Welcome to Bolden Your Money, where we dive into the decisions shaping our financial lives. I'm your host, Steve Chen, and today we've got Barry Ritholtz joining us from New York, and he's the co-founder, chairman, and CIO of Ritholtz Wealth Management, and he also recently wrote a book, How Not to Invest. And he also hosts a popular podcast, Masters in Business. So he is pretty well known. We're going to dive into his book and talk about some of the mistakes that we want to help people avoid. So with that, Barry, welcome to our show.
Hey, Steve. Thanks for having me.
No, I appreciate you making the time. And just, you know, before we get going, I wanted to share a quick anecdote. So I was texting my brother this morning. He shared your blog, The Big Picture, with me like 20 years ago plus. That thing used to be on GeoCities.
That's right. '98, it launched on GeoCities back in the day when you had to code the HTML by hand. And once WYSIWYG came along with software like Six Apart, it went from a half hour of writing and two hours of coding to a half hour writing and two minutes of coding. Like technology has made us all more efficient and more productive.
100%. And for people who don't know what WYSIWYG is, it's what you see is what you get. That's, by the way, that's the only technical jargon I'm going to use today. It's okay. It's just impressive. So anyway, it was the first kind of finance-oriented blog ever shared with me, and I just, and so I was checking out. I was like, 'Hey, guess what? I'm going to have Barry Ritholtz on our podcast.' And he's still reading it. So he's like, 'The daily read.'
It's just part of my process. But I started on a trading desk, and if you can see the rest of my office with books and crap piled up, everything is a mess, and you know it's really quite a disaster. But in order to compensate for that, I would just put together my list every day. And I learned don't read crap on the way into the office because it'll get in your head when you're trying to make good trading decisions. And so I would make my list every day. Here are the earnings that are coming out. Here's consensus. Here's the range. Here's the economic lists that are coming out, economic releases. Here are the 10 things I skimmed through New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal that I want to read on the way home. And that eventually became something that got xeroxed and shared around the office in the 1990s.
And then that eventually became something that once I found people were faxing it, it was like, hey, I could just email it to them. Get an email address. So that became an email list, and then in '98 that became GeoCities, which I really regret that when GeoCities went belly up, they didn't at least archive the stuff. I grabbed three or four of my favorite posts, and when they said they were going out, I didn't know they were like, we're really going out. Yahoo did the same thing with their video, and like any of the appearances anyone did in the '90s or 2000s on Yahoo was this rich mine of behavioral data showing just how biased individual investors are, and all that stuff disappeared.
I remember well, we can, we'll get into it a little later, but that's like one of those things like, what a shame, how much... There's a great story about Monty Python on the BBC, and somebody lent them like $40,000 to buy the videotape masters from the BBC because they were going to just reuse them, like, oh, the content isn't anything, the 40-cent tape is what mattered. And Yahoo, GeoCities is the same thing, they just wipe those servers and it's gone. That's too bad.
Yeah, it's pretty interesting hearing your story that you were kind of doing this like, you know, faxing it around, emailing it around, you know, early GeoCities internet. And yeah, so you appreciate kind of probably what's happening with AI and everything now, right? Like another, you know, evolution of tech that is going to amplify people's influence significantly.
I think I have a slightly different perspective on AI than a lot of people. Technology is a tool. Anything that makes me more productive, more efficient means either I can crank out the same work in less time or in the same time crank out more work. So I used to have these debates with my economist friends about the famous Robert Solow quote, Nobel laureate, I think MIT, Robert Solow: 'Technological progress is everywhere except for the productivity data.' And I always laugh because it's like, so what you're saying is your measurement is imperfect or just outright wrong, or maybe that might be true for heavy industry, but any information service or service business, I just don't believe that there's no productivity gains. I just know what we do today with 75 people would have taken 300 20 years ago.
100%. Oh yeah, you're right. I have seen that data too where they're like, 'Oh, it doesn't look like we're getting more productive.' You're like, I find that hard to believe given like what we're doing.
Right. In the book, there's a quote I rely on frequently, which is George Box: 'All models are wrong, but some are useful.' And so as long as you recognize economic models, portfolio models, all of these are a, I don't want to say false, but an imperfect reproduction of reality, take them with a big grain of salt, you'll be in much better shape.
