, indexing and ETFs both held up great.
What do you attribute that to?
Well, one of the books I've been reading was a guest you just had on the show, Robin's book about, you know, fabulous debt and the bond markets. And I think with each of the dislocations, and let me go back to the dislocation in 2020, I thought the most interesting set of things that happened back then was what happened in the bond market. The bond market was dislocated. The ETF market was not. And what really catalyzed kind of that dislocation was a whole series of movements towards ETFs, towards electronic kind of venues, towards more exchange-traded versus over-the-counter pieces. And the bond market, even today, six years later, is still in need of modernization. But that was a real catalyst to help the bond market modernize. If you go back even earlier to the financial crisis, markets dislocated, but more and more investors moved into index investing and particularly ETF investing. And we saw that kind of in Vanguard's flows at the time. And each dislocation kind of results in learnings about the market structure. And at least in more recent history, it's made market structure better because you learn a few things. Consumers and investors learn a few things. And it's how do you make sure that the system remains resilient through each one of these? But I think ETFs, whether it's bond ETFs or equity ETFs, can, even if I look back over the past 15 years, have kind of weathered most or almost everything that's been thrown at them.
I have so many questions for you about running Vanguard and the future of that company. But last question before we get to that. You worked very closely with Larry Fink.
I did, for nearly a dozen years. Yeah.
How did his leadership affect how you think about running a company? What did you take from him?
Well, you know, founders are different, right? Founders. And you'll know this too, kind of given your role at Ritholtz, that founders are different than CEOs. And I think the things I really learned from that whole experience was really just about the need to always be able to reinvent and look around corners and anticipate kind of a series of things. And I think learning from a founder of a company that's built the company up at scale was a really great way, in my kind of broad business experience, to learn something new and learn from someone who started the firm, really, really interesting.