Yeah. Awesome. All right. Well, look, before we jump into the book, I would love if you can give us just a couple minutes on your career. So I saw that like one highlight when I was, you're on the equestrian team at Stony Brook. So you're the first person here I've met who has been on the equestrian team, and then would love to kind of, you know, for you to kind of zip through that.
So spent my summers as a kid upstate New York, play baseball, swim. Oh wait, there's a horse farm here. Hey, what can I do to ride horses? Well, it's $40 for an hour. Well, I'm 12 and don't have $40, but what can I do? You could muck out the stalls, water down the horses, groom them, this, that. I don't know how to do any of that. We'll show you. So I had been riding horses like western. You sit in a saddle. It's a big comfy couch and you go for a ride. And for the most part, I'm the one who gives the horses carrots and apples. So they like me. They let me. They do what I ask.
Once you... So I undergraduate applied mathematics and physics at Stony Brook, and eventually, which I was really good at in high school and in college, it's like I'm pretty good at this, but those guys are great. So eventually switched to political science and philosophy. And when I do that, suddenly my calendar was a lot freer. So I read in this campus paper that Stony Brook has a nationally competitive equestrian team, and I'm like, 'Wait, what?' So Smoke Run Farms was like a 15-minute walk from campus, from my dorm. So one Saturday morning, I walk over, I meet the head coach, and I'm like, 'Hey, I've been riding western horses. I'm interested in learning how to really ride.' And he's like, 'Well, you have to sign up for a class. It's two or three gym credits a semester, and it's $5 a week.' $5 a week. It was like $50 for an hour. And it's instructed, not just on a trail. Okay, let's do that.
And the ironic funny thing about that is when I went to apply to graduate, it turned out that I had been doing that for, I don't know, two and a half, three and a half years. I had so many gym credits that I was short graduation. I had like 138 gym total credits, 118 of which applied to graduation. I had to find two credits in order to graduate. Too many horseback riding class. So that was really fun.
I didn't know what I wanted to do with my life, and I live on Long Island, and the rule is, hey, you're a Jewish kid from, went to college, don't know what you do yourself, go to law school. So that's what I did. Loved law school, wasn't a big fan of being a lawyer, you know, graduated cum laude, all that nonsense. The teaching of legal studies is fascinating, the practice of law is really tedious and detail-oriented, and the guy who named his blog The Big Picture, probably not the guy you want doing all the little detail legal work on your behalf. And when the opportunity came to go work for a friend at, not E*TRADE, I just read somebody said he worked at E*TRADE, no, the firm that was the predecessor firm to what eventually became E*TRADE, that's where I started on a trading desk.
Okay, got it. And how did you pick, like how did you get into trading? Like what motivated that?
Misery. I was miserable as a lawyer. And I had done some work for somebody who later goes on to be Bill Porter at E*TRADE's right-hand man, and he's the co-founder of ISC, wildly successful. I'm still in touch with Marty, we chat all the time. But he said, if you're miserable as, and he's also an MBA JD, he said, if you're miserable as an attorney, you got a good head for numbers, you're good with computers, why don't you join the trading desk? What do I do? You'll figure it out. And that was essentially the training. They push everybody into the deep end of the pool, and whoever doesn't drown, congrats, you're a trader.
When you're a trader though, at that point in the, like what years was this?
Right around the Netscape IPO. So long before the dot-com implosion, but pretty much right up to it. '96, '97.
Yeah. Okay. But are you dealing with like retail people and like making trades for them, or are you like taking institutional?
So you are executing order flow on behalf of the company, and as you demonstrate the ability to do this and have a P&L, you get a capital line, and your capital grows as you show, you know, P&L responsibility. No cockups. And you know there were some guys who were wildly profitable and then would blow up, and there were guys who were really steady, and I was somewhere in between. I decided to... My wife once said to me like, 'I don't understand. You're up 50 grand. You're down 50 grand. Like, can't you?' She's a teacher. Yeah. Ready, steady, stable. So I had enough self-awareness to know I was always looking for that vein. Like, the dopamine hit was really a thing. And so I figured out maybe I can make a living doing this, but what I really should do is go to a shop that has research and analytics and take everything I've learned and bring it there.
In fact, I was really fortunate because I had spoken to a bunch of guys I knew from Merrill and elsewhere that were on trading desks and said, 'Hey, give me something.' You know, you come out of law school, it's like, 'Give me something to read. What can I learn?' And one guy suggested Reminiscences of a Stock Operator. Okay, classic. Probably the best recommendation someone gave me as a newbie trader was Jack Schwager's Market Wizards, which is all about risk management and discipline. But I was kind of fascinated by the ups and downs and why is this guy killing it and why is that guy getting crushed? And then next month that switches. And so I found a book, I don't know how I found it, called How We Know What Isn't So by Thomas Gilovich, a professor at Cornell. Really the first mainstream behavioral economics book. I think it was published in '93 or '91. So by '96 or '97 I stumbled onto that, and that just opened a whole new world for me, figuring out how and why we make decisions, and even more importantly, how and why these decisions go awry, not because we pick the wrong stock, but because of the way we go about that decision-making process. That was fascinating.
So it sounds like you're, you know, you go through school, you try law, didn't love law. A lot of lawyers, this happens to a lot of folks.
I think that seven years after graduation is the stat, 50% of all lawyers who pass the bar are not practicing.
Yeah, it's good stuff for people who are thinking about going to law school right now.
Plus, but I will tell you, I believe it's better intellectual training than an MBA. If you're going into wealth management, if you're going into investment banking, you know, save a year, go get the MBA.
Got it. Okay. And then you're kind of writing behind the scenes the whole time. So you go from law, become a trader, you're kind of continuing to write, and then like fast forward, you know, you start your firm, right, in 2013, right?
So let me give you a little background to that. So I spent most of my career turning down money because I didn't want, you know, nervous clients in my ear every 2% move down. I got a little bit of pushback a month and a half ago. I did a post, 'Tune out the noise,' and, 'No, you can't do that. This is, you know, existential.' And here it is six weeks later and we're, you know, 3% above April 2nd. Yeah. And so the funny thing is, we'll talk about the book, but there are like four or six chapters in here on how to manage the noise and navigate it. And I sometimes forget people haven't read everything I've written. So when I say that, it's within the context of here's 500 words. If you want to read 5,000 words on that topic, it's a couple of chapters in the book. So, you know, Howard Marks likes to say smart and hardworking is good, smart, hardworking, and lucky is better. I'm paraphrasing.
My mom was a real estate agent. And for someone who worked on the investment side in Wall Street, I spent a lot more time watching real estate than the average Wall Street guy. And so in '04, '05, '06, it was pretty obvious that if you looked at the proper data, it was obvious that something was terribly amiss. Yep. So the three data points I love to point out: if you look at 100 years of median income to median home price, it was like this. And then in '03, '04, '05, '06, it did this. And then cost of owning versus renting, it's the same hockey stick chart. And then value of US GDP to the total value of real estate, like how much is all the residential real estate as a percentage of GDP, same thing. It's really steady for decades and then whoop. So because I was fortunate to be looking at that, and I also read and wrote a piece about Reinhart and Rogoff, who eventually turned this into a book, but they write a paper on what happens to a country when a credit crisis unfolds, and I'll save you 50 pages: real estate falls 30%. And there's five recent examples. It was like Japan, Helsinki, Mexico, the US Great Depression. I always forget whatever the fifth one is. Maybe it was Sweden, Norway, but it doesn't matter.
So as an exercise, I said, let's see if we can, I'm making a long story short or long story medium, let's see if we can figure out what happens to the Dow at 13,000 and change if real estate falls 30%. And this is why I say you got to be a little lucky. The number, and I did the Dow only because I didn't have the patience to do all 500 stocks in the S&P, I come up with a number about 9,800, but then the behavioral finance comes in. I'm like, hey, if we break 10, we're going to 6,800. Want to overcorrect. Yeah, totally. And I thought the number was irrelevant. It's made up. It's just... And nobody wanted to talk about the analysis like, 6,800? What? That's down 50%. So for all of 2007, I was the idiot on Wall Street. Yeah. And then in '08, you're a genius. Well, it took a while.
In the beginning, stuff started to go south, and I had a conversation with a buddy. Hey, don't let me be that a-hole where if we get anywhere near 6,800, I double down and say 3,400. So you're empowered to kick my ass if I do that. And again, dumb luck. My wife's a teacher. We travel on the school calendar. It has nothing to do with me. We're on vacation. We come back. There's a, March 2009, there's a message on the voicemail. Hey, we're at 7,000, call me back. Hey, we're at 6,900, call me back. Hey, 6,800, I'm coming over to kick your ass. And I get home. I'm like, I was on vacation, we just got back. What are you doing? I'm gonna go through all my numbers, put out a piece right now. And I literally said, 'Cover your short, go longs. Every data point I look at from market internals to economics to sentiment, they're as pinned as far to the edge as possible.' And I send it out, and immediately Sunday night, Henry Blodget responds.
And I had been on when the piece first came out, and everybody thought I was an idiot. And then when we broke 10,000, he had me back on, and he's like, 'Come on the show tomorrow.' I'm like, I just got back from vacation. I got to come. No, come tomorrow. So he talked me into coming on Yahoo Finance, and I just said, hey, you know, we're down 50-something percent. Why? Every indicator is negative. When is that not a great entry? And so by the dumbest of dumb luck, the next day, bottom, and the market's up a thousand points within like 48 hours of my interview. I think the interview was Monday. They released it Tuesday, and the market bottomed in like Tuesday 8 a.m. And I wasn't sure if it was Tuesday or Wednesday when the market screamed higher. Yeah. But it was just dumb luck. It was a total coincidence, but people started throwing so much money at me, and a number of colleagues said, 'Dude, it's so hard to raise money. You got to stop turning it down.' Yeah. Okay, I'll be the CIO. You run the back office crap. I have no patience for that. And that was, I don't know, almost $6 billion ago.
So that's how you got started, but like the firm, when did the firm start? I thought it started in 2013.
So the firm launched September 2013. I had hired Josh from the sales side, I want to say late 2010, 2011, somewhere in that. So, you know, this all kind of came together slowly, and then we hired Chris Vinn, and then we hired Mike Batnick. Yeah. And when we decided we were going to tap out and launch our own, it was a pretty, I was pretty comfortable that we would be fine. I did not know when the fire hose would turn off. And over the next decade, Josh became a rock star. Mike Batnick became a rock star. Ben Carlson became a rock star. Nick Maggiulli, and on and on. Blair and Callie, and we just keep adding pieces to the board. So it's no longer just me bringing the money in. And if anything, I'm a minority rainmaker compared to how much talent is out there.
Yeah. I remember I was at one of your conferences like several years ago, and I think Josh described it as we're building the boy band of bloggers as a media company. Yeah, we'll talk about the whole media side of things. So anyway, so I just want to actually, so for the audience, yeah, definitely having some, you know, insight and like awareness of like the history makes a ton of sense. I will say like back in 2005, I was in escrow buying our first house, and I was like, 'This makes no sense. I've saved my whole life. I'm in Northern California to buy a house, and anyone who can fog a mirror can get like a million dollars of credit.' I'm like, 'This is crazy.' And I actually, that was so real estate is a way to build wealth, especially out here. And I was like, 'All right, I bailed out of the house. I bailed out of escrow.' And I was like, 'We're going to keep renting. This doesn't make any sense.' And then I actually did the same thing you did, but like not as tech. I was like drawing a line of like the appreciation of California real estate. And it was like now it's this, but like long-term it's like this. So I'm like, I'm willing to pay, I bought our house in 2009, I'm willing to pay this price here, not up here. We bought it for like 30% off the peak, right?
And that's the Reinhart and Rogoff number. Financial credit crises lead to real estate falling 30%. And then if you go through history, you'll see down 50% in equities along with a down 30% real estate is not all that unusual. It happens within credit crisis more frequently than not.
My favorite part, my favorite line in Bailout Nation was you said they'll give a mortgage to anyone who can fog a mirror.
There were two, I don't know if it's a husband and wife, but two people who bought a house together. They were strawberry pickers. Yeah. And if they would have taken 100% of their pre-tax income and gave it to the bank, they still wouldn't have been able to make the mortgage payment. Yeah. And so when people blame the borrowers, it's like, hey, you're the bank. You're the professionals. This is on you. You screwed this up. Our mistake was not sending all the banks to the, you know, the nice building downtown with the Roman columns, the bankruptcy court. That's where they all should have gone. I know that was a giant miss. I mean, it was ridiculous.
But yeah, if you kind of see what's going on, you know, it's like Warren Buffett, like buy when there's blood in the streets. I mean, the other thing I did get right is I nailed, like I remember buying Google at 350, and then it doubled quickly, and I was like, 'Oh, don't get greedy.' And I sold, and that was a huge mistake. You know, it's like you do have to put your money to work when people are freaking out, and then you have to keep it, like stay in the market.
So right. And I believe that's Rothschild who said, 'Buy when there's blood in the streets.' And he was correct.
Yeah. Okay. So, all right. Well, just to wrap up this section. So did you kind of envision this for your life? It just sounds like...
No. No plan, no idea. It was just, I never planned on being an RIA, but it was like we were at a hybrid RIA software company. So they had a technology that I was running that division. Mm-hmm. Trying to figure out how to use technology to make better investment sector stock selections. And we had a BD and an RIA. And you know, as all this money was coming in, a big part of me was like, I don't want money to go here because I don't like their models, their methodology. There's not a true fiduciary part of this. So we set up the fiduciary part of the RIA inside. But you really, and I was doing a ton of CNBC in the 2000s and Bloomberg and Fox, and it was kind of funny to go on TV one afternoon. Hey, come for the talk about hedge funds, come for the high fees, stay for the underperformance, and go back to the office and as an email, here are the new six hedge funds on our platform. So this was kind of inevitable that we would have had to leave. It wasn't a good cultural fit after a while, but eventually it was like, hey, we should really figure out how to do this ourselves.
And we continually just tack into whatever is working, right? You know, when the wind is coming from the south, well, you're going to the north and vice versa. So whatever worked, we did more of it. We tried a lot of stuff. Some of it worked, some of it didn't. When we first were thinking, and I had been hosting The Big Picture conference since '09, so we had done that for like a decade when the idea came from Matt Middleton to, we had done WealthStack with him in 2019, when the idea from him is, hey, let's get the band back together after COVID and put on another show. Great. How do we make this not be a super spreader event? We'll host the whole thing outside, it'll be a festival. There was a ton of pushback. There were a lot of people like, this is going to flop, you're going to land on your face. And my attitude is, if I crash and burn, I get up, I brush myself off, we try something else. You know, if you're not failing, you're not trying hard enough. You're not occasionally striking out. You're not swinging at enough pitches. So that, you know, that was the whole backdrop of if it works, do more of it. If it doesn't work, do less of it.
Probably pretty good philosophy in life also. 100%. And also sounds like it's interesting, like I met Matt Middleton. I didn't know you knew him like way back in the day, but clearly you've...
He was at Informa, and we had done a few conferences with them. I want to say, I don't remember if it was 2018. I vividly remember 2019 doing WealthStack was our conference in Scottsdale, Arizona. And Matt Middleton and his team ran it. And when they wanted to extract themselves from Informa during the pandemic, we were like, we're in. What do we have to do? So we have a small piece of them. We're colleagues and collaborators, and we're thrilled to be working with him.
Yeah. No, it's been a really good synergy. I went to the first Future Proof, and that was the little one. You, the last year was, I think this year it's going to be close to 5,000.
I've been going to the California one. I didn't go to the Miami one, but it's definitely been cool and useful. It makes it very real, right? Like I think it's hard, like you know, you're out here running this media company and you're like, okay, you know, there's lots of people out there in cyber world or whatever, right? And then you're like, oh, you bring 5,000 people together, you're like, holy smokes, there's a lot of people here, and you know, it's real.
So the fun thing about writing, doing podcasts and writing blog posts and other things is, you know, you don't really know where it lands. And what's been so gratifying, Future Proof and other events, are the number of people who are like, hey man, really, you've helped me develop my asset management, my investment philosophy. The whole world is trying to get me to panic out of stocks in '10, '11, '12. And you know, thanks for doing what you do. Reading you has kept me level and steady. I mean, that is just so gratifying to know that the work, you never know who reads your stuff. You don't know, you know, it doesn't always show up. But sometimes to see that you have a, or having a positive impact, it's fabulous